The role of nuclear power in the future energy system

Currently widely accepted consensus is that greenhouse gas emissions produced by the mankind have to be reduced in order to avoid further global warming. The European Union has set a variety of CO2 reduction and renewable generation targets for its member states. The current energy system in the Nordic countries is one of the most carbon free in the world, but the aim is to achieve a fully carbon neutral energy system. The objective of this thesis is to consider the role of nuclear power in the future energy system. Nuclear power is a low carbon energy technology because it produces virtually no air pollutants during operation. In this respect, nuclear power is suitable for a carbon free energy system. In this master's thesis, the basic characteristics of nuclear power are presented and compared to fossil fuelled and renewable generation. Nordic energy systems and different scenarios in 2050 are modelled. Using models and information about the basic characteristics of nuclear power, an opinion is formed about its role in the future energy system in Nordic countries. The model shows that it is possible to form a carbon free Nordic energy system. Nordic countries benefit from large hydropower capacity which helps to offset fluctuating nature of wind power. Biomass fuelled generation and nuclear power provide stable and predictable electricity throughout the year. Nuclear power offers better energy security and security of supply than fossil fuelled generation and it is competitive with other low carbon technologies.

Mitigation possibilities to Greenhouse gas emissions from power production in India

Global warming is assertively the greatest environmental challenge for humans of 21st century. It is primarily caused by the anthropogenic greenhouse gas (GHG) that trap heat in the atmosphere. Because of which, the GHG emission mitigation, globally, is a critical issue in the political agenda of all high-profile nations. India, like other developing countries, is facing this threat of climate change while dealing with the challenge of sustaining its rapid economic growth. India’s economy is closely connected to its natural resource base and climate sensitive sectors like water, agriculture and forestry. Due to Climate change the quality and distribution of India’s natural resources may transform and lead to adverse effects on livelihood of its people. Therefore, India is expected to face a major threat due to the projected climate change. This study proposes possible solutions for GHG emission mitigation that are specific to the power sector of India. The methods discussed here will take Indian power sector from present coal dominant ideology to a system, centered with renewable energy sources. The study further proposes a future scenario for 2050, based on the present Indian government policies and global energy technologies advancements.

Evaluation of the main energy scenarios for the global energy transition

Energy scenarios are used as a tool to examine credible future states and pathways. The one who constructs a scenario defines the framework in which the possible outcomes exist. The credibility of a scenario depends on its compatibility with real world experiences, and on how well the general information of the study, methodology, and originality and processing of data are disclosed. In the thesis, selected global energy scenarios’ transparency and desirability from the society’s point of view were evaluated based on literature derived criteria. The global energy transition consists of changes to social conventions and economic development in addition to technological development. Energy solutions are economic and ethical choices due to far-reaching impacts of energy decision-making. Currently the global energy system is mostly based on fossil fuels, which is unsustainable over the long-term due to various reasons: negative climate change impacts, negative health impacts, depletion of fossil fuel reserves, resource-use conflicts with water management and food supply, loss of biodiversity, challenge to preserve ecosystems and resources for future generations, and inability of fossil fuels to provide universal access to modern energy services. Nuclear power and carbon capture and storage cannot be regarded as sustainable energy solutions due to their inherent risks and required long-term storage. The energy transition is driven by a growing energy demand, decreasing costs of renewables, modularity and scalability of renewable technologies, macroeconomic benefits of using renewables, investors’ risk awareness, renewable energy related attractive business opportunities, almost even distribution of solar and wind resources on the planet, growing awareness of the planet’s environmental status, environmental movements and tougher environmental legislation. Many of the investigated scenarios identified solar and wind power as a backbone for future energy systems. The scenarios, in which the solar and wind potentials were deployed in largest scale, met best the set out sustainability criteria. In future research, energy scenarios’ transparency can be improved by better disclosure on who has ordered the study, clarifying the funding, clearly referencing to used sources and indicating processed data, and by exploring how variations in cost assumptions and deployment of technologies influence on the outcomes of the study.

