From archives to archival science Elements for a discursive construction

This work tries to outline the theoretical background established by archival science manuals, based mainly on discourse analysis as a key discipline to understand which the differences are and points of conceptual commonality in archival science traditions studied that to some extent, are additional. As archival science is a product of historically constructed knowledge, the context of conceptual production ultimately reflects in the different schools of thought and in the methodological approach. The manuals discussed here were selected by their canon and their wide dissemination in the archival science field, and are: the Manual for the arrangement and description of archives of the Association of Dutch Archivists (1898), and Jenkinson's A manual of archive administration including the problems of war archives and archive making. We considered how in these manuals two key concepts are discussed as for organization methodology in archival science: description and classification, establishing, from these concepts, which are the intertwined discourses in these texts and relating them to their historical aspects.

Postmodern archival science and contemporary diplomatics New approaches for archival knowledge organization

New information technologies and new forms of documentary production have led archivists to rethink the role of archival science in the so-called information age. Since the late 1980s, the principles, methods and concepts stated by the well-known manuals of the 19th and the 20th centuries have been reconsidered along with their application to the organic sets of document in the 21st century. In this new scenario of reformulation and reinterpretation regarding the perspectives on archival knowledge organization, two trends with different approaches have emerged in North America and Europe: postmodern archival science and contemporary diplomatics, respectively. The first one was introduced by Terry Cook, who proposed a reformulation of the basic concepts and the functional analysis method focusing on the process and context of document creation. The second approach originated in Italy and incorporated all the theoretical and methodological models of classic diplomatics. The studies following this new trend were disseminated by Luciana Duranti and aimed to ensure the production, access and use of the documentation generated in the present times focusing on document typology, as opposed by the postmodern approach. The purpose of this study is to elucidate the connection points and distinct features between the two trends concerning the organization of archival knowledge.

Challenges of Knowledge Representation in Contemporary Archival Science

Since its emergence as a discipline, in the nineteenth century (1889), the theory and practice of Archival Science have focused on the arrangement and description of archival materials as complementary and inseparable nuclear processes that aim to classify, to order, to describe and to give access to records. These processes have their specific goals sharing one in common: the representation of archival knowledge. In the late 1980 a paradigm shift was announced in Archival Science, especially after the appearance of the new forms of document production and information technologies. The discipline was then invited to rethink its theoretical and methodological bases founded in the nineteenth century so it could handle the contemporary archival knowledge production, organization and representation. In this sense, the present paper aims to discuss, under a theoretical perspective, the archival representation, more specifically the archival description facing these changes and proposals, in order to illustrate the challenges faced by Contemporary Archival Science in a new context of production, organization and representation of archival knowledge.

Forensic Injustice: Human Rights, Archival Science and Racialized Feminicide in Guatemala

The call to access and preserve the state records that document crimes committed by the state during Guatemala’s civil war has become an archival imperative entangled with neoliberal human rights discourses of “truth, justice, and memory.” 200,000 people were killed and disappeared in Guatemala’s civil war including acts of genocide in which 85% of massacres involved sexual violence committed against Mayan women. This dissertation argues that in an attempt to tell the official story of the civil war, American Human Rights organizations and academic institutions have constructed a normative identity whose humanity is attached to a scientific and evidentiary value as well as an archival status representing the materiality and institutionality of the record. Consequently, Human Rights discourses grounded in Western knowledges, in particular archival science and law, which prioritize the appearance of truth erase the material and epistemological experience of indigenous women during wartimes. As a result, the subjectivity that has surfaced on the record as most legible has mostly pertained to non-indigenous, middle class, urban, leftist men who were victims of enforced disappearance not genocide. This dissertation investigates this conflicting narrative that remembers a non-indigenous revolutionary masculine hero and grants him justice in human rights courtrooms simply because of a document attesting to his death. A main research question addressed in this project is why the promise of "truth and justice" under the name of human rights becomes a contentious site for gendered indigenous bodies? I conduct a discursive and rhetorical analysis of documentary film, declassified Guatemalan police and military records such as Operation Sofia, a military log known for “documenting the genocide” during rural counterinsurgencies executed by the military. I interrogate the ways in which racialized feminicides or the hyper-sexualized racial violence that has historically dehumanized indigenous women falls outside of discourses of vision constructed by Western positivist knowledges to reinscribe the ideal human right subject. I argue for alternative epistemological frames that recognize genocide as sexualized and gendered structures that have simultaneously produced racialized feminicides in order to disrupt the colonial structures of capitalism, patriarchy and heterosexuality. Ironically, these structures of power remain untouched by the dominant human rights discourse and its academic, NGO, and state collaborators that seek "truth and justice" in post-conflict Guatemala.

