Laboratory study on the performance of recycled concrete aggregates blended with reclaimed asphalt pavement as pavement granular material

Production of recycled concrete aggregates (RCA) from construction and demolition (C&D) waste has become popular all over the world since the availability of land spaces are limited to dispose. Therefore it is important to seek alternative applications for RCA. The use of RCA in base and sub-base layers in granular pavement is a viable solution. In mechanistic pavement design, rutting (permanent deformation) is considered as the major failure mechanisms of the pavement. The rutting is the accumulation of permanent deformation of pavement layers caused by the repetitive vehicle load. In Queensland, Australia, it is accepted to have the maximum of 20% of reclaimed asphalt pavement (RAP) in RCA and therefore, it is important to investigate the effect of RAP on the permanent deformation properties of RCA. In this study, a series of repeated load triaxial (RLT) tests were conducted on RCA blended with different percentage of RAP to investigate the permanent deformation and resilient modulus properties of RCA. The vertical deformation and resilient modulus values were used to determine the response of RCA for the cyclic loading under standard pressure and loading conditions.

Investigation of using waste engine oil blended with reclaimed asphalt materials to improve pavement recyclability

With the increasing importance of conserving natural resources and moving toward sustainable practices, the aging transportation infrastructure can benefit from these ideas by improving their existing recycling practices. When an asphalt pavement needs to be replaced, the existing pavement is removed and ground up. This ground material, known as reclaimed asphalt pavement (RAP), is then added into new asphalt roads. However, since RAP was exposed to years of ultraviolet degradation and environmental weathering, the material has aged and cannot be used as a direct substitute for aggregate and binder in new asphalt pavements. One material that holds potential for restoring the aged asphalt binder to a usable state is waste engine oil. This research aims to study the feasibility of using waste engine oil as a recycling agent to improve the recyclability of pavements containing RAP. Testing was conducted in three phases, asphalt binder testing, advanced asphalt binder testing, and laboratory mixture testing. Asphalt binder testing consisted of dynamic shear rheometer and rotational viscometer testing on both unaged and aged binders containing waste engine oil and reclaimed asphalt binder (RAB). Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR) testing was carried out to on the asphalt binders blended with RAB and waste engine oil compare the structural indices indicative of aging. Lastly, sample asphalt samples containing waste engine oil and RAP were subjected to rutting testing and tensile strength ratio testing. These tests lend evidence to support the claim that waste engine oil can be used as a rejuvenating agent to chemically restore asphalt pavements containing RAP. Waste engine oil can reduce the stiffness and improve the low temperature properties of asphalt binders blended with RAB. Waste engine oil can also soften asphalt pavements without having a detrimental effect on the moisture susceptibility.

Investigation on characteristics and performance of recycled concrete aggregates as granular materials for unbound pavements

This research was a step forward in investigating the characteristics of recycled concrete aggregates to use as an unbound pavement material. The results present the guidelines for successfully application of recycled concrete aggregates in high traffic volume roads. Outcomes of the research create more economical and environmental benefits through reducing the depletion of natural resources and effectively manage the generated concrete waste before disposal as land fill.

Performance evaluation of asphalt pavements using the Incremental-Recursive procedure of the Mechanistic-Empirical design software CalME

