How Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation Can Modulate Implicit Motor Sequence Learning and Consolidation: A Brief Review

The purpose of this review is to investigate how transcranial direct current stimulation(tDCS)can modulate implicit motor sequence learning and consolidation. So far, most of the studies have focused on the modulating effect of tDCS for explicit motor learning. Here, we focus explicitly on implicit motor sequence learning and consolidation in order to improve our understanding about the potential of tDCS to affect this kind of unconscious learning. Specifically, we concentrate on studies with the serial reaction time task (SRTT), the classical paradigm for measuring implicit motor sequence learning. The influence of tDCS has been investigated for the primary motor cortex, the premotor cortex, the prefrontal cortex, and the cerebellum. The results indicate that tDCS above the primary motor cortex gives raise to the most consistent modulating effects for both implicit motor sequence learning and consolidation.

Learning joint representations for order and timing of perceptual-motor sequences: a dynamic neural field approach

Many of our everyday tasks require the control of the serial order and the timing of component actions. Using the dynamic neural field (DNF) framework, we address the learning of representations that support the performance of precisely time action sequences. In continuation of previous modeling work and robotics implementations, we ask specifically the question how feedback about executed actions might be used by the learning system to fine tune a joint memory representation of the ordinal and the temporal structure which has been initially acquired by observation. The perceptual memory is represented by a self-stabilized, multi-bump activity pattern of neurons encoding instances of a sensory event (e.g., color, position or pitch) which guides sequence learning. The strength of the population representation of each event is a function of elapsed time since sequence onset. We propose and test in simulations a simple learning rule that detects a mismatch between the expected and realized timing of events and adapts the activation strengths in order to compensate for the movement time needed to achieve the desired effect. The simulation results show that the effector-specific memory representation can be robustly recalled. We discuss the impact of the fast, activation-based learning that the DNF framework provides for robotics applications.

Neural substrates and functional connectivity associated with sleep-dependent and independent consolidation of new motor skills

La mémoire n’est pas un processus unitaire et est souvent divisée en deux catégories majeures: la mémoire déclarative (pour les faits) et procédurale (pour les habitudes et habiletés motrices). Pour perdurer, une trace mnésique doit passer par la consolidation, un processus par lequel elle devient plus robuste et moins susceptible à l’interférence. Le sommeil est connu comme jouant un rôle clé pour permettre le processus de consolidation, particulièrement pour la mémoire déclarative. Depuis plusieurs années cependant, son rôle est aussi reconnu pour la mémoire procédurale. Il est par contre intéressant de noter que ce ne sont pas tous les types de mémoire procédurale qui requiert le sommeil afin d’être consolidée. Entre autres, le sommeil semble nécessaire pour consolider un apprentissage de séquences motrices (s’apparentant à l’apprentissage du piano), mais pas un apprentissage d’adaptation visuomotrice (tel qu’apprendre à rouler à bicyclette). Parallèlement, l’apprentissage à long terme de ces deux types d’habiletés semble également sous-tendu par des circuits neuronaux distincts; c’est-à-dire un réseau cortico-striatal et cortico-cérébelleux respectivement. Toutefois, l’implication de ces réseaux dans le processus de consolidation comme tel demeure incertain. Le but de cette thèse est donc de mieux comprendre le rôle du sommeil, en contrôlant pour le simple passage du temps, dans la consolidation de ces deux types d’apprentissage, à l’aide de l’imagerie par résonnance magnétique fonctionnelle et d’analyses de connectivité cérébrale. Nos résultats comportementaux supportent l’idée que seul l’apprentissage séquentiel requiert le sommeil pour déclencher le processus de consolidation. Nous suggérons de plus que le putamen est fortement associé à ce processus. En revanche, les performances d’un apprentissage visuomoteur s’améliorent indépendamment du sommeil et sont de plus corrélées à une plus grande activation du cervelet. Finalement, en explorant l’effet du sommeil sur la connectivité cérébrale, nos résultats démontrent qu’en fait, un système cortico-striatal semble être plus intégré suite à la consolidation. C’est-à-dire que l’interaction au sein des régions du système est plus forte lorsque la consolidation a eu lieu, après une nuit de sommeil. En opposition, le simple passage du temps semble nuire à l’intégration de ce réseau cortico-striatal. En somme, nous avons pu élargir les connaissances quant au rôle du sommeil pour la mémoire procédurale, notamment en démontrant que ce ne sont pas tous les types d’apprentissages qui requièrent le sommeil pour amorcer le processus de consolidation. D’ailleurs, nous avons également démontré que cette dissociation de l’effet du sommeil est également reflétée par l’implication de deux réseaux cérébraux distincts. À savoir, un réseau cortico-striatal et un réseau cortico-cérébelleux pour la consolidation respective de l’apprentissage de séquence et d’adaptation visuomotrice. Enfin, nous suggérons que la consolidation durant le sommeil permet de protéger et favoriser une meilleure cohésion au sein du réseau cortico-striatal associé à notre tâche; un phénomène qui, s’il est retrouvé avec d’autres types d’apprentissage, pourrait être considéré comme un nouveau marqueur de la consolidation.

