Evolutionary conservation of the membrane fusion machine

Recent structural studies of proteins mediating membrane fusion reveal intriguing similarities between diverse viral and mammalian systems. Particularly striking is the close similarity between the transmembrane envelope glycoproteins from the retrovirus HTLV-1 and the filovirus Ebola. These similarities suggest similar mechanisms of membrane fusion. The model that fits most currently available data suggests fusion activation in viral systems is driven by a symmetrical conformational change triggered by an activation event such as receptor binding or a pH change. The mammalian vesicle fusion mediated by the SNARE protein complex most likely occurs by a similar mechanism but without symmetry constraints.

Dynamin-SNARE interactions control trans-SNARE formation in intracellular membrane fusion.

The fundamental processes of membrane fission and fusion determine size and copy numbers of intracellular organelles. Although SNARE proteins and tethering complexes mediate intracellular membrane fusion, fission requires the presence of dynamin or dynamin-related proteins. Here we study these reactions in native yeast vacuoles and find that the yeast dynamin homologue Vps1 is not only an essential part of the fission machinery, but also controls membrane fusion by generating an active Qa SNARE-tethering complex pool, which is essential for trans-SNARE formation. Our findings provide new insight into the role of dynamins in membrane fusion by directly acting on SNARE proteins.

Force-induced globule-coil transition in laminin binding protein and its role for viral-cell membrane fusion.

The specific interactions of the pairs laminin binding protein (LBP)-purified tick-borne encephalitis viral surface protein E and certain recombinant fragments of this protein, as well as West Nile viral surface protein E and certain recombinant fragments of that protein, are studied by combined methods of single-molecule dynamic force spectroscopy (SMDFS), enzyme immunoassay and optical surface waves-based biosensor measurements. The experiments were performed at neutral pH (7.4) and acid pH (5.3) conditions. The data obtained confirm the role of LBP as a cell receptor for two typical viral species of the Flavivirus genus. A comparison of these data with similar data obtained for another cell receptor of this family, namely human αVβ3 integrin, reveals that both these receptors are very important. Studying the specific interaction between the cell receptors in question and specially prepared monoclonal antibodies against them, we could show that both interaction sites involved in the process of virus-cell interaction remain intact at pH 5.3. At the same time, for these acid conditions characteristic for an endosome during flavivirus-cell membrane fusion, SMDFS data reveal the existence of a force-induced (effective already for forces as small as 30-70 pN) sharp globule-coil transition for LBP and LBP-fragments of protein E complexes. We argue that this conformational transformation, being an analog of abrupt first-order phase transition and having similarity with the famous Rayleigh hydrodynamic instability, might be indispensable for the flavivirus-cell membrane fusion process. Copyright © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Sequential analysis of trans-SNARE formation in intracellular membrane fusion.

SNARE complexes are required for membrane fusion in the endomembrane system. They contain coiled-coil bundles of four helices, three (Q(a), Q(b), and Q(c)) from target (t)-SNAREs and one (R) from the vesicular (v)-SNARE. NSF/Sec18 disrupts these cis-SNARE complexes, allowing reassembly of their subunits into trans-SNARE complexes and subsequent fusion. Studying these reactions in native yeast vacuoles, we found that NSF/Sec18 activates the vacuolar cis-SNARE complex by selectively displacing the vacuolar Q(a) SNARE, leaving behind a Q(bc)R subcomplex. This subcomplex serves as an acceptor for a Q(a) SNARE from the opposite membrane, leading to Q(a)-Q(bc)R trans-complexes. Activity tests of vacuoles with diagnostic distributions of inactivating mutations over the two fusion partners confirm that this distribution accounts for a major share of the fusion activity. The persistence of the Q(bc)R cis-complex and the formation of the Q(a)-Q(bc)R trans-complex are both sensitive to the Rab-GTPase inhibitor, GDI, and to mutations in the vacuolar tether complex, HOPS (HOmotypic fusion and vacuolar Protein Sorting complex). This suggests that the vacuolar Rab-GTPase, Ypt7, and HOPS restrict cis-SNARE disassembly and thereby bias trans-SNARE assembly into a preferred topology.

