11 resultados para Equilibrium Surface Tension
em Doria (National Library of Finland DSpace Services) - National Library of Finland, Finland
Resumo:
High reflectivity and high thermal conductivity, high vapour pressure of alloyingelements as well as low liquid surface tension and low ionisation potential, make laser welding of aluminium and its alloys a demanding task.Problems that occur during welding are mainly process instabilities of the keyhole and the melt pool, increased plasma formation above the melt pool and loss of alloying elements. These problems lead to unwanted metallurgical defects like hot cracks and porosity in the weld bead andother problems concerning the shape and appearance of the weld bead. In order to minimise the defects and improve the weld quality, the process and beam parameters need to be carefully adjusted along with a consideration concerning the use of filler wire for the welding process. In this work the welding of 3,0 mm thick grade 5083 aluminium alloy plates using a 3,0 kW Nd:YAG laser with grade 5183 filler wire addition is investigated. The plates were welded as butt joints with air gap sizes 0,5 mm, 0,7mm and 1,0 mm. The analysis of the weld beads obtained from the weldedsamples showed that the least imperfections were produced with 0,7 mm air gaps at moderate welding speeds. The analysis also covered the calculation of the melting efficiency and the study of the shape of the weld bead. The melting efficiency was on average around 20 % for the melting process of the welded plates. The weld beads showed the characteristic V-shape of a laser weld and retained this shape during the whole series of experiments.
Resumo:
Alikriittisellä vedellä tarkoitetaan paineistettua vettä, joka on kriittisen lämpötilansa (374 °C) alapuolella nestemäisessä tilassa. Veden tiheys pienenee lämpötilan kasvaessa Veden liuotinominaisuuksia voidaan säädellä lämpötilan avulla. Veden pintajännitys, viskositeetti, tiheys ja polaarisuus pienenevät lämpötilan kasvaessa, ja alikriittisen veden aineominaisuudet muuttuvat lähemmäksi orgaanista liuotinta. Alikriittisen veden dielektrisyysvakion aleneminen johtuu pääasiassa lämpötilan vaikutuksesta ja vain vähän paineen vaikutuksesta. Alikriittistä vettä on käytetty liuottimena uutossa, mutta nyt myös alikriittinen kromatografia on kehittymässä oleva erotusmenetelmä. Työn kokeellisessa osassa kehitettiin kromatografinen laitteisto alikriittiselle vedelle, jolla tutkittiin sokerialkoholien ja sokerien kromatografista erotusta alikriittisen veden avulla. Lisäksi tutkittiin sokerialkoholien, sokereiden ja stationäärifaasien termistä kestävyyttä. Tutkittavina komponentteina olivat sorbitoli, mannitoli, ksylitoli, arabinoosi, mannoosi, ksyloosi, maltoosi ja ramnoosi. Stationäärifaaseina käytettiin makrohuokoista funktionalisoimatonta polystyreenidivinyylibentseenikopolymeeriä, sekä vahvoja ja heikkoja divinyylibentseenillä ristisilloitettuja kationinvaihtohartseja, jotka olivat joko Na+- tai Ca2+-ionimuodoissa. Veden lämpötilan nostaminen vaikuttaa sekä kromatografisen stationäärifaasin tilavuusmuutoksiin että näytekomponenttien ominaisuuksiin. Vahvoilla kationinvaihtimilla havaittiin termisten tilavuusmuutosten riippuvan ionimuodosta: Na+-muotoiset hartsit turpoavat ja Ca2+-muotoiset kutistuvat lämpötilan noustessa. Heikot kationinvaihtimet kutistuvat molemmissa ionimuodoissa, mutta Ca2+-muoto kutistuu Na+-muotoa voimakkaammin. Näytekomponenteista sokerialkoholien havaittiin kestävän paremmin korkeita lämpötiloja kuin sokerien. Sokerialkoholeista kestävimmäksi havaittiin ksylitoli ja sokereista ramnoosi. Tutkittavien komponenttien piikkien havaittiin kapenevan, häntimisen vähenevän, ja piikkien eluoituvan aikaisemmin riippuen käytettävästä stationäärifaasista. Ca2+-muotoisen vahvan kationinvaihtimen kompleksinmuodostuskyky heikkeni lämpötilan kasvaessa. Näytekomponenttien erotus ei kuitenkaan parantunut lämpötilan noustessa tutkituilla stationäärifaaseilla.
