Strategies towards evaluation beyond scientific impact

Various research fields, like organic agricultural research, are dedicated to solving real-world problems and contributing to sustainable development. Therefore, systems research and the application of interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary approaches are increasingly endorsed. However, research performance depends not only on self-conception, but also on framework conditions of the scientific system, which are not always of benefit to such research fields. Recently, science and its framework conditions have been under increasing scrutiny as regards their ability to serve societal benefit. This provides opportunities for (organic) agricultural research to engage in the development of a research system that will serve its needs. This article focuses on possible strategies for facilitating a balanced research evaluation that recognises scientific quality as well as societal relevance and applicability. These strategies are (a) to strengthen the general support for evaluation beyond scientific impact, and (b) to provide accessible data for such evaluations. Synergies of interest are found between open access movements and research communities focusing on global challenges and sustainability. As both are committed to increasing the societal benefit of science, they may support evaluation criteria such as knowledge production and dissemination tailored to societal needs, and the use of open access. Additional synergies exist between all those who scrutinise current research evaluation systems for their ability to serve scientific quality, which is also a precondition for societal benefit. Here, digital communication technologies provide opportunities to increase effectiveness, transparency, fairness and plurality in the dissemination of scientific results, quality assurance and reputation. Furthermore, funders may support transdisciplinary approaches and open access and improve data availability for evaluation beyond scientific impact. If they begin to use current research information systems that include societal impact data while reducing the requirements for narrative reports, documentation burdens on researchers may be relieved, with the funders themselves acting as data providers for researchers, institutions and tailored dissemination beyond academia.

Modelo de medición grupos de investigación COLCIENCIAS y su relación con el entorno internacional

El modelo de medición de COLCIENCIAS es la forma en la cual los grupos de investigación llevan a cabo el proceso de investigación para la obtención del reconocimiento que otorga la entidad, este modelo contiene una serie de aspectos que incrementan la calidad de los hallazgos obtenidos por medio de tipologías, estos acompañados por la conformación de un grupo bien estructurado, aumentan la confiabilidad de la producción del conocimiento. En las tablas se pueden ver los productos de los grupos los cuales son los resultados generados por estos en los procesos de investigación científica y responden al plan de trabajo, las líneas de investigación y los proyectos del grupo. Existen tipologías de productos, cada uno de los cuatro grandes tipos cuenta con una definición general que incluye diferentes subtipos y productos, para cada uno de los cuales se categorizan por requerimientos de calidad, en categorías diferentes.

The Recognition as a Quality Methodology Proposal in the Learning Process

In the education field, the question for the holistic formation is continuous and controversial. Moreover, with the obvious changes in the global knowledge production, apprehension and transmission, is crucial asking for the role of the education in the changes of the individual toward autonomy and take decisions in relationship with the educational process and the responsibility like a person sharing with knowledge like an issue of social development. In this context, this paper, presents results of an investigation made on 1995, about the recognition value like a methodology proposal of learning quality, for consider their propositions to be in force into an educational structure.

La Androergología: una nueva disciplina de la educación

A research work on the micro firms in Caroni district, has been developing since 1994. Such study pretends to deepen the theory that let the empiric- philosophical- conceptual and methodological building of a new discipline in education, called Androergology. The most outstanding aspects that can be seen from the philosophical bases are the following: its ontology, as aempowerment of the individual abilities through mental structures change in a community of pairs; ethics as the one based on the assignment of Good for the process of creatingsocioproductive communities_ which also means a liberating function since it can achieve a sustainable economic development by the assembling of micro firms nets; and the epistemology derived from the bases of the General Theory of Systems and the Morin’s circular complexities. Among the principles of this discipline that can be mentioned are ContinuingEducation- since the individual already belongs to a society that always creates knowledge, global markets - the undertaker should produce for a world society, the age of this microfirm’s man- as a discussion upon the knowledge production in that individual as an epistemic subject, the Integral Education- since the spiritual, social and humanistic aspects should beadded to the technical ones; and the Contextual Formation-since the process should take place into the unit of production. The androergologic methodology is thought out as a processof two inputs: the business needs diagnosis and the knowledge of context. The central part focuses its attention on the adult learning process situation; and the concentric circles whichmean the ideal synergical relationship between the programmatic contents, learning processes, the androergologist and the necessary supervising process, which results to be theintegral and innovating element of this method. 

