Development of a Mechanism and Process to Continuously Produce Spherical, Torrefied Biomass

Thesis (Master, Mechanical and Materials Engineering) -- Queen's University, 2016-06-17 02:15:25.215

DEVELOPMENT OF A MECHANISM AND PROCESS TO CONTINUOUSLY PRODUCE SPHERICAL, TORREFIED BIOMASS PELLETS

A recently developed novel biomass fuel pellet, the Q’ Pellet, offers significant improvements over conventional white pellets, with characteristics comparable to those of coal. The Q’ Pellet was initially created at bench scale using a proprietary die and punch design, in which the biomass was torrefied in-situ¬ and then compressed. To bring the benefits of the Q’ Pellet to a commercial level, it must be capable of being produced in a continuous process at a competitive cost. A prototype machine was previously constructed in a first effort to assess continuous processing of the Q’ Pellet. The prototype torrefied biomass in a separate, ex-situ reactor and transported it into a rotary compression stage. Upon evaluation, parts of the prototype were found to be unsuccessful and required a redesign of the material transport method as well as the compression mechanism. A process was developed in which material was torrefied ex-situ and extruded in a pre-compression stage. The extruded biomass overcame multiple handling issues that had been experienced with un-densified biomass, facilitating efficient material transport. Biomass was extruded directly into a novel re-designed pelletizing die, which incorporated a removable cap, ejection pin and a die spring to accommodate a repeatable continuous process. Although after several uses the die required manual intervention due to minor design and manufacturing quality limitations, the system clearly demonstrated the capability of producing the Q’ Pellet in a continuous process. Q’ Pellets produced by the pre-compression method and pelletized in the re-designed die had an average dry basis gross calorific value of 22.04 MJ/kg, pellet durability index of 99.86% and dried to 6.2% of its initial mass following 24 hours submerged in water. This compares well with literature results of 21.29 MJ/kg, 100% pellet durability index and <5% mass increase in a water submersion test. These results indicate that the methods developed herein are capable of producing Q’ Pellets in a continuous process with fuel properties competitive with coal.

Esiselvitys puupolttoaineen jalostamisesta torrefiointitekniikalla

Fossiilisten polttoaineiden käytöstä aiheutuvia kasvihuonekaasupäästöjä pyritään vähentämään EU:ssa mm. päästökaupan avulla. Uusiutumattomien polttoaineiden tilalle kehitetään biopolttoaineita, joita voidaan hyödyntää olemassa olevien voimalaitosten polttolaitteistoilla. Biopolttoaineiden etuna on, ettäniiden ei katsota lisäävän hiilidioksidipäästöjä, koska biomassa sitoo itseensä kasvaessaan poltossa vapautuvan määrän hiiltä. Eräs kiinnostavimmista jalostetuista biopolttoaineista on torrefioitu puu, joka vastaa useimmilta ominaisuuksiltaan kivihiiltä ja jota voidaan käyttää hiilivoimalaitoksissa ilman laitteistomuutoksia. Torrefiointi on puun eräänlaista paistamista hapettomissa olosuhteissa 250-270ºC:ssa, jolloin siitä saadaanpoistettua vesi ja osa haihtuvista aineista. Puun väri muuttuu suklaanruskeaksi, se kevenee, ei savuta poltettaessa, hylkii vettä, jauhautuu hyvin sekä sillä on pienet hiukkaspäästöt. Käsitellyn puun ominaisuudet muuttuvat säilyvyydeltään ja käyttöominaisuuksiltaan merkittävästi raaka-aineeseen verrattuna. Torrefioinnilla saavutetaan puulle polttoainekäytön kannalta myös paremmat ja kestävämmät ominaisuudet kuin hiiltämällä. Torrefiointiprosessia on tutkittu jonkin verran ja torrefioidun biomassan polttoa voimalaitosmittakaavassa on kokeiltu pienessä mittakaavassa. Torrefioitu materiaali on alhaisen tiheytensä vuoksi hankalaa ja kallista kuljettaa,joten sen tiheyttä tulee nostaa kuljetuksia varten tiivistämällä esim.pelletöimällä. Torrefionti yhdistettynä pelletöintiin on parhaimmillaan kilpailukykyinen vaihtoehto, kun kivihiiltä korvaavaa biomassaa jalostetaan kaukana käyttöpaikasta ja kuljetetaan irtotavarana aluskuljetuksina. Torrefioitua puuta on tiettävästi poltettu vain hollantilaisessa voimalaitoksessa. Tässä esiselvityksessä kootun tiedon perusteella torrefioidun puupolttoaineen tuottamiseen Suomen olosuhteissa arvioidaan olevan teknis-taloudellisia mahdollisuuksia. Kuitenkin torrefiointiprosessin soveltaminen suomen olosuhteisiin ja kotimaisiin raakaaineisiin vaatii panostusta jatkotutkimukseen ennen varsinaiseen toteutusvaiheeseen siirtymistä.

