Global Fatigue Assessment of a Decommissioned Jacket Platform for a Sustainable Reuse as an Offshore Wind Turbine

When the offshore oil and gas supplies exhaust, offshore platforms must be decommissioned and removed. The present thesis highlights the importance of evaluating the possibility of reuse of decommissioned offshore jacket platforms for offshore wind energy. In order to shift to the new structure, the topside must be removed from the substructure and a wind turbine can be installed in its place. The feasibility of this project was investigated using a finite element analysis software called Sesam. To study fatigue life in offshore structures, an exhaustive review of the background and state of the art was done. A finite element model was created by the means of Sesam and two different fatigue analysis approaches were applied and compared. In the end, an analysis methodology is suggested for the structural fatigue analysis of offshore wind turbine structures based on international standards, addressing the industry’s need to account for the combined effect of wind and hydrodynamic loads in these type of structures.

Influence of advanced load simulation models on fatigue design of jackets for offshore wind turbines.

Constant developments in the field of offshore wind energy have increased the range of water depths at which wind farms are planned to be installed. Therefore, in addition to monopile support structures suitable in shallow waters (up to 30 m), different types of support structures, able to withstand severe sea conditions at the greater water depths, have been developed. For water depths above 30 m, the jacket is one of the preferred support types. Jacket represents a lightweight support structure, which, in combination with complex nature of environmental loads, is prone to highly dynamic behavior. As a consequence, high stresses with great variability in time can be observed in all structural members. The highest concentration of stresses occurs in joints due to their nature (structural discontinuities) and due to the existence of notches along the welds present in the joints. This makes them the weakest elements of the jacket in terms of fatigue. In the numerical modeling of jackets for offshore wind turbines, a reduction of local stresses at the chord-brace joints, and consequently an optimization of the model, can be achieved by implementing joint flexibility in the chord-brace joints. Therefore, in this work, the influence of joint flexibility on the fatigue damage in chord-brace joints of a numerical jacket model, subjected to advanced load simulations, is studied.

FEM and experimental analysis of a wind turbine blade

This paperwork compares the a numerical validation of the finite element model (FEM) with respect the experimental tests of a new generation wind turbine blade designed by TPI Composites Inc. called BSDS (Blade System Design Study). The research is focused on the analysis by finite element (FE) of the BSDS blade and its comparison with respect the experimental data from static and dynamic investigations. The goal of the research is to create a general procedure which is based on a finite element model and will be used to create an accurate digital copy for any kind of blade. The blade prototype was created in SolidWorks and the blade of Sandia National Laboratories Blade System Design Study was accurately reproduced. At a later stage the SolidWorks model was imported in Ansys Mechanical APDL where the shell geometry was created and modal, static and fatigue analysis were carried out. The outcomes of the FEM analysis were compared with the real test on the BSDS blade at Clarkson University laboratory carried out by a new procedures called Blade Test Facility that includes different methods for both the static and dynamic test of the wind turbine blade. The outcomes from the FEM analysis reproduce the real behavior of the blade subjected to static loads in a very satisfying way. A most detailed study about the material properties could improve the accuracy of the analysis.

Fatigue Design Challenges of Transition Pieces from Decommissioned Platforms for Offshore Wind Energy

All structures are subjected to various loading conditions and combinations. For offshore structures, these loads include permanent loads, hydrostatic pressure, wave, current, and wind loads. Typically, sea environments in different geographical regions are characterized by the 100-year wave height, surface currents, and velocity speeds. The main problems associated with the commonly used, deterministic method is the fact that not all waves have the same period, and that the actual stochastic nature of the marine environment is not taken into account. Offshore steel structure fatigue design is done using the DNVGL-RP-0005:2016 standard which takes precedence over the DNV-RP-C203 standard (2012). Fatigue analysis is necessary for oil and gas producing offshore steel structures which were first constructed in the Gulf of Mexico North Sea (the 1930s) and later in the North Sea (1960s). Fatigue strength is commonly described by S-N curves which have been obtained by laboratory experiments. The rapid development of the Offshore wind industry has caused the exploration into deeper ocean areas and the adoption of new support structural concepts such as full lattice tower systems amongst others. The optimal design of offshore wind support structures including foundation, turbine towers, and transition piece components putting into consideration, economy, safety, and even the environment is a critical challenge. In this study, fatigue design challenges of transition pieces from decommissioned platforms for offshore wind energy are proposed to be discussed. The fatigue resistance of the material and structural components under uniaxial and multiaxial loading is introduced with the new fatigue design rules whilst considering the combination of global and local modeling using finite element analysis software programs.

