53 resultados para automatic test case generation


Relevância:

100.00% 100.00%

Publicador:

Resumo:

As the development of integrated circuit technology continues to follow Moore’s law the complexity of circuits increases exponentially. Traditional hardware description languages such as VHDL and Verilog are no longer powerful enough to cope with this level of complexity and do not provide facilities for hardware/software codesign. Languages such as SystemC are intended to solve these problems by combining the powerful expression of high level programming languages and hardware oriented facilities of hardware description languages. To fully replace older languages in the desing flow of digital systems SystemC should also be synthesizable. The devices required by modern high speed networks often share the same tight constraints for e.g. size, power consumption and price with embedded systems but have also very demanding real time and quality of service requirements that are difficult to satisfy with general purpose processors. Dedicated hardware blocks of an application specific instruction set processor are one way to combine fast processing speed, energy efficiency, flexibility and relatively low time-to-market. Common features can be identified in the network processing domain making it possible to develop specialized but configurable processor architectures. One such architecture is the TACO which is based on transport triggered architecture. The architecture offers a high degree of parallelism and modularity and greatly simplified instruction decoding. For this M.Sc.(Tech) thesis, a simulation environment for the TACO architecture was developed with SystemC 2.2 using an old version written with SystemC 1.0 as a starting point. The environment enables rapid design space exploration by providing facilities for hw/sw codesign and simulation and an extendable library of automatically configured reusable hardware blocks. Other topics that are covered are the differences between SystemC 1.0 and 2.2 from the viewpoint of hardware modeling, and compilation of a SystemC model into synthesizable VHDL with Celoxica Agility SystemC Compiler. A simulation model for a processor for TCP/IP packet validation was designed and tested as a test case for the environment.

Relevância:

100.00% 100.00%

Publicador:

Resumo:

Ohjelmistotestauksen avulla voidaan tarkastella sovelluksen vastaavuutta vaatimuksiin. Tavoitteena on löytää sovelluksesta virheitä, ja siten parantaa sovelluksen laatua. Sovelluksen laatu voidaan määritellä useilla mittareilla, kuten esimerkiksi testattavuudella. Tässä työssä tarkastellaan WWW-sovelluksen automatisoidun testauksen toteutusta, jossa käytetään apuna testauskehystä. Automatisoituun testaukseen kuuluu testitapausten suunnittelu sekä toteutus, joiden lopputuloksena on uudelleenajettavia testitapauksia. Testaus keskittyy sovelluksen toiminnallisuuteen ja jättää tietokantaan päivitettävien tietojen tarkastamisen tekemättä. Testaus suoritetaan ilman tarkempaa tietoa sovelluksen sisäisestä toiminnasta. Testattava sovellus on Mobilding-hankkeessa toteutettu WWW-sovellus, jonka avulla hallinnoidaan rakennuksen elementtejä. Työssä vertaillaan WWW-sovelluksen käyttöliittymän testaukseen soveltuvia testauskehyksiä, ja pyritään tuomaan esille niiden ominaispiirteitä. Työn tuloksena on uudelleensuoritettavia testitapahtumia. Lisäksi pohditaan ohjelmointikäytäntöjä, joilla voidaan edistää automatisoitua testausta. Ohjelmointikäytännöt perustuvat työn toteutuksen aikana havaittuihin ongelmiin.

Relevância:

100.00% 100.00%

Publicador:

Resumo:

Testaustapausten valitseminen on testauksessa tärkeää, koska kaikkia testaustapauksia ei voida testata aika- ja raharajoitteiden takia. Testaustapausten valintaan on paljon eri menetelmiä joista eniten esillä olevat ovat malleihin perustuva valinta, kombinaatiovalinta ja riskeihin perustuva valinta. Kaikkiin edellä mainittuihin menetelmiin testaustapaukset luodaan ohjelman spesifikaation perusteella. Malleihin perustuvassa menetelmässä käytetään hyväksi ohjelman toiminnasta olevia malleja, joista valitaan tärkeimmät testattavaksi. Kombinaatiotestauksessa testitapaukset on muodostettu ominaisuuspareina jolloin yhden parin testaamisesta päätellään kahden ominaisuuden toiminta. Kombinaatiotestaus on tehokas löytämään virheitä, jotka johtuvat yhdestä tai kahdesta tekijästä. Riskeihin perustuva testaus pyrkii arvioimaan ohjelman riskejä ja valitsemaan testitapaukset niiden perusteella. Kaikissa menetelmissä priorisointi on tärkeässä roolissa, jotta testauksesta saadaan riittävä luotettavuus ilman kustannusten nousua.

