Diseño de una interfaz de representación gráfica de la base de datos de HRTF

El actual proyecto consiste en la creación de una interfaz gráfica de usuario (GUI) en entorno de MATLAB que realice una representación gráfica de la base de datos de HRTF (Head-Related Transfer Function). La función de transferencia de la cabeza es una herramienta muy útil en el estudio de la capacidad del ser humano para percibir su entorno sonoro, además de la habilidad de éste en la localización de fuentes sonoras en el espacio que le rodea. La HRTF biaural (terminología para referirse al conjunto de HRTF del oído izquierdo y del oído derecho) en sí misma, posee información de especial interés ya que las diferencias entre las HRTF de cada oído, conceden la información que nuestro sistema de audición utiliza en la percepción del campo sonoro. Por ello, la funcionalidad de la interfaz gráfica creada presenta gran provecho dentro del estudio de este campo. Las diferencias interaurales se caracterizan en amplitud y en tiempo, variando en función de la frecuencia. Mediante la transformada inversa de Fourier de la señal HRTF, se obtiene la repuesta al impulso de la cabeza, es decir, la HRIR (Head-Related Impulse Response). La cual, además de tener una gran utilidad en la creación de software o dispositivos de generación de sonido envolvente, se utiliza para obtener las diferencias ITD (Interaural Time Difference) e ILD (Interaural Time Difference), comúnmente denominados “parámetros de localización espacial”. La base de datos de HRTF contiene la información biaural de diferentes puntos de ubicación de la fuente sonora, formando una red de coordenadas esféricas que envuelve la cabeza del sujeto. Dicha red, según las medidas realizadas en la cámara anecoica de la EUITT (Escuela Universitaria de Ingeniería Técnica de Telecomunicación), presenta una precisión en elevación de 10º y en azimut de 5º. Los receptores son dos micrófonos alojados en el maniquí acústico llamado HATS (Hats and Torso Simulator) modelo 4100D de Brüel&Kjaer. Éste posee las características físicas que influyen en la percepción del entorno como son las formas del pabellón auditivo (pinna), de la cabeza, del cuello y del torso humano. Será necesario realizar los cálculos de interpolación para todos aquellos puntos no contenidos en la base de datos HRTF, este proceso es sumamente importante no solo para potenciar la capacidad de la misma sino por su utilidad para la comparación entre otras bases de datos existentes en el estudio de este ámbito. La interfaz gráfica de usuario está concebida para un manejo sencillo, claro y predecible, a la vez que interactivo. Desde el primer boceto del programa se ha tenido clara su filosofía, impuesta por las necesidades de un usuario que busca una herramienta práctica y de manejo intuitivo. Su diseño de una sola ventana reúne tanto los componentes de obtención de datos como los que hacen posible la representación gráfica de las HRTF, las HRIR y los parámetros de localización espacial, ITD e ILD. El usuario podrá ir alternando las representaciones gráficas a la vez que introduce las coordenadas de los puntos que desea visualizar, definidas por phi (elevación) y theta (azimut). Esta faceta de la interfaz es la que le otorga una gran facilidad de acceso y lectura de la información representada en ella. Además, el usuario puede introducir valores incluidos en la base de datos o valores intermedios a estos, de esta manera, se indica a la interfaz la necesidad de realizar la interpolación de los mismos. El método de interpolación escogido es el de la ponderación de la distancia inversa entre puntos. Dependiendo de los valores introducidos por el usuario se realizará una interpolación de dos o cuatro puntos, siendo éstos limítrofes al valor introducido, ya sea de phi o theta. Para añadir versatilidad a la interfaz gráfica de usuario, se ha añadido la opción de generar archivos de salida en forma de imagen de las gráficas representadas, de tal forma que el usuario pueda extraer los datos que le interese para cualquier valor de phi y theta. Se completa el presente proyecto fin de carrera con un trabajo de investigación y estudio comparativo de la función y la aplicación de las bases de datos de HRTF dentro del marco científico y de investigación. Esto ha hecho posible concentrar información relacionada a través de revistas científicas de investigación como la JAES (Journal of the Audio Engineering Society) o la ASA (Acoustical Society of America), además, del IEEE ( Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers) o la “Web of knowledge” entre otras. Además de realizar la búsqueda en estas fuentes, se ha optado por vías de información más comunes como Google Académico o el portal de acceso “Ingenio” a los todos los recursos electrónicos contenidos en la base de datos de la universidad. El estudio genera una ampliación en el conocimiento de la labor práctica de las HRTF. La mayoría de los estudios enfocan sus esfuerzos en mejorar la percepción del evento sonoro mediante su simulación en la escucha estéreo o multicanal. A partir de las HRTF, esto es posible mediante el análisis y el cálculo de datos como pueden ser las regresiones, siendo éstas muy útiles en la predicción de una medida basándose en la información de la actual. Otro campo de especial interés es el de la generación de sonido 3D. Mediante la base de datos HRTF es posible la simulación de una señal biaural. Se han diseñado algoritmos que son implementados en dispositivos DSP, de tal manera que por medio de retardos interaurales y de diferencias espectrales es posible llegar a un resultado óptimo de sonido envolvente, sin olvidar la importancia de los efectos de reverberación para conseguir un efecto creíble de sonido envolvente. Debido a la complejidad computacional que esto requiere, gran