Highlighting Interdisciplinarity between Physics and Mathematics in Historical Papers on Special Relativity: Development of an Analytical Tool for Characterising Boundary Crossing Mechanisms

Questa tesi di laurea si colloca all'interno del progetto Erasmus + IDENTITIES, il cui obiettivo è sviluppare materiali didattici interdisciplinari per la formazione iniziale degli insegnanti. Nello specifico, si dà seguito ad una ricerca condotta da Lorenzo Miani, finalizzata a mettere in evidenza come la Teoria della Relatività Speciale (STR) sia storicamente nata da una speciale interazione tra matematica e fisica. Tale co-evoluzione è stata cercata, e messa in evidenza, attraverso l’analisi dei quattro articoli fondativi della STR scritti da Lorentz (1904), Poincaré (1906), Einstein (1905) e Minkowski (1908). Per l’analisi di questi articoli abbiamo utilizzato la metafora del “confine”, esposta nella metateoria di Akkerman e Bakker (2011), riferendosi al confine tra Matematica e Fisica. È stato sviluppato uno strumento operativo di analisi di articoli originali per estrarne il rapporto tra le due discipline. Un’analisi di questo tipo può portare un contributo considerevole al Justification Problem, intercettando la possibilità di indagare sull’identità della Matematica, intesa come disciplina. Questo tipo di analisi ha permesso di comprendere gli “stili al confine” di ogni autore, e la natura delle Trasformazioni di Lorentz in quanto oggetto di confine. È inoltre illustrata la progettazione di un’attività per la formazione iniziale degli insegnanti. Questa si configura come un tutorial per lavori di gruppo, ed è stata sperimentata nel corso di Didattica della Fisica dell’Università di Bologna, tenuto dalla Professoressa Olivia Levrini. Grazie all’attività, è stato possibile riflettere sulle identità disciplinari e sull’importanza di fare “esperienze di confine” per superare stereotipi. Lo strumento elaborato nella tesi si apre a sviluppi futuri, dal momento che si presta ad essere utilizzato per l’analisi di una grande varietà di testi e per la costruzione di “boundary zone”, sempre più auspicate e incentivate nei report europei.

Born-Infeld electrodynamics in very special relativity

Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo (FAPESP)

de Sitter special relativity

A special relativity based on the de Sitter group is introduced, which is a theory that might hold up in the presence of a non-vanishing cosmological constant. Like ordinary special relativity, it retains the quotient character of spacetime, and a notion of homogeneity. As a consequence, the underlying spacetime will be a de Sitter spacetime, whose associated kinematics will differ from that of ordinary special relativity. The corresponding modified notions of energy and momentum are obtained, and the exact relationship between them, which is invariant under a re-scaling of the involved quantities, explicitly exhibited. Since the de Sitter group can be considered a particular deformation of the Poincare group, this theory turns out to be a specific kind of deformed (or doubly) special relativity. Some experimental consequences, as well as the causal structure of spacetime-modified by the presence of the de Sitter horizon-are briefly discussed.

De Sitter Special Relativity: Effects on cosmology

Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo (FAPESP)

Noninertial observers in special relativity and clock synchronization debates

Selleri's arguments that a consideration of noninertial reference frames in the framework of special relativity identify absolute simultaneity as being Nature's choice of synchronization are considered. In the case of rectilinearly accelerating rockets, it is argued by considering two rockets which maintain a fixed proper separation rather than a fixed separation relative to the inertial frame in which they start from rest, that what seems the most natural choice for a simultaneity convention is problem-dependent and that Einstein's definition is the most natural (though still conventional) choice in this case. In addition, the supposed problems special relativity has with treating a rotating disk, namely how a pulse of light traveling around the circumference of the disk can have a local speed of light equal to c everywhere but a global speed not equal to c, and how coordinate transformations to the disk can give the Lorentz transformations in the limit of large disk radius but small angular velocity, are addressed. It is shown that the theory of Fermi frames solves both of these problems. It is also argued that the question of defining simultaneity relative to a uniformly rotating disk does riot need to be resolved in order to resolve Ehrenfest's paradox.

Dimensional reduction and gauge group reduction in Bianchi-type cosmology

In this paper we examine in detail the implementation, with its associated difficulties, of the Killing conditions and gauge fixing into the variational principle formulation of Bianchi-type cosmologies. We address problems raised in the literature concerning the Lagrangian and the Hamiltonian formulations: We prove their equivalence, make clear the role of the homogeneity preserving diffeomorphisms in the phase space approach, and show that the number of physical degrees of freedom is the same in the Hamiltonian and Lagrangian formulations. Residual gauge transformations play an important role in our approach, and we suggest that Poincaré transformations for special relativistic systems can be understood as residual gauge transformations. In the Appendixes, we give the general computation of the equations of motion and the Lagrangian for any Bianchi-type vacuum metric and for spatially homogeneous Maxwell fields in a nondynamical background (with zero currents). We also illustrate our counting of degrees of freedom in an appendix.

Gauge group and reality conditions in Ashtekar's complex formulation of canonical gravity

We discuss reality conditions and the relation between spacetime diffeomorphisms and gauge transformations in Ashtekars complex formulation of general relativity. We produce a general theoretical framework for the stabilization algorithm for the reality conditions, which is different from Diracs method of stabilization of constraints. We solve the problem of the projectability of the diffeomorphism transformations from configuration-velocity space to phase space, linking them to the reality conditions. We construct the complete set of canonical generators of the gauge group in the phase space which includes all the gauge variables. This result proves that the canonical formalism has all the gauge structure of the Lagrangian theory, including the time diffeomorphisms.

Spin-2 gravitational trace anomaly

The part proportional to the Euler-Poincar characteristic of the contribution of spin-2 fields to the gravitational trace anomaly is computed. It is seen to be of the same sign as all the lower-spin contributions, making anomaly cancellation impossible. Subtleties related to Weyl invariance, gauge independence, ghosts, and counting of degrees of freedom are pointed out.

BRST-invariant path integral for a spinning relativistic particle

The propagator of a relativistic spinning particle is calculated using the Becchi-Rouet-Stora-Tyutin-(BRST)-invariant path-integral formalism of Fradkin and Vilkovisky. The spinless case is considered as an introduction to the formalism.

1/c expansion of a separable model of direct-interaction type

The properties of a proposed model of N point particles in direct interaction are considered in the limit of small velocities. It is shown that, in this limit, time correlations cancel out and that Newtonian dynamics is recovered for the system in a natural way.

Batalin-Vilkovisky analysis of covariant and noncovariant actions

The equivalence between the covariant and the noncovariant versions of a constrained system is shown to hold after quantization in the framework of the field-antifield formalism. Our study covers the cases of electromagnetism and Yang-Mills fields and sheds light on some aspects of the Faddeev-Popov method, for both the covariant and noncovariant approaches, which have not been fully clarified in the literature.

Newton-Hooke algebras, nonrelativistic branes, and generalized pp-wave metrics

The Newton-Hooke algebras in d dimensions are constructed as contractions of dS(AdS) algebras. Nonrelativistic brane actions are WZ terms of these Newton-Hooke algebras. The NH algebras appear also as subalgebras of multitemporal relativistic conformal algebras, SO(d+1,p+2). We construct generalizations of pp-wave metrics from these algebras.

Classical motions from pseudoclassical spin-1/2 particle models

The classical trajectory and spin precessions of Bargmann, Michel, and Telegdi are deduced from a pseudoclassical model of a relativistic spin-(1/2) particle. The corresponding deduction from a non- relativistic model is also given.