Lämpöyrittäjäkonsepti biotuotteelle

Fossiilisista polttoaineista aiheutuvia hiilidioksidipäästöjä yritetään vähentää muun muassa lisäämällä uusiutuvien polttoaineiden käyttöä. Kiinteän biomassan ominaisuudet eroavat fossiilisesta kivihiilestä kuitenkin niin paljon, ettei biomassalla voida suoraan korvata kivihiiltä. Biomassan lämpökäsittely muuttaa sen ominaisuuksia kivihiilen kaltaiseksi, jolloin sillä on mahdollista korvata kivihiiltä. Tässä diplomityössä on tutkittu biomassan lämpökäsittelyä eli torrefiointia. Työn lähtökohtana on luoda pohjaa liikeidealle, jossa torrefioitua biomassaa tuotetaan pienissä lämpölaitoksissa lämmöntuotannon ohella. Työ sisältää laboratoriokokeita, joissa tarkastellaan käytännön kokeilla biomassan torrefioinnissa tapahtuvia ominaisuuksien muutoksia. Biomassan torrefiointiin suunnitellaan lisäksi pientä koelaitetta, jonka kokoa on mahdollista suurentaa jatkossa lämpölaitoskokoluokkaan asti. Torrefioidun biomassan tuotantokustannuksia on tarkasteltu laiteinvestointien, raaka-aine- sekä käyttökustannuksien kautta. Laboratoriokokeiden perusteella on saatu tuloksia optimaalisista toiminta-arvoista lämpökäsittelymenetelmille. Lämpöyrittäjälle on luotu perustoiminta-ajatus torrefioidun biomassan tuotannolle, jossa on tarkasteltu myös tuotannon kannattavuutta. Tämä työ antaa pohjaa aiheen jatkotutkimukselle ja -kehitykselle.

Biopolttoaineen rinnakkaispolton kannattavuustarkastelu hiilipölypolttokattilassa Martinlaakso 2:ssa

Euroopan unionin asettamat tavoitteet kasvihuonepäästöjen vähennykselle johtavat vih-reämpään teknologiaan. Tämä diplomityö on teoreettinen tutkimus, joka käsittelee biopolt-toaineen rinnakkaispolton kannattavuutta Vantaan Energian Martinlaakso 2:sen hiilipöly-polttokattilassa. Työssä perehdytään viiteen eri biopolttoainevaihtoehtoon, joita tarkastellaan viidessä eri skenaariossa, jotka vastaavat: 10, 20, 30, 40 ja 50 % biopolttoaineen osuutta kattilassa tuo-tetusta energiasta. Skenaarioissa on pohdittu tarvittavia investointikustannuksia ja muutos-töitä hiilipölypolttokattilassa. Tutkimuksessa on huomioitu myös uusi isojen laitosten pääs-töjä koskeva direktiivi, kattilan oletettava käyttöikä sekä biopolttoaineiden tuet. Saaduista arvioista on lopuksi laskettu vuosittainen polttoainekohtainen kustannusarvio ja investoin-nin kannattavuusarvio. Tuloksista voidaan päätellä, että sahanpurun mahdollisimman suuri hyötykäyttö on kannat-tavaa. Mikäli halutaan käyttää suuria määriä biopolttoainetta, (yli 20 % tuotetusta energias-ta) ei sahanpuru ole varteenotettava vaihtoehto huonon saatavuutensa johdosta. Tällöin hakkeen kaasutuslaitos olisi paras ratkaisu, mutta laitoksen kannattavuus riippuu tulevista energiatuista. Ilman energiatukia sahanpurun hyötykäyttö on ainoa kannattava investointi.