parte de los estudios coinciden en desarrollar sistemas más eficientes, llegando a objetivos tales como la generación de sonido 3D en tiempo real. ABSTRACT. This project involves the creation of a Graphic User Interface (GUI) in the Matlab environment which creates a graphic representation of the HRTF (Head-Related Transfer Function) database. The head transfer function is a very useful tool in the study of the capacity of human beings to perceive their sound environment, as well as their ability to localise sound sources in the area surrounding them. The binaural HRTF (terminology which refers to the HRTF group of the left and right ear) in itself possesses information of special interest seeing that the differences between the HRTF of each ear admits the information that our system of hearing uses in the perception of each sound field. For this reason, the functionality of the graphic interface created presents great benefits within the study of this field. The interaural differences are characterised in space and in time, varying depending on the frequency. By means of Fourier's transformed inverse of the HRTF signal, the response to the head impulse is obtained, in other words, the HRIR (Head-Related Impulse Response). This, as well as having a great use in the creation of software or surround sound generating devices, is used to obtain ITD differences (Interaural Time Difference) and ILD (Interaural Time Difference), commonly named “spatial localisation parameters”. The HRTF database contains the binaural information of different points of sound source location, forming a network of spherical coordinates which surround the subject's head. This network, according to the measures carried out in the anechoic chamber at the EUITT (School of Telecommunications Engineering) gives a precision in elevation of 10º and in azimuth of 5º. The receivers are two microphones placed on the acoustic mannequin called HATS (Hats and Torso Simulator) Brüel&Kjaer model 4100D. This has the physical characteristics which affect the perception of the surroundings which are the forms of the auricle (pinna), the head, neck and human torso. It will be necessary to make interpolation calculations for all those points which are not contained the HRTF database. This process is extremely important not only to strengthen the database's capacity but also for its usefulness in making comparisons with other databases that exist in the study of this field. The graphic user interface is conceived for a simple, clear and predictable use which is also interactive. Since the first outline of the program, its philosophy has been clear, based on the needs of a user who requires a practical tool with an intuitive use. Its design with only one window unites not only the components which obtain data but also those which make the graphic representation of the HRTFs possible, the hrir and the ITD and ILD spatial location parameters. The user will be able to alternate the graphic representations at the same time as entering the point coordinates that they wish to display, defined by phi (elevation) and theta (azimuth). The facet of the interface is what provides the great ease of access and reading of the information displayed on it. In addition, the user can enter values included in the database or values which are intermediate to these. It is, likewise, indicated to the interface the need to carry out the interpolation of these values. The interpolation method is the deliberation of the inverse distance between points. Depending on the values entered by the user, an interpolation of two or four points will be carried out, with these being adjacent to the entered value, whether that is phi or theta. To add versatility to the graphic user interface, the option of generating output files in the form of an image of the graphics displayed has been added. This is so that the user may extract the information that interests them for any phi and theta value. This final project is completed with a research and comparative study essay on the function and application of HRTF databases within the scientific and research framework. It has been possible to collate related information by means of scientific research magazines such as the JAES (Journal of the Audio Engineering Society), the ASA (Acoustical Society of America) as well as the IEEE (Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers) and the “Web of knowledge” amongst others. In addition to carrying out research with these sources, I also opted to use more common sources of information such as Academic Google and the “Ingenio” point of entry to all the electronic resources contained on the university databases. The study generates an expansion in the knowledge of the practical work of the HRTF. The majority of studies focus their efforts on improving the perception of the sound event by means of its simulation in stereo or multichannel listening. With the HRTFs, this is possible by means of analysis and calculation of data as can be the regressions. These are very useful in the prediction of a measure being based on the current information. Another field of special interest is that of the generation of 3D sound. Through HRTF databases it is possible to simulate the binaural signal. Algorithms have been designed which are implemented in DSP devices, in such a way that by means of interaural delays and wavelength differences it is possible to achieve an excellent result of surround sound, without forgetting the importance of the effects of reverberation to achieve a believable effect of surround sound. Due to the computational complexity that this requires, a great many studies agree on the development of more efficient systems which achieve objectives such as the generation of 3D sound in real time.