Interference during the implicit learning of two different motor sequences

It has been demonstrated that learning a second motor task after having learned a first task may interfere with the long-term consolidation of the first task. However, little is known about immediate changes in the representation of the motor memory in the early acquisition phase within the first minutes of the learning process. Therefore, we investigated such early interference effects with an implicit serial reaction time task in 55 healthy subjects. Each subject performed either a sequence learning task involving two different sequences, or a random control task. The results showed that learning the first sequence led to only a slight, short-lived interference effect in the early acquisition phase of the second sequence. Overall, learning of neither sequence was impaired. Furthermore, the two processes, sequence-unrelated task learning (i.e. general motor training) and the sequence learning itself did not appear to interfere with each other. In conclusion, although the long-term consolidation of a motor memory has been shown to be sensitive to other interfering memories, the present study suggests that the brain is initially able to acquire more than one new motor sequence within a short space of time without significant interference.

Étude multimodale de la consolidation d’habiletés motrices à ‎l’aide de l’IRMf et de l’EEG

La consolidation est le processus qui transforme une nouvelle trace mnésique labile en ‎une autre plus stable et plus solide. Une des tâches utilisées en laboratoire pour ‎l’exploration de la consolidation motrice dans ses dimensions comportementale et ‎cérébrale est la tâche d’apprentissage de séquences motrices. Celle-ci consiste à ‎reproduire une même série de mouvements des doigts, apprise de manière implicite ou ‎explicite, tout en mesurant l’amélioration dans l’exécution. Les études récentes ont ‎montré que, dans le cas de l’apprentissage explicite de cette tâche, la consolidation de la ‎trace mnésique associée à cette nouvelle habileté dépendrait du sommeil, et plus ‎particulièrement des fuseaux en sommeil lent. Et bien que deux types de fuseaux aient ‎été décrits (lents et rapides), le rôle de chacun d’eux dans la consolidation d’une ‎séquence motrice est encore mal exploré. En effet, seule une étude s’est intéressée à ce ‎rôle, montrant alors une implication des fuseaux rapides dans ce processus mnésique ‎suite à une nuit artificiellement altérée. D’autre part, les études utilisant l’imagerie ‎fonctionnelle (IRMf et PET scan) menées par différentes équipes dont la notre, ont ‎montré des changements au niveau de l’activité du système cortico-striatal suite à la ‎consolidation motrice. Cependant, aucune corrélation n’a été faite à ce jour entre ces ‎changements et les caractéristiques des fuseaux du sommeil survenant au cours de la nuit ‎suivant un apprentissage moteur. Les objectifs de cette thèse étaient donc: 1) de ‎déterminer, à travers des enregistrements polysomnographiques et des analyses ‎corrélationnelles, les caractéristiques des deux types de fuseaux (i.e. lents et rapides) ‎associées à la consolidation d’une séquence motrice suite à une nuit de sommeil non ‎altérée, et 2) d’explorer, à travers des analyses corrélationnelles entre les données ‎polysomnographiques et le signal BOLD (« Blood Oxygenated Level Dependent »), ‎acquis à l’aide de l’imagerie par résonance magnétique fonctionnelle (IRMf), ‎l’association entre les fuseaux du sommeil et les activations cérébrales suite à la ‎consolidation de la séquence motrice. Les résultats de notre première étude ont montré ‎une implication des fuseaux rapides, et non des fuseaux lents, dans la consolidation ‎d’une séquence motrice apprise de manière explicite après une nuit de sommeil non ‎altérée, corroborant ainsi les résultats des études antérieures utilisant des nuits de ‎sommeil altérées. En effet, les analyses statistiques ont mis en évidence une ‎augmentation significative de la densité des fuseaux rapides durant la nuit suivant ‎l’apprentissage moteur par comparaison à la nuit contrôle. De plus, cette augmentation ‎corrélait avec les gains spontanés de performance suivant la nuit. Par ailleurs, les ‎résultats de notre seconde étude ont mis en évidence des corrélations significatives entre ‎l’amplitude des fuseaux de la nuit expérimentale d’une part et les gains spontanés de ‎performance ainsi que les changements du signal BOLD au niveau du système cortico-‎striatal d’autre part. Nos résultats suggèrent donc un lien fonctionnel entre les fuseaux ‎du sommeil, les gains de performance ainsi que les changements neuronaux au niveau ‎du système cortico-striatal liés à la consolidation d’une séquence motrice explicite. Par ‎ailleurs, ils supportent l’implication des fuseaux rapides dans ce type de consolidation ; ‎ceux-ci aideraient à l’activation des circuits neuronaux impliqués dans ce processus ‎mnésique et amélioreraient par la même occasion la consolidation motrice liée au ‎sommeil.‎