Hybrid foundations for offshore wind turbines

Nowadays offshore wind turbines represents a valid answer for energy production but with an increasing in costs mainly due to foundation technology required. Hybrid foundations composed by suction caissons over which is welded a tower supporting the nacelle and the blades allows a strong costs reduction. Here a monopod configuration is studied in a sandy soil in a 10 m water depth. Bearing capacity, sliding resistance and pull-out resistance are evaluated. In a second part the installation process occurring in four steps is analysed. considering also the effect of stress enhancement due to frictional forces opposing to penetration growing at skirt sides both inside and outside. In a three dimensional finite element model using Straus7 the soil non-linearity is considered in an approximate way through an iterative procedure using the Yokota empirical decay curves.

Cure Induced Residual Stresses on Thick Composite Components Manufactured by Additive Process

This study investigates the effect of an additive process in manufacturing of thick composites. Airstone 780 E epoxy resin and 785H Hardener system is used in the analysis since it is widely used wind turbine blade, namely thick components. As a fiber, fabric by SAERTEX (812 g/m2) with a 0-90 degrees layup direction is used. Temperature overshoot is a major issue during the manufacturing of thick composites. A high temperature overshoot leads to an increase in residual stresses. These residual stresses are causing warping, delamination, dimensional instability, and undesired distortion of composite structures. A coupled thermo-mechanical model capable of predicting cure induced residual stresses have been built using the commercial FE software Abaqus®. The possibility of building thick composite components by means of adding a finite number of sub-laminates has been investigated. The results have been compared against components manufactured following a standard route. The influence of pre-curing of the sub-laminates has also been addressed and results compared with standard practice. As a result of the study, it is found that introducing additive process can prevent temperature overshoot to occur and benefits the residual stresses generation during the curing process. However, the process time required increases by 50%, therefore increasing the manufacturing costs. An optimized cure cycle is required to minimize process time and cure induced defects simultaneously.

Numerical Analysis and Redesign of a High Speed Linear Cascade Wind Tunnel for Aircraft Gas Turbine Engines Testing

Linear cascade testing serves a fundamental role in the research, development, and design of turbomachines as it is a simple yet very effective way to compute the performance of a generic blade geometry. These kinds of experiments are usually carried out in specialized wind tunnel facilities. This thesis deals with the numerical characterization and subsequent partial redesign of the S-1/C Continuous High Speed Wind Tunnel of the Von Karman Institute for Fluid Dynamics. The current facility is powered by a 13-stage axial compressor that is not powerful enough to balance the energy loss experienced when testing low turning airfoils. In order to address this issue a performance assessment of the wind tunnel was performed under several flow regimes via numerical simulations. After that, a redesign proposal aimed at reducing the pressure loss was investigated. This consists of a linear cascade of turning blades to be placed downstream of the test section and designed specifically for the type of linear cascade being tested. An automatic design procedure was created taking as input parameters those measured at the outlet of the cascade. The parametrization method employed Bézier curves to produce an airfoil geometry that could be imported into a CAD software so that a cascade could be designed. The proposal was simulated via CFD analysis and proved to be effective in reducing pressure losses up to 41%. The same tool developed in this thesis could be adopted to design similar apparatuses and could also be optimized and specialized for the design of turbomachines components.

Attenuation of thermal radiation from flare through water curtains on offshore platform.

Flaring has been widely used in the upstream operation of the oil and gas industry, both onshore and offshore. It is considered a safe and reliable way to protect assets from overpressure and the environment from toxic gas using combustion. However, there are drawbacks to using flares, such as vibration and thermal radiation. Excessive contact with thermal radiation is harmful to offshore personnel and equipment. Research organizations and companies have invested time and money to combat this. Many technologies have been developed so far to reduce the risk of thermal radiation, one of them being the water curtain system. Several tests were done to see the effectiveness of the water curtain system in mitigating thermal radiation in an offshore environment. Each test varied in the flare output, wind speed, and the size of water droplets size of the water curtain. Later, the results of each test were compared and analyzed. The results showed that a water curtain system could be a solution to excessive thermal radiation that comes from an offshore flare. Moreover, the water curtain with smaller water droplets diameter gives a more favorable result in reducing thermal radiation. These results suggest that, although it offers simplicity and efficiency, designing an efficient water curtain system requires deep study. Various conditions, such as wind speed, flare intensity, and the size of the water droplets, plays a vital role in the effectiveness of the water curtain system in attenuating thermal radiation.

