Convergence analysis and validation of low cost distance metrics for computational cost reduction of the Iterative Closest Point algorithm

The Iterative Closest Point algorithm (ICP) is commonly used in engineering applications to solve the rigid registration problem of partially overlapped point sets which are pre-aligned with a coarse estimate of their relative positions. This iterative algorithm is applied in many areas such as the medicine for volumetric reconstruction of tomography data, in robotics to reconstruct surfaces or scenes using range sensor information, in industrial systems for quality control of manufactured objects or even in biology to study the structure and folding of proteins. One of the algorithm’s main problems is its high computational complexity (quadratic in the number of points with the non-optimized original variant) in a context where high density point sets, acquired by high resolution scanners, are processed. Many variants have been proposed in the literature whose goal is the performance improvement either by reducing the number of points or the required iterations or even enhancing the complexity of the most expensive phase: the closest neighbor search. In spite of decreasing its complexity, some of the variants tend to have a negative impact on the final registration precision or the convergence domain thus limiting the possible application scenarios. The goal of this work is the improvement of the algorithm’s computational cost so that a wider range of computationally demanding problems from among the ones described before can be addressed. For that purpose, an experimental and mathematical convergence analysis and validation of point-to-point distance metrics has been performed taking into account those distances with lower computational cost than the Euclidean one, which is used as the de facto standard for the algorithm’s implementations in the literature. In that analysis, the functioning of the algorithm in diverse topological spaces, characterized by different metrics, has been studied to check the convergence, efficacy and cost of the method in order to determine the one which offers the best results. Given that the distance calculation represents a significant part of the whole set of computations performed by the algorithm, it is expected that any reduction of that operation affects significantly and positively the overall performance of the method. As a result, a performance improvement has been achieved by the application of those reduced cost metrics whose quality in terms of convergence and error has been analyzed and validated experimentally as comparable with respect to the Euclidean distance using a heterogeneous set of objects, scenarios and initial situations.

Using GNG to improve 3D feature extraction—Application to 6DoF egomotion

Several recent works deal with 3D data in mobile robotic problems, e.g. mapping or egomotion. Data comes from any kind of sensor such as stereo vision systems, time of flight cameras or 3D lasers, providing a huge amount of unorganized 3D data. In this paper, we describe an efficient method to build complete 3D models from a Growing Neural Gas (GNG). The GNG is applied to the 3D raw data and it reduces both the subjacent error and the number of points, keeping the topology of the 3D data. The GNG output is then used in a 3D feature extraction method. We have performed a deep study in which we quantitatively show that the use of GNG improves the 3D feature extraction method. We also show that our method can be applied to any kind of 3D data. The 3D features obtained are used as input in an Iterative Closest Point (ICP)-like method to compute the 6DoF movement performed by a mobile robot. A comparison with standard ICP is performed, showing that the use of GNG improves the results. Final results of 3D mapping from the egomotion calculated are also shown.

Combining visual features and Growing Neural Gas networks for robotic 3D SLAM

The use of 3D data in mobile robotics provides valuable information about the robot’s environment. Traditionally, stereo cameras have been used as a low-cost 3D sensor. However, the lack of precision and texture for some surfaces suggests that the use of other 3D sensors could be more suitable. In this work, we examine the use of two sensors: an infrared SR4000 and a Kinect camera. We use a combination of 3D data obtained by these cameras, along with features obtained from 2D images acquired from these cameras, using a Growing Neural Gas (GNG) network applied to the 3D data. The goal is to obtain a robust egomotion technique. The GNG network is used to reduce the camera error. To calculate the egomotion, we test two methods for 3D registration. One is based on an iterative closest points algorithm, and the other employs random sample consensus. Finally, a simultaneous localization and mapping method is applied to the complete sequence to reduce the global error. The error from each sensor and the mapping results from the proposed method are examined.

