Emergence of multidrug-resistant tuberculosis in a community-based directly observed treatment programme in rural South Africa

OBJECTIVE: Although little studied in developing countries, multidrug-resistant tuberculosis (MDR-TB) is considered a major threat. We report the molecular epidemiology, clinical features and outcome of an emerging MDR-TB epidemic. METHODS: In 1996 all tuberculosis suspects in the rural Hlabisa district, South Africa, had sputum cultured, and drug susceptibility patterns of mycobacterial isolates were determined. Isolates with MDR-TB (resistant to both isoniazid and rifampicin) were DNA fingerprinted by restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) using IS6110 and polymorphic guanine-cytosine-rich sequence-based (PGRS) probes. Patients with MDR-TB were traced to determine outcome. Data were compared with results from a survey of drug susceptibility done in 1994. RESULTS: The rate of MDR-TB among smear-positive patients increased six-fold from 0.36% (1/275) in 1994 to 2.3% (13/561) in 1996 (P = 0.04). A further eight smear-negative cases were identified in 1996 from culture, six of whom had not been diagnosed with tuberculosis. MDR disease was clinically suspected in only five of the 21 cases (24%). Prevalence of primary and acquired MDR-TB was 1.8% and 4.1%, respectively. Twelve MDR-TB cases (67%) were in five RFLP-defined clusters. Among 20 traced patients, 10 (50%) had died, five had active disease (25%) and five (25%) were apparently cured. CONCLUSIONS: The rate of MDR-TB has risen rapidly in Hlabisa, apparently due to both reactivation disease and recent transmission. Many patients were not diagnosed with tuberculosis and many were not suspected of drug-resistant disease, and outcome was poor.

A psychological treatment programme for traumatised exmilitary personnel in the UK

A large proportion of homeless people in the UK are former members of the armed services and suffer from a mental illness. In fact, homelessness itself can be considered a symptom or manifestation of other underlying psychological difficulties. For these reasons Community Housing and Therapy (CHT) considers that providing psychological therapies to treat the homeless population is a more effective way of tackling the problem of homelessness, as it addresses the roots of the problem. This approach is one which is beginning to be recognized by leading agencies in the field. At the same time, the provision of psychological therapies for symptoms such as depression and anxiety has become accepted through the Department of Health’s (DoH) Increased Access to Psychological Therapies ( IAPT) initiative. Depression is the most common psychiatric disorder that homeless people suffer and it is well documented that psychological treatments for depression can be extremely effective. As well as approaching homelessness from the angle of psychological therapies, CHT in its work with the ex-service community has become increasingly aware that there are a large number of non statutory homeless that do not get the same attention as rough sleepers.

Effectiveness of a treatment programme for immigrants who committed gender-based violence against their partners

Resumen tomado de la publicación

Outcomes of the South African National Antiretroviral Treatment Programme for children: the IeDEA Southern Africa collaboration

OBJECTIVES: To assess paediatric antiretroviral treatment (ART) outcomes and their associations from a collaborative cohort representing 20% of the South African national treatment programme. DESIGN AND SETTING: Multi-cohort study of 7 public sector paediatric ART programmes in Gauteng, Western Cape and KwaZulu-Natal provinces. SUBJECTS: ART-naive children (< or = 16 years) who commenced treatment with > or = 3 antiretroviral drugs before March 2008. OUTCOME MEASURES: Time to death or loss to follow-up were assessed using the Kaplan-Meier method. Associations between baseline characteristics and mortality were assessed with Cox proportional hazards models stratified by site. Immune status, virological suppression and growth were described in relation to duration of ART. RESULTS: The median (interquartile range) age of 6 078 children with 9 368 child-years of follow-up was 43 (15 - 83) months, with 29% being < 18 months. Most were severely ill at ART initiation. More than 75% of children were appropriately monitored at 6-monthly intervals with viral load suppression (< 400 copies/ml) being 80% or above throughout 36 months of treatment. Mortality and retention in care at 3 years were 7.7% (95% confidence interval 7.0 - 8.6%) and 81.4% (80.1 - 82.6%), respectively. Together with young age, all markers of disease severity (low weight-for-age z-score, high viral load, severe immune suppression, stage 3/4 disease and anaemia) were independently associated with mortality. CONCLUSIONS: Dramatic clinical benefit for children accessing the national ART programme is demonstrated. Higher mortality in infants and those with advanced disease highlights the need for early diagnosis of HIV infection and commencement of ART.

