Developing a three-dimensional in-vitro cell culture model for studying breast and prostate cancer using starPEG-heparin hydrogels

Introduction Hydrogels prepared from poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) and maleimide-functionalized heparin provide a potential matrix for use in developing three dimensional (3D) models. We have previously demonstrated that these hydrogels support the cultivation of human umbilical vein endothelial cells (HUVECs) (1). We extend this body of work to study the ability to create an extracellular matrix (ECM)-like model to study breast and prostate cancer cell growth in 3D. Also, we investigate the ability to produce a tri-culture mimicking tumour angiogenesis with cancer spheroids, HUVECs and mesenchymal stem cells (MSC). Materials and Methods The breast cancer cell lines, MCF-7 and MDA-MB-231, and prostate cancer cell lines, LNCaP and PC3, were seeded into starPEG-heparin hydrogels and grown for 14 Days to analyse the effects of varying hydrogel stiffness on spheroid development. Resulting hydrogel constructs were analyzed via Alamar Blue assays, light microscopy, and immunofluorescence staining for cytokeratin 8/18, Ki67 and E-Cadherin. Cancer cell lines were then pre-grown in hydrogels for 5-7 days and then re-seeded into starPEG-heparin hydrogels functionalised with RGD, SDF-1, bFGF and VEGF as spheroids with HUVECs and MSC and grown for 14 days as a tri-culture in Endothelial Cell Growth Medium (ECGM; Promocell). Cell lines were also seeded as a single cell suspension into the functionalised tri-culture system. Cultures were fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde and analysed via immunostaining for Von Willebrand Factor and CD31, as well as the above mentioned markers, and observed using confocal microscopy. Results Cultures prepared in MMP-cleavable starPEG-heparin hydrogels display spheroid formation in contrast to adherent growth on tissue culture plastic. Small differences were visualised in cancer spheroid growth between different gel stiffness across the range of cell lines. Cancer cell lines were able to be co-cultivated with HUVECs and MSC. HUVEC tube formation and cancer line spheroid formation occured after 3-4 days. Interaction was visualised between tumours and HUVECs via confocal microscopy. Slightly increased interaction was seen between cancer tumours and micro-vascular tubes when seeded as single cells compared with the pre-formed spheroid approach. Further studies intend to utilise cytokine gradients to further optimise the ECM environment of in situ tumour angiogenesis. Discussion and Conclusions Our results confirm the suitability of hydrogels constructed from starPEG-heparin for HUVECs and MSC co-cultivation with cancer cell lines to study cell-cell and cell-matrix interactions in a 3D environment. This represents a step forward in the development of 3D culture models to study the pathomechanisms of breast and prostate cancer. References 1. Tsurkan MV, Chwalek K, Prokoph S, Zieris A, Levental KR, Freudenberg U, Werner C. Advanced Materials. 25, 2606-10, 2013. Disclosures The authors declare no conflicts of interest

Response of porcine intestinal in vitro organ culture tissues following exposure to Lactobacillus plantarum JC1 and Salmonella Typhimurium SL1344.

The development of novel intervention strategies for the control of zoonoses caused by bacteria such as Salmonella spp. in livestock requires appropriate experimental models to assess their suitability. Here, a novel porcine intestinal in vitro organ culture (IVOC) model utilizing cell crown (CC) technology (CCIVOC) (Scaffdex) was developed. The CCIVOC model was employed to investigate the characteristics of association of S. enterica serovar Typhimurium strain SL1344 with porcine intestinal tissue following exposure to a Lactobacillus plantarum strain. The association of bacteria to host cells was examined by light microscopy and electron microscopy (EM) after appropriate treatments and staining, while changes in the proteome of porcine jejunal tissues were investigated using quantitative label-free proteomics. Exposure of porcine intestinal mucosal tissues to L. plantarum JC1 did not reduce the numbers of S. Typhimurium bacteria associating to the tissues but was associated with significant (P < 0.005) reductions in the percentages of areas of intestinal IVOC tissues giving positive staining results for acidic mucins. Conversely, the quantity of neutrally charged mucins present within the goblet cells of the IVOC tissues increased significantly (P < 0.05). In addition, tubulin- was expressed at high levels following inoculation of jejunal IVOC tissues with L. plantarum. Although L. plantarum JC1 did not reduce the association of S. Typhimurium strain SL1344 to the jejunal IVOC tissues, detection of increased acidic mucin secretion, host cytoskeletal rearrangements, and proteins involved in the porcine immune response demonstrated that this strain of L. plantarum may contribute to protecting the pig from infections by S. Typhimurium or other pathogens.

