Alignment of the genomes of brachypodium distachyon and temperate cereals and grasses using bacterial artificial chromosome landing with fluorescence in situ hybridization

Robert Hasterok, Agnieszka Marasek, Iain S. Donnison, Ian Armstead, Ann Thomas, Ian P. King, Elzbieta Wolny, Dominika Idziak, John Draper and Glyn Jenkins (2006). Alignment of the genomes of brachypodium distachyon and temperate cereals and grasses using bacterial artificial chromosome landing with fluorescence in situ hybridization.Genetics, 73 (1), 349-362. Sponsorship: Royal Society / BBSRC;BBSRC RAE2008

Brachypodium distachyon. A new model system for functional genomics in grasses

John Draper, Luis A.J. Mur, Glyn Jenkins, Gadab C. Ghosh-Biswas, Pauline Bablak, Robert Hasterok,and Andrew P.M. Routledge (2001). Brachypodium distachyon. A new model system for functional genomics in grasses. Plant Physiology, 127 (4), 1539-1555. Sponsorship: BBSRC / Gatsby Foundation RAE2008

The family of DOF transcription factors in Brachypodium distachyon: phylogenetic comparison with rice and barley DOFs and expression profiling

ABSTRACT: Transcription factors (TFs) are proteins that have played a central role both in evolution and in domestication, and are major regulators of development in living organisms. Plant genome sequences reveal that approximately 7% of all genes encode putative TFs. The DOF (DNA binding with One Finger) TF family has been associated with vital processes exclusive to higher plants and to their close ancestors (algae, mosses and ferns). These are seed maturation and germination, light-mediated regulation, phytohormone and plant responses to biotic and abiotic stresses, etc. In Hordeum vulgare and Oryza sativa, 26 and 30 different Dof genes, respectively, have been annotated. Brachypodium distachyon has been the first Pooideae grass to be sequenced and, due to its genomic, morphological and physiological characteristics, has emerged as the model system for temperate cereals, such as wheat and barley. RESULTS: Through searches in the B. distachyon genome, 27 Dof genes have been identified and a phylogenetic comparison with the Oryza sativa and the Hordeum vulgare DOFs has been performed. To explore the evolutionary relationship among these DOF proteins, a combined phylogenetic tree has been constructed with the Brachypodium DOFs and those from rice and barley. This phylogenetic analysis has classified the DOF proteins into four Major Cluster of Orthologous Groups (MCOGs). Using RT-qPCR analysis the expression profiles of the annotated BdDof genes across four organs (leaves, roots, spikes and seeds) has been investigated. These results have led to a classification of the BdDof genes into two groups, according to their expression levels. The genes highly or preferentially expressed in seeds have been subjected to a more detailed expression analysis (maturation, dry stage and germination). CONCLUSIONS: Comparison of the expression profiles of the Brachypodium Dof genes with the published functions of closely related DOF sequences from the cereal species considered here, deduced from the phylogenetic analysis, indicates that although the expression profile has been conserved in many of the putative orthologs, in some cases duplication followed by subsequent divergence may have occurred (neo-functionalization).

Validation of microsatellite markers for cytotype discrimination in the model grass Brachypodium distachyon

Brachypodium distachyon (2n = 2x = 10) is a small annual grass species where the existence of three different cytotypes (10, 20 and 30 chromosomes) has long been regarded as a case of autopolyploid series, with x = 5. However, it has been demonstrated that the cytotypes assumed to be polyploids represent two separate Brachypodium species recently named as B. stacei (2n = 2x = 20) and B. hybridum (2n = 4x = 30). The aim of this study was to find a PCR-based alternative approach that could replace standard cytotyping methods (i. e., chromosome counting and flow cytometry) to characterize each of the three Brachypodium species. We have analyzed with four microsatellite (SSR) markers eighty-three Brachypodium distachyon-type lines from varied locations in Spain, including the Balearic and Canary Islands. Within this set of lines, 64, 4 and 15 had 10, 20 and 30 chromosomes, respectively. The surveyed markers produced cytotype-specific SSR profiles. So, a single amplification product was generated in the diploid samples, with non-overlapping allelic ranges between the 2n = 10 and 2n = 20 cytotypes, whereas two bands, one in the size range of each of the diploid cytotypes, were amplified in the 2n = 30 lines. Furthermore, the remarkable size difference obtained with the SSR ALB165 allowed the identification of the Brachypodium species by simple agarose gel electrophoresis.