Resumo:
The objective of this thesis was to identify the effects of different factors on the tension and tension relaxation of wet paper web after high-speed straining. The study was motivated by the plausible connection between wet web mechanical properties and wet web runnability on paper machines shown by previous studies. The mechanical properties of wet paper were examined using a fast tensile test rig with a strain rate of 1000%/s. Most of the tests were carried out with laboratory handsheets, but samples from a pilot paper machine were also used. The tension relaxation of paper was evaluated as the tension remaining after 0.475 s of relaxation (residual tension). The tensile and relaxation properties of wet webs were found to be strongly dependent on the quality and amount of fines. With low fines content, the tensile strength and residual tension of wet paper was mainly determined by the mechanical interactions between fibres at their contact points. As the fines strengthen the mechanical interaction in the network, the fibre properties also become important. Fibre deformations caused by the mechanical treatment of pulp were shown to reduce the mechanical properties of both dry and wet paper. However, the effect was significantly higher for wet paper. An increase of filler content from 10% to 25% greatly reduced the tensile strength of dry paper, but did not significantly impair wet web tensile strength or residual tension. Increased filler content in wet web was shown to increase the dryness of the wet web after the press section, which partly compensates for the reduction of fibrous material in the web. It is also presumable that fillers increase entanglement friction between fibres, which is beneficial for wet web strength. Different contaminants present in white water during sheet formation resulted in lowered surface tension and increased dryness after wet pressing. The addition of different contaminants reduced the tensile strength of the dry paper. The reduction of dry paper tensile strength could not be explained by the reduced surface tension, but rather on the tendency of different contaminants to interfere with the inter-fibre bonding. Additionally, wet web strength was not affected by the changes in the surface tension of white water or possible changes in the hydrophilicity of fibres caused by the addition of different contaminants. The spraying of different polymers on wet paper before wet pressing had a significant effect on both dry and wet web tensile strength, whereas wet web elastic modulus and residual tension were basically not affected. We suggest that the increase of dry and wet paper strength could be affected by the molecular level interactions between these chemicals and fibres. The most significant increases in dry and wet paper strength were achieved with a dual application of anionic and cationic polymers. Furthermore, selectively adding papermaking chemicals to different fibre fractions (as opposed to adding chemicals to the whole pulp) improved the wet web mechanical properties and the drainage of the pulp suspension.
Resumo:
Since the introduction of automatic orbital welding in pipeline application in 1961, significant improvements have been obtained in orbital pipe welding systems. Requirement of more productive welding systems for pipeline application forces manufacturers to innovate new advanced systems and welding processes for orbital welding method. Various methods have been used to make welding process adaptive, such as visual sensing, passive visual sensing, real-time intelligent control, scan welding technique, multi laser vision sensor, thermal scanning, adaptive image processing, neural network model, machine vision, and optical sensing. Numerous studies are reviewed and discussed in this Master’s thesis and based on a wide range of experiments which already have been accomplished by different researches the vision sensor are reported to be the best choice for adaptive orbital pipe welding system. Also, in this study the most welding processes as well as the most pipe variations welded by orbital welding systems mainly for oil and gas pipeline applications are explained. The welding results show that Gas Metal Arc Welding (GMAW) and its variants like Surface Tension Transfer (STT) and modified short circuit are the most preferred processes in the welding of root pass and can be replaced to the Gas Tungsten Arc Welding (GTAW) in many applications. Furthermore, dual-tandem gas metal arc welding technique is currently considered the most efficient method in the welding of fill pass. Orbital GTAW process mostly is applied for applications ranging from single run welding of thin walled stainless tubes to multi run welding of thick walled pipes. Flux cored arc welding process is faster process with higher deposition rate and recently this process is getting more popular in pipe welding applications. Also, combination of gas metal arc welding and Nd:YAG laser has shown acceptable results in girth welding of land pipelines for oil and gas industry. This Master’s thesis can be implemented as a guideline in welding of pipes and tubes to achieve higher quality and efficiency. Also, this research can be used as a base material for future investigations to supplement present finding.