A novel medium for the development of in vitro cell culture system from Penaeus monodon

Lack of a valid shrimp cell line has been hampering the progress of research on shrimp viruses. One of the reasons identified was the absence of an appropriate medium which would satisfy the requirements of the cells in vitro. We report the first attempt to formulate an exclusive shrimp cell culture medium (SCCM) based on the haemolymph components of Penaeus monodon prepared in isosmotic seawater having 27 % salinity. The SCCM is composed of 22 amino acids, 4 sugars, 6 vitamins, cholesterol, FBS, phenol red, three antibiotics, potassium dihydrogen phosphate and di-sodium hydrogen phosphate at pH 6.8–7.2. Osmolality was adjusted to 720 ± 10 mOsm kg-1 and temperature of incubation was 25 8C. The most appropriate composition was finally selected based on the extent of attachment of cells and their proliferation by visual observation. Metabolic activity of cultured cells was measured by MTT assay and compared with that in L-15 (29), modified L-15 and Grace’s insect medium, and found better performance in SCCM especially for lymphoid cells with 107 % increase in activity and 85 ± 9 days of longevity. The cells from ovary and lymphoid organs were passaged twice using the newly designed shrimp cell dissociation ‘‘cocktail’’.

An assessment of the prebiotic potential of single and blended substrates in anaerobic in vitro batch culture fermentations using canine faecal samples as inocula

Previously, using an in vitro static batch culture system, it was found that rice bran (RB), inulin, fibersol, mannanoligosaccharides (MOS), larch arabinogalactan and citrus pectin elicited prebiotic effects (in terms of increased numbers of bifidobacteria and lactic acid bacteria) on the faecal microbiota of a dog. The aim of the present study was to confirm the prebiotic potential of each individual substrate using multiple faecal donors, as well as assessing the prebiotic potential of 15 substrate blends made from them. Anaerobic static and stirred, pH-controlled batch culture systems inoculated with faecal samples from healthy dogs were used for this purpose. Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis using seven oligonucleotide probes targeting selected bacterial groups and DAPI (total bacteria) was used to monitor bacterial populations during fermentation runs. High-performance liquid chromatography was used to measure butyrate produced as a result of bacterial fermentation of the substrates. RB and a MOS/RB blend (1:1, w/w) were shown to elicit prebiotic and butyrogenic effects on the canine microbiota in static batch culture fermentations. Further testing of these substrates in stirred, pH-controlled batch culture fermentation systems confirmed the prebiotic and butyrogenic effects of MOS/RB, with no enhancement of Clostridium clusters I and II and Escherichia coli populations.

Effet de différents ratios d’acides linoléique/α-linolénique et de l’entérolactone sur les marqueurs du métabolisme des lipides, d’inflammation et de stress oxydatif dans un modèle in vitro de culture de tissus hépatiques bovins