Measuring end-to-end delay in real-time auralisation systems

One of the major challenges in the development of an immersive system is handling the delay between the tracking of the user’s head position and the updated projection of a 3D image or auralised sound, also called end-to-end delay. Excessive end-to-end delay can result in the general decrement of the “feeling of presence”, the occurrence of motion sickness and poor performance in perception-action tasks. These latencies must be known in order to provide insights on the technological (hardware/software optimization) or psychophysical (recalibration sessions) strategies to deal with them. Our goal was to develop a new measurement method of end-to-end delay that is both precise and easily replicated. We used a Head and Torso simulator (HATS) as an auditory signal sensor, a fast response photo-sensor to detect a visual stimulus response from a Motion Capture System, and a voltage input trigger as real-time event. The HATS was mounted in a turntable which allowed us to precisely change the 3D sound relative to the head position. When the virtual sound source was at 90º azimuth, the correspondent HRTF would set all the intensity values to zero, at the same time a trigger would register the real-time event of turning the HATS 90º azimuth. Furthermore, with the HATS turned 90º to the left, the motion capture marker visualization would fell exactly in the photo-sensor receptor. This method allowed us to precisely measure the delay from tracking to displaying. Moreover, our results show that the method of tracking, its tracking frequency, and the rendering of the sound reflections are the main predictors of end-to-end delay.

Selection of information in auditory virtual reality

ERP, auditory virtual reality, dichotic listening, selective auditory attention, cocktail-party phenomenon, HRTF

Méthodes de spatialisation sonore et intégration dans le processus de composition

L’espace est un élément peu exploré en musique. Méconnu des compositeurs, il n’est généralement pas pensé comme paramètre musical « composable ». Pourtant si la musique peut être perçue comme une organisation et une succession d’éléments dans le temps, pourquoi ne pourrait-elle pas l’être aussi dans l’espace? Ce travail se veut en quelque sorte un pont entre la recherche et la pratique, qui se construit par la synthèse de l’information que j’ai pu trouver sur chacune des quatre méthodes de spatialisation abordées ici. Dans un premier temps, je traiterai de leur développement, leur fonctionnement et des possibilités d’intégration de ces méthodes dans le processus de composition musicale, notamment en discutant les outils disponibles. Dans un second temps, les pièces Minimale Sédation et Fondations, toutes deux composées en octophonie seront discutées. J’expliquerai leurs processus de composition à travers les intentions, les techniques d’écriture et les outils qui ont menés à leurs créations.

