Contribution of Mental Health Service User Groups to Mental Health Services and Policy in Ghana : The Case of Mental Health Society of Ghana

RESUMO: Este estudo procurou documentar a perspectiva (s) dos utentes de saúde mental e das associações de prestadores de cuidados sobre a prestação, o papel e a contribuição de serviços de saúde mental da comunidade tal como foram percebidos por um número de informadores-chave, incluindo os utentes do serviço mentais e os próprios prestadores de cuidados. O caso específico da Sociedade Saúde Mental do Gana (MEHSOG) foi o foco deste estudo. O modelo foi o de um estudo de caso, utilizando discussões de grupo e entrevistas com informadores-chave como instrumentos de recolha de dados. Estas ferramentas de colheita de dados foram complementadas por observações dos participantes e pela revisão de documentos da MEHSOG e dos vários grupos de apoio da comunidade de auto-ajuda que compõem a associação nacional. O estudo revelou que os utentes dos serviços de saúde mental e seus prestadores de cuidados constituem um importante grupo de partes interessadas na prestação de serviços de saúde mental da comunidade e no desenvolvimento de políticas que tenham em conta as necessidades e os direitos das pessoas com doença mental ou epilepsia. O envolvimento da MEHSOG promove a mobilização de membros e famílias relacionadas com a doença mental de beneficiar de serviços de tratamento bem organizados com um impacto significativo na melhoria da saúde e da participação dos utentes dos serviços e seus prestadores de cuidados primários em processos de tomada de decisão da família e na comunidade processos de desenvolvimento. Os utentes dos serviços por beneficiarem de tratamento, e os prestadores de cuidados primários, por se tornarem mais livres e menos sobrecarregados com a responsabilidade de cuidar, podem passar a envolver-se mais em atividades que melhoramo seu estado, o de suas famílias e das comunidades. A advocacia dos membros da MEHSOG para conseguir que a “Mental Health Bill” se transforme numa Lei foi também um desenvolvimento significativo resultante da participação ativa dos utentes do serviço em chamar a atenção para uma nova e inclusiva legislação de saúde mental para o Gana. Entre os fatores e oportunidades que permitiram aos utentes dos serviços de saúde mental e aos prestadores de cuidados primários de pessoas com doença mental apoiar activamente a prestação de serviços de saúde mental comunitária e o desenvolvimento de políticas conta-se a contribuição da sociedade civil do Gana, particularmente o movimento da deficiência, e os esforços anteriores de ONGs em saúde mental e dos profissionais de saúde mental para ter uma nova lei em saúde mental. Observámos um certo número de desafios e barreiras que actuam de forma a limitar a influência dos utentes dos serviços de saúde mental na provisão da saúde mental comunitária e no desenvolvimento de políticas. Entre elas o estigma social contra a doença mental e pessoas com doença mental ou epilepsia e seus cuidadores primaries é um factor chave. O estigma tem alterado a percepção e as análises do público em geral, especialmente dos profissionais de saúde e das autoridades políticas afetando a priorização dos problemas de saúde mental nas políticas e programas. Outro desafio foi a deficiente infra-estrutura disponível para apoiar serviços de saúde mentais que assegurem aos utentes permanecerem em bom estado de saúde e bem-estar para serem advogados de si próprios. A recomendação do presente estudo é que os movimentos de utentes dos serviços de saúde mental são importantes e que eles precisam de ser apoiados e encorajados a desempenhar o seu papel como pessoas com experiência vivida para contribuir para a organização e prestação de serviços de saúde mental, bem como para a implementação, monitorização e avaliação de políticas e programas. ------------------------------------ ABSTRACT: This study sought to document the perspective(s) of mental health users and care-givers associations in community mental health service provision and their role and contribution as it was perceived by a number of key informants including the mental service users and care-givers themselves. The specific case of the Mental Health Society of Ghana (MEHSOG) was the focus of this study. A case study approach was used to with Focus Group Discussions and Key Informants Interviews being the data collection tools that were used. These data collection tools were complemented by participant observations and review of documents of the MEHSOG and the various community self-help peer support groups that make up the national association. The study revealed that mental health service users and their care-givers constitute an important stakeholder group in community mental health service provision and development of policies that factor in the needs and rights of persons with mental illness or epilepsy. MEHSOG’s involvement in mobilising members and education families to come forward with the relations with mental illness to benefit from treatment services were well made a significant impact in improving the health and participation of service users and their primary carers in family decision-making processes and in community development processes. Service users, on benefiting from treatment, and primary care-givers, on becoming freer and less burdened with the responsibility of care, move on to engage in secure livelihoods activities, which enhanced their status in their families and communities. The advocacy MEHSOG members undertook in getting the mental health Bill become Law was also noted as significant development that was realised as a result of active involvement of service users in calling for a new and inclusive mental health legislation for Ghana. Enabling factors and opportunities that enabled mental health service users and primary care-givers of people with mental illness to actively support community mental health service provision and policy development is with the vibrant civil society presence in Ghana, particularly the disability movement, and earlier efforts by NGOs in mental health in Ghana long-side mental health professionals to have a new law in mental health. A number of challenges were also noted which were found to limit the extent to which mental health service users can be influential in community mental health service provision and policy development. Key among them was the social stigma against mental illness and people with mental illness or epilepsy and their primary carers. Stigma has affected perceptions, analyses of the general public, especially health practitioners and policy authorities that it has affected their prioritisation of mental health issues in policies and programmes. Another challenge was the poor infrastructure available to support enhanced mental health care services that ensure mental health service users remain in a good state of health and wellbeing to advocate for themselves. The recommendation from the study is that mental health service user movements are important and need to be supported and encouraged to play their role as persons with lived experience to inform organisation and provision of mental health services as well as design and implementation, monitoring and evaluation of policies and programes.

