Benchmarked Quality Measurement Process in a Software Validation Process

Jatkuva laadunmittaus osana ohjelmistoprosessia on yleistynyt ohjelmistoyritysten keskuudessa viime vuosien aikana. ISO 9001:2000 -laatustandardi vaatii yrityksiltä tuotteiden ja prosessien laadun mittaamista ja seuraamista. Laadun mittareiden valinta on haastava tehtävä. Yritykset luulevat usein mittaavansa laatua, vaikka ne todellisuudessa mittaavatkin ohjelmistojen eri ominaisuuksia kuten kokoa tai monimutkaisuutta. Tässä diplomityössä kehitetään ohjelmistojen validointiprosessiin vertailuun perustuva laadunmittausprosessi ohjelmistotuotteiden laadun arviointiin, mittaamiseen ja seurantaan. Laatumittarit valitaan ennalta määriteltyjen kriteereiden mukaisesti, ja niille asetetaan tavoitearvot vertailuanalyysistä saatujen tulosten perusteella. Laadunmittausprosessin lisäksi työssä annetaan suositus prosessin käyttöönotosta ja käytöstä osana yrityksen toimintaa, mikä mahdollistaa jatkuvan seurannan sekä kehityksen tulevaisuudessa.

Clinical Learning Environment and Supervision. Development and Validation of the CLES Evaluation Scale

The purpose of the study is: (1) to describe how nursing students' experienced their clinical learning environment and the supervision given by staff nurses working in hospital settings; and (2) to develop and test an evaluation scale of Clinical Learning Environment and Supervision (CLES). The study has been carried out in different phases. The pilot study (n=163) explored the association between the characteristics of a ward and its evaluation as a learning environment by students. The second version of research instrument (which was developed by the results of this pilot study) were tested by an expert panel (n=9 nurse teachers) and test-retest group formed by student nurses (n=38). After this evaluative phase, the CLES was formed as the basic research instrument for this study and it was tested with the Finnish main sample (n=416). In this phase, a concurrent validity instrument (Dunn & Burnett 1995) was used to confirm the validation process of CLES. The international comparative study was made by comparing the Finnish main sample with a British sample (n=142). The international comparative study was necessary for two reasons. In the instrument developing process, there is a need to test the new instrument in some other nursing culture. Other reason for comparative international study is the reflecting the impact of open employment markets in the European Union (EU) on the need to evaluate and to integrate EU health care educational systems. The results showed that the individualised supervision system is the most used supervision model and the supervisory relationship with personal mentor is the most meaningful single element of supervision evaluated by nursing students. The ward atmosphere and the management style of ward manager are the most important environmental factors of the clinical ward. The study integrates two theoretical elements - learning environment and supervision - in developing a preliminary theoretical model. The comparative international study showed that, Finnish students were more satisfied and evaluated their clinical placements and supervision with higher scores than students in the United Kingdom (UK). The difference between groups was statistical highly significant (p= 0.000). In the UK, clinical placements were longer but students met their nurse teachers less frequently than students in Finland. Arrangements for supervision were similar. This research process has produced the evaluation scale (CLES), which can be used in research and quality assessments of clinical learning environment and supervision in Finland and in the UK. CLES consists of 27 items and it is sub-divided into five sub-dimensions. Cronbach's alpha coefficient varied from high 0.94 to marginal 0.73. CLES is a compact evaluation scale and user-friendliness makes it suitable for continuing evaluation.

Validation Studies of Thermal-hydraulic Code for Safety Analysis of Nuclear Power Plants

This thesis gives an overview of the validation process for thermal hydraulic system codes and it presents in more detail the assessment and validation of the French code CATHARE for VVER calculations. Three assessment cases are presented: loop seal clearing, core reflooding and flow in a horizontal steam generator. The experience gained during these assessment and validation calculations has been used to analyze the behavior of the horizontal steam generator and the natural circulation in the geometry of the Loviisa nuclear power plant. The cases presented are not exhaustive, but they give a good overview of the work performed by the personnel of Lappeenranta University of Technology (LUT). Large part of the work has been performed in co-operation with the CATHARE-team in Grenoble, France. The design of a Russian type pressurized water reactor, VVER, differs from that of a Western-type PWR. Most of thermal-hydraulic system codes are validated only for the Western-type PWRs. Thus, the codes should be assessed and validated also for VVER design in order to establish any weaknesses in the models. This information is needed before codes can be used for the safety analysis. Theresults of the assessment and validation calculations presented here show that the CATHARE code can be used also for the thermal-hydraulic safety studies for VVER type plants. However, some areas have been indicated which need to be reassessed after further experimental data become available. These areas are mostly connected to the horizontal stem generators, like condensation and phase separation in primary side tubes. The work presented in this thesis covers a large numberof the phenomena included in the CSNI code validation matrices for small and intermediate leaks and for transients. Also some of the phenomena included in the matrix for large break LOCAs are covered. The matrices for code validation for VVER applications should be used when future experimental programs are planned for code validation.

