MOVPE growth of III-V semiconductors on silicon for third generation solar cells

Esta Tesis trata sobre el desarrollo y crecimiento -mediante tecnología MOVPE (del inglés: MetalOrganic Vapor Phase Epitaxy)- de células solares híbridas de semiconductores III-V sobre substratos de silicio. Esta integración pretende ofrecer una alternativa a las células actuales de III-V, que, si bien ostentan el récord de eficiencia en dispositivos fotovoltaicos, su coste es, a día de hoy, demasiado elevado para ser económicamente competitivo frente a las células convencionales de silicio. De este modo, este proyecto trata de conjugar el potencial de alta eficiencia ya demostrado por los semiconductores III-V en arquitecturas de células fotovoltaicas multiunión con el bajo coste, la disponibilidad y la abundancia del silicio. La integración de semiconductores III-V sobre substratos de silicio puede afrontarse a través de diferentes aproximaciones. En esta Tesis se ha optado por el desarrollo de células solares metamórficas de doble unión de GaAsP/Si. Mediante esta técnica, la transición entre los parámetros de red de ambos materiales se consigue por medio de la formación de defectos cristalográficos (mayoritariamente dislocaciones). La idea es confinar estos defectos durante el crecimiento de sucesivas capas graduales en composición para que la superficie final tenga, por un lado, una buena calidad estructural, y por otro, un parámetro de red adecuado. Numerosos grupos de investigación han dirigido sus esfuerzos en los últimos años en desarrollar una estructura similar a la que aquí proponemos. La mayoría de éstos se han centrado en entender los retos asociados al crecimiento de materiales III-V, con el fin de conseguir un material de alta calidad cristalográfica. Sin embargo, prácticamente ninguno de estos grupos ha prestado especial atención al desarrollo y optimización de la célula inferior de silicio, cuyo papel va a ser de gran relevancia en el funcionamiento de la célula completa. De esta forma, y con el fin de completar el trabajo hecho hasta el momento en el desarrollo de células de III-V sobre silicio, la presente Tesis se centra, fundamentalmente, en el diseño y optimización de la célula inferior de silicio, para extraer su máximo potencial. Este trabajo se ha estructurado en seis capítulos, ordenados de acuerdo al desarrollo natural de la célula inferior. Tras un capítulo de introducción al crecimiento de semiconductores III-V sobre Si, en el que se describen las diferentes alternativas para su integración; nos ocupamos de la parte experimental, comenzando con una extensa descripción y caracterización de los substratos de silicio. De este modo, en el Capítulo 2 se analizan con exhaustividad los diferentes tratamientos (tanto químicos como térmicos) que deben seguir éstos para garantizar una superficie óptima sobre la que crecer epitaxialmente el resto de la estructura. Ya centrados en el diseño de la célula inferior, el Capítulo 3 aborda la formación de la unión p-n. En primer lugar se analiza qué configuración de emisor (en términos de dopaje y espesor) es la más adecuada para sacar el máximo rendimiento de la célula inferior. En este primer estudio se compara entre las diferentes alternativas existentes para la creación del emisor, evaluando las ventajas e inconvenientes que cada aproximación ofrece frente al resto. Tras ello, se presenta un modelo teórico capaz de simular el proceso de difusión de fosforo en silicio en un entorno MOVPE por medio del software Silvaco. Mediante este modelo teórico podemos determinar qué condiciones experimentales son necesarias para conseguir un emisor con el diseño seleccionado. Finalmente, estos modelos serán validados y constatados experimentalmente mediante la caracterización por técnicas analíticas (i.e. ECV o SIMS) de uniones p-n con emisores difundidos. Uno de los principales problemas asociados a la formación del emisor por difusión de fósforo, es la degradación superficial del substrato como consecuencia de su exposición a grandes concentraciones de fosfina (fuente de fósforo). En efecto, la rugosidad del silicio debe ser minuciosamente controlada, puesto que éste servirá de base para el posterior crecimiento epitaxial y por tanto debe presentar una superficie prístina para evitar una degradación morfológica y cristalográfica de las capas superiores. En este sentido, el Capítulo 4 incluye un análisis exhaustivo sobre la degradación morfológica de los substratos de silicio durante la formación del emisor. Además, se proponen diferentes alternativas para la recuperación de la superficie con el fin de conseguir rugosidades sub-nanométricas, que no comprometan la calidad del crecimiento epitaxial. Finalmente, a través de desarrollos teóricos, se establecerá una correlación entre la degradación morfológica (observada experimentalmente) con el perfil de difusión del fósforo en el silicio y por tanto, con las características del emisor. Una vez concluida la formación de la unión p-n propiamente dicha, se abordan los problemas relacionados con el crecimiento de la capa de nucleación de GaP. Por un lado, esta capa será la encargada de pasivar la subcélula de silicio, por lo que su crecimiento debe ser regular y homogéneo para que la superficie de silicio quede totalmente pasivada, de tal forma que la velocidad de recombinación superficial en la interfaz GaP/Si sea mínima. Por otro lado, su crecimiento debe ser tal que minimice la aparición de los defectos típicos de una heteroepitaxia de una capa polar sobre un substrato no polar -denominados dominios de antifase-. En el Capítulo 5 se exploran diferentes rutinas de nucleación, dentro del gran abanico de posibilidades existentes, para conseguir una capa de GaP con una buena calidad morfológica y estructural, que será analizada mediante diversas técnicas de caracterización microscópicas. La última parte de esta Tesis está dedicada al estudio de las propiedades