Promoting Metacognitive Skills in a CSCL environment: implications for instructional and technology design

This paper aims to better understand the development of students’ learning processes when participating actively in a specific Computer Supported Collaborative Learning system called KnowCat. To this end, a longitudinal case study was designed, in which eighteen university students took part in a 12-month (two semesters) learning project. During this time period, the students followed an instructional process, using some elements of KnowCat (KnowCat key features) design to support and improve their interaction processes, especially peer learning processes. Our research involved both supervising the students’ collaborative learning processes throughout the learning project and focusing our analysis on the qualitative evolution of the students’ interaction processes and on the development of metacognitive learning processes. The results of the current research reveal that the instructional application of the CSCL-KnowCat system may favour and improve the development of the students’ metacognitive learning processes. Additionally, the implications of the design of computer supported collaborative learning networks and pedagogical issues are discussed in this paper.

Estils d'aprenentatge i rendiment acadèmic. Un estudi sobre alumnat de la Diplomatura de mestres de la Universitat de Vic

Com a part inicial d'un procés més ampli d’implementació dels principis del Disseny Instruccional Universal a la Universitat de Vic, aquest estudi ha examinat i explorat els estils d'aprenentatge dels estudiants de primer curs de la Diplomatura de Mestre a la Universitat de Vic. Els objectius han estat, analitzar els perfils dels estils d’aprenentatge dels alumnes de primer curs d'educació per determinar si hi havia diferències significatives en l'estil d'aprenentatge preferit en base a especialitat escollida, edat i sexe, així com també detectar correlacions entre estilsd'aprenentatge i rendiment acadèmic. S’ha estudiat una mostra de 243 estudiants. L'instrument de mesura ha estat el “Index of Learning Styles Questuinnaire”. S’ha procedit a fer un anàlisi descriptiu i ANOVA. Els resultats mostren una distribució de les quatre dimensions del ILS similars als perfils d’altres poblacions d'altres universitats. La immensa majoria dels estudiants resulten visuals i sensorial i indiferents per a les dimensions actiu-reflexiu i seqüencial-global. Per especialitat i edat només les dimensions actiureflexiu ivisual-verbal han mostrat diferències significatives. Per gènere no s'han trobat diferèncie significatives . Pel que respecta al rendiment acadèmic, només la dimensió visual-verbal sembla tenir una relació significativa, obtenint qualificacions sensiblement més altes aquells estudiants amb un perfil verbal més alts que els efectes visuals. S’ha generat dues noves variables "nivell de dispersió" i "grau de risc". No s’ha trobat cap relació entre aquests dos factors i el rendiment acadèmic. S’han discutit els resultats. L’instrument ILSQ sembla presentar un valor moderat com a element predictiu de dificultats l'aprenentatge de l’alumnat i el seu rendiment acadèmic.

The interactional space in CLIL (Content and Language Integrated Learning) and EFL (English as a Foreign Language) classrooms

Aquest estudi pretén investigar els intercanvis verbals mestre/a – aprenent(s) en dos contextos d'instrucció diferents: classes amb un enfocament AICLE (Aprenentatge Integrat de Continguts Curriculars i Llengua Estrangera) on s’aprenen continguts no lingüístics a través de l’anglès, per una banda, i classes 'tradicionals' d'anglès com a llengua estrangera, on l’anglès és alhora objecte d’estudi i vehicle de comunicació, per una altra banda. Més concretament, les preguntes que formula el/la mestre/a, la producció oral dels aprenents i el 'feedback' del/de la mestre/a en els episodis d’atenció a la forma s’han estudiat a la llum de les principals teories provinents del camp de l’Adquisició de Segones Llengües (SLA) per tal de demostrar el seu paper en l’aprenentatge de l’anglès. El corpus de dades prové de l’enregistrament de 7 sessions AICLE i d'11 sessions EFL enregistrades en format àudio i vídeo en dos centres públics d’Educació Primària (EP) de Catalunya. A cadascuna de les escoles, el/la mateix/a mestre/a és l’encarregat/da dels dos tipus d’instrucció amb el mateix grup d’aprenents (10-11 anys d’edat), fet que permet eliminar variables individuals com l'aptitud dels aprenents o l'estil del/de la mestre/a.Els resultats mostren un cert nombre de similituds discursives entre AICLE i EFL donat que ambdós enfocaments tenen lloc en el context-classe amb unes característiques ben definides. Tal com apunta la recerca realitzada en aquest camp, la instrucció AICLE reuneix un seguit de condicions idònies per un major desenvolupament dels nivells de llengua anglesa més enllà de les classes ‘tradicionals’ d’anglès. Malgrat això, aquest estudi sembla indicar que el potencial d'AICLE pel que fa a facilitar una exposició rica a l’anglès i una producció oral significativa no s’explota degudament. En aquest sentit, els resultats d’aquest estudi poden contribuir a la formació dels futurs professors d'AICLE si es busca l’assoliment d’una complementarietat d’ambdós contextos amb l’objectiu últim de millorar els nivells de domini de la llengua anglesa.

