Fretting studies on self-mated stainless steel and chromium carbide coated surfaces under controlled environment conditions

Adhesive wear has been widely accepted as the type of wear which is most frequently encountered under fretting conditions. Present study has been carried out to study the mode of failure and mechanisms associated under conditions where strong adhesion prevails at the contact interface. Mechanical variables such as normal load, displacement amplitude, and environment conditions were controlled so as to simulate adhesion as the governing mechanism at the contact interface. Self-mated Stainless Steel (SS) and chromium carbide with 25% nickel chrome binder coatings using plasma spray and high-velocity oxy-fuel (HVOF) processes on SS were considered as the material for contacting bodies. Damage in the form of plastic deformation, fracture, and material transfer has been observed. Further, chromium carbide with 25% nickel chrome binder coatings using HVOF process on SS shows less fretting damage, and can be considered as an effective palliative against fretting damage, even under high vacuum conditions. (C) 2013 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Fretting wear behaviour of hydroxyapatite-titanium composites in simulated body fluid, supplemented with 5 g l(-1) bovine serum albumin

Damaged articulating joints can be repaired or replaced with synthetic biomaterials, which can release wear debris due to articulation, leading to the osteolysis. In a recent work, it has been shown that it is possible to achieve a better combination of flexural strength/fracture toughness as well as in vitro bioactivity and cytocompatibility properties in spark plasma sintered hydroxyapatite-titanium (HA-Ti) composites. Although hydroxyapatite and titanium are well documented for their good biocompatibility, nanosized hydroxyapatite (HA) and titanium (Ti) particles can cause severe toxicity to cells. In order to address this issue, fretting wear study of HA-Ti composites under dry and wet (1x SBF, supplemented with 5 g l(-1) bovine serum albumin (BSA)) condition was performed to assess the wear resistance as well as wear debris formation, in vitro. The experimental results reveal one order of magnitude lower wear rate for HA-10 wt% Ti (7.5 x 10(-5) mm(3) N-1 m(-1)) composite than monolithic HA (3.9 x 10(-4) mm(3) N-1 m(-1)) in simulated body fluid. The difference in the tribological properties has been analyzed in the light of phase assemblages and mechanical properties. Overall, the results suggest the potential use of HA-Ti composites over existing HA-based biocomposites in orthopedic as well as dental applications.

Fretting wear study of Cu-10 wt% TiB2 and Cu-10 wt% TiB2-10 wt% Pb composites

In developing materials with better tribological properties, it is always conceived that the addition of softer phase would result in better frictional behavior. In order to address this issue, we report here the results of fretting wear study on Cu-10 wt% TiB2 and Cu-10 wt% TiB2-10 wt% Pb composites, sintered using spark plasma sintering (SPS) technique. It was found out that the addition of softer phase i.e. 10 wt % Pb to Cu-10 wt% TiB2 composites has not resulted in the lowering of the coefficient of friction (COF). The combination of steady state COF (0.6) and wear rate (10(-3) mm(3)/N-m) was measured and such properties are even better than that obtained with TiB2 coatings reported in the literature. For Cu-10 wt% TiB2 sintered at different temperature, a lower wear resistance with increase in hardness is being measured. An attempt has been made to correlate the observed wear behavior with the surface and subsurface deformation. The formation of a wear-resistant delaminated tribolayer consisting of TiB2 particles and ultrafine oxide debris (Cu, Fe, Ti)(x)O-y was the reason assigned for the observed low wear rate of these composites. (C) 2013 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Microstructure-hardness-fretting wear resistance correlation in ultrafine grained Cu-TiB2-Pb composites

The retention of the desired combination of mechanical/tribological properties in ultrafine grained materials presents important challenges in the field of bulk metallic composites. In order to address this aspect, the present work demonstrates how one can achieve a good combination of hardness and wear resistance in Cu-Pb-TiB2 composites, consolidated by spark plasma sintering at low temperatures ( < 500 degrees C). Transmission electron microscope (TEM) studies reveal ultrafine grains of Cu (100-400 nm) with coarser TiB2 particles (1-2 mu m) along with fine scale Pb dispersoid at triple junctions or at the grain boundaries of Cu. Importantly, a high hardness of around 2.2 GPa and relative density of close to 90% relative density (rho(theo)) have been achieved for Cu-15 wt% TiB2-10 wt% Pb composite. Such property theo, combination has never been reported for any Cu-based nanocomposite, by conventional processing route. In reference to the tribological performance, fretting wear tests were conducted on the sintered nanocomposites and a good combination of steady state COF (0.6-0.7) and wear rate (10-4 mm(3)/N m) were measured. An inverse relationship between wear rate and hardness was recorded and this commensurates well with Archard's relationship of abrasive wear. The formation of a wear-resistant delaminated tribolayer consisting of TiB2 particles and ultrafine oxide debris, (Cu, Fe, Ti)(x)O-y as confirmed from subsurface imaging using focused ion beam microscopy has been identified as the key factors for the low wear rate of these composites. (C) 2014 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Damage mechanisms in stainless steel and chromium carbide coatings under controlled environment fretting conditions

