Subunit composition of VRAC channels determines substrate specificity and cellular resistance to Pt-based anti-cancer drugs

Although platinum-based drugs are widely used chemotherapeutics for cancer treatment, the determinants of tumor cell responsiveness remain poorly understood. We show that the loss of subunits LRRC8A and LRRC8D of the heteromeric LRRC8 volume-regulated anion channels (VRACs) increased resistance to clinically relevant cisplatin/carboplatin concentrations. Under isotonic conditions, about 50% of cisplatin uptake depended on LRRC8A and LRRC8D, but neither on LRRC8C nor on LRRC8E. Cell swelling strongly enhanced LRRC8-dependent cisplatin uptake, bolstering the notion that cisplatin enters cells through VRAC. LRRC8A disruption also suppressed drug-induced apoptosis independently from drug uptake, possibly by impairing VRAC-dependent apoptotic cell volume decrease. Hence, by mediating cisplatin uptake and facilitating apoptosis, VRAC plays a dual role in the cellular drug response. Incorporation of the LRRC8D subunit into VRAC substantially increased its permeability for cisplatin and the cellular osmolyte taurine, indicating that LRRC8 proteins form the channel pore. Our work suggests that LRRC8D-containing VRACs are crucial for cell volume regulation by an important organic osmolyte and may influence cisplatin/carboplatin responsiveness of tumors.

Blocking the epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition pathway abrogates resistance to anti-folate chemotherapy in lung cancer.

Anticancer therapies currently used in the clinic often can neither eradicate the tumor nor prevent disease recurrence due to tumor resistance. In this study, we showed that chemoresistance to pemetrexed, a multi-target anti-folate (MTA) chemotherapeutic agent for non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC), is associated with a stem cell-like phenotype characterized by an enriched stem cell gene signature, augmented aldehyde dehydrogenase activity and greater clonogenic potential. Mechanistically, chemoresistance to MTA requires activation of epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition (EMT) pathway in that an experimentally induced EMT per se promotes chemoresistance in NSCLC and inhibition of EMT signaling by kaempferol renders the otherwise chemoresistant cancer cells susceptible to MTA. Relevant to the clinical setting, human primary NSCLC cells with an elevated EMT signaling feature a significantly enhanced potential to resist MTA, whereas concomitant administration of kaempferol abrogates MTA chemoresistance, regardless of whether it is due to an intrinsic or induced activation of the EMT pathway. Collectively, our findings reveal that a bona fide activation of EMT pathway is required and sufficient for chemoresistance to MTA and that kaempferol potently regresses this chemotherapy refractory phenotype, highlighting the potential of EMT pathway inhibition to enhance chemotherapeutic response of lung cancer.

Galactofuranose in Mycoplasma mycoides is important for membrane integrity and conceals adhesins but does not contribute to serum resistance.

Mycoplasma mycoides subsp. capri (Mmc) and subsp. mycoides (Mmm) are important ruminant pathogens worldwide causing diseases such as pleuropneumonia, mastitis and septicaemia. They express galactofuranose residues on their surface, but their role in pathogenesis has not yet been determined. The M. mycoides genomes contain up to several copies of the glf gene, which encodes an enzyme catalysing the last step in the synthesis of galactofuranose. We generated a deletion of the glf gene in a strain of Mmc using genome transplantation and tandem repeat endonuclease coupled cleavage (TREC) with yeast as an intermediary host for the genome editing. As expected, the resulting YCp1.1-Δglf strain did not produce the galactofuranose-containing glycans as shown by immunoblots and immuno-electronmicroscopy employing a galactofuranose specific monoclonal antibody. The mutant lacking galactofuranose exhibited a decreased growth rate and a significantly enhanced adhesion to small ruminant cells. The mutant was also 'leaking' as revealed by a β-galactosidase-based assay employing a membrane impermeable substrate. These findings indicate that galactofuranose-containing polysaccharides conceal adhesins and are important for membrane integrity. Unexpectedly, the mutant strain showed increased serum resistance.

Sphingosine kinase 2 deficient mice exhibit reduced experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis: Resistance to FTY720 but not ST-968 treatments

The immunomodulatory drug FTY720 is presently approved for the treatment of relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis. It is a prodrug that requires activation by sphingosine kinase 2 (SK-2) to induce T cell homing to secondary lymphoid tissue. In this study, we have investigated the role of SK-2 in experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) in C57BL/6 mice. We show that SK-2 deficiency reduced clinical symptoms of EAE. Furthermore, in SK-2-deficient mice, the protective effect of FTY720 on EAE was abolished, while the non-prodrug FTY720-derivative ST-968 was still fully active. Protection was paralleled by reduced numbers of T-lymphocytes in blood and a reduced blood-brain-barrier leakage. This correlated with reduced mRNA expression of ICAM-1, VCAM-1, but enhanced expression of PECAM-1. A similar regulation of permeability and of PECAM-1 was seen in primary cultures of isolated mouse brain vascular endothelial cells and in a human immortalized cell line upon SK-2 knockdown. In summary, these data demonstrated that deletion of SK-2 exerts a protective effect on the pathogenesis of EAE in C57BL/6 mice and that SK-2 is essential for the protective effect of FTY720 but not of ST-968. Thus, ST-968 is a promising novel immunomodulatory compound that may be a valuable alternative to FTY720 under conditions where SK-2 activity is limited.

Functional differences of beta-tubulin isotypes: A study of microtubule assembly and antimitotic drug resistance