El poder electrónico para la gente: un desafío para la democracia contemporánea

Los adelantos tecnológicos han transformado prácticamente todos los aspectos de nuestras vidas. En la última década, la producción de conocimiento se ha dado casi de manera exponencial, y ello, sin lugar a dudas, también tiene implicaciones en la forma como nos relacionamos entre nosotros como ciudadanos y con el Estado. El presente artículo hace una reflexión acerca de los desafíos que el sistema democrático actual tiene para lograr una autodeterminación de los grupos e individuos y la inclusión efectiva en el sistema. Para tal fin, se deben encaminar dos grandes procesos: en el primero, el objetivo debe ser el empoderamiento de la gente con respecto al uso creativo de todas aquellas herramientas electrónicas que el mundo ofrece y el segundo tiene que ver con la construcción que el Estado debe realizar para comunicarse con los ciudadanos en un nuevo contexto de ubicuidad social. ---Electronic power to the people: a challenge to contemporary democracyTechnological advances have transformed virtually every aspect of our lives. In the last decade, knowledge production has grown almost exponentially, and this, undoubtedly has implications in how we relate to each of us as citizens and the state. This article makes a reflection on the challenges that the current democratic system is to achieve self-determination of groups and individuals and the effective inclusion into the system. To that end, must be directed at two major processes, the first aimed at empowering people in all those electronic tools that the world offers us to make it a creative use, and the second has to do with the ability of the State have to build to communicate with citizens in a new context of social ubiquity.Key words: electronic power, Internet, democracy, inclusion, self determination, State, government, education, rights.---O poder eletrônico para gente: Um desafio para a democracia contemporâneaOs avanços tecnológicos têm transformado praticamente todos os aspectos de nossas vidas. Na última década, a produção de conhecimento se tem dado quase de maneira exponencial, e isso, certamente, também tem implicações na forma como nos relacionamos entre nós como cidadãos e com o Estado. O presente artigo faz uma reflexão acerca dos desafios que o sistema democrático atual tem para lograr uma autodeterminação dos grupos e indivíduos e a inclusão efetiva no sistema. Para tal fim, se devem encaminhar dois grandes processos: no primeiro, o objetivo deve ser o empoderamento das pessoas em relação ao uso criativo de todas aquelas ferramentas eletrônicas que o mundo oferece e o segundo tem que ver com a construção que o Estado deve realizar para se comunicar com os cidadãos em um contexto de ubiqüidade social.Palavras chave: Poder eletrônico, democracia, inclusão, autodeterminação, Estado, governo, educação, direitos.

La Crisis ambiental como proceso. Un análisis reflexivo sobre su emergencia, desarrollo y profundización desde la perspectiva de la teoría crítica

La investigación se focaliza en el análisis de la crisis ambiental considerada como un fenómeno complejo de evolución incierta producto de un proceso socio histórico, cuyos orígenes se remontan a los albores del proyecto moderno y deben rastrearse en un cúmulo de circunstancias que expresan las contradicciones de un modelo socioeconómico identificado con el crecimiento sostenido de la producción y las magnitudes económicas. Partiendo de esta base, se propone abordar la relación entre saber sociológico y crisis ambiental, a partir de las contribuciones de la teoría crítica a la compresión de las causas profundas de la crisis ambiental y de sus elementos constitutivos. Para lo cual se propone profundizar en algunas categorías desarrolladas por la corriente social crítica, las cuales si bien no se refieren en forma directa a la problemática ambiental, se vislumbran como campos fértiles para comprender los procesos sociales generadores de la crisis ambiental así como las alternativas que han de adoptarse para su resolución, teniendo en cuenta los mecanismos que ejerce el sistema para neutralizar los cambios que implica la conformación de una racionalidad alternativa. Acorde con ello, la primera parte del trabajo se centra en el abordaje de la relación sociedad naturaleza en el marco de tres grandes procesos sociales identificados como cosmológico, teocéntrico y antropocéntrico, haciendo especial hincapié en la correlación que en cada una de las etapas consideradas se establece entre racionalidad dominante, producción de conocimiento y conceptualización de naturaleza. El segundo capítulo profundiza en los efectos de la racionalidad instrumental sobre la ruptura del proyecto moderno y su incidencia sobre la emergencia de la crisis ambiental, a partir de la posición adoptada por Heidegger y por los referentes de la Escuela de Frankfurt. Posteriormente el análisis se estructura en torno a las dimensiones críticas de la modernidad avanzada, considerada como contexto situacional de desarrollo y profundización de la crisis ambiental, teniendo en cuenta los aportes teóricos desarrollados por Zygmunt Bauman e Immanuel Wallerstein. Al finalizar se presentan las conclusiones generales de la tesis y las posibles líneas de investigación que se abren a partir del trabajo desarrollado.