Health-related quality of life in school children: validation of instrument, child self assessment, parent-proxy assessment and school nursing documentation of health check-ups

The aims of this study were to validate an international Health-Related Quality of Life (HRQL) instrument, to describe child self and parent-proxy assessed HRQL at child age 10 to 12 and to compare child self assessments with parent-proxy assessments and school nursing documentation. The study is part of the Schools on the Move –research project. In phase one, a cross-cultural translation and validation process was performed to develop a Finnish version of Pediatric Quality of Life Inventory™ 4.0 (PedsQL™ 4.0). The process included a two-way translation, cognitive interviews (children n=7, parents n=5) and a survey (children n=1097, parents n=999). In phase two, baseline and follow-up surveys (children n=986, parents n=710) were conducted to describe and compare the child self and parent-proxy assessed HRQL in school children between the ages 10 and 12. Phase three included two separate data, school nurse documented patient records (children n=270) and a survey (children n=986). The relation between child self assessed HRQL and school nursing documentation was evaluated. Validity and reliability of the Finnish version of PedsQL™ 4.0 was good (Child Self Report α=0.91, Parent-Proxy Report α=0.88). Children reported lower HRQL scores at the emotional (mean 76/80) than the physical (mean 85/89) health domains and significantly lower scores at the age of 10 than 12 (dMean=4, p=<0.001). Agreement between child self and parent-proxy assessment was fragile (r=0,4, p=<0.001) but increased as the child grew from age 10 to 12 years. At health check-ups, school nurses documented frequently children’s physical health, such as growth (97%) and posture (98/99%) but seldom emotional issues, such as mood (2/7%). The PedsQLTM 4.0 is a valid instrument to assess HRQL in Finnish school children although future research is recommended. Children’s emotional wellbeing needs future attention. HRQL scores increase during ages between childhood and adolescence. Concordance between child self and parent-proxy assessed HRQL is low. School nursing documentation, related to child health check-ups, is not in line with child self assessed HRQL and emotional issues need more attention.

Development of a process for the direct synthesis of hydrogen peroxide in a novel microstructured reactor

Microreactors have proven to be versatile tools for process intensification. Over recent decades, they have increasingly been used for product and process development in chemical industries. Enhanced heat and mass transfer in the reactors due to the extremely high surfacearea- to-volume ratio and interfacial area allow chemical processes to be operated at extreme conditions. Safety is improved by the small holdup volume of the reactors and effective control of pressure and temperature. Hydrogen peroxide is a powerful green oxidant that is used in a wide range of industries. Reduction and auto-oxidation of anthraquinones is currently the main process for hydrogen peroxide production. Direct synthesis is a green alternative and has potential for on-site production. However, there are two limitations: safety concerns because of the explosive gas mixture produced and low selectivity of the process. The aim of this thesis was to develop a process for direct synthesis of hydrogen peroxide utilizing microreactor technology. Experimental and numerical approaches were applied for development of the microreactor. Development of a novel microreactor was commenced by studying the hydrodynamics and mass transfer in prototype microreactor plates. The prototypes were designed and fabricated with the assistance of CFD modeling to optimize the shape and size of the microstructure. Empirical correlations for the mass transfer coefficient were derived. The pressure drop in micro T-mixers was investigated experimentally and numerically. Correlations describing the friction factor for different flow regimes were developed and predicted values were in good agreement with experimental results. Experimental studies were conducted to develop a highly active and selective catalyst with a proper form for the microreactor. Pd catalysts supported on activated carbon cloths were prepared by different treatments during the catalyst preparation. A variety of characterization methods were used for catalyst investigation. The surface chemistry of the support and the oxidation state of the metallic phase in the catalyst play important roles in catalyst activity and selectivity for the direct synthesis. The direct synthesis of hydrogen peroxide was investigated in a bench-scale continuous process using the novel microreactor developed. The microreactor was fabricated based on the hydrodynamic and mass transfer studies and provided a high interfacial area and high mass transfer coefficient. The catalysts were prepared under optimum treatment conditions. The direct synthesis was conducted at various conditions. The thesis represents a step towards a commercially viable direct synthesis. The focus is on the two main challenges: mitigating the safety problem by utilization of microprocess technology and improving the selectivity by catalyst development.

