Where Stories Collide : Montage and the Short Story Cycle

This thesis uses Sergei Eisenstein’s filmic theories of montage to examine the modernist American short story cycle, a genre of independent short stories that work together to create a larger and interrelated whole. Similar to the shot-by-shot editing process of montage, the story cycle builds its intertextual meaning story-by-story from an aggregate of abrupt narrative transitions and juxtapositions. Eisenstein famously felt that montage, the editing together of film fragments, was not a process of linkage, but of collision –each radically different shot in a film should crash into the next shot, until audience members were intellectually provoked into synthesizing these collisions through dialectical processes. I offer montage as an interpretive strategy for negotiating the narrative collisions in story cycles such as Sherwood Anderson’s Winesburg, Ohio, William Faulkner’s Go Down, Moses, and Eudora Welty’s The Golden Apples. For Go Down, Moses, I argue that Eisenstein’s politically rendered “montage of attractions” provides a template for investigating the shock tactics behind Faulkner’s chronologically and racially entangled stories of whites and African Americans. For The Golden Apples, I consider the opposites and doubles in Welty’s fiction with Eisenstein’s similar belief in the “opposing passions” of the world. Not only, then, do I suggest that the modernist story cycle bears a cinematic influence, but I also offer Eisenstein’s theories of montage and collision as a heuristic for formal, thematic, and even political patterns in a genre infamous for its resistance to definition and classification.

First U.S. battleships through Panama Canal: Missouri, Ohio, Wisconsin (postcard ca 1914)

Leonard Carpenter Panama Canal Collection. Photographs: Dredging, Soldiers, and Ships. [Box 1] from the Special Collections & Area Studies Department, George A. Smathers Libraries, University of Florida.

U.S.S. Ohio, Panama Canal (ca. 1914)

Leonard Carpenter Panama Canal Collection. Photographs: Dredging, Soldiers, and Ships. [Box 1] from the Special Collections & Area Studies Department, George A. Smathers Libraries, University of Florida.

The Moravian missions in Ohio. By Francis C. Huebner.

http://www.archive.org/details/moravianmissions014001mbp

Diary of David Zeisberger a Moravian missionary among the Indians of Ohio

http://www.archive.org/details/diaryofdavid01zeisrich http://www.archive.org/details/diaryofdavid02zeisrich

The Missionary pioneer, or, A brief memoir of the life, labours, and death of John Stewart, (man of colour) founder, under God of the mission among the Wyandotts at Upper Sandusky, Ohio / Published by Joseph Mitchell.

http://www.archive.org/details/missionarypionee00stewrich

[Illisible, le sénateur de l'] Ohio, Warren G. Harding : [photographie de presse] / [Agence Rol]

Référence bibliographique : Rol, 58591

[James Middleton] Cox, gouverneur de l'Ohio : [photographie de presse] / [Agence Rol]

Référence bibliographique : Rol, 58595

Boulevard du Dayton News (Ohio), propriété de M. [le sénateur James] Cox [angle de S. Ludlow St. et W. 4th St. à Dayton, Ohio] : [photographie de presse] / [Agence Rol]

Référence bibliographique : Rol, 60120

Citizens’ Savings and Loan Association, Cleveland, Ohio passbook

Citizens’ Savings and Loan Association, Cleveland, Ohio passbook issued to Isabel G. Price, 1882- 1901.

Printed blank sent to Mr. B. Allen from the Clough Stone Co. of North Amherst, Ohio, Miners and Manufacturers of Grindstones and Building Stone

Printed blank sent to Mr. B. Allen from the Clough Stone Co. of North Amherst, Ohio, Miners and Manufacturers of Grindstones and Building Stone regarding shipping. This is signed by Mr. Davis, July 19, 1876.

Sketches of the campaign in northern México in eighteen hundred forty-six and seven by an officer of the first regiment of Ohio volunteers.

UANL