El Sistema educatiu als territoris autònoms palestins: estudi interpretatiu

El propòsit d'aquesta investigació és conèixer, descriure i interpretar el sistema educatiu palestí per saber si una situació de conflicte afecta -i en quina mesura- el funcionament, estructura, resultats i comprensió del concepte educatiu en una regió. Per assolir-ho, s'ha cercat informació bibliogràfica en diferents fonts, a més de la observació in situ de la realitat educativa palestina, fent entrevistes a diferents agents de la regió. Cal esmentar que el treball teòric és general però la descripció pràctica és contextualitzada a Nablus, una ciutat de Cisjordània. Els resultats obtinguts en aquesta investigació educativa de la branca de l'Educació Comparada han estat diversos, concretar-se en diferents conclusions: les conseqüències d'una guerra silenciosa que fa més de 60 anys que es perllonga en el temps implica dificultats econòmiques i administratives que afecten directament al sistema educatiu de la regió; objectius del govern palestí encarats a desenvolupar la població amb una aplicació pràctica real que els acompleix; importància de l'imaginari social de la nació per comprendre la importància del concepte d'Educació i les accions i atacs que rep aquest concepte per part de l'Estat d'Israel i on la comunitat internacional no es posiciona; la necessitat de crear un Estat Independent Palestí

Assessment and reuse of contents in the competence-based educational platform InterMediActor

This paper describes a failure alert system and a methodology for content reuse in a new instructional design system called InterMediActor (IMA). IMA provides an environment for instructional content design, production and reuse, and for students’ evaluation based in content specification through a hierarchical structure of competences. The student assessment process and information extraction process for content reuse are explained.

Supporting the reuse of effective CSCL learning designs through social structure representations

Distance and blended collaborative learning settings are usually characterized by different social structures defined in terms of groups' number, dimension, and composition; these structures are variable and can change within the same activity. This variability poses additional complexity to instructional designers, when they are trying to develop successful experiences from existing designs. This complexity is greatly associated with the fact that learning designs do not render explicit how social structures influenced the decisions of the original designer, and thus whether the social structures of the new setting could preclude the effectiveness of the reused design. This article proposes the usage of new representations (social structure representations, SSRs) able to support unskilled designers in reusing existing learning designs, through the explicit characterization of the social structures and constraints embedded either by the original designers or the reusing teachers, according to well-known principles of good collaborative learning practice. The article also describes an evaluation process that involved university professors, as well as the main findings derived from it. This process supported the initial assumptions about the effectiveness of SSRs, with significant evidence from both qualitative and qualitative data.

Student modeling based on fuzzy inference mechanisms

The paper presents a competence-based instructional design system and a way to provide a personalization of navigation in the course content. The navigation aid tool builds on the competence graph and the student model, which includes the elements of uncertainty in the assessment of students. An individualized navigation graph is constructed for each student, suggesting the competences the student is more prepared to study. We use fuzzy set theory for dealing with uncertainty. The marks of the assessment tests are transformed into linguistic terms and used for assigning values to linguistic variables. For each competence, the level of difficulty and the level of knowing its prerequisites are calculated based on the assessment marks. Using these linguistic variables and approximate reasoning (fuzzy IF-THEN rules), a crisp category is assigned to each competence regarding its level of recommendation.