Il concetto di “sostenibilità” si riferisce allo sviluppo dei sistemi umani attraverso il più piccolo impatto possibile sul sistema ambientale. Le opere che si inseriscono bene nel contesto ambientale circostante e le pratiche che rispettano le risorse in maniera tale da permettere una crescita e uno sviluppo a lungo termine senza impattare sull’ambiente sono indispensabili in una società moderna. I progressi passati, presenti e futuri che hanno reso i conglomerati bituminosi materiali sostenibili dal punto di vista ambientale sono particolarmente importanti data la grande quantità di conglomerato usato annualmente in Europa e negli Stati Uniti. I produttori di bitume e di conglomerato bituminoso stanno sviluppando tecniche innovative per ridurre l’impatto ambientale senza compromettere le prestazioni meccaniche finali. Un conglomerato bituminoso ad “alta lavorabilità” (WMA), pur sviluppando le stesse caratteristiche meccaniche, richiede un temperatura di produzione minore rispetto a quella di un tradizionale conglomerato bituminoso a caldo (HMA). L’abbassamento della temperature di produzione riduce le emissioni nocive. Questo migliora le condizioni dei lavoratori ed è orientato verso uno sviluppo sostenibile. L’obbiettivo principale di questa tesi di laurea è quello di dimostrare il duplice valore sia dal punto di vista dell’eco-compatibilità sia dal punto di vista meccanico di questi conglomerati bituminosi ad “alta lavorabilità”. In particolare in questa tesi di laurea è stato studiato uno SMA ad “alta lavorabilità” (PGGWMA). L’uso di materiali a basso impatto ambientale è la prima fase verso un progetto ecocompatibile ma non può che essere il punto di partenza. L’approccio ecocompatibile deve essere esteso anche ai metodi di progetto e alla caratterizzazione di laboratorio dei materiali perché solo in questo modo è possibile ricavare le massime potenzialità dai materiali usati. Un’appropriata caratterizzazione del conglomerato bituminoso è fondamentale e necessaria per una realistica previsione delle performance di una pavimentazione stradale. La caratterizzazione volumetrica (Mix Design) e meccanica (Deformazioni Permanenti e Comportamento a fatica) di un conglomerato bituminoso è una fase importante. Inoltre, al fine di utilizzare correttamente i materiali, un metodo di progetto avanzato ed efficiente, come quello rappresentato da un approccio Empirico-Meccanicistico (ME), deve essere utilizzato. Una procedura di progetto Empirico-Meccanicistica consiste di un modello strutturale capace di prevedere gli stati di tensione e deformazione all’interno della pavimentazione sotto l’azione del traffico e in funzione delle condizioni atmosferiche e di modelli empirici, calibrati sul comportamento dei materiali, che collegano la risposta strutturale alle performance della pavimentazione. Nel 1996 in California, per poter effettivamente sfruttare i benefici dei continui progressi nel campo delle pavimentazioni stradali, fu iniziato un estensivo progetto di ricerca mirato allo sviluppo dei metodi di progetto Empirico - Meccanicistici per le pavimentazioni stradali. Il risultato finale fu la prima versione del software CalME che fornisce all’utente tre approcci diversi di l’analisi e progetto: un approccio Empirico, uno Empirico - Meccanicistico classico e un approccio Empirico - Meccanicistico Incrementale - Ricorsivo. Questo tesi di laurea si concentra sulla procedura Incrementale - Ricorsiva del software CalME, basata su modelli di danno per quanto riguarda la fatica e l’accumulo di deformazioni di taglio dai quali dipendono rispettivamente la fessurazione superficiale e le deformazioni permanenti nella pavimentazione. Tale procedura funziona per incrementi temporali successivi e, usando i risultati di ogni incremento temporale, ricorsivamente, come input dell’incremento temporale successivo, prevede le condizioni di una pavimentazione stradale per quanto riguarda il modulo complesso dei diversi strati, le fessurazioni superficiali dovute alla fatica, le deformazioni permanenti e la rugosità superficiale. Al fine di verificare le propreità meccaniche del PGGWMA e le reciproche relazioni in termini di danno a fatica e deformazioni permanenti tra strato superficiale e struttura della pavimentazione per fissate condizioni ambientali e di traffico, è stata usata la procedura Incrementale – Ricorsiva del software CalME. Il conglomerato bituminoso studiato (PGGWMA) è stato usato in una pavimentazione stradale come strato superficiale di 60 mm di spessore. Le performance della pavimentazione sono state confrontate a quelle della stessa pavimentazione in cui altri tipi di conglomerato bituminoso sono stati usati come strato superficiale. I tre tipi di conglomerato bituminoso usati come termini di paragone sono stati: un conglomerato bituminoso ad “alta lavorabilità” con granulometria “chiusa” non modificato (DGWMA), un conglomerato bituminoso modificato con polverino di gomma con granulometria “aperta” (GGRAC) e un conglomerato bituminoso non modificato con granulometria “chiusa” (DGAC). Nel Capitolo I è stato introdotto il problema del progetto ecocompatibile delle pavimentazioni stradali. I materiali a basso impatto ambientale come i conglomerati bituminosi ad “alta lavorabilità” e i conglomerati bituminosi modificati con polverino di gomma sono stati descritti in dettaglio. Inoltre è stata discussa l’importanza della caratterizzazione di laboratorio dei materiali e il valore di un metodo razionale di progetto delle pavimentazioni stradali. Nel Capitolo II sono stati descritti i diversi approcci progettuali utilizzabili con il CalME e in particolare è stata spiegata la procedura Incrementale – Ricorsiva. Nel Capitolo III sono state studiate le proprietà volumetriche e meccaniche del PGGWMA. Test di Fatica e di Deformazioni Permanenti, eseguiti rispettivamente con la macchina a fatica per flessione su quattro punti e il Simple Shear Test device (macchina di taglio semplice), sono stati effettuati su provini di conglomerato bituminoso e i risultati dei test sono stati riassunti. Attraverso questi dati di laboratorio, i parametri dei modelli della Master Curve, del danno a fatica e dell’accumulo di deformazioni di taglio usati nella procedura Incrementale – Ricorsiva del CalME sono stati valutati. Infine, nel Capitolo IV, sono stati presentati i risultati delle simulazioni di pavimentazioni stradali con diversi strati superficiali. Per ogni pavimentazione sono stati analizzati la fessurazione superficiale complessiva, le deformazioni permanenti complessive, il danno a fatica e la profondità delle deformazioni in ognuno degli stati legati.

