Science of retracted science: a citation analysis of the arts and humanities domain

In the scholarly publishing domain, a retraction is raised when a specific publication is considered erroneous by the venue in which it appeared after it was published. The aim of this work is uncovering new insights and learn new important information to help us understand the retraction phenomenon in the arts and humanities domain. Our investigation is based on a methodology defined using quantitative and qualitative measures derived from previous studies in the transdisciplinary research field of “science of science” (SciSci). The designed methodology takes into account a general case of retraction and applies a citation analysis based on five phases. Citations to retracted publications (before and after their retraction) are gathered and characterized with a set of attributes, including general metadata and information extracted from citing entities’ full text. The annotated characteristics are further considered for a statistical and a textual analysis (i.e., a topic modeling analysis). The contribution of this thesis is grounded by addressing the following research questions: (RQ1) How did scholarly research cite retracted humanities publications before and after their retraction? (RQ2) Did all the humanities areas behave similarly concerning the retraction phenomenon? (RQ3) What are the main differences and similarities in the retraction dynamics between the humanities domain and the STEM disciplines? RQ1 and RQ2 are addressed by tuning and applying the methodology on the analysis of the retracted publications in the humanities domain. RQ3 is addressed on two levels, i.e., considering and comparing: (L1) the outcomes of the past studies on the retraction in STEM, and (L2) the results obtained from an analysis of a retraction case in STEM using the defined methodology.

Visual scanning in sports actions: comparison between soccer goalkeepers and judo fighters

Visual search and oculomotor behaviour are believed to be very relevant for athlete performance, especially for sports requiring refined visuo-motor coordination skills. Modern coaches believe that a correct visuo-motor strategy may be part of advanced training programs. In this thesis two experiments are reported in which gaze behaviour of expert and novice athletes were investigated while they were doing a real sport specific task. The experiments concern two different sports: judo and soccer. In each experiment, number of fixations, fixation locations and mean fixation duration (ms) were considered. An observational analysis was done at the end of the paper to see perceptual differences between near and far space. Purpose: The aim of the judo study was to delineate differences in gaze behaviour characteristics between a population of athletes and one of non athletes. Aspects specifically investigated were: search rate, search order and viewing time across different conditions in a real-world task. The second study was aimed at identifying gaze behaviour in varsity soccer goalkeepers while facing a penalty kick executed with instep and inside foot. Then an attempt has been done to compare the gaze strategies of expert judoka and soccer goalkeepers in order to delineate possible differences related to the different conditions of reacting to events occurring in near (peripersonal) or far (extrapersonal) space. Judo Methods: A sample of 9 judoka (black belt) and 11 near judoka (white belt) were studied. Eye movements were recorded at 500Hz using a video based eye tracker (EyeLink II). Each subject participated in 40 sessions for about 40 minutes. Gaze behaviour was considered as average number of locations fixated per trial, the average number of fixations per trial, and mean fixation duration. Soccer Methods: Seven (n = 7) intermediate level male volunteered for the experiment. The kickers and goalkeepers, had at least varsity level soccer experience. The vision-in-action (VIA) system (Vickers 1996; Vickers 2007) was used to collect the coupled gaze and motor behaviours of the goalkeepers. This system integrated input from a mobile eye tracking system (Applied Sciences Laboratories) with an external video of the goalkeeper’s saving actions. The goalkeepers took 30 penalty kicks on a synthetic pitch in accordance with FIFA (2008) laws. Judo Results: Results indicate that experts group differed significantly from near expert for fixations duration, and number of fixations per trial. The expert judokas used a less exhaustive search strategy involving fewer fixations of longer duration than their novice counterparts and focused on central regions of the body. The results showed that in defence and attack situation expert group did a greater number of transitions with respect to their novice counterpart. Soccer Results: We found significant main effect for the number of locations fixated across outcome (goal/save) but not for foot contact (instep/inside). Participants spent more time fixating the areas in instep than inside kick and in goal than in save situation. Mean and standard error in search strategy as a result of foot contact and outcome indicate that the most gaze behaviour start and finish on ball interest areas. Conclusions: Expert goalkeepers tend to spend more time in inside-save than instep-save penalty, differences that was opposite in scored penalty kick. Judo results show that differences in visual behaviour related to the level of expertise appear mainly when the test presentation is continuous, last for a relatively long period of time and present a high level of uncertainty with regard to the chronology and the nature of events. Expert judoist performers “anchor” the fovea on central regions of the scene (lapel and face) while using peripheral vision to monitor opponents’ limb movements. The differences between judo and soccer gaze strategies are discussed on the light of physiological and neuropsychological differences between near and far space perception.