Fretting is of a serious concern in many industrial components, specifically, in nuclear industry for the safe and reliable operation of various component and/or system. Under fretting condition small amplitude oscillations induce surface degradation in the form of surface cracks and/or surface wear. Comprehensive experimental studies have been carried out simulating different fretting regimes under ambient and vacuum (10(-9) MPa) conditions and, temperature up to 400 degrees C. Studies have been carried out with stainless steel spheres on stainless steel flats, and stainless steel spheres against chromium carbide, with 25% nickel chrome binder coatings. Mechanical responses are correlated with the damage observed. It has been observed that adhesion plays a vital role in material degradation process, and its effectiveness depends on mechanical variables such as normal load, interfacial tangential displacement, characteristics of the contacting bodies and most importantly on the environment conditions. Material degradation mechanism for ductile materials involved severe plastic deformation, which results in the initiation or nucleation of cracks. Ratcheting has been observed as the governing damage mode for crack nucleation under cyclic tangential loading condition. Further, propagation of the cracks has been observed under fatigue and their orientation has been observed to be governed by the contact conditions prevailing at the contact interface. Coated surfaces show damage in the form of brittle fracture and spalling of the coatings. Existence of stick slip has been observed under high normal load and low displacement amplitude. It has also been observed that adhesion at the contact interface and instantaneous cohesive strength of the contacting bodies dictates the occurrence of material transfer. The paper discusses the mechanics and mechanisms involved in fretting damage under controlled environment conditions. (C) 2015 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Damage quantification under sliding and seizure condition using first-of-a-kind fretting machine

In a practical situation, it is difficult to model exact contact conditions clue to challenges involved in the estimation of contact forces, and relative displacements between the contacting bodies. Sliding and seizure conditions were simulated on first-of-a-kind displacement controlled system. Self-mated stainless steels have been investigated in detail. Categorization of contact conditions prevailing at the contact interface has been carried out based on the variation of coefficient of friction with number of cycles, and three-dimensional fretting loops. Surface and subsurface micro-cracks have been observed, and their characteristic shows strong dependence on loading conditions. Existence of shear bands in the subsurface region has been observed for high strain and low strain rate loading conditions. Studies also include the influence of initial surface roughness on the damage under two extreme contact conditions. (C) 2013 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Effect of fretting on fatigue performance of Ti-1023 titanium alloy

The plain fatigue and fretting fatigue tests of Ti-1023 titanium alloy were performed using a high-frequency push-pull fatigue testing machine. Both σmax versus number of cycles to failure curves were obtained for comparative analysis of the fretting effect on fatigue performance of the titanium alloy. Meanwhile, by analyzing the fracture of plain fatigue and fretting fatigue, the fretting scar and the fretting debris observed by scanning electron microscopy (SEM), the mechanism of fretting fatigue failure of Ti-1023 titanium alloy is discussed. The fretting fatigue strength of Ti-1023 titanium alloy is 175 MPa under 10 MPa contact pressure, which is 21% of plain fatigue strength (836 MPa). Under fretting condition, the Ti-1023 titanium alloy fatigue fracture failure occurs in a shorter fatigue life. When it comes to σmax versus number of cycles to failure curves, data points in the range of 106–107 cycles under plain fatigue condition moved to the range of 105–106 under fretting fatigue condition. The integrity of the fatigue specimen surface was seriously damaged under the effect of fretting. With the alternating stress loaded on specimen, the stress concentrated on the surface of fretting area, which brought earlier the initiation and propagation of crack.