Resumo:
Diplomityön tarkoitus oli selvittää verhopäällystyspastoille sopivia analyysimenetelmiä. Verhopäällystyksessä onnistunut päällystystapahtuma vaatii venymäviskositeetin ja pintajännityksen hyvää hallintaa. Kirjallisuusosassa käsiteltiin verhopäällystystä, verhopäällystyspastojen koostumusta, reologiaa ja pintajännitystä. Kirjallisuusosassa käsiteltiin lisäksi verhopäällystyspastojen reologian ja pintajännityksen mittaamiseen soveltuvia mittausmenetelmiä. Verhopäällystyksen luonteen vuoksi kirjallisuusosassa syvennyttiin venymäviskositeetin ja dynaamisen pintajännityksen mittaamiseen tarkoitettuihin menetelmiin. Kokeellisessa osassa tutkittiin päällystyspastasarjojen reologiaa ja pintajännitystä verhopäällystystä varten. Osaan päällystyspastoista luotiin venymäviskositeettia ja osasta laskettiin pintajännitystä. Venymäviskositeetin mittaamista varten työssä käytettiin ACAV A2 -reometriin liitettyjä teräsreikälevyjä. Dynaamisen pintajännityksen mittaamista varten työssä käytettiin KSV BPA-800P -pintajännitysmittaria. ACAV A2 -reometriin liitettyjen teräsreikälevyjen (reiän sisähalkaisija 0,5 tai 0,7 mm) avulla mitattiin venymäviskositeettia kuvaavia Eulerin lukuarvoja onnistuneesti suurilla kiintoainepitoisuuksilla (50, 60 tai 65 p %). Erikoispaksuntajan määrää lisäämällä onnistuttiin luomaan huomattavaa venymäviskositeettia. Kiintoainepitoisuuden kasvaessa kasvoi myös venymäviskositeetti. Tavanomaisille paksuntajille mitattiin hieman kohonneita venymäviskositeetteja verrattuna referenssipäällystyspastaan. Pigmenttikoostumuksella (kalsiumkarbonaatti/kaoliini) ei näyttänyt olevan vaikutusta venymäviskositeettiin, tai vaikutus oli suhteellisen pieni. Dynaamisen pintajännityksen mittaamista varten käytössä ollut KSV BPA-800P -pintajännitysmittari ei toiminut luotettavasti, vaikka näytteitä laimennettiin. Kiintoainepitoisuudessa 10 p-% olleilla laimennoksilla saavutettiin analysoinnin kannalta parhaat tulokset. Tuloksista saatiin kuitenkin viitteitä, että kyseinen mittari voisi olla potentiaalinen menetelmä dynaamisen pintajännityksen mittaamiseksi.
Resumo:
Mass-produced paper electronics (large area organic printed electronics on paper-based substrates, “throw-away electronics”) has the potential to introduce the use of flexible electronic applications in everyday life. While paper manufacturing and printing have a long history, they were not developed with electronic applications in mind. Modifications to paper substrates and printing processes are required in order to obtain working electronic devices. This should be done while maintaining the high throughput of conventional printing techniques and the low cost and recyclability of paper. An understanding of the interactions between the functional materials, the printing process and the substrate are required for successful manufacturing of advanced devices on paper. Based on the understanding, a recyclable, multilayer-coated paper-based substrate that combines adequate barrier and printability properties for printed electronics and sensor applications was developed in this work. In this multilayer structure, a thin top-coating consisting of mineral pigments is coated on top of a dispersion-coated barrier layer. The top-coating provides well-controlled sorption properties through controlled thickness and porosity, thus enabling optimizing the printability of functional materials. The penetration of ink solvents and functional materials stops at the barrier layer, which not only improves the performance of the functional material but also eliminates potential fiber swelling and de-bonding that can occur when the solvents are allowed to penetrate into the base paper. The multi-layer coated paper under consideration in the current work consists of a pre-coating and a smoothing layer on which the barrier layer is deposited. Coated fine paper may also be used directly as basepaper, ensuring a smooth base for the barrier layer. The top layer is thin and smooth consisting of mineral pigments such as kaolin, precipitated calcium carbonate, silica or blends of these. All the materials in the coating structure have been chosen in order to maintain the recyclability and sustainability of the substrate. The substrate can be coated in steps, sequentially layer by layer, which requires detailed understanding and tuning of the wetting properties and topography of the barrier layer versus the surface tension of the top-coating. A cost competitive method for industrial scale production is the curtain coating technique allowing extremely thin top-coatings to be applied simultaneously with a closed and sealed barrier layer. The understanding of the interactions between functional materials formulated and applied on paper as inks, makes it possible to create a paper-based substrate that can be used to manufacture printed electronics-based devices and sensors on paper. The multitude of functional materials and their complex interactions make it challenging to draw general conclusions in this topic area. Inevitably, the results become partially specific to the device chosen and the materials needed in its manufacturing. Based on the results, it is clear that for inks based on dissolved or small size functional materials, a barrier layer is beneficial and ensures the functionality of the printed material in a device. The required active barrier life time depends on the solvents or analytes used and