5 resultados para Peer review
em Universidad de Alicante
Resumo:
Tradicionalmente, la literatura ha evidenciado debilidades en el sistema de revisión por pares en el ámbito de los artículos publicados en revistas. Hasta la fecha apenas se ha dedicado atención a estas debilidades en el campo de los congresos. Este trabajo examina los factores determinantes de las evaluaciones por pares que reciben las comunicaciones de los congresos a partir de las características de sus autores y del propio manuscrito. Asimismo, analiza la relación existente entre el grado de aceptación/rechazo de las comunicaciones y la calidad de las publicaciones posteriores que se derivan de las mismas. Los resultados obtenidos en un congreso de marketing evidencian que la orientación cuantitativa, las referencias bibliográficas y las notas a pie de página influyen en la evaluación por pares de las comunicaciones. Además, se detecta que aquellas comunicaciones que son aceptadas para su presentación en el congreso, posteriormente resultan publicadas en revistas de mayor calidad.
Resumo:
In this work, batch and dynamic adsorption tests are coupled for an accurate evaluation of CO2 adsorption performance for three different activated carbons obtained from olives stones by chemical activation followed by physical activation with CO2 at varying times, i.e. 20, 40 and 60 h. Kinetic and thermodynamic CO2 adsorption tests from simulated flue-gas at different temperature and CO2 pressure are carried out both in batch (a manometric equipment operating with pure CO2) and dynamic (a lab-scale fixed-bed column operating with CO2/N2 mixture) conditions. The textural characterization of the activated carbon samples shows a direct dependence of both micropore and ultramicropore volume on the activation time, hence AC60 has the higher contribution. The adsorption tests conducted at 273 and 293 K showed that, when CO2 pressure is lower than 0.3 bar, the lower the activation time the higher CO2 adsorption capacity and a ranking ωeq(AC20)>ωeq(AC40)>ωeq(AC60) can be exactly defined when T= 293 K. This result can be likely ascribed to a narrower pore size distribution of the AC20 sample, whose smaller pores are more effective for CO2 capture at higher temperature and lower CO2 pressure, the latter representing operating conditions of major interest for decarbonation of a flue-gas effluent. Moreover, the experimental results obtained from dynamic tests confirm the results derived from the batch tests in terms of CO2 adsorption capacity. It is important to highlight that the adsorption of N2 on the synthesized AC samples can be considered negligible. Finally, the importance of a proper analysis of characterization data and adsorption experimental results is highlighted for a correct assessment of CO2 removal performances of activated carbons at different CO2 pressure and operating temperature.
Resumo:
Los estándares actuales de calidad en publicación científica se basan en la revisión por pares, aunque este proceso tiene sus limitaciones, como la existencia de revisiones discrepantes, revisiones de baja calidad o el anonimato. La actuación de un/una buen/a editor/a después de la revisión puede y debe atemperar estos posibles problemas, ya que debe exigir una nueva revisión o seleccionar revisores/as adicionales.
Resumo:
In autumn 2012, the new release 05 (RL05) of monthly geopotencial spherical harmonics Stokes coefficients (SC) from GRACE (Gravity Recovery and Climate Experiment) mission was published. This release reduces the noise in high degree and order SC, but they still need to be filtered. One of the most common filtering processing is the combination of decorrelation and Gaussian filters. Both of them are parameters dependent and must be tuned by the users. Previous studies have analyzed the parameters choice for the RL05 GRACE data for oceanic applications, and for RL04 data for global application. This study updates the latter for RL05 data extending the statistics analysis. The choice of the parameters of the decorrelation filter has been optimized to: (1) balance the noise reduction and the geophysical signal attenuation produced by the filtering process; (2) minimize the differences between GRACE and model-based data; (3) maximize the ratio of variability between continents and oceans. The Gaussian filter has been optimized following the latter criteria. Besides, an anisotropic filter, the fan filter, has been analyzed as an alternative to the Gauss filter, producing better statistics.
Publishing and impact criteria, and their bearing on Translation Studies: In search of comparability
Resumo:
This paper questions the current concept of quality as used in research assessment rankings and peer review, with special reference to the link often established between impact and the way this impact is measured in the form of citation counting. Taking translation studies as a case study, we will offer a two-level approach to reveal both the macro- and micro-level biases that exist in this regard. We will first review three key aspects related to the idea of the quality of publications, namely peer review, journal indexing, and journal impact factor. We will then pinpoint some of the main macro-level problems regarding current practices and criteria as applied to translation studies, such as Thomson Reuters World of Science's journal coverage, citation patterns, and publication format. Next we will provide a micro-textual and practical perspective, focusing on citation counts and suggesting a series of corrective measures to increase comparability.