Limits and tradeoffs in the control of autocatalytic systems

Despite the complexity of biological networks, we find that certain common architectures govern network structures. These architectures impose fundamental constraints on system performance and create tradeoffs that the system must balance in the face of uncertainty in the environment. This means that while a system may be optimized for a specific function through evolution, the optimal achievable state must follow these constraints. One such constraining architecture is autocatalysis, as seen in many biological networks including glycolysis and ribosomal protein synthesis. Using a minimal model, we show that ATP autocatalysis in glycolysis imposes stability and performance constraints and that the experimentally well-studied glycolytic oscillations are in fact a consequence of a tradeoff between error minimization and stability. We also show that additional complexity in the network results in increased robustness. Ribosome synthesis is also autocatalytic where ribosomes must be used to make more ribosomal proteins. When ribosomes have higher protein content, the autocatalysis is increased. We show that this autocatalysis destabilizes the system, slows down response, and also constrains the system’s performance. On a larger scale, transcriptional regulation of whole organisms also follows architectural constraints and this can be seen in the differences between bacterial and yeast transcription networks. We show that the degree distributions of bacterial transcription network follow a power law distribution while the yeast network follows an exponential distribution. We then explored the evolutionary models that have previously been proposed and show that neither the preferential linking model nor the duplication-divergence model of network evolution generates the power-law, hierarchical structure found in bacteria. However, in real biological systems, the generation of new nodes occurs through both duplication and horizontal gene transfers, and we show that a biologically reasonable combination of the two mechanisms generates the desired network.

Utp25p, a nucleolar Saccharomyces cerevisiae protein, interacts with U3 snoRNP subunits and affects processing of the 35S pre-rRNA

In eukaryotes, pre-rRNA processing depends on a large number of nonribosomal trans-acting factors that form intriguingly organized complexes. Two intermediate complexes, pre-40S and pre-60S, are formed at the early stages of 35S pre-rRNA processing and give rise to the mature ribosome subunits. Each of these complexes contains specific pre-rRNAs, some ribosomal proteins and processing factors. The novel yeast protein Utp25p has previously been identified in the nucleolus, an indication that this protein could be involved in ribosome biogenesis. Here we show that Utp25p interacts with the SSU processome proteins Sas10p and Mpp10p, and affects 18S rRNA maturation. Depletion of Utp25p leads to accumulation of the pre-rRNA 35S and the aberrant rRNA 23S, and to a severe reduction in 40S ribosomal subunit levels. Our results indicate that Utp25p is a novel SSU processome subunit involved in pre-40S maturation.

Yeast Rnt1p is required for cleavage of the pre-ribosomal RNA in the 3' ETS but not the 5' ETS

We have reexamined the role of yeast RNase III (Rnt1p) in ribosome synthesis. Analysis of pre-rRNA processing in a strain carrying a complete deletion of the RNT1 gene demonstrated that the absence of Rnt1p does not block cleavage at site A0 in the 5' external transcribed spacers (ETS), although the early pre-rRNA cleavages at sites A0, A1, and A2 are kinetically delayed. In contrast, cleavage in the 3' ETS is completely inhibited in the absence of Rnt1p, leading to the synthesis of a reduced level of a 3' extended form of the 25S rRNA. The 3' extended forms of the pre-rRNAs are consistent with the major termination at site T2 (+210). We conclude that Rnt1p is required for cleavage in the 3' ETS but not for cleavage at site A0. The sites of in vivo cleavage in the 3' ETS were mapped by primer extension. Two sites of Rnt1p-dependent cleavage were identified that lie on opposite sides of a predicted stem loop structure, at +14 and +49. These are in good agreement with the consensus Rnt1p cleavage site. Processing of the 3' end of the mature 25S rRNA sequence in wild-type cells was found to occur concomitantly with processing of the 5' end of the 5.8S rRNA, supporting previous proposals that processing in ITS1 and the 3' ETS is coupled.