Plasticity and neuromodulation of the extended recurrent visual network

The extended visual network, which includes occipital, temporal and parietal posterior cortices, is a system characterized by an intrinsic connectivity consisting of bidirectional projections. This network is composed of feedforward and feedback projections, some hierarchically arranged and others bypassing intermediate areas, allowing direct communication across early and late stages of processing. Notably, the early visual cortex (EVC) receives considerably more feedback and lateral inputs than feedforward thalamic afferents, placing it at the receiving end of a complex cortical processing cascade, rather than just being the entrance stage of cortical processing of retinal input. The critical role of back-projections to visual cortices has been related to perceptual awareness, amplification of neural activity in lower order areas and improvement of stimulus processing. Recently, significant results have shown behavioural evidence suggesting the importance of reentrant projections in the human visual system, and demonstrated the feasibility of inducing their reversible modulation through a transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) paradigm named cortico-cortical paired associative stimulation (ccPAS). Here, a novel research line for the study of recurrent connectivity and its plasticity in the perceptual domain was put forward. In the present thesis, we used ccPAS with the aim of empowering the synaptic efficacy, and thus the connectivity, between the nodes of the visuocognitive system to evaluate the impact on behaviour. We focused on driving plasticity in specific networks entailing the elaboration of relevant social features of human faces (Chapters I & II), alongside the investigation of targeted pathways of sensory decisions (Chapter III). This allowed us to characterize perceptual outcomes which endorse the prominent role of the EVC in visual awareness, fulfilled by the activity of back-projections originating from distributed functional nodes.

Alpha oscillations index the functionality and the plastic changes of the visual system

Alpha oscillations are linked to visual awareness and to the periodical sampling of visual information, suggesting that alpha rhythm reflect an index of the functionality of the posterior cortices, and hence of the visual system. Therefore, the present work described a series of studies investigating alpha oscillations as a biomarker of the functionality and the plastic modifications of the visual system in response to lesions to the visual cortices or to external stimulations. The studies presented in chapter 5 and 6 showed that posterior lesions alter alpha oscillations in hemianopic patients, with reduced alpha reactivity at the eyes opening and decreased alpha functional connectivity, especially in right-lesioned hemianopics, with concurrent dysfunctions in the theta range, suggesting a specialization of the right hemisphere in orchestrating alpha oscillations and coordinating complex interplays among different brain rhythms. The study presented in chapter 7 investigated a mechanism of rhythmical attentional sampling of visual information in healthy participants, showing that perceptual performance is influenced by a rhythmical mechanism of attentional allocation, occurring at lower-alpha frequencies (i.e., 7 Hz), when a single spatial location is monitored, and at lower frequencies (i.e., 5 Hz), when attention is allocated to two spatial locations. Moreover, the right hemisphere seemed to have a dominance in this rhythmical attentional sampling, distributing attentional resources to the entire visual field. Finally, the study presented in chapter 8 showed that prolonged visual entrainment induce long-term modulations of resting-state alpha activity in healthy participants, suggesting that persistent modifications in the functionality of the visual system are possible. Altogheter, these findings show that functional processes and plastic changes of the visual system are reflected in alpha oscillatory patterns. Therefore, investigating and promoting alpha oscillations may contribute to the development of rehabilitative protocols to ameliorate the functionality of the visual system, in brain lesioned patients.