Chez la vache laitière à haut rendement, la période de transition entourant la parturition est généralement accompagnée d’un déficit énergétique, d’un métabolisme des lipides perturbé et d’une augmentation de l’inflammation et du stress oxydatif. Afin d’améliorer la balance énergétique et de diminuer certains effets négatifs associés à la période de transition, il est fréquent que les producteurs administrent des diètes riches en lipides (ex. Mégalac®, riche en acide palmitique) aux vaches laitières à haut rendement. Par exemple, l’ajout de lipides saturés à la ration améliore la balance énergétique et diminue l’accumulation des triglycérides dans le foie. Cependant, plusieurs troubles métaboliques demeurent, tels que l’inflammation et le stress oxydatif, pouvant être observés entre autres au niveau du foie. Comme alternative aux lipides saturés, l’ajout d’acides gras polyinsaturés (AGPIs) pourrait contribuer à améliorer la balance énergétique tout en diminuant certains effets négatifs associés à la période de transition. Toutefois, les AGPIs sont sujets aux phénomènes de peroxydation ce qui pourrait augmenter le stress oxydatif chez l’animal. Pour limiter ces dommages oxydatifs, l’utilisation de la graine de lin entière, riche en acides gras oméga-3 (n-3) et en lignans (antioxydants), en supplément alimentaire apparaît comme une avenue prometteuse. Des travaux antérieurs rapportent qu’une supplémentation en différents dérivés de la graine de lin (ex. AGPIs, lignans) module l’expression de certains gènes impliqués dans la réponse au stress oxydatif et le métabolisme des lipides dans la glande mammaire de la vache laitière. Cependant, il n’existe aucune étude rapportant l’effet de divers composés de la graine de lin sur le métabolisme lipidique et certains marqueurs de stress oxydatif dans le foie de la vache laitière. Ce projet de recherche a été réalisé afin de déterminer les effets de différents ratios d’acides linoléique (LA)/acide alpha-linolénique (ALA) (n-6/n-3, AGPI) en présence ou non d’entérolactone (ENL, lignan mammalien) sur (1) l’expression hépatique de gènes liés au métabolisme des lipides, au processus inflammatoire et au stress oxydatif, (2) les dommages aux lipides et aux protéines et (3) l’activité de l’enzyme superoxyde dismutase (SOD) dans le foie de la vache laitière en début de lactation. Un modèle in vitro de culture de tissu hépatique en tranches minces a été utilisé puisqu’il permet de préserver les interactions cellules-matrice et entre les cellules. Les gènes sélectionnés ont été choisis en se référant à diverses études antérieures et incluent certains gènes différentiellement exprimés dans le foie et la glande mammaire de la vache laitière en période de transition. Des régulateurs de la transcription (ex. MLXIPL et SREBF1), de même que leurs gènes cibles ont été priorisés. Les tissus issus de biopsies hépatiques de vaches Holstein en début de lactation ont été mis en culture et soumis à huit traitements composés de différents ratios d’AGPIs n-6/n-3, d’ENL et d’une combinaison des deux. Suite à ces traitements, les niveaux d’ARNm des gènes sélectionnés ont été mesurés par PCR quantitatif (RT-qPCR). Les dommages aux lipides ont été mesurés par l’essai des « thiobarbituric acid reactive substances » (TBARS) et les dommages aux protéines par une analyse des protéines carbonyles. Finalement, un essai enzymatique a été effectué pour mesurer l’activité de la SOD, une enzyme jouant un rôle dans le système de défense contre les radicaux libres. Les résultats de cette étude démontrent que l’ajout d’AGPIs (LA et ALA) dans le milieu de culture augmente l’expression de certains gènes liés au stress oxydatif (NQO1, PRDX3, PTGS2 et SOD1) et diminue l’expression de plusieurs gènes liés à l’activité lipogénique (ACACA, FASN, SCD et SREBF1). L’addition d’ENL dans le milieu de culture augmente l’abondance de l’ARNm des gènes cibles de MLXIPL, soit FASN et SCD, deux gènes impliqués dans l’activité lipogénique. Cette régulation à la hausse suggère qu’une supplémentation en tourteau ou en farine de lin (riche an lignans) en début de lactation pourrait avoir des effets non désirés et augmenter le risque de stéatose hépatique. Les analyses de peroxydation des lipides ont révélés une augmentation des dommages aux lipides en présence des AGPIs et un retour aux valeurs du traitement contrôle lorsque l’ENL est ajouté aux AGPIs. Une augmentation similaire est observée pour l’activité de la SOD avec l’ajout des AGPIs au milieu de culture, ainsi qu’un retour aux valeurs contrôle lorsque l’ENL est ajouté aux AGPIs. Ces résultats suggèrent qu’une supplémentation en graines de lin entières serait bénéfique en début de lactation puisque les AGPIs pourraient diminuer l’activité lipogénique au niveau du foie, alors que les lignans présents naturellement dans l’écorce de la graine de lin, pourraient réduire le stress oxydatif et les dommages aux lipides provoqués par des niveaux élevés en AGPIs.