Mammalian cells express 7 β-tubulin isotypes in a tissue specific manner. This has long fueled the speculation that different isotypes carry out different functions. To provide direct evidence for their functional significance, class III, IVa, and VI β-tubulin cDNAs were cloned into a tetracycline regulated expression vector and stably transfected Chinese hamster ovary cell lines expressing different levels of ectopic β-tubulin were compared for effects on microtubule organization, microtubule assembly and sensitivity to antimitotic drugs. It was found that all three isotypes coassembled with endogenous β-tubulin. βVI expression caused distinct microtubule rearrangements including microtubule dissociation from the centrosome and accumulation at the cell periphery; whereas expression of βIII and βVIa caused no observable changes in the interphase microtubule network. Overexpression of all 3 isotypes caused spindle malformation and mitotic defects. Both βIII and βIVa disrupted microtubule assembly in proportion to their abundance and thereby conferred supersensitivity to microtubule depolymerizing drugs. In contrast, βVI stabilized microtubules at low stoichiometry and thus conferred resistance to many microtubule destabilizing drugs but not vinblastine. The 3 isotypes caused differing responses to microtubule stabilizing drugs. Expression of βIII conferred paclitaxel resistance while βVI did not. Low expression of βIVa caused supersensitivity to paclitaxel, whereas higher expression resulted in the loss of supersensitivity. The results suggest that βIVa may possess an enhanced ability to bind paclitaxel that increases sensitivity to the drug and acts substoichiometrically. At high levels of βVIa expression, however, microtubule disruptive effects counteract the assembly promoting pressure exerted by increased paclitaxel binding, and drug supersensitivity is lost. From this study, I concluded that β-tubulin isotypes behave differently from each other in terms of microtubule organization, microtubule assembly and dynamics, and antimitotic drug sensitivity. The isotype composition of cell can impart subtle to dramatic effects on the properties of microtubules leading to potential functional consequences and opening the opportunity to exploit differences in microtubule isotype composition for therapeutic gain. ^

Novel Use of Dual Anti-Inflammatory Therapy to Overcome Drug Resistance and Improve Functional Recovery Following Spinal Cord Injury

Over 1.2 million Americans are currently living with a traumatic spinal cord injury (SCI). Despite the need for effective therapies, there are currently no proven effective treatments that can improve recovery of function in SCI patients. Many therapeutic compounds have shown promise in preclinical models of SCI, but all of these have fallen short in clinical trials. P-glycoprotein (Pgp) is an active transporter expressed on capillary endothelial cell membranes at the blood-spinal cord barrier (BSCB). Pgp limits passive diffusion of blood-borne drugs into the CNS, by actively extruding drugs from the endothelial cell membrane. Pgp can become pathologically up-regulated, thus greatly impeding therapeutic drug delivery (‘multidrug resistance’). Importantly, many drugs that have been evaluated for the treatment of SCI are Pgp substrates. We hypothesized that Pgp-mediated drug resistance diminishes the delivery and efficacy of neuroprotective drugs following SCI. We observed a progressive, spatial spread of Pgp overexpression within the injured spinal cord. To assess Pgp function, we examined spinal cord uptake of systemically-delivered riluzole, a drug that is currently being evaluated in clinical trials as an SCI intervention. Blood-to-spinal cord riluzole penetration was reduced following SCI in wild-type but not Pgp-null rats, highlighting a critical role for Pgp in mediating spinal cord drug resistance after injury. Others have shown that pro-inflammatory signaling drives Pgp up-regulation in cancer and epilepsy. We have detected inflammation in both acutely- and chronically-injured spinal cord tissue. We therefore evaluated the ability of the dual COX-/5-LOX inhibitor licofelone to attenuate Pgp-mediated drug resistance following SCI. Licofelone treatment both reduced spinal cord Pgp levels and enhanced spinal cord riluzole bioavailability following SCI. Thus, we propose that licofelone may offer a new combinatorial treatment strategy to enhance spinal cord drug delivery following SCI. Additionally, we assessed the ability of licofelone, riluzole, or both to enhance recovery of locomotor function following SCI. We found that licofelone treatment conferred a significant improvement in hindlimb function that was sustained through the end of the study. In contrast, riluzole did not improve functional outcome. We therefore conclude that licofelone holds promise as a potential neuroprotective intervention for SCI.

Mechanisms of multidrug resistance: Differences between natural and acquired adriamycin -resistant human colon carcinoma cells

Mechanisms of multidrug resistance (MDR) were studied in two independent MDR sublines (AdR1.2 and SRA1.2) derived from the established human colon carcinoma cell line LoVo. AdR1.2 was developed by long-term continuous exposure of the cells to adriamycin (AdR) in stepwise increments of concentration, while SRA1.2 was selected by repetitive pulse treatments with AdR at a single concentration. In this dissertation, the hypothesis that the mechanism of drug resistance in SRA1.2 is different than that in AdR1.2 is tested. While SRA1.2 demonstrated similar biological characteristics when compared to the parental LoVo, AdR1.2 exhibited remarkable alterations in biological properties. The resistance phenotype of AdR1.2 was reversible when the cells were grown in the drug-free medium whereas SRA1.2 maintained its resistance for at least 10 months under similar conditions. Km and Vmax of carrier-mediated facilitated diffusion AdR transport were similar among the three lines. However, both resistant sublines exhibited an energy-dependent drug efflux. AdR1.2 appeared to possess an activated efflux pump, and a decreased nucleus-binding of AdR, whereas SRA1.2 showed merely a lower affinity in binding of AdR to the nuclei. Southern blot analysis showed no amplification of the MDR1 gene in either of the two resistant subclones. However, Western blot analysis using the C219 monoclonal antibody against P170 glycoprotein detected a Mr 150-kDa plasma protein (P150) in AdR1.2 but not in SRA1.2 or in the parental LoVo. In vitro phosphorylation studies revealed that P150 was a phosphoprotein; its phosphorylation was Mg$\sp{2+}$-dependent and could be enhanced by verapamil, an agent capable of increasing intracellular AdR accumulation in AdR1.2 cells. The phosphorylation studies also revealed elevated phosphorylation of a Mr 66-kDa plasma membrane protein that was detectable in the AdR1.2 revertant and in AdR1.2 when verapamil was present, suggesting that hyperphosphorylation of the Mr 66-kDa protein may be related to the reversal of MDR. SDS-PAGE of the plasma membrane protein demonstrated overproduction of a Mr 130-kDa, MDR-related protein in both the resistant sublines. The Mr 130-kDa, MDR-related protein in both the resistant sublines. The Mr 130-kDa protein was not immunoreactive with C219, but its absence in the AdR1.2 revertant and the parental LoVo suggests that it is an MDR-related plasma membrane protein. In conclusion, the results from this study support the author's hypothesis that the mechanisms responsible for "Acquired" and "Natural" MDR are not identical. ^

Pathways leading to apoptosis resistance in a murine B -cell lymphoma cell system