fotovoltaicas de la célula inferior. En ella se analiza la evolución de los tiempos de vida de portadores minoritarios de la base durante dos etapas claves en el desarrollo de la estructura Ill-V/Si: la formación de la célula inferior y el crecimiento de las capas III-V. Este estudio se ha llevado a cabo en colaboración con la Universidad de Ohio, que cuentan con una gran experiencia en el crecimiento de materiales III-V sobre silicio. Esta tesis concluye destacando las conclusiones globales del trabajo realizado y proponiendo diversas líneas de trabajo a emprender en el futuro. ABSTRACT This thesis pursues the development and growth of hybrid solar cells -through Metal Organic Vapor Phase Epitaxy (MOVPE)- formed by III-V semiconductors on silicon substrates. This integration aims to provide an alternative to current III-V cells, which, despite hold the efficiency record for photovoltaic devices, their cost is, today, too high to be economically competitive to conventional silicon cells. Accordingly, the target of this project is to link the already demonstrated efficiency potential of III-V semiconductor multijunction solar cell architectures with the low cost and unconstrained availability of silicon substrates. Within the existing alternatives for the integration of III-V semiconductors on silicon substrates, this thesis is based on the metamorphic approach for the development of GaAsP/Si dual-junction solar cells. In this approach, the accommodation of the lattice mismatch is handle through the appearance of crystallographic defects (namely dislocations), which will be confined through the incorporation of a graded buffer layer. The resulting surface will have, on the one hand a good structural quality; and on the other hand the desired lattice parameter. Different research groups have been working in the last years in a structure similar to the one here described, being most of their efforts directed towards the optimization of the heteroepitaxial growth of III-V compounds on Si, with the primary goal of minimizing the appearance of crystal defects. However, none of these groups has paid much attention to the development and optimization of the bottom silicon cell, which, indeed, will play an important role on the overall solar cell performance. In this respect, the idea of this thesis is to complete the work done so far in this field by focusing on the design and optimization of the bottom silicon cell, to harness its efficiency. This work is divided into six chapters, organized according to the natural progress of the bottom cell development. After a brief introduction to the growth of III-V semiconductors on Si substrates, pointing out the different alternatives for their integration; we move to the experimental part, which is initiated by an extensive description and characterization of silicon substrates -the base of the III-V structure-. In this chapter, a comprehensive analysis of the different treatments (chemical and thermal) required for preparing silicon surfaces for subsequent epitaxial growth is presented. Next step on the development of the bottom cell is the formation of the p-n junction itself, which is faced in Chapter 3. Firstly, the optimization of the emitter configuration (in terms of doping and thickness) is handling by analytic models. This study includes a comparison between the different alternatives for the emitter formation, evaluating the advantages and disadvantages of each approach. After the theoretical design of the emitter, it is defined (through the modeling of the P-in-Si diffusion process) a practical parameter space for the experimental implementation of this emitter configuration. The characterization of these emitters through different analytical tools (i.e. ECV or SIMS) will validate and provide experimental support for the theoretical models. A side effect of the formation of the emitter by P diffusion is the roughening of the Si surface. Accordingly, once the p-n junction is formed, it is necessary to ensure that the Si surface is smooth enough and clean for subsequent phases. Indeed, the roughness of the Si must be carefully controlled since it will be the basis for the epitaxial growth. Accordingly, after quantifying (experimentally and by theoretical models) the impact of the phosphorus on the silicon surface morphology, different alternatives for the recovery of the surface are proposed in order to achieve a sub-nanometer roughness which does not endanger the quality of the incoming III-V layers. Moving a step further in the development of the Ill-V/Si structure implies to address the challenges associated to the GaP on Si nucleation. On the one hand, this layer will provide surface passivation to the emitter. In this sense, the growth of the III-V layer must be homogeneous and continuous so the Si emitter gets fully passivated, providing a minimal surface recombination velocity at the interface. On the other hand, the growth should be such that the appearance of typical defects related to the growth of a polar layer on a non-polar substrate is minimized. Chapter 5 includes an exhaustive study of the GaP on Si nucleation process, exploring different nucleation routines for achieving a high morphological and structural quality, which will be characterized by means of different microscopy techniques. Finally, an extensive study of the photovoltaic properties of the bottom cell and its evolution during key phases in the fabrication of a MOCVD-grown III-V-on-Si epitaxial structure (i.e. the formation of the bottom cell; and the growth of III-V layers) will be presented in the last part of this thesis. This study was conducted in collaboration with The Ohio State University, who has extensive experience in the growth of III-V materials on silicon. This thesis concludes by highlighting the overall conclusions of the presented work and proposing different lines of work to be undertaken in the future.