Modulation du système glutamatergique pendant l’apprentissage moteur : une étude de spectroscopie par résonance magnétique fonctionnelle

La présente étude avait pour but d’explorer les modulations fonctionnelles putaminales du signal de spectroscopie par résonance magnétique (SRM) combiné du glutamate et de la glutamine (Glx), ainsi que de l’acide γ-aminobutyrique (GABA) en lien avec l’apprentissage d’une séquence motrice. Nous avons émis l’hypothèse que les concentrations de Glx seraient spécifiquement augmentées pendant et après la pratique d’une telle tâche, et ce comparativement à une condition d’exécution motrice simple conçue pour minimiser l’apprentissage. La tâche d’appuis séquentiels des doigts (« finger taping task ») utilisée est connue pour induire un apprentissage moteur évoluant en phases, avec une progression initialement rapide lors de la première session d’entraînement (phase rapide), puis lente lors de sessions subséquentes (phase lente). Cet apprentissage est également conçu comme dépendant de processus « on-line » (pendant la pratique) d’acquisition et « off-line » (entre les périodes de pratique) de consolidation de la trace mnésique de l’habilité motrice. Une grande quantité de données impliquent le système de neurotransmission glutamatergique, principalement par l’action de ses récepteurs N-Méthyl-D-aspartate (NMDAR) et métabotropiques (mGluR), dans une multitude de domaine de la mémoire. Quelques-unes de ces études suggèrent que cette relation s’applique aussi à des mémoires de type motrice ou dépendante du striatum. De plus, certains travaux chez l’animal montrent qu’une hausse des concentrations de glutamate et de glutamine peut être associée à l’acquisition et/ou consolidation d’une trace mnésique. Nos mesures de SRM à 3.0 Tesla, dont la qualité ne s’est avérée satisfaisante que pour le Glx, démontrent qu’une telle modulation des concentrations de Glx est effectivement détectable dans le putamen après la performance d’une tâche motrice. Elles ne nous permettent toutefois pas de dissocier cet effet putativement attribuable à la plasticité du putamen associée à l’apprentissage moteur de séquence, de celui de la simple activation neuronale causée par l’exécution motrice. L’interprétation de l’interaction non significative, montrant une plus grande modulation par la tâche motrice simple, mène cependant à l’hypothèse alternative que la plasticité glutamatergique détectée est potentiellement plus spécifique à la phase lente de l’apprentissage, suggérant qu’une seconde expérience ainsi orientée et utilisant une méthode de SRM plus sensible au Glx aurait donc de meilleures chances d’offrir des résultats concluants.