Relevância:

100.00% 100.00%

Publicador:

Resumo:

Percarboxylic acids are commonly used as disinfection and bleaching agents in textile, paper, and fine chemical industries. All of these applications are based on the oxidative potential of these compounds. In spite of high interest in these chemicals, they are unstable and explosive chemicals, which increase the risk of synthesis processes and transportation. Therefore, the safety criteria in the production process should be considered. Microreactors represent a technology that efficiently utilizes safety advantages resulting from small scale. Therefore, microreactor technology was used in the synthesis of peracetic acid and performic acid. These percarboxylic acids were produced at different temperatures, residence times and catalyst i.e. sulfuric acid concentrations. Both synthesis reactions seemed to be rather fast because with performic acid equilibrium was reached in 4 min at 313 K and with peracetic acid in 10 min at 343 K. In addition, the experimental results were used to study the kinetics of the formation of performic acid and peracetic acid. The advantages of the microreactors in this study were the efficient temperature control even in very exothermic reaction and good mixing due to the short diffusion distances. Therefore, reaction rates were determined with high accuracy. Three different models were considered in order to estimate the kinetic parameters such as reaction rate constants and activation energies. From these three models, the laminar flow model with radial velocity distribution gave most precise parameters. However, sulfuric acid creates many drawbacks in this synthesis process. Therefore, a ´´greener´´ way to use heterogeneous catalyst in the synthesis of performic acid in microreactor was studied. The cation exchange resin, Dowex 50 Wx8, presented very high activity and a long life time in this reaction. In the presence of this catalyst, the equilibrium was reached in 120 second at 313 K which indicates a rather fast reaction. In addition, the safety advantages of microreactors were investigated in this study. Four different conventional methods were used. Production of peracetic acid was used as a test case, and the safety of one conventional batch process was compared with an on-site continuous microprocess. It was found that the conventional methods for the analysis of process safety might not be reliable and adequate for radically novel technology, such as microreactors. This is understandable because the conventional methods are partly based on experience, which is very limited in connection with totally novel technology. Therefore, one checklist-based method was developed to study the safety of intensified and novel processes at the early stage of process development. The checklist was formulated using the concept of layers of protection for a chemical process. The traditional and three intensified processes of hydrogen peroxide synthesis were selected as test cases. With these real cases, it was shown that several positive and negative effects on safety can be detected in process intensification. The general claim that safety is always improved by process intensification was questioned.

Relevância:

100.00% 100.00%

Publicador:

Resumo:

Wind energy has obtained outstanding expectations due to risks of global warming and nuclear energy production plant accidents. Nowadays, wind farms are often constructed in areas of complex terrain. A potential wind farm location must have the site thoroughly surveyed and the wind climatology analyzed before installing any hardware. Therefore, modeling of Atmospheric Boundary Layer (ABL) flows over complex terrains containing, e.g. hills, forest, and lakes is of great interest in wind energy applications, as it can help in locating and optimizing the wind farms. Numerical modeling of wind flows using Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) has become a popular technique during the last few decades. Due to the inherent flow variability and large-scale unsteadiness typical in ABL flows in general and especially over complex terrains, the flow can be difficult to be predicted accurately enough by using the Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes equations (RANS). Large- Eddy Simulation (LES) resolves the largest and thus most important turbulent eddies and models only the small-scale motions which are more universal than the large eddies and thus easier to model. Therefore, LES is expected to be more suitable for this kind of simulations although it is computationally more expensive than the RANS approach. With the fast development of computers and open-source CFD software during the recent years, the application of LES toward atmospheric flow is becoming increasingly common nowadays. The aim of the work is to simulate atmospheric flows over realistic and complex terrains by means of LES. Evaluation of potential in-land wind park locations will be the main application for these simulations. Development of the LES methodology to simulate the atmospheric flows over realistic terrains is reported in the thesis. The work also aims at validating the LES methodology at a real scale. In the thesis, LES are carried out for flow problems ranging from basic channel flows to real atmospheric flows over one of the most recent real-life complex terrain problems, the Bolund hill. All the simulations reported in the thesis are carried out using a new OpenFOAM® -based LES solver. The solver uses the 4th order time-accurate Runge-Kutta scheme and a fractional step method. Moreover, development of the LES methodology includes special attention to two boundary conditions: the upstream (inflow) and wall boundary conditions. The upstream boundary condition is generated by using the so-called recycling technique, in which the instantaneous flow properties are sampled on aplane downstream of the inlet and mapped back to the inlet at each time step. This technique develops the upstream boundary-layer flow together with the inflow turbulence without using any precursor simulation and thus within a single computational domain. The roughness of the terrain surface is modeled by implementing a new wall function into OpenFOAM® during the thesis work. Both, the recycling method and the newly implemented wall function, are validated for the channel flows at relatively high Reynolds number before applying them to the atmospheric flow applications. After validating the LES model over simple flows, the simulations are carried out for atmospheric boundary-layer flows over two types of hills: first, two-dimensional wind-tunnel hill profiles and second, the Bolund hill located in Roskilde Fjord, Denmark. For the twodimensional wind-tunnel hills, the study focuses on the overall flow behavior as a function of the hill slope. Moreover, the simulations are repeated using another wall function suitable for smooth surfaces, which already existed in OpenFOAM® , in order to study the sensitivity of the flow to the surface roughness in ABL flows. The simulated results obtained using the two wall functions are compared against the wind-tunnel measurements. It is shown that LES using the implemented wall function produces overall satisfactory results on the turbulent flow over the two-dimensional hills. The prediction of the flow separation and reattachment-length for the steeper hill is closer to the measurements than the other numerical studies reported in the past for the same hill geometry. The field measurement campaign performed over the Bolund hill provides the most recent field-experiment dataset for the mean flow and the turbulence properties. A number of research groups have simulated the wind flows over the Bolund hill. Due to the challenging features of the hill such as the almost vertical hill slope, it is considered as an ideal experimental test case for validating micro-scale CFD models for wind energy applications. In this work, the simulated results obtained for two wind directions are compared against the field measurements. It is shown that the present LES can reproduce the complex turbulent wind flow structures over a complicated terrain such as the Bolund hill. Especially, the present LES results show the best prediction of the turbulent kinetic energy with an average error of 24.1%, which is a 43% smaller than any other model results reported in the past for the Bolund case. Finally, the validated LES methodology is demonstrated to simulate the wind flow over the existing Muukko wind farm located in South-Eastern Finland. The simulation is carried out only for one wind direction and the results on the instantaneous and time-averaged wind speeds are briefly reported. The demonstration case is followed by discussions on the practical aspects of LES for the wind resource assessment over a realistic inland wind farm.

Relevância:

40.00% 40.00%

Publicador:

Relevância:

40.00% 40.00%

Publicador:

Resumo:

The environmental impact of landfill is a growing concern in waste management practices. Thus, assessing the effectiveness of the solutions implemented to alter the issue is of importance. The objectives of the study were to provide an insight of landfill advantages, and to consolidate landfill gas importance among others alternative fuels. Finally, a case study examining the performances of energy production from a land disposal at Ylivieska was carried out to ascertain the viability of waste to energy project. Both qualitative and quantitative methods were applied. The study was conducted in two parts; the first was the review of literatures focused on landfill gas developments. Specific considerations were the conception of mechanism governing the variability of gas production and the investigation of mathematical models often used in landfill gas modeling. Furthermore, the analysis of two main distributed generation technologies used to generate energy from landfill was carried out. The review of literature revealed a high influence of waste segregation and high level of moisture content for waste stabilization process. It was found that the enhancement in accuracy for forecasting gas rate generation can be done with both mathematical modeling and field test measurements. The result of the case study mainly indicated the close dependence of the power output with the landfill gas quality and the fuel inlet pressure.