Archival Classification and Knowledge Organization: Theoretical Possibilities for the Archival Field

The main goal of this study is to outline a possible relation between archival classification and knowledge organization theory. In this sense, we seek to contribute to the conceptual classification in Archival Science, since there is a lack of systematization about archival classification; not just classification, but even the study of historical and conceptual aspects of the discipline. In the context of knowledge organization there is a considerable amount of research on how to build classification schemes and indexing systems that can help contribute to and expand archival classification theory. In order to comprehend this vast field of theories and methodologies we construct a parallel comparing the classification concepts in both areas and analyzing these concepts.

How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bits: Archival Motivation in the Digital Age

Why do people become archivists? Historically (and anecdotally) it was a deep love of musty, old records that drew people to the profession. While there have been many other motivating forces that inspired would-be archivists, it is most often that one hears of people seeking jobs in archives for love of “the stuff,” as evidenced in Kate Thiemer’s blog post, Honest tips for wannabe archivists (2012). As a result of the continually advancing presence of digitized and born digital archival collections, the physical nature of archival “stuff” is changing. While there remains the physical imprint of digital information on floppy disks, CDs, DVDs, hard drives, and old computers; the aspects of these physical artifacts might not evoke the same visceral pull to the profession as musty, raspy, paper-based documents. In light of this shift in physical presentation of information, we are faced with the question: how does love of archival “stuff” translate to work in digital archives? What is and/or will be the pull to become a digital archivist? To answer these questions, we will perform a survey-based study where we will invite archivists who work with both traditional and digital archival material to answer questions related to the aspects of their work that inspired or motivated them to join the profession. What motivates people to become archivists? What aspects of digital archives do or can potentially motivate people to seek out a career as an archivist? What, if any, motivational factors for becoming a traditional archivist are the same as those for becoming a digital archivist? What, if any, motivational factors for becoming a traditional archivist are different from those for becoming a digital archivist? By answering these questions, we hope to expand the archival discussion on what it means to be an archivist in the digital age. What compelling intrinsic, evidential, or informational values are present in digital archival content that will draw professionals to the field? Are there other values inherent in digital content that are currently unexplored? In our poster, we will present our discussion of the topic, our survey design, and results we have at the time of the Institute. Thiemer, K. (2012). Honest tips for wannabe archivists. Archivesnext blog. Retrieved from http://www.archivesnext.com/?p=2849

Archivist as activist : lessons from three queer community archives in California

California is home to multiple queer community archives created by community members outside of government, academic, and public archives. These archives are maintained by the communities and are important spaces not only for the preservation of records, but also as safe spaces to study, gather, and learn about the communities’ histories. This article describes the histories of three such queer community archives (Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual, Transgender Historical Society Lavender Library, Archives, and Cultural Exchange of Sacramento, Inc.; and ONE National Gay & Lesbian Archives) in order to discuss the role of activism in the community archives and implications for re-examining the role of activism to incorporate communities into the heart of archival professional work. By understanding the impetus for creating and maintaining queer community archives, archivists can use this knowledge to foster more reflective practices to be more inclusive in their archival practices through outreach, collaboration, and descriptive practices. This article extends our knowledge of community archives and provides evidence for the need to include communities in archival professional practice.