A visibilidade das universidades portuguesas na web : estudo webométrico

Esta dissertação resulta de uma investigação que levou a cabo um estudo webométrico sobre a presença das universidades portuguesas na Web, avaliando a visibilidade das instituições através do cálculo de um indicador webométrico, o Web Impact Factor. A World Wide Web é, na atualidade, um dos principais meios de difusão de Informação. Os Estudos Métricos da Informação visam quantificar e avaliar a produção de Informação, objeto de estudo de disciplinas como a Infometria, a Cienciometria e a Bibliometria. Recentemente, surgiram a Cibermetria e a Webometria como novas disciplinas que estudam a produção e difusão da Informação no contexto do Ciberespaço e da World Wide Web, respetivamente. As universidades, enquanto polos privilegiados de produção e difusão de conhecimento, são o objeto de estudo natural da Webometria e a avaliação da sua presença na World Wide Web contribui para a análise do desempenho destas instituições. Para a realização deste trabalho foi adotada a metodologia proposta por Noruzi, que calcula três categorias de Web Impact Factor: o WIF Total, o WIF Revisto e o Selflink WIF. De modo a calcular estas categorias, foram recolhidos dados quantitativos de inlinks, selflinks, número total de páginas e número de páginas indexadas pelo motor de pesquisa. O motor de pesquisa utilizado foi o Altavista, tendo sido realizadas pesquisas de expressões booleanas durante o primeiro semestre de 2009. Após a recolha, os dados foram tratados estatisticamente e procedeu-se ao cálculo das categorias do WIF. Conclui-se que existe uma maior visibilidade das universidades públicas portuguesas porque obtêm melhores resultados ao nível de duas categorias do Web Impact Factor: o WIF Revisto e o Selflink WIF.

Museologial process : exclusion criteria

In the last few years, reflections around knowledge building in the museology area have increased considerably, allowing us to cast many gazes over our actions, and, consequently, enabling us to a wider debate around our professional action field, decreasing our exclusion from the academic environment – museologists reproducing the knowledge produced in other areas. In the present work, we shall approach some issues related to the museological process, taking as a reference several studies about the subject, which, due to the time given to us in this round table, could not be re-presented here for discussion. Besides, we have dedicated a chapter to such approach in our publication titled “Museological Process and Education: building a didactic-community museum”. So we have opted instead to carry out a reflection about exclusion, looking into the museum institution and into the application of museological processes; in other words, we shall carry out a self-criticism, in which I include myself, affecting an analysis that will be debated here, considering, additionally, that the museums and museological practices are in relation to the other social global practices, therefore, they are the result of human relations at each historical moment. Finally, based on our lived experience, we shall give continuity to our reflection process, highlighting the importance of knowledge production for the area of museology and the relevance of the theory-practice relation, punctuating some aspects we think that may contribute to the construction of a museological action that may serve as a historical elaboration in securing a space for self- determination.

Forum theorizing in the context of professional practice: The case for middle-range theories

This commentary seeks to complement the contribution of the Building Research & Information special issue on 'Developing Theories for the Built Environment' (2008) by highlighting the important role of middle-range theories within the context of professional practice. Middle-range theories provide a form of theorizing that lies between abstract grand theorizing and atheoretical local descriptions. They are also characterized by the way in which they directly engage with the concerns of practitioners. In the context of professional practice, any commitment to theorizing should habitually be combined with an equivalent commitment to empirical research; rarely is it appropriate to neglect one in favour of the other. Any understanding of the role that theory plays in professional practice must further be informed by Schon's seminal ideas on reflective practice. Practitioners are seen to utilize theories as inputs to a process of continuous reflection, thereby guarding against complacency and routinization. The authors would challenge any assumption that academics alone are responsible for generating theories, thereby limiting the role of practitioners to their application. Such a dichotomized view is contrary to established ideas on Mode 2 knowledge production and current trends towards co-production research in the context of the built environment.

Policy ‘framing’ and evidence-based planning: ‘epistemic communities’ in the multi-jurisdictional environment of an enlarged Europe

The following paper builds on ongoing discussions over the spatial and territorial turns in planning, as it relates to the dynamics of evidence-based planning and knowledge production in the policy process. It brings this knowledge perspective to the organizational and institutional dynamics of transformational challenges implicit in the recent enlargement of the EU. Thus it explores the development of new spatial ideas and planning approaches, and their potential to shape or ‘frame’ spatial policy through the formulation of new institutional arrangements and the de-institutionalization of others. That is, how knowledge is created, contested, mobilized and controlled across governance architectures or territorial knowledge channels. In so doing, the paper elaborates and discusses a theoretical framework through which the interplay of knowledge and policymaking can be conceptualized and analyzed.