Mechanical tension as a driver of connective tissue growth in vitro

We propose the progressive mechanical expansion of cell-derived tissue analogues as a novel, growth-based approach to in vitro tissue engineering. The prevailing approach to producing tissue in vitro is to culture cells in an exogenous “scaffold” that provides a basic structure and mechanical support. This necessarily pre-defines the final size of the implantable material, and specific signals must be provided to stimulate appropriate cell growth, differentiation and matrix formation. In contrast, surgical skin expansion, driven by increments of stretch, produces increasing quantities of tissue without trauma or inflammation. This suggests that connective tissue cells have the innate ability to produce growth in response to elevated tension. We posit that this capacity is maintained in vitro, and that order-of-magnitude growth may be similarly attained in self-assembling cultures of cells and their own extracellular matrix. The hypothesis that growth of connective tissue analogues can be induced by mechanical expansion in vitro may be divided into three components: (1) tension stimulates cell proliferation and extracellular matrix synthesis; (2) the corresponding volume increase will relax the tension imparted by a fixed displacement; (3) the repeated application of static stretch will produce sustained growth and a tissue structure adapted to the tensile loading. Connective tissues exist in a state of residual tension, which is actively maintained by resident cells such as fibroblasts. Studies in vitro and in vivo have demonstrated that cellular survival, reproduction, and matrix synthesis and degradation are regulated by the mechanical environment. Order-of-magnitude increases in both bone and skin volume have been achieved clinically through staged expansion protocols, demonstrating that tension-driven growth can be sustained over prolonged periods. Furthermore, cell-derived tissue analogues have demonstrated mechanically advantageous structural adaptation in response to applied loading. Together, these data suggest that a program of incremental stretch constitutes an appealing way to replicate tissue growth in cell culture, by harnessing the constituent cells’ innate mechanical responsiveness. In addition to offering a platform to study the growth and structural adaptation of connective tissues, tension-driven growth presents a novel approach to in vitro tissue engineering. Because the supporting structure is secreted and organised by the cells themselves, growth is not restricted by a “scaffold” of fixed size. This also minimises potential adverse reactions to exogenous materials upon implantation. Most importantly, we posit that the growth induced by progressive stretch will allow substantial volumes of connective tissue to be produced from relatively small initial cell numbers.

Combined Effect of Cryogel Matrix and Temperature-Reversible Soluble-Insoluble Polymer for the Development of in Vitro Human Liver Tissue

Hepatic cell culture on a three-dimensional (3D) matrix or as a hepatosphere appears to be a promising in vitro biomimetic system for liver tissue engineering applications. In this study, we have combined the concept of a 3D scaffold and a spheroid culture to develop an in vitro model to engineer liver tissue for drug screening. We have evaluated the potential of poly(ethylene glycol)-alginate-gelatin (PAG) cryogel matrix for in vitro culture of human liver cell lines. The synthesized cryogel matrix has a flow rate of 7 mL/min and water uptake capacity of 94% that enables easy nutrient transportation in the in vitro cell culture. Youngs modulus of 2.4 kPa and viscoelastic property determine the soft and elastic nature of synthesized cryogel. Biocompatibility of PAG cryogel was evaluated through MTT assay of HepG2 and Huh-7 cells on matrices. The proliferation and functionality of the liver cells were enhanced by culturing hepatic cells as spheroids (hepatospheres) on the PAG cryogel using temperature-reversible soluble-insoluble polymer, poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) (PNIPAAm). Pore size of the cryogel above 100 mu m modulated spheroid size that can prevent hypoxia condition within the spheroid culture. Both the hepatic cells have shown a significant difference (P < 0.05) in terms of cell number and functionality when cultured with PNIPAAm. After 10 days of culture using 0.05% PNIPAAm, the cell number increased by 11- and 7-fold in case of HepG2 and Huh-7 cells, respectively. Similarly, after 10 days of hepatic spheroids culture on PAG cryogel, the albumin production, urea secretion, and CYP450 activity were significantly higher in case of culture with PNIPAAm. The developed tissue mass on the PAG cryogel in the presence of PNIPAAm possess polarity, which was confirmed using F-actin staining and by presence of intercellular bile canalicular lumen. The developed cryogel matrix supports liver cells proliferation and functionality and therefore can be used for in vitro and in vivo drug testing.

Blood-brain barrier in vitro model: A tissue engineering approach and validation

This dissertation evaluated the feasibility of using commercially available immortalized cell lines in building a tissue engineered in vitro blood-brain barrier (BBB) co-culture model for preliminary drug development studies. Mouse endothelial cell line and rat astrocyte cell lines purchased from American Type Culture Collections (ATCC) were the building blocks of the co-culture model. An astrocyte derived acellular extracellular matrix (aECM) was introduced in the co-culture model to provide a novel in vitro biomimetic basement membrane for the endothelial cells to form endothelial tight junctions. Trans-endothelial electrical resistance (TEER) and solute mass transport studies were engaged to quantitatively evaluate the tight junction formation on the in-vitro BBB models. Immuno-fluorescence microscopy and Western Blot analysis were used to qualitatively verify the in vitro expression of occludin, one of the earliest discovered tight junction proteins. Experimental data from a total of 12 experiments conclusively showed that the novel BBB in vitro co-culture model with the astrocyte derived aECM (CO+aECM) was promising in terms of establishing tight junction formation represented by TEER values, transport profiles and tight junction protein expression when compared with traditional co-culture (CO) model setups and endothelial cells cultured alone. Experimental data were also found to be comparable with several existing in vitro BBB models built from various methods. In vitro colorimetric sulforhodamine B (SRB) assay revealed that the co-cultured samples with aECM resulted in less cell loss on the basal sides of the insert membranes than that from traditional co-culture samples. The novel tissue engineering approach using immortalized cell lines with the addition of aECM was proven to be a relevant alternative to the traditional BBB in vitro modeling.