The family of DOF transcription factors in Brachypodium distachyon: BdDof24 in germinating seeds

The DOF (DNA binding with One Finger) transcription factor (TF) family is characterized by a binding domain of 52 amino acid residues that is structured as a Cys2/Cys2 Zn2+ finger that recognizes the common core 5?-T/AAAAG-3? in the promoter regions of their target genes. DOF TFs have been associated with biological processes exclusive to higher plants and their close ancestors (algae, mosses and ferns).

Thermographic imaging: assessment of drought and heat tolerance in Spanish germplasm of Brachypodium distachyon.

The annual grass Brachypodium distachyon has been recently recognized as the model plant for functional genomics of temperate grasses, including cereals of economic relevance like wheat and barley. Sixty-two lines of B. distachyon were assessed for response to drought stress and heat tolerance. All these lines, except the reference genotype BD21, derive from specimens collected in 32 distinct locations of the Iberian Peninsula, covering a wide range of geo- climatic conditions. Sixteen lines of Brachypodium hybridum, an allotetraploid closely related to B. distachyon were used as reference of abiotic-stress well-adapted genotypes. Drought tolerance was assessed in a green-house trial. At the rosette-stage, no irrigation was applied to treated plants whereas their replicates at the control were maintained well watered during all the experiment. Thermographic images of treated and control plants were taken after 2 and 3 weeks of drought treatment, when stressed plants showed medium and extreme wilting symptoms. The mean leaf temperature of stressed (LTs) and control (LTc) plants was estimated based upon thermographic records from selected pixels (183 per image) that strictly correspond to leaf tissue. The response to drought was based on the analysis of two parameters: LTs and the thermal difference (TD) between stressed and control plants (LTs – LTc). The response to heat stress was based on LTc. Comparison of the mean values of these parameters showed that: 1) Genotypes better adapted to drought (B. hybridum lines) presented a higher LTs and TD than B. distachyon lines. 2) Under high temperature conditions, watered plants of B. hybridum lines maintained lower LTc than those of B. distachyon. Those results suggest that in these species adaptation to drought is linked to a more efficient stomata regulation: under water stress stomata are closed, increasing foliar temperature but also water use efficiency by reducing transpiration. With high temperature and water availability the results are less definite, but still seems that opening stomata allow plants to increase transpiration and therefore to diminish foliar temperature.

Factores transcripcionales de la clase DOF en Brachypodium distachyon: caracterización molecular de BdDOF24 durante la germinación de las semillas