Good practice transfer within small construction specialist trade contractors

Government and institutionally-driven ‘good practice transfer’ initiatives are consistently presented as a means to enhance construction firm and industry performance. Two implicit tenets of these initiatives appear to be: knowledge embedded in good practice will transfer automatically; and, the potential of implementing good practice will be capitalised regardless of the context where it is to be used. The validity of these tenets is increasingly being questioned and, concurrently, more nuanced knowledge production understandings are being developed which recognise and incorporate context-specificity. This research contributes to this growing, more critical agenda by examining the actual benefits accrued from good practice transfer from the perspective of a small specialist trade contracting firm. A concept model for successful good practice transfer is developed from a single longitudinal case study within a small heating and plumbing firm. The concept model consists of five key variables: environment, strategy, people, technology, and organisation of work. The key findings challenge the implicit assumptions prevailing in the existing literature and support a contingency approach that argues successful good practice transfer is not just adopting and mechanistically inserting into the firm, but requires addressing ‘behavioural’ aspects. For successful good practice transfer, small specialist trade contracting firms need to develop and operationalise organisation slack, mechanisms for scanning external stimuli and absorbing knowledge. They also need to formulate and communicate client-driven external strategies; to motive and educate people at all levels; to possess internal or accessible complementary skills and knowledge; to have ‘soft focus’ immediate/mid-term benefits at a project level; and, to embed good practice in current work practices.

Using digital data and bibliometric analysis for researching doctoral education

As more digital data become publicly available new opportunities for researchers in education are arising. Researchers may be unaware of the existence and usefulness of such data even though these are freely available. In this article the use of one such source of information is described and its potential for research into research education discussed. We sought to exploit the research potential of the existing, yet dispersed, collection of online Australian thesis records to inform their research into the development of the PhD in Australia. Having created a searchable and reliable database from the available records, bibliometric analyses enabled us to map knowledge production and research capability in institutional and disciplinary settings from 1949 to 2003 as indicated by PhD theses. This is in contrast to the more familiar use of data based on student load or completion rates, and complements that data by focusing on research output as opposed to student throughput.

Creating spaces for pedagogy : research as learning

As teacher-educators, the authors designed and implemented a small study that mapped teacher-education students' understandings of their own identities and how they made sense of ethnicity and class differences among their secondary students while on teaching rounds. While the authors did not set out to 'teach' their research participants, it was during the analysis of data from the research project, that they began to realise the potential of research to create opportunities for learning. In this paper the authors speculate on the 'conditions' of knowledge production and suggest that the dialogic nature of interviews and focus group discussions can offer pedagogical spaces for learning. Research designs that incorporate opportunities for participants to re-tell narratives over periods of time, may position participants as experts in knowledge production and may reposition them and researchers in more equitable power relations. The authors present an example of one participant's narrative together with their interpretations to explore how research potentially offers 'evidence' of learning. While this is tentative only, the authors suggest there is a need to create spaces for pedagogy in the design and execution of educational research.

Challenging librarians : the relevance of the doctorate in professional practice

We, as librarians, are adept at challenging academics, students and administrators about the crucial role of information literacy in higher education and lifelong learning. Consequently, the push for strategic partnerships with academics is frequently in the foreground of our thinking. Concomitantly, the push for academic status for librarians is raised occasionally, particularly as a pay and equity issue. Yet, our purposes may appear somewhat misguided or rhetorical when contrasted to the nominal prerequisites required for professional practice, especially when compared with those of academics. The issues of information literacy and knowledge production within a knowledge economy compound such debate. This paper argues that ‘credential creep’ is catching up with librarians in the university sector. In order to be regarded as integral to academic endeavour, those of us who ‘teach’ information literacy may need to match the qualifications normally required by academics. Consonant with this proposal is the Australian and New Zealand Information Literacy Framework: Principles, Standards and Practice (Bundy, 2004) of the Australian and New Zealand Institute for Information Literacy (ANZIIL) and the Council of Australian University Librarians (CAUL). The Framework mirrors many of the desired outcomes of a doctoral degree, a degree possessed by approximately one per cent of Australian librarians but, in comparison, by more than fi fty-four per cent of Australian academics. This paper challenges—not academics—but librarians, to embrace the notion of undertaking doctoral study to enhance our professional (or amateur) practice and our information literacy. The recommendation is derived in essence from my study on doctoral research and information literacy (Macauley, 2001). It also incorporates the current discourse on these issues and uses personal narrative to articulate the findings. It seeks also to explore those tensions and contradictions commensurate with practising what we preach.

Publication patterns in journals dedicated to issues of marketing and society : benchmarking and analysis

The purpose of this paper is to examine the nature and distribution of scholars engaged in knowledge production in journals focusing on marketing and society, broadly defined. Who is interested in issues of marketing and society? Where are they from? How does this compare to patterns of scholarship in recognized journals in marketing? The answers to these questions have implications for how sub-disciplines like Macromarketing can position themselves for future growth.