VVER-440 Thermal Hydraulics as a Computer Code Validation Challenge

This thesis concentrates on the validation of a generic thermal hydraulic computer code TRACE under the challenges of the VVER-440 reactor type. The code capability to model the VVER-440 geometry and thermal hydraulic phenomena specific to this reactor design has been examined and demonstrated acceptable. The main challenge in VVER-440 thermal hydraulics appeared in the modelling of the horizontal steam generator. The major challenge here is not in the code physics or numerics but in the formulation of a representative nodalization structure. Another VVER-440 specialty, the hot leg loop seals, challenges the system codes functionally in general, but proved readily representable. Computer code models have to be validated against experiments to achieve confidence in code models. When new computer code is to be used for nuclear power plant safety analysis, it must first be validated against a large variety of different experiments. The validation process has to cover both the code itself and the code input. Uncertainties of different nature are identified in the different phases of the validation procedure and can even be quantified. This thesis presents a novel approach to the input model validation and uncertainty evaluation in the different stages of the computer code validation procedure. This thesis also demonstrates that in the safety analysis, there are inevitably significant uncertainties that are not statistically quantifiable; they need to be and can be addressed by other, less simplistic means, ultimately relying on the competence of the analysts and the capability of the community to support the experimental verification of analytical assumptions. This method completes essentially the commonly used uncertainty assessment methods, which are usually conducted using only statistical methods.

Analysis and modelling of chemical looping combustion process with and without oxygen uncoupling

Effective control and limiting of carbon dioxide (CO₂) emissions in energy production are major challenges of science today. Current research activities include the development of new low-cost carbon capture technologies, and among the proposed concepts, chemical combustion (CLC) and chemical looping with oxygen uncoupling (CLOU) have attracted significant attention allowing intrinsic separation of pure CO₂ from a hydrocarbon fuel combustion process with a comparatively small energy penalty. Both CLC and CLOU utilize the well-established fluidized bed technology, but several technical challenges need to be overcome in order to commercialize the processes. Therefore, development of proper modelling and simulation tools is essential for the design, optimization, and scale-up of chemical looping-based combustion systems. The main objective of this work was to analyze the technological feasibility of CLC and CLOU processes at different scales using a computational modelling approach. A onedimensional fluidized bed model frame was constructed and applied for simulations of CLC and CLOU systems consisting of interconnected fluidized bed reactors. The model is based on the conservation of mass and energy, and semi-empirical correlations are used to describe the hydrodynamics, chemical reactions, and transfer of heat in the reactors. Another objective was to evaluate the viability of chemical looping-based energy production, and a flow sheet model representing a CLC-integrated steam power plant was developed. The 1D model frame was succesfully validated based on the operation of a 150 kWth laboratory-sized CLC unit fed by methane. By following certain scale-up criteria, a conceptual design for a CLC reactor system at a pre-commercial scale of 100 MWth was created, after which the validated model was used to predict the performance of the system. As a result, further understanding of the parameters affecting the operation of a large-scale CLC process was acquired, which will be useful for the practical design work in the future. The integration of the reactor system and steam turbine cycle for power production was studied resulting in a suggested plant layout including a CLC boiler system, a simple heat recovery setup, and an integrated steam cycle with a three pressure level steam turbine. Possible operational regions of a CLOU reactor system fed by bituminous coal were determined via mass, energy, and exergy balance analysis. Finally, the 1D fluidized bed model was modified suitable for CLOU, and the performance of a hypothetical 500 MWth CLOU fuel reactor was evaluated by extensive case simulations.