Effect of field damping layer on two step absorption of quantum dots solar cells

Multi-stacked InAs/AlGaAs quantum dot solar cells (QDSCs) introduced with field damping layers (FDL) which sustain the junction built-in potential have been studied. Without an external bias condition, the external quantum efficiency (EQE) of QD layers are reduced by introducing the thick FDL, because the carrier escape due to built-in electric field was suppressed. On the other hand, the photocurrent production due to two-step absorption is increased by the formation of flat-band QD structure for QDSC with thick FDL.

Component integration strategies in metamorphic 4-junction III-V concentrator solar cells

Progressing beyond 3-junction inverted-metamorphic multijunction solar cells grown on GaAs substrates, to 4-junction devices, requires the development of high quality metamorphic 0.7 eV GaInAs solar cells. Once accomplished, the integration of this subcell into a full, Monolithic, series connected, 4J-IMM structure demands the development of a metamorphic tunnel junction lattice matched to the 1eV GaInAs subcell. Moreover, the 0.7 eV junction adds about 2 hours of growth time to the structure, implying a heavier annealing of the subcells and tunnel junctions grown first. The final 4J structure is above 20 Pm thick, with about half of this thickness used by the metamorphic buffers required to change the lattice constant throughout the structure. Thinning of these buffers would help reduce the total thickness of the 4J structure to decrease its growth cost and the annealing time. These three topics: development of a metamorphic tunnel junction for the 4th junction, analysis of the annealing, and thinning of the structure, are tackled in this work. The results presented show the successful implementation of an antimonide-based tunnel junction for the 4th junction and of pathways to mitigate the impact of annealing and reduce the thickness of the metamorphic buffers.

Highly conductive p++-AlGaAs/n++-GaInP tunnel junctions for operation up to 15,000 suns in concentrator solar cells

In the last few decades there has been great interest in III-V multijunction solar cells (MJSC) for concentrator applications due to their promise to significantly reduce the cost of electricity. Being formed by series connection of several solar cells with different bandgaps, a key role in a MJSC structure is played by the tunnel junctions (TJ) aimed to implement such series connection. Essentially, tunnel junctions (tunnel diodes or Esaki diodes) are thin, heavily doped p-n junctions where quantum tunneling plays a key role as a conduction mechanism. Such devices were discovered by Nobel laureate Leo Esaki at the end of 1950. The key feature of tunnel junctions for their application in MJSC is that, as long as quantum tunneling is the dominant conduction mechanism, they exhibit a linear I-V dependence until the peak tunneling current (Jp) is reached. This initial ohmic region in the I-V curve is ideal for implementing low-loss interconnections between the subcells with different energy bandgaps that constitute a MJSC.