Uses for JNK: the many and varied substrates of the c-Jun N-terminal kinases

The c-Jun N-terminal kinases (JNKs) are members of a larger group of serine/ threonine (Ser/Thr) protein kinases from the mitogen-activated protein kinase family. JNKs were originally identified as stress-activated protein kinases in the livers of cycloheximide-challenged rats. Their subsequent purification, cloning, and naming as JNKs have emphasized their ability to phosphorylate and activate the transcription factor c-Jun. Studies of c-Jun and related transcription factor substrates have provided clues about both the preferred substrate phosphorylation sequences and additional docking domains recognized by JNK There are now more than 50 proteins shown to be substrates for JNK These include a range of nuclear substrates, including transcription factors and nuclear hormone receptors, heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoprotein K and the Pol I-specific transcription factor TIF-IA, which regulates ribosome synthesis. Many nonnuclear substrates have also been characterized, and these are involved in protein degradation (e.g., the E3 ligase Itch), signal transduction (e.g., adaptor and scaffold proteins and protein kinases), apoptotic cell death (e.g., mitochondrial Bcl2 family members), and cell movement (e.g., paxillin, DCX, microtubule-associated proteins, the stathmin family member SCG10, and the intermediate filament protein keratin 8). The range of JNK actions in the cell is therefore likely to be complex. Further characterization of the substrates of JNK should provide clearer explanations of the intracellular actions of the JNKs and may allow new avenues for targeting the JNK pathways with therapeutic agents downstream of JNK itself.

Oligonucleotide-directed peptide synthesis in a ribosome- and ribozyme-free system

Peptide bond formation by the ribosome requires 23S rRNA and its interaction with the 3′-CCA end of tRNA. To investigate the possible evolutionary development of the peptidyl transfer reaction, we tried to obtain peptide bond formation without the ribosome or rRNA simply by using a piece of tRNA—an aminoacyl-minihelix—mixed with sequence-specific oligonucleotides that contained puromycin. Peptide bond formation was detected by gel electrophoresis, TLC analysis, and mass spectrometry. Peptide synthesis depended on sequence complementarity between the 3′-CCA sequence of the minihelix and the puromycin-bearing oligonucleotide. However, proximity of the reacting species was not by itself sufficient for peptide bond formation. In addition, imidazole as a catalyst was required. Its role may be similar to the recently proposed mechanism, wherein A2451 of 23S rRNA works as a general base. Thus, peptide bond formation can be achieved with a simple, minimized system that captures the essence of an interaction seen in the ribosome.

Fluctuations in protein synthesis from a single RNA template: Stochastic kinetics of ribosomes

Proteins are polymerized by cyclic machines called ribosomes, which use their messenger RNA (mRNA) track also as the corresponding template, and the process is called translation. We explore, in depth and detail, the stochastic nature of the translation. We compute various distributions associated with the translation process; one of them-namely, the dwell time distribution-has been measured in recent single-ribosome experiments. The form of the distribution, which fits best with our simulation data, is consistent with that extracted from the experimental data. For our computations, we use a model that captures both the mechanochemistry of each individual ribosome and their steric interactions. We also demonstrate the effects of the sequence inhomogeneities of real genes on the fluctuations and noise in translation. Finally, inspired by recent advances in the experimental techniques of manipulating single ribosomes, we make theoretical predictions on the force-velocity relation for individual ribosomes. In principle, all our predictions can be tested by carrying out in vitro experiments.

Impact of rRNA methylations on ribosome recycling and fidelity of initiation in Escherichia coli

Ribosomal RNA (rRNA) contains a number of modified nucleosides in functionally important regions including the intersubunit bridge regions. As the activity of ribosome recycling factor (RRF) in separating the large and the small subunits of the ribosome involves disruption of intersubunit bridges, we investigated the impact of rRNA methylations on ribosome recycling. We show that deficiency of rRNA methylations, especially at positions 1518 and 1519 of 16S rRNA near the interface with the 50S subunit and in the vicinity of the IF3 binding site, adversely affects the efficiency of RRF-mediated ribosome recycling. In addition, we show that a compromise in the RRF activity affords increased initiation with a mutant tRNA(fMet) wherein the three consecutive G-C base pairs ((29)GGG(31):39CCC41), a highly conserved feature of the initiator tRNAs, were mutated to those found in the elongator tRNA(Met) ((29)UCA(31):(39)psi GA(41)). This observation has allowed us to uncover a new role of RRF as a factor that contributes to fidelity of initiator tRNA selection on the ribosome. We discuss these and earlier findings to propose that RRF plays a crucial role during all the steps of protein synthesis.