En torno a los efectos de la edad en el aprendizaje escolar de una lengua extrangera

The purpose of this article is to treat a currently much debated issue, the effects of age on second language learning. To do so, we contrast data collected by our research team from over one thousand seven hundred young and adult learners with four popular beliefs or generalizations, which, while deeply rooted in this society, are not always corroborated by our data.Two of these generalizations about Second Language Acquisition (languages spoken in the social context) seem to be widely accepted: a) older children, adolescents and adults are quicker and more efficient at the first stages of learning than are younger learners; b) in a natural context children with an early start are more liable to attain higher levels of proficiency. However, in the context of Foreign Language Acquisition, the context in which we collect the data, this second generalization is difficult to verify due to the low number of instructional hours (a maximum of some 800 hours) and the lower levels of language exposure time provided. The design of our research project has allowed us to study differences observed with respect to the age of onset (ranging from 2 to 18+), but in this article we focus on students who began English instruction at the age of 8 (LOGSE Educational System) and those who began at the age of 11 (EGB). We have collected data from both groups after a period of 200 (Time 1) and 416 instructional hours (Time 2), and we are currently collecting data after a period of 726 instructional hours (Time 3). We have designed and administered a variety of tests: tests on English production and reception, both oral and written, and within both academic and communicative oriented approaches, on the learners' L1 (Spanish and Catalan), as well as a questionnaire eliciting personal and sociolinguistic information. The questions we address and the relevant empirical evidence are as follows: 1. "For young children, learning languages is a game. They enjoy it more than adults."Our data demonstrate that the situation is not quite so. Firstly, both at the levels of Primary and Secondary education (ranging from 70.5% in 11-year-olds to 89% in 14-year-olds) students have a positive attitude towards learning English. Secondly, there is a difference between the two groups with respect to the factors they cite as responsible for their motivation to learn English: the younger students cite intrinsic factors, such as the games they play, the methodology used and the teacher, whereas the older students cite extrinsic factors, such as the role of their knowledge of English in the achievement of their future professional goals. 2 ."Young children have more resources to learn languages." Here our data suggest just the opposite. The ability to employ learning strategies (actions or steps used) increases with age. Older learners' strategies are more varied and cognitively more complex. In contrast, younger learners depend more on their interlocutor and external resources and therefore have a lower level of autonomy in their learning. 3. "Young children don't talk much but understand a lot"This third generalization does seem to be confirmed, at least to a certain extent, by our data in relation to the analysis of differences due to the age factor and productive use of the target language. As seen above, the comparably slower progress of the younger learners is confirmed. Our analysis of interpersonal receptive abilities demonstrates as well the advantage of the older learners. Nevertheless, with respect to passive receptive activities (for example, simple recognition of words or sentences) no great differences are observed. Statistical analyses suggest that in this test, in contrast to the others analyzed, the dominance of the subjects' L1s (reflecting a cognitive capacity that grows with age) has no significant influence on the learning process. 4. "The sooner they begin, the better their results will be in written language"This is not either completely confirmed in our research. First of all, we perceive that certain compensatory strategies disappear only with age, but not with the number of instructional hours. Secondly, given an identical number of instructional hours, the older subjects obtain better results. With respect to our analysis of data from subjects of the same age (12 years old) but with a different number of instructional hours (200 and 416 respectively, as they began at the ages of 11 and 8), we observe that those who began earlier excel only in the area of lexical fluency. In conclusion, the superior rate of older learners appears to be due to their higher level of cognitive development, a factor which allows them to benefit more from formal or explicit instruction in the school context. Younger learners, however, do not benefit from the quantity and quality of linguistic exposure typical of a natural acquisition context in which they would be allowed to make use of implicit learning abilities. It seems clear, then, that the initiative in this country to begin foreign language instruction earlier will have positive effects only if it occurs in combination with either higher levels of exposure time to the foreign language, or, alternatively, with its use as the language of instruction in other areas of the curriculum.

¿Por qué no ha fructificado la propuesta del profesor como investigador? Y algunas propuestas para resistir a un presente nostálgico

En aquest article es revisa el marc que ha permès situar algunes de les propostes de John Elliot en l'educació espanyola. En especial, es para atenció al desafiament que va suposar el plantejament de la investigació en l'acció i la noció del professor com a investigador. Alhora que s'analitza la seva acollida favorable inicial entre una part de la comunitat acadèmica i el professorat innovador, es revisen algunes de les possibles causes de per què no va fructificar en el marc d'una reforma com la de 1990. Tot això serveix de pont per destacar la vigència de les idees i aportacions de John Elliott, amb motiu de la seva investidura com a doctor honoris causa per la Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, en el moment històric que viu el nostre sistema educatiu a partir de l'aprovació de la LOCE. Tenir en compte les idees i propostes de John Elliott pot suggerir-nos algunes formes de resistència en un moment que molts educadors innovadors i compromesos en el seu treball viuen com a profundament regressiu.