Uptake of and virological response to antiretroviral therapy among HIV-infected former and current injecting drug users and persons in an opiate substitution treatment programme: the Swiss HIV Cohort Study

OBJECTIVES: The aim of the study was to investigate the influence of continued injecting drug use, enrolment in an opiate substitution treatment programme (OSTP), or cessation of injecting drug use on the uptake and course of antiretroviral therapy (ART). Design A prospective observational study of all participants in the Swiss HIV Cohort Study followed between 1997 and 2006 was carried out. METHODS: We distinguished four groups of former or current injecting drug users (IDUs): (i) abstinent former IDUs; (ii) persons in OSTPs without concomitant injecting drug use; (iii) persons in OSTPs with concomitant injecting drug use; (vi) current IDUs. These groups were compared with a group of patients who had never been IDUs. Factors related to ART uptake and virological endpoints were analysed using logistic generalized estimating equations. RESULTS: We followed 8660 participants for 48 477 person-years; 29.7% were in the IDU HIV transmission group. The likelihood of being on ART at biannual visits was lower among individuals in OSTPs with concomitant injecting drug use [odds ratio (OR) 0.79; 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.71-0.89] and current IDUs (OR 0.80; 95% CI 0.67-0.96), compared with those who had never been IDUs (reference), abstinent former IDUs (OR 1.13; 95% CI 1.02-1.25) and individuals in OSTPs without injecting drug use (OR 1.18; 95% CI 1.06-1.31). The likelihood of suppressed viral replication on ART was similar among those who had never been IDUs, abstinent former IDUs and individuals in an OSTP without injecting drug use, and lower among those in OSTPs with concomitant drug use (OR 0.82; 95% CI 0.72-0.93) and current IDUs (OR 0.81; 0.65-1.00). Adherence to ART was decreased among persons with continued injecting drug use, and correlated with virological outcome. CONCLUSIONS: Uptake of and virological response to ART were improved among abstinent former IDUs and persons in OSTPs without concomitant injecting drug use, compared with persons with continued injecting drug use.

GIS/GPS to document increased access to community-based treatment for tuberculosis in Africa

Application of geographic information system (GIS) and global positioning system (GPS) technology in the Hlabisa community-based tuberculosis treatment programme documents the increase in accessibility to treatment after the expansion of the service from health facilities to include community workers and volunteers.

The impact of repeated treatment with praziquantel of schistosomiasis in children under six years of age living in an endemic area for Schistosoma haematobium infection

Praziquantel was given every eight weeks for two years to children aged under six years of age, living in a Schistosoma haematobium endemic area. Infection with S. haematobium and haematuria were examined in urine and antibody profiles (IgA, IgE, IgM, IgG1, IgG2, IgG3, and IgG4) against S. haematobium adult worm and egg antigens were determined from sera collected before each treatment. Chemotherapy reduced infection prevalence and mean intensity from 51.8% and 110 eggs per 10 ml urine, respectively, before starting re-treatment programme to very low levels thereafter. Praziquantel is not accumulated after periodic administration in children. Immunoglobulin levels change during the course of treatment with a shift towards 'protective' mechanisms. The significant changes noted in some individuals were the drop in 'blocking' IgG2 and IgG4 whereas the 'protecting' IgA and IgG1 levels increased. The antibody profiles in the rest of the children remained generally unchanged throughout the study and no haematuria was observed after the second treatment. The removal of worms before production of large number of eggs, prevented the children from developing morbidity.

A Process Analysis of Males and Females who Attended a Community Based Addiction Treatment Service: Towards an Expanded Paradigm

A process analysis was conducted in a community - based treatment programme for alcohol abuse. The aims of the study were: to evaluate assessment instruments and measures; to measure change following treatment; to monitor gender differences; to assess the importance of early and current relationships; and to evaluate the effects of therapists. Subjects (n=145, males 83/females 62) completed a semi-structured interview schedule, Severity of Alcohol Dependency Questionnaire (SADQ), Short Alcohol Dependence Data Questionnaire (SADD); General Health Questionnaire (GHQ 12), and Alcohol Problems Questionnaire (APQ). A further three non-standardised self-rated measures were devised by the author. Included was the opportunity to obtain qualitative data. Follow up data was collected at 3, 9 and 15 months following first assessment. The SADD, APQ and consumption measures using detailed drink diaries proved the most relevant assessment measures. Following treatment, there was significant reduction in clients' dependency levels at 3 months, maintained through 9 and 15 months. Key client-rated changes were progress in reducing consumption and alcohol problems leading to a better quality of life and health. Qualitative data augmented these quantitative results. Psychological and acquired cognitive behavioural skills emerged as the main reasons for positive change and the treatment programme was found to have played a significant role in their acquisition. It appears that addressing marital problems can lead to a reduction in alcohol dependency levels. Gender analysis showed that males and females were similar in demographic characteristics, alcohol history details and dependence levels. It was concluded that the differences found did not necessitate different treatment programmes for women. Early family relationships were more problematic for females. Therapist performance varied and that variance was reflected in their clients' outcomes.This resource was contributed by The National Documentation Centre on Drug Use.