Effect of contact pressure on fretting fatigue behavior of Ti-1023

With a new test facility, we have investigated fretting fatigue properties of Ti-1023 titanium alloy at different contact pressure. Both fatigue fracture and fretting scar were analyzed by scanning electron microscopy (SEM). Moreover, the depth of crack initiation area in fatigue fracture has been analyzed quantitatively, to investigate the relationship between the depth of crack initiation area and the fretting fatigue strength. The changing trends of the depth of crack initiation area and fretting fatigue strength with the increase of contact pressure show obvious opposite correlations. The depth of crack initiation area increases rapidly with the increase of contact pressure at low contact pressure (smaller than 10 MPa), and the fretting fatigue strength drops rapidly. At the contact pressure of 10–45 MPa, both the depth of crack initiation area and the fretting fatigue strength do not vary significantly. Contact pressure influences fatigue strength through influencing the initiation of fatigue crack. The main damage patterns are fatigue flake and plow.

Evaluation of the fretting fatigue behaviour of commercially pure titanium

Fretting fatigue occurs when the contact surfaces of two components undergo small oscillatory movement while they are subjected to a clamping force. A cyclic external load gives rise to the early initiation of fatigue cracks, thus reducing their service life. In this paper, the fretting fatigue behaviour of commercially pure titanium flat samples (1.5 mm thick) is evaluated. A fretting device composed of a frame, load cell, and two screw-mounted cylindrical fretting pads with convex extremities was built and set to a servo-hydraulic testing machine. The fatigue tests were conducted under load control at a frequency of 10 Hz and stress ratio R = 0.1, with various contact load values applied to the fretting pads. Additional tests under inert environment allowed assessing the role of oxidation on the wear debris formation. The fracture surfaces and fretting scars were analysed via scanning electron microscopy in order to evaluate the surface damage evolution and its effect on the fatigue crack features. The effect of the fretting condition on the S-N curve of the material in the range of 10(4)-10(6) cycles is described. Fatigue crack growth calculations allowed estimating the crack initiation and propagation lives under fretting conditions. The effect of the fretting condition in fatigue life is stronger for the lower values of cyclic stress and does not seem to depend on the contact loading value.

Issues on the mean stress effect in fretting fatigue of a 7050-T7451 Al alloy posed by new experimental data

The aims of this work are: (i) to produce new experimental data for fretting fatigue considering the presence of a mean bulk stress and (ii) to assess two design methodologies against failure by fretting fatigue. Tests on a cylinder–flat contact configuration were conducted using a fretting apparatus mounted on a servo-hydraulic machine. The material used for both the pads and fatigue specimen was an aeronautical 7050-T7451 Al alloy. The experimental program was designed with all relevant parameters, apart from the mean bulk load (always applied before the contact loads), kept constant. The mean bulk stress varied from compressive to tensile values while maintaining a high peak pressure in order to encourage crack initiation. Two methodologies against fretting fatigue are proposed and confronted against the experimental data. The non-local stress-based methodology considers the evaluation of a critical plane fatigue criterion at the center of a process zone located beneath the contacting surfaces. The results showed that it correctly predicts crack initiation, but was not capable to provide successful prediction of the integrity of the specimens. Alternatively, we considered a crack arrest criterion which has the potential to provide a more complete description about the integrity of the specimens.

Il fenomeno del fretting in elementi albero-mozzo soggetti a flessione rotante indagato tramite controlli non distruttivi e analisi al microscopio

L'usura da fretting è un fenomeno che accompagna il comportamento a fatica dei componenti, in accoppiamenti per interferenza. Essa è dovuta allo slittamento relativo delle superfici accoppiate e comporta la riduzione della vita a fatica. In questo elaborato si parte da conoscenze pregresse riguardanti la morfologia delle superfici soggette a fretting e si cerca di individuare caratteristiche peculiari in provini albero-mozzo soggetti a flessione rotante, con prove di fatica a vita interrotta. Vengono utilizzati i fluidi penetranti per individuare cricche in fase di propagazione e per determinare un piano di sezione longitudinale ottimale dei provini, per poter osservare le superfici periferiche dei pezzi usurati. Infine vengono sfruttati i microscopi ottico e multifocale per osservare più approfonditamente il fenomeno.

In-Vivo Corrosion and Fretting of Modular TI-6AL-4V/CO-CR-MO Hip Prostheses: The Influence of Microstructure and Design Parameters

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the incidence of corrosion and fretting in 48 retrieved titanium-6aluminum-4vanadium and/or cobalt-chromium-molybdenum modular total hip prosthesis with respect to alloy material microstructure and design parameters. The results revealed vastly different performance results for the wide array of microstructures examined. Severe corrosion/fretting was seen in 100% of as-cast, 24% of low carbon wrought, 9% of high carbon wrought and 5% of solution heat treated cobalt-chrome. Severe corrosion/fretting was observed in 60% of Ti-6Al-4V components. Design features which allow for fluid entry and stagnation, amplification of contact pressure and/or increased micromotion were also shown to play a role. 75% of prosthesis with high femoral head-trunnion offset exhibited poor performance compared to 15% with a low offset. Large femoral heads (>32mm) did not exhibit poor corrosion or fretting. Implantation time was not sufficient to cause poor performance; 54% of prosthesis with greater than 10 years in-vivo demonstrated none or mild corrosion/fretting.