Health care costs of domestic violence against women – evidence from Portugal

Our main objective is to estimate the additional health care costs to the Portuguese National Health Service (NHS) due to domestic violence against women. We collected information through a survey addressed to health care centres’ female users. Both victims and non-victims of violence were inquired. We estimate costs according to five different groups – consultation costs, health care treatment and therapeutic costs, costs of complementary and diagnostic exams, drugs costs and transport costs. The estimations have been split into two perspectives – the NHS perspective (public perspective) and private perspective of inquired women (out of pocket payments). The timeframe of our calculations is one year, referring to all costs generated by domestic violence situations in the last twelve months. Essentially costs were estimated through the product of total number of episodes by the average estimated price per episode. Additionally, for the private costs, we also considered the costs originated by income losses, the opportunity cost of time spent on health care treatments and the work inability caused by sickness. The results suggest that the victims of domestic violence’s additional demand for health care is valued €140 per annum, that is about 22% higher than health care costs of non-victims. These results match those of similar studies for the United States, taking account of per capita differences in health care spending. A large proportion (90%) of the additional costs associated with domestic violence is supported by the NHS, where consultations and drugs are the most important contributors of such costs. Health consequences of domestic violence result from losses in quality of life and worst health status of victims and correspond to additional permanent economic costs of domestic violence episodes.

Double coverage and demand for health care: Evidence from quantile regression

An individual experiences double coverage when he bene ts from more than one health insurance plan at the same time. This paper examines the impact of such supplementary insurance on the demand for health care services. Its novelty is that within the context of count data modelling and without imposing restrictive parametric assumptions, the analysis is carried out for di¤erent points of the conditional distribution, not only for its mean location. Results indicate that moral hazard is present across the whole outcome distribution for both public and private second layers of health insurance coverage but with greater magnitude in the latter group. By looking at di¤erent points we unveil that stronger double coverage e¤ects are smaller for high levels of usage. We use data for Portugal, taking advantage of particular features of the public and private protection schemes on top of the statutory National Health Service. By exploring the last Portuguese Health Survey, we were able to evaluate their impacts on the consumption of doctor visi

Analysis of mental health service financial models with a particular emphasis of Ireland

ABSTRACT: Financing is a critical factor in ensuring the optimal development and delivery of a mental health system. The primary method of financing worldwide is tax-based. However many low income countries depend on out-of-pocket payments. There is a report on Irish Health Care funding but none that deals exclusively with mental health care. This paper analyses the various financial models that exist globally with respect to financing the mental health sector, examines the impact of various models on service users, especially in terms of relative ‘financial burden’ and provides a more detailed examination of the current mental health funding situation in Ireland After extensive internet and hardcopy research on the above topics, the findings were analysed and a number of recommendations were reached. Mental health service should be free at the point of delivery to achieve universal coverage. Government tax-based funding or mandatory social insurance with government top-ups, as required, appears the optimal option, although there is no one funding system applicable everywhere. Out-of-pocket funding can create a crippling financial burden for service users. It is important to employ improved revenue collection systems, eliminate waste, provide equitable resource distribution, ring fence mental health funding and cap the number of visits, where necessary. Political, economic, social and cultural factors play a role in funding decisions and this can be clearly seen in the context of the current economic recession in Ireland. Only 33% of the Irish population has access to free public health care and the number health insurance policy holders has dramatically declined, resulting in increased out-of-pocket payments. This approach risks negatively impacting on the social determinants of health, increasing health inequalities and negatively affecting economic productivity. It is therefore important the Irish government examines other options to provide funding for mental health services.