Adipose differentiation of bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells using Pluronic F-127 hydrogel in vitro

Due to increasing clinical demand for adipose tissue, a suitable scaffold for engineering adipose tissue constructs is needed. In this study, we have developed a three-dimensional (3-D) culture system using bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells (BM-MSC) and a Pluronic F-127 hydrogel scaffold as a step towards the in vitro tissue engineering of fat. BM-MSC were dispersed into a Pluronic F-127 hydrogel with or without type I collagen added. The adipogenic differentiation of the BM-MSC was assessed by cellular morphology and further confirmed by Oil Red O staining. The BM-MSC differentiated into adipocytes in Pluronic F-127 in the presence of adipogenic stimuli over a period of 2 weeks, with some differentiation present even in absence of such stimuli. The addition of type I collagen to the Pluronic F-127 caused the BM-MSC to aggregate into clumps, thereby generating an uneven adipogenic response, which was not desirable.

Produção in vitro e criopreservação de raízes de Cleome rosea Vahl (Capparaceae)

Cleome rosea é uma espécie nativa, de porte herbáceo, ocorrente em restingas brasileiras. Estudos recentes têm revelado o potencial medicinal da espécie para importantes propriedades farmacológicas, como por exemplo, as atividades anti-inflamatória, antigenotóxica, antiviral e antibacteriana. Porém, nos últimos anos, C. rosea não tem sido encontrada em várias regiões de seu ambiente natural, devido, principalmente, às ações antrópicas. Dessa forma, torna-se relevante o desenvolvimento de métodos de conservação que permitam o estudo e exploração das propriedades medicinais da espécie. O cultivo in vitro de raízes representa uma forma eficiente para produção de biomassa, devido ao rápido crescimento, produção estável de metabólitos, além de representar uma potencial fonte de explantes para a propagação em massa de diferentes espécies. O presente trabalho teve como objetivo a produção in vitro de culturas de raízes de C. rosea, associada à criopreservação, como forma de manutenção em longo prazo das culturas, monitorada através da análise de estabilidade genética. As culturas estabelecidas a partir de explantes radiculares de plantas propagadas in vitro de C. rosea demonstraram excelente capacidade de multiplicação de raízes em meio de cultura suplementado com o fitorregulador ANA, com manutenção dessa capacidade ao longo de sucessivas subculturas. Associado a esses resultados, o estabelecimento de protocolos de criopreservação pelo método de vitrificação resultou em elevados valores de frequência de recuperação do material após congelamento em nitrogênio líquido com as soluções de vitrificação PVS2 e PVS3. Os estudos de monitoramento da estabilidade genética, pela técnica de marcadores moleculares RAPD, revelaram a presença de polimorfismos significativos em uma das três culturas iniciadas a partir de raízes de C. rosea criopreservadas. Esses resultados demonstram as possibilidades de produção de raízes de C. rosea e conservação em longo prazo através da criopreservação, iniciando estudos inéditos para a espécie.

Avaliação do potencial antimalárico de Norantea brasiliensis Choisy (Marcgraviaceae) cultivada in vitro e in vivo