Impact of resistance exercise on ribosome biogenesis is acutely regulated by post-exercise recovery strategies

Muscle hypertrophy occurs following increased protein synthesis, which requires activation of the ribosomal complex. Additionally, increased translational capacity via elevated ribosomal RNA (rRNA) synthesis has also been implicated in resistance training-induced skeletal muscle hypertrophy. The time course of ribosome biogenesis following resistance exercise (RE) and the impact exerted by differing recovery strategies remains unknown. In the present study, the activation of transcriptional regulators, the expression levels of pre-rRNA, and mature rRNA components were measured through 48 h after a single-bout RE. In addition, the effects of either low-intensity cycling (active recovery, ACT) or a cold-water immersion (CWI) recovery strategy were compared. Nine male subjects performed two bouts of high-load RE randomized to be followed by 10 min of either ACT or CWI. Muscle biopsies were collected before RE and at 2, 24, and 48 h after RE. RE increased the phosphorylation of the p38-MNK1-eIF4E axis, an effect only evident with ACT recovery. Downstream, cyclin D1 protein, total eIF4E, upstream binding factor 1 (UBF1), and c-Myc proteins were all increased only after RE with ACT. This corresponded with elevated abundance of the pre-rRNAs (45S, ITS-28S, ITS-5.8S, and ETS-18S) from 24 h after RE with ACT. In conclusion, coordinated upstream signaling and activation of transcriptional factors stimulated pre-rRNA expression after RE. CWI, as a recovery strategy, markedly blunted these events, suggesting that suppressed ribosome biogenesis may be one factor contributing to the impaired hypertrophic response observed when CWI is used regularly after exercise.

Effect of mutations on the p53 IRES RNA structure Implications for de-regulation of the synthesis of p53 isoforms

Earlier we have demonstrated the presence of internal ribosome entry site (IRES) within tumor suppressor p53 mRNA. Here we have mapped the putative secondary structure of p53-IRES RNA using information from chemical probing and nuclease mapping experiments. Additionally, the secondary structure of the IRES element of the wild-type RNA was compared with cancer-derived silent mutant p53 RNAs. These mutations might result in the conformational alterations of p53-IRES RNAs. The results also indicate decreased IRES activities of the mutants as compared to wild-type RNA. Further, it was observed that some of the cytoplasmic trans-acting factors, critical for enhancing IRES function, were unable to bind mutant RNAs as efficiently as to wild-type. Our results suggest that hnRNP C1/C2 binds to p53-IRES and siRNA mediated partial silencing of hnRNP C1/C2 showed appreciable decrease in IRES function and consequent decrease in the level of the corresponding p53 isoform. Interestingly mutant p53 IRES showed lesser binding with hnRNP C1/C2 protein. Finally, upon doxorubicin treatment, the mutant RNAs were unable to show enhanced p53 synthesis to similar extent compared to wild type. Taken together, these observations suggest that mutations occurring in the p53 IRES might have profound implications for de-regulation of its expression and activity.

Targeting ribosome assembly on the HCV RNA using a small RNA molecule

Translation initiation of hepatitis C virus (HCV) RNA is the initial obligatory step of the viral life cycle, mediated through the internal ribosome entry site (IRES) present in the 5'-untranslated region (UTR). Initiation on the HCV IRES is mediated by multiple structure-specific interactions between IRES RNA and host 40S ribosomal subunit. In the present study we demonstrate that the SLIIIef domain, in isolation from other structural elements of HCV IRES, retain the ability to interact with 40S ribosome subunit. A small RNA SLRef, mimicking the SLIIIef domain was found to interact specifically with human La protein and the ribosomal protein S5 and selectively inhibit HCV RNA translation. More importantly, SLRef RNA showed significant suppression of replication in HCV monocistronic replicon and decrease of negative strand synthesis in HCV cell culture system. Finally, using Sendai virus based virosome, the targeted delivery of SLRef RNA into mice liver succeeded in selectively inhibiting HCV IRES mediated translation in vivo.