The purpose and use of passenger ships in 2058 - Future scenarios generated by the Delphi method

The purpose of the thesis is to generate scenarios of future purposes and of use of ships, suitable for STX Finland Cruise Oy to design and build, over a 50 year time span by applying the Delphi method and an open innovation approach in a future workshop. The scenarios were mapped out with help of two Delphi survey rounds and one future workshop. The number of participants in both surveys and the workshop was some twenty experts in each, representing various fields. On the basis of the first survey round, four different subject areas were selected for analysis: purposes for the use of ships; energy efficiency of cruises and ships; cost efficiency of sea transportation and vacation; and the views and expectations of the customers in the future. As a result of the future workshop, four different themes were established, which were studied further during the second Delphi round. The themes are future service and operation concepts; versatile uses of the space in ships; communication of environmental benefits of ships, future energy solutions and social interaction between passengers onboard. In addition to generating the scenarios, further aim of the thesis is to implement the Delphi method and workshop activity as foresight tools for STX Europe and to produce a chart of a future shipbuilding foresight community to can serve the open innovation processes in the maritime cluster as a whole.

Development of a measuring-control system for energy monitoring in low power

In this thesis a control system for an intelligent low voltage energy grid is presented, focusing on the control system created by using a multi-agent approach which makes it versatile and easy to expand according to the future needs. The control system is capable of forecasting the future energy consumption and decisions making on its own without human interaction when countering problems. The control system is a part of the St. Petersburg State Polytechnic University’s smart grid project that aims to create a smart grid for the university’s own use. The concept of the smart grid is interesting also for the consumers as it brings new possibilities to control own energy consumption and to save money. Smart grids makes it possible to monitor the energy consumption in real-time and to change own habits to save money. The intelligent grid also brings possibilities to integrate the renewable energy sources to the global or the local energy production much better than the current systems. Consumers can also sell their extra power to the global grid if they want.

Commercialization of Modern Renewable Energy

The threat of global warming and its consequences are widely recognized, and the question of how to proceed with the long transition towards fossil fuel -neutral economies concerns many nations and people. At the same time the world’s primary energy use is predicted to increase significantly during the next decades as a result of global population and welfare increase. Improved energy efficiency and increased use of renewable energy sources in the world’s energy mix play important roles in the future energy production and consumption. The objective of this thesis is to study how novel renewable energy technologies, such as distributed small-scale bio-fueled combined heat and power production and wind power technologies could be commercialized efficiently. A wide array of attributes may contribute to the diffusion of new products. In general, the bioenergy and wind power technologies are in emerging phases, and the diffusion stage varies from country to country. The effects of firms’ technology choices, collaboration and alliances are studied in this thesis. Furthermore, the roles of national energy infrastructure and energy support schemes in the commercialization of new renewable energy products are explored. The empirical data is based on energy expert interviews, financial and patent data, and literature reviews of different case studies. The thesis comprises two parts. The first part provides an overview of the study, and the second part includes six research publications. The results reveal that small-scale bio-fueled combined heat and power production and wind power technologies are still in emerging phases in their life cycles, and energy support schemes are crucial in the market diffusion. The study contributes to earlier findings in the literature and industry by confirming that adequate energy policies and energy infrastructure are fundamental in the commercialization of novel renewable energy technologies. Firm-specific issues, including business relationships and new business models, and market-related issues will have a more significant role in the market penetration in the future, when the technologies mature and become competitive without political support schemes.