Preliminary temperature accelerated life test (ALT) on lattice mismatched triple-junction concentrator solar cells-on-carriers

A temperature accelerated life test on concentrator lattice mismatched Ga0.37In0.63P/Ga0.83In0.17As/Ge triple-junction solar cells-on-carrier is being carried out. The solar cells have been tested at three different temperatures: 125, 145 and 165°C and the nominal photo-current condition (500X) is emulated by injecting current in darkness. The final objective of these tests is to evaluate the reliability, warranty period, and failure mechanism of these solar cells in a moderate period of time. Up to now only the test at 165°C has finished. Therefore, we cannot provide complete reliability information, but we have carried out preliminary data and failure analysis with the current results.

3-D modeling of perimeter recombination in GaAs diodes and its influence on concentrator solar cells

This paper describes a complete modelling of the perimeter recombination of GaAs diodes which solves most unknowns and suppresses the limitations of previous models. Because of the three dimensional nature of the implemented model, it is able to simulate real devices. GaAs diodes on two epiwafers with different base doping levels, sizes and geometries, namely square and circular are manufactured. The validation of the model is achieved by fitting the experimental measurements of the dark IV curve of the manufactured GaAs diodes. A comprehensive 3-D description of the occurring phenomena affecting the perimeter recombination is supplied with the help of the model. Finally, the model is applied to concentrator GaAs solar cells to assess the impact of their doping level, size and geometry on the perimeter recombination.

Impact of metal-organic vapor phase epitaxy environment on silicon bulk lifetime for III–V-on-Si multijunction solar cells

With the final goal of integrating III-V materials on silicon substrates for tandem solar cells, the influence of the Metal-Organic Vapor Phase Epitaxy (MOVPE) environment on the minority carrier properties of silicon wafers has been evaluated. These properties will essentially determine the photovoltaic performance of the bottom cell in a III-V-on-Si tandem solar cell. A comparison of the base minority carrier lifetimes obtained for different thermal processes carried out in a MOVPE reactor on Czochralski silicon wafers has been carried out. An important degradation of minority carrier lifetime during the surface preparation (i.e. H2 anneal) has been observed. Three different mechanisms have been proposed for explaining this behavior: 1) the introduction of extrinsic impurities coming from the reactor; 2) the activation of intrinsic lifetime killing impurities coming from the wafer itself; and finally, 3) the formation of crystal defects, which eventually become recombination centers. The effect of the emitter formation by phosphorus diffusion has also been evaluated. In this sense, it has been reported that lifetime can be recovered during the emitter formation either by the effect of the P on extracting impurities, or by the role of the atomic hydrogen on passivating the defects.

New strategies in laser processing of TCOs for light management improvement in thin-film silicon solar cells

Light confinement strategies play a crucial role in the performance of thin-film (TF) silicon solar cells. One way to reduce the optical losses is the texturing of the transparent conductive oxide (TCO) that acts as the front contact. Other losses arise from the mismatch between the incident light spectrum and the spectral properties of the absorbent material that imply that low energy photons (below the bandgap value) are not absorbed, and therefore can not generate photocurrent. Up-conversion techniques, in which two sub-bandgap photons are combined to give one photon with a better matching with the bandgap, were proposed to overcome this problem. In particular, this work studies two strategies to improve light management in thin film silicon solar cells using laser technology. The first one addresses the problem of TCO surface texturing using fully commercial fast and ultrafast solid state laser sources. Aluminum doped Zinc Oxide (AZO) samples were laser processed and the results were optically evaluated by measuring the haze factor of the treated samples. As a second strategy, laser annealing experiments of TCOs doped with rare earth ions are presented as a potential process to produce layers with up-conversion properties, opening the possibility of its potential use in high efficiency solar cells.

Material requirements for the adoption of unconventional silicon crystal and wafer growth techniques for high-efficiency solar cells

Silicon wafers comprise approximately 40% of crystalline silicon module cost, and represent an area of great technological innovation potential. Paradoxically, unconventional wafer-growth techniques have thus far failed to displace multicrystalline and Czochralski silicon, despite four decades of innovation. One of the shortcomings of most unconventional materials has been a persistent carrier lifetime deficit in comparison to established wafer technologies, which limits the device efficiency potential. In this perspective article, we review a defect-management framework that has proven successful in enabling millisecond lifetimes in kerfless and cast materials. Control of dislocations and slowly diffusing metal point defects during growth, coupled to effective control of fast-diffusing species during cell processing, is critical to enable high cell efficiencies. To accelerate the pace of novel wafer development, we discuss approaches to rapidly evaluate the device efficiency potential of unconventional wafers from injection-dependent lifetime measurements.

