Captured by conventions : On objectivity and factuality in international news agency discourse

The thesis explores the discourse of two global news agencies, the Associated Press (AP) and Reuters, which together with the French AFP are generally regarded as the world s leading news distributors. A glance at the guidelines given by AP and Reuters to their journalists shows that these two news agencies make a lot of effort to strive for objectivity the well-known journalistic ideal, which, however, is an almost indefinable concept. In journalism textbooks definitions of objectivity often contain various components: detachment, nonpartisanship, facticity, balance, etc. AP and Reuters, too, in their guidelines, present several other ideals besides objectivity , viz., reliability, accuracy, balance, freedom from bias, precise sourcing, reporting the truth, and so on. Other central concepts connected to objectivity are neutrality and impartiality. However, objectivity is, undoubtedly, the term that is most often mentioned when the ethics of journalism is discussed, acting as a kind of umbrella term for several related journalistic ideals. It can even encompass the other concept that is relevant for this study, that of factuality. These two intertwined concepts are extremely complex; paradoxically, it is easier to show evidence of the lack of objectivity or factuality than of their existence. I argue that when journalists conform to the deep-rooted conventions of objective news reporting, facts may be blurred, and the language becomes vague and ambiguous. As global distributors of news, AP and Reuters have had an influential role in creating and reinforcing conventions of (at least English-language) news writing. These conventions can be seen to work at various levels of news reporting: the ideological (e.g., defining what is regarded as newsworthy, or who is responsible), structural (e.g., the well-known inverted pyramid model), and stylistic (e.g., presupposing that in hard news reports, the journalist s voice should be backgrounded). On the basis of my case studies, I have found four central conventions to be worthy of closer examination: the conventional structure of news reports, the importance of newsworthiness, the tactics of impersonalisation which tends to blur news actors responsibility, and the routines of presenting emotions. My linguistic analyses draw mainly on M.A.K. Halliday s Systemic Functional Grammar, on notions of transitivity, ergativity, nominalisation and grammatical metaphor. The Appraisal framework, too, has provided useful tools for my analyses. The thesis includes six case studies dealing with the following topics: metaphors in political reporting, terrorism discourse, terrorism fears, emotions more generally, unnamed sources as rhetorical constructs, and responsibility in the convention of attribution.

The Negative News Threshold - an Explanation for Negative Skewness in Stock Returns

A vast literature documents negative skewness and excess kurtosis in stock return distributions on several markets. We approach the issue of negative skewness from a different angle than in previous studies by suggesting a model, which we denote the “negative news threshold” hypothesis, that builds on asymmetrically distributed information and symmetric market responses. Our empirical tests reveal that returns for days when non-scheduled news are disclosed are the source of negative skewness in stock returns. This finding lends solid support to our model and suggests that negative skewness in stock returns is induced by asymmetries in the news disclosure policies of firm management.

Intraday Seasonalities and Macroeconomic News Announcements

Using a data set consisting of three years of 5-minute intraday stock index returns for major European stock indices and U.S. macroeconomic surprises, the conditional mean and volatility behaviors in European market were investigated. The findings suggested that the opening of the U.S market significantly raised the level of volatility in Europe, and that all markets respond in an identical fashion. Furthermore, the U.S. macroeconomic surprises exerted an immediate and major impact on both European stock markets’ returns and volatilities. Thus, high frequency data appear to be critical for the identification of news that impacted the markets.

Alternative News Sources as 'Collaboratory' Journalism. A case study of Helsingin Sanomat and its relation with the Youth Voice Editorial Board