The aberrant activation of signal transduction pathways has long been linked to uncontrolled cell proliferation and the development of cancer. The activity of one such signaling module, the Mitogen-Activated Protein Kinase (MAPK) pathway, has been implicated in several cancer types including pancreatic, breast, colon, and lymphoid malignancies. Interestingly, the activation of MAP-Kinase-Kinase-Kinase proteins often leads to the additional activation of NF-κB, a transcription factor that acts as a cell survival signal through its control of antiapoptotic genes. We have investigated the role of a specific dimer form of the NF-κB transcription factor family, NF-κB1 (p50) homodimers, in its control of the proto-oncogene, Bcl-2, and we have identified the MEK/ERK (MAPK) signaling cascade as a mediator of NF-κB1 activity. ^ Two murine B cell lymphoma cell lines were used for these studies: LY-as, an apoptosis proficient line with low Bcl-2 protein expression and no nuclear NF-κB activity, and LY-ar, a nonapoptotic line with constitutive p50 homodimer activity and 30 times more Bcl-2 protein expression than LY-as. Experiments modulating p50 activity correlated the activation of p50 homodimers with Bcl-2 expression and additional gel shift experiments demonstrated that the Bcl-2 P1 promoter had NF-κB sites with which recombinant p50 was able to interact. In vitro transcription revealed that p50 enhanced the production of transcripts derived from the Bcl-2 P1 promoter. These data strongly suggest that Bcl-2 is a target gene for p50-mediated transcription and suggest that the activation of p50 homodimers contributes to the expression of Bcl-2 observed in LY-ar cells. ^ Studies of upstream MAPK pathways that could influence NF-κB activity demonstrated that LY-ar cells had phosphorylated ERK proteins while LY-as cells did not. Treatment of LY-ar cells with the MEK inhibitors PD 98059, U0126, and PD 184352 led to a loss of phosphorylated ERK, a reversal of nuclear p50 homodimer DNA binding, and a decrease in the amount of Bcl-2 protein expression. Similarly, the activation of the MEK/ERK pathway in LY-as cells by phorbol ester led to Bcl-2 expression that could be blocked by PD 98059. Furthermore, treatment of LY-ar cells with TNFα, an IKK activator, did not change the suppressive effect of PD 98059 on p50 homodimer activity, suggesting an IKK-independent pathway for p50 homodimer activation. Lastly, all three MEK inhibitors sensitized LY-ar cells to radiation-induced apoptosis. ^ These data indicate that the activation of the MEK/ERK MAP-Kinase signaling pathway acts upstream of p50 homodimer activation and Bcl-2 expression in this B cell lymphoma cell system and suggest that the activation of MEK/ERK may be a key step in the progression of lymphoma to advanced-staged disease. Other researchers have used MEK inhibitors to inhibit cell growth and sensitize a number of tumors to chemotherapies. In light of our data, MEK inhibitors may additionally be useful clinically to radiosensitize cancers of lymphoid origin. ^

Arabidopsis heterotrimeric G-protein regulates cell wall defense and resistance to necrotrophic fungi

The Arabidopsis heterotrimeric G-protein controls defense responses to necrotrophic and vascular fungi. The agb1 mutant impaired in the Gβ subunit displays enhanced susceptibility to these pathogens. Gβ/AGB1 forms an obligate dimer with either one of the Arabidopsis Gγ subunits (γ1/AGG1 and γ2/AGG2). Accordingly, we now demonstrate that the agg1 agg2 double mutant is as susceptible as agb1 plants to the necrotrophic fungus Plectosphaerella cucumerina. To elucidate the molecular basis of heterotrimeric G-protein-mediated resistance, we performed a comparative transcriptomic analysis of agb1-1 mutant and wild-type plants upon inoculation with P. cucumerina. This analysis, together with metabolomic studies, demonstrated that G-protein-mediated resistance was independent of defensive pathways required for resistance to necrotrophic fungi, such as the salicylic acid, jasmonic acid, ethylene, abscisic acid, and tryptophan-derived metabolites signaling, as these pathways were not impaired in agb1 and agg1 agg2 mutants. Notably, many mis-regulated genes in agb1 plants were related with cell wall functions, which was also the case in agg1 agg2 mutant. Biochemical analyses and Fourier Transform InfraRed (FTIR) spectroscopy of cell walls from G-protein mutants revealed that the xylose content was lower in agb1 and agg1 agg2 mutants than in wild-type plants, and that mutant walls had similar FTIR spectratypes, which differed from that of wild-type plants. The data presented here suggest a canonical functionality of the Gβ and Gγ1/γ2 subunits in the control of Arabidopsis immune responses and the regulation of cell wall composition.

Disruption of abscisic acid signaling constitutively activates Arabidopsis resistance to the necrotrophic fungus Plectosphaerella cucumerina.

Plant resistance to necrotrophic fungi is regulated by a complex set of signaling pathways that includes those mediated by the hormones salicylic acid (SA), ethylene (ET), jasmonic acid (JA), and abscisic acid (ABA). The role of ABA in plant resistance remains controversial, as positive and negative regulatory functions have been described depending on the plant-pathogen interaction analyzed. Here, we show that ABA signaling negatively regulates Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) resistance to the necrotrophic fungus Plectosphaerella cucumerina. Arabidopsis plants impaired in ABA biosynthesis, such as the aba1-6 mutant, or in ABA signaling, like the quadruple pyr/pyl mutant (pyr1pyl1pyl2pyl4), were more resistant to P. cucumerina than wild-type plants. In contrast, the hab1-1abi1-2abi2-2 mutant impaired in three phosphatases that negatively regulate ABA signaling displayed an enhanced susceptibility phenotype to this fungus. Comparative transcriptomic analyses of aba1-6 and wild-type plants revealed that the ABA pathway negatively regulates defense genes, many of which are controlled by the SA, JA, or ET pathway. In line with these data, we found that aba1-6 resistance to P. cucumerina was partially compromised when the SA, JA, or ET pathway was disrupted in this mutant. Additionally, in the aba1-6 plants, some genes encoding cell wall-related proteins were misregulated. Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy and biochemical analyses of cell walls from aba1-6 and wild-type plants revealed significant differences in their Fourier transform infrared spectratypes and uronic acid and cellulose contents. All these data suggest that ABA signaling has a complex function in Arabidopsis basal resistance, negatively regulating SA/JA/ET-mediated resistance to necrotrophic fungi.