Mapeamento de regiões de ativação cerebral durante tarefas deglutórias por imagens de ressonância magnética funcional

INTRODUÇÃO: A deglutição é um processo fisiológico complexo que acontece por uma sequência motora automática, regulada por um complicado mecanismo neuromotor e neuromuscular que é iniciado de maneira consciente e é resultado da integridade anatômica e funcional de diversas estruturas faciais. É de extrema importância para a nutrição do organismo como um todo. Um dos maiores desafios no campo das ciências é identificar os substratos neurais de comportamentos fisiológicos, incluindo esse processo de deglutição. O desenvolvimento da tecnologia em neuroimagem funcional nos últimos anos está provocando um rápido avanço no conhecimento de funções cerebrais, o que resultou numa explosão de novos achados em neurociência. OBJETIVO: Mapear as regiões de ativação cerebral durante o fenômeno da deglutição por meio do exame de ressonância magnética funcional. MÉTODO: Participaram do estudo quatro indivíduos do sexo feminino, com idade entre 18 e 30 anos, sem alterações neurológicas, estruturais e alimentares. Após a aprovação da Instituição (Clínica Lobo), do Comité de Ética e Pesquisa do Instituto de Ciências da Saúde (ICS) e a aprovação escrita de cada paciente através do termo de consentimento livre e esclarecido, foram submetidos a quatro provas deglutórias, utilizando a técnica de ressonância magnética funcional. RESULTADOS: Foi possível a determinação da ativação dos hemisférios cerebrais e cerebelares e as especificas áreas que os compõem. Mesmo com uma amostragem pequena, os resultados das análises individuais mostraram padrões de acordo com a literatura, conjuntamente com dados novos. DISCUSSÃO: O cerebelo é responsável pela coordenação da ação motora e manutenção da harmonia dos movimentos, posição e equilíbrio do bolo alimentar; o bolbo raquidiano juntamente com o tronco cerebral constitui o centro de atividades reflexas que controla funções ou respostas orgânicas automáticas como a deglutição; o mesencéfalo é a parte do encéfalo que coordena a informação visual; o tálamo encaminha quase todo o tipo de informação sensorial para as zonas específicas do córtex cerebral; o hipotálamo, importante na experimentação das sensações de prazer, regula as funções homeostáticas do corpo, gustação, olfação, salivação, interagindo com o sistema nervoso autônomo e o sistema límbico está ligado ao controle e direção das reações emocionais, sob a ação da amígdala, no processamento de odores e no armazenamento de conteúdos da memória, aqui através do hipocampo. CONCLUSÃO: O ato de deglutir é um processo complexo, ativando muitas áreas cerebrais, dentre elas podemos destacar a gustativa, mental/visual e a olfativa e que é iniciado muito antes dos processos mecânicos envolvidos, conforme demonstrado pelas áreas corticais e subcorticais ativadas. A área olfativa foi a mais notadamente destacada nas imagens colhidas pela Rmf.

Brain activation during anticipation of sound sequences

Music consists of sound sequences that require integration over time. As we become familiar with music, associations between notes, melodies, and entire symphonic movements become stronger and more complex. These associations can become so tight that, for example, hearing the end of one album track can elicit a robust image of the upcoming track while anticipating it in total silence. Here, we study this predictive “anticipatory imagery” at various stages throughout learning and investigate activity changes in corresponding neural structures using functional magnetic resonance imaging. Anticipatory imagery (in silence) for highly familiar naturalistic music was accompanied by pronounced activity in rostral prefrontal cortex (PFC) and premotor areas. Examining changes in the neural bases of anticipatory imagery during two stages of learning conditional associations between simple melodies, however, demonstrates the importance of fronto-striatal connections, consistent with a role of the basal ganglia in “training” frontal cortex (Pasupathy and Miller, 2005). Another striking change in neural resources during learning was a shift between caudal PFC earlier to rostral PFC later in learning. Our findings regarding musical anticipation and sound sequence learning are highly compatible with studies of motor sequence learning, suggesting common predictive mechanisms in both domains.

