Higher-order molecular properties and excitation energies in single-reference and multireference coupled-cluster theory

Coupled-cluster (CC) theory is one of the most successful approaches in high-accuracy quantum chemistry. The present thesis makes a number of contributions to the determination of molecular properties and excitation energies within the CC framework. The multireference CC (MRCC) method proposed by Mukherjee and coworkers (Mk-MRCC) has been benchmarked within the singles and doubles approximation (Mk-MRCCSD) for molecular equilibrium structures. It is demonstrated that Mk-MRCCSD yields reliable results for multireference cases where single-reference CC methods fail. At the same time, the present work also illustrates that Mk-MRCC still suffers from a number of theoretical problems and sometimes gives rise to results of unsatisfactory accuracy. To determine polarizability tensors and excitation spectra in the MRCC framework, the Mk-MRCC linear-response function has been derived together with the corresponding linear-response equations. Pilot applications show that Mk-MRCC linear-response theory suffers from a severe problem when applied to the calculation of dynamic properties and excitation energies: The Mk-MRCC sufficiency conditions give rise to a redundancy in the Mk-MRCC Jacobian matrix, which entails an artificial splitting of certain excited states. This finding has established a new paradigm in MRCC theory, namely that a convincing method should not only yield accurate energies, but ought to allow for the reliable calculation of dynamic properties as well. In the context of single-reference CC theory, an analytic expression for the dipole Hessian matrix, a third-order quantity relevant to infrared spectroscopy, has been derived and implemented within the CC singles and doubles approximation. The advantages of analytic derivatives over numerical differentiation schemes are demonstrated in some pilot applications.

Spectroscopic properties from hybrid QM, MM molecular dynamics simulation

The central aim of this thesis work is the application and further development of a hybrid quantum mechanical/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) based approach to compute spectroscopic properties of molecules in complex chemical environments from electronic structure theory. In the framework of this thesis, an existing density functional theory implementation of the QM/MM approach is first used to calculate the nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) solvent shifts of an adenine molecule in aqueous solution. The findings show that the aqueous solvation with its strongly fluctuating hydrogen bond network leads to specific changes in the NMR resonance lines. Besides the absolute values, also the ordering of the NMR lines changes under the influence of the solvating water molecules. Without the QM/MM scheme, a quantum chemical calculation could have led to an incorrect assignment of these lines. The second part of this thesis describes a methodological improvement of the QM/MM method that is designed for cases in which a covalent chemical bond crosses the QM/MM boundary. The development consists in an automatized protocol to optimize a so-called capping potential that saturates the electronic subsystem in the QM region. The optimization scheme is capable of tuning the parameters in such a way that the deviations of the electronic orbitals between the regular and the truncated (and "capped") molecule are minimized. This in turn results in a considerable improvement of the structural and spectroscopic parameters when computed with the new optimized capping potential within the QM/MM technique. This optimization scheme is applied and benchmarked on the example of truncated carbon-carbon bonds in a set of small test molecules. It turns out that the optimized capping potentials yield an excellent agreement of NMR chemical shifts and protonation energies with respect to the corresponding full molecules. These results are very promising, so that the application to larger biological complexes will significantly improve the reliability of the prediction of the related spectroscopic properties.