The role of nuclear and other conventional power plants in the flexible energy system

This thesis reviews the role of nuclear and conventional power plants in the future energy system. The review is done by utilizing freely accesible publications in addition to generating load duration and ramping curves for Nordic energy system. As the aim of the future energy system is to reduce GHG-emissions and avoid further global warming, the need for flexible power generation increases with the increased share of intermittent renewables. The goal of this thesis is to offer extensive understanding of possibilities and restrictions that nuclear power and conventional power plants have regarding flexible and sustainable generation. As a conclusion, nuclear power is the only technology that is able to provide large scale GHG-free power output variations with good ramping values. Most of the currently operating plants are able to take part in load following as the requirement to do so is already required to be included in the plant design. Load duration and ramping curves produced prove that nuclear power is able to cover most of the annual generation variation and ramping needs in the Nordic energy system. From the conventional power generation methods, only biomass combustion can be considered GHG-free because biomass is considered carbon neutral. CFB combusted biomass has good load follow capabilities in good ramping and turndown ratios. All the other conventional power generation technologies generate GHG-emissions and therefore the use of these technologies should be reduced.

Renewable energy scenarios for South Karelia – non-industrial energy demands

Tässä diplomityössä tarkastellaan täysin uusiutuvaa energiajärjestelmää Etelä-Karjalan maakunnan alueella, mikä onkin jo tällä hetkellä Suomen uusiutuvin maakunta. Diplomityössä tarkastellaan julkisen sektorin, liikenteen ja rakennusten energian kulutusta mutta teollisuuden energiankäyttö jätetään tarkastelun ulkopuolelle. Työssä tutustutaan tämän hetken Etelä-Karjalan energiajärjestelmään ja sen perusteella tehdään referenssi-skenaario. Tulevaisuuden skenaariot tehdään vuosille 2030 ja 2050. Tulevaisuuden skenaarioissa muutos keskittyy järjestelmän sähköistymiseen ja uusiutuvien tuotantomuotojen integroimiseen järjestelmään. Sähköistyminen kasvattaa sähkönkulutusta, joka pyritään kattamaan uusiutuvilla tuotantomuodoilla, lähinnä tuuli- ja aurinkovoimalla. Liikennesektori rajataan kumipyöräliikenteeseen ja sen muutos tulee olemaan haastavin ja aikaa vievin. Muutokseen pyritään liikennepolttoaineiden tuotannolla maakunnassa sekä sähköautoilulla. Uusiutuva energiajärjestelmä tarvitsee tuotannon ja kysynnän joustoa sekä älyä järjestelmältä. Työssä tarkastellaan myös järjestelmän kustannuksia sekä työllisyysvaikutuksia.

Baltian maihin ja Puolaan suuntautuvan merirahtiliikenteen tulevaisuusskenaarioita

Työssä käsitellään Itämeren rahtiliikennettä ja sen kehitykseen vaikuttavia tekijöitä. Työn ajankohtaisuutta on lisännyt Euroopan unionin laajentuminen toukokuussa 2004, jolloin Viro, Latvia, Liettua ja Puola liittyivät kaikki EU:hun. Työn teoriaosuus painottuu tulevaisuudentutkimukseen ja erityisesti skenaariotutkimukseen. Työssä on esitetty kahdenlaisia skenaarioita. Toisissa käsitellä Suomesta ja Ruotsista Baltian maihin suuntautuvaa rahtiliikennettä. Skenaariot on ulottuvat aina vuoteen 2011 asti. Toiset skenaariot puolestaan käsittelevät Suomen ja Puolan välisen rahtiliikenteen tulevaisuutta. Baltian skenaarioissa korostuu Venäjän suuri rooli. Venäjälle suuntautuva transitoliikenne on kaikille Baltian maille hyvin tärkeää. Sen määrän kehitys kuitenkin riippuu hyvin paljon Venäjän omien satamien sekä Venäjän talouden kehityksestä. Venäjän taloudellinen kehitys säätelee myös hyvin paljon ympäristön kehitystä. Baltian liikenteen kehittymistä säätelee myös vahvasti koko Itä-Euroopan sekä Valko-Venäjän ja Ukrainan liikenteen kehitys. Euroopan unionin jäsenyys tuo omat lisänsä kehityksen suunnille erilaisten tukien ja kehitysprojektien mukana. Puolan skenaarioissa korostuu Puolan maantieteellisen sijainnin merkitys keskellä Eurooppaa. Paineet Saksan ruuhkaongelmien purkamisen ja itäisen Euroopan nopean talouskasvun myötä keskittyvät Puolan liikenteeseen. Puolan maaliikenneinfrastruktuuri vaatii suuria kehitysprojekteja, joita rahoittamaan tarvitaan etenkin Euroopan Unionia. Puolan valtion suuri asukaspotentiaali tekee siitä myös erityisen kiinnostavan sijoituskohteen ulkomaisille investoijille. Myös tämä osaltaan lisää Puolan liikennettä. Sekä Puolassa, että Baltiassa eletään vahvan kasvun aikaa. Tämä tekee molemmista mielenkiintoisen vaihtoehdon liikennöintikohteeksi.