Tecnología de registro y reproducción sonora para entornos de realidad virtual

Este proyecto de fin de carrera tiene como objetivo obtener una visión detallada de los sistemas y tecnologías de grabación y reproducción utilizadas para aplicaciones de audio 3D y entornos de realidad virtual, analizando las diferentes alternativas existentes, su funcionamiento, características, detalles técnicos y sus ámbitos de aplicación. Como punto de partida se estudiará la teoría psicoacústica y la localización de fuentes sonoras en el espacio, base para el estudio de los sistemas de audio 3D. Se estudiará tanto la espacialización sonora en un espacio real y la espacialización virtual (simulación mediante procesado de información de la localización de fuentes sonoras), en los que intervienen algunos fenómenos acústicos y psicoacústicos como ITD, o diferencia de tiempo que existe entre una señal acústica que llega a los pabellones auditivos, la ILD, o diferencia de intensidad o amplitud que hay entre la señal que llega a los pabellones auditivos y la localización espacial mediante otra serie de mecanismos biaurales. Tras una visión general de la teoría psicoacústica y la espacialización sonora, se analizarán con detalle los elementos de grabación y reproducción existentes para audio 3D. Concretamente, a lo largo del proyecto se profundizará en el funcionamiento del sistema estéreo, caracterizado por el posicionamiento sonoro mediante la utilización de dos canales; del sistema biaural, caracterizado por reconstruir campos sonoros mediante el uso de las HRTF; de los sistemas multicanal, detallando gran parte de las alternativas y configuraciones existentes; del sistema Ambiophonics, caracterizado por implementar filtros de cruce; del sistema Ambisonics, y sus diferentes formatos y técnicas de codificación y decodificación; y del sistema Wavefield Synthesis, caracterizado por recrear ambientes sonoros en grandes espacios. ABSTRACT This project aims to get a detailed view of recording and reproducing systems and technologies used to 3D audio applications and virtual reality environments, analyzing the different alternatives available, their functioning, features, technical details and their different scopes of applications. As a starting point, will be studied the psychoacoustic theory and the localization of sound sources in space, basis for the 3D audio study. Will be studied both the spacialization of sound sources in real space as virtual spatialization of sound sources (simulation by information processing of localization of sound sources), in which involves some acoustic and psychoacoustic phenomena like ITD (or the Interaural time difference), the ILD, (or the Interaural Level Difference) and spatial localization by another set of binaural mechanisms. After a general overview of the psychoacoustics theory and the sound spatialization, will be analyzed in detail existing methods of recording and reproducing for 3D audio. Specifically, during the project will analyze the characteristics of the stereo systems, characterized by sound positioning using two channels; the binaural systems, characterized by reconstructing sound fields by using the HRTF; the multichannel systems, detailing many of the existing alternatives and configurations; the Ambiophonics system, which is characterized by implementing crosstalk elimination techniques; the Ambiosonics system, and its various formats and encoding and decoding techniques; and the Wavefield Synthesis system, characterized by recreate soundscapes in large spaces.

3-dimensional binaural sound rendering using acoustic measurements stored in the SOFA format