New developments in state-specific multireference coupled-cluster theory

Coupled-cluster theory in its single-reference formulation represents one of the most successful approaches in quantum chemistry for the description of atoms and molecules. To extend the applicability of single-reference coupled-cluster theory to systems with degenerate or near-degenerate electronic configurations, multireference coupled-cluster methods have been suggested. One of the most promising formulations of multireference coupled cluster theory is the state-specific variant suggested by Mukherjee and co-workers (Mk-MRCC). Unlike other multireference coupled-cluster approaches, Mk-MRCC is a size-extensive theory and results obtained so far indicate that it has the potential to develop to a standard tool for high-accuracy quantum-chemical treatments. This work deals with developments to overcome the limitations in the applicability of the Mk-MRCC method. Therefore, an efficient Mk-MRCC algorithm has been implemented in the CFOUR program package to perform energy calculations within the singles and doubles (Mk-MRCCSD) and singles, doubles, and triples (Mk-MRCCSDT) approximations. This implementation exploits the special structure of the Mk-MRCC working equations that allows to adapt existing efficient single-reference coupled-cluster codes. The algorithm has the correct computational scaling of d*N^6 for Mk-MRCCSD and d*N^8 for Mk-MRCCSDT, where N denotes the system size and d the number of reference determinants. For the determination of molecular properties as the equilibrium geometry, the theory of analytic first derivatives of the energy for the Mk-MRCC method has been developed using a Lagrange formalism. The Mk-MRCC gradients within the CCSD and CCSDT approximation have been implemented and their applicability has been demonstrated for various compounds such as 2,6-pyridyne, the 2,6-pyridyne cation, m-benzyne, ozone and cyclobutadiene. The development of analytic gradients for Mk-MRCC offers the possibility of routinely locating minima and transition states on the potential energy surface. It can be considered as a key step towards routine investigation of multireference systems and calculation of their properties. As the full inclusion of triple excitations in Mk-MRCC energy calculations is computational demanding, a parallel implementation is presented in order to circumvent limitations due to the required execution time. The proposed scheme is based on the adaption of a highly efficient serial Mk-MRCCSDT code by parallelizing the time-determining steps. A first application to 2,6-pyridyne is presented to demonstrate the efficiency of the current implementation.

Molecular dynamics simulations of sheared brush-like systems

Mit Hilfe von Molekulardynamik-Simulationen untersuchen wir bürstenartige Systeme unter guten Lösungsmittelbedingungen. Diese Systeme sind, dank ihren vielfältigen Beschaffenheiten, die von Molekularparametern und äußeren Bedingungen abhängig sind, wichtig für viele industrielle Anwendungen. Man vermutet, dass die Polymerbürsten eine entscheidende Rolle in der Natur wegen ihrer einzigartigen Gleiteigenschaften spielen. Ein vergröbertes Modell wird verwendet, um die strukturellen und dynamischen Eigenschaften zweier hochkomprimierter Polymerbürsten, die eine niedrige Reibung aufweisen, zu untersuchen. Allerdings sind die Lubrikationseigenschaften dieser Systeme, die in vielen biologischen Systemen vorhanden sind, beeinflußt. Wir untersuchen so-genannte "weiche Kolloide", die zwischen den beiden Polymerbürsten eingebettet sind, und wie diese Makroobjekte auf die Polymerbürsten wirken.rnrnNicht-Gleichgewichts-Molekulardynamik-Simulationen werden durchgeführt, in denen die hydrodynamischen Wechselwirkungen durch die Anwendung des DPD-Thermostaten mit expliziten Lösungsmittelmolekülen berücksichtigt werden. Wir zeigen, dass die Kenntnis der Gleichgewichtseigenschaften des Systems erlaubt, dynamische Nichtgleichgewichtsigenschaften der Doppelschicht vorherzusagen.rnrnWir untersuchen, wie die effektive Wechselwirkung zwischen kolloidalen Einschlüßen durch die Anwesenheit der Bürsten (in Abhängigkeit der Weichheit der Kolloide und der Pfropfdichte der Bürsten) beeinflußt wird. Als nächsten Schritt untersuchen wir die rheologische Antwort von solchen komplexen Doppelschichten auf Scherung. Wir entwickeln eine Skalen-Theorie, die die Abhängigkeit der makroskopischen Transporteigenschaften und der lateralen Ausdehnung der verankerten Ketten von der Weissenberg Zahl oberhalb des Bereichs, in dem die lineare Antwort-Theorie gilt, voraussagt. Die Vorhersagen der Theorie stimmen gut mit unseren und früheren numerischen Ergebnissen und neuen Experimenten überein. Unsere Theorie bietet die Möglichkeit, die Relaxationszeit der Doppelschicht zu berechnen. Wenn diese Zeit mit einer charakteristischen Längenskala kombiniert wird, kann auch das ''transiente'' (nicht-stationäre) Verhalten beschrieben werden.rnrnrnWir untersuchen die Antwort des Drucktensors und die Deformation der Bürsten während der Scherinvertierung für grosse Weissenberg Zahlen. Wir entwickeln eine Vorhersage für die charakteristische Zeit, nach der das System wieder den stationären Zustand erreicht.rnrnrnElektrostatik spielt eine bedeutende Rolle in vielen biologischen Prozessen. Die Lubrikationseigenschaften der Polymerbürsten werden durch die Anwesenheit langreichweitiger Wechselwirkungen stark beeinflusst. Für unterschiedliche Stärken der elektrostatischen Wechselwirkungen untersuchen wir rheologische Eigenschaften der Doppelschicht und vergleichen mit neutralen Systemen. Wir studieren den kontinuierlichen Übergang der Systemeigenschaften von neutralen zu stark geladenen Bürsten durch Variation der Bjerrumlänge und der Ladungsdichte.