A malária é uma doença infecciosa causada por protozoários do gênero Plasmodium, transmitidos ao homem, principalmente, através da picada do mosquito infectado. O tratamento é realizado por meio do uso de drogas, como a cloroquina, uma vez que não há vacina eficiente contra a doença. Porém, a resistência dos parasitos aos medicamentos tem levado à busca por novas substâncias com atividade antimalárica, inclusive de origem vegetal. Nesse contexto, o presente trabalho teve por objetivo avaliar a atividade antimalárica de extratos metanólicos de Norantea brasiliensis cultivada sob condições in vivo e in vitro, espécie nativa ocorrente em restingas, com potencial medicinal já comprovado para várias atividades. Foram desenvolvidos protocolos de calogênese e cultura de raízes da espécie visando à definição de um sistema de produção de metabólitos. Para a cultura in vitro, explantes foram inoculados em meio líquido e sólido contendo diferentes fitorreguladores e concentrações. A partir da cultura de tecidos, foram testados extratos do material produzido biotecnologicamente para comparação com o material botânico cultivado no campo. Os testes sobre o potencial antimalárico foram realizados in vivo, utilizando-se camundongos infectados pelo Plasmodium berghei ANKA, e in vitro utilizando o Plasmodium falciparum. Em seguida foram administrados a cloroquina e os extratos vegetais. A parasitemia foi observada seguindo os protocolos já estabelecidos pelo Laboratório de Imunofarmacologia do Instituto Oswaldo Cruz (IOC). Resultados mostraram que explantes foliares e caulinares de plantas germinadas in vitro, inoculados em meio sólido B5 suplementado com 2,0 mg.mL-1 de ANA, são as melhores fontes para a produção de raízes, apresentando maiores valores de peso fresco e peso seco, mostrando-se um sistema promissor para a produção in vitro de metabólitos da espécie. A avaliação da atividade antimalárica in vivo revelou seu potencial a partir de extrato de raízes de planta cultivada in vivo, na concentração de 50 mg/kg apresentando redução significativa da parasitemia quando comparada com o controle não tratado. Paralelamente, nos testes in vitro a concentração de 100 μg/kg do extrato de raízes de planta cultivada in vivo apresentou diferença significativa quando comparada com as outras concentrações testadas e o controle negativo. Além disso, há uma tendência de aumento do efeito inibitório conforme o aumento da concentração do extrato. Os resultados indicam o potencial de atividade antimalárica em raízes de N. brasiliensis, sendo este estudo o primeiro realizado para a espécie

Impact of various endocrine and paracrine factors on in vitro culture of preantral follicles in rodents

Folliculogenesis is a complex process regulated by various paracrine and autocrine factors. In vitro growth systems of primordial and preantral follicles have been developed for future use of immature oocytes, as sources of fertilizable oocytes and for studying follicular growth and oocyte maturation mechanisms. Rodents were often chosen for in vitro follicular culture research and a lot of factors implicated in folliculogenesis have been identified using this model. To date, the mouse is the only species in which the whole process of follicular growth, oocyte maturation, fertilization and embryo transfer into recipient females was successfully performed. However, the efficiency of in vitro culture systems must still be considerably improved. Within the follicle, numerous events affect cell proliferation and the acquisition of oocyte developmental competency in vitro, including interactions between the follicular cells and the oocyte, and the composition of the culture medium. Effects of the acting factors depend on the stage of follicle development, the culture system used and the species. This paper reviews the action of endocrine, paracrine factors and other components of culture medium on in vitro growth of preantral follicles in rodents.

Meios de cultura no desenvolvimento de ápices caulinares de mamoneira (Ricinus communis L.) in vitro

A pesquisa da composição do meio de cultura mais adequado à espécie vegetal e ao tipo de explante empregado é o fator de maior relevância da cultura de tecidos. O cultivo de ápice caulinar com recuperação da planta matriz é uma técnica de grande impacto para a propagação de plantas in vitro, regeneração de plantas livres de vírus, conservação de germoplasma e modificação genética. Objetivou-se, neste trabalho, avaliar composições do meio de cultivo para organogênese direta in vitro a partir de ápices caulinares pertencentes à população FCA-UNESP-PB de mamoneira (Ricinus communis L.), com vistas à propagação clonal de genótipos elite. Foram testadas quatro formulações: MS básico (T1), MS modificado 1 (T2), MS modificado 2 (T3) e WPM (T4), em delineamento experimental inteiramente casualizado, com 20 repetições em cada tratamento, sendo a repetição 1 ápice caulinar/frasco. O T3 apresentou-se superior e diferiu significativamente dos outros tratamentos apresentando 35% dos ápices caulinares diferenciados e desenvolvidos; seguiu-se o T2 com 10% e os tratamentos T1 e T4 não apresentaram diferenciação de tecidos. Os resultados permitiram concluir que os balanceamentos de sais minerais nos meios de cultura avaliados, especialmente a relação NO3 / NH4 e ausência de FeSO4.7H2O, indicaram grande influência no desenvolvimento de ápices caulinares de mamoneira.