Calcareous nannofossil assemblages of Ocean Anoxic Event 2 in ODP Sites 207-1258 and 207-1260

The calcareous nannofossils of the Cenomanian/Turonian boundary interval of Sites 1258 and 1260 (Ocean Drilling Program Leg 207) have been studied in order to understand the depositional environment during Oceanic Anoxic Event 2 (OAE2) in the equatorial Atlantic. Nannofossil assemblages show a significant change in relative abundances during the positive d13Corg excursion interval. The strong increase of the high productivity indicator Zeugrhabdotus erectus and the simultaneous decrease of the oligotrophic taxa Watznaueria barnesiae and Watznaueria fossacincta are indicative of enhanced fertility. The decrease of Eprolithus floralis may be attributed to the surface-water temperature increase during OAE2, which is, however, not very significant (~2-3 °C), as suggested by published TEX86 data. It seems more likely that the decrease of E. floralis during OAE2 was evoked by the breakdown of water-column stratification, indicating it as a deep-dwelling species, which prefers stratified waters with a deep nutricline. Prediscosphaera spp. and Retecapsa ficula, which show a significant increase in relative abundances during OAE2, seem to prefer eutrophic environments, while Amphizygus brooksii and Zeugrhabdotus noeliae lower surface-water fertility. Gartnerago segmentatum, Broinsonia spp., Watznaueria biporta, and Seribiscutum gaultensis decrease in abundances during OAE2. It is not clear if they preferred an oligotrophic environment, cooler surface-waters, or if they were inhabitants of the lower photic zone. Published geochemical data suggest that enhanced fertility and higher temperatures during OAE2 may have been caused by submarine volcanic activity through the release of biolimiting micronutrients into the ocean and carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. The breakdown of water-column stratification may have increased further nutrient availability.

Planktic and benthic foraminifreral isotope data for ODP Site 207-1258

The mid-Cretaceous is widely considered the archetypal ice-free greenhouse interval in Earth history, with a thermal maximum around Cenomanian-Turonian boundary time (ca. 90 Ma). However, contemporaneous glaciations have been hypothesized based on sequence stratigraphic evidence for rapid sea-level oscillation and oxygen isotope excursions in records generated from carbonates of questionable preservation and/or of low resolution. We present new oxygen isotope records for the mid-Cenomanian Demerara Rise that are of much higher resolution than previously available, taken from both planktic and benthic foraminifers, and utilizing only extremely well preserved glassy foraminifers. Our records show no evidence of glaciation, calling into question the hypothesized ice sheets and rendering the origin of inferred rapid sea-level oscillations enigmatic. Simple mass-balance calculations demonstrate that this Cretaceous sea-level paradox is unlikely to be explained by hidden ice sheets existing below the limit of d18O detection.