Two divergent ways to manage HR and to get to the top: an exploratory study in micro firms

Aim of the paper: The purpose of this paper is to examine human resources management practices (HRM practices) in small firms and to improve the understanding of the relationship between this kind of practices and business growth. This exploratory study is based on the resource-based view of the firm and empirical work carried out in two small firms by relating HRM practices with the firms’ results. Contribution to the literature: This is an in-depth study of HRM practices and its impact on performance growth in micro firms, isolating and controlling for most of the contextual and internal variables considered in the literature that relate HRM to growth. Firm growth analysis was broadened by the use of several dependent variables: employment growth and operational and financial performance growth. Some hypotheses for further research in identifying HRM practices in small business and its relation with firm growth are suggested. Methodology: Case study methodology was used to study two firms. The techniques used to collect data were semi-structured interviews to the owner and all the employees, unstructured observation at the firms’ facilities (during two days), entrepreneur profile definition (survey answer) and document data collection (on demographic characterization and performance results). Data was analyzed through content analysis methodology, and categories derived from the interviews’ protocols and literature. Results and implications: Results revealed that despite the firms’ organizational characteristics similarities, they differ significantly in owners’ motivation to grow, HRM practices and organizational performance and growth. Future studies should pay special attention to owner willingness to grow, to firms’ years of experience in business, to staff’s years of experience in their field of work and turnover. HRM practices in micro/small firms should be better defined and characterized. The external image of management posture relating to longitudinal financial results and growth should also be explored.

Uma perspectiva foucaudiana na auditoria à avaliação de desempenho na administração pública

Motivation: Auditing is not merely a collection of technical tasks but also a programmatic idea circulating in organizational environment, an idea which promises a certain style of control and organizational transparency (Power, 1998, p. 122) Performance appraisal within public organization aims to promote this organizational transparency and promote learning and improvement process both for employees and for the organization. However, we suggest that behind its clear intentions, there are some other goals tied to performance appraisal that could be seen as components of a discipline and surveillance systems to make the employee “knowable, calculable and administrative object” (Miller and Rose, 1990, p. 5). Objective: In Portuguese public organizations, performance appraisal follows the SIADAP (Performance Appraisal Systems for Public Administration). The objective of this study is to capture whatever employees of public organizations (appraisers and appraisee) perceived the performance appraisal system (SIADAP) as an appraisal model that promotes equity, learning and improvement or just as an instrument of control to which they feel dominated and watched over. Method: We developed an in-depth qualitative case study using semi-structured interviews with appraisers and their subordinates in the administrative department of a university institute of Medicine. The discourse of the participants was theoretically analyzed based on Foucauldian framework. Prior to qualitative data collection, we collected quantitative data, with a questionnaire, to measure the (un)satisfaction of employees with the all appraisal system. Findings: Although some key points of Foucault perspective were identified, its framework revealed some limitations to capture the all complexity of performance appraisal. Qualitative data revealed a significant tendency in discourses of appraisers and their subordinates considering SIADAP as an instrument that’s aims to introduced political rationalities and limits to the employer’s promotions within their careers. Contribution: This study brings a critical perspectives and new insights about performance appraisals in Portuguese’s public administrations. It is original contribution to management of human recourses in public administration and primary to audit of performance appraisal systems.

Proposta de implementação da responsabilidade social numa empresa de engenharia e construção

Este estudo tem como finalidade analisar a possibilidade de implementação e integração do sistema de gestão da responsabilidade social numa empresa de engenharia e construção, de acordo com a norma NP 4469-1 (2008). Um dos objetivos deste trabalho é explorar uma das atividades fundamentais para o crescimento da economia: a construção. Esta funciona como barómetro da economia nacional, ou seja, movimenta vários setores importantes na sua cadeia de produção, contribuindo na criação de riqueza como também de emprego. Como consequência das mudanças na economia nos últimos anos, o comércio nacional transformou-se em comércio globalizado, tendo como mercado não só um país mas o mundo inteiro. As empresas veem isso como um desafio, independentemente da sua dimensão. A redução de custos e a diferenciação não podem ser a única fonte de competitividade. A recente situação de instabilidade económica mundial impulsiona as empresas a inovarem na sua imagem para com os stakeholders e, assim, garantir o seu desenvolvimento e sustentabilidade financeira. A temática da Responsabilidade Social Empresarial (RSE) surgiu da necessidade de existir um espírito empresarial responsável, ao encontro do conceito de desenvolvimento sustentável (Baylis e Smith, 2005). Apesar da ampla divulgação da noção de responsabilidade social das empresas, não se verifica, no entanto, uma definição exata da mesma, pois o tema tem sido abordado de diversas formas e tem dividido opiniões ao longo dos anos. A responsabilidade social é, assim, um fruto da gestão das organizações e das profundas críticas sociais, legais, éticas e económicas, inspiradas nos parâmetros da obtenção de valor social (Parra, 2003). A sustentabilidade revela uma mudança de paradigma do mundo empresarial, na medida em que as empresas devem adotar práticas socialmente responsáveis, que integrem de forma voluntária as preocupações ambientais, sociais e económicas no desenvolvimento das suas atividades operacionais e das suas interações com as partes interessadas.