Comparison of energy balances of steam explosion and torrefaction technologies

The present study introduce two pretreatment technologies which are torrefaction and steam explosion, and compare energy balance for both technologies to investigate and compare the use of these technologies to improve pelletization. In this research, torrefaction and steam explosion pretreatments were accomplished on the mixed small diameter wood (70%) with moisture content of 40 %, and logging residues (30%) with moisture content of 45 % at temperature 230 ̊C, and treatment duration 10 min. Competing methods were evaluated, and the results showed higher volumetric energy for steam explosion pellet than torrefied pellet.

Torrefioidun biohiilipelletin kirjallisuustutkimus ja koeajot pilottilaitoksessa

Tämä raportti käsittelee ”Torrefioidun biohiilipelletin laatu ja varastoitavuus” hankkeen tuloksia. Hankkeen tavoitteena oli tutkia torrefioidun biohiilipelletin prosessiteknologiaa, markkinoita ja tuotantokustannuksia kirjallisuustutkimusosiossa. Hankkeen päätutkimus keskittyi koeajoihin pilottilaitoksella, jossa valmistettiin biohiilipellettiä erilaisista puuraaka-aineista. Pilottilaitos oli perustettu Torrec Oy:n toimesta Etelä-Savon Energian Pursialan voimalaitoksen yhteyteen Mikkelissä ja sen tuotanto oli käynnistynyt kesällä 2014. Kaikki koe-erät valmistettiin vain käyttämällä sidonta-aineena lauhdevettä, jota oli tiivistynyt säiliön pohjalle torrefiointiprosessin aikana. Näin ollen erillistä lisäsidonta-aineita ei tarvittu, jolloin voidaan säästää tuotantokustannuksissa jatkossakin. Euroopan Unioni on asettanut 20 % tavoitteen uusiutuvien energioiden käytölle vuoteen 2020, josta biomassalla voidaan kattaa kaksi kolmannesta. Tutkimushankkeen tavoitteena oli metsään perustuvan bioenergiatuotannon lisääminen ja tuontienergian korvaaminen kotimaisella polttoaineella. Hankkeen tarkoituksena oli tutkimusanalyysien kautta kehittää uutta kilpailukykyistä teknologiavaihtoehtoa puupolttoaineiden hyödyntämiseksi. Torrefiointiteknologiaa ollaan kaupallistamassa ympäri Eurooppaa parasta aikaa ja uusia biohiilen tuotantolaitoksia on kehitteillä ja rakenteilla. Tutkimuksen tulokset osoittavat, että biohiilipelletillä on mahdollisuudet suurimittakaavaiseen energiantuotantoon laadun suhteen, kunhan sen käyttäminen tulee edullisemmaksi laitoksissa. Toisaalta, tämä kehitys vaatii tukimekanismeja valtion puolelta, jotta pelletit lähtisivät todella liikkeelle markkinoilla.

The feasibility of torrefaction for the co-firing of wood in pulverised-fuel boilers