Studies on rabbit reticulocyte ribosomes and polyribosomes and their relation to hemoglobin synthesis

This dissertation is divided into three parts.

The first section is concerned with protein synthesis in cellfree systems from reticulocytes. The sub-cellular reticulocyte fractions, reagents, etc. have been examined for the presence of traces of ribonuclease, using. an assay based upon the loss of infectivity of RNA fran bacteriophage MS2. This assay is sensitive to 5 x 10^-7 γ RNase/ml. In addition, the loss of synthetic capacity of an 80S ribosome on dissociation has been studied, and can be attributed to loss of messenger RNA when the monomer is separated into subunits. The presence of ribonuclease has been shown to be a major cause of polyribosome disintegration during cell-free protein synthesis.

The second section concerns the changes in ribosomes and polyribosomes which occur during the maturation of a reticulocyte into an erythrocyte. With increasing age, the cells lose a large proportion of the ribonucleoprotein, but the percentage of ribosomes present as polyribosomes is only slightly altered. The loss of hemoglobin synthesis on maturation is probably due to both the loss of total ribosomes and to the lessened specific activity of the polyribosomes.

The third section contains analytical ultracentrifugation data on 80S ribosomes, polyribosomes, and ribosomal RNA from reticulocytes. The 60s and 40s subunits, obtained by dissociation of the 80s particle with inorganic pyrophosphate, were also studied. The RNA from reticulocyte ribosomes has been examined under a variety of denaturing conditions, including dimethyl sulfoxide treatment, formaldehyde reaction and thermal denaturation. From these studies we can conclude that the 28S and 16S RNA's are single polynucleotide chains and are not made up of smaller RNA subunits hydrogen-bonded together.

Visualising ribosome profiling and using it for reading frame detection and exploration of eukaryotic translation initiation

Ribosome profiling (ribo-seq) is a recently developed technique that provides genomewide information on protein synthesis (GWIPS) in vivo. The high resolution of ribo-seq is one of the exciting properties of this technique. In Chapter 2, I present a computational method that utilises the sub-codon precision and triplet periodicity of ribosome profiling data to detect transitions in the translated reading frame. Application of this method to ribosome profiling data generated for human HeLa cells allowed us to detect several human genes where the same genomic segment is translated in more than one reading frame. Since the initial publication of the ribosome profiling technique in 2009, there has been a proliferation of studies that have used the technique to explore various questions with respect to translation. A review of the many uses and adaptations of the technique is provided in Chapter 1. Indeed, owing to the increasing popularity of the technique and the growing number of published ribosome profiling datasets, we have developed GWIPS-viz (http://gwips.ucc.ie), a ribo-seq dedicated genome browser. Details on the development of the browser and its usage are provided in Chapter 3. One of the surprising findings of ribosome profiling of initiating ribosomes carried out in 3 independent studies, was the widespread use of non-AUG codons as translation initiation start sites in mammals. Although initiation at non-AUG codons in mammals has been documented for some time, the extent of non-AUG initiation reported by these ribo-seq studies was unexpected. In Chapter 4, I present an approach for estimating the strength of initiating codons based on the leaky scanning model of translation initiation. Application of this approach to ribo-seq data illustrates that initiation at non-AUG codons is inefficient compared to initiation at AUG codons. In addition, our approach provides a probability of initiation score for each start site that allows its strength of initiation to be evaluated.

