Greenhouse gas emissions from peat and biomass-derived fuels, electricity and heat — Estimation of various production chains by using LCA methodology

More discussion is required on how and which types of biomass should be used to achieve a significant reduction in the carbon load released into the atmosphere in the short term. The energy sector is one of the largest greenhouse gas (GHG) emitters and thus its role in climate change mitigation is important. Replacing fossil fuels with biomass has been a simple way to reduce carbon emissions because the carbon bonded to biomass is considered as carbon neutral. With this in mind, this thesis has the following objectives: (1) to study the significance of the different GHG emission sources related to energy production from peat and biomass, (2) to explore opportunities to develop more climate friendly biomass energy options and (3) to discuss the importance of biogenic emissions of biomass systems. The discussion on biogenic carbon and other GHG emissions comprises four case studies of which two consider peat utilization, one forest biomass and one cultivated biomasses. Various different biomass types (peat, pine logs and forest residues, palm oil, rapeseed oil and jatropha oil) are used as examples to demonstrate the importance of biogenic carbon to life cycle GHG emissions. The biogenic carbon emissions of biomass are defined as the difference in the carbon stock between the utilization and the non-utilization scenarios of biomass. Forestry-drained peatlands were studied by using the high emission values of the peatland types in question to discuss the emission reduction potential of the peatlands. The results are presented in terms of global warming potential (GWP) values. Based on the results, the climate impact of the peat production can be reduced by selecting high-emission-level peatlands for peat production. The comparison of the two different types of forest biomass in integrated ethanol production in pulp mill shows that the type of forest biomass impacts the biogenic carbon emissions of biofuel production. The assessment of cultivated biomasses demonstrates that several selections made in the production chain significantly affect the GHG emissions of biofuels. The emissions caused by biofuel can exceed the emissions from fossil-based fuels in the short term if biomass is in part consumed in the process itself and does not end up in the final product. Including biogenic carbon and other land use carbon emissions into the carbon footprint calculations of biofuel reveals the importance of the time frame and of the efficiency of biomass carbon content utilization. As regards the climate impact of biomass energy use, the net impact on carbon stocks (in organic matter of soils and biomass), compared to the impact of the replaced energy source, is the key issue. Promoting renewable biomass regardless of biogenic GHG emissions can increase GHG emissions in the short term and also possibly in the long term.

Suopohjat kierrätykseen : mitä tehdä vanhoilla turvetuotantoalueilla?

Summary: Reuse of peatlands - what shall we do with the old peat production areas?

Aurinkokeräimien käyttö turpeen kenttäkuivauksessa

Tämä tutkimus tehtiin osana Vapo Oy:n uuden turvetuotantotekniikan kehitystä. Kihniön Aitonevalle on rakennettu uuden turvetuotantotekniikan tutkimusalue, johon kuuluu muun muassa yksi lämmittämätön kuivatuskenttä sekä yksi aurinkolämmöllä lämmitetty kuivatuskenttä aurinkokeräimineen ja putkistoineen. Työn tavoitteena oli selvittää aurinkolämmöllä lämmitetyn kuivatuskentän tuotannon teho verrattuna lämmittämättömään kenttään. Toinen tavoite oli selvittää Aitonevan tutkimusalueella käytössä olevista aurinkokeräimistä turpeen kuivaustarkoitukseen parhaiten soveltuva keräin. Tuotantoa uudella menetelmällä tehtiin vuoden 2005 kesän ajan. Tuotantotehon ero pyrittiin selvittämään seuraamalla yksittäisten turvetuotantoerien eli satokiertojen kuivumista kosteusnäyttein ja toisaalta vertaamalla koko kesän aikana saatua tuotantoa. Aurinkokeräimien vertailu toteutettiin energiamäärä- ja hyötysuhdemittauksin. Lisäksi kuivatuskenttien lämpötiloja mitattiin kentässä tapahtuvan lämmönsiirron selvittämiseksi. Mittausten perusteella havaittiin, ettälämmitetyn ja lämmittämättömän kentän välillä on tutkimuksen aikaisella kenttärakenteella 6-8 % ero satokierron aikana haihdutetussa vesimäärässä. Tätä voidaanpitää odotuksia pienempänä. Kenttien lämpötilamittausten perusteella osoittautui, että kentän pintarakenne tulisi eristää maaperästä, koska kentän alle siirrettyä lämpöä siirtyy häviöinä kylmään pohjamaahan. Käytössä olleista aurinkokeräimistä parhaaksi osoittautui katettu kumimattokeräin niin hyötysuhteen kuin tehokkuudenkin puolesta. Työn aikana todettiin, että tutkimusta keräimien ja varsinkinkenttärakenteen suhteen tulee jatkaa tulevaisuudessa ennen aurinkokeräinkentän laajamittaisen käytön aloittamista.