Mode-coupling theory: generalizations, high dimensions and microscopic dynamics

This work contains several applications of the mode-coupling theory (MCT) and is separated into three parts. In the first part we investigate the liquid-glass transition of hard spheres for dimensions d→∞ analytically and numerically up to d=800 in the framework of MCT. We find that the critical packing fraction ϕc(d) scales as d²2^(-d), which is larger than the Kauzmann packing fraction ϕK(d) found by a small-cage expansion by Parisi and Zamponi [J. Stat. Mech.: Theory Exp. 2006, P03017 (2006)]. The scaling of the critical packing fraction is different from the relation ϕc(d)∼d2^(-d) found earlier by Kirkpatrick and Wolynes [Phys. Rev. A 35, 3072 (1987)]. This is due to the fact that the k dependence of the critical collective and self nonergodicity parameters fc(k;d) and fcs(k;d) was assumed to be Gaussian in the previous theories. We show that in MCT this is not the case. Instead fc(k;d) and fcs(k;d), which become identical in the limit d→∞, converge to a non-Gaussian master function on the scale k∼d^(3/2). We find that the numerically determined value for the exponent parameter λ and therefore also the critical exponents a and b depend on the dimension d, even at the largest evaluated dimension d=800. In the second part we compare the results of a molecular-dynamics simulation of liquid Lennard-Jones argon far away from the glass transition [D. Levesque, L. Verlet, and J. Kurkijärvi, Phys. Rev. A 7, 1690 (1973)] with MCT. We show that the agreement between theory and computer simulation can be improved by taking binary collisions into account [L. Sjögren, Phys. Rev. A 22, 2866 (1980)]. We find that an empiric prefactor of the memory function of the original MCT equations leads to similar results. In the third part we derive the equations for a mode-coupling theory for the spherical components of the stress tensor. Unfortunately it turns out that they are too complex to be solved numerically.

Scale bridging concepts in molecular simulation : coarse-graining and thermodynamic coupling

In dieser Arbeit wurden Simulation von Flüssigkeiten auf molekularer Ebene durchgeführt, wobei unterschiedliche Multi-Skalen Techniken verwendet wurden. Diese erlauben eine effektive Beschreibung der Flüssigkeit, die weniger Rechenzeit im Computer benötigt und somit Phänomene auf längeren Zeit- und Längenskalen beschreiben kann.rnrnEin wesentlicher Aspekt ist dabei ein vereinfachtes (“coarse-grained”) Modell, welches in einem systematischen Verfahren aus Simulationen des detaillierten Modells gewonnen wird. Dabei werden ausgewählte Eigenschaften des detaillierten Modells (z.B. Paar-Korrelationsfunktion, Druck, etc) reproduziert.rnrnEs wurden Algorithmen untersucht, die eine gleichzeitige Kopplung von detaillierten und vereinfachten Modell erlauben (“Adaptive Resolution Scheme”, AdResS). Dabei wird das detaillierte Modell in einem vordefinierten Teilvolumen der Flüssigkeit (z.B. nahe einer Oberfläche) verwendet, während der Rest mithilfe des vereinfachten Modells beschrieben wird.rnrnHierzu wurde eine Methode (“Thermodynamische Kraft”) entwickelt um die Kopplung auch dann zu ermöglichen, wenn die Modelle in verschiedenen thermodynamischen Zuständen befinden. Zudem wurde ein neuartiger Algorithmus der Kopplung beschrieben (H-AdResS) der die Kopplung mittels einer Hamilton-Funktion beschreibt. In diesem Algorithmus ist eine zur Thermodynamischen Kraft analoge Korrektur mit weniger Rechenaufwand möglich.rnrnAls Anwendung dieser grundlegenden Techniken wurden Pfadintegral Molekulardynamik (MD) Simulationen von Wasser untersucht. Mithilfe dieser Methode ist es möglich, quantenmechanische Effekte der Kerne (Delokalisation, Nullpunktsenergie) in die Simulation einzubeziehen. Hierbei wurde zuerst eine Multi-Skalen Technik (“Force-matching”) verwendet um eine effektive Wechselwirkung aus einer detaillierten Simulation auf Basis der Dichtefunktionaltheorie zu extrahieren. Die Pfadintegral MD Simulation verbessert die Beschreibung der intra-molekularen Struktur im Vergleich mit experimentellen Daten. Das Modell eignet sich auch zur gleichzeitigen Kopplung in einer Simulation, wobei ein Wassermolekül (beschrieben durch 48 Punktteilchen im Pfadintegral-MD Modell) mit einem vereinfachten Modell (ein Punktteilchen) gekoppelt wird. Auf diese Weise konnte eine Wasser-Vakuum Grenzfläche simuliert werden, wobei nur die Oberfläche im Pfadintegral Modell und der Rest im vereinfachten Modell beschrieben wird.