Differences in access and patient outcomes across antiretroviral treatment clinics in the Free State province: a prospective cohort study

Objective. To assess differences in access to antiretroviral treatment (ART) and patient outcomes across public sector treatment facilities in the Free State province, South Africa. Design. Prospective cohort study with retrospective database linkage. We analysed data on patients enrolled in the treatment programme across 36 facilities between May 2004 and December 2007, and assessed percentage initiating ART and percentage dead at 1 year after enrolment. Multivariable logistic regression was used to estimate associations of facility-level and patient-level characteristics with both mortality and treatment status. Results. Of 44 866 patients enrolled, 15 219 initiated treatment within 1 year; 8 778 died within 1 year, 7 286 before accessing ART. Outcomes at 1 year varied greatly across facilities and more variability was explained by facility-level factors than by patient-level factors. The odds of starting treatment within 1 year improved over calendar time. Patients enrolled in facilities with treatment initiation available on site had higher odds of starting treatment and lower odds of death at 1 year compared with those enrolled in facilities that did not offer treatment initiation. Patients were less likely to start treatment if they were male, severely immunosuppressed (CD4 count ≤50 cells/μl), or underweight (<50 kg). Men were also more likely to die in the first year after enrolment. Conclusions. Although increasing numbers of patients started ART between 2004 and 2007, many patients died before accessing ART. Patient outcomes could be improved by decentralisation of treatment services, fast-tracking the most immunodeficient patients and improving access, especially for men.

Correcting mortality for loss to follow-up: a nomogram applied to antiretroviral treatment programmes in sub-Saharan Africa

Background The World Health Organization estimates that in sub-Saharan Africa about 4 million HIV-infected patients had started antiretroviral therapy (ART) by the end of 2008. Loss of patients to follow-up and care is an important problem for treatment programmes in this region. As mortality is high in these patients compared to patients remaining in care, ART programmes with high rates of loss to follow-up may substantially underestimate mortality of all patients starting ART. Methods and Findings We developed a nomogram to correct mortality estimates for loss to follow-up, based on the fact that mortality of all patients starting ART in a treatment programme is a weighted average of mortality among patients lost to follow-up and patients remaining in care. The nomogram gives a correction factor based on the percentage of patients lost to follow-up at a given point in time, and the estimated ratio of mortality between patients lost and not lost to follow-up. The mortality observed among patients retained in care is then multiplied by the correction factor to obtain an estimate of programme-level mortality that takes all deaths into account. A web calculator directly calculates the corrected, programme-level mortality with 95% confidence intervals (CIs). We applied the method to 11 ART programmes in sub-Saharan Africa. Patients retained in care had a mortality at 1 year of 1.4% to 12.0%; loss to follow-up ranged from 2.8% to 28.7%; and the correction factor from 1.2 to 8.0. The absolute difference between uncorrected and corrected mortality at 1 year ranged from 1.6% to 9.8%, and was above 5% in four programmes. The largest difference in mortality was in a programme with 28.7% of patients lost to follow-up at 1 year. Conclusions The amount of bias in mortality estimates can be large in ART programmes with substantial loss to follow-up. Programmes should routinely report mortality among patients retained in care and the proportion of patients lost. A simple nomogram can then be used to estimate mortality among all patients who started ART, for a range of plausible mortality rates among patients lost to follow-up.

Immunologic response to antiretroviral therapy in hepatitis C virus-coinfected adults in a population-based HIV/AIDS treatment program

BACKGROUND: We sought to characterize the impact that hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection has on CD4 cells during the first 48 weeks of antiretroviral therapy (ART) in previously ART-naive human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-infected patients. METHODS: The HIV/AIDS Drug Treatment Programme at the British Columbia Centre for Excellence in HIV/AIDS distributes all ART in this Canadian province. Eligible individuals were those whose first-ever ART included 2 nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors and either a protease inhibitor or a nonnucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitor and who had a documented positive result for HCV antibody testing. Outcomes were binary events (time to an increase of > or = 75 CD4 cells/mm3 or an increase of > or = 10% in the percentage of CD4 cells in the total T cell population [CD4 cell fraction]) and continuous repeated measures. Statistical analyses used parametric and nonparametric methods, including multivariate mixed-effects linear regression analysis and Cox proportional hazards analysis. RESULTS: Of 1186 eligible patients, 606 (51%) were positive and 580 (49%) were negative for HCV antibodies. HCV antibody-positive patients were slower to have an absolute (P<.001) and a fraction (P = .02) CD4 cell event. In adjusted Cox proportional hazards analysis (controlling for age, sex, baseline absolute CD4 cell count, baseline pVL, type of ART initiated, AIDS diagnosis at baseline, adherence to ART regimen, and number of CD4 cell measurements), HCV antibody-positive patients were less likely to have an absolute CD4 cell event (adjusted hazard ratio [AHR], 0.84 [95% confidence interval [CI], 0.72-0.98]) and somewhat less likely to have a CD4 cell fraction event (AHR, 0.89 [95% CI, 0.70-1.14]) than HCV antibody-negative patients. In multivariate mixed-effects linear regression analysis, HCV antibody-negative patients had increases of an average of 75 cells in the absolute CD4 cell count and 4.4% in the CD4 cell fraction, compared with 20 cells and 1.1% in HCV antibody-positive patients, during the first 48 weeks of ART, after adjustment for time-updated pVL, number of CD4 cell measurements, and other factors. CONCLUSION: HCV antibody-positive HIV-infected patients may have an altered immunologic response to ART.