Investigation on performance characteristics of dense graded hot mix asphalt with RAP and Crumb Rubber

The use of recycled materials in asphalt mixtures such as reclaimed asphalt pavements (RAP) have become widely accepted as a replacement for virgin asphalt binder or virgin aggregates. In this study, the RAP content was 30%, and CR additives were blended with the soft unmodified binder by using dry processes. The objective of this study was to investigate and evaluate the engineering properties of dry method application of crumb rubber influences on reclaimed asphalt pavement (RAP) mixtures. To evaluate the effect of rubber-bitumen interaction on the mixture’s mechanical properties, a laboratory investigation has been conducted on a range of dense graded and 30% RAP by dry process crumb rubber modified (CRM) asphalt mixtures containing 0% (control), 1% crumb rubber by the total aggregate mass. The experimental program in this research include the binder extraction for estimating the amount of aged binder in the both fine and coarse RAP material. Before extracting the binder the RAP sieve analysis, have been done to provide the Black grading curve. In continue after the binder extraction the material sieved again to providing the white curve. The comparison of Black and White curve indicated that there is a remarkable difference between the aggregate grading even for the fine RAP. The experimental program was continued by fabricating 12 specimens in different 4 types of mixtures. For the first group no RAP, no rejuvenator and no crumb rubber were used. For the second group 30% of virgin aggregates substituted by RAP material and the third group was similar to the second group just with 0.01% rejuvenator. the forth group was the group, which in that the specimens contain RAP, rejuvenator and crumb rubber. Finally the specimens were tested for Indirect tensile strength. The results indicated that the addition of crumb rubber increased the optimum amount of binder in the mixture with 30% RAP.

Performance of rubberized asphalt pavements in Illinois /

"IHR-R07"--Technical report documentation page.

Accommodating energy price volatility in life cycle cost analysis of asphalt pavements

Energy price is related to more than half of the total life cycle cost of asphalt pavements. Furthermore, the fluctuation related to price of energy has been much higher than the general inflation and interest rate. This makes the energy price inflation an important variable that should be addressed when performing life cycle cost (LCC) studies re- garding asphalt pavements. The present value of future costs is highly sensitive to the selected discount rate. Therefore, the choice of the discount rate is the most critical element in LCC analysis during the life time of a project. The objective of the paper is to present a discount rate for asphalt pavement projects as a function of interest rate, general inflation and energy price inflation. The discount rate is defined based on the portion of the energy related costs during the life time of the pavement. Consequently, it can reflect the financial risks related to the energy price in asphalt pavement projects. It is suggested that a discount rate sensitivity analysis for asphalt pavements in Sweden should range between –20 and 30%.

