Alternative dispute resolution : are apology and forgiveness simply two sides of the one coin?

Alternative dispute resolution (a.d.r.) processes are entrenched in western style legal systems. Forms of dispute resolution are utilised within schools and health systems; built in to commercial contracts; found in workplaces, clubs and organisations; and accepted in general day-to-day community disputes. The a.d.r. literature includes references to ‘apology’, but is largely silent on ‘forgiveness’. Where an apology is offered as part of a dispute resolution process, practice suggests that formalised ‘forgiveness’ rarely follows. Mediators may agree there is a meaningful place for apology in dispute resolution processes, but are most unlikely to support a view that forgiveness, as a conscious act, has an equivalent place. Yet, if forgiveness is not limited to the ‘pardoning of an offence’, but includes a ‘giving up of resentment’, or the relinquishing of a grudge, then forgiveness may play an underestimated role in dispute management. In the context of some day-to-day dispute management practice, this paper questions whether forgiveness should follow an apology; and concludes that meaningful resolutions can be reached without any formal element of ‘forgiveness’ or absolution. However, dispute management practitioners need to be aware of the latent role other aspects of forgiveness may play for the disputing parties.

Industrialized housing in China : a coin with two sides

China today is experiencing a time when housing is needed more than ever and one approach satisfying this need is by industrialization - a streamlined process aimed at generating profits and promoting energy efficiency in the housing sectors. Although large housing programs have been completed in China, few housing projects have been built in an industrialized manner. One contributing factor is that industrialization is not omnipotent and, just as a coin has two sides, not all the outcomes of industrialization are beneficial. In this paper, a preliminary assessment is made of these two sides - the benefits and hindrances of industrialized housing in China - by literature review and survey. Case studies are used to verify the questionnaire survey results and from which the advantages and disadvantages involved are compared. The findings indicate the need for formulating policies to encourage industrialized housing in China and for well-planned R&D themes to be implemented simultaneously with industry practices in the near future.

Hanukkah lamp from Italy Coin

Obverse: 1 Lira silver coin. Reverse: Hanukkah lamp from Italy.

Port of Eilat Coin

Obverse: Silver 5 Lirot coin. Reverse: A stylized lighthouse, the seawall, stylized inscription.

Hanukkah lamp from North Africa Coin

Obverse: Silver 1 Lira coin. Reverse: Hanukkah lamp from North Africa

And He Gave up His Life in Battle Coin

Obverse: 1 Lira coin, torch and inscription. Reverse: Inside of a depressed pentagon there is a design of a war elephant bearing a turret and Greek soldiers equipped for battle. The elephant is being stabbed by Elazar.

Knesset Coin

Obverse: Silver 5 Lirot coin with large emblem of the State of Israel. Reverse: Design of the building of Knesset.

Theodore Herzl Centenary Coin

Obverse: silver 5 Lirot coin. Reverse: In the upper right portait of Theodore Herzl in rectangle with rounded corners. Below the emblem of the state of Israel.

Bar Mitzvah Coin

Obverse: Silver 5 Lirot coin, in the right side olive branch. Reverse: A stylized reproduction of an ancient Holy Ark which appears on a gold-vessel painted in the 13th century C.E.

Mikveh Israel Centenary Coin

Obverse: Silver 10 Lirot coin, a stylized spikelet of corn. Reverse: Schematic plough.

Half Shekel Coin

Obverse: Silver Half Lira coin. Reverse: A raised reproduction of an ancient silver half-shekel of beaded rim from the third year of the first Jewish revolt against the Romans 66-73 C.E.. At the center of the coin in a chalice inscription in the archaic Hebrew letters.

Half-Shekel Coin

Obverse: Silver Half Lira coin. Reverse: A raised reproduction of an ancient silver half-shekel of beaded rim from the third year of the first Jewish revolt against the Romans 66-73 C.E.. At the center of the coin in a chalice inscription in the archaic Hebrew letters.

Israel Museum Jerusalem Coin

Obverse: Silver 5 Lirot coin. Replica of the capital and part of a pillar, of the 7th century BCE found at Ramat Rachel on the outskirts of Jerusalem. Reverse: A stylized relief of the buildings of Israeli Museum in Jerusalem.

Pidyon HaBen 5 Pieces Coin Set

5 Silver coin set in olive-wood box with certificates. Obverse: 25 Silver Lirot coin. In the lower part big emblem of the State of Israel. Reverse: Five pomegranate flowers round a five-pointed star.

David Ben-Gurion Commemorative Coin Set

3 pieces commemorative coin set in a box. 2 silver coins, 1 gold coin. Obverse: 25 Lirot silver coins, 500 Lirot gold coin. In the center the state emblem of the State of Israel. Reverse: Portrait of David Ben-Gurion.