Improving family functioning and child outcome in methadone maintained families: the Parents Under Pressure programme

Twelve families responded to posters displayed in a methadone clinic for inclusion in a pilot study assessing the viability and potential utility of an intensive, multi-component family-focused intervention, the Parents Under Pressure programme. The programme was designed to improve child behaviour, decrease parental stress and improve family functioning in methadone-maintained families by targeting affect regulation, mood, views of self as a parent, drug use and parenting skills. Nine of the families completed the programme delivered in their homes; eight were recontacted at 3 months. Each family reported significant improvements in three domains: parental functioning, parent - child relationship and parental substance use and risk behaviour. In addition to the changes in family functioning, the majority of families reported a decrease in concurrent alcohol use, HIV risk-taking behaviour and maintenance dose of methadone. The families reported high levels of satisfaction with the programme. It is recommended that future studies include independent measures (e.g. behavioural observations) of child outcome and parental functioning. The results were optimistic and provided the impetus to evaluate the treatment programme using a randomized controlled trial.

Randomized controlled trial of two cigarette quit programmes in coronary care patients after acute myocardial infarction

Background: Tobacco cessation after acute myocardial infarction (AMI) substantially improves outcome but how effective individual programmes are needs to be established. To date, few studies have examined this factor. Aims: To assess the outcome of two smoking cessation programmes after AMI. Methods: One hundred and ninety-eight current smokers admitted to coronary care with an AMI participated in a randomized controlled study comparing two outpatient tobacco interventions, the Stanford Heart Attack Staying Free (SF) programme and a Usual Care (UC) programme. Results: Log-rank analyses revealed that patients in the SF programme were retained longer (P < 0.001) and had higher cotinine validated abstinence rates (P < 0.001) compared with patients in the UC programme. Twelve months after intervention, 39% of the SF programme compared with 2% of the UC programme demonstrated cotinine validated tobacco cessation, representing a significant reduced relapse rate in the SF programme (chi (2), P < 0.001). Conclusions: The SF smoking cessation programme initiated in hospital can significantly reduce smoking rates at 12 months after myocardial infarction. Although superior to the UC quit programme, Australian outcomes were lower than the American programme originators' published outcomes.