Estudio y mejora de métodos de registro 3D: aceleración sobre unidades de procesamiento gráfico y caracterización del espacio de transformaciones iniciales

Durante los últimos años ha sido creciente el uso de las unidades de procesamiento gráfico, más conocidas como GPU (Graphic Processing Unit), en aplicaciones de propósito general, dejando a un lado el objetivo para el que fueron creadas y que no era otro que el renderizado de gráficos por computador. Este crecimiento se debe en parte a la evolución que han experimentado estos dispositivos durante este tiempo y que les ha dotado de gran potencia de cálculo, consiguiendo que su uso se extienda desde ordenadores personales a grandes cluster. Este hecho unido a la proliferación de sensores RGB-D de bajo coste ha hecho que crezca el número de aplicaciones de visión que hacen uso de esta tecnología para la resolución de problemas, así como también para el desarrollo de nuevas aplicaciones. Todas estas mejoras no solamente se han realizado en la parte hardware, es decir en los dispositivos, sino también en la parte software con la aparición de nuevas herramientas de desarrollo que facilitan la programación de estos dispositivos GPU. Este nuevo paradigma se acuñó como Computación de Propósito General sobre Unidades de Proceso Gráfico (General-Purpose computation on Graphics Processing Units, GPGPU). Los dispositivos GPU se clasifican en diferentes familias, en función de las distintas características hardware que poseen. Cada nueva familia que aparece incorpora nuevas mejoras tecnológicas que le permite conseguir mejor rendimiento que las anteriores. No obstante, para sacar un rendimiento óptimo a un dispositivo GPU es necesario configurarlo correctamente antes de usarlo. Esta configuración viene determinada por los valores asignados a una serie de parámetros del dispositivo. Por tanto, muchas de las implementaciones que hoy en día hacen uso de los dispositivos GPU para el registro denso de nubes de puntos 3D, podrían ver mejorado su rendimiento con una configuración óptima de dichos parámetros, en función del dispositivo utilizado. Es por ello que, ante la falta de un estudio detallado del grado de afectación de los parámetros GPU sobre el rendimiento final de una implementación, se consideró muy conveniente la realización de este estudio. Este estudio no sólo se realizó con distintas configuraciones de parámetros GPU, sino también con diferentes arquitecturas de dispositivos GPU. El objetivo de este estudio es proporcionar una herramienta de decisión que ayude a los desarrolladores a la hora implementar aplicaciones para dispositivos GPU. Uno de los campos de investigación en los que más prolifera el uso de estas tecnologías es el campo de la robótica ya que tradicionalmente en robótica, sobre todo en la robótica móvil, se utilizaban combinaciones de sensores de distinta naturaleza con un alto coste económico, como el láser, el sónar o el sensor de contacto, para obtener datos del entorno. Más tarde, estos datos eran utilizados en aplicaciones de visión por computador con un coste computacional muy alto. Todo este coste, tanto el económico de los sensores utilizados como el coste computacional, se ha visto reducido notablemente gracias a estas nuevas tecnologías. Dentro de las aplicaciones de visión por computador más utilizadas está el registro de nubes de puntos. Este proceso es, en general, la transformación de diferentes nubes de puntos a un sistema de coordenadas conocido. Los datos pueden proceder de fotografías, de diferentes sensores, etc. Se utiliza en diferentes campos como son la visión artificial, la imagen médica, el reconocimiento de objetos y el análisis de imágenes y datos de satélites. El registro se utiliza para poder comparar o integrar los datos obtenidos en diferentes mediciones. En este trabajo se realiza un repaso del estado del arte de los métodos de registro 3D. Al mismo tiempo, se presenta un profundo estudio sobre el método de registro 3D más utilizado, Iterative Closest Point (ICP), y una de sus variantes más conocidas, Expectation-Maximization ICP (EMICP). Este estudio contempla tanto su implementación secuencial como su implementación paralela en dispositivos GPU, centrándose en cómo afectan a su rendimiento las distintas configuraciones de parámetros GPU. Como consecuencia de este estudio, también se presenta una propuesta para mejorar el aprovechamiento de la memoria de los dispositivos GPU, permitiendo el trabajo con nubes de puntos más grandes, reduciendo el problema de la limitación de memoria impuesta por el dispositivo. El funcionamiento de los métodos de registro 3D utilizados en este trabajo depende en gran medida de la inicialización del problema. En este caso, esa inicialización del problema consiste en la correcta elección de la matriz de transformación con la que se iniciará el algoritmo. Debido a que este aspecto es muy importante en este tipo de algoritmos, ya que de él depende llegar antes o no a la solución o, incluso, no llegar nunca a la solución, en este trabajo se presenta un estudio sobre el espacio de transformaciones con el objetivo de caracterizarlo y facilitar la elección de la transformación inicial a utilizar en estos algoritmos.