Torrefaction is the partial pyrolysis of wood characterised by thermal degradation of predominantly hemicellulose under inert atmosphere. Torrefaction can be likened to coffee roasting but with wood in place of beans. This relatively new process concept makes wood more like coal. Torrefaction has attracted interest because it potentially enables higher rates of co-firing in existing pulverised-coal power plants and hence greater net CO2 emission reductions. Academic and entrepreneurial interest in torrefaction has sky rocketed in the last decade. Research output has focused on the many aspects of torrefaction – from detailed chemical changes in feedstock to globally-optimised production and supply scenarios with which to sustain EU emission-cutting directives. However, despite its seemingly simple concept, torrefaction has retained a somewhat mysterious standing. Why hasn’t torrefied pellet production become fully commercialised? The question is one of feasibility. This thesis addresses this question. Herein, the feasibility of torrefaction in co-firing applications is approached from three directions. Firstly, the natural limitations imposed by the structure of wood are assessed. Secondly, the environmental impact of production and use of torrefied fuel is evaluated and thirdly, economic feasibility is assessed based on the state of the art of pellet making. The conclusions reached in these domains are as follows. Modification of wood’s chemical structure is limited by its naturally existing constituents. Consequently, key properties of wood with regards to its potential as a co-firing fuel have a finite range. The most ideal benefits gained from wood torrefaction cannot all be realised simultaneously in a single process or product. Although torrefaction at elevated pressure may enhance some properties of torrefied wood, high-energy torrefaction yields are achieved at the expense of other key properties such as heating value, grindability, equilibrium moisture content and the ability to pelletise torrefied wood. Moreover, pelletisation of even moderately torrefied fuels is challenging and achieving a standard level of pellet durability, as required by international standards, is not trivial. Despite a reduced moisture content, brief exposure of torrefied pellets to water from rainfall or emersion results in a high level of moisture retention. Based on the above findings, torrefied pellets are an optimised product. Assessment of energy and CO2-equivalent emission balance indicates that there is no environmental barrier to production and use of torrefied pellets in co-firing. A long product transport distance, however, is necessary in order for emission benefits to exceed those of conventional pellets. Substantial CO2 emission reductions appear possible with this fuel if laboratory milling results carry over to industrial scales for direct co-firing. From demonstrated state-of-the-art pellet properties, however, the economic feasibility of torrefied pellet production falls short of conventional pellets primarily due to the larger capital investment required for production. If the capital investment for torrefied pellet production can be reduced significantly or if the pellet-making issues can be resolved, the two production processes could be economically comparable. In this scenario, however, transatlantic shipping distances and a dry fuel are likely necessary for production to be viable. Based on demonstrated pellet properties to date, environmental aspects and production economics, it is concluded that torrefied pellets do not warrant investment at this time. However, from the presented results, the course of future research in this field is clear.