Key-elements of family interventions for psychosis : a qualitative research

RESUMO:As perturbações psicóticas são doenças mentais complexas sendo influenciadas na sua etiologia e prognóstico por factores biológicos e psicossociais. A interferência do ambiente familiar na evolução da doença espelha bem esta realidade. Quando em 1962 George Brown e colaboradores descobriram que ambientes familiares com elevada Emoção Expressa (EE) contribuíam para um aumento significativo do número de recaídas de pessoas com esquizofrenia (Brown et al., 1962), estava aberto o caminho para o desenvolvimento de novas intervenções familiares. A EE inclui cinco componentes: três componentes negativos, i.e. criticismo, hostilidade e envolvimento emocional excessivo; e dois componentes positivos, i.e. afectividade e apreço (Amaresha & Venkatasubramanian, 2012; Kuipers et al., 2002). No final dos anos 1970 surgiram os primeiros trabalhos na área das intervenções familiares nas psicoses (IFP). Dois grupos em países diferentes, no Reino Unido e nos Estados Unidos da América, desenvolveram quase em simultâneo duas abordagens distintas. Em Londres, a equipa liderada por Julian Leff desenhava uma intervenção combinando sessões unifamiliares em casa, incluindo o paciente, e sessões em grupo, apenas para os familiares (Leff et al., 1982). Por seu turno, em Pittsburgh, Gerard Hogarty e colaboradores desenvolviam uma abordagem que compreendia a dinamização de sessões educativas em grupo (Anderson e tal., 1980). Para designar este trabalho, Hogarty e colaboradores propuseram o termo “psicoeducação”. As IFP começaram a ser conhecidas por esta designação que se generalizou até aos dias de hoje. Neste contexto a educação era vista como a partilha de informação acerca da doença, dos profissionais para os familiares. Nas sessões os profissionais eram informados acerca das manifestações, etiologia, tratamento e evolução das psicoses, bem como de formas para lidar com as situações difíceis geradas pela doença, e.g. risco de recaída. Os trabalhos pioneiros das IFP foram rapidamente sucedidos pelo desenvolvimento de novos modelos e a proliferação de estudos de eficácia. Para além dos modelos de Leff e Hogarty, os modelos IFP que ficaram mais conhecidos foram: (1) a Terapia Familiar-Comportamental, desenvolvida por Ian Falloon e colaboradores (Falloon et al., 1984); e (2) a Terapia Multifamiliar em Grupo, desenvolvida por William McFarlane e colaboradores (McFarlane, 1991). O incremento de estudos de eficácia contribuiu rapidamente para as primeiras meta-análises. Estas, por sua vez, resultaram na inclusão das IFP nas normas de orientação clínica mais relevantes para o tratamento das psicoses, nomeadamente da esquizofrenia (e.g. PORT Recomendations e NICE Guidelines). No geral os estudos apontavam para uma diminuição do risco de recaída na esquizofrenia na ordem dos 20 a 50% em dois anos (Pitschel-Walz et al., 2001). No final dos anos 1990 as IFP atingiam assim o apogeu. Contudo, a sua aplicação prática tem ficado aquém do esperado e as barreiras à implementação das IFP passaram a ser o foco das atenções (Gonçalves-Pereira et al., 2006; Leff, 2000). Simultaneamente, alguns autores começaram a levantar a questão da incerteza sobre quais os elementos-chave da intervenção. O conhecimento sobre o processo das IFP era reduzido e começaram a surgir as primeiras publicações sobre o assunto (Lam, 1991). Em 1997 foi dinamizada uma reunião de consenso entre os três investigadores mais relevantes do momento, Falloon, Leff e McFarlane. Deste encontro promovido pela World Schizophrenia Fellowship for Schizophrenia and Allied Disorders surgiu um documento estabelecendo dois objectivos e quinze princípios para as IFP (WFSAD, 1997). Não obstante os contributos que foram feitos, continua a existir uma grande falta de evidência empírica acerca do processo das IFP e dos seus elementos-chave (Cohen et al., 2008; Dixon et al., 2001; Lam, 1991; Leff, 2000; McFarlane et al., 2003). Também em Portugal, apesar da reflexão teórica nesta área e do registo de ensaios de efectividade de grupos para familiares – estudo FAPS (Gonçalves-Pereira, 2010), os componentes fundamentais das IFP nunca foram analisados directamente. Assim, o projecto de investigação descrito nesta tese teve como objectivo identificar os elementos-chave das IFP com base em investigação qualitativa. Para tal, conduzimos três estudos que nos permitiriam alcançar dados empíricos sobre o tema. O primeiro estudo (descrito no Capítulo 2) consistiu na realização de uma revisão sistemática da literatura científica acerca das variáveis relacionadas com o processo das IFP. A nossa pesquisa esteve focada essencialmente em estudos qualitativos. Contudo, decidimos não restringir demasiado os critérios de inclusão tendo em conta as dificuldades em pesquisar sobre investigação qualitativa nas bases de dados electrónicas e também devido ao facto de ser possível obter informação sobre as variáveis relacionadas com o processo a partir de estudos quantitativos. O método para este estudo foi baseado no PRISMA Statement para revisões sistemáticas da literatura. Depois de definirmos os critérios de inclusão e exclusão, iniciámos várias pesquisas nas bases de dados electrónicas utilizando termos booleanos, truncações e marcadores de campo. Pesquisámos na PubMed/MEDLINE, Web of Science e nas bases de dados incluídas na EBSCO Host (Academic Search Complete; Education Research Complete; Education Source; ERIC; and PsycINFO). As pesquisas geraram 733 resultados. Depois de serem removidos os duplicados, 663 registos foram analisados e foram seleccionados 38 artigos em texto integral. No final, 22 artigos foram incluídos na síntese qualitativa tendo sido agrupados em quatro categorias: (1) estudos examinando de forma abrangente o processo; (2) estudos acerca da opinião dos participantes sobre a intervenção que receberam; (3) estudos comparativos que individualizaram variáveis sobre o processo; e (4) estudos acerca de variáveis mediadoras. Os resultados evidenciaram um considerável hiato na investigação em torno do processo das IFP. Identificámos apenas um estudo que abordava de forma abrangente o processo das IFP (Bloch, et al., 1995). Este artigo descrevia uma análise qualitativa de um estudo experimental de uma IFP. Contudo, as suas conclusões gerais revelaramse pobres e apenas se podia extrair com certeza de que as IFP devem ser baseadas nas necessidades dos participantes e que os terapeutas devem assumir diferentes papéis ao longo da intervenção. Da revisão foi possível perceber que os factores terapêuticos comuns como a aliança terapêutica, empatia, apreço e a “aceitação incondicional”, podiam ser eles próprios um elemento isolado para a eficácia das IFP. Outros estudos enfatizaram a educação como elemento chave da intervenção (e.g. Levy-Frank et al., 2011), ao passo que outros ainda colocavam a ênfase no treino de estratégias para lidar com a doença i.e. coping (e.g. Tarrier et al., 1988). Com base nesta diversidade de resultados e tendo em conta algumas propostas prévias de peritos (McFarlane, 1991; Liberman & Liberman, 2003), desenvolvemos a hipótese de concebermos as IFP como um processo por etapas, de acordo com as necessidades dos familiares. No primeiro nível estariam as estratégias relacionadas com os factores terapêuticos comuns e o suporte emocional,no segundo nível a educação acerca da doença, e num nível mais avançado, o foco