Androgens and estrogens stimulate ribosome biogenesis in prostate and breast cancer cells in receptor dependent manner

Ribosome biogenesis is a fundamental cellular process intimately linked to cell growth and proliferation, which is upregulated in most of cancers especially in aggressive cancers. In breast and prostate cancers steroid hormone receptor signalling is the principal stimulus for cancer growth and progression. Here we investigated the link between estrogen and androgen receptor signalling and the initial stage of ribosome biogenesis - transcription of rRNA genes. We have discovered that estrogen or androgen treatment can positively regulate rRNA synthesis in breast and prostate cancer cells respectively and that this effect is receptor dependent. This novel and interesting finding suggests a previously unidentified link between steroid hormone receptor signalling pathways and the regulation of ribosome biogenesis.

Investigation of the mechanism of repression of rRNA synthesis by an anticancer drug

Ribosome biogenesis is a fundamental cellular process which is tightly regulated in normal cells. A number of tumour suppressors and oncogenes could affect the production of ribosomes at different levels and an upregulation could lead to increased protein biosynthesis which is one of the characteristic features of all cancer cells. Ribosome biogenesis is a very complex process which requires coordinated transcription by all three nucleolar polymerases and the first event in this process is synthesis of ribosomal RNA (rRNA) by RNA Polymerase I (Pol I). Importantly, recent data has pictured rRNA transcription as a key regulator of whole ribosome biogenesis and therefore makes it a valid and very attractive target for anticancer therapy, as well as a perspective biomarker. However, at the moment there is only one known specific inhibitor of Pol I transcription (at stage one of clinical trials) and this makes it very difficult for the development of drugs which would target rRNA transcription and consequently ribosome biogenesis. We have recently discovered that antitumor alkaloid ellipticine (isolated in 1959 from the plant species Ochrosia) is a potent inhibitor of Pol I transcription (both in vitro and in vivo). Ellipticine and its derivatives are known as efficient topoisomerase II inhibitors and inhibitors of some kinases, however we have shown that these inhibitory activities and the ability of ellipticine to repress Pol I activity are unrelated. Moreover, our preliminary data suggests that ellipticine specifically targets Pol I transcription and it has no effect on transcription by Pol II and Pol III at the same time scale. The possible mechanisms of inhibition of Pol I transcription by ellipticines will be discussed.

Semisynthetic aminoglycoside antibiotics : toward biomimetic synthesis, evasion of bacterial resistance and reduced toxicity