their volatility. High aspect ratio mineral pigments, which create tortuous pathways and physical barriers within the barrier layer limit the penetration of solvents used in functional inks. The surface pore volume and pore size can be optimized for a given printing process and ink through a choice of pigment type and coating layer thickness. However, when manufacturing multilayer functional devices, such as transistors, which consist of several printed layers, compromises have to be made. E.g., while a thick and porous top-coating is preferable for printing of source and drain electrodes with a silver particle ink, a thinner and less absorbing surface is required to form a functional semiconducting layer. With the multilayer coating structure concept developed in this work, it was possible to make the paper substrate suitable for printed functionality. The possibility of printing functional devices, such as transistors, sensors and pixels in a roll-to-roll process on paper is demonstrated which may enable introducing paper for use in disposable “onetime use” or “throwaway” electronics and sensors, such as lab-on-strip devices for various analyses, consumer packages equipped with product quality sensors or remote tracking devices.
Resumo:
In the framework of the biorefinery concept researchers aspire to optimize the utilization of plant materials, such as agricultural wastes and wood. For most of the known processes, the first steps in the valorisation of biomass are the extraction and purification of the individual components. The obtained raw products by means of a controlled separation can consecutively be modified to result in biofuels or biogas for energy production, but also in value-added products such as additives and important building blocks for the chemical and material industries. Considerable efforts are undertaken in order to substitute the use of oil-based starting materials or at least minimize their processing for the production of everyday goods. Wood is one of the raw materials, which have gained large attention in the last decades and its composition has been studied in detail. Nowadays, the extraction of water-soluble hemicelluloses from wood is well known and so for example xylan can be obtained from hardwoods and O-acetyl galactoglucomannans (GGMs) from softwoods. The aim of this work was to develop water-soluble amphiphilic materials of GGM and to assess their potential use as additives. Furthermore, GGM was also applied as a crosslinker in the synthesis of functional hydrogels for the removal of toxic metals and metalloid ions from aqueous solutions. The distinguished products were obtained by several chemical approaches and analysed by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (NMR), Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), size exclusion chromatography (SEC), thermal gravimetric analysis (TGA), scanning electron microscope SEM, among others. Bio-based surfactants were produced by applying GGM and different fatty acids as starting materials. On one hand, GGM-grafted-fatty acids were prepared by esterification and on the other hand, well-defined GGM-block-fatty acid derivatives were obtained by linking amino-functional fatty acids to the reducing end of GGM. The reaction conditions for the syntheses were optimized and the resultant amphiphilic GGM derivatives were evaluated concerning their ability to reduce the surface tension of water as surfactants. Furthermore, the block-structured derivatives were tested in respect to their applicability as additives for the surface modification of cellulosic materials. Besides the GGM surfactants with a bio-based hydrophilic and a bio-based hydrophobic part, also GGM block-structured derivatives with a synthetic hydrophobic tail, consisting of a polydimethylsiloxane chain, were prepared and assessed for the hydrophobization of surface of nanofibrillated cellulose films. In order to generate GGM block-structured derivatives containing a synthetic tail with distinguished physical and chemical properties, as well as a tailored chain length, a controlled polymerization method was used. Therefore, firstly an initiator group was introduced at the reducing end of the GGM and consecutively single electron transfer-living radical polymerization (SET-LRP) was performed by applying three different monomers in individual reactions. For the accomplishment of the synthesis and the analysis of the products, challenges related to the solubility of the reactants had to be overcome. Overall, a synthesis route for the production of GGM block-copolymers bearing different synthetic polymer chains was developed and several derivatives were obtained. Moreover, GGM with different molar masses were, after modification, used as a crosslinker in the synthesis of functional hydrogels. Hereby, a cationic monomer was used during the free radical polymerization and the resultant hydrogels were successfully tested for the removal of chromium and arsenic ions from aqueous solutions. The hydrogel synthesis was tailored and materials with distinguished physical properties, such as the swelling rate, were obtained after purification. The results generated in this work underline the potential of bio-based products and the urge to continue carrying out research in order to be able to use more green chemicals for the manufacturing of biorenewable and biodegradable daily products.