Obama's law : analysis of a breakthrough law on healthcare access and lessons for the Portuguese health system management

ABSTRACT - The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act shook the foundations of the US health system, offering all Americans access to health care by changing the way the health insurance industry works. As President Obama signed the Act on 23 March 2010, he said that it stood for “the core principle that everybody should have some basic security when it comes to their health care”. Unlike the U.S., the Article 64 of the Portuguese Constitution provides, since 1976, the right to universal access to health care. However, facing a severe economic crisis, Portugal has, under the supervision of the Troika, a tight schedule to implement measures to improve the efficiency of the National Health Service. Both countries are therefore despite their different situation, in a conjuncture of reform and the use of new health management measures. The present work, using a qualitative research methodology examines the Affordable Care Act in order to describe its principles and enforcement mechanisms. In order to describe the reality in Portugal, the Portuguese health system and the measures imposed by Troika are also analyzed. The intention of this entire analysis is not only to disclose the innovative U.S. law, but to find some innovative measures that could serve health management in Portugal. Essentially we identified the Exchanges and Wellness Programs, described throughout this work, leaving also the idea of the possibility of using them in the Portuguese national health system.

Essays in health economics: Volume-Outcome Effect, upcoding behaviour and the evaluation of a short-term intervention program

Evidence in the literature suggests a negative relationship between volume of medical procedures and mortality rates in the health care sector. In general, high-volume hospitals appear to achieve lower mortality rates, although considerable variation exists. However, most studies focus on US hospitals, which face different incentives than hospitals in a National Health Service (NHS). In order to add to the literature, this study aims to understand what happens in a NHS. Results reveal a statistically significant correlation between volume of procedures and better outcomes for the following medical procedures: cerebral infarction, respiratory infections, circulatory disorders with AMI, bowel procedures, cirrhosis, and hip and femur procedures. The effect is explained with the practice-makes-perfect hypothesis through static effects of scale with little evidence of learning-by-doing. The centralization of those medical procedures is recommended given that this policy would save a considerable number of lives (reduction of 12% in deaths for cerebral infarction).

Practice variations in the production of health

This study investigates three questions related to medical practice variation. First, it tests whether average length of stay across Portuguese National Health Service hospitals varies when controlling for differences in patients’ characteristics. Second, it looks at hospital-level characteristics in order to find out whether these are able to explain differences in average length of stay across hospitals. Finally, it proposes a best practice average length of stay for each of the six episodes of care analyzed. To perform the analysis, administrative data from the Diagnosis-Related groups’ data set for the year of 2012 was used. A replication of a hierarchical two-stage model with hospital fixed effects was carried out. The results show that after taking patients’ characteristics into account, variation in average length of stay across hospitals exists. This variation cannot be explained by hospital-level characteristics.

Decentralization and privatization in Portuguese health reforms

ABSTRACT - The Portuguese National Health Service (SNS), a universal, centralized and public owned health care system, exhibits an extraordinary record of equalization in the access to health care and health gains in the late thirty years. However, the most recent history of the Portuguese health reform is pervaded by the influence of decentralization and privatization. Decentralization has been present in the system design since the 1976 Constitution, at least in theory. Private ownership of health care suppliers and out-ofpocket expenditures, on the financing side, both have a long tradition of relevance in the NHS mix of services. The initial aim of this study was to demonstrate expected parallelism between health reforms and public administration reforms, where a common pattern of joint decentralization and privatization was observed in many countries. Observers would be tempted to consider these two movements as common signs of new public management (NPM) developments. They have common objectives, are established around the core concepts of gains in effectiveness, efficiency, equity and quality of public services, through improved accountability. However, in practice, in Portugal, each movement was developed in a totally separated way. Besides those rooted in the NPM theory, there are few visible signs of association between decentralization and privatization. Decentralization, in the Portuguese SNS, was never intended to be followed by a privatization movement; it was seen merely as a public administration tool. Private management of health services, as stated in the most recent SNS legislation, was never intended to have decentralization as a condition or as a consequence. Paradoxically, in the Portuguese context, it has led invariably to centralized control. While presented as separate instruments for a common purpose, the association between decentralization and privatization still lacks a convincing demonstration. Many common health care management stereotypes remain to be checked out if we want to look for eventual associations between these two organizational tools.