Les antibiotiques aminoglycosidiques sont des agents bactéricides de grande valeur et d’efficacité à large spectre contre les pathogènes Gram-positifs et Gram-négatifs, dont plusieurs membres naturels et semisynthétiques sont importants dans l’histoire clinique depuis 1950. Des travaux crystallographiques sur le ribosome, récompensés par le prix Nobel, ont démontré comment leurs diverses structures polyaminées sont adaptées pour cibler une hélice d’ARN dans le centre de codage de la sous-unité 30S du ribosome bactérien. Leur interférence avec l’affinité et la cinétique des étapes de sélection et vérification des tARN induit la synthèse de protéines à basse fidélité, et l’inhibition de la translocation, établissant un cercle vicieux d’accumulation d’antibiotique et de stress sur la membrane. En réponse à ces pressions, les pathogènes bactériens ont évolué et disséminé une panoplie de mécanismes de résistance enzymatiques et d’expulsion : tels que les N acétyltransférases, les O phosphotransférases et les O nucleotidyltransférases qui ciblent les groupements hydroxyle et amino sur le coeur des aminoglycosides; des méthyl-transférases, qui ciblent le site de liaison ribosomale; et des pompes d’expulsion actives pour l’élimination sélective des aminoglycosides, qui sont utilisés par les souches Gram-négatives. Les pathogènes les plus problématiques, qui présentent aujourd’hui une forte résilience envers la majorité des classes d’antibiotiques sur le bord de la pan-résistance ont été nommés des bactéries ESKAPE, une mnémonique pour Enterococcus faecium, Staphylococcus aureus, Klebsiella pneumoniae, Acinetobacter baumannii, Pseudomonas aeruginosa et Enterobacteriaceae. La distribution globale des souches avec des mécanismes de résistance envers les standards cliniques aminoglycosides, tels que la tobramycine, l’amikacine et la gentamicine, est comprise entre 20 et 60% des isolées cliniques. Ainsi, les aminoglycosides du type 4,6-disubstitués-2-deoxystreptamine sont inadéquats comme thérapies anti-infectieuses à large spectre. Cependant, la famille des aminoglycosides 4,5-disubstitués, incluant la butirosine, la neomycine et la paromomycine, dont la structure plus complexe, pourrait constituter une alternative. Des collègues dans le groupe Hanessian et collaborateurs d’Achaogen Inc. ont démontré que certains analogues de la paraomomycine et neomycine, modifiés par désoxygénation sur les positions 3’ et 4’, et par substitution avec la chaîne N1-α-hydroxy-γ-aminobutyramide (HABA) provenant de la butirosine, pourrait produire des antibiotiques très prometteurs. Le Chapitre 4 de cette dissertation présente la conception et le développement d’une stratégie semi-synthétique pour produire des nouveaux aminoglycosides améliorés du type 4,5 disubstitués, inspiré par des modifications biosynthétiques de la sisomicine, qui frustrent les mécanismes de résistance bactérienne distribuées globalement. Cette voie de synthèse dépend d’une réaction d’hydrogénolyse de type Tsuji catalysée par palladium, d’abord développée sur des modèles monosaccharides puis subséquemment appliquée pour générer un ensemble d’aminoglycosides hybrides entre la neomycine et la sisomicine. Les études structure-activité des divers analogues de cette nouvelle classe ont été évaluées sur une gamme de 26 souches bactériennes exprimant des mécanismes de résistance enzymatique et d’expulsion qui englobe l’ensemble des pathogènes ESKAPE. Deux des antibiotiques hybrides ont une couverture antibacterienne excellente, et cette étude a mis en évidence des candidats prometteurs pour le développement préclinique. La thérapie avec les antibiotiques aminoglycosidiques est toujours associée à une probabilité de complications néphrotoxiques. Le potentiel de toxicité de chaque aminoglycoside peut être largement corrélé avec le nombre de groupements amino et de désoxygénations. Une hypothèse de longue date dans le domaine indique que les interactions principales sont effectuées par des sels des groupements ammonium, donc l’ajustement des paramètres de pKa pourrait provoquer une dissociation plus rapide avec leurs cibles, une clairance plus efficace et globalement des analogues moins néphrotoxiques. Le Chapitre 5 de cette dissertation présente la conception et la synthèse asymétrique de chaînes N1 HABA β substitutées par mono- et bis-fluoration. Des chaînes qui possèdent des γ-N pKa dans l’intervalle entre 10 et 7.5 ont été appliquées sur une neomycine tétra-désoxygénée pour produire des antibiotiques avancés. Malgré la réduction considérable du γ N pKa, le large spectre bactéricide n’a pas été significativement affecté pour les analogues fluorés isosteriques. De plus, des études structure-toxicité évaluées avec une analyse d’apoptose propriétaire d’Achaogen ont démontré que la nouvelle chaîne β,β difluoro-N1-HABA est moins nocive sur un modèle de cellules de rein humain HK2 et elle est prometteuse pour le développement d’antibiotiques du type neomycine avec des propriétés thérapeutiques améliorées. Le chapitre final de cette dissertation présente la proposition et validation d’une synthèse biomimétique par assemblage spontané du aminoglycoside 66-40C, un dimère C2 symétrique bis-imine macrocyclique à 16 membres. La structure proposée du macrocycle a été affinée par spectroscopie nucléaire à un système trans,trans-bis-azadiène anti-parallèle. Des calculs indiquent que l’effet anomérique de la liaison α glycosidique entre les anneaux A et B fournit la pré-organisation pour le monomère 6’ aldéhydo sisomicine et favorise le produit macrocyclique observé. L’assemblage spontané dans l’eau a été étudié par la dimérisation de trois divers analogues et par des expériences d’entre croisement qui ont démontré la généralité et la stabilité du motif macrocyclique de l'aminoglycoside 66-40C.