Gestão de documentos no Poder Legislativo: análise do funcionamento de uma Comissão Parlamentar de Inquérito

Estudo de caráter exploratório que visa analisar o funcionamento de uma Comissão Parlamentar de Inquérito da Câmara dos Deputados a partir do ferramental metodológico da gestão de documentos e da arquivologia. A pesquisa foi realizada a partir das fontes primárias do acervo da Comissão Parlamentar de Inquérito da Pirataria de Produtos Industrializados. As unidades da Câmara dos Deputados objeto de análise foram a Coordenação de Arquivo e o Departamento de Comissões. A interpretação dos dados e a discussão teórica apoiaram-se na literatura especializada nas áreas de gestão de documentos, arquivologia, ciência da informação. A implantação da gestão de documentos foi analisada tendo em conta a sua relevância para o alcance da transparência administrativa. Foram analisados os tipos de controle realizados pelos parlamentos e abordadas as principais características das Comissões Parlamentares de Inquérito. Os resultados indicaram que: i) a gestão de documentos é uma importante ferramenta de gerenciamento para as modernas administrações; ii) a aplicação da gestão de documentos nas Comissões Parlamentares de Inquérito pode contribuir para maior eficácia desses instrumentos legislativos de investigação; iii) a implantação de um programa de gestão de documentos possibilita maior acesso do público aos documentos e às informações da instituição.

As imagens médicas do Hospital Miguel Bombarda – proposta para o seu tratamento documental

A presente dissertação de mestrado apresenta o trabalho desenvolvido em torno de um conjunto de fotografias provenientes do Hospital Miguel Bombarda e custodiadas pelo Centro Hospitalar Psiquiátrico de Lisboa. Partindo de uma reflexão sobre a fotografia enquanto documento de arquivo e, por isso, enquadrada num certo contexto que presidiu à sua produção e conservação, pretende-se contribuir para uma melhor compreensão de um conjunto retratos de doentes. Os objectivos deste trabalho passam por procurar compreender as abordagens teóricas relativamente à fotografia enquanto documento de arquivo, reconstituir o contexto de produção da documentação fotográfica seleccionada e perceber de que forma este conhecimento pode enriquecer a leitura das imagens. É apresentada numa proposta de descrição arquivística sob a forma de um catálogo. Pretende-se que a descrição seja capaz de reflectir a investigação efectuada e possa também servir de modelo e ser alargada à restante documentação fotográfica.

Contributos para a descrição arquivística dos álbuns fotográficos do serviço do Ultramar na Fundação Calouste Gulbenkian

O presente Relatório de Estágio descreve as actividades levadas a cabo no Arquivo da Fundação Calouste Gulbenkian em torno do objecto de estudo constituído pelos álbuns fotográficos do Serviço do Ultramar, que se apresentam e caracterizam. Os trabalhos desenvolvidos compreendem a descrição das peças que os compõem, apresentando contributos ao nível da descrição da documentação fotográfica em contexto arquivístico e em complementaridade à existente, com o objectivo de gerar descrições uniformes e coerentes, promovendo uma melhor recuperação e acesso à informação tendo em vista a sua disponibilização ao utilizador. Paralelamente à dimensão arquivística e atendendo ao seu contexto de produção administrativa, são ainda abordados e apresentados aspectos de índole teórica associados à função probatória e papel institucional da produção de imagens com carácter de representação e a sua utilização pela instituição.