Una aproximació als problemes d'equitat al sistema educatiu espanyol

El sistema educatiu espanyol s'enfronta a una sèrie de grans reptes en l'àmbit de l'equitat. Alguns d'ells són comuns a tots els països europeus, però d'altres són específics d'Espanya o manifesten una gravetat especial en el context espanyol. Les polítiques d'educació des de la dècada de 1970 han permès l'accés al sistema educatiu de sectors populars cada cop més amplis, i s'han aplicat diverses reformes que han allargat l'escolarització obligatòria fins els 16 anys. Amb tot, i malgrat els progressos, el cert és que els nivells d'accés i d'èxit escolar encara estant molt marcats per factors socioeconòmics, ètnics i regionals.

En torno a los efectos de la edad en el aprendizaje escolar de una lengua extrangera

The purpose of this article is to treat a currently much debated issue, the effects of age on second language learning. To do so, we contrast data collected by our research team from over one thousand seven hundred young and adult learners with four popular beliefs or generalizations, which, while deeply rooted in this society, are not always corroborated by our data.Two of these generalizations about Second Language Acquisition (languages spoken in the social context) seem to be widely accepted: a) older children, adolescents and adults are quicker and more efficient at the first stages of learning than are younger learners; b) in a natural context children with an early start are more liable to attain higher levels of proficiency. However, in the context of Foreign Language Acquisition, the context in which we collect the data, this second generalization is difficult to verify due to the low number of instructional hours (a maximum of some 800 hours) and the lower levels of language exposure time provided. The design of our research project has allowed us to study differences observed with respect to the age of onset (ranging from 2 to 18+), but in this article we focus on students who began English instruction at the age of 8 (LOGSE Educational System) and those who began at the age of 11 (EGB). We have collected data from both groups after a period of 200 (Time 1) and 416 instructional hours (Time 2), and we are currently collecting data after a period of 726 instructional hours (Time 3). We have designed and administered a variety of tests: tests on English production and reception, both oral and written, and within both academic and communicative oriented approaches, on the learners' L1 (Spanish and Catalan), as well as a questionnaire eliciting personal and sociolinguistic information. The questions we address and the relevant empirical evidence are as follows: 1. "For young children, learning languages is a game. They enjoy it more than adults."Our data demonstrate that the situation is not quite so. Firstly, both at the levels of Primary and Secondary education (ranging from 70.5% in 11-year-olds to 89% in 14-year-olds) students have a positive attitude towards learning English. Secondly, there is a difference between the two groups with respect to the factors they cite as responsible for their motivation to learn English: the younger students cite intrinsic factors, such as the games they play, the methodology used and the teacher, whereas the older students cite extrinsic factors, such as the role of their knowledge of English in the achievement of their future professional goals. 2 ."Young children have more resources to learn languages." Here our data suggest just the opposite. The ability to employ learning strategies (actions or steps used) increases with age. Older learners' strategies are more varied and cognitively more complex. In contrast, younger learners depend more on their interlocutor and external resources and therefore have a lower level of autonomy in their learning. 3. "Young children don't talk much but understand a lot"This third generalization does seem to be confirmed, at least to a certain extent, by our data in relation to the analysis of differences due to the age factor and productive use of the target language. As seen above, the comparably slower progress of the younger learners is confirmed. Our analysis of interpersonal receptive abilities demonstrates as well the advantage of the older learners. Nevertheless, with respect to passive receptive activities (for example, simple recognition of words or sentences) no great differences are observed. Statistical analyses suggest that in this test, in contrast to the others analyzed, the dominance of the subjects' L1s (reflecting a cognitive capacity that grows with age) has no significant influence on the learning process. 4. "The sooner they begin, the better their results will be in written language"This is not either completely confirmed in our research. First of all, we perceive that certain compensatory strategies disappear only with age, but not with the number of instructional hours. Secondly, given an identical number of instructional hours, the older subjects obtain better results. With respect to our analysis of data from subjects of the same age (12 years old) but with a different number of instructional hours (200 and 416 respectively, as they began at the ages of 11 and 8), we observe that those who began earlier excel only in the area of lexical fluency. In conclusion, the superior rate of older learners appears to be due to their higher level of cognitive development, a factor which allows them to benefit more from formal or explicit instruction in the school context. Younger learners, however, do not benefit from the quantity and quality of linguistic exposure typical of a natural acquisition context in which they would be allowed to make use of implicit learning abilities. It seems clear, then, that the initiative in this country to begin foreign language instruction earlier will have positive effects only if it occurs in combination with either higher levels of exposure time to the foreign language, or, alternatively, with its use as the language of instruction in other areas of the curriculum.