Trans-SNARE pairing can precede a hemifusion intermediate in intracellular membrane fusion.

The question concerning whether all membranes fuse according to the same mechanism has yet to be answered satisfactorily. During fusion of model membranes or viruses, membranes dock, the outer membrane leaflets mix (termed hemifusion), and finally the fusion pore opens and the contents mix. Viral fusion proteins consist of a membrane-disturbing 'fusion peptide' and a helical bundle that pin the membranes together. Although SNARE (soluble N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive factor attachment protein receptor) complexes form helical bundles with similar topology, it is unknown whether SNARE-dependent fusion events on intracellular membranes proceed through a hemifusion state. Here we identify the first hemifusion state for SNARE-dependent fusion of native membranes, and place it into a sequence of molecular events: formation of helical bundles by SNAREs precedes hemifusion; further progression to pore opening requires additional peptides. Thus, SNARE-dependent fusion may proceed along the same pathway as viral fusion: both use a docking mechanism via helical bundles and additional peptides to destabilize the membrane and efficiently induce lipid mixing. Our results suggest that a common lipidic intermediate may underlie all fusion reactions of lipid bilayers.

The role of the vacuolar H+ - ATPase in membrane fusion

RésuméLa H+-ATPase vacuolaire (V-ATPase) est un complexe enzymatique composé de deux secteurs multimériques (VQ et Vi) dont l'association dans la cellule est réversible. Le secteur intramembranaire de la V-ATPase (V0) interagit physiquement avec des protéines SNARE et stimule la fusion homotypique des vacuoles de la levure (lysosomes), la sécrétion de neurotransmetteurs et d'insuline, la fusion entre phagosome et lysosome ainsi que la sécrétion des corps multivésiculaires par un mécanisme inconnu. Dans cette étude j'ai identifié des résidues d'acides amines situés dans des sous-unités de V0 impliqués dans le mécanisme de fusion des vacuoles mais non essentiels pour l'acidification vacuolaire par la V-ATPase. j'ai utilisé un protocole de mutagenèse aléatoire pour produire des libraries de mutants des sous unités de V0. Ces libraries ont été analysées in vivo afin d'identifier des alleles qui permettent la translocation des protons mais produisent une vacuole fragmentée, phénotype indiquant un défaut dans la fusion membranaire. Les vacuoles des mutants ont été isolées et caractéisées en utilisant une grande variété d'outils biochimiques pour déterminer précisément l'impact des différentes mutations sur l'accomplissement d'événements clés du processus de fusion.J'ai identifié des mutations associées à des défauts spécifiques de la fusion dans plusieurs sous-unités de V0. Dans les protéolipides c, c' et c" ces mutations se concentrent dans la partie cytosolique des domaines transmembranaires. Elles renforcent les associations entre les secteurs de la V-ATPase et entre V0 et les SNAREs. Dans la fusion vacuolaire ces mutations permettent la formation de complexes SNAREs en trans mais inhibent l'induction de la fusion. Par contre, la deletion de la sous- unité d influence les étapes de la fusion qui précèdent la formation des complexes trans-SNAREs. Mes résultats démontrent que V0 joue des rôles différents dans plusieurs étapes de la fusion et que ces fonctions sont liées au système des SNAREs. Ils différencient génétiquement les activités de V0 dans la translocation des protons et dans la fusion et identifient de nombreux résidus importants pour la fusion vacuolaire. De plus, compte tenu de la grande conservation de sequence des protéolipides chez les eukaryotes les mutations identifiées dans cette l'étude apportent de nouvelles informations pour analyser la fonction de V0 dans des organismes multicellulaires pour lesquels la function catalytique de la V-ATPase est essentielle à la survie.Résumé pour le large publicLe transport de protéines et de membranes est important pour maintenir la fonction des organelles dans la cellule. Il s'excerce au niveau des vesicules. La fusion membranaire est un processus élémentaire de ce transport. Pour fusionner deux membranes, il faut la coordination de deux activités: le rapprochement et la déstabiiization des deux membranes. La collaboration d'un ensemble de proteins conservés chez les eukaryotes, est nécessaire pour catalyser ces activités. Les proteins SNAREs sont les protagonistes