The influence of patient and doctor gender on diagnosing coronary heart disease

Using novel methods, this paper explores sources of uncertainty and gender bias in primary care doctors' diagnostic decision-making about coronary heart disease (CHD). Claims about gendered consultation styles and quality of care are re-examined, along with the adequacy of CHD models for women. Randomly selected doctors in the UK and the US (n=112, 56 per country, stratified by gender) were shown standardised videotaped vignettes of actors portraying patients with CHD. Patients' age, gender, ethnicity and social class were varied systematically. During interviews, doctors gave free-recall accounts of their decision-making, which were analysed to determine patient and doctor gender effects. We found differences in male and female doctors' responses to different types of patient information. Female doctors recall more patient cues overall, particularly about history presentation, and particularly amongst women. Male doctors appear less affected by patient gender but both male and especially female doctors take more account of male patients' age, and consider more age-related disease possibilities for men than women. Findings highlight the need for better integration of knowledge about female presentations within accepted CHD risk models, and do not support the contention that women receive better-quality care from female doctors.

Woman doctor with patient

General note: Title and date provided by Bettye Lane.

Home and Ambulatory Blood Pressure to Identify White Coat and Masked Hypertension in the Pediatric Patient

OBJECTIVE To evaluate the effect of the environment and the observer on the measurement of blood pressure (BP) as well as to compare home BP (HBP) and ambulatory BP (ABP) measurements in the diagnosis of white coat hypertension (WCH) and masked hypertension (MH) in children and adolescents with hypertension (HT). METHODS BP of 40 patients with HT (75% of which had secondary HT and were on antihypertensive medication), mean age 12.1 years was evaluated through casual measurements at the clinic and at the HT unit, HBP for 14 days with the OMRON HEM 705 CP monitor (Omron, Tokyo, Japan) and ABP performed with SPACELABS 90207 (Spacelabs, Redmond, WA), for 24 h. RESULTS HT was diagnosed at the doctor`s office by ABP and HBP in 30/40, 27/40, and 31/40 patients, respectively. Based on office BP and ABP, 60% of patients were normotensive, 17.5% HT, 7.5% had WCH, and 15% had MH, whereas based on office BP and HBP 65, 12.5, 10, and 12.5% of patients were classified according to these diagnoses, respectively. There was considerable diagnostic agreement of HT by ABP and HBP (McNemar test, P < 0.01) (kappa = 0.56). CONCLUSION In hypertensive children and adolescents, HBP and ABP present comparable results. HBP appears to be a useful diagnostic test for the detection of MH and WCH in pediatric patients.

Does primary medical practitioner involvement with a specialist team improve patient outcomes? A systematic review.

Patients with chronic or complex medical or psychiatric conditions are treated by many practitioners, including general practitioners (GPs). Formal liaison between primary and specialist is often assumed to offer benefits to patients The aim of this study was to assess the efficacy of formal liaison of GPs with specialist service providers on patient health outcomes, by conducting a systematic review of the published literature in MEDLINE, EMBASE, PsychINFO, CINAHL and Cochrane Library databases using the following search terms family physicians': synonyms of 'patient care planning', 'patient discharge' and 'patient care team'; and synonyms of 'randomised controlled trials'. Seven studies were identified, involving 963 subjects and 899 controls. most health outcomes were unchanged, although some physical and functional health outcomes were improved by formal liaison between GPs and specialist services, particularly among chronic mental illness patients. Some health outcomes worsened during the intervention. Patient retention rates within treatment programmes improved with GP involvement, as did patient satisfaction. Doctor (GP and specialist) behaviour changed, with reports of more rational use of resources and diagnostic tests, improved clinical skills, more frequent use of appropriate treatment strategies, and more frequent clinical behaviours designed to detect disease complications Cost effectiveness could not be determined. In conclusion, formal liaison between GPs and specialist services leaves most physical health outcomes unchanged, but improves functional outcomes in chronically mentally ill patients. It may confer modest long-term health benefits through improvements in patient concordance with treatment programmes and more effective clinical practice.