La semilla es el órgano que garantiza la propagación y continuidad evolutiva de las plantas espermatofitas y constituye un elemento indispensable en la alimentación humana y animal. La semilla de cereales acumula en el endospermo durante la maduración, mayoritariamente, almidón y proteínas de reserva. Estas reservas son hidrolizadas en la germinación por hidrolasas sintetizadas en la aleurona en respuesta a giberelinas (GA), siendo la principal fuente de energía hasta que la plántula emergente es fotosintéticamente activa. Ambas fases del desarrollo de la semilla, están reguladas por una red de factores de transcripción (TF) que unen motivos conservados en cis- en los promotores de sus genes diana. Los TFs son proteínas que han desempeñado un papel central en la evolución y en el proceso de domesticación, siendo uno de los principales mecanismos de regulación génica; en torno al 7% de los genes de plantas codifican TFs. Atendiendo al motivo de unión a DNA, éstos, se han clasificado en familias. La familia DOF (DNA binding with One Finger) participa en procesos vitales exclusivos de plantas superiores y sus ancestros cercanos (algas, musgos y helechos). En las semillas de las Triticeae (subfamilia Pooideae), se han identificado varias proteínas DOF que desempeñan un papel fundamental en la regulación de la expresión génica. Brachypodium distachyon es la primera especie de la subfamilia Pooideae cuyo genoma (272 Mbp) ha sido secuenciado. Su pequeño tamaño, ciclo de vida corto, y la posibilidad de ser transformado por Agrobacterium tumefaciens (plásmido Ti), hacen que sea el sistema modelo para el estudio de cereales de la tribu Triticeae con gran importancia agronómica mundial, como son el trigo y la cebada. En este trabajo, se han identificado 27 genes Dof en el genoma de B. distachyon y se han establecido las relaciones evolutivas entre estos genes Dof y los de cebada (subfamilia Pooideae) y de arroz (subfamilia Oryzoideae), construyendo un árbol filogenético en base al alineamiento múltiple del dominio DOF. La cebada contiene 26 genes Dof y en arroz se han anotado 30. El análisis filogenético establece cuatro grupos de genes ortólogos (MCOGs: Major Clusters of Orthologous Genes), que están validados por motivos conservados adicionales, además del dominio DOF, entre las secuencias de las proteínas de un mismo MCOG. El estudio global de expresión en diferentes órganos establece un grupo de nueve genes BdDof expresados abundantemente y/o preferencialmente en semillas. El estudio detallado de expresión de estos genes durante la maduración y germinación muestra que BdDof24, ortólogo putativo a BPBF-HvDOF24 de cebada, es el gen más abundante en las semillas en germinación de B. distachyon. La regulación transcripcional de los genes que codifican hidrolasas en la aleurona de las semillas de cereales durante la post‐germinación ha puesto de manifiesto la existencia en sus promotores de un motivo tripartito en cis- conservado GARC (GA-Responsive Complex), que unen TFs de la clase MYB-R2R3, DOF y MYBR1-SHAQKYF. En esta tesis, se ha caracterizado el gen BdCathB de Brachypodium que codifica una proteasa tipo catepsina B y es ortólogo a los genes Al21 de trigo y HvCathB de cebada, así como los TFs responsables de su regulación transcripcional BdDOF24 y BdGAMYB (ortólogo a HvGAMYB). El análisis in silico del promotor BdCathB ha identificado un motivo GARC conservado, en posición y secuencia, con sus ortólogos en trigo y cebada. La expresión de BdCathB se induce durante la germinación, así como la de los genes BdDof24 y BdGamyb. Además, los TFs BdDOF24 y BdGAMYB interaccionan en el sistema de dos híbridos de levadura e in planta en experimentos de complementación bimolecular fluorescente. En capas de aleurona de cebada, BdGAMYB activa el promotor BdCathB, mientras que BdDOF24 lo reprime; este resultado es similar al obtenido con los TFs ortólogos de cebada BPBF-HvDOF24 y HvGAMYB. Sin embargo, cuando las células de aleurona se transforman simultáneamente con los dos TFs, BdDOF24 tiene un efecto aditivo sobre la trans-activación mediada por BdGAMYB, mientras que su ortólogo BPBF-HvDOF24 produce el efecto contrario, revirtiendo el efecto de HvGAMYB sobre el promotor BdCathB. Las diferencias entre las secuencias deducidas de las proteínas BdDOF24 y BPBF-HvDOF24 podrían explicar las funciones opuestas que desempeñan en su interacción con GAMYB. Resultados preliminares con líneas de inserción de T-DNA y de sobre-expresión estable de BdGamyb, apoyan los resultados obtenidos en expresión transitoria. Además las líneas homocigotas knock-out para el gen BdGamyb presentan alteraciones