Renzi, Maggi, Tardewski: (des)encuentros de la literatura, la historia y la filosofía en torno al concepto de verdad en Respiración artificial, de Ricardo Piglia (Dossier: Novela, historia y nación en América Latina)

El ensayo explora tres posibles lecturas del concepto de verdad en Respiración artificial, de Ricardo Piglia, mediante el análisis de tres personajes: el novelista Renzi, el historiador Maggi y el filósofo Tardewski. Cada uno constituye, según su oficio, una representación de la verdad. La verdad histórica es relativizada por la verdad de la ficción personificada por Renzi, y esta encuentra un fundamento narrativo en la investigación histórica que Maggi desarrolla. La verdad filosófica de Tardewski permanece aislada e íntegra. La clave del texto es el descubrimiento de que la verdad de la razón filosófica es el villano de la novela, pues constituye una fuerza tiránica, totalitaria y devastadora, cuya lejanía de los hechos reales le impide explicarlos y darles sentido.

El tratado trinitario en la Suma de Teología de Santo Tomás de Aquino

En el presente trabajo, apoyándonos en los resultados de las más recientes investigaciones tomasianas, ofrecemos una introducción a los sofisticados desarrollos del tratado trinitario de la Suma de Teología de santo Tomás de Aquino. Después de una breve exposición de la síntesis trinitaria especulativa que nuestro autor ofrece en la Suma contra Gentiles, nos detendremos en el estudio del cometido y la estructura del tratado que nos ocupa, procurando poner de manifiesto la diferencia y la complementariedad que existe entre ambos tratados.

A Philosophical enquiry in the nature, origin and extent of animal motion, deduced from the principles of reason and analogy /

Mode of access: Internet.

A continuation of the Letters to the philosophers and politicians of France, on the subject of religion: and of the Letters to a philosophical unbeliever; in answer to Mr. Paine's Age of reason.

Evans 29352.

Understanding the practical sense of health actions: contributions of Philosophical Hermeneutics

Health actions have a powerful tech no-scientific armory invested in their instrumental success. Conversely, they have a fragile conceptual basis for the understanding and transformation of the practical sense of health-disease-care processes that especifically take place nowadays. This essay intends to identify the potential contributions of philosophical hermeneutics to overcome such fragility. With this purpose and through contemporary hermeneutics, the recovery of the aristotelian distinction between theory, technique and praxis and its repercussions is discussed, for a systematic treatment of the practical reason of health actions. Against this backdrop, the following stands out: the dialogic essence of understanding-interpreting human acts; the fusion of horizons as the movement of realization of those processes of understanding; and happiness projects, existential guide to everyday life, as the impulse and the possibility of openness of the reason to the practical sense of health actions.

Abortion in public reason

What abortion laws a liberal political community ought to have? Much has been said about the moral problem of abortion, but there has not been yet (to my knowledge) a fully articulate account of the bearing of the competing answers to this ethical problem on liberal public reason. The first part of my project consists in a critical review of the different attempts to solve the various philosophical puzzles, both metaphysical and moral, posed by the abortion problem. Why is it wrong to kill beings like you and me? By answering this question we shall gain a better insight into those properties we have that give us such strong reasons against killing beings like us. Here we face a tremendous philosophical diffuculty, for it is not possible to determine what the robustest account of the wrongness of killing is without dealing with deeper metaethical and metaphysical problems. Indeed, consequentialist and nonconsequentialist moral theories differ in what it is that makes an action morally wrong -is it just the outcome of the action as compared with the outcomes of its alternatives? Or is it something else? Also, what are we essentially? Is the foetus merely our precursor? Then killing a foetus is relevantly similar to contraception. Or is the foetus one of us? If so, when we kill it, are we depriving it of a future as valuable as ours? Perhaps the relation of identity (the fact that it is its future as opposed to someone else's) doesn't matter. That may be because the foetus is an aggregate of biological and psychological facts and perhaps aggregates are not substances. Or maybe it is a substance but only psychological realtions matter, not personal identity. The second part of my project has to do with the different status these metaphisical and ethical positions ought to have in liberal public reason. Though this is the part in which most research is still needed, my own intuition is that, given the depth of the philosphical views in competition, restrictive abortion laws ought to be considered unrespectful to citizens' autonomy.

Ornament of Reason : an annoted english translation of rMa bya Byang chub brtson 'grus's : commentary to the Mūlamadhyamakakārikā

The present work contains an English translation of the Ornament of Reason (Tib. dBu ma'i rtsa ba shes rab kyi 'grel ba thad pa'i rgyan), an influential 12th century Tibetan commentary to a classic of Indian Buddhism, Nàgàrjuna's Root of the Middle Way (Skt. Mûlamadhyamaka-kârikâ Tib. dBu ma'i rtsa ba shes rab ces bya ba). The author, rMa bya byang chub brtson 'grus's, was among the first Tibetans to explicitly align themselves with the philosophical project of the 7th century Indian Madhyamaka teacher, CandrakTrti. With his stern revision and transformative re-employment of the epistemological framework that CandrakTrti otherwise scorns, rMa bya was however to develop an original and highly influential Madhyamaka interpretation.¦rMa bya's "topical outline" (Tib. sa bead) of his commentary is contained in the first appendix to the translation. The second appendix contains a digitalized version of the Rumtek edition of rMa bya's commentary, cross-referenced to the page numbers of the translation. The annotations contain concise explanatory remarks and suggestions for further reading, as well as identifications of the passages that rMa bya cites.

Critical studies: aspects of reason I

Book review of 'Aspects of reason' by P. Grice.

Abduction by philosophers: reorienting philosophical methodology

A reorientation is needed in methodological debate about the role of intuitions in philosophy. Methodological debate has lost sight of the reason why it makes sense to focus on questions about intuitions when thinking about the methods or epistemology of philosophy. The problem is an approach to methodology which gives a near exclusive focus to questions about some evidential role that intuitions may or may not play in philosophers' arguments. A new approach is needed. Approaching methodological questions about the role of intuitions in philosophy with an abductive model of philosophical enquiry in mind will help ensure the debate doesn't lose sight of what motivates the debate.

A formação humana na perspectiva histórico-ontológica

The theme of human formation is at the centre of the philosophy of education, whose aim is precisely the process of human promotion brought about by education. Starting from the critical vigilance proper to philosophy, the text sketches a phenomenology of the present time, verifying that the ideas prevailing in education at present are centred on the critique of reason and on the notions of truth and objectivity. This neo-pragmatism, which in the attempt to oppose metaphysics becomes deeply metaphysical, reducing everything to language, is contested by the authors with Marx's thoughts as a historicising philosophy that concerns not abstract subjects, but real individuals, historical subjects that are constituted as a synthesis of social relations. To that end, the authors resort to the historical ontological reflection on human formation contained in Marx's Economic and Philosophical Manuscripts of 1844. The article concludes by defending the proposition that access to the classics is a necessary condition for human formation.