Design of an indirectly fired gas turbine integrated with an organic rankine cycle unit for combined heat and power production

In the last years, the European countries have paid increasing attention to renewable sources and greenhouse emissions. The Council of the European Union and the European Parliament have established ambitious targets for the next years. In this scenario, biomass plays a prominent role since its life cycle produces a zero net carbon dioxide emission. Additionally, biomass can ensure plant operation continuity thanks to its availability and storage ability. Several conventional systems running on biomass are available at the moment. Most of them are performant either in the large-scale or in the small power range. The absence of an efficient system on the small-middle scale inspired this thesis project. The object is an innovative plant based on a wet indirectly fired gas turbine (WIFGT) integrated with an organic Rankine cycle (ORC) unit for combined heat and power production. The WIFGT is a performant system in the small-middle power range; the ORC cycle is capable of giving value to low-temperature heat sources. Their integration is investigated in this thesis with the aim of carrying out a preliminary design of the components. The targeted plant output is around 200 kW in order not to need a wide cultivation area and to avoid biomass shipping. Existing in-house simulation tools are used: They are adapted to this purpose. Firstly the WIFGT + ORC model is built; Zero-dimensional models of heat exchangers, compressor, turbines, furnace, dryer and pump are used. Different fluids are selected but toluene and benzene turn out to be the most suitable. In the indirectly fired gas turbine a pressure ratio around 4 leads to the highest efficiency. From the thermodynamic analysis the system shows an electric efficiency of 38%, outdoing other conventional plants in the same power range. The combined plant is designed to recover thermal energy: Water is used as coolant in the condenser. It is heated from 60°C up to 90°C, ensuring the possibility of space heating. Mono-dimensional models are used to design the heat exchange equipment. Different types of heat exchangers are chosen depending on the working temperature. A finned-plate heat exchanger is selected for the WIFGT heat transfer equipment due to the high temperature, oxidizing and corrosive environment. A once-through boiler with finned tubes is chosen to vaporize the organic fluid in the ORC. A plate heat exchanger is chosen for the condenser and recuperator. A quasi-monodimensional model for single-stage axial turbine is implemented to design both the WIFGT and the ORC turbine. The system simulation after the components design shows an electric efficiency around 34% with a decrease by 10% compared to the zero-dimensional analysis. The work exhibits the system potentiality compared to the existing plants from both technical and economic point of view.

Stress Concentration Factor and Fatigue Life Evaluation in offshore tubular KT-Joints

In the last few decades, offshore field has grown fast especially after the notable development of technologies, explorations of oil and gas in deep water and the high concern of offshore companies in renewable energy mainly Wind Energy. Fatigue damage was noticed as one of the main problems causing failure of offshore structures. The purpose of this research is to focus on the evaluation of Stress Concentration Factor and its influence on Fatigue Life for 2 tubular KT-Joints in offshore Jacket structure using different calculation methods. The work is done by using analytical calculations, mainly Efthymiou’s formulations, and numerical solutions, FEM analysis, using ABAQUS software. As for the analytical formulations, the calculations were done according to the geometrical parameters of each method using excel sheets. As for the numerical model, 2 different types of tubular KT-Joints are present where for each model 5 shell element type, 3 solid element type and 3 solid-with-weld element type models were built on ABAQUS. Meshing was assigned according to International Institute of Welding (IIW) recommendations, 5 types of mesh element, to evaluate the Hot-spot stresses. 23 different types of unitary loading conditions were assigned, 9 axial, 7 in-plane bending moment and 7 out-plane bending moment loads. The extraction of Hot-spot stresses and the evaluation of the Stress Concentration Factor were done using PYTHON scripting and MATLAB. Then, the fatigue damage evaluation for a critical KT tubular joint based on Simplified Fatigue Damage Rule and Local Approaches (Strain Damage Parameter and Stress Damage Parameter) methods were calculated according to the maximum Stress Concentration Factor conducted from DNV and FEA methods. In conclusion, this research helped us to compare different results of Stress Concentration Factor and Fatigue Life using different methods and provided us with a general overview about what to study next in the future.

Metocean Climate Impact on the Fatigue Assessment of a Jacket-Type Offshore Platform

When the offshore oil and gas supplies exhaust, most offshore platforms are decommissioned and removed. The purpose of this paper is to evaluate the fatigue damage that will occur during the service life of a jacket-type offshore platform using different fatigue approaches in particular locations. The locations considered for this metocean climate impact study were Norway (North Sea), Portugal (Atlantic Ocean - Leixões) and Italy (Adriatic Sea). A finite element model was created by the means of Sesam and two different fatigue analysis, deterministic and spectral, were applied. For the fatigue assessment, an appropriate description of the site-specific wave environment, during the jacket platform service life, must be accomplished. This description is usually provided by a wave scatter diagram. Wave scatter diagrams usually represent the long-term wave environment during a (typical) year and are based on several years of site-specific data to ensure that they adequately represent the wave environment at the location of the structure. In this thesis, the comparison between these fatigue approaches will serve as a pilot study for planned reliability analysis in decommissioned offshore platforms in order to maximize the reuse of these platforms for future wind generation systems.