Representation of motor habit in a sequence of repetitive reach and grasp movements performed by macaque monkeys: evidence for a contribution of the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex.

In the context of an autologous cell transplantation study, a unilateral biopsy of cortical tissue was surgically performed from the right dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (dlPFC) in two intact adult macaque monkeys (dlPFC lesioned group), together with the implantation of a chronic chamber providing access to the left motor cortex. Three other monkeys were subjected to the same chronic chamber implantation, but without dlPFC biopsy (control group). All monkeys were initially trained to perform sequential manual dexterity tasks, requiring precision grip. The motor performance and the prehension's sequence (temporal order to grasp pellets from different spatial locations) were analysed for each hand. Following the surgery, transient and moderate deficits of manual dexterity per se occurred in both groups, indicating that they were not due to the dlPFC lesion (most likely related to the recording chamber implantation and/or general anaesthesia/medication). In contrast, changes of motor habit were observed for the sequential order of grasping in the two monkeys with dlPFC lesion only. The changes were more prominent in the monkey subjected to the largest lesion, supporting the notion of a specific effect of the dlPFC lesion on the motor habit of the monkeys. These observations are reminiscent of previous studies using conditional tasks with delay that have proposed a specialization of the dlPFC for visuo-spatial working memory, except that this is in a different context of "free-will", non-conditional manual dexterity task, without a component of working memory.

Number of options in a movement sequence affects learners' behavior in a self-controlled practice condition

Self controlling practice implies a process of decision making which suggests that the options in a self controlled practice condition could affect learners The number of task components with no fixed position in a movement sequence may affect the (Nay learners self control their practice A 200 cm coincident timing track with 90 light emitting diodes (LEDs)-the first and the last LEDs being the warning and the target lights respectively was set so that the apparent speed of the light along the track was 1 33 m/sec Participants were required to touch six sensors sequentially the last one coincidently with the lighting of the tar get light (timing task) Group 1 (n=55) had only one constraint and were instructed to touch the sensors in any order except for the last sensor which had to be the one positioned close to the target light Group 2 (n=53) had three constraints the first two and the last sensor to be touched Both groups practiced the task until timing error was less than 30 msec on three consecutive trials There were no statistically significant differences between groups in the number of trials needed to reach the performance criterion but (a) participants in Group 2 created fewer sequences corn pared to Group 1 and (b) were more likely to use the same sequence throughout the learning process The number of options for a movement sequence affected the way learners self-controlled their practice but had no effect on the amount of practice to reach criterion performance.

Sequence heterogeneity in Parkinsonian speech

Parkinson's disease (PD) is a neurodegenerative movement disorder primarily due to basal ganglia dysfunction. While much research has been conducted on Parkinsonian deficits in the traditional arena of musculoskeletal limb movement, research in other functional motor tasks is lacking. The present study examined articulation in PD with increasingly complex sequences of articulatory movement. Of interest was whether dysfunction would affect articulation in the same manner as in limb-movement impairment. In particular, since very Similar (homogeneous) articulatory sequences (the tongue twister effect) are more difficult for healthy individuals to achieve than dissimilar (heterogeneous) gestures, while the reverse may apply for skeletal movements in PD, we asked which factor would dominate when PD patients articulated various grades of artificial tongue twisters: the influence of disease or a possible difference between the two motor systems. Execution was especially impaired when articulation involved a sequence of motor program heterogeneous in terms of place of articulation. The results are suggestive of a hypokinesic tendency in complex sequential articulatory movement as in limb movement. It appears that PD patients do show abnormalities in articulatory movement which are similar to those of the musculoskeletal system. The present study suggests that an underlying disease effect modulates movement impairment across different functional motor systems. (C) 1998 Academic Press.