en anteras y polen y no producen semillas viables. ABSTRACT The seed is the plant organ of the spermatophytes responsible for the dispersion and survival in the course of evolution. In addition, it constitutes one of the most importan elements of human food and animal feed. The main reserves accumulated in the endosperm of cereal seeds through the maturation phase of development are starch and proteins. Its degradation by hydrolases synthetized in aleurone cells in response to GA upon germination provides energy, carbon and nitrogen to the emerging seedling before it acquires complete photosynthetic capacity. Both phases of seed development are controlled by a network of transcription factors (TFs) that interact with specific cis- elements in the promoters of their target genes. TFs are proteins that have played a central role during evolution and domestication, being one of the most important regulatory mechanisms of gene expression. Around 7% of genes in plant genomes encode TFs. Based on the DNA binding motif, TFs are classified into families. The DOF (DNA binding with One Finger) family is involved in specific processes of plants and its ancestors (algae, mosses and ferns). Several DOF proteins have been described to play important roles in the regulation of genes in seeds of the Triticeae tribe (Pooideae subfamily). Brachypodium distachyon is the first member of the Pooideae subfamily to be sequenced. Its small size and compact structured genome (272 Mbp), the short life cycle, small plant size and the possibility of being transformed with Agrobacterium tumefaciens (Ti-plasmid) make Brachypodium the model system for comparative studies within cereals of the Triticeae tribe that have big economic value such as wheat and barley. In this study, 27 Dof genes have been identified in the genome of B. distachyon and the evolutionary relationships among these Dof genes and those frome barley (Pooideae subfamily) and those from rice (Oryzoideae subfamily) have been established by building a phylogenetic tree based on the multiple alignment of the DOF DNA binding domains. The barley genome (Hordeum vulgare) contains 26 Dof genes and in rice (Oryza sativa) 30 genes have been annotated. The phylogenetic analysis establishes four Major Clusters of Orthologous Genes (MCOGs) that are supported by additional conserved motives out of the DOF domain, between proteins of the same MCOG. The global expression study of BdDof genes in different organs and tissues classifies BdDof genes into two groups; nine of the 27 BdDof genes are abundantly or preferentially expressed in seeds. A more detailed expression analysis of these genes during seed maturation and germination shows that BdDof24, orholog to barley BPBF-HvDof24, is the most abundantly expressed gene in germinating seeds. Transcriptional regulation studies of genes that encode hydrolases in aleurone cells during post-germination of cereal seeds, have identified in their promoters a tripartite conserved cis- motif GARC (GA-Responsive Complex) that binds TFs of the MYB-R2R3, DOF and MYBR1-SHAQKYF families. In this thesis, the characterization of the BdCathB gene, encoding a Cathepsin B-like protease and that is ortholog to the wheat Al21 and the barley HvCathB genes, has been done and its transcriptional regulation by the TFs BdDOF24 and BdGAMYB (ortholog to HvGAMYB) studied. The in silico analysis of the BdCathB promoter sequence has identified a GARC motif. BdCathB expression is induced upon germination, as well as, those of BdDof24 and BdGamyb genes. Moreover, BdDOF24 and BdGAMYB interact in yeast (Yeast 2 Hybrid System, Y2HS) and in planta (Bimolecular Fluorecence Complementation, BiFC). In transient assays in aleurone cells, BdGAMYB activates the BdCathB promoter, whereas BdDOF24 is a transcriptional repressor, this result is similar to that obtained with the barley orthologous genes BPBF-HvDOF24 and HvGAMYB. However, when aleurone cells are simultaneously transformed with both TFs, BdDOF24 has an additive effect to the trans-activation mediated by BdGAMYB, while its ortholog BPBF-HvDOF24 produces an opposite effect by reducing the HvGAMYB activation of the BdCathB promoter. The differences among the deduced protein sequences between BdDOF24 and BPBF-HvDOF24 could explain their opposite functions in the interaction with GAMYB protein. Preliminary results of T-DNA insertion (K.O.) and stable over-expression lines of BdGamyb support the data obtained in transient expression assays. In addition, the BdGamyb homozygous T-DNA insertion (K.O.) lines have anther and pollen alterations and they do not produce viable seeds.