The new paradigm of connectedness and empowerment brought by the interactivity feature of the Web 2.0 has been challenging the traditional centralized performance of mainstream media. The corporation has been able to survive the strong winds by transforming itself into a global multimedia business network embedded in the network society. By establishing networks, e.g. networks of production and distribution, the global multimedia business network has been able to sight potential solutions by opening the doors to innovation in a decentralized and flexible manner. Under this emerging context of re-organization, traditional practices like sourcing need to be re- explained and that is precisely what this thesis attempts to tackle. Based on ICT and on the network society, the study seeks to explain within the Finnish context the particular case of Helsingin Sanomat (HS) and its relations with the youth news agency, Youth Voice Editorial Board (NÄT). In that sense, the study can be regarded as an explanatory embedded single case study, where HS is the principal unit of analysis and NÄT its embedded unit of analysis. The thesis was able to reach explanations through interrelated steps. First, it determined the role of ICT in HS’s sourcing practices. Then it mapped an overview of the HS’s sourcing relations and provided a context in which NÄT was located. And finally, it established conceptualized institutional relational data between HS and NÄT for their posterior measurement through social network analysis. The data set was collected via qualitative interviews addressed to online and offline editors of HS as well as interviews addressed to NÄT’s personnel. The study concluded that ICT’s interactivity and User Generated Content (UGC) are not sourcing tools as such but mechanism used by HS for getting ideas that could turn into potential news stories. However, when it comes to visual communication, some exemptions were found. The lack of official sources amidst the immediacy leads HS to rely on ICT’s interaction and UGC. More than meets the eye, ICT’s input into the sourcing practice may be more noticeable if the interaction and UGC is well organized and coordinated into proper and innovative networks of alternative content collaboration. Currently, HS performs this sourcing practice via two projects that differ, precisely, by the mode they are coordinated. The first project found, Omakaupunki, is coordinated internally by Sanoma Group’s owned media houses HS, Vartti and Metro. The second project found is coordinated externally. The external alternative sourcing network, as it was labeled, consists of three actors, namely HS, NÄT (professionals in charge) and the youth. This network is a balanced and complete triad in which the actors connect themselves in relations of feedback, recognition, creativity and filtering. However, as innovation is approached very reluctantly, this content collaboration is a laboratory of experiments; a ‘COLLABORATORY’.

News Media, Crime and Fear of Violence

Finland witnessed a surge in crime news reporting during the 1990s. At the same time, there was a significant rise in the levels of fear of crime reported by surveys. This research examines whether and how the two phenomena: news media and fear of violence were associated with each other. The dissertation consists of five sub-studies and a summary article. The first sub-study is a review of crime reporting trends in Finland, in which I have reviewed prior research and used existing Finnish datasets on media contents and crime news media exposure. The second study examines the association between crime media consumption and fear of crime when personal and vicarious victimization experiences have been held constant. Apart from analyzing the impact of crime news consumption on fear, media effects on general social trust are analyzed in the third sub-study. In the fourth sub-study I have analyzed the contents of the Finnish Poliisi-TV programme and compared the consistency of the picture of violent crime between official data sources and the programme. In the fifth and final sub-study, the victim narratives of Poliisi-TV s violence news contents have been analyzed. The research provides a series of results which are unprecedented in Finland. First, it observes that as in many other countries, the quantity of crime news supply has increased quite markedly in Finland. Second, it verifies that exposure to crime news is related to being worried about violent victimization and avoidance behaviour. Third, it documents that exposure to TV crime reality-programming is associated with reduced social trust among Finnish adolescents. Fourth, the analysis of Poliisi-TV shows that it transmits a distorted view of crime when contrasted with primary data sources on crime, but that this distortion is not as big as could be expected from international research findings and epochal theories of sociology. Fifth, the portrayals of violence victims in Poliisi-TV do not fit the traditional ideal types of victims that are usually seen to dominate crime media. The fact that the victims of violence in Poliisi-TV are ordinary people represents a wider development of the changing significance of the crime victim in Finland. The research concludes that although the media most likely did have an effect on the rising public fears in the 1990s, the mechanism was not as straight forward as has often been claimed. It is likely that there are other factors in the fear-media equation that are affecting both fear levels and crime reporting and that these factors are interactive in nature. Finally, the research calls for a re-orientation of media criminology and suggests more emphasis on the positive implications of crime in the media. Keywords: crime, media, fear of crime, violence, victimization, news

Ketoprofeenin biologinen käytettävyys ja farmakokinetiikka sioilla eri antotavoilla ja ketoprofeeniyliannoksen farmakokinetiikka ja vaikutus munuaisiin lampailla