Side-Channel Attack Protection Techniques in FPGA Systems using Enhanced Dual-Rail Solutions

Esta tesis doctoral se centra principalmente en técnicas de ataque y contramedidas relacionadas con ataques de canal lateral (SCA por sus siglas en inglés), que han sido propuestas dentro del campo de investigación académica desde hace 17 años. Las investigaciones relacionadas han experimentado un notable crecimiento en las últimas décadas, mientras que los diseños enfocados en la protección sólida y eficaz contra dichos ataques aún se mantienen como un tema de investigación abierto, en el que se necesitan iniciativas más confiables para la protección de la información persona de empresa y de datos nacionales. El primer uso documentado de codificación secreta se remonta a alrededor de 1700 B.C., cuando los jeroglíficos del antiguo Egipto eran descritos en las inscripciones. La seguridad de la información siempre ha supuesto un factor clave en la transmisión de datos relacionados con inteligencia diplomática o militar. Debido a la evolución rápida de las técnicas modernas de comunicación, soluciones de cifrado se incorporaron por primera vez para garantizar la seguridad, integridad y confidencialidad de los contextos de transmisión a través de cables sin seguridad o medios inalámbricos. Debido a las restricciones de potencia de cálculo antes de la era del ordenador, la técnica de cifrado simple era un método más que suficiente para ocultar la información. Sin embargo, algunas vulnerabilidades algorítmicas pueden ser explotadas para restaurar la regla de codificación sin mucho esfuerzo. Esto ha motivado nuevas investigaciones en el área de la criptografía, con el fin de proteger el sistema de información ante sofisticados algoritmos. Con la invención de los ordenadores se ha acelerado en gran medida la implementación de criptografía segura, que ofrece resistencia eficiente encaminada a obtener mayores capacidades de computación altamente reforzadas. Igualmente, sofisticados cripto-análisis han impulsado las tecnologías de computación. Hoy en día, el mundo de la información ha estado involucrado con el campo de la criptografía, enfocada a proteger cualquier campo a través de diversas soluciones de cifrado. Estos enfoques se han fortalecido debido a la unificación optimizada de teorías matemáticas modernas y prácticas eficaces de hardware, siendo posible su implementación en varias plataformas (microprocesador, ASIC, FPGA, etc.). Las necesidades y requisitos de seguridad en la industria son las principales métricas de conducción en el diseño electrónico, con el objetivo de promover la fabricación de productos de gran alcance sin sacrificar la seguridad de los clientes. Sin embargo, una vulnerabilidad en la implementación práctica encontrada por el Prof. Paul Kocher, et al en 1996 implica que un circuito digital es inherentemente vulnerable a un ataque no convencional, lo cual fue nombrado posteriormente como ataque de canal lateral, debido a su fuente de análisis. Sin embargo, algunas críticas sobre los algoritmos criptográficos teóricamente seguros surgieron casi inmediatamente después de este descubrimiento. En este sentido, los circuitos digitales consisten típicamente en un gran número de celdas lógicas fundamentales (como MOS - Metal Oxide Semiconductor), construido sobre un sustrato de silicio durante la fabricación. La lógica de los circuitos se realiza en función de las innumerables conmutaciones de estas células. Este mecanismo provoca inevitablemente cierta emanación física especial que puede ser medida y correlacionada con el comportamiento interno del circuito. SCA se puede utilizar para revelar datos confidenciales (por ejemplo, la criptografía de claves), analizar la arquitectura lógica, el tiempo e incluso inyectar fallos malintencionados a los circuitos que se implementan en sistemas embebidos, como FPGAs, ASICs, o tarjetas inteligentes. Mediante el uso de la comparación de correlación entre la cantidad de fuga estimada y las fugas medidas de forma real, información confidencial puede ser reconstruida en mucho menos tiempo y computación. Para ser precisos, SCA básicamente cubre una amplia gama de tipos de ataques, como los análisis de consumo de energía y radiación ElectroMagnética (EM). Ambos se basan en análisis estadístico y, por lo tanto, requieren numerosas muestras. Los algoritmos de cifrado no están intrínsecamente preparados para ser resistentes ante SCA. Es por ello que se hace necesario durante la implementación de circuitos integrar medidas que permitan camuflar las fugas a través de "canales laterales". Las medidas contra SCA están evolucionando junto con el desarrollo de nuevas técnicas de ataque, así como la continua mejora de los dispositivos electrónicos. Las características físicas requieren contramedidas sobre la capa física, que generalmente se pueden clasificar en soluciones intrínsecas y extrínsecas. Contramedidas extrínsecas se ejecutan para confundir la fuente de ataque mediante la integración de ruido o mala alineación de la actividad interna. Comparativamente, las contramedidas intrínsecas están integradas en el propio algoritmo, para modificar la aplicación con el fin de minimizar las fugas medibles, o incluso hacer que dichas fugas no puedan ser medibles. Ocultación y Enmascaramiento son dos técnicas típicas incluidas en esta categoría. Concretamente, el enmascaramiento se aplica a nivel algorítmico, para alterar los datos intermedios sensibles con una máscara de manera reversible. A diferencia del enmascaramiento lineal, las operaciones no lineales que ampliamente existen en criptografías modernas son difíciles de enmascarar. Dicho método de ocultación, que ha sido verificado como una solución efectiva, comprende principalmente la codificación en doble carril, que está ideado especialmente para aplanar o eliminar la fuga dependiente de dato en potencia o en EM. En esta tesis doctoral, además de la descripción de las metodologías de ataque, se han dedicado grandes esfuerzos sobre la estructura del prototipo de la lógica propuesta, con el fin de realizar investigaciones enfocadas a la seguridad sobre contramedidas de arquitectura a nivel lógico. Una característica de SCA reside en el formato de las fuentes de fugas. Un típico ataque de canal lateral se refiere al análisis basado en la potencia, donde la capacidad fundamental del transistor MOS y otras capacidades parásitas son las fuentes esenciales de fugas. Por lo tanto, una lógica robusta resistente a SCA debe eliminar o mitigar las fugas de estas micro-unidades, como las puertas lógicas básicas, los puertos I/O y las rutas. Las herramientas EDA proporcionadas por los vendedores manipulan la lógica desde un nivel más alto, en lugar de realizarlo desde el nivel de puerta, donde las fugas de canal lateral se manifiestan. Por lo tanto, las implementaciones clásicas apenas satisfacen estas necesidades e inevitablemente atrofian el prototipo. Por todo ello, la implementación de un esquema de diseño personalizado y flexible ha de ser tomado en cuenta. En esta tesis se presenta el diseño y la implementación de una lógica innovadora para contrarrestar SCA, en la que se abordan 3 aspectos fundamentales: I. Se basa en ocultar la estrategia sobre el circuito en doble carril a nivel de puerta para obtener dinámicamente el equilibrio de las fugas en las capas inferiores; II. Esta lógica explota las características de la arquitectura de las FPGAs, para reducir al mínimo el gasto de recursos en la implementación; III. Se apoya en un conjunto de herramientas asistentes personalizadas, incorporadas al flujo genérico de diseño sobre FPGAs, con el fin de manipular los circuitos de forma automática. El kit de herramientas de diseño automático es compatible con la lógica de doble carril propuesta, para facilitar la aplicación