On the Origin of Ideas : An Abductivist Approach to Discovery

The purpose of this study is to analyze and develop various forms of abduction as a means of conceptualizing processes of discovery. Abduction was originally presented by Charles S. Peirce (1839-1914) as a "weak", third main mode of inference -- besides deduction and induction -- one which, he proposed, is closely related to many kinds of cognitive processes, such as instincts, perception, practices and mediated activity in general. Both abduction and discovery are controversial issues in philosophy of science. It is often claimed that discovery cannot be a proper subject area for conceptual analysis and, accordingly, abduction cannot serve as a "logic of discovery". I argue, however, that abduction gives essential means for understanding processes of discovery although it cannot give rise to a manual or algorithm for making discoveries. In the first part of the study, I briefly present how the main trend in philosophy of science has, for a long time, been critical towards a systematic account of discovery. Various models have, however, been suggested. I outline a short history of abduction; first Peirce's evolving forms of his theory, and then later developments. Although abduction has not been a major area of research until quite recently, I review some critiques of it and look at the ways it has been analyzed, developed and used in various fields of research. Peirce's own writings and later developments, I argue, leave room for various subsequent interpretations of abduction. The second part of the study consists of six research articles. First I treat "classical" arguments against abduction as a logic of discovery. I show that by developing strategic aspects of abductive inference these arguments can be countered. Nowadays the term 'abduction' is often used as a synonym for the Inference to the Best Explanation (IBE) model. I argue, however, that it is useful to distinguish between IBE ("Harmanian abduction") and "Hansonian abduction"; the latter concentrating on analyzing processes of discovery. The distinctions between loveliness and likeliness, and between potential and actual explanations are more fruitful within Hansonian abduction. I clarify the nature of abduction by using Peirce's distinction between three areas of "semeiotic": grammar, critic, and methodeutic. Grammar (emphasizing "Firstnesses" and iconicity) and methodeutic (i.e., a processual approach) especially, give new means for understanding abduction. Peirce himself held a controversial view that new abductive ideas are products of an instinct and an inference at the same time. I maintain that it is beneficial to make a clear distinction between abductive inference and abductive instinct, on the basis of which both can be developed further. Besides these, I analyze abduction as a part of distributed cognition which emphasizes a long-term interaction with the material, social and cultural environment as a source for abductive ideas. This approach suggests a "trialogical" model in which inquirers are fundamentally connected both to other inquirers and to the objects of inquiry. As for the classical Meno paradox about discovery, I show that abduction provides more than one answer. As my main example of abductive methodology, I analyze the process of Ignaz Semmelweis' research on childbed fever. A central basis for abduction is the claim that discovery is not a sequence of events governed only by processes of chance. Abduction treats those processes which both constrain and instigate the search for new ideas; starting from the use of clues as a starting point for discovery, but continuing in considerations like elegance and 'loveliness'. The study then continues a Peircean-Hansonian research programme by developing abduction as a way of analyzing processes of discovery.

The book-lover : a guide to the best reading /

Includes index.

Fresh-water aquaria: their construction, arrangement, and management, with full information as to the best water-plants and live stock to be kept, how and where to obtain them, and how to keep them in health,

Mode of access: Internet.

A descriptive guide to the best fiction, British and American,

Classified: A, English (by periods), Scottish, Irish, Colonial; B, American (by periods); C-L, translations (by languages); followed by an index of authors and titles, and one of subjects. Critical and descriptive notes; best or "representative" works are starred.

Marsh's manual of reformed phonetic short-hand: being a complete guide to the best system of phonography and verbatim reporting.

Mode of access: Internet.

The Book of rural life; knowledge and inspiration, a guide to the best in modern living ....

"Managing editor, John A. Bellows ... editor in chief, Edward Mowbray Tuttle."

The book-lover, a guide to the best reading.

Mode of access: Internet.

Special report of the State Board of Insanity to the Massachusetts General Court as to the best method of providing for the insane. (In compliance with chapter 34, resolves of 1908) May, 1908.

At head of title: Senate document no. 358.

A selection of one hundred of Perrin's fables : accompanied with a key, containing the text, a literal and a free translation arranged in such a manner as to point out the difference between the French and the English idiom : also a figured pronunciation of the French, according to the best French works extant on the subject : the whole preceded by a short treatise on the sounds of the French language, compared with those of the English /

Mode of access: Internet.

Appendix to lectures on English grammar : containing an additional number of incorrect phrases, or vulgarisms, and a selection of nearly four hundred words : which are frequently pronounced contrary to the best usage.

Mode of access: Internet.

The New and complete American encyclopedia: or, Universal dictionary of arts and sciences; on an improved plan: in which the respective sciences are arranged into complete systems, and the arts digested into distinct treatises; also the detached parts of knowledge alphabetically arranged and copiously explained, according to the best authorities.

"From the Encyclopedia Perthensis, with improvements."

The book-lover : a guide to the best reading /

Mode of access: Internet.

The history of Mexico, from the Spanish conquest to the present era; containing a condensed and connected general view of the manners, customs, religion, commerce, soil, and agriculture - animal, vegetable, and mineral productions - a concise political and statistical review of the changes effected in that country, with is present form of government, &c. &c. - Also, observations, speculative and practical, as to the best means of working the Mexican mines, by a combination of British talent, capital, and machinery.

Mode of access: Internet.

Stories of standard teaching pieces; containing educational notes and legends pertaining to the best known and most useful pianoforte compositions in general use by students of music and designed as a companion volume to the author's "Descriptive analyses of pianoforte compositions",

Mode of access: Internet.

The botanist's calendar and pocket flora arranged according to the Linnaean system. To which are added references to the best figures of British plants.

Mode of access: Internet.