Physical and Chemical Performance Testing of Ontario Asphalt Pavements

Thermal and fatigue cracking are the two of the major pavement distress phenomena that contribute significantly towards increased premature pavement failures in Ontario. This in turn puts a massive burden on the provincial budgets as the government spends huge sums of money on the repair and rehabilitation of roads every year. Governments therefore need to rethink and re-evaluate their current measures in order to prevent it in future. The main objectives of this study include: the investigation of fatigue distress of 11 contract samples at 10oC, 15oC, 20oC and 25oC and the use of crack-tip-opening-displacement (CTOD) requirements at temperatures other than 15oC; investigation of thermal and fatigue distress of the comparative analysis of 8 Ministry of Transportation (MTO) recovered and straight asphalt samples through double-edge-notched-tension test (DENT) and extended bending beam rheometry (EBBR); chemical testing of all samples though X-ray Fluorescence (XRF) and Fourier transform infrared analysis (FTIR); Dynamic Shear Rheometer (DSR) higher and intermediate temperature grading; and the case study of a local Kingston road. Majority of 11 contract samples showed satisfactory performance at all temperatures except one sample. Study of CTOD at various temperatures found a strong correlation between the two variables. All recovered samples showed poor performance in terms of their ability to resist thermal and fatigue distress relative to their corresponding straight asphalt as evident in DENT test and EBBR results. XRF and FTIR testing of all samples showed the addition of waste engine oil (WEO) to be the root cause of pavement failures. DSR high temperature grading showed superior performance of recovered binders relative to straight asphalt. The local Kingston road showed extensive signs of damage due to thermal and fatigue distress as evident from DENT test, EBBR results and pictures taken in the field. In the light of these facts, the use of waste engine oil and recycled asphalt in pavements should be avoided as these have been shown to cause premature failure in pavements. The DENT test existing CTOD requirements should be implemented at other temperatures in order to prevent the occurrences of premature pavement failures in future.

Rutting performance of asphalt pavements

Cold in-place recycling (CIR) and cold central plant recycling (CCPR) of asphalt concrete (AC) and/or full-depth reclamation (FDR) of AC and aggregate base are faster and less costly rehabilitation alternatives to conventional reconstruction for structurally distressed pavements. This study examines 26 different rehabilitation projects across the USA and Canada. Field cores from these projects were tested for dynamic modulus and repeated load permanent deformation. These structural characteristics are compared to reference values for hot mix asphalt (HMA). A rutting sensitivity analysis was performed on two rehabilitation scenarios with recycled and conventional HMA structural overlays in different climatic conditions using the Mechanistic Empirical Pavement Design (MEPDG). The cold-recycled scenarios exhibited performance similar to that of HMA overlays for most cases. The exceptions were the cases with thin HMA wearing courses and/or very poor cold-recycled material quality. The overall conclusion is that properly designed CIR/FDR/CCPR cold-recycled materials are a viable alternative to virgin HMA materials.

Uma avaliação técnico/econômica da reciclagem de revestimentos asfálticos a frio em usina em área urbana