seria o treino de estratégias para lidar com a doença e diminuir a EE. Neste estudo concluímos que nem todas as famílias iriam precisar de IFP complexas e que nesses casos seria possível obter resultados favoráveis com IFP pouco intensas. O Estudo 2 (descrito no Capítulo 3) consistiu numa análise qualitativa dos registos clínicos do primeiro ensaio clínico da IFP de Leff e colaboradores (Leff et al., 1982). Este ensaio clínico culminou numa das evidências mais substanciais alguma vez alcançada com uma IFP (Leff et al., 1982; Leff et al., 1985; Pitschel-Walz et al., 2001). Este estudo teve como objectivo modular a EE recorrendo a um modelo misto com que compreendia sessões familiares em grupo e algumas sessões unifamiliares em casa, incluindo o paciente. Os resultados mostraram uma diminuição das recaídas em nove meses de 50% no grupo de controlo para 8% no grupo experimental. Os registos analisados neste estudo datam do período de 1977 a 1982 e podem ser considerados como material histórico de alto valor, que surpreendentemente nunca tinha sido analisado. Eram compostos por descrições pormenorizadas dos terapeutas, incluindo excertos em discurso directo e estavam descritos segundo uma estrutura, contendo também os comentários dos terapeutas. No total os registos representavam 85 sessões em grupo para familiares durante os cinco anos do ensaio clínico e 25 sessões unifamiliares em casa incluindo o paciente. Para a análise qualitativa decidimos utilizar um método de análise dedutivo, com uma abordagem mecânica de codificação dos registos em categorias previamente definidas. Tomámos esta decisão com base na extensão apreciável dos registos e porque tínhamos disponível informação válida acerca das categorias que iríamos encontrar nos mesmos, nomeadamente a informação contida no manual da intervenção, publicado sob a forma de livro, e nos resultados da 140 nossa revisão sistemática da literatura (Estudo 1). Deste modo, foi construída uma grelha com a estrutura de codificação, que serviu de base para a análise, envolvendo 15 categorias. De modo a cumprir com critérios de validade e fidelidade rigorosos, optámos por executar uma dupla codificação independente. Deste modo dois observadores leram e codificaram independentemente os registos. As discrepâncias na codificação foram revistas até se obter um consenso. No caso de não ser possível chegar a acordo, um terceiro observador, mais experiente nos aspectos técnicos das IFP, tomaria a decisão sobre a codificação. A análise foi executada com recurso ao programa informático NVivo® versão 10 (QSR International). O número de vezes que cada estratégia foi utilizada foi contabilizado, especificando a sessão e o participante. Os dados foram depois exportados para uma base de dados e analisados recorrendo ao programa informático de análise estatística SPSS® versão 20 (IBM Corp.). Foram realizadas explorações estatísticas para descrever os dados e obter informação sobre possíveis relações entre as variáveis. De modo a perceber a significância das observações, recorremos a testes de hipóteses, utilizando as equações de estimação generalizadas. Os resultados da análise revelaram que as estratégias terapêuticas mais utilizadas na intervenção em grupo foram: (1) a criação de momentos para ouvir as necessidades dos participantes e para a partilha de preocupações entre eles – representando 21% de todas as estratégias utilizadas; (2) treino e aconselhamento acerca de formas para lidar com os aspectos mais difíceis da doença – 15%; (3) criar condições para que os participantes recebam suporte emocional – 12%; (4) lidar com o envolvimento emocional excessivo 10%; e (5) o reenquadramento das atribuições dos familiares acerca dos comportamentos dos pacientes – 10%. Nas sessões unifamiliares em casa, as estratégias mais utilizadas foram: (1) lidar com o envolvimento emocional excessivo – representando 33% de todas as estratégias utilizadas nas sessões unifamiliares em casa; (2) treino e aconselhamento acerca de formas para lidar com os aspectos desafiadores da doença – 22%; e (3) o reenquadramento das atribuições dos familiares acerca dos comportamentos dos pacientes, juntamente com o lidar com a zanga, o conflito e a rejeição – ambas com 10%. A análise longitudinal mostrou que a criação de momentos para ouvir as necessidades dos familiares tende a acontecer invariavelmente ao longo do programa. Sempre que isso acontece, são geralmente utilizadas estratégias para ajudar os familiares a lidarem melhor com os aspectos difíceis da doença e estratégias para fomentar o suporte emocional. Por sua vez, foi possível perceber que o trabalho para diminuir o envolvimento emocional excessivo pode acontecer logo nas primeiras sessões. O reenquadramento e o lidar com a zanga/ conflito/ rejeição tendem a acontecer a partir da fase intermédia até às últimas sessões. A análise das diferenças entre os familiares com baixa EE e os de elevada EE, mostrou que os familiares com elevada EE tendem a tornar-se o foco da intervenção grupal. Por sua vez, os familiares com baixa EE recebem mais estratégias relacionadas com aliança terapêutica, comparativamente com os familiares com elevada EE. São de realçar os dados relativamente às estratégias educativas. Foi possível observar que estas tendem a acontecer mais no início dos grupos, não estando associadas a outras estratégias. Contudo é de notar a sua baixa utilização, a rondar apenas os 5%.O Estudo 3 (descrito no Capítulo 4) surgiu como uma forma de completar a análise do Estudo 2, permitindo uma visão mais narrativa do processo e focando, adicionalmente, as mudanças que ocorrem nos participantes. Com base nos mesmos registos utilizados no Estudo 2, codificámos de forma secundária os registos em duas categorias i.e. marcadores de mudança e marcadores emocionais. Os marcadores de mudança foram cotados sempre que um participante exibia comportamentos ou pensamentos diferentes dos anteriores no sentido de uma eventual redução na EE. Os marcadores emocionais correspondiam à expressão intensa de sentimentos por parte dos participantes nas sessões e que estariam relacionados com assuntos-chave para essas pessoas. Os excertos que continham a informação destes marcadores foram posteriormente revistos e articulados com notas e comentários não estruturados que recolhemos durante a codificação do Estudo 2. Com base nesta informação os registos foram revistos e, utilizando um método indutivo, elaborámos uma narrativa acerca da intervenção. Os resultados da narrativa foram discutidos com dados de que dispúnhamos, referentes a reuniões com os terapeutas envolvidos na intervenção em análise (Elizabeth Kuipers, Ruth Berkowitz e Julian Leff; Londres, Novembro de 2011). Reconhecemos que, pela sua natureza não estruturada e indutiva, a avaliação narrativa está mais sujeita ao viés de observador. Não obstante, os resultados deste Estudo 3 parecem revestir uma consistência elevada. O mais relevante foi a evidência de que na intervenção em análise ocorreram mudanças emocionais significativas nos familiares ao longo das sessões em grupo. Numa fase inicial os familiares tenderam a expressar sentimentos de zanga. Seguidamente, os terapeutas iam nterrompendo o discurso de reminiscências, direccionavam o discurso para as suas preocupações actuais e os familiares pareciam ficar mais calmos. Contudo, à medida que os 143 participantes “mergulhavam” nos problemas com que se confrontavam na