Ultrafiltration of pulp mill bleaching effluents

Main objective of this research was to find suitable polymeric ultrafiltration membranes with high retentions, good capacities and low fouling tendencies for the E2- and EP-effluent ultrafiltration. Purpose was to treat alkaline bleaching effluents with ultrafiltration in a way that permeates of the filtrations could be recycled back to process and the consumption of fresh water in the pulp mill could be reduced significantly. In the theoretical part of this work the challenges set by the pulp and paper indus-try processes for membranes were examined. An overview of the membrane tech-nology in the pulp industry was also provided. In addition process conditions in the chemical pulp bleaching and properties of bleaching effluents were discussed in literature study. In experimental part the E2- and EP-stage bleaching effluents from Stora Enso Imatra kraft pulp mill were ultrafiltered with CR250- and CR200-filters. Suitable membranes for ultrafiltration were chosen after screening experiments. Concentra-tion experiment was made for the E2-effluent in order to estimate water saving potential. The E2-effluent was finally ultrafiltered in the pulp mill in order to test the feasibility of ultrafiltration in a real industrial environment. Good membrane for the EP-effluent ultrafiltration based on the EP-screening ex-periments was polyethersulfone membrane UP020 with cut-off value of 20 000 Da. Polysulfone membrane UFX05 with cut-off value of 5 000 Da was promising membrane for the ultrafiltration of the E2-effluent. Based on the concentration filtration of the E2-effluent with UFX05 membrane the water saving potential could be 2.2 m3/Adt for the industrial scale ultrafiltration process. Retention re-sults, such as average COD retention of 60 %, from the trial filtration at the pulp mill with UFX05 membrane were modest compared to the screening experiments, where average COD retention was 75 %. Therefore tighter ultrafiltration mem-branes should be tested for the ultrafiltration of the E2-effluent. The UP020 mem-brane seemed to be suitable for the ultrafiltration of the EP-effluent however con-centration and pilot scale ultrafiltration experiments are needed to verify this.

PWR PACTEL -koelaitteiston ylätilan mallinnusvaihtoehtojen tarkastelu APROS-ohjelmistolla

Diplomityössä selvitetään PWR PACTEL -koelaitteiston APROS-mallin ylätilan toimi¬vuut¬ta ja tutkitaan tapoja parantaa mallin simulointitarkkuutta. Työssä on esitelty PWR PACTEL -koelaitteiston sekä APROS-simulointiohjelman pääpiirteet ja tutustuttu simu¬loin¬ti¬ohjelmien kelpoistukseen. Simulointiosiossa tarkastellaan yksinkertaisen ja muokatun ylätilamallin toimivuutta ver¬taa¬mal¬la simulointia koelaitteistolla tehtyjen kokeiden mittaustuloksiin. Lisäksi tutkitaan nel¬¬jää tapaa parantaa ylätilamallin toimivuutta: virtausvastusten säätö, lämpöhäviöiden sä䬬tö, rakenteelliset muutokset ja laskentakorrelaatioiden vaihtaminen. Simulointituloksia ver¬¬ra¬¬taan kahteen koelaitteistolla suoritettuun kokeeseen, joista toinen on tasapainotilankoe ja toinen dynaamisen tilan koe. Työssä havaittiin, että nykyisin käytössä olevaa mallia on kehitetty jo varsin paljon, ver¬rat¬tu¬na ns. yksinkertaiseen malliin. Testatuilla parannusvaihtoehdoilla saatiin hieman paran¬net¬tua ylätilan lämpötilojen simulointia tasapainotilassa. Dynaamisen tilan osalta havaittiin pien¬tä parannusta mallin toiminnassa ylätilamallin rakennemuutosten jälkeen. Tulosten poh¬jalta arvioitiin, että mallia on mahdollista kehittää muuttamalla ylätilamallin raken¬net¬ta.

UHPLC-epäpuhtausmenetelmän kehittäminen ja validointi inhalaatiovalmisteelle

Tämän diplomityön tarkoituksena on kehittää menetelmä, jolla voidaan seurata inhalaatiovalmisteen sisältämiä epäpuhtauksia. Menetelmä kehitetään erittäin korkean suorituskyvyn kromatografialaitteistolle (Ultra High Performance Liquid Chromatography, UHPLC) jo olemassa olevan HPLC-epäpuhtausmenetelmän pohjalta. Uusi menetelmä kehitetään analyysiajan lyhentämiseksi ja erotuksen resoluution parantamiseksi. Työn kirjallisuusosa esittelee lyhyesti inhalaatiovalmisteet sekä nestekromatografian perusteet. Korkean erotuskyvyn nestekromatografia ja analysoinnin apuna käytettävät parametrit selvitetään laskukaavoineen. Kirjallisuusosa keskittyy epäpuhtausmenetelmän kehittämisen kulkuun ja menetelmän validoinnissa suoritettaviin kokeisiin. Soveltavassa osassa Orion Oyj:n kehitteillä olevalle kahden vaikuttavan aineen inhalaatiovalmisteelle kehitetään UHPLC-epäpuhtausmenetelmä kirjallisuusosiossa esitellyn menetelmäkehitysrungon pohjalta. Menetelmäkehityksen kulku ja analyysin olosuhteiden valinta esitellään pääpiirteittäin, jonka jälkeen kehitetty menetelmä validoidaan sille tehdyn validointisuunnitelman mukaisesti. Kehitetystä UHPLC-epäpuhtausmenetelmästä saatiin 16 minuuttia lyhyempi kuin vastaava HPLC-epäpuhtausmenetelmä. Myös analyysin resoluutio parantui merkittävästi. Toistuvien injektioiden jälkeen kromatogrammissa esiintyi kuitenkin häntimistä, joka johti merkittävään resoluution heikkenemiseen. Häntimisen syyksi epäiltiin toisen vaikuttavan aineen kiinnittymistä kolonnimateriaaliin, mutta sen estämiseksi ehdotetut toimenpiteet eivät sopineet kehitettyyn menetelmään.