Ketoprofeeni on yleisesti käytetty ei-steroidinen tulehduskipulääke (NSAID) lampaiden ja sikojen kivunlievityksessä. Tietoa ketoprofeenin oikeista annosmääristä eri eläinlajeilla on saatavilla rajallisesti. Oikeaa lääkeainemäärää ei voida luotettavasti ekstrapoloida toisten eläinlajien tai ihmisten perusteella. Epäillyissä tulehduskipulääkemyrkytyksissä ongelmana on tietää, oliko eläimen saama lääkeannos toksinen. Lampailla tehdyn tutkimuksen tavoitteena oli selvittää, muuttuuko ketoprofeenin kinetiikka kymmenkertaisella yliannoksella, tutkia yliannoksen vaikutusta munuaisiin ja löytää yksinkertainen tapa diagnosoida yliannos virtsasta. Sioilla tehdyn tutkimuksen tavoitteena oli selvittää ketoprofeenin biologista käytettävyyttä ja ketoprofeenin farmakokinetiikkaa sioilla intravaskulaarisella, intramuskulaarisella ja peroraalisella annolla. Keskeiset tutkimuksessa määritettävät muuttujat olivat AUC0-_, Cmax ja tmax. Hyötyosuus laskettiin i.v. -annon perusteella. Kuudelle lampaalle annettiin 30 mg/kg i.v. -ketoprofeenia. Ketoprofeenin pitoisuuksia seurattiin 24 tunnin ajan plasmanäytteillä, joiden perusteella määritettiin farmakokineettiset parametrit. Veri- ja virtsanäytteistä tutkittiin muun muassa mahdollisesta munuaisvauriosta kertovia entsyymejä. 24 tunnin kuluttua lääkkeenannosta lampaat lopetettiin ja munuaiset tutkittiin histologisesti. Tutkittaville kahdeksalle sialle annosteltiin 3 mg/kg intravaskulaarista, intramuskulaarista ja oraalista ketoprofeenia sekä 6 mg/kg oraalista ketoprofeenia. Tutkimus suoritettiin satunnaistettuna vaihtovuorotutkimuksena. Ketoprofeenin pitoisuuksia seurattiin plasmanäytteillä 48 tunnin ajan lääkkeenannosta ja kaikille antotavoille laskettiin farmakokineettiset parametrit. Lisäksi tutkittiin valmisteiden biologinen samanarvoisuus. Molempien tutkimusten in vivo -kokeet suoritettiin Eläinlääketieteellisessä tiedekunnassa. Samoin munuaisten histologinen tutkimus ja virtsasta ja verestä tehdyt määritykset, lukuun ottamatta ketoprofeeninpitoisuuden analysointia. Plasman ketoprofeenipitoisuus analysoitiin korkean erotuskyvyn nestekromatografialla (HPLC). Ketoprofeenimääritykset ja farmakokineettinen analyysi suoritettiin Farmasian tiedekunnassa. Lampaiden kymmenkertainen ketoprofeeniyliannos oli toksinen. Seerumin urea- ja kreatiniinipitoisuus nousivat ja histologisissa näytteissä näkyi akuutti munuaistiehyen vaurio. Useiden entsyymien pitoisuus nousi virtsassa. Selvimmin ja nopeimmin nousi virtsan laktaattidehydrogenaasipitoisuus, jonka määrittäminen vaikuttaa potentiaaliselta tavalta diagnosoida ketoprofeenin toksinen annos. Ketoprofeenin eliminaation puoliintumisaika toksisella annoksella oli samaa suuruusluokkaa kuin aiemmissa tutkimuksissa terapeuttisella annoksella, joten yliannos ei muuttanut ketoprofeenin kinetiikkaa. AUC- ja Cmax -arvot olivat suhteessa suurempia kuin terapeuttisella annoksella, joten tutkimuksen perusteella kyseiset arvot eivät nousseet lineaarisesti annoksen noustessa toksiseksi. Sioille annetut ketoprofeenivalmisteet eivät olleet biologisesti samanarvoisia keskenään. Hyötyosuus oli erittäin hyvä kaikilla antotavoilla. tmax oli kaikilla antotavoilla hieman yli tunnin kuluttua lääkkeenannosta. Oraalisen 3 mg/kg -annoksen Cmax oli 5,1 mg/l ja AUC 32 mg l-1 h ja intramuskulaarisen vastaavat arvot olivat 7,6 mg/l ja 37 mg l-1 h. Oraalisen ketoprofeenin annostasojen AUC- ja Cmax -arvot korreloivat keskenään, joten ketoprofeenin kinetiikka oli lineaarista. Intravaskulaarisen ja oraalisen annon puoliintumisajoissa oli tilastollisesti merkitsevä ero. Ketoprofeenin jakautumistilavuudessa ja puhdistumassa ei ollut tilastollisesti merkitsevää eroa eri antotapojen välillä.

Silva Fennica Vol. 24, 1990.

Julkaistu Silva Fennica Vol. 24(4) -numeron liitteenä.