Resumo:
Electrospraying or electrostatic atomisation is a process of liquid disruption by electrostatic forces. When liquid is brought into an electric field, charge is induced to its surface. Once the repulsive electrostatic force exceeds the liquid surface tension, the liquid disrupts into small highly charged droplets. The size of the electrosprayed droplets can range from hundreds of micrometers down to a few tens of nanometers. Electrospraying can be used not only to produce droplets, but also solid particles. The research presented in this thesis concentrates on producing drug particles by this method. In the experiments, a drug powder was dissolved in a convenient solvent and the solution was atomised. The solvent was then evaporated from the formed droplets in a drying medium and inside each droplet, a dense cluster of the dissolved drug remained. From the pharmaceutical point of view, the most important characteristics of the produced particles are size distribution, porosity, crystal form and degree of crystallinity. These properties affect the dissolution behaviour and ultimately the drug bioavailability in the body. The effects of electrostatic atomization on the aforementioned characteristics are generally not well understood. The research focused on studying these particle properties and finding possible correlations with the spraying parameters. The produced droplets were dried either under atmospheric or reduced pressure, the latter in order to improve the drying process. Special emphasis was put on implementing the spraying under reduced pressure, and the effects of the drying pressure on particle properties. Based on the results, the possibilities to enhance the dissolution of poorly soluble drugs by this method were estimated. In the course of experiments, it was also discovered that electrospraying may have a profound effect on the polymorphic form of the produced drug particles. In the light of the obtained results, it was concluded that electrospraying may offer a valuable tool to overcome some of the challenges met in modern drug development and formulation.
Resumo:
Maalit ovat hyvin komplekseja seoksia, jotka sisältävät erilaisia pinta-aktiivisia aineita. Erilaisia pinta-aktiivisia apuaineita käytetään varsinkin vesiohenteisissa maaleissa veden korkean pintajännityksen takia. Nämä maalin komponentit saat-tavat kuitenkin aiheuttaa maaliin vaahtoamisongelmia. Maalien vaahtoaminen aiheuttaa esimerkiksi erilaisia pintavikoja maalikalvossa ja epäotpimaalista tuo-tantosäiliöiden ja pakkausten täyttöä. Joissain tapauksissa myös maalin funktio-naalisuus saattaa häiriintyä. Maalien vaahtoamista pyritään vähentämään pääasiassa vaahdonestäjiksi kutsu-tuilla apuaineilla. Tärkeimmät vesipohjaisissa maaleissa käytettävät vaahdonestäjät ovat mineraaliöljyjä sekä silikonipohjaisia vaahdonestäjiä. Tässä työssä tutkitaan kolmen eri vesiohenteisen sisäseinämaalin vaahtoamista ja mahdollisia keinoja vähentää sitä. Laboratoriossa kokeillaan nykyisten vaahdonestäjien tilalle mahdollisia korvaavia apuaineita. Lisäksi kullekin maalille luodaan koesuunni-telma, jonka mukaan toteutetaan tehtaalla sarja koeajoja, joilla pyritään löytämään sopiva vaahdonestäjän annostus sekä lisäystapa kullekin maalille, siten että maalien vaahtoaminen vähenee. Laboratoriokokeiden perusteella korvaavaa vaahdonestäjää nykyisten tilalle ei löydetty. Valmistusprosessin yhteydessä sen sijaan havaittiin, että vaahdonestäjän lisäystapaa muuttamalla voisi olla mahdollista vähentää maalien vaahtoamista merkittävästi lisäämättä käytettävää vaahdonestäjän annostusta.