Tulevaisuushallintaa: skenaarioperustainen toimintamalli Case: Sankar Marketing Oy

Tämän tutkimuksen tavoitteena oli rakentaa Sankar Marketing Oy:lle normatiivinen, skenaarioperustainen toimintamalli tulevaisuudenhallintaan. Menetelmällisesti tavoitteena oli kokonaisuuden hallittavuus. Yleiset skenaariot (ongelmien kasautuminen, tietoyhteiskunta hyvinvointiyhteiskuntana ja markkinavetoinen kehitys) toimivat näkökulmien aukaisijoina. Tulevaisuustaulukkomuotoinen väljästi kohdennettu skenaario rakennettiin tulevaisuusstudion, lehti- ja kirjasurveyn avulla. Taulukosta analysoitiin rakenteellisella- ja vaikuttavuusanalyysilla tärkeimmät muuttujat esille. Empiiriset tulokset: 1. Sankar Marketing Oy:n missio ja visiot rakennettiin tärkeimpien muuttujien, paradigman ja yrityksessä vallitsevien arvojen avulla. 2. Kasvulle, henkilöstölle ja markkinoinnille määritettiin visioita tukevat pitkän aikavälin strategiset linjaukset, jotka arvotettiin strategiaskenaarion avulla. 3. Toimenpidesuunnitelmat muodostivat kehitysurien polun bas-menetelmällä analysoidusta nykytilasta pitkän tähtäimen visioon. Uutuusarvoa tutkimukseen tuo toimintamallin uskottavuus, joka saatiin aikaiseksi yhdistämällä valittujen metodien rajapinnat aukottomaksi päättelyketjuksi.

Etelä-Savon energiatase 2006

The aim of this thesis is to create the energy balance from county of South Savo and 20 municipalities comprising the year 2006. The energy balance is restricted to county and municipality borders. Purpose of energy balance is to clarify the present state of energy supply and present information for future decisions. The main objectives for the future are e.g. replacing oil with renewable energy sources and exploiting the forest reserves of South Savo more effectively. Today South Savo is known as being one of the forerunners in use of renewable energy. The growing demand for energy is in South Savo mostly covered with renewable energy sources such as forest chips. The initial data for this thesis is gathered from local energy companies and energy producers. This thesis also exploits formerly made energy balances, publications and statistic from different organisations. The literature study of thesis begins with the basic information about South Savo and energy sources used in the year 2006. Following the thesis includes the energy balance consisting of primary energy sources and consumption of energy. Rest of the thesis includes facts about carbon dioxide emissions, future energy sources and conclusions of results, reliability and expected use of this thesis. Results of this thesis define well the present state of South Savo and are in line with county goals. The results will be used as an aid for policy-making and for considering the condition of current energy supply in South Savo. The method of doing this energy balance can be adapted for other counties as well.