principaux dans la fusion membranaire. Néanmoins, d'autres protéines, comme des Rab-GTPases et des chaperonnes, sont nécessaires pour permettre ce phénomène de fusion. Toutes ces protéines sont temporairement associées avec les SNAREs et leur fonction dans la fusion membranaire est souvent directement liée à leur activité dans cette association. Le secteur transmembranaire V0 de la V-ATPase rnteragit avec des SNAREs et est essentiel pour la fusion dans une variété de systèmes modèles comme la mouche, la souris et la levure. Le secteur V0 est composé de six protéines différentes. Avec te secteur Va, qui réside dans le cytosol, il forme la V-ATPase dont la fonction principale est l'acidification des organelles par translocation des protons à travers la membrane par un mécanisme ressemblant à celui d'une pompe. V0joue un role dans la fusion membranaire, indépendamment de son activité catalytique liée au pompage des protons, et ce rôle est encore largement méconnu à ce jour. Le but de ma thèse était de mieux comprendre l'implication de V0 dans ce contexte.Pour étudier des activités liées à la V-ATPase, la levure est un excellent modèle d'étude car elle survie à une inactivation de l'enzyme alors que le meme traitement serait léthal pour des organismes multicellulaires. Dans ma thèse j'ai utilisé la fusion homotypique de la vacuole de levure comme système modèle pour étudier le rôle de V0 dans la fusion. J'ai muté des gènes qui encodent des sous- unités de V0 et les ai introduit dans des souches privées des gènes respectifs. Dans les librairies de souches portant différentes versions de ces gènes j'ai cherché des clones exprimant une V-ATPase intacte et fonctionnelle mais qui possèdent une vacuole fragmentée. Le plus souvent, une vacuole fragmentée indique un défaut dans la fusion vacuolaire. Dans les trois types de protéolipides qui composent un cylindre dans le secteur V0, j'ai trouvé des clones avec une vacuole fragmentée. Après avoir isolé les mutations responsable de ce type de morphologie vacuolaire, j'ai isolé les vacuoles de ces clones pour étudier leur activités dans différentes étapes de la fusion vacuolaire. Les résultats de ces analyses mettent en évidence une implication de V0 dans plusieurs étapes de la fusion vacuolaire. Certaines mutations sélectionnées dans mon étude inhibent une étape précoce de la fusion qui inclue la dissociation des complexes SNARE, tandis que d'autres mutations inhibent une étape tardive du processus de fusion qui inclue la transmission d'une force disruptive dans la membrane.AbstractThe membrane-integral V0 sector of the vacuolar H+-ATPase (V-ATPase) interacts with SNARE proteins. V0 stimulates fusion between yeast vacuoles (lysosomes) (Peters et al., 2001b), secretion of neurotransmitters and insulin (Hiesinger et al., 2005a, Sun-Wada et al., 2006a), phagosome-lysosome fusion (Peri and Nusslein-Volhard, 2008) and secretion of multivesicular bodies (Liegeois et al., 2006b) by a yet unknown mechanism. In my thesis, I identified sites in V0 subunits that are involved in yeast vacuole fusion but dispensable for the proton pumping by the V-ATPase. I randomly mutagenized V0 subunits and screened in vivo for mutant alleles that support proton pumping but cause fragmented vacuoles, a phenotype indicative of a fusion defect. Mutant vacuoles were isolated and analyzed in a cell-free system, allowing assay of key events in fusion, such as trans-SNARE pairing, lipid transition and fusion pore opening (Reese et al., 2005b).Mutants with selective fusion defects were found in several V0 subunits. In the proteolipids c, c' and c", critical mutations are concentated in the cytosolic half of the transmembrane domains. These mutations rendered the V-ATPase holoenzyme more stable and modulated V0-SNARE associations. In vacuole fusion critical proteolipid mutations permitted trans-SNARE pairing but impeded the induction of lipid flow between the membranes. Deletion of subunit d, by contrast, influenced early stages of fusion that precede trans-SNARE pairing. My results show that V0 acts in several steps of the fusion process and that its function is intimately connected to the SNARE system. They genetically separate the proton pump and fusion activities of V0 and identify numerous critical residues. Given the high sequence conservation of proteolipids in eukaryotic life, the identified mutations may be helpful in analyzing the fusion function of V0 also in mammalian cells, where V- ATPase pump function is essential for survival.