A robust and fast method for 6DoF motion estimation from generalized 3D data

Nowadays, there is an increasing number of robotic applications that need to act in real three-dimensional (3D) scenarios. In this paper we present a new mobile robotics orientated 3D registration method that improves previous Iterative Closest Points based solutions both in speed and accuracy. As an initial step, we perform a low cost computational method to obtain descriptions for 3D scenes planar surfaces. Then, from these descriptions we apply a force system in order to compute accurately and efficiently a six degrees of freedom egomotion. We describe the basis of our approach and demonstrate its validity with several experiments using different kinds of 3D sensors and different 3D real environments.

A new approach for semi-automatic rock mass joints recognition from 3D point clouds

Rock mass characterization requires a deep geometric understanding of the discontinuity sets affecting rock exposures. Recent advances in Light Detection and Ranging (LiDAR) instrumentation currently allow quick and accurate 3D data acquisition, yielding on the development of new methodologies for the automatic characterization of rock mass discontinuities. This paper presents a methodology for the identification and analysis of flat surfaces outcropping in a rocky slope using the 3D data obtained with LiDAR. This method identifies and defines the algebraic equations of the different planes of the rock slope surface by applying an analysis based on a neighbouring points coplanarity test, finding principal orientations by Kernel Density Estimation and identifying clusters by the Density-Based Scan Algorithm with Noise. Different sources of information —synthetic and 3D scanned data— were employed, performing a complete sensitivity analysis of the parameters in order to identify the optimal value of the variables of the proposed method. In addition, raw source files and obtained results are freely provided in order to allow to a more straightforward method comparison aiming to a more reproducible research.

A new betweenness centrality measure based on an algorithm for ranking the nodes of a network

We propose and discuss a new centrality index for urban street patterns represented as networks in geographical space. This centrality measure, that we call ranking-betweenness centrality, combines the idea behind the random-walk betweenness centrality measure and the idea of ranking the nodes of a network produced by an adapted PageRank algorithm. We initially use a PageRank algorithm in which we are able to transform some information of the network that we want to analyze into numerical values. Numerical values summarizing the information are associated to each of the nodes by means of a data matrix. After running the adapted PageRank algorithm, a ranking of the nodes is obtained, according to their importance in the network. This classification is the starting point for applying an algorithm based on the random-walk betweenness centrality. A detailed example of a real urban street network is discussed in order to understand the process to evaluate the ranking-betweenness centrality proposed, performing some comparisons with other classical centrality measures.

Algorithm for the detection of outliers based on the theory of rough sets

Outliers are objects that show abnormal behavior with respect to their context or that have unexpected values in some of their parameters. In decision-making processes, information quality is of the utmost importance. In specific applications, an outlying data element may represent an important deviation in a production process or a damaged sensor. Therefore, the ability to detect these elements could make the difference between making a correct and an incorrect decision. This task is complicated by the large sizes of typical databases. Due to their importance in search processes in large volumes of data, researchers pay special attention to the development of efficient outlier detection techniques. This article presents a computationally efficient algorithm for the detection of outliers in large volumes of information. This proposal is based on an extension of the mathematical framework upon which the basic theory of detection of outliers, founded on Rough Set Theory, has been constructed. From this starting point, current problems are analyzed; a detection method is proposed, along with a computational algorithm that allows the performance of outlier detection tasks with an almost-linear complexity. To illustrate its viability, the results of the application of the outlier-detection algorithm to the concrete example of a large database are presented.