Assessment of Environmental Impacts of Power Generation

Through indisputable evidence of climate change and its link to the greenhouse gas emissions comes the necessity for change in energy production infrastructure during the coming decades. Through political conventions and restrictions energy industry is pushed toward using bigger share of renewable energy sources as energy supply. In addition to climate change, sustainable energy supply is another major issue for future development plans, but neither of these should come with unbearable price. All the power production types have environmental effects as well as strengths and weaknesses. Although each change comes with a price, right track in minimising the environmental impacts and energy supply security can be found by combining all possible low-carbon technologies and by improving energy efficiency in all sectors, for creating a new power production infrastructure of tolerable energy price and of minor environmental effects. GEMIS-Global Emission Model for Integrated Systems is a life-cycle analysis program which was used in this thesis to make indicative energy models for Finland’s future energy supply. Results indicate that the energy supply must comprise both high capacity nuclear power as well as large variation of renewable energy sources for minimization of all environmental effects and keeping energy price reasonable.

Etelä-Karjalan energiaselvitys ja maakunnan energiatalouden tulevaisuus

Diplomityössä on selvitetty Etelä-Karjalan maakunnan energian käyttöä nyt ja tulevaisuudessa. Tavoitteena on selvittää eri energialähteiden hankintavaihtoehtoja, sekä eri energialähteiden käytön kehittymissuunnat seuraavan 10 - 20 vuoden kuluessa. Diplomityö on tehty Etelä-Karjalan liiton toimeksiannosta ja sitä tullaan käyttämään taustaselvityksenä maakuntakaavan laadinnassa sekä maakunnan aluevarauksia määriteltäessä. Tarkoituksena on arvioida miten energiahuollon rakenne tulee muuttumaan tulevaisuudessa ja mikä merkitys tulevaisuuden energiaratkaisuilla on alueiden käyttöön ja aluerakenteeseen liittyen. Etelä-Karjala on osa Euroopan suurinta metsäteollisuuskeskittymää ja maakunta on Suomen suurimpia teollisuuden energian- ja sähkönkäyttäjiä. Etelä-Karjalan vahva metsäteollisuus ja sen käyttämät puupolttoaineet sekä sijainti Venäjän maakaasuvarojen läheisyydessä ja kattava maakaasuverkko vaikuttavat merkittävästi maakunnan energiataseeseen. Vuonna 2007 Etelä-Karjalan primäärienergiankäyttö oli 24,3 TWh, tästä uusiutuvien energialähteiden osuus oli 68 % ja fossiilisten energialähteiden osuus 22 %. Etelä-Karjalan energiatalouden tulevaisuuteen vaikuttaa merkittävästi maakunnan metsäteollisuuden tulevaisuus. Tiukentuvan energia- ja ilmastopolitiikan ja ympäristömääräysten myötä maakunnan energiatehokkuutta on parannettava kaikilla sektoreilla. Maakunnan energiankulutusta voidaan vähentää tehostamalla energiantuotantoa, tiivistämällä yhdyskuntarakennetta ja lisäämällä bioenergian käyttöä energiantuotannossa. Etelä-Karjalassa on myös potentiaalia lisätä vaihtoehtoisten energialähteiden osuutta maakunnan energiatalouden tulevaisuudessa.

Biopolttoaineiden ongelmat

Biopolttoaineilla on tärkeä rooli tulevaisuuden energiahuollossa. Biopolttoaineiden käyttöä pyritäänkin lisäämään monin keinoin. Ensimmäisen sukupolven biopolttoaineet ovat jo olleet aikansa markkinoilla ja toisen sukupolven polttoaineet ovat saapumassa markkinoille. Tässä työssä tutkitaan eri biopolttoaine vaihtoehtoja ensimmäisestä toiseen sukupolveen sekä tutkitaan niiden käytön ongelmia. Biopolttoaineiden käyttö on lisääntynyt huomattavasti viime vuosien aikoina, jonka myötä on tullut esiin monia ongelmia. Ongelmia aiheuttavat niin ilmastolliset, taloudelliset, teknologiset kuin valtapoliittiset asiat.