The simple economics of risk-sharing agreements between the NHS and the pharmaceutical industry

The Janssen-Cilag proposal for a risk-sharing agreement regarding bortezomib received a welcome signal from NICE. The Office of Fair Trading report included risk-sharing agreements as an available tool for the National Health Service. Nonetheless, recent discussions have somewhat neglected the economic fundamentals underlying risk-sharing agreements. We argue here that risk-sharing agreements, although attractive due to the principle of paying by results, also entail risks. Too many patients may be put under treatment even with a low success probability. Prices are likely to be adjusted upward, in anticipation of future risk-sharing agreements between the pharmaceutical company and the third-party payer. An available instrument is a verification cost per patient treated, which allows obtaining the first-best allocation of patients to the new treatment, under the risk sharing agreement. Overall, the welfare effects of risk-sharing agreements are ambiguous, and care must be taken with their use.

25 anos de Inquérito Nacional de Saúde em Portug

RESUMO - O Inquérito Nacional de Saúde é um instrumento de observação em saúde promovido pelo Ministério da Saúde desde 1987, em resposta às necessidades crescentes de informação de saúde ligadas ao estabelecimento e às exigências de planeamento e avaliação decorrentes da instituição do Serviço Nacional de Saúde. O Inquérito Nacional de Saúde conta, até agora, com quatro edições. Os dados provêm através do estudo transversal de amostras probabilísticas da população portuguesa, através de entrevistas no domicílio, utilizando instrumentos e métodos válidos e estáveis. Os indicadores gerados descrevem o estado de saúde, utilização de cuidados de saúde e determinantes de saúde da população portuguesa residente em unidades de alojamento familiar e tem representatividade a nível nacional e regional. Além de útil para a investigação dos padrões e tendências na área da saúde da população, esta informação é importante como elemento de planeamento, na identificação de necessidades em saúde e na avaliação dos eventuais efeitos e impactes das intervenções realizadas na saúde da população. A evolução do Inquérito Nacional de Saúde depende da definição das necessidades de informação epidemiológica por parte do Estado e da sua integração no sistema europeu de inquéritos de saúde. --------------------------ABSTRACT – The National Health Interview Survey is an instrument of observation in health promoted by the Ministry of Health since 1987, in response to the growing demand for health information, derived from the institution of the National Health Service, as well as its planning and evaluation activities. The National Health Interview Survey has had four editions so far. Data are obtained through the cross-sectional study of probabilistic samples of the Portuguese population, through interviews at home, using valid and stable instruments and methods. Obtained indicators describe the state of health, use of health care and health determinants of the Portuguese population living in familiar dwellings, and are representative at national and regional levels. Besides its usefulness for the study of patterns and trends, this information is important for planning purposes, in the identification of health needs and for the evaluation of the eventual effects of the planned health interventions. The future of the National Health Interview Survey depends on the State’s definition of the needs of epidemiological information and also on its participation in the European system of health surveys. Keywords: health surveys; health indicators; epidem

O processo de contratualização na saúde em Portugal (1996-20

RESUMO - Através da investigação teórica analisa-se o processo de implementação da contratualização em Portugal e procura- -se perspectivar o seu desenvolvimento. Questionam-se ainda os factores críticos que no contexto português condicionam a implementação de políticas de mudança no sector da saúde e descortina-se o desenvolvimento deste importante instrumento de mudança à luz dos ensinamentos obtidos, quer na revisão bibliográfica quer nos casos Inglês e Espanhol. --------------------------ABSTRACT – Through a theoretical research, the implementation of the contracting process in Portugal is analysed and its development is envisioned. In addition, the critical factors, which constrain the implementation of change policies in the Portuguese health sector, are questioned. The development of this important tool of change is foreseen in the light of relevant findings, arising both from the literature review and from the British

Modelling HIV/AIDS length of stay in Portugal

Tese apresentada como requisito parcial para obtenção do grau de Doutor em Estatística e Gestão de Informação pelo Instituto Superior de Estatística e Gestão de Informação da Universidade Nova de Lisboa

A utilização de actos complementares de diagnóstico: uma análise económica

Dissertação submetida para obtenção do grau de Doutor em Saúde Pública Especialidade de Economia da Saúde