De l'escriptura a l'oralitat, de la recepció a l'expressió, de la competència a l'ús

Com sabem, hi ha suficients símptomes per afirmar que el sistema escolar català no acaba d"aconseguir un desenvolupament òptim de la fluïdesa oral en català que pogués permetre als alumnes que no tenen aquesta llengua com a inicial un grau de col·loquialització suficient per poder-la usar sense sentir incomoditat o inseguretat. Certament, això no és la sola responsabi litat del sistema en si sinó també del context demosociolingüístic en què les institucions escolars es troben inserides. Aquest context és caracteritzat, per a molta de la població escolar, per una altíssima concentració residencial d"individus de llengua inicial castellana amb poques oportunitats de relació habitual amb altres persones de llengua inicial catalana. Aquest estat de coses fa que el procés de bilingüització en català hagi de dependre fonamentalment del sistema escolar, ja que no pot obtenir els efectes contextuals d"un contacte sovintejat i habitual entre les poblacions, com el que es produïa encara a Catalunya abans, diguem, del 1960.

¿Por qué no ha fructificado la propuesta del profesor como investigador? Y algunas propuestas para resistir a un presente nostálgico

En aquest article es revisa el marc que ha permès situar algunes de les propostes de John Elliot en l'educació espanyola. En especial, es para atenció al desafiament que va suposar el plantejament de la investigació en l'acció i la noció del professor com a investigador. Alhora que s'analitza la seva acollida favorable inicial entre una part de la comunitat acadèmica i el professorat innovador, es revisen algunes de les possibles causes de per què no va fructificar en el marc d'una reforma com la de 1990. Tot això serveix de pont per destacar la vigència de les idees i aportacions de John Elliott, amb motiu de la seva investidura com a doctor honoris causa per la Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, en el moment històric que viu el nostre sistema educatiu a partir de l'aprovació de la LOCE. Tenir en compte les idees i propostes de John Elliott pot suggerir-nos algunes formes de resistència en un moment que molts educadors innovadors i compromesos en el seu treball viuen com a profundament regressiu.

Videojuegos como un entorno de aprendizaje: el caso de "Monturiol el joc"

Video games in a learning environ-ment and their application to the educational world has become a common study between researchers because the use of videogames in the classroom is coherent with a compe-tence-based education theory. A social science approach to video-games allows an exhaustive under-standing of the video games and of the game experience in the classroom. When a video game gives to the user a high level of immersion, all his interest and energy is focused in the game, this fact together with the motivation in the video game is the basis of interest for educators and researchers in the potentiality of the video games as learning environ-ments. In this presentation, we will show and analyze the importance of the video games in an educational context, using a case study: the video game "Monturiol el joc". In the paper, we describe the video game structure, the instructional function, the practice application and the future work. Also, we discuss the impor-tance of the video games as a learning immersive environment, and we conclude our report with a brief analysis of the importance of the study of video games.

Descartes wears Converse: Liberal Arts for the Twenty-First Century Student

Students today have a different way of relating to information due to the new media channels that have arisen in the last decades. These have changed the way high-school and undergraduate students learn and they have altered the manner by which they perceive the world. Today’s Education Theory must take this fact into account in order to enhance the student’s learning process. The objective of this project is to give an example of how this enhancement may be achieved. First, it will give a brief overview of the relation between today’s young generations and the different channels of information; secondly, it will analyze the cognitive, psychological and educational theories that explain how the human brain learns and the important value that nonverbal information has for the memory system; afterwards, it will focus on this nonverbal information, looking at the possible effects that it may have on human memory and learning; finally, it will give an example of the practical implementation of this theory through the presentation of three animated instructional videos that have been created with the specific aim of enhancing the young generation’s understanding of some complex subjects of the Liberal Arts.