altura, os sentimentos de zanga davam lugar a sentimentos de perda e angústia. Nessa altura os terapeutas enfatizavam o suporte emocional e introduziam progressivamente técnicas de reenquadramento para ajudar os participantes a avaliar de forma mais positiva as situações. Este trabalho dava lugar a sentimentos mais positivos, como a aceitação, apreço e a sensação de controlo. O Estudo 3 evidenciou também o que designamos como o “Efeito de Passagem de Testemunho”. Este efeito aconteceu sempre que um membro novo se juntava ao grupo. Os membros antigos, que estavam a ser o alvo das atenções e naturalmente a receber mais intervenção, mudam de papel e passam eles próprios a focar as suas atenções nos membros mais recentes do grupo, contribuindo para a dinâmica do grupo com as mesmas intervenções que os ajudaram previamente. Por exemplo, alguns membros antigos que eram altamente críticos nos grupos em relação aos seus familiares passavam a fazer comentários de reenquadramento dirigidos para os novos membros. Por fim, o Capítulo 5 resume as conclusões gerais deste projecto de investigação. Os estudos apresentados permitiram um incremento no conhecimento acerca do processo das IFP. Anteriormente esta informação era baseada sobretudo na opinião de peritos. Com este projecto aumentámos o nível de evidência ao apresentar estudos com base em dados empíricos. A análise qualitativa do Estudo 2 permitiu pela primeira vez, tanto quanto é do nosso conhecimento, perceber de forma aprofundada o processo subjacente a uma IFP (no contexto de um ensaio clínico que se revelou como um dos mais eficazes de sempre). Identificámos as estratégias mais utilizadas, as relações entre elas e a sua diferente aplicação entre familiares com baixa EE e familiares com alta EE.O Estudo 3 completou a informação incluindo aspectos relacionados com as mudanças individuais durante o programa. No final foi possível perceber que as IFP devem ser um programa por etapas. Nos Estudo 2 e 3, evidenciámos que numa fase inicial, os terapeutas dedicaram especial atenção para que os familiares tivessem espaço para partilharem as suas necessidades, disponibilizando logo de seguida estratégias para promover o suporte emocional e estratégias de coping. Num nível subsequente do programa, o trabalho terapêutico avançou para estratégias mais direccionadas para regular a EE, mantendo sempre as estratégias iniciais ao longo das sessões. Assim apesar de a educação ter sido um componente importante na IFP em análise, houve outras estratégias mais relevantes no processo. A evidência gerada pelos Estudos 2 e 3 baseou-se em registos históricos de elevado valor, sendo que os constructos subjacentes na época, nomeadamente a EE, continuam a ser a base da investigação e prática das IFP a nível mundial em diferentes culturas (Butzlaff & Hooley, 1998). Concluímos que as IFP são um processo complexo com diferentes níveis de intervenção, podendo gerar mudanças emocionais nos participantes durante as sessões. No futuro será importante replicar o nosso trabalho (nomeadamente o Estudo 2) com outras abordagens de IFP, de modo a obter informação acerca do seu processo. Esse conhecimento será fundamental para uma possível evolução do paradigma das IFP. ----------- ABSTRACT: Background: Psychotic-spectrum disorders are complex biopsychosocial conditions and family issues are important determinants of prognosis. The discovery of the influence of expressed emotion on the course of schizophrenia paved the road to the development of family interventions aiming to lower the “emotional temperature” in the family. These treatment approaches became widely recognised. Effectiveness studies showed remarkable and strong results in relapse prevention and these interventions were generalised to other psychotic disorders besides schizophrenia. Family interventions for psychosis (FIP) prospered and were included in the most important treatment guidelines. However, there was little knowledge about the process of FIP. Different FIP approaches all led to similar outcomes. This intriguing fact caught the attention of authors and attempts were made to identify the key-elements of FIP. Notwithstanding, these efforts were mainly based on experts’ opinions and the conclusions were scanty. Therefore, the knowledge about the process of FIP remains unclear. Aims: To find out which are the key-elements of FIP based on empirical data. Methods: Qualitative research. Three studies were conducted to explore the process of FIP and isolate variables that allowed the identification of the key-elements of FIP. Study 1 consisted of a systematic literature review of studies evaluating process-related variables of FIP. Study 2 subjected the intervention records of a formerly conducted effective clinical trial of FIP to a qualitative analysis. Records were analysed into categories and the emerging data were explored using descriptive statistics and generalised estimating equations. Study 3 consisted of a narrative evaluation using an inductive qualitative approach, examining the same data of Study 2. Emotional markers and markers of change were identified in the records and the content of these excerpts was synthesised and discussed. Results: On Study 1, searches revealed 733 results and 22 papers were included in the qualitative synthesis. We found a single study comprehensively exploring the process of FIP. All other studies focused on particular aspects of the process-related variables. The key-elements of FIP seemed to be the so-called “common therapeutic factors”, followed by education about the illness and coping skills training. Other elements were also identified, as the majority of studies evidenced a multiple array of components. Study 2,revealed as the most used strategies in the intervention programme we analysed: the addressing of needs; sharing; coping skills and advice; emotional support; dealing with overinvolvement; and reframing relatives’ views about patients’ behaviours. Patterns of the usefulness of the strategies throughout the intervention programme were identified and differences between high expressed emotion and low expressed emotion relatives were elucidated. Study 3 accumulated evidence that relatives experience different emotions during group sessions, ranging from anger to grief, and later on, to acceptance and positive feelings. Discussion: Study 1 suggested a stepped model of intervention according to the needs of the families. It also revealed a gap in qualitative research of FIP. Study 2 demonstrated that therapists of the trial under analysis often created opportunities for relatives to express and share their concerns throughout the entire treatment programme. The use of this strategy was immediately followed by coping skills enhancement, advice and emotional support. Strategies aiming to deal with overinvolvement may also occur early in the treatment programme. Reframing was the next most used strategy, followed by dealing with anger, conflict and rejection. This middle and later work seems to operate in lowering criticism and hostility, while the former seems to diminish overinvolvement. Single-family sessions may be used to augment the work developed in the relatives groups. Study 3 revealed a missing part of Study 2. It demonstrated that the process of FIP promotes emotional changes in the relatives and therapists must be sensitive to the emotional pathway of each participant in the group.