Relevância:

30.00% 30.00%

Publicador:

Resumo:

The research of condition monitoring of electric motors has been wide for several decades. The research and development at universities and in industry has provided means for the predictive condition monitoring. Many different devices and systems are developed and are widely used in industry, transportation and in civil engineering. In addition, many methods are developed and reported in scientific arenas in order to improve existing methods for the automatic analysis of faults. The methods, however, are not widely used as a part of condition monitoring systems. The main reasons are, firstly, that many methods are presented in scientific papers but their performance in different conditions is not evaluated, secondly, the methods include parameters that are so case specific that the implementation of a systemusing such methods would be far from straightforward. In this thesis, some of these methods are evaluated theoretically and tested with simulations and with a drive in a laboratory. A new automatic analysis method for the bearing fault detection is introduced. In the first part of this work the generation of the bearing fault originating signal is explained and its influence into the stator current is concerned with qualitative and quantitative estimation. The verification of the feasibility of the stator current measurement as a bearing fault indicatoris experimentally tested with the running 15 kW induction motor. The second part of this work concentrates on the bearing fault analysis using the vibration measurement signal. The performance of the micromachined silicon accelerometer chip in conjunction with the envelope spectrum analysis of the cyclic bearing faultis experimentally tested. Furthermore, different methods for the creation of feature extractors for the bearing fault classification are researched and an automatic fault classifier using multivariate statistical discrimination and fuzzy logic is introduced. It is often important that the on-line condition monitoring system is integrated with the industrial communications infrastructure. Two types of a sensor solutions are tested in the thesis: the first one is a sensor withcalculation capacity for example for the production of the envelope spectra; the other one can collect the measurement data in memory and another device can read the data via field bus. The data communications requirements highly depend onthe type of the sensor solution selected. If the data is already analysed in the sensor the data communications are needed only for the results but in the other case, all measurement data need to be transferred. The complexity of the classification method can be great if the data is analysed at the management level computer, but if the analysis is made in sensor itself, the analyses must be simple due to the restricted calculation and memory capacity.

Relevância:

30.00% 30.00%

Publicador:

Resumo:

Langattoman laajakaistaisen tietoliikennetekniikan kehittyminen on herättänyt kiinnostuksen sen ammattimaiseen hyödyntämiseen yleisen turvallisuuden ja kriisinhallinnan tarpeisiin. Hätätilanteissa usein olemassa olevat kiinteät tietoliikennejärjestelmät eivät ole ollenkaan käytettävissä tai niiden tarjoama kapasiteetti ei ole riittävä. Tästä syystä on noussut esiin tarve nopeasti toimintakuntoon saatettaville ja itsenäisille langattomille laajakaistaisille järjestelmille. Tässä diplomityössä on tarkoitus tutkia langattomia ad hoc monihyppy -verkkoja yleisen turvallisuuden tarpeiden pohjalta ja toteuttaa testialusta, jolla voidaan demonstroida sekä tutkia tällaisen järjestelmän toimintaa käytännössä. Työssä tutkitaan pisteestä pisteeseen sekä erityisesti pisteestä moneen pisteeseen suoritettavaa tietoliikennettä. Mittausten kohteena on testialustan tiedonsiirtonopeus, lähetysteho ja vastaanottimen herkkyys. Näitä tuloksia käytetään simulaattorin parametreina, jotta simulaattorin tulokset olisivat mahdollisimman aidot ja yhdenmukaiset testialustan kanssa. Sen jälkeen valitaan valikoima yleisen turvallisuuden vaatimusten mukaisia ohjelmia ja sovellusmalleja, joiden suorituskyky mitataan erilaisten reititysmenetelmien alaisena sekä testialustalla että simulaattorilla. Tuloksia arvioidaan ja vertaillaan. Multicast monihyppy -video päätettiin sovelluksista valita tutkimusten pääkohteeksi ja sitä sekä sen ominaisuuksia on tarkoitus myös oikeissa kenttäkokeissa.

Relevância:

30.00% 30.00%

Publicador:

Resumo:

Nowadays the used fuel variety in power boilers is widening and new boiler constructions and running models have to be developed. This research and development is done in small pilot plants where more faster analyse about the boiler mass and heat balance is needed to be able to find and do the right decisions already during the test run. The barrier on determining boiler balance during test runs is the long process of chemical analyses of collected input and outputmatter samples. The present work is concentrating on finding a way to determinethe boiler balance without chemical analyses and optimise the test rig to get the best possible accuracy for heat and mass balance of the boiler. The purpose of this work was to create an automatic boiler balance calculation method for 4 MW CFB/BFB pilot boiler of Kvaerner Pulping Oy located in Messukylä in Tampere. The calculation was created in the data management computer of pilot plants automation system. The calculation is made in Microsoft Excel environment, which gives a good base and functions for handling large databases and calculations without any delicate programming. The automation system in pilot plant was reconstructed und updated by Metso Automation Oy during year 2001 and the new system MetsoDNA has good data management properties, which is necessary for big calculations as boiler balance calculation. Two possible methods for calculating boiler balance during test run were found. Either the fuel flow is determined, which is usedto calculate the boiler's mass balance, or the unburned carbon loss is estimated and the mass balance of the boiler is calculated on the basis of boiler's heat balance. Both of the methods have their own weaknesses, so they were constructed parallel in the calculation and the decision of the used method was left to user. User also needs to define the used fuels and some solid mass flowsthat aren't measured automatically by the automation system. With sensitivity analysis was found that the most essential values for accurate boiler balance determination are flue gas oxygen content, the boiler's measured heat output and lower heating value of the fuel. The theoretical part of this work concentrates in the error management of these measurements and analyses and on measurement accuracy and boiler balance calculation in theory. The empirical part of this work concentrates on the creation of the balance calculation for the boiler in issue and on describing the work environment.

Relevância:

30.00% 30.00%

Publicador:

Resumo:

Työn tavoitteena on kehittää arvoinnovaatio yritysverkostolle. Arvoinnovaation teoreettisen viitekehyksen konkretisoimiseksi ja arvioimiseksi käytetään työssä kohteena ProPortfolio - ohjelmistotuotetta sekä sen kehittämistyössä saatuja kokemuksia. ProPortfolio on vuosina 2001-2004 kehitetty mobiiliin teknologiaan perustuva ohjelmistosovellus. ProPortfolio ohjelmisto on liikkeenjohdon konsulttiyritys Tuloskunto Oy:n johdolla ja TEKES:n rahoittamassa hankkeessa kehitetty pientaloprojektien toteuttajaverkoston toiminnanohjausjärjestelmä. Pitkäaikaisen kilpailuedun saavuttaminen erottumalla kilpailijoiden massasta on kasvava haaste yrityksille. Tutkijoiden Kimin ja Mauborgnen kehittämän arvoinnovaation ja strategisen suunnittelun prosessin lähtökohtana on kilpailun kiertäminen differoitumalla kilpailijoista ja uusien markkinoiden luominen. Perinteisen strategisen ajattelutavan mukaan yritykset voivat tuottaa korkeampaa arvoaasiakkaille korkeammin kustannuksin tai kohtuullista arvoa pienemmin kustannuksin. Eli strateginen asemointi perustuu valintaan differoitumisen ja kustannusjohtajuuden välillä (Porter,1985). Arvoinnovaatioon perustuvassa asemoinnissa tavoitellaan sekä differoitumista että kustannusjohtajuutta samanaikaisesti. Arvoinnovaation keskeisimmät kriteerit täyttyivät kehityshankkeen lopputuloksena syntyneessä ProPortfolio -ohjelmistotuotteessa. Tämän työn pohjalta voidaan todeta, että Kimin ja Mauborgnen kehittämä strategian suunnitteluprosessi on laaja ja vaativa. Arvoinnovaatio syntyy harvoin hetkellisenä oivalluksena, vaan kehittyy järjestelmällisen työskentelyn tuloksena. ProPortfolio -ohjelmistotuotteen arvoinnovaation muodostuminen perustui kehityshankkeen onnistuneeseen asiakastarpeiden tunnistamiseen ja ennakoimiseen. Selkeän kuvan hahmottuminen ratkaistavista ongelmista auttoi asemoimaan hankkeen jatkokehitystyön oikein ja loi edellytykset arvoinnovaation muodostumiselle. Tutkijat Kim jaMauborgne ovat haastaneet perinteiset strategiatyöskentelyn mallit. Tutkimustuloksiinsa pohjautuen he ovat kehittäneet uuden arvoinnovaatioon perustuvan strategisen suunnittelun teoreettisen viitekehikon ja prosessin. Nämä mallit tulevat varmasti jättämään pysyvän jäljen strategiatyöskentelyn nykykäytäntöihin.