Catalytic direct synthesis of hydrogen peroxide in a novel microstructured reactor

The direct synthesis from hydrogen and oxygen is a green alternative for production of hydrogen peroxide. However, this process suffers from two challenges. Firstly, mixtures of hydrogen and oxygen are explosive over a wide range of concentrations (4-94% H2 in O2). Secondly, the catalytic reaction of hydrogen and oxygen involves several reaction pathways, many of them resulting in water production and therfore decreasing selectivity. The present work deals with these two challenges. The safety problem was dealed by employing a novel microstructured reactor. Selectivity of the reaction was highly improved by development a set of new catalysts. The final goal was to develop an effective and safe continuous process for direct synthesis of hydrogen peroxide from H2 and O2. Activated carbon cloth and Sibunit were examined as the catalysts’ supports. Palladium and gold monometallic and palladium-gold bimetallic catalysts were thoroughly investigated by numerous kinetic experiments performed in a tailored batch reactor and several catalyst charachterization methods. A complete set of data for direct synthesis of H2O2 and its catalytic decomposition and hydrogenation was obtained. These data were used to assess factors influencing selectivity and activity of the catalysts in direct synthesis of H2O2 as well as its decomposition and hydrogenation. A novel microstructured reactor was developed based on hydrodynamics and mass transfer studies in prototype microstractural plates. The shape and the size of the structural elements in the microreactor plate were optimized in a way to get high gas-liquid interfacial area and gas-liquid mass transfer. Finally, empirical correlations for the volumetric mass transfer coefficient were derived. A bench-scale continuous process was developed by using the novel microstructral plate reactor. A series of kinetic experiments were performed to investigate the effects of the gas and the liquid feed rates and their ratio, the amount of the catalyst, the gas feed composition and pressure on the final rate of H2O2 production and selectivity.

Feasibility study of submerged membrane bioreactor (MBR) as an alternative to conventional activated sludge process (CASP) for municipal wastewater treatment: A pilot scale study

The conventional activated sludge processes (CAS) for the treatment of municipal wastewater are going to be outdated gradually due to more stringent environmental protection laws and regulations. The Membrane bioreactors (MBRs) are the most promising modern technology widely accepted in the world of wastewater treatment due to their highly pronounced features such as high quality effluent, less foot print and working under high MLSS concentration. This research project was carried out to investigate the feasibility and effectiveness of MBR technology compare to the CAS process based on the scientific facts and results. The pilot scale MBR pilot plant was run for more than 150 days and the analysis results were evaluated. The prime focus of the project was to evaluate the correlation of permeate flux under different operating MLSS concentrations. The permeate flux was found almost constant regardless of variations in MLSS concentrations. The removal of micropollutant such as heavy metals, PCPPs, PFCs, steroidal hormones was also studied. The micropollutant removal performance of MBR process was found relatively effective than CAS process. Furthermore, the compatibility of submerged membranes within the bioreactor had truly reduced the process footprint.

Capillary electrophoresis: Applicability and method validation for biorefinery analytics

Wood-based bioprocesses present one of the fields of interest with the most potential in the circular economy. Expanding the use of wood raw material in sustainable industrial processes is acknowledged on both a global and a regional scale. This thesis concerns the application of a capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE) method with the aim of monitoring wood-based bioprocesses. The range of detectable carbohydrate compounds is expanded to furfural and polydatin in aquatic matrices. The experimental portion has been conducted on a laboratory scale with samples imitating process samples. This thesis presents a novel strategy for the uncertainty evaluation via in-house validation. The focus of the work is on the uncertainty factors of the CZE method. The CZE equipment is sensitive to ambient conditions. Therefore, a proper validation is essential for robust application. This thesis introduces a tool for process monitoring of modern bioprocesses. As a result, it is concluded that the applied CZE method provides additional results to the analysed samples and that the profiling approach is suitable for detecting changes in process samples. The CZE method shows significant potential in process monitoring because of the capability of simultaneously detecting carbohydrate-related compound clusters. The clusters can be used as summary terms, indicating process variation and drift.

Testing a large-scale forestry scenario model by means of successive inventories on a forest property

Abstract