Genes encoding beta-mannanases in Brachypodium distachyon seeds have a role not only in cell wall softening upon germination sensu stricto but also during post-germinative reserve mobilization

En la coleorriza en semillas de Brachypodium son abundantes los mananos y estos van desapareciendo conforme progresa la germinación (entre 12-27 h), al mismo tiempo se observa un pico de actividad endo-beta-mananasa. Se ha establecido que de los 6 miembros de la familia MAN en B. distachyon 3 se expresan en el embrión en germinación y BdMAN3 también es abundante en la aleurona.

Mannans and endo-beta-mannanases (MAN) in Brachypodium distachyon: expression profiling and possible role of the BdMAN genes during coleorhiza-limited seed germination

Immunolocalization of mannans in the seeds of Brachypodium distachyon reveals the presence of these polysaccharides in the root embryo and in the coleorhiza in the early stages of germination (12h), decreasing thereafter to the point of being hardly detected at 27h. Concurrently, the activity of endo-β-mannanases (MANs; EC 3.2.1.78) that catalyse the hydrolysis of β-1,4 bonds in mannan polymers, increases as germination progresses. The MAN gene family is represented by six members in the Brachypodium genome, and their expression has been explored in different organs and especially in germinating seeds. Transcripts of BdMAN2, BdMAN4 and BdMAN6 accumulate in embryos, with a maximum at 24–30h, and are detected in the coleorhiza and in the root by in situ hybridization analyses, before root protrusion (germination sensu stricto). BdMAN4 is not only present in the embryo root and coleorhiza, but is abundant in the de-embryonated (endosperm) imbibed seeds, while BdMAN2 and BdMAN6 are faintly expressed in endosperm during post-germination (36–42h). BdMAN4 and BdMAN6 transcripts are detected in the aleurone layer. These data indicate that BdMAN2, BdMAN4 and BdMAN6 are important for germination sensu stricto and that BdMAN4 and BdMAN6 may also influence reserve mobilization. Whether the coleorhiza in monocots and the micropylar endosperm in eudicots have similar functions, is discussed.

Environmental niche variation and evolutionary diversification of the Brachypodium distachyon grass complex species in their native circum-Mediterranean range

PREMISE OF THE STUDY: We conducted environmental niche modeling (ENM) of the Brachypodium distachyon s.l. complex, a model group of two diploid annual grasses ( B. distachyon , B. stacei ) and their derived allotetraploid ( B. hybridum) , native to the circum-Mediterranean region. We (1) investigated the ENMs of the three species in their native range based on present and past climate data; (2) identifi ed potential overlapping niches of the diploids and their hybrid across four Quaternary windows; (3) tested whether speciation was associated with niche divergence/conservatism in the complex species; and (4) tested for the potential of the polyploid outperforming the diploids in the native range. M ETHODS: Geo-referenced data, altitude, and 19 climatic variables were used to construct the ENMs. We used paleoclimate niche models to trace the potential existence of ancestral gene fl ow among the hybridizing species of the complex. KEY RESULTS: Brachypodium distachyon grows in higher, cooler, and wetter places, B. stacei in lower, warmer, and drier places, and B. hybridum in places with intermediate climatic features. Brachypodium hybridum had the largest niche overlap with its parent niches, but a similar distribution range and niche breadth. C ONCLUSIONS: Each species had a unique environmental niche though there were multiple niche overlapping areas for the diploids across time, suggesting the potential existence of several hybrid zones during the Pleistocene and the Holocene. No evidence of niche divergence was found, suggesting that species diversifi cation was not driven by ecological speciation but by evolutionary history, though it could be associated to distinct environmental adaptations.