Chemical changes in biomass during torrefaction

Torrefaction is moderate thermal treatment (~200-300 °C) of biomass in an inert atmosphere. The torrefied fuel offers advantages to traditional biomass, such as higher heating value, reduced hydrophilic nature, increased its resistance to biological decay, and improved grindability. These factors could, for instance, lead to better handling and storage of biomass and increased use of biomass in pulverized combustors. In this work, we look at several aspects of changes in the biomass during torrefaction. We investigate the fate of carboxylic groups during torrefaction and its dependency to equilibrium moisture content. The changes in the wood components including carbohydrates, lignin, extractable materials and ashforming matters are also studied. And at last, the effect of K on torrefaction is investigated and then modeled. In biomass, carboxylic sites are partially responsible for its hydrophilic characteristic. These sites are degraded to varying extents during torrefaction. In this work, methylene blue sorption and potentiometric titration were applied to measure the concentration of carboxylic groups in torrefied spruce wood. The results from both methods were applicable and the values agreed well. A decrease in the equilibrium moisture content at different humidity was also measured for the torrefied wood samples, which is in good agreement with the decrease in carboxylic group contents. Thus, both methods offer a means of directly measuring the decomposition of carboxylic groups in biomass during torrefaction as a valuable parameter in evaluating the extent of torrefaction. This provides new information to the chemical changes occurring during torrefaction. The effect of torrefaction temperature on the chemistry of birch wood was investigated. The samples were from a pilot plant at Energy research Center of the Netherlands (ECN). And in that way they were representative of industrially produced samples. Sugar analysis was applied to analyze the hemicellulose and cellulose content during torrefaction. The results show a significant degradation of hemicellulose already at 240 °C, while cellulose degradation becomes significant above 270 °C torrefaction. Several methods including Klason lignin method, solid state NMR and Py-GC-MS analyses were applied to measure the changes in lignin during torrefaction. The changes in the ratio of phenyl, guaiacyl and syringyl units show that lignin degrades already at 240 °C to a small extent. To investigate the changes in the extractives from acetone extraction during torrefaction, gravimetric method, HP-SEC and GC-FID followed by GC-MS analysis were performed. The content of acetone-extractable material increases already at 240 °C torrefaction through the degradation of carbohydrate and lignin. The molecular weight of the acetone-extractable material decreases with increasing the torrefaction temperature. The formation of some valuable materials like syringaresinol or vanillin is also observed which is important from biorefinery perspective. To investigate the change in the chemical association of ash-forming elements in birch wood during torrefaction, chemical fractionation was performed on the original and torrefied birch samples. These results give a first understanding of the changes in the association of ashforming elements during torrefaction. The most significant changes can be seen in the distribution of calcium, magnesium and manganese, with some change in water solubility seen in potassium. These changes may in part be due to the destruction of carboxylic groups. In addition to some changes in water and acid solubility of phosphorous, a clear decrease in the concentration of both chlorine and sulfur was observed. This would be a significant additional benefit for the combustion of torrefied biomass. Another objective of this work is studying the impact of organically bound K, Na, Ca and Mn on mass loss of biomass during torrefaction. These elements were of interest because they have been shown to be catalytically active in solid fuels during pyrolysis and/or gasification. The biomasses were first acid washed to remove the ash-forming matters and then organic sites were doped with K, Na, Ca or Mn. The results show that K and Na bound to organic sites can significantly increase the mass loss during torrefaction. It is also seen that Mn bound to organic sites increases the mass loss and Ca addition does not influence the mass loss rate on torrefaction. This increase in mass loss during torrefaction with alkali addition is unlike what has been found in the case of pyrolysis where alkali addition resulted in a reduced mass loss. These results are important for the future operation of torrefaction plants, which will likely be designed to handle various biomasses with significantly different contents of K. The results imply that shorter retention times are possible for high K-containing biomasses. The mass loss of spruce wood with different content of K was modeled using a two-step reaction model based on four kinetic rate constants. The results show that it is possible to model the mass loss of spruce wood doped with different levels of K using the same activation energies but different pre-exponential factors for the rate constants. Three of the pre-exponential factors increased linearly with increasing K content, while one of the preexponential factors decreased with increasing K content. Therefore, a new torrefaction model was formulated using the hemicellulose and cellulose content and K content. The new torrefaction model was validated against the mass loss during the torrefaction of aspen, miscanthus, straw and bark. There is good agreement between the model and the experimental data for the other biomasses, except bark. For bark, the mass loss of acetone extractable material is also needed to be taken into account. The new model can describe the kinetics of mass loss during torrefaction of different types of biomass. This is important for considering fuel flexibility in torrefaction plants.

Preparation and Investigation of Bio-coal Mixture Fuels Used in Large Diesel Engines

Coal slurry was of vital interest during the last century due to its potential as an alternative fuel where liquid fuels were necessary. Recently, environmental impacts of the traditional fuels, similarities of bio-coal to that of coal, and huge bio-coal supply has attracted the attention to prepare bio-coal slurries as a new fuel. Rudolf Diesel who invented the diesel engine on 1895 was of the opinion that diesel engines are capable to use different kinds of fuels due to the special design. He tried some kind of vegetable oil to operate on his IC engine. Recently, due to high energy density and more environmentally friendly fuel, researchers believe that bio-coal slurries could act as a new alternative fuel in large diesel engines. Loads of research on different kinds of bio-coal slurry were done by the other researchers worldwide and a lot of progress to boost slurry’s quality were achieved recently. The present study aims to achieve the ideal condition of different factors affecting on the quality of bio-coal slurry. One charcoal sample and two kinds of torrefied wood were used to investigate and compare the reaction of various factors. The results show a great gap between the quality of slurries made of different samples and more researches are necessary to fully understand the impact of the different parameter and improving the quality.