Prevalence and factors associated to the epidemic neuropathy in a population assisted by a family doctor in Cuba

With the outbreak of an epidemic neuropathy (EN) of unknown ethiology, a study of the prevalence and factors associated to the disease was carried out in the Zamora community, municipality of Marianao, Havana City. There were 11 patients identified with EN for a prevalence rate of 1.7/100. The major risk group was the one between 45 and 64 years of age, female sex, black skin. In the univaried analysis, a high prevalence ratio (PR) was found linked to beverage intake (PR=5.32 95%; confidence intervals (CI) = 1.2-24.4), frequent drugs intake (PR=6.59; CI=1.8-24.6), consumption of edible of non certified fats (PR=4.48; CI=1.2-16.7) and the smoking habit (PR=3.6; CI=1.1-12.2). More than73/100 (CI= 68.7-78.3) of the people under serologic study were infected with Coxsakie virus A-9 (strain 47) isolated from a patient still under research. It seems there are many factors like linder intake, antecedents of hemorrhagic conjuntivitis, nutritional aspects and others that, with the virus isolated were associated with this epidemiologic situation.

"S'il vous plaît docteur, mettez-moi en arrêt"! Certificats médicaux pour raisons psychologiques ["Doctor please, give me a sick leave"!: medical certificates for psychological reasons].

General practitioners are regularly called to evaluate the psychological work capacity of patients. The implicit motivation behind the explicit reason for requesting a sick leave is linked to the subject's history and the way he transfers it in his professional life. An incapacity to work harbours a variety of challenges for the patient, the physician and their relationship. In order to get a better understanding of all the issues at stake, the doctor should understand the significances that represents the work to the patient and the consequences of a sick leave and its associated transference and countertransference issues.

L'apport du patient simulé dans l'apprentissage de la relation médecin-malade: résultats d'une évaluation préliminaire

Contexte : Les étudiants de 4° année des études de médecine à la faculté de biologie et de médecine de Lausanne bénéficient d'un enseignement des habiletés à la communication médecin-malade, ayant recours à un patient simulé joué par un comédien. But : Évaluer la pertinence de cette méthode active dans l'optique de renforcer cet enseignement dans le curriculum. Méthodes : Un questionnaire demande aux étudiants d'apprécier leurs apprentissages, ainsi que le dispositif d'enseignement. Un autre questionnaire évalue les compétences de l'étudiant qui mène l'entretien par l'étudiant lui-même (étudiant actif), par les étudiants observateurs, par l'enseignant et par le patient simulé. Résultats : Ce dispositif d'enseignement est apprécié des étudiants et permet aux étudiants qui ont mené l'entretien et aux étudiants observateurs d'en tirer un bénéfice. Les étudiants actifs ont tendance à évaluer leurs compétences d'entretien plus négativement que ne le font l'enseignant, le comédien et les étudiants observateurs .Conclusion : Ce dispositif d'enseignement est perçu comme pertinent par l'ensemble des participants, mais devrait être renforcé pour donner à chaque étudiant l'occasion de participer activement à l'entrevue simulée. -- Context: 4th year medicine students at the Faculty of Biology and Medicine of Lausanne were taught to develop patient-doctor communication skills, using a simulated patient played by an actor. Objective: To assess the relevance of this active method in the perspective of reinforcing this teaching approach in the curriculum. Method: This new form of teaching was assessed by questionnaires filled by all participants, i.e. students involved in the communication (active student), students who were bystanders (observer students), the tutor, as well as the actor. Results: This teaching approach was appreciated from all students, active and observer, allowing them to gain benefit from the interview on communication skills acquirement. The active students assessed their communication skills more negatively than did the teacher, the actor and the observer students. Conclusion: This teaching method seems to be relevant for all participants and should be reinforced to give the opportunity for each student to participate as an active student.

Science, practice and patient needs: the work of the Plinius Maior Society.

The Plinius Maior Society is a European multinational, multidisciplinary group of clinicians and researchers in the alcoholism field, which strives for a comprehensive care concept in the management of alcoholism and alcohol-related problems. The Society, using evidence-based medicine, has developed a set of protocols, in the forms of guidelines, flow-charts, leaflets and booklets, for use as tools in research on and treatment of alcohol dependence, with a view to standardize clinical research procedures and to bridge the gap between the alcoholism researcher, practitioner and patient. These protocols or tools have been subjected to a review process during their preparation, and further comments on their validity will be integrated in their updates. Seven protocols have so far been developed, two of which, 'Guidelines on Evaluation of Treatment of Alcohol Dependence' and 'Detection and Management of Patients with Psychiatric and Alcohol Use Disorders', are aimed at the clinical researcher and specialists, whereas three others [in the form of decision trees (flow-charts)] are aimed at the general practitioner and other primary health care providers. These are entitled 'Alcohol Risk Assessment and Intervention in Primary Care', 'Withdrawal from Alcohol at Home' and 'Brief Intervention in Patients with Alcohol-Related Problems'. The remaining two tools are booklets aimed at the patient, one to support initiatives for detection of drinking problems and primary intervention, namely 'Do you have this Problem? Discuss it with your Doctor!', and the other to assist the patient in relapse prevention after the early stages of treatment, namely 'On the Way to Recovery'. The protocols for the general practitioners and patients have so far been produced in seven European languages, and, as with the Guidelines, feedback from target users will be collected and incorporated in future updates. The Society continually seeks to consider areas of clinical importance for its work and, as it enters the new millennium, it hopes to address and make a significant contribution to the most pressing problem in the management of alcohol dependence, namely relapse.

Docteur, j'ai un ganglion [Doctor, I have a lymph node]

To investigate a recently developed lymphadenopathy can be simple or complex. The medical history, presence or not of symptoms, the general physical examination, and the localization and characteristics of the adenopathy, most often lead to a diagnosis and therapy when indicated. Among young adults, the etiology is either infectious or reactive, rarely tumoral, as opposed to elderly persons. The most important step is to look at signs of severity (or non banality) such as an increased size, hard consistency, supra-clavicular location, an immunocompromised host, a history of Tb exposition. If present, these signs will trigger a biopsy with cyto- or histopathological examination mostly to rule out a malignant tumor. This article reviews the practical steps of an investigation of an isolated adenopathy in an adult patient.

Dépistage du cancer de la prostate: partager avec le patient les incertitudes [Sharing uncertainties of prostate cancer screening].

The decision of whether our patients should undergo prostate cancer screening with the prostate specifc antigen (PSA) test remains daunting. The role of the primary care doctor is to help men decide between a potential decrease in mortality from a slow evolving but sometimes lethal cancer, and the risk of diagnosing and treating cancers that would have otherwise been indolent and asymptomatic. We can structure our discussions with three steps: choice, option, and decision making. A decision aid, such as the one that we have adapted and simplifed from the Collège des médecins du Québec, can help with this complex decision.

Les modifications de la relation médecin/patient au contact de la télématique médicale: quelques réflexions à battons rompus

La relation entre un médecin et son patient a grandement évolué. Aujourd’hui le médecin, loin de jouer le rôle paternaliste d’autrefois, se voit obligé d’établir un dialogue avec son patient. Des informations sont transmises de l’un à l’autre et de l’autre à l’un, le tout dans une optique de cogestion de la santé du patient. D’un côté le patient doit fournir au médecin les informations suffisantes pour que celui-ci établisse un diagnostic. D’un autre côté le médecin doit informer le patient de son état de santé et des mesures qu’il compte prendre. Dans la foulée du développement des nouvelles technologies, les modes de transmission de telles informations présentent de nouvelles problématiques. L’auteur propose ici une étude de la relation patient/médecin lorsqu’il s’agit de la transmission de données relatives à l’état de santé par Internet ou un réseau privé et du rôle de chacune des parties dans ce réseau en regard de la Directive 95/46/CE. Il ressort de cette étude que le médecin se voit imposer certaines responsabilités à titre de responsable du traitement, notamment en ce qui concerne le traitement des données personnelles de son patient. Ce dernier, en tant que personne concernée au sens de la Directive, se voit donc octroyer des droits fondamentaux en matière de confidentialité. De plus il détermine, en collaboration avec le médecin, les finalités du traitement de ces données personnelles.

La sous-traitance des données du patient au regard de la Directive 95/46

La gestion des données du patient occupe une place significative dans la pratique de l’art de guérir. Il arrive fréquemment que des personnes participent à la production ou à la gestion des données du patient alors que, praticiens de la santé ou non, elles ne travaillent pas sous l’autorité ou la direction du praticien ou de l’équipe en charge du patient. Au regard de la directive