Several groups all over the world are researching in several ways to render 3D sounds. One way to achieve this is to use Head Related Transfer Functions (HRTFs). These measurements contain the Frequency Response of the human head and torso for each angle. Some years ago, was only possible to measure these Frequency Responses only in the horizontal plane. Nowadays, several improvements have made possible to measure and use 3D data for this purpose. The problem was that the groups didn't have a standard format file to store the data. That was a problem when a third part wanted to use some different HRTFs for 3D audio rendering. Every of them have different ways to store the data. The Spatially Oriented Format for Acoustics or SOFA was created to provide a solution to this problem. It is a format definition to unify all the previous different ways of storing any kind of acoustics data. At the moment of this project they have defined some basis for the format and some recommendations to store HRTFs. It is actually under development, so several changes could come. The SOFA[1] file format uses a numeric container called netCDF[2], specifically the Enhaced data model described in netCDF 4 that is based on HDF5[3]. The SoundScape Renderer (SSR) is a tool for real-time spatial audio reproduction providing a variety of rendering algorithms. The SSR was developed at the Quality and Usability Lab at TU Berlin and is now further developed at the Institut für Nachrichtentechnik at Universität Rostock [4]. This project is intended to be an introduction to the use of SOFA files, providing a C++ API to manipulate them and adapt the binaural renderer of the SSR for working with the SOFA format. RESUMEN. El SSR (SoundScape Renderer) es un programa que está siendo desarrollado actualmente por la Universität Rostock, y previamente por la Technische Universität Berlin. El SSR es una herramienta diseñada para la reproducción y renderización de audio 2D en tiempo real. Para ello utiliza diversos algoritmos, algunos orientados a sistemas formados por arrays de altavoces en diferentes configuraciones y otros algoritmos diseñados para cascos. El principal objetivo de este proyecto es dotar al SSR de la capacidad de renderizar sonidos binaurales en 3D. Este proyecto está centrado en el binaural renderer del SSR. Este algoritmo se basa en el uso de HRTFs (Head Related Transfer Function). Las HRTFs representan la función de transferencia del sistema formado por la cabeza y el torso del oyente. Esta función es medida desde diferentes ángulos. Con estos datos el binaural renderer puede generar audio en tiempo real simulando la posición de diferentes fuentes. Para poder incluir una base de datos con HRTFs en 3D se ha hecho uso del nuevo formato SOFA (Spatially Oriented Format for Acoustics). Este nuevo formato se encuentra en una fase bastante temprana de su desarrollo. Está pensado para servir como formato estándar para almacenar HRTFs y cualquier otro tipo de medidas acústicas, ya que actualmente cada laboratorio cuenta con su propio formato de almacenamiento y esto hace bastante difícil usar varias bases de datos diferentes en un mismo proyecto. El formato SOFA hace uso del contenedor numérico netCDF, que a su vez esta basado en un contenedor más básico llamado HRTF-5. Para poder incluir el formato SOFA en el binaural renderer del SSR se ha desarrollado una API en C++ para poder crear y leer archivos SOFA con el fin de utilizar los datos contenidos en ellos dentro del SSR.

Reduced-parameter model of head-related transfer functions for synthesized spatial audio

Digital systems can generate left and right audio channels that create the effect of virtual sound source placement (spatialization) by processing an audio signal through pairs of Head-Related Transfer Functions (HRTFs) or, equivalently, Head-Related Impulse Responses (HRIRs). The spatialization effect is better when individually-measured HRTFs or HRIRs are used than when generic ones (e.g., from a mannequin) are used. However, the measurement process is not available to the majority of users. There is ongoing interest to find mechanisms to customize HRTFs or HRIRs to a specific user, in order to achieve an improved spatialization effect for that subject. Unfortunately, the current models used for HRTFs and HRIRs contain over a hundred parameters and none of those parameters can be easily related to the characteristics of the subject. This dissertation proposes an alternative model for the representation of HRTFs, which contains at most 30 parameters, all of which have a defined functional significance. It also presents methods to obtain the value of parameters in the model to make it approximately equivalent to an individually-measured HRTF. This conversion is achieved by the systematic deconstruction of HRIR sequences through an augmented version of the Hankel Total Least Squares (HTLS) decomposition approach. An average 95% match (fit) was observed between the original HRIRs and those re-constructed from the Damped and Delayed Sinusoids (DDSs) found by the decomposition process, for ipsilateral source locations. The dissertation also introduces and evaluates an HRIR customization procedure, based on a multilinear model implemented through a 3-mode tensor, for mapping of anatomical data from the subjects to the HRIR sequences at different sound source locations. This model uses the Higher-Order Singular Value Decomposition (HOSVD) method to represent the HRIRs and is capable of generating customized HRIRs from easily attainable anatomical measurements of a new intended user of the system. Listening tests were performed to compare the spatialization performance of customized, generic and individually-measured HRIRs when they are used for synthesized spatial audio. Statistical analysis of the results confirms that the type of HRIRs used for spatialization is a significant factor in the spatialization success, with the customized HRIRs yielding better results than generic HRIRs.