Painovoimaisen kemiallisen vesienkäsittelymenetelmän soveltuvuus pienille turvetuotantoalueille

Turvetuotannon suurimpana ympäristövaikutuksena pidetään tuotantoalueiden valuma-vesistä johtuvia ympäristövaikutuksia. Tiukentunut ympäristölainsäädäntö edellyttää uusilta turvetuotantoalueilta parhaan käyttökelpoisen tekniikan käyttöä valumavesien-käsittelyssä. Parhaaksi käyttökelpoiseksi tekniikaksi luetaan pintavalutus- ja kasvilli-suuskentän sekä kemikaloinnin käyttö valumavesien puhdistuksessa. Tämän tutkimuksen tarkoituksena oli selvittää painovoimaisen kemiallisen vesienkäsit-telymenetelmän soveltuvuutta pienille turvetuotantoalueille. Tutkimuskohteena oli Lep-pisuo Luumäen kunnassa, jonne rakennettiin 2010 painovoimaisen kemikaloinnin koe-laitteisto. Laitteiston puhdistustulosta tarkasteltiin kemikalointiin tulevan ja lähtevän veden sekä taustanäytepisteiden tarkkailutulosten avulla. Laitteiston toimivuutta arvioi-tiin kemikaalin annostelun ja toimintavarmuuden avulla. Vuoden 2010 tarkkailutuloksista saatiin keskimääräisiksi erotustehokkuuksiksi koko-naisfosforin osalta 65,2 %, kokonaistypen osalta 28,1 % ja CODMn osalta 65,5 %. Ke-mikaloinnista lähtevän veden kokonaisfosforipitoisuus oli 7,7 μg/l, kokonaistyppipitoi-suus 656 μg/l ja CODMn 5,5 mg/l O2. Ferrisulfaatin annostelu oli keskimäärin 81 mg/l, vaihteluvälillä 25–268 mg/l.

Pintavalutuskentän ja kemikalointiaseman soveltuvuus turvetuotantoalueille

Tässä kandidaatintyössä tutkittiin kahden eri vesiensuojelurakenteen toimivuutta ja soveltuvuutta turvetuotantoalueelle. Työn tavoitteena oli vertailla pintavalutuskentän ja kemiallisen vedenkäsittelyn eroavaisuuksia toiminnoiltaan ja puhdistustehoiltaan. Lisäksi työn tavoitteena oli tarkastella parhaimman vesiensuojelurakenteen valintaan vaikuttavia tekijöitä. Työ toteutettiin vertailemalla Vapo Oy:n tarkkailuraporteista sekä turvetuotantoalueiden ominaiskuormitusselvityksistä koottuja tilastoja. Vertailu suoritettiin puhdistustulosten ja kuormituslukujen avulla. Tuotantoaluekohtaisia tarkkailuraportteja oli käytettävissä kolmelta edeltävältä vuodelta ja työssä käytetty ominaiskuormitusselvitys oli koonti vuosien 2008–2012 tuloksista. Työstä saadut tulokset tukevat vesiensuojelumenetelmistä jo saatavilla olevaa teoriaa. Turvetuotantoalueelle paras käyttökelpoinen tekniikka on pintavalutuskenttä, mikä osoittautui työssä tasaisen laadukkaaksi menetelmäksi. Työssä havaittiin kemiallisen vedenkäsittelyn olevan epävarmaa ja haastavaa. Työstä saadut tulokset osoittavat käsittelyn jatkokehittämisen tarpeen.

Effect of nitrogen fertilization, grass species and cultivar on sod production on Valkeasuo peat bog - a case study

Selostus: Typpilannoituksen, kasvilajin ja lajikkeen vaikutus siirtonurmikon tuotanto-ominaisuuksiin Valkeasuon turvetuotannon jättöalueella

Growth, yield and secondary metabolite production of Drosera species cultivated in peat beds in Finland

Tiivistelmä

Increased temperature sensitivity of net DOC production from ombrotrophic peat due to water table draw-down.

