Collating the knowledge base for core outcome set development: developing and appraising the search strategy for a systematic review

Background: The COMET (Core Outcome Measures in Effectiveness Trials) Initiative is developing a publicly accessible online resource to collate the knowledge base for core outcome set development (COS) and the applied work from different health conditions. Ensuring that the database is as comprehensive as possible and keeping it up to date are key to its value for users. This requires the development and application of an optimal, multi-faceted search strategy to identify relevant material. This paper describes the challenges of designing and implementing such a search, outlining the development of the search strategy for studies of COS development, and, in turn, the process for establishing a database of COS.

Methods: We investigated the performance characteristics of this strategy including sensitivity, precision and numbers needed to read. We compared the contribution of databases towards identifying included studies to identify the best combination of methods to retrieve all included studies.

Results: Recall of the search strategies ranged from 4% to 87%, and precision from 0.77% to 1.13%. MEDLINE performed best in terms of recall, retrieving 216 (87%) of the 250 included records, followed by Scopus (44%). The Cochrane Methodology Register found just 4% of the included records. MEDLINE was also the database with the highest precision. The number needed to read varied between 89 (MEDLINE) and 130 (SCOPUS).

Conclusions: We found that two databases and hand searching were required to locate all of the studies in this review. MEDLINE alone retrieved 87% of the included studies, but actually 97% of the included studies were indexed on MEDLINE. The Cochrane Methodology Register did not contribute any records that were not found in the other databases, and will not be included in our future searches to identify studies developing COS. SCOPUS had the lowest precision rate (0.77) and highest number needed to read (130). In future COMET searches for COS a balance needs to be struck between the work involved in screening large numbers of records, the frequency of the searching and the likelihood that eligible studies will be identified by means other than the database searches.

Development of a Phase Separation Strategy in Macrocyclization Reactions

La réaction de macrocyclisation est une transformation fondamentale en chimie organique de synthèse. Le principal défi associcé à la formation de macrocycles est la compétition inhérente avec la réaction d’oligomérisation qui mène à la formation de sousproduits indésirables. De plus, l’utilisation de conditions de dilutions élevées qui sont nécessaires afin d’obtenir une cyclisation “sélective”, sont souvent décourageantes pour les applications à l’échelle industrielle. Malgré cet intérêt pour les macrocycles, la recherche visant à développer des stratégies environnementalement bénignes, qui permettent d’utiliser des concentrations normales pour leur synthèse, sont encore rares. Cette thèse décrit le développement d’une nouvelle approche générale visant à améliorer l’efficacité des réactions de macrocyclisation en utilisant le contrôle des effets de dilution. Une stratégie de “séparation de phase” qui permet de réaliser des réactions à des concentrations plus élevées a été developpée. Elle se base sur un mélange de solvant aggrégé contrôlé par les propriétés du poly(éthylène glycol) (PEG). Des études de tension de surface, spectroscopie UV et tagging chimique ont été réalisées afin d’élucider le mécanisme de “séparation de phase”. Il est proposé que celui-ci fonctionne par diffusion lente du substrat organique vers la phase ou le catalyseur est actif. La nature du polymère co-solvant joue donc un rôle crutial dans le contrôle de l’aggrégation et de la catalyse La stratégie de “séparation de phase” a initiallement été étudiée en utilisant le couplage oxidatif d’alcynes de type Glaser-Hay co-catalysé par un complexe de cuivre et de nickel puis a été transposée à la chimie en flux continu. Elle fut ensuite appliquée à la cycloaddition d’alcynes et d’azotures catalysée par un complexe de cuivre en “batch” ainsi qu’en flux continu.

Exploring the relationship between listening development and strategy use

This paper reports on an investigation into the development of the listening proficiency and strategic behaviour of 15 lower-intermediate learners of French in England. We consider whether listeners remain in the same listening proficiency group after six months, and whether changes in strategy use are related to movement or non-movement between listening proficiency groups. We also examine whether learners’ strategic behaviour reflects their teachers’ approaches to listening. Data were gathered at two time points from a recall protocol which learners completed after listening to short passages and from verbal reports made by learners while they completed a multiple choice listening task. Teacher interviews provided information on how listening had been presented in learners' classrooms. We detected little movement by students across the listening proficiency groups between the two time points. In spite of some changes in frequency of strategy use, we also observed stability in manner of use by some learners. Differences in strategy use were more evident between groups (non-movers, improvers and decliners) than between uses from Time 1 to Time 2. We conclude by discussing the pedagogical implications of these findings.