Effect of changing data collection parameters on statistical motor unit number estimates

The effect of number of samples and selection of data for analysis on the calculation of surface motor unit potential (SMUP) size in the statistical method of motor unit number estimates (MUNE) was determined in 10 normal subjects and 10 with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). We recorded 500 sequential compound muscle action potentials (CMAPs) at three different stable stimulus intensities (10–50% of maximal CMAP). Estimated mean SMUP sizes were calculated using Poisson statistical assumptions from the variance of 500 sequential CMAP obtained at each stimulus intensity. The results with the 500 data points were compared with smaller subsets from the same data set. The results using a range of 50–80% of the 500 data points were compared with the full 500. The effect of restricting analysis to data between 5–20% of the CMAP and to standard deviation limits was also assessed. No differences in mean SMUP size were found with stimulus intensity or use of different ranges of data. Consistency was improved with a greater sample number. Data within 5% of CMAP size gave both increased consistency and reduced mean SMUP size in many subjects, but excluded valid responses present at that stimulus intensity. These changes were more prominent in ALS patients in whom the presence of isolated SMUP responses was a striking difference from normal subjects. Noise, spurious data, and large SMUP limited the Poisson assumptions. When these factors are considered, consistent statistical MUNE can be calculated from a continuous sequence of data points. A 2 to 2.5 SD or 10% window are reasonable methods of limiting data for analysis. Muscle Nerve 27: 320–331, 2003

Influência da actividade do tronco inferior na sequência de activação muscular proximal durante o passo (fase de apoio) - em crianças com quadro motor diplegia

A marcha assegura uma progressão do corpo, compatível com o equilíbrio dinâmico e adaptada a potenciais factores destabilizadores, de um ponto de vista antecipatório, através de sinergias coordenadas entre os MSs, o tronco e os MIs. O tronco inferior tem um papel preponderante na marcha, sobretudo na estabilização necessária durante a fase de apoio. Esta actividade implica mobilidade pélvica e alongamento activo dos abdominais para conseguir a relação comprimento-tensão muscular óptima entre quadricípite e isquiotibiais, permitindo uma correcta sequência, timing e amplitude de activação. Nas crianças com alterações neuromotoras existem alterações no controlo do movimento e na estrutura do próprio movimento, alterando todo este processo. Como tal, este estudo tem como principal objectivo determinar a influência da actividade do tronco inferior na activação muscular proximal durante a fase de apoio da marcha, em crianças com quadro motor de diplegia, caracterizada por uma dificuldade na relação entre os membros e entre estes e o tronco. Para responder a este objectivo realizou-se um estudo de série de casos, com 2 crianças com quadro motor de diplegia. Efectuou-se EMG dos músculos abdominais, quadricípite e isquiotibiais e análise de imagem (para amplitude da CF) durante a marcha, em ambos os membros e em dois momentos de avaliação, separados por 2 meses, nos quais se realizou um protocolo de intervenção terapêutica adequado a cada caso. Os resultados indicam que a variação de amplitude da CF desde a fase de ataque ao solo à fase média de apoio é aproximadamente igual em M0e M1; concretamente, a amplitude inicial é inferior à de referência (pouca flexão) (melhor em M0) e a amplitude final é superior à de referência (pouca extensão) (melhor em M1). Estes resultados são idênticos em ambos os casos. Na EMG verificou-se uma actividade mais global e sincronizada de todos os músculos, mantendo-se aproximadamente a mesma percentagem de activação em M1, sobretudo no caso 1. No caso 2 verificou-se uma maior eficiência na variação da percentagem de activação dos abdominais, em M1, e dos isquiotibiais, à direita. Em conclusão, pode dizer-se que, em crianças com alterações neuromotoras (quadro motor de diplegia), uma actividade mais eficiente e sincronizada no tempo do tronco inferior, nomeadamente dos abdominais, contribui para uma maior capacidade de extensão da CF, durante a fase de apoio.

Soleus activity in post-stroke subjects: movement sequence from standing to sitting

O documento em anexo encontra-se na versão post-print (versão corrigida pelo editor).