práctica sobre la familia de FPGA del fabricante Xilinx. En este sentido, la metodología y las herramientas son flexibles para ser extendido a una amplia gama de aplicaciones en las que se desean obtener restricciones mucho más rígidas y sofisticadas a nivel de puerta o rutado. En esta tesis se realiza un gran esfuerzo para facilitar el proceso de implementación y reparación de lógica de doble carril genérica. La viabilidad de las soluciones propuestas es validada mediante la selección de algoritmos criptográficos ampliamente utilizados, y su evaluación exhaustiva en comparación con soluciones anteriores. Todas las propuestas están respaldadas eficazmente a través de ataques experimentales con el fin de validar las ventajas de seguridad del sistema. El presente trabajo de investigación tiene la intención de cerrar la brecha entre las barreras de implementación y la aplicación efectiva de lógica de doble carril. En esencia, a lo largo de esta tesis se describirá un conjunto de herramientas de implementación para FPGAs que se han desarrollado para trabajar junto con el flujo de diseño genérico de las mismas, con el fin de lograr crear de forma innovadora la lógica de doble carril. Un nuevo enfoque en el ámbito de la seguridad en el cifrado se propone para obtener personalización, automatización y flexibilidad en el prototipo de circuito de bajo nivel con granularidad fina. Las principales contribuciones del presente trabajo de investigación se resumen brevemente a continuación: Lógica de Precharge Absorbed-DPL logic: El uso de la conversión de netlist para reservar LUTs libres para ejecutar la señal de precharge y Ex en una lógica DPL. Posicionamiento entrelazado Row-crossed con pares idénticos de rutado en redes de doble carril, lo que ayuda a aumentar la resistencia frente a la medición EM selectiva y mitigar los impactos de las variaciones de proceso. Ejecución personalizada y herramientas de conversión automática para la generación de redes idénticas para la lógica de doble carril propuesta. (a) Para detectar y reparar conflictos en las conexiones; (b) Detectar y reparar las rutas asimétricas. (c) Para ser utilizado en otras lógicas donde se requiere un control estricto de las interconexiones en aplicaciones basadas en Xilinx. Plataforma CPA de pruebas personalizadas para el análisis de EM y potencia, incluyendo la construcción de dicha plataforma, el método de medición y análisis de los ataques. Análisis de tiempos para cuantificar los niveles de seguridad. División de Seguridad en la conversión parcial de un sistema de cifrado complejo para reducir los costes de la protección. Prueba de concepto de un sistema de calefacción auto-adaptativo para mitigar los impactos eléctricos debido a la variación del proceso de silicio de manera dinámica. La presente tesis doctoral se encuentra organizada tal y como se detalla a continuación: En el capítulo 1 se abordan los fundamentos de los ataques de canal lateral, que abarca desde conceptos básicos de teoría de modelos de análisis, además de la implementación de la plataforma y la ejecución de los ataques. En el capítulo 2 se incluyen las estrategias de resistencia SCA contra los ataques de potencia diferencial y de EM. Además de ello, en este capítulo se propone una lógica en doble carril compacta y segura como contribución de gran relevancia, así como también se presentará la transformación lógica basada en un diseño a nivel de puerta. Por otra parte, en el Capítulo 3 se abordan los desafíos relacionados con la implementación de lógica en doble carril genérica. Así mismo, se describirá un flujo de diseño personalizado para resolver los problemas de aplicación junto con una herramienta de desarrollo automático de aplicaciones propuesta, para mitigar las barreras de diseño y facilitar los procesos. En el capítulo 4 se describe de forma detallada la elaboración e implementación de las herramientas propuestas. Por otra parte, la verificación y validaciones de seguridad de la lógica propuesta, así como un sofisticado experimento de verificación de la seguridad del rutado, se describen en el capítulo 5. Por último, un resumen de las conclusiones de la tesis y las perspectivas como líneas futuras se incluyen en el capítulo 6. Con el fin de profundizar en el contenido de la tesis doctoral, cada capítulo se describe de forma más detallada a continuación: En el capítulo 1 se introduce plataforma de implementación hardware además las teorías básicas de ataque de canal lateral, y contiene principalmente: (a) La arquitectura genérica y las características de la FPGA a utilizar, en particular la Xilinx Virtex-5; (b) El algoritmo de cifrado seleccionado (un módulo comercial Advanced Encryption Standard (AES)); (c) Los elementos esenciales de los métodos de canal lateral, que permiten revelar las fugas de disipación correlacionadas con los comportamientos internos; y el método para recuperar esta relación entre las fluctuaciones físicas en los rastros de canal lateral y los datos internos procesados; (d) Las configuraciones de las plataformas de pruebas de potencia / EM abarcadas dentro de la presente tesis. El contenido de esta tesis se amplia y profundiza a partir del capítulo 2, en el cual se abordan varios aspectos claves. En primer lugar, el principio de protección de la compensación dinámica de la lógica genérica de precarga de doble carril (Dual-rail Precharge Logic-DPL) se explica mediante la descripción de los elementos compensados a nivel de puerta. En segundo lugar, la lógica PA-DPL es propuesta como aportación original, detallando el protocolo de la lógica y un caso de aplicación. En tercer lugar, dos flujos de diseño personalizados se muestran para realizar la conversión de doble carril. Junto con ello, se aclaran las definiciones técnicas relacionadas con la manipulación por encima de la netlist a nivel de LUT. Finalmente, una breve discusión sobre el proceso global se aborda en la parte final del capítulo. El Capítulo 3 estudia los principales retos durante la implementación de DPLs en FPGAs. El nivel de seguridad de las soluciones de resistencia a SCA encontradas en el estado del arte se ha degenerado debido a las barreras de implantación a través de herramientas EDA convencionales. En el escenario de la arquitectura FPGA estudiada, se discuten los problemas de los formatos de doble carril, impactos parásitos, sesgo tecnológico y la viabilidad de implementación. De acuerdo con estas elaboraciones, se plantean dos problemas: Cómo implementar la lógica propuesta sin penalizar los niveles de seguridad, y cómo manipular un gran número de celdas y automatizar el proceso. El PA-DPL propuesto en el capítulo 2 se valida con una serie de iniciativas, desde características estructurales como doble carril entrelazado o redes de rutado clonadas, hasta los métodos de aplicación tales como las herramientas de personalización y automatización de EDA. Por otra parte, un sistema de calefacción auto-adaptativo es representado y aplicado a una lógica de doble núcleo, con el fin de ajustar alternativamente la temperatura local para equilibrar los impactos negativos de la variación del proceso durante la operación en tiempo real. El capítulo 4 se centra en los detalles de la implementación del kit de herramientas. Desarrollado sobre una API third-party, el kit de herramientas personalizado es capaz de manipular los elementos de la lógica de circuito post P&R ncd (una versión binaria ilegible del xdl) convertido al formato XDL Xilinx. El mecanismo y razón de ser del conjunto de instrumentos propuestos son cuidadosamente descritos, que cubre la detección de enrutamiento y los enfoques para la reparación. El conjunto de herramientas desarrollado tiene como objetivo lograr redes de enrutamiento estrictamente idénticos para la lógica de doble carril, tanto para