Structure-based modeling of head -related transfer functions towards interactive customization of binaural sound systems

One of the most popular techniques for creating spatialized virtual sounds is based on the use of Head-Related Transfer Functions (HRTFs). HRTFs are signal processing models that represent the modifications undergone by the acoustic signal as it travels from a sound source to each of the listener's eardrums. These modifications are due to the interaction of the acoustic waves with the listener's torso, shoulders, head and pinnae, or outer ears. As such, HRTFs are somewhat different for each listener. For a listener to perceive synthesized 3-D sound cues correctly, the synthesized cues must be similar to the listener's own HRTFs. ^ One can measure individual HRTFs using specialized recording systems, however, these systems are prohibitively expensive and restrict the portability of the 3-D sound system. HRTF-based systems also face several computational challenges. This dissertation presents an alternative method for the synthesis of binaural spatialized sounds. The sound entering the pinna undergoes several reflective, diffractive and resonant phenomena, which determine the HRTF. Using signal processing tools, such as Prony's signal modeling method, an appropriate set of time delays and a resonant frequency were used to approximate the measured Head-Related Impulse Responses (HRIRs). Statistical analysis was used to find out empirical equations describing how the reflections and resonances are determined by the shape and size of the pinna features obtained from 3D images of 15 experimental subjects modeled in the project. These equations were used to yield “Model HRTFs” that can create elevation effects. ^ Listening tests conducted on 10 subjects show that these model HRTFs are 5% more effective than generic HRTFs when it comes to localizing sounds in the frontal plane. The number of reversals (perception of sound source above the horizontal plane when actually it is below the plane and vice versa) was also reduced by 5.7%, showing the perceptual effectiveness of this approach. The model is simple, yet versatile because it relies on easy to measure parameters to create an individualized HRTF. This low-order parameterized model also reduces the computational and storage demands, while maintaining a sufficient number of perceptually relevant spectral cues. ^

In-car sound linear simulation

In recent years, vehicle acoustics have gained significant importance in new car development: increasingly advanced infotainment systems for spatial audio and sound enhancement algorithms have become the norm in modern vehicles. In the past, car manufacturers had to build numerous prototypes to study the sound behaviour inside the car cabin or the effect of new algorithms under development. Nowadays, advanced simulation techniques can reduce development costs and time. In this work, after selecting the reference test vehicle, a modern luxury sedan equipped with a high-end sound system, two independent tools were developed: a simulation tool created in the Comsol Multiphysics environment and an auralization tool developed in the Cycling ‘74 MAX environment. The simulation tool can calculate the impulse response and acoustic spectrum at a specific position inside the cockpit. Its input data are the vehicle’s geometry, acoustic absorption parameters of materials, the acoustic characteristics and position of loudspeakers, and the type and position of virtual microphones (or microphone arrays). The simulation tool can also provide binaural impulse responses thanks to Head Related Transfer Functions (HRTFs) and an innovative algorithm able to compute the HRTF at any distance and angle from the head. Impulse responses from simulations or acoustic measurements inside the car cabin are processed and fed into the auralization tool, enabling real-time interaction by applying filters, changing the channels gain or displaying the acoustic spectrum. Since the acoustic simulation of a vehicle involves multiple topics, the focus of this work has not only been the development of two tools but also the study and application of new techniques for acoustic characterization of the materials that compose the cockpit and the loudspeaker simulation. Specifically, three different methods have been applied for material characterization through the use of a pressure-velocity probe, a Laser Doppler Vibrometer (LDV), and a microphone array.