Transition from hemifusion to pore opening is rate limiting for vacuole membrane fusion.

Fusion pore opening and expansion are considered the most energy-demanding steps in viral fusion. Whether this also applies to soluble N-ethyl-maleimide sensitive fusion protein attachment protein receptor (SNARE)- and Rab-dependent fusion events has been unknown. We have addressed the problem by characterizing the effects of lysophosphatidylcholine (LPC) and other late-stage inhibitors on lipid mixing and pore opening during vacuole fusion. LPC inhibits fusion by inducing positive curvature in the bilayer and changing its biophysical properties. The LPC block reversibly prevented formation of the hemifusion intermediate that allows lipid, but not content, mixing. Transition from hemifusion to pore opening was sensitive to guanosine-5'-(gamma-thio)triphosphate. It required the vacuolar adenosine triphosphatase V0 sector and coincided with its transformation. Pore opening was rate limiting for the reaction. As with viral fusion, opening the fusion pore may be the most energy-demanding step for intracellular, SNARE-dependent fusion reactions, suggesting that fundamental aspects of lipid mixing and pore opening are related for both systems.

Viral membrane fusion: is glycoprotein G of rhabdoviruses a representative of a new class of viral fusion proteins?

Enveloped viruses always gain entry into the cytoplasm by fusion of their lipid envelope with a cell membrane. Some enveloped viruses fuse directly with the host cell plasma membrane after virus binding to the cell receptor. Other enveloped viruses enter the cells by the endocytic pathway, and fusion depends on the acidification of the endosomal compartment. In both cases, virus-induced membrane fusion is triggered by conformational changes in viral envelope glycoproteins. Two different classes of viral fusion proteins have been described on the basis of their molecular architecture. Several structural data permitted the elucidation of the mechanisms of membrane fusion mediated by class I and class II fusion proteins. In this article, we review a number of results obtained by our laboratory and by others that suggest that the mechanisms involved in rhabdovirus fusion are different from those used by the two well-studied classes of viral glycoproteins. We focus our discussion on the electrostatic nature of virus binding and interaction with membranes, especially through phosphatidylserine, and on the reversibility of the conformational changes of the rhabdovirus glycoprotein involved in fusion. Taken together, these data suggest the existence of a third class of fusion proteins and support the idea that new insights should emerge from studies of membrane fusion mediated by the G protein of rhabdoviruses. In particular, the elucidation of the three-dimensional structure of the G protein or even of the fusion peptide at different pH's might provide valuable information for understanding the fusion mechanism of this new class of fusion proteins.

Inactivation of vesicular stomatitis virus through inhibition of membrane fusion by chemical modification of the viral glycoprotein

Membrane fusion is an essential step in the entry of enveloped viruses into their host cells triggered by conformational changes in viral glycoproteins. We have demonstrated previously that modification of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) with diethylpyrocarbonate (DEPC) abolished conformational changes on VSV glycoprotein and the fusion reaction catalyzed by the virus. In the present study, we evaluated whether treatment with DEPC was able to inactivate the virus. Infectivity and viral replication were abolished by viral treatment with 0.5 mM DEPC. Mortality profile and inflammatory response in the central nervous system indicated that G protein modification with DEPC eliminates the ability of the virus to cause disease. In addition, DEPC treatment did not alter the conformational integrity of surface proteins of inactivated VSV as demonstrated by transmission electron microscopy and competitive ELISA. Taken together, our results suggest a potential use of histidine (His) modification to the development of a new process of viral inactivation based on fusion inhibition. © 2006 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

N-(3-Cyanophenyl)-2-phenylacetamide, an effective inhibitor of morbillivirus-induced membrane fusion with low cytotoxicity