Use of thermographic imaging to screen for drought-tolerant genotypes in Brachypodium distachyon

Thermal imaging has been used to evaluate the response to drought and warm temperatures in a collection of Brachypodium distachyon lines adapted to varied environmental conditions. Thermographic records were able to separate lines from contrasting rainfall regimes. Genotypes from dryer environments showed warmer leaves under water deficit, which suggested that decreased evapotranspiration was related to a more intense stomatal closure. When irrigated and under high temperature conditions, drought-adapted lines showed cooler leaves than lines from wetter zones. The consistent, inverse thermographic response of lines to water stress and heat validates the reliability of this method to assess drought tolerance in this model cereal. It additionally supports the hypothesis that stomatal-based mechanisms are involved in natural variation for drought tolerance in Brachypodium. The study further suggests that these mechanisms are not constitutive but likely related to a more efficient closing response to avoid dehydration in adapted genotypes. Higher leaf temperature under water deficit seems a dependable criterion of drought tolerance, not only in B. distachyon but also in the main cereal crops and related grasses where thermography can facilitate high-throughput preliminary screening of tolerant materials.

The Effects of High Steady State Auxin Levels on Root Cell Elongation in Brachypodium.

The long-standing Acid Growth Theory of plant cell elongation posits that auxin promotes cell elongation by stimulating cell wall acidification and thus expansin action. To date, the paucity of pertinent genetic materials has precluded thorough analysis of the importance of this concept in roots. The recent isolation of mutants of the model grass species Brachypodium distachyon with dramatically enhanced root cell elongation due to increased cellular auxin levels has allowed us to address this question. We found that the primary transcriptomic effect associated with elevated steady state auxin concentration in elongating root cells is upregulation of cell wall remodeling factors, notably expansins, while plant hormone signaling pathways maintain remarkable homeostasis. These changes are specifically accompanied by reduced cell wall arabinogalactan complexity but not by increased proton excretion. On the contrary, we observed a tendency for decreased rather than increased proton extrusion from root elongation zones with higher cellular auxin levels. Moreover, similar to Brachypodium, root cell elongation is, in general, robustly buffered against external pH fluctuation in Arabidopsis thaliana However, forced acidification through artificial proton pump activation inhibits root cell elongation. Thus, the interplay between auxin, proton pump activation, and expansin action may be more flexible in roots than in shoots.

二穗短柄草的遗传转化及VER2等基因在水稻中的功能初探

作为模式植物，水稻和拟南芥对于禾本科植物的研究都有其不足，二穗短柄草（Brachypodiumdistachyon）有望成为它们良好的补充。它具有作为一种模式植物所应该具有的各项优点，并且它与温带禾本科植物的亲缘关系比水稻更近。建立其良好转化体系是其成功应用的一环。本论文第一章以建立其农杆菌转化体系为目的，成功的诱导了其胚性愈伤组织，获得了潮霉素抗性愈伤，发现乙酰丁香酮浓度与转化效率的关系，并证明Silwet L-77对提高其转化效率有明显的作用，为进一步完善其转化体系打下了基础。 VER2是由本实验室发现的小麦春化相关基因，并己证明它可能参与春化过程中O-CJlcNAc介导的信号传导。本论文第二章研究了将VER2在水稻中过表达所引起的表型，发现VER2与光有类似的抑制根生长的作用，并且能够互相影响对方的表型，说明二者在水稻内调控根生长的信号途径既有共同的作用，但是又相互制约。进一步的研究有可能会找到水稻根内IAA响应的重要因子。 在第三章中，根据芯片数据克隆了水稻的十个可能与赤霉素、茉莉酸和减数分裂相关的上下调基因，并对其中四个利用过表达和RNAi技术进行了水稻转化，以研究它们在水稻中的功能。其中一个基因过表达的表型与赤霉素缺陷造成矮化和叶色深绿两个特征一致，而RNAi导致植株高度增加、叶色黄绿。而该基因受赤霉素诱导上调的程度在三个芯片杂交结果中最大(log2=2.3275)这一点也为其功能提供了很好的提示，即可能参与了赤霉素信号途径。