Evaluación de la integridad estructural de tubos de generadores de vapor con defectos volumétricos debidos al fretting.

Los Generadores de vapor (GVs) en una central nuclear están conformados por un manojo de tubos que actúan como una barrera entre el sistema primario contaminado y el secundario. A través de los tubos de GVs (TGVs) se desarrolla el intercambio de calor que produce el vapor que después accionará las turbinas de la central. Estos componentes están sometidos a unas condiciones térmicas, químicas y mecánicas bastante severas, que pueden provocar la aparición de defectos geométricos y volumétricos comprometiendo su integridad estructural. Es por esta razón que el mantenimiento de los GVs es importante para la operación económica y segura de las centrales nucleares. Uno de los principales mecanismos de desgaste de los tubos de GVs es el fenómeno conocido como fretting. El mismo provoca el adelgazamiento de las paredes de los TGVs debido a pequeños movimientos relativos entre superficies en contacto. Dado el caso particular de los GVs del reactor CAREM-25 en los que el circuito primario se encuentra del lado externo de los tubos que lo constituyen, la ocurrencia de este mecanismo de daño podría comprometer la integridad de los mismos haciéndolos más susceptibles al daño por colapso. El presente trabajo constituye una continuación del Proyecto integrador finalizado en el 2015 por Pablo Lazo en el que se evaluó la influencia de efectos de ovalización en el colapso de los tubos de los GVs. Se evalúa ahora la influencia de defectos volumétricos debido a fretting. Esto se realizó a través de modelos numéricos que estiman la presión de colapso en los tubos con y sin defecto. Los resultados de los modelos se compararon con resultados de expresiones analíticas obtenidas por otros autores, valores experimentales propios y otros valores de referencia. A partir del análisis de los resultados se derivaron algunas conclusiones que ayudan a entender el comportamiento de los tubos de GVs con defectos debido a mecanismo de daño por fretting. Además se desarrollaron expresiones matemáticas que ayudan a definir las dimensiones de los defectos que comprometen la integridad estructural de los TGVs en el caso del reactor CAREM-25.

Evaluación de la integridad estructural de tubos de generadores de vapor con defectos volumétricos debidos al fretting.

Los Generadores de vapor (GVs) en una central nuclear están conformados por un manojo de tubos que actúan como una barrera entre el sistema primario contaminado y el secundario. A través de los tubos de GVs (TGVs) se desarrolla el intercambio de calor que produce el vapor que después accionará las turbinas de la central. Estos componentes están sometidos a unas condiciones térmicas, químicas y mecánicas bastante severas, que pueden provocar la aparición de defectos geométricos y volumétricos comprometiendo su integridad estructural. Es por esta razón que el mantenimiento de los GVs es importante para la operación económica y segura de las centrales nucleares. Uno de los principales mecanismos de desgaste de los tubos de GVs es el fenómeno conocido como fretting. El mismo provoca el adelgazamiento de las paredes de los TGVs debido a pequeños movimientos relativos entre superficies en contacto. Dado el caso particular de los GVs del reactor CAREM-25 en los que el circuito primario se encuentra del lado externo de los tubos que lo constituyen, la ocurrencia de este mecanismo de daño podría comprometer la integridad de los mismos haciéndolos más susceptibles al daño por colapso. El presente trabajo constituye una continuación del Proyecto integrador finalizado en el 2015 por Pablo Lazo en el que se evaluó la influencia de efectos de ovalización en el colapso de los tubos de los GVs. Se evalúa ahora la influencia de defectos volumétricos debido a fretting. Esto se realizó a través de modelos numéricos que estiman la presión de colapso en los tubos con y sin defecto. Los resultados de los modelos se compararon con resultados de expresiones analíticas obtenidas por otros autores, valores experimentales propios y otros valores de referencia. A partir del análisis de los resultados se derivaron algunas conclusiones que ayudan a entender el comportamiento de los tubos de GVs con defectos debido a mecanismo de daño por fretting. Además se desarrollaron expresiones matemáticas que ayudan a definir las dimensiones de los defectos que comprometen la integridad estructural de los TGVs en el caso del reactor CAREM-25.