Resumo:
The monitoring and control of hydrogen sulfide (H2S) level is of great interest for a wide range of application areas including food quality control, defense and antiterrorist applications and air quality monitoring e.g. in mines. H2S is a very poisonous and flammable gas. Exposure to low concentrations of H2S can result in eye irritation, a sore throat and cough, shortness of breath, and fluid retention in the lungs. These symptoms usually disappear in a few weeks. Long-term, low-level exposure may result in fatigue, loss of appetite, headache, irritability, poor memory, and dizziness. Higher concentrations of 700 - 800 ppm tend to be fatal. H2S has a characteristic smell of rotten egg. However, because of temporary paralysis of olfactory nerves, the smelling capability at concentrations higher than 100 ppm is severely compromised. In addition, volatile H2S is one of the main products during the spoilage of poultry meat in anaerobic conditions. Currently, no commercial H2S sensor is available which can operate under anaerobic conditions and can be easily integrated in the food packaging. This thesis presents a step-wise progress in the development of printed H2S gas sensors. Efforts were made in the formulation, characterization and optimization of functional printable inks and coating pastes based on composites of a polymer and a metal salt as well as a composite of a metal salt and an organic acid. Different processing techniques including inkjet printing, flexographic printing, screen printing and spray coating were utilized in the fabrication of H2S sensors. The dispersions were characterized by measuring turbidity, surface tension, viscosity and particle size. The sensing films were characterized using X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, X-ray diffraction, atomic force microscopy and an electrical multimeter. Thin and thick printed or coated films were developed for gas sensing applications with the aim of monitoring the H2S concentrations in real life applications. Initially, a H2S gas sensor based on a composite of polyaniline and metal salt was developed. Both aqueous and solvent-based dispersions were developed and characterized. These dispersions were then utilized in the fabrication of roll-to-roll printed H2S gas sensors. However, the humidity background, long term instability and comparatively lower detection limit made these sensors less favourable for real practical applications. To overcome these problems, copper acetate based sensors were developed for H2S gas sensing. Stable inks with excellent printability were developed by tuning the surface tension, viscosity and particle size. This enabled the formation of inkjet-printed high quality copper acetate films with excellent sensitivity towards H2S. Furthermore, these sensors showed negligible humidity effects and improved selectivity, response time, lower limit of detection and coefficient of variation. The lower limit of detection of copper acetate based sensors was further improved to sub-ppm level by incorporation of catalytic gold nano-particles and subsequent plasma treatment of the sensing film. These sensors were further integrated in an inexpensive wirelessly readable RLC-circuit (where R is resistor, L is inductor and C is capacitor). The performance of these sensors towards biogenic H2S produced during the spoilage of poultry meat in the modified atmosphere package was also demonstrated in this thesis. This serves as a proof of concept that these sensors can be utilized in real life applications.
Resumo:
Computational material science with the Density Functional Theory (DFT) has recently gained a method for describing, for the first time the non local bonding i.e., van der Waals (vdW) bonding. The newly proposed van der Waals-Density Functional (vdW-DF) is employed here to address the role of non local interactions in the case of H2 adsorption on Ru(0001) surface. The later vdW-DF2 implementation with the DFT code VASP (Vienna Ab-initio Simulation Package) is used in this study. The motivation for studying H2 adsorption on ruthenium surface arose from the interest to hydrogenation processes. Potential energy surface (PES) plots are created for adsorption sites top, bridge, fcc and hcp, employing the vdW-DF2 functional. The vdW-DF yields 0.1 eV - 0.2 eV higher barriers for the dissociation of the H2 molecule; the vdW-DF seems to bind the H2 molecule more tightly together. Furthermore, at the top site, which is found to be the most reactive, the vdW functional suggests no entrance barrier or in any case smaller than 0.05 eV, whereas the corresponding calculation without the vdW-DF does. Ruthenium and H2 are found to have the opposite behaviors with the vdW-DF; Ru lattice constants are overestimated while H2 bond length is shorter. Also evaluation of the CPU time demand of the vdW-DF2 is done from the PES data. From top to fcc sites the vdW-DF computational time demand is larger by 4.77 % to 20.09 %, while at the hcp site it is slightly smaller. Also the behavior of a few exchange correlation functionals is investigated along addressing the role of vdW-DF. Behavior of the different functionals is not consistent between the Ru lattice constants and H2 bond lengths. It is thus difficult to determine the quality of a particular exchange correlation functional by comparing equilibrium separations of the different elements. By comparing PESs it would be computationally highly consuming.