Avaluació criminològica i psicològica dels agressors domèstics

La violència domèstica constitueix un fenomen que preocupa tant la nostra societat com els professionals que hi treballen. Els programes de tractament psicològic són una eina més per prevenir la repetició de la conducta violenta dels agressors domèstics. Intervenir en aquestes persones és imprescindible, ja que una bona part de les víctimes retornen amb el seu agressor i, si no és el cas, l'agressor pot repetir el mateix patró conductual de violència amb una nova parella. Per aquest motiu, l'objectiu d'aquest estudi és avaluar l'eficàcia del programa de tractament d'agressors domèstics que s'ha dut a terme al Centre Penitenciari Quatre Camins (Barcelona) durant el període 2007-2008. D'altra banda, un segon objectiu d'aquesta investigació és comprovar si les variables criminològiques rellevants a la investigació internacional poden tenir alguna influència o modular l'eficàcia del programa de tractament. Per a la consecució d'aquests objectius s'han avaluat diverses variables psicològiques (distorsions cognitives, impulsivitat, empatia, ira, motivació terapèutica, etc.), les quals conformen els ingredients terapèutics que integren la intervenció psicològica. Tanmateix, s'han recollit tota una sèrie de variables criminològiques dels subjectes que s'han inclòs en les anàlisis estadístiques posteriors. El disseny de la investigació consisteix en una comparació intrasubjectes de les mesures psicològiques abans i després del tractament (comparació pre i posttractament). Aquest estudi constitueix la continuació d'una investigació anterior en l'àmbit del tractament dels agressors domèstics iniciada al Centre Penitenciari Quatre Camins l'any 2006. Les principals conclusions d'aquest estudi són que el programa de tractament amb agressors domèstics rep un suport parcial de les dades empíriques obtingudes i que les variables criminològiques no semblen tenir influència en els resultats positius de la intervenció psicològica.