Numerical modelling of axially loaded piled foundations with physical tests validation

L'oggetto della tesi è la modellazione numerica di pali di fondazione per turbine eoliche in ambiente offshore. Il metodo di modellazione comprende l'interpretazione di prove CPT per l'estrapolazione dei parametri geotecnici del terreno, la creazione di un modello dell'interazione tra struttura e terreno tramite il software agli elementi finiti Abaqus, la sua verifica, l'ottimizzazione dell'estensione del modello del terreno e della mesh e la simulazione numerica del comportamento di pali caricati assialmente in compressione. Grazie al confronto con i risultati di test su modelli fisici, eseguiti nel laboratorio dell'istituto Fraunhofer IWES di Hannover, di tre pali aventi la stessa geometria ma installati in punti con diverse condizioni di compattazione della sabbia, è stata possibile la messa a punto di una strategia di simulazione più accurata possibile e la sua validazione. A conclusione del lavoro è stato eseguito un esempio di design di una fondazione jacket per una turbina eolica offshore.

A framework for the environmental risk assessment of offshore carbon storage in CCS systems

Carbon capture and storage (CCS) represents an interesting climate mitigation option, however, as for any other human activity, there is the impelling need to assess and manage the associated risks. This study specifically addresses the marine environmental risk posed by CO2 leakages associated to CCS subsea engineering system, meant as offshore pipelines and injection / plugged and abandoned wells. The aim of this thesis work is to start approaching the development of a complete and standardized practical procedure to perform a quantified environmental risk assessment for CCS, with reference to the specific activities mentioned above. Such an effort would be of extreme relevance not only for companies willing to implement CCS, as a methodological guidance, but also, by uniformizing the ERA procedure, to begin changing people’s perception about CCS, that happens to be often discredited due to the evident lack of comprehensive and systematic methods to assess the impacts on the marine environment. The backbone structure of the framework developed consists on the integration of ERA’s main steps and those belonging to the quantified risk assessment (QRA), in the aim of quantitatively characterizing risk and describing it as a combination of magnitude of the consequences and their frequency. The framework developed by this work is, however, at a high level, as not every single aspect has been dealt with in the required detail. Thus, several alternative options are presented to be considered for use depending on the situation. Further specific studies should address their accuracy and efficiency and solve the knowledge gaps emerged, in order to establish and validate a final and complete procedure. Regardless of the knowledge gaps and uncertainties, that surely need to be addressed, this preliminary framework already finds some relevance in on field applications, as a non-stringent guidance to perform CCS ERA, and it constitutes the foundation of the final framework.

Development and Automatization of a Planar Jet Wind Tunnel for the X-wire Calibration

The scope of this study is to design an automatic control system and create an automatic x-wire calibrator for a facility named Plane Air Tunnel; whose exit creates planar jet flow. The controlling power state as well as automatic speed adjustment of the inverter has been achieved. Thus, the wind tunnel can be run with respect to any desired speed and the x-wire can automatically be calibrated at that speed. To achieve that, VI programming using the LabView environment was learned, to acquire the pressure and temperature, and to calculate the velocity based on the acquisition data thanks to a pitot-static tube. Furthermore, communication with the inverter to give the commands for power on/off and speed control was also done using the LabView VI coding environment. The connection of the computer to the inverter was achieved by the proper cabling using DAQmx Analog/Digital (A/D) input/output (I/O). Moreover, the pressure profile along the streamwise direction of the plane air tunnel was studied. Pressure tappings and a multichannel pressure scanner were used to acquire the pressure values at different locations. Thanks to that, the aerodynamic efficiency of the contraction ratio was observed, and the pressure behavior was related to the velocity at the exit section. Furthermore, the control of the speed was accomplished by implementing a closed-loop PI controller on the LabView environment with and without using a pitot-static tube thanks to the pressure behavior information. The responses of the two controllers were analyzed and commented on by giving suggestions. In addition, hot wire experiments were performed to calibrate automatically and investigate the velocity profile of a turbulent planar jet. To be able to analyze the results, the physics of turbulent planar jet flow was studied. The fundamental terms, the methods used in the derivation of the equations, velocity profile, shear stress behavior, and the effect of vorticity were reviewed.