posicionamiento separado como para el entrelazado. Este capítulo particularmente especifica las bases técnicas para apoyar las implementaciones en los dispositivos de Xilinx y su flexibilidad para ser utilizado sobre otras aplicaciones. El capítulo 5 se enfoca en la aplicación de los casos de estudio para la validación de los grados de seguridad de la lógica propuesta. Se discuten los problemas técnicos detallados durante la ejecución y algunas nuevas técnicas de implementación. (a) Se discute el impacto en el proceso de posicionamiento de la lógica utilizando el kit de herramientas propuesto. Diferentes esquemas de implementación, tomando en cuenta la optimización global en seguridad y coste, se verifican con los experimentos con el fin de encontrar los planes de posicionamiento y reparación optimizados; (b) las validaciones de seguridad se realizan con los métodos de correlación y análisis de tiempo; (c) Una táctica asintótica se aplica a un núcleo AES sobre BCDL estructurado para validar de forma sofisticada el impacto de enrutamiento sobre métricas de seguridad; (d) Los resultados preliminares utilizando el sistema de calefacción auto-adaptativa sobre la variación del proceso son mostrados; (e) Se introduce una aplicación práctica de las herramientas para un diseño de cifrado completa. Capítulo 6 incluye el resumen general del trabajo presentado dentro de esta tesis doctoral. Por último, una breve perspectiva del trabajo futuro se expone, lo que puede ampliar el potencial de utilización de las contribuciones de esta tesis a un alcance más allá de los dominios de la criptografía en FPGAs. ABSTRACT This PhD thesis mainly concentrates on countermeasure techniques related to the Side Channel Attack (SCA), which has been put forward to academic exploitations since 17 years ago. The related research has seen a remarkable growth in the past decades, while the design of solid and efficient protection still curiously remain as an open research topic where more reliable initiatives are required for personal information privacy, enterprise and national data protections. The earliest documented usage of secret code can be traced back to around 1700 B.C., when the hieroglyphs in ancient Egypt are scribed in inscriptions. Information security always gained serious attention from diplomatic or military intelligence transmission. Due to the rapid evolvement of modern communication technique, crypto solution was first incorporated by electronic signal to ensure the confidentiality, integrity, availability, authenticity and non-repudiation of the transmitted contexts over unsecure cable or wireless channels. Restricted to the computation power before computer era, simple encryption tricks were practically sufficient to conceal information. However, algorithmic vulnerabilities can be excavated to restore the encoding rules with affordable efforts. This fact motivated the development of modern cryptography, aiming at guarding information system by complex and advanced algorithms. The appearance of computers has greatly pushed forward the invention of robust cryptographies, which efficiently offers resistance relying on highly strengthened computing capabilities. Likewise, advanced cryptanalysis has greatly driven the computing technologies in turn. Nowadays, the information world has been involved into a crypto world, protecting any fields by pervasive crypto solutions. These approaches are strong because of the optimized mergence between modern mathematical theories and effective hardware practices, being capable of implement crypto theories into various platforms (microprocessor, ASIC, FPGA, etc). Security needs from industries are actually the major driving metrics in electronic design, aiming at promoting the construction of systems with high performance without sacrificing security. Yet a vulnerability in practical implementation found by Prof. Paul Kocher, et al in 1996 implies that modern digital circuits are inherently vulnerable to an unconventional attack approach, which was named as side-channel attack since then from its analysis source. Critical suspicions to theoretically sound modern crypto algorithms surfaced almost immediately after this discovery. To be specifically, digital circuits typically consist of a great number of essential logic elements (as MOS - Metal Oxide Semiconductor), built upon a silicon substrate during the fabrication. Circuit logic is realized relying on the countless switch actions of these cells. This mechanism inevitably results in featured physical emanation that can be properly measured and correlated with internal circuit behaviors. SCAs can be used to reveal the confidential data (e.g. crypto-key), analyze the logic architecture, timing and even inject malicious faults to the circuits that are implemented in hardware system, like FPGA, ASIC, smart Card. Using various comparison solutions between the predicted leakage quantity and the measured leakage, secrets can be reconstructed at much less expense of time and computation. To be precisely, SCA basically encloses a wide range of attack types, typically as the analyses of power consumption or electromagnetic (EM) radiation. Both of them rely on statistical analyses, and hence require a number of samples. The crypto algorithms are not intrinsically fortified with SCA-resistance. Because of the severity, much attention has to be taken into the implementation so as to assemble countermeasures to camouflage the leakages via "side channels". Countermeasures against SCA are evolving along with the development of attack techniques. The physical characteristics requires countermeasures over physical layer, which can be generally classified into intrinsic and extrinsic vectors. Extrinsic countermeasures are executed to confuse the attacker by integrating noise, misalignment to the intra activities. Comparatively, intrinsic countermeasures are built into the algorithm itself, to modify the implementation for minimizing the measurable leakage, or making them not sensitive any more. Hiding and Masking are two typical techniques in this category. Concretely, masking applies to the algorithmic level, to alter the sensitive intermediate values with a mask in reversible ways. Unlike the linear masking, non-linear operations that widely exist in modern cryptographies are difficult to be masked. Approved to be an effective counter solution, hiding method mainly mentions dual-rail logic, which is specially devised for flattening or removing the data-dependent leakage in power or EM signatures. In this thesis, apart from the context describing the attack methodologies, efforts have also been dedicated to logic prototype, to mount extensive security investigations to countermeasures on logic-level. A characteristic of SCA resides on the format of leak sources. Typical side-channel attack concerns the power based analysis, where the fundamental capacitance from MOS transistors and other parasitic capacitances are the essential leak sources. Hence, a robust SCA-resistant logic must eliminate or mitigate the leakages from these micro units, such as basic logic gates, I/O ports and routings. The vendor provided EDA tools manipulate the logic from a higher behavioral-level, rather than the lower gate-level where side-channel leakage is generated. So, the classical implementations barely satisfy these needs and inevitably stunt the prototype. In this case, a customized and flexible design scheme is appealing to be devised. This thesis profiles an innovative logic style to counter SCA, which mainly addresses three major aspects: I. The proposed logic is based on the hiding strategy over gate-level dual-rail style to dynamically overbalance side-channel leakage from lower circuit layer; II. This logic exploits architectural features of modern FPGAs, to minimize the implementation expenses; III. It is supported by a set of assistant custom tools, incorporated by the generic FPGA design flow, to have circuit manipulations in an automatic manner. The automatic design toolkit supports the proposed dual-rail logic, facilitating the practical implementation on Xilinx FPGA families. While the methodologies and the tools are flexible to be expanded to a wide range of applications where rigid and sophisticated gate- or routing- constraints are desired. In this thesis a great effort is done to streamline the implementation workflow of generic dual-rail logic. The feasibility of the proposed solutions is validated by selected and widely used crypto algorithm, for thorough and fair evaluation w.r.t. prior solutions. All the proposals are effectively verified by security experiments. The presented research work attempts to solve the implementation troubles. The essence that will be formalized along this thesis is that a customized execution toolkit for modern FPGA systems is developed to work together with the generic FPGA design flow for creating innovative dual-rail logic. A method in crypto security area is constructed to obtain customization, automation and flexibility in low-level circuit prototype with fine-granularity in intractable routings. Main contributions of the presented work are summarized next: Precharge Absorbed-DPL logic: Using the netlist conversion to reserve free LUT inputs to execute the Precharge and Ex signal in a dual-rail logic style. A row-crossed interleaved placement method with identical routing pairs in dual-rail networks, which helps to increase the resistance against selective EM measurement and mitigate the impacts from process variations. Customized execution and automatic transformation tools for producing identical networks for the proposed dual-rail logic. (a) To detect and repair the conflict nets; (b) To detect and repair the asymmetric nets. (c) To be used in other logics where strict network control is required in Xilinx scenario. Customized correlation analysis testbed for EM and power attacks, including the platform construction, measurement method and attack analysis. A timing analysis based method for quantifying the security grades. A methodology of security partitions of complex crypto systems for reducing the protection cost. A proof-of-concept self-adaptive heating system to mitigate electrical impacts over process variations in dynamic dual-rail compensation manner. The thesis chapters are organized as follows: Chapter 1 discusses the side-channel attack fundamentals, which covers from theoretic basics to analysis models, and further to platform setup and attack execution. Chapter 2 centers to SCA-resistant strategies against generic power and EM attacks. In this chapter, a major contribution, a compact and secure dual-rail logic style, will be originally proposed. The logic transformation based on bottom-layer design will be presented. Chapter 3 is scheduled to elaborate the implementation challenges of generic dual-rail styles. A customized design flow to solve the implementation problems will be described along with a self-developed automatic implementation toolkit, for mitigating the design barriers and facilitating the processes. Chapter 4 will originally elaborate the tool specifics and construction details. The implementation case studies and security validations for the proposed logic style, as well as a sophisticated routing verification experiment, will be described in Chapter 5. Finally, a summary of thesis conclusions and perspectives for future work are included in Chapter 5. To better exhibit the thesis contents, each chapter is further described next: Chapter 1 provides the introduction of hardware implementation testbed and side-channel attack fundamentals, and mainly contains: (a) The FPGA generic architecture and device features, particularly of Virtex-5 FPGA; (b) The selected crypto algorithm - a commercially and extensively used Advanced Encryption Standard (AES) module - is detailed; (c) The essentials of Side-Channel methods are profiled. It reveals the correlated dissipation leakage to the internal behaviors, and the method to recover this relationship between the physical fluctuations in side-channel traces and the intra processed data; (d) The setups of the power/EM testing platforms enclosed inside the thesis work are given. The content of this thesis is expanded and deepened from chapter 2, which is divided into several aspects. First, the protection principle of dynamic compensation of the generic dual-rail precharge logic is explained by describing the compensated gate-level elements. Second, the novel DPL is originally proposed by detailing the logic protocol and an implementation case study. Third, a couple of custom workflows are shown next for realizing the rail conversion. Meanwhile, the technical definitions that are about to be manipulated above LUT-level netlist are clarified. A brief discussion about the batched process is given in the final part. Chapter 3 studies the implementation challenges of DPLs in FPGAs. The security level of state-of-the-art SCA-resistant solutions are decreased due to the implementation barriers using conventional EDA tools. In the studied FPGA scenario, problems are discussed from dual-rail format, parasitic impact, technological bias and implementation feasibility. According to these elaborations, two problems arise: How to implement the proposed logic without crippling the security level; and How to manipulate a large number of cells and automate the transformation. The proposed PA-DPL in chapter 2 is legalized with a series of initiatives, from structures to implementation methods. Furthermore, a self-adaptive heating system is depicted and implemented to a dual-core logic, assumed to alternatively adjust local temperature for balancing the negative impacts from silicon technological biases on real-time. Chapter 4 centers to the toolkit system. Built upon a third-party Application Program Interface (API) library, the customized toolkit is able to manipulate the logic elements from post P&R circuit (an unreadable binary version of the xdl one) converted to Xilinx xdl format. The mechanism and rationale of the proposed toolkit are carefully convoyed, covering the routing detection and repairing approaches. The developed toolkit aims to achieve very strictly identical routing networks for dual-rail logic both for separate and interleaved placement. This chapter particularly specifies the technical essentials to support the implementations in Xilinx devices and the flexibility to be expanded to other applications. Chapter 5 focuses on the implementation of the case studies for validating the security grades of the proposed logic style from the proposed toolkit. Comprehensive implementation techniques are discussed. (a) The placement impacts using the proposed toolkit are discussed. Different execution schemes, considering the global optimization in security and cost, are verified with experiments so as to find the optimized placement and repair schemes; (b) Security validations are realized with correlation, timing methods; (c) A systematic method is applied to a BCDL structured module to validate the routing impact over security metric; (d) The preliminary results using the self-adaptive heating system over process variation is given; (e) A practical implementation of the proposed toolkit to a large design is introduced. Chapter 6 includes the general summary of the complete work presented inside this thesis. Finally, a brief perspective for the future work is drawn which might expand the potential utilization of the thesis contributions to a wider range of implementation domains beyond cryptography on FPGAs.

Optically enhanced photon recycling in mechanically stacked multijunction solar cells

Multijunction solar cells can be fabricated by mechanically bonding together component cells that are grown separately. Here, we present four-junction four-terminal mechanical stacks composed of GaInP/GaAs tandems grown on GaAs substrates and GaInAsP/GaInAs tandems grown on InP substrates. The component cells were bonded together with a low-index transparent epoxy that acts as an angularly selective reflector to the GaAs bandedge luminescence, while simultaneously transmitting nearly all of the subbandgap light. As determined by electroluminescence measurements and optical modeling, the GaAs subcell demonstrates a higher internal radiative limit and, thus, higher subcell voltage, compared with GaAs subcells without the epoxy reflector. The best cells demonstrate 38.8 ± 1.0% efficiency under the global spectrum at 1000 W/m2 and ~ 42% under the direct spectrum at ~100 suns. Eliminating the series resistance is the key challenge for further improving the concentrator cells.

VMAT2 knockout mice: Heterozygotes display reduced amphetamine-conditioned reward, enhanced amphetamine locomotion, and enhanced MPTP toxicity

The brain vesicular monoamine transporter (VMAT2) pumps monoamine neurotransmitters and Parkinsonism-inducing dopamine neurotoxins such as 1-methyl-4-phenyl-phenypyridinium (MPP+) from neuronal cytoplasm into synaptic vesicles, from which amphetamines cause their release. Amphetamines and MPP+ each also act at nonvesicular sites, providing current uncertainties about the contributions of vesicular actions to their in vivo effects. To assess vesicular contributions to amphetamine-induced locomotion, amphetamine-induced reward, and sequestration and resistance to dopaminergic neurotoxins, we have constructed transgenic VMAT2 knockout mice. Heterozygous VMAT2 knockouts are viable into adult life and display VMAT2 levels one-half that of wild-type values, accompanied by smaller changes in monoaminergic markers, heart rate, and blood pressure. Weight gain, fertility, habituation, passive avoidance, and locomotor activities are similar to wild-type littermates. In these heterozygotes, amphetamine produces enhanced locomotion but diminished behavioral reward, as measured by conditioned place preference. Administration of the MPP+ precursor N-methyl-4-phenyl-1,2,3,6-tetrahydropyridine to heterozygotes produces more than twice the dopamine cell losses found in wild-type mice. These mice provide novel information about the contributions of synaptic vesicular actions of monoaminergic drugs and neurotoxins and suggest that intact synaptic vesicle function may contribute more to amphetamine-conditioned reward than to amphetamine-induced locomotion.

p53-dependent regulation of MDR1 gene expression causes selective resistance to chemotherapeutic agents

Loss of functional p53 paradoxically results in either increased or decreased resistance to chemotherapeutic drugs. The inconsistent relationship between p53 status and drug sensitivity may reflect p53’s selective regulation of genes important to cytotoxic response of chemotherapeutic agents. We reasoned that the discrepant effects of p53 on chemotherapeutic cytotoxicity is due to p53-dependent regulation of the multidrug resistance gene (MDR1) expression in tumors that normally express MDR1. To test the hypothesis that wild-type p53 regulates the endogenous mdr1 gene we stably introduced a trans-dominant negative (TDN) p53 into rodent H35 hepatoma cells that express P-glycoprotein (Pgp) and have wild-type p53. Levels of Pgp and mdr1a mRNA were markedly elevated in cells expressing TDN p53 and were linked to impaired p53 function (both transactivation and transrepression) in these cells. Enhanced mdr1a gene expression in the TDN p53 cells was not secondary to mdr1 gene amplification and Pgp was functional as demonstrated by the decreased uptake of vinblastine. Cytotoxicity assays revealed that the TDN p53 cell lines were selectively insensitive to Pgp substrates. Sensitivity was restored by the Pgp inhibitor reserpine, demonstrating that only drug retention was the basis for loss of drug sensitivity. Similar findings were evident in human LS180 colon carcinoma cells engineered to overexpress TDN p53. Therefore, the p53 inactivation seen in cancers likely leads to selective resistance to chemotherapeutic agents because of up-regulation of MDR1 expression.

Overexpression of thioredoxin h leads to enhanced activity of starch debranching enzyme (pullulanase) in barley grain

Biochemically active wheat thioredoxin h has been overexpressed in the endosperm of transgenic barley grain. Two DNA constructs containing the wheat thioredoxin h gene (wtrxh) were used for transformation; each contained wtrxh fused to an endosperm-specific B1-hordein promoter either with or without a signal peptide sequence for targeting to the protein body. Twenty-two stable, independently transformed regenerable lines were obtained by selecting with the herbicide bialaphos to test for the presence of the bar herbicide resistance gene on a cotransformed plasmid; all were positive for this gene. The presence of wtrxh was confirmed in 20 lines by PCR analysis, and the identity and level of expression of wheat thioredoxin h was assessed by immunoblots. Although levels varied among the different transgenic events, wheat thioredoxin h was consistently highly expressed (up to 30-fold) in the transgenic grain. Transgenic lines transformed with the B1-hordein promoter with a signal peptide sequence produced a higher level of wheat thioredoxin h on average than those without a signal sequence. The overexpression of thioredoxin h in the endosperm of germinated grain effected up to a 4-fold increase in the activity of the starch debranching enzyme, pullulanase (limit dextrinase), the enzyme that specifically cleaves α-1,6 linkages in starch. These results raise the question of how thioredoxin h enhances the activity of pullulanase because it was found that the inhibitor had become inactive before the enzyme showed appreciable activity.