Trata-se nesta dissertação do emprego da reciclagem a frio de revestimentos asfálticos em usina com a finalidade de aproveitamento como camada de revestimento em vias de tráfego leve e muito leve. São revistos os conceitos de dimensionamento de pavimentos e da dosagem de misturas asfálticas. Dá-se especial atenção ao valor do revestimento asfáltico recuperado e a relevância que a reciclagem tem sobre a redução do descarte de resíduos sólidos no meio ambiente. Identifica-se a importância do emprego da reciclagem sobre o comportamento da sociedade. A metodologia adotada tem por base uma revisão bibliográfica dos registros de trabalhos de reciclagem a frio realizados no Brasil e no exterior. Faz-se um relato dos procedimentos de caracterização dos materiais envolvidos e dos cuidados a serem observados para obter-se um produto final de qualidade. Estão aqui descritos os processos industriais de usinagem da mistura reciclada em plantas industriais fixas. É estabelecida uma proposta de definição da viabilidade econômica de emprego da reciclagem a frio em comparação com o revestimento asfáltico tradicional. Ao final são registrados temas a serem estudados visando tornar a reciclagem a frio de revestimentos asfálticos em usinas de áreas urbanas mais conhecida e considerada como alternativa para a melhoria da qualidade de vida nas cidades.

Implementation of pseudo J-integral based Paris’ law for fatigue cracking in asphalt mixtures and pavements

Pavement analysis and design for fatigue cracking involves a number of practical problems like material assessment/screening and performance prediction. A mechanics-aided method can answer these questions with satisfactory accuracy in a convenient way when it is appropriately implemented. This paper presents two techniques to implement the pseudo J-integral based Paris’ law to evaluate and predict fatigue cracking in asphalt mixtures and pavements. The first technique, quasi-elastic simulation, provides a rational and appropriate reference modulus for the pseudo analysis (i.e., viscoelastic to elastic conversion) by making use of the widely used material property: dynamic modulus. The physical significance of the quasi-elastic simulation is clarified. Introduction of this technique facilitates the implementation of the fracture mechanics models as well as continuum damage mechanics models to characterize fatigue cracking in asphalt pavements. The second technique about modeling fracture coefficients of the pseudo J-integral based Paris’ law simplifies the prediction of fatigue cracking without performing fatigue tests. The developed prediction models for the fracture coefficients rely on readily available mixture design properties that directly affect the fatigue performance, including the relaxation modulus, air void content, asphalt binder content, and aggregate gradation. Sufficient data are collected to develop such prediction models and the R2 values are around 0.9. The presented case studies serve as examples to illustrate how the pseudo J-integral based Paris’ law predicts fatigue resistance of asphalt mixtures and assesses fatigue performance of asphalt pavements. Future applications include the estimation of fatigue life of asphalt mixtures/pavements through a distinct criterion that defines fatigue failure by its physical significance.

Investigation on performance characteristics of dense graded hot mix asphalt with RAP and crumb rubber

The objective of this study was to fundamentally characterize the laboratory performance of traditional hot mix asphalt (HMA) mixtures incorporating high RAP content and waste tire crumb rubber through their fundamental engineering properties. The nominal maximum aggregates size was chosen for this research was 12mm (considering the limitation of aggregate size for surface layer) and both coarse and fine aggregates are commonly used in Italy that were examined and analyzed in this study. On the other hand, the RAP plays an important role in reducing production costs and enhancing the environmentally sustainable pavements instead of using virgin materials in HMA. Particularly, this study has aimed to use 30% of RAP content (25% fine aggregate RAP and 5% coarse aggregate RAP) and 1% of CR additives by the total weight of aggregates for mix design. The mixture of aggregates, RAP and CR were blended with different amount of unmodified binder through dry processes. Generally, the main purposes of this study were investigating on capability of using RAP and CR in dense graded HMA and comparing the performance of rejuvenator in RAP with CR. In addition, based on the engineering analyses during the study, we were able compare the fundamental Indirect Tensile Strength (ITS) value of dense graded HMA and also mechanical characteristics in terms of Indirect Tensile Stiffness Modulus (ITSM). In order to get an extended comparable data, four groups of different mixtures such as conventional mixture with only virgin aggregates (DV), mixture with RAP (DR), mixture with RAP and rejuvenator (DRR), and mixture with RAP, rejuvenator, CR (DRRCr) were investigated in this research experimentally. Finally, the results of those tests indicated that the mixtures with RAP and CR had the high stiffness and less thermal sensitivity, while the mixture with virgin aggregates only had very low values in comparison.