Financiamento hospitalar em Portugal : incentivos à selecção e equidade

RESUMO - Contexto: O sistema de financiamento do internamento hospitalar público Português é de natureza prospectiva, através de um orçamento global baseado no casemix para os doentes do Serviço Nacional de Saúde (SNS) e de um pagamento por episódio para os doentes dos subsistemas. Em ambos os casos, o financiamento baseia-se principalmente nos Grupos de Diagnóstico Homogéneos (GDH) correspondentes a cada episódio, seja para atribuir um preço por doente saído no caso dos doentes dos subsistemas, seja para calcular o casemix do hospital no caso dos doentes do SNS. Atendendo à heterogeneidade de utilização de recursos intra GDH, resultante das características e necessidades individuais de cada doente, é expectável que o hospital, tendo em vista a garantia da sustentabilidade económica e financeira e/ou a obtenção de mais-valias, procure que o custo de produção fique aquém do preço médio pago, o que pode resultar na selecção de doentes. Por outro lado, ao não ser tida em conta no financiamento, e na ausência de selecção, a heterogeneidade intra GDH pode resultar na injusta recompensa/penalização de uns hospitais em detrimento de outros, tendo em conta as características e necessidades da população que servem e pelas quais não são compensados. Objectivos: O presente estudo propôs-se, por isso, avaliar o impacte que as características inerentes aos doentes têm no consumo de recursos hospitalares, tendo em vista inferir se as mesmas criam incentivos à selecção de doentes ou são fonte de penalizações ou recompensas injustas para os hospitais. Metodologia: Foi utilizada a amostra completa dos doentes internados no ano 2007 por doenças e perturbações do aparelho circulatório (Grande Categoria de Diagnóstico 5) nos 76 hospitais públicos Portugueses (69.905 episódios). Assumiu-se como proxy dos custos a variável tempo de internamento, e avaliou-se, mediante a realização de uma regressão linear multivariada, a relação existente entre a variação no tempo de internamento e as características sexo, idade, severidade, comorbilidades e estatuto económico dos doentes, tendo-se concluído que todas, menos o sexo, têm impacte significativo no tempo de internamento. Uma análise preliminar da distribuição das características identificadas como indutoras de custos pelos hospitais em estudo, conforme o resultado financeiro alcançado por estes fosse positivo ou negativo, sugeriu que as mesmas podem ter impacte nos resultados financeiros alcançados pelos hospitais. Conclusão: Concluiu-se que a actual metodologia de financiamento dos hospitais públicos portugueses possui incentivos à selecção de doentes, visto possibilitar a identificação de doentes que pelas suas características se tornam menos “rentáveis” para os hospitais, o que se pode traduzir numa perda de qualidade assistencial e de acessibilidade para os mesmos e beneficia/penaliza uns hospitais em detrimento de outros, de acordo com as características da população que servem.

Transplante renal : desigualdades no acesso

RESUMO - Em Portugal estima-se que existam cerca de 14 mil insuficientes renais crónicos e estima-se que em 2025 sejam 24 mil. As alternativas de tratamento são: hemodiálise, diálise peritoneal ou o transplante renal. Das alternativas de tratamento, o transplante renal é considerado a melhor alternativa terapêutica proporcionando melhor qualidade de vida, aumentando a sobrevida dos doentes, caracterizando-se por ser menos oneroso e por apresentar melhor custo- efectivo, quando comparado com hemodiálise ou diálise peritoneal. Portugal situa-se entre os primeiros da Europa, relativo ao número de transplantes renais efectuados (56,1 por milhão de habitante), em 2010 efectuaram-se 573 transplantes renais. Apesar disso, muitos são os doentes que continuam em lista de espera a aguardar transplante, em média os doentes esperam cerca de dois a três anos por um transplante renal, quando o tempo ideal seria três a seis meses. Por outro lado, estudos internacionais demonstram que existem desigualdades no acesso ao transplante renal, assim à semelhança de outros países torna-se pertinente estudar a realidade portuguesa em relação à temática da desigualdade no acesso, dado o objectivo primordial do Serviço Nacional de Saúde de garantir a equidade nos cuidados de saúde. Este trabalho tem como objectivo principal avaliar se factores como o sexo, idade a localização geográfica influenciam o acesso ao transplante renal, contribuindo para desigualdades no acesso. Este trabalho baseou-se na base de dados dos doentes inscritos em lista de espera para transplante renal, respeitante à área de abrangência do Centro de Histocompatibilidade do Sul. Caracterizou-se a população quanto ao sexo, idade, concelho, região de saúde e unidade de transplantação. Determinou-se ainda, os tempos médios de espera para inscrição em lista activa e para transplante por sexo, idade, região de saúde e unidade de transplantação.Dos resultados obtidos salienta-se que as desigualdades encontradas no acesso ao transplante renal verificam-se entre o início do tratamento até à inscrição em lista activa para transplante. Depois dos doentes em lista activa, o tempo de espera médio não é influenciado significativamente pelo sexo, idade ou localização geográfica.