La diffusion d'archives à l'aide des technologies du Web 2.0 : le cas du Musée McCord

Ce mémoire explore le concept de diffusion des archives à l’ère du Web 2.0. Dans le contexte nord-américain, la diffusion en archivistique englobe les aspects de promotion, de mise en valeur et de communication des archives. Le Web 2.0 offre un potentiel très intéressant pour la diffusion d’archives. Ce moyen de diffusion est défini comme étant un ensemble de principes et de technologies qui crée et facilite l’interaction entre plusieurs individus. Peu d’études ont été menées sur la diffusion des archives à l’ère du Web 2.0, c’est pourquoi notre recherche s’est intéressée à un milieu qui a intégré le Web 2.0 afin d’instaurer un dialogue avec ses usagers, connus et potentiels, pour exploiter ses archives et augmenter sa visibilité, soit le Musée McCord. Dans cette étude de cas simple certains membres du personnel du Musée McCord ont été rencontrés, afin de découvrir les motivations de l’institution à se lancer dans l’utilisation d’outils issus de ces technologies. De plus, l’étude a permis d’observer quels outils ont été choisis, comment et pourquoi. Ensuite, les avantages et les désavantages de cette nouvelle utilisation ont été mis en lumière. Enfin, les étapes de la mise en place d’outils du Web 2.0 sont exposées.

Les archives dans l'art de Robert Rauschenberg

Ce mémoire adopte une perspective archivistique afin d'examiner l'art de Robert Rauschenberg, un artiste américain ayant fait ses débuts sur la scène artistique new-yorkaise des années soixante. Il est pertinent de voir les stratégies d’appropriation des artistes des années soixante, dont faisait partie Rauschenberg, comme ayant « mis la table » pour le mouvement des artistes allant puiser dans les archives pour leur pratique artistique, mouvement qui s'est développé depuis la fin des années quatre-vingt et le début des années quatre-vingt-dix. L'ensemble des rapports de l'artiste avec les archives est d'abord étudié. Ensuite, une lecture archivistique d'un corpus d'oeuvres est réalisée afin de mieux comprendre les particularités de l'utilisation des archives par Rauschenberg. Les conditions d'utilisation des archives sont relevées ainsi que la conception des archives comme mémoire, pour se terminer avec les rapports entre les archives et la photographie.

Archives et création : nouvelles perspectives sur l'archivistique

Ce cahier de recherche fait état des travaux menés au cours de la première étape (2013-2014) du projet « Archives et création : nouvelles perspectives sur l’archivistique ». Il comprend les textes suivants : Yvon Lemay et Anne Klein, « Introduction », p. 4-6; Yvon Lemay, « Archives et création : nouvelles perspectives sur l’archivistique », p. 7-19; Anne-Marie Lacombe, « Exploitation des archives à des fins de création : un aperçu de la littérature », p. 20-59; Simon Côté-Lapointe, « Archives sonores et création : une pratique à la croisée des chemins », p. 60-83; Hélène Brousseau, « Fibres, archives et société », p. 84-104; Annie Lecompte-Chauvin, « Comment les archives entrent dans nos vies par le biais de la littérature », p. 105-120; Aude Bertrand, « Valeurs, usages et usagers des archives », p. 121-150; Laure Guitard, « Indexation, émotions, archives », p. 151-168; Anne Klein, Denis Lessard et Anne-Marie Lacombe, « Archives et mise en archives dans le champ culturel. Synthèse du colloque « Archives et création, regards croisés : tournant archivistique, courant artistique », p. 169-178. De plus, dans le but de situer le projet dans un contexte plus large, le cahier inclut une bibliographie des travaux effectués sur les archives et la création depuis 2007, p. 179-182.