The production and release of dissolved organic carbon (DOC) from peat soils is thought to be sensitive to changes in climate, specifically changes in temperature and rainfall. However, little is known about the actual rates of net DOC production in response to temperature and water table draw-down, particularly in comparison to carbon dioxide (CO2) fluxes. To explore these relationships, we carried out a laboratory experiment on intact peat soil cores under controlled temperature and water table conditions to determine the impact and interaction of each of these climatic factors on net DOC production. We found a significant interaction (P < 0.001) between temperature, water table draw-down and net DOC production across the whole soil core (0 to −55 cm depth). This corresponded to an increase in the Q10 (i.e. rise in the rate of net DOC production over a 10 °C range) from 1.84 under high water tables and anaerobic conditions to 3.53 under water table draw-down and aerobic conditions between −10 and − 40 cm depth. However, increases in net DOC production were only seen after water tables recovered to the surface as secondary changes in soil water chemistry driven by sulphur redox reactions decreased DOC solubility, and therefore DOC concentrations, during periods of water table draw-down. Furthermore, net microbial consumption of DOC was also apparent at − 1 cm depth and was an additional cause of declining DOC concentrations during dry periods. Therefore, although increased temperature and decreased rainfall could have a significant effect on net DOC release from peatlands, these climatic effects could be masked by other factors controlling the biological consumption of DOC in addition to soil water chemistry and DOC solubility. These findings highlight both the sensitivity of DOC release from ombrotrophic peat to episodic changes in water table draw-down, and the need to disentangle complex and interacting controls on DOC dynamics to fully understand the impact of environmental change on this system.

Competitiveness Comparison of the Electricity Production Alternatives

The competitiveness comparison is carried out for merely electricity producing alternatives. In Finland, further construction of CHP (combined heat and power) power plants will continue and cover part of the future power supply deficit, but also new condensing power plant capacity will be needed. The following types of power plants are studied: - nuclear power plant, - coal-fired condensing power plant - combined cycle gas turbine plant, - peat-fired condensing power plant. - wood-fired condensing power plant - wind power plant The calculations have been made using the annuity method with a real interest rate of 5 % perannum and with a fixed price level as of March 2003. With the annual full load utilization time of 8000 hours the nuclear electricity would cost 23,7 ¤/MWh, the gas based electricity 32,3 ¤/MWh and coal based electricity 28,1 ¤/MWh. If the influence of emission trading is taken into account,the advantage of the nuclear power will still be improved. Inorder to study the impact of changes in the input data, a sensitivity analysis has been carried out. It reveals that the advantage of the nuclear power is quite clear. E.g. the nuclear electricity is rather insensitive tothe changes of the uranium price, whereas for natural gas alternative the rising trend of gas price causes the greatest risk.

Utilization of Meat and bone meal for energy production

At the end of the 1990s the stock breeding in the Europe was suffering from the animal disease epidemics such as Bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) and foot –and mouth disease. The European Union (EU) tackled to this problem by tightening the legislation of animal by-products. At this point, rendering and fat producing industries faces new challenges, which they have to cope with in a way of trying to find alternatives to their products (animal fats and meat and bone meal). One of the most promising alternatives to utilize these products was to use them in energy production purposes. The purpose of the Thesis was to examine the utilization possibilities of Meat and bone meal (MBM) for energy production. The first part of the Thesis consists of theory part. The theory part includes evaluation of basic properties of MBM as a fertilizer and as a fuel, legislative evaluation and evaluation of different burning techniques. The second part of the Thesis consists of burning tests in Energy laboratory of LUT with different mixtures of peat and MBM. The purpose of the burning tests was to identify co-firing possibilities of peat and MBM and emission- and ash properties for peat and MBM.

Excavation-drier method of energy-peat extraction reduces long-term climatic impact

Climatic impacts of energy-peat extraction are of increasing concern due to EU emissions trading requirements. A new excavation-drier peat extraction method has been developed to reduce the climatic impact and increase the efficiency of peat extraction. To quantify and compare the soil GHG fluxes of the excavation drier and the traditional milling methods, as well as the areas from which the energy peat is planned to be extracted in the future (extraction reserve area types), soil CO2, CH4 and N2O fluxes were measured during 2006–2007 at three sites in Finland. Within each site, fluxes were measured from drained extraction reserve areas, extraction fields and stockpiles of both methods and additionally from the biomass driers of the excavation-drier method. The Life Cycle Assessment (LCA), described at a principal level in ISO Standards 14040:2006 and 14044:2006, was used to assess the long-term (100 years) climatic impact from peatland utilisation with respect to land use and energy production chains where utilisation of coal was replaced with peat. Coal was used as a reference since in many cases peat and coal can replace each other in same power plants. According to this study, the peat extraction method used was of lesser significance than the extraction reserve area type in regards to the climatic impact. However, the excavation-drier method seems to cause a slightly reduced climatic impact as compared with the prevailing milling method.