Molecular dynamics simulations of silicate and borate glasses and melts : structure, diffusion dynamics and vibrational properties

Molecular dynamics simulations of silicate and borate glasses and melts: Structure, diffusion dynamics and vibrational properties. In this work computer simulations of the model glass formers SiO2 and B2O3 are presented, using the techniques of classical molecular dynamics (MD) simulations and quantum mechanical calculations, based on density functional theory (DFT). The latter limits the system size to about 100−200 atoms. SiO2 and B2O3 are the two most important network formers for industrial applications of oxide glasses. Glass samples are generated by means of a quench from the melt with classical MD simulations and a subsequent structural relaxation with DFT forces. In addition, full ab initio quenches are carried out with a significantly faster cooling rate. In principle, the structural properties are in good agreement with experimental results from neutron and X-ray scattering, in all cases. A special focus is on the study of vibrational properties, as they give access to low-temperature thermodynamic properties. The vibrational spectra are calculated by the so-called ”frozen phonon” method. In all cases, the DFT curves show an acceptable agreement with experimental results of inelastic neutron scattering. In case of the model glass former B2O3, a new classical interaction potential is parametrized, based on the liquid trajectory of an ab initio MD simulation at 2300 K. In this course, a structural fitting routine is used. The inclusion of 3-body angular interactions leads to a significantly improved agreement of the liquid properties of the classical MD and ab initio MD simulations. However, the generated glass structures, in all cases, show a significantly lower fraction of 3-membered planar boroxol rings as predicted by experimental results (f=60%-80%). The largest boroxol ring fraction of f=15±5% is observed in the full ab initio quenches from 2300 K. In case of SiO2, the glass structures after the quantum mechanical relaxation are the basis for calculations of the linear thermal expansion coefficient αL(T), employing the quasi-harmonic approximation. The striking observation is a change change of sign of αL(T) going along with a temperature range of negative αL(T) at low temperatures, which is in good agreement with experimental results.

Numerical analysis of the relation between interactions and structure in a molecular fluid

Coarse graining is a popular technique used in physics to speed up the computer simulation of molecular fluids. An essential part of this technique is a method that solves the inverse problem of determining the interaction potential or its parameters from the given structural data. Due to discrepancies between model and reality, the potential is not unique, such that stability of such method and its convergence to a meaningful solution are issues.rnrnIn this work, we investigate empirically whether coarse graining can be improved by applying the theory of inverse problems from applied mathematics. In particular, we use the singular value analysis to reveal the weak interaction parameters, that have a negligible influence on the structure of the fluid and which cause non-uniqueness of the solution. Further, we apply a regularizing Levenberg-Marquardt method, which is stable against the mentioned discrepancies. Then, we compare it to the existing physical methods - the Iterative Boltzmann Inversion and the Inverse Monte Carlo method, which are fast and well adapted to the problem, but sometimes have convergence problems.rnrnFrom analysis of the Iterative Boltzmann Inversion, we elaborate a meaningful approximation of the structure and use it to derive a modification of the Levenberg-Marquardt method. We engage the latter for reconstruction of the interaction parameters from experimental data for liquid argon and nitrogen. We show that the modified method is stable, convergent and fast. Further, the singular value analysis of the structure and its approximation allows to determine the crucial interaction parameters, that is, to simplify the modeling of interactions. Therefore, our results build a rigorous bridge between the inverse problem from physics and the powerful solution tools from mathematics. rn