Relevância:

30.00% 30.00%

Publicador:

Resumo:

This thesis attempts to find whether scenario planning supports the organizational strategy as a method for addressing uncertainty. The main issues are why, what and how scenario planning fits in organizational strategy and how the process could be supported to make it more effective. The study follows the constructive approach. It starts with examination of competitive advantage and the way that an organization develops strategy and how it addresses the uncertainty in its operational environment. Based on the conducted literature review, scenario methods would seem to provide versatile platform for addressing future uncertainties. The construction is formed by examining the scenario methods and presenting suitable support methods, which results in forming of the theoretical proposition for supporter scenario process. The theoretical framework is tested in laboratory conditions, and the results from the test sessions are used a basis for scenario stories. The process of forming the scenarios and the results are illustrated and presented for scrutiny

Relevância:

30.00% 30.00%

Publicador:

Resumo:

The evaluation of investments in advanced technology is one of the most important decision making tasks. The importance is even more pronounced considering the huge budget concerning the strategic, economic and analytic justification in order to shorten design and development time. Choosing the most appropriate technology requires an accurate and reliable system that can lead the decision makers to obtain such a complicated task. Currently, several Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs) manufacturers that design global products are seeking local firms to act as their sales and services representatives (called distributors) to the end user. At the same time, the end user or customer is also searching for the best possible deal for their investment in ICT's projects. Therefore, the objective of this research is to present a holistic decision support system to assist the decision maker in Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) - working either as individual decision makers or in a group - in the evaluation of the investment to become an ICT's distributor or an ICT's end user. The model is composed of the Delphi/MAH (Maximising Agreement Heuristic) Analysis, a well-known quantitative method in Group Support System (GSS), which is applied to gather the average ranking data from amongst Decision Makers (DMs). After that the Analytic Network Process (ANP) analysis is brought in to analyse holistically: it performs quantitative and qualitative analysis simultaneously. The illustrative data are obtained from industrial entrepreneurs by using the Group Support System (GSS) laboratory facilities at Lappeenranta University of Technology, Finland and in Thailand. The result of the research, which is currently implemented in Thailand, can provide benefits to the industry in the evaluation of becoming an ICT's distributor or an ICT's end user, particularly in the assessment of the Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) programme. After the model is put to test with an in-depth collaboration with industrial entrepreneurs in Finland and Thailand, the sensitivity analysis is also performed to validate the robustness of the model. The contribution of this research is in developing a new approach and the Delphi/MAH software to obtain an analysis of the value of becoming an ERP distributor or end user that is flexible and applicable to entrepreneurs, who are looking for the most appropriate investment to become an ERP distributor or end user. The main advantage of this research over others is that the model can deliver the value of becoming an ERP distributor or end user in a single number which makes it easier for DMs to choose the most appropriate ERP vendor. The associated advantage is that the model can include qualitative data as well as quantitative data, as the results from using quantitative data alone can be misleading and inadequate. There is a need to utilise quantitative and qualitative analysis together, as can be seen from the case studies.

Relevância:

30.00% 30.00%

Publicador:

Resumo:

Tämä pro gradu tutkielma esittää markkinointistrategian digitaaliselle matkapuhelinpalvelulle penetroiduttaessa uusille markkinoille. MegaFon on uuden sukupolven mobiilioperaattori, jolla on lukuisia teknlogiaan perustuvia etuisuuksia puolellaan. Markkinointistrategian perusteena asiakkaat on määritelty, paikallistettu ja analysoitu. Tämän lisäksi, palvelun positiointi, hinnoittelu- ja jakelukanavavaihtoehdot on myöskin analysoitu ja määritelty. Menestystekijöihin liittyvät kysymykset, myynnin jälkeiseen toimintaan liittyvät asiat on myös tutkittu. Teoreettiset aspektit liittyvät pääsääntöisesti uuden palvelun ja palveluiden lanseeramiseen (palvelu, palvelun elinkaariajattelu), niiden markkinointistrategioihin lanseerausvaiheessa ja markkinointikanavien päättämiseen. Tutkimuksessa on selitetty MegaFonin ennustamis- ja lähestymistavat, joilla on valotettu todellista markkinatilannetta. Tämän tutkielman informaatio on kerätty useista lähteistä, kuten: yleistä aiheeseen liittyvää kirjallisuutta, sisäisiä raportteja ja Megafonin materiaalia, yhteistyökumppaneiden aineistoa, Internettia ja muuta saatavilla olevaa materiaalia. Tuloksena on määritelty päätöksenteon avainkohdat ja osaltaan perinteiset lähestymistavat on kyseenalaistettu.