Based on the structural similarity of viral fusion proteins within the family Paramyxoviridae, we tested recently described and newly synthesized acetanilide derivatives for their capacity to inhibit measles virus (MV)-, canine distemper virus (CDV)- and Nipah virus (NiV)-induced membrane fusion. We found that N-(3-cyanophenyl)-2-phenylacetamide (compound 1) has a high capacity to inhibit MV- and CDV-induced (IC(50) muM), but not NiV-induced, membrane fusion. This compound is of outstanding interest because it can be easily synthesized and its cytotoxicity is low [50 % cytotoxic concentration (CC(50)) >/= 300 muM], leading to a CC(50)/IC(50) ratio of approximately 100. In addition, primary human peripheral blood lymphocytes and primary dog brain cell cultures (DBC) also tolerate high concentrations of compound 1. Infection of human PBMC with recombinant wild-type MV is inhibited by an IC(50) of approximately 20 muM. The cell-to-cell spread of recombinant wild-type CDV in persistently infected DBC can be nearly completely inhibited by compound 1 at 50 muM, indicating that the virus spread between brain cells is dependent on the activity of the viral fusion protein. Our findings demonstrate that this compound is a most applicable inhibitor of morbillivirus-induced membrane fusion in tissue culture experiments including highly sensitive primary cells.

Structural rearrangements of the central region of the morbillivirus attachment protein stalk domain trigger F protein refolding for membrane fusion

It is unknown how receptor binding by the paramyxovirus attachment proteins (HN, H, or G) triggers the fusion (F) protein to fuse with the plasma membrane for cell entry. H-proteins of the morbillivirus genus consist of a stalk ectodomain supporting a cuboidal head; physiological oligomers consist of non-covalent dimer-of-dimers. We report here the successful engineering of intermolecular disulfide bonds within the central region (residues 91-115) of the morbillivirus H-stalk; a sub-domain that also encompasses the putative F-contacting section (residues 111-118). Remarkably, several intersubunit crosslinks abrogated membrane fusion, but bioactivity was restored under reducing conditions. This phenotype extended equally to H proteins derived from virulent and attenuated morbillivirus strains and was independent of the nature of the contacted receptor. Our data reveal that the morbillivirus H-stalk domain is composed of four tightly-packed subunits. Upon receptor binding, these subunits structurally rearrange, possibly inducing conformational changes within the central region of the stalk, which, in turn, promote fusion. Given that the fundamental architecture appears conserved among paramyxovirus attachment protein stalk domains, we predict that these motions may act as a universal paramyxovirus F-triggering mechanism.

Mechanism for active membrane fusion triggering by morbillivirus attachment protein.

The paramyxovirus entry machinery consists of two glycoproteins that tightly cooperate to achieve membrane fusion for cell entry: the tetrameric attachment protein (HN, H, or G, depending on the paramyxovirus genus) and the trimeric fusion protein (F). Here, we explore whether receptor-induced conformational changes within morbillivirus H proteins promote membrane fusion by a mechanism requiring the active destabilization of prefusion F or by the dissociation of prefusion F from intracellularly preformed glycoprotein complexes. To properly probe F conformations, we identified anti-F monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) that recognize conformation-dependent epitopes. Through heat treatment as a surrogate for H-mediated F triggering, we demonstrate with these MAbs that the morbillivirus F trimer contains a sufficiently high inherent activation energy barrier to maintain the metastable prefusion state even in the absence of H. This notion was further validated by exploring the conformational states of destabilized F mutants and stabilized soluble F variants combined with the use of a membrane fusion inhibitor (3g). Taken together, our findings reveal that the morbillivirus H protein must lower the activation energy barrier of metastable prefusion F for fusion triggering.

Content mixing and membrane integrity during membrane fusion driven by pairing of isolated v-SNAREs and t-SNAREs

Membrane bilayer fusion has been shown to be mediated by v- and t-SNAREs initially present in separate populations of liposomes and to occur with high efficiency at a physiologically meaningful rate. Lipid mixing was demonstrated to involve both the inner and the outer leaflets of the membrane bilayer. Here, we use a fusion assay that relies on duplex formation of oligonucleotides introduced in separate liposome populations and report that SNARE proteins suffice to mediate complete membrane fusion accompanied by mixing of luminal content. We also find that SNARE-mediated membrane fusion does not compromise the integrity of liposomes.