Archive(s) : approche dialectique et exploitation artistique

Les archives sont aujourd’hui utilisées et envisagées hors de leur lieu traditionnel qu’est le service d’archives et souvent même hors de l’action des archivistes. Cette thèse de doctorat propose un renversement dialectique benjaminien dans la conception de l’archivistique dont le point central devient l’utilisation des archives définitives plutôt que la production des documents. Les premiers chapitres retracent les différentes compréhensions des archives depuis la création des institutions nationales au 19e siècle jusqu’au renouvellement opéré par certains archivistes se réclamant de la postmodernité à la fin du 20e siècle. Cette histoire des archives et de l’archivistique montre que les archives définitives sont caractérisées au regard du rapport au passé qu’elles permettent et que les archivistes pensent leur objet depuis la question historiographique de l’écriture de l’histoire. Ainsi, deux conceptions générales des archives coexistent aujourd’hui et apparaissent comme essentiellement contradictoires en ce que l’une (traditionnelle) est centrée sur le créateur des documents et le passé compris comme l’ensemble des actes posés par le créateur, tandis que l’autre (postmoderne) se fonde sur les fonctions sociales des archives et sur le rôle de l’archiviste. L’élément commun à ces deux visions est l’absence de prise en charge théorique des utilisateurs et de l’exploitation des documents. Or, en suivant les traces et la pensée de Walter Benjamin, nous proposons de penser la double nature des archives comme documents et comme témoignage tout en articulant cette pensée à l’archive comme modalité d’inscription de soi dans le temps. Il en ressort que les archives peuvent être considérées comme une objectivation du passé relevant d’une temporalité chronologique au cœur de laquelle réside, à l’état latent, l’archive potentiellement libératrice. L’exploitation artistique des archives, telle qu’elle est présentée dans le cinquième chapitre, montre comment la notion d’archives explose. En outre, l’observation de ce type particulier d’exploitation permet de mettre au jour le fait que les archives sont toujours inscrites dans des conditions d’utilisation (contexte, matérialité, dispositif, rapport au public) qui sont autant de conditions d’existence de l’archive. Parmi les questions abordées par les artistes celles de la mémoire, de l’authenticité, des archives comme moyen d’appropriation du monde et comme objet poétique sont alors autant de points d’entrée possibles pour revisiter l’archivistique. Le dernier chapitre synthétise l’ensemble des renouvellements proposés au fil de la thèse de manière implicite ou explicite. Nous y envisageons une temporalité non chronologique où les archives sont un objet du passé qui, saisi par un présent dialectique singulier, sont tournées à la fois vers le passé et vers l’avenir. De nouvelles perspectives sont ouvertes pour l’archivistique à partir des caractéristiques assignées aux archives par les artistes. Finalement, c’est le cycle de vie des archives qui peut être revu en y incluant l’exploitation comme dimension essentielle.

Archives et création : nouvelles perspectives sur l’archivistique

Ce cahier de recherche fait état des travaux menés au cours de la deuxième étape (2014-2015) du projet « Archives et création : nouvelles perspectives sur l’archivistique ». Les textes sont les suivants : Yvon Lemay et Anne Klein, « Préface », p. 4-5; Yvon Lemay, « Deuxième cahier de recherche : présentation », p. 6-26; Érika Nimis, « Combler les silences de l’histoire africaine. Ou comment des artistes visuels s’approprient des archives photographiques pour éclairer le passé à la lumière du présent », p. 27-42; Hélène Brousseau, « L'utilisation d’archives dans les arts visuels : dialogue entre une artiste et une archiviste », p. 43-58; Simon Côté-Lapointe, « Créer à partir d’archives : bilan, démarches et techniques d’un projet exploratoire », p. 59-95; Annaëlle Winand, « Le concept d’archive(s) et les films de réemploi », p. 96-111; Nicolas Bednarz et Céline Widmer, « Archives au pluriel : le Montréal de 1914-1918. L’expérience d’une création collaborative et multidisciplinaire », p. 112-142; Mattia Scarpulla, « La mémoire performative. Considérations sur les traces de la danse et les dispositifs de capture des mouvements », p. 143-173; Yvon Lemay et Anne Klein, « Quartiers disparus : l’envers du décor », p. 174-190. De plus, le cahier comprend une « Bibliographie » des travaux effectués sur les archives et la création depuis 2007, p. 191-196, et des informations sur « Les auteurs », p. 197.