Hydrological controls on soil redox dynamics in a peat-based, restored wetland

Increasing areas of altered wetland are being restored by re-flooding the soil. Evidence in the literature indicates that this practice can induce the redox-mediated release of soil nutrients, thereby increasing the risk of diffuse water pollution. However, for the sake of improving wedand management decisions, there is a need for more detailed studies of the underlying relationship between the hydrological and redox dynamics that explain this risk; this is particularly the case in agricultural peatlands that are commonly targeted for the creation of lowland wet grassland. A 12-month field study was conducted to evaluate the relationship between hydrological fluctuations and soil redox potential (Eh) in a nutrient-rich peat field (32 g N kg(-1) and 1100 mg P kg(-1) in the surface 0-30 cm soil) that had been restored as lowland wet grassland from intensive arable production. Field tensiometers were installed at the 30-, 60- and 90-cm soil depths, and Pt electrodes at the 10-, 30-, 60- and 90-cm depths, for daily logging of soil water tension and Eh, respectively. The values for soil water tension displayed a strong negative relationship (P < 0.001) with monthly dip well observations of water table height. Calculations of soil water potential from the logged tension values were used, therefore, to provide a detailed profile of field water level and, together with precipitation data, explained some of the variation in Eh. For example, during the summer, alternating periods of aerobism (Eh > 330 mV) in the surface, 0-10 cm layer of peat coincided with intense precipitation events. Redox potential throughout the 30-100 cm profile also fluctuated seasonally; indeed, at all depths Eh displayed a strong, negative relationship (P < 0.001) with water table height over the 12-month study period. However, Eh throughout the 30-100 cm profile remained relatively low (< 230 mV), indicating permanently reduced conditions that are associated with denitrification and reductive dissolution of Fe-bound P. The implications of these processes in the N- and P-rich peat for wetland plant diversity and water quality are discussed. (c) 2006 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Effect of cattle urine addition on the surface emissions and subsurface concentrations of greenhouse gases in a UK peat grassland

Grazing systems represent a substantial percentage of the global anthropogenic flux of nitrous oxide (N2O) as a result of nitrogen addition to the soil. The pool of available carbon that is added to the soil from livestock excreta also provides substrate for the production of carbon dioxide (CO2) and methane (CH4) by soil microorganisms. A study into the production and emission of CO2, CH4 and N2O from cattle urine amended pasture was carried out on the Somerset Levels and Moors, UK over a three-month period. Urine-amended plots (50 g N m−2) were compared to control plots to which only water (12 mg N m−2) was applied. CO2 emission peaked at 5200 mg CO2 m−2 d−1 directly after application. CH4 flux decreased to −2000 μg CH4 m−2 d−1 two days after application; however, net CH4 flux was positive from urine treated plots and negative from control plots. N2O emission peaked at 88 mg N2O m−2 d−1 12 days after application. Subsurface CH4 and N2O concentrations were higher in the urine treated plots than the controls. There was no effect of treatment on subsurface CO2 concentrations. Subsurface N2O peaked at 500 ppm 12 days after and 1200 ppm 56 days after application. Subsurface NO3− concentration peaked at approximately 300 mg N kg dry soil−1 12 days after application. Results indicate that denitrification is the key driver for N2O release in peatlands and that this production is strongly related to rainfall events and water-table movement. N2O production at depth continued long after emissions were detected at the surface. Further understanding of the interaction between subsurface gas concentrations, surface emissions and soil hydrological conditions is required to successfully predict greenhouse gas production and emission.

Modelling the effect of the physical and chemical characteristics of the materials used as casing layers on the production parameters of Agaricus bisporus

The aim of this research was to show the mathematical data obtained through the correlations found between the physical and chemical characteristics of casing layers and the final mushrooms' properties. For this purpose, 8 casing layers were used: soil, soil + peat moss, soil + black peat, soil + composted pine bark, soil + coconut fibre pith, soil + wood fibre, soil + composted vine shoots and, finally, the casing of La Rioja subjected to the ruffling practice. The conclusion that interplays in the fructification process with only the physical and chemical characteristics of casing are complicated was drawn. The mathematical data obtained in earliness could be explained in non-ruffled cultivation. The variability observed for the mushroom weight and the mushroom diameter variables could be explained in both ruffled and non-ruffled cultivations. Finally, the properties of the final quality of mushrooms were established by regression analysis.

Production flush of Agaricus blazei on Brazilian casing layers

Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo (FAPESP)