Four-Band Hamiltonian for fast calculations in intermediate-band solar cells

The 8-dimensional Luttinger–Kohn–Pikus–Bir Hamiltonian matrix may be made up of four 4-dimensional blocks. A 4-band Hamiltonian is presented, obtained from making the non-diagonal blocks zero. The parameters of the new Hamiltonian are adjusted to fit the calculated effective masses and strained QD bandgap with the measured ones. The 4-dimensional Hamiltonian thus obtained agrees well with measured quantum efficiency of a quantum dot intermediate band solar cell and the full absorption spectrum can be calculated in about two hours using Mathematica© and a notebook. This is a hundred times faster than with the commonly-used 8-band Hamiltonian and is considered suitable for helping design engineers in the development of nanostructured solar cells.

Temperature of solar cells with regard to photoactive and non-photoactive light absorption in concentrator PV modules

A new method has recently been proposed by us for accurate measurement of the solar cell temperature in any operational regime, in particular, at a maximum power point (MPP) of the I-V curve (T-p-n(MPP)). For this, fast switching of a cell from MPP to open circuit (OC) regime is carried out and open circuit voltage V-oc is measured immediately (within about 1 millisecond), so that this value becomes to be an indicator of T-p-n(MPP). In the present work, we have considered a practical case, when a solar cell is heated not only by absorption of light incident upon its surface (called "photoactive" absorption of power), but also by heat transferred from structural elements surrounding the cell and heated by absorption of direct or diffused sunlight ("non-photoactive" absorption of power with respect to a solar cell). This process takes place in any concentrator module with non-ideal concentrators. Low overheating temperature of the p-n junction (or p-n junctions in a multijunction cell) is a cumulative parameter characterizing the quality of a solar module by the factor of heat removal effectiveness and, at the same time, by the factor of low "non-photoactive" losses.

Demonstration of the operation principles of intermediate band solar cells at room temperature

In this work we report, for the first time at room temperature, experimental results that prove, simultaneously in the same device, the two main physical principles involved in the operation of intermediate band solar cells: (1) the production of sub-bandgap photocurrent by two optical transitions through the intermediate band; (2) the generation of an output voltage which is not limited by the photon energy absorption threshold. These principles, which had always required cryogenic temperatures to be evidenced all together, are now demonstrated at room temperature on an intermediate band solar cell based on InAs quantum dots with Al0.3Ga0.7As barriers.

Effect of Sb on the quantum efficiency of GaInP solar cells

The energy bandgap of GaInP solar cells can be tuned by modifying the degree of order of the alloy. In this study, we employed Sb to increase the energy bandgap of the GaInP and analyzed its impact on the performance of GaInP solar cells. An effective change in the cutoff wavelength of the external quantum efficiency of GaInP solar cells and an effective increase of 50 mV in the open-circuit voltage of GaInP/Ga(In)As/Ge triple junction solar cells were obtained with the use of Sb. Copyright © 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Generalized optoelectronic model of series-connected multijunction solar cells

The emission of light from each junction in a series-connected multijunction solar cell both complicates and elucidates the understanding of its performance under arbitrary conditions. Bringing together many recent advances in this understanding, we present a general 1-D model to describe luminescent coupling that arises from both voltage-driven electroluminescence and voltage-independent photoluminescence in nonideal junctions that include effects such as Sah-Noyce-Shockley (SNS) recombination with n ≠ 2, Auger recombination, shunt resistance, reverse-bias breakdown, series resistance, and significant dark area losses. The individual junction voltages and currents are experimentally determined from measured optical and electrical inputs and outputs of the device within the context of the model to fit parameters that describe the devices performance under arbitrary input conditions. Techniques to experimentally fit the model are demonstrated for a four-junction inverted metamorphic solar cell, and the predictions of the model are compared with concentrator flash measurements.

Energy yield determination of concentrator solar cells using laboratory measurements

The annual energy conversion efficiency is calculated for a four junction inverted metamorphic solar cell that has been completely characterized in the laboratory at room temperature using measurements fit to a comprehensive optoelectronic model of the multijunction solar cells. A simple model of the temperature dependence is used redict the performance of the solar cell under varying temperature and spectra characteristic of Golden, CO for an entire year. The annual energy conversion efficiency is calculated by integrating the predicted cell performance over the entire year. The effects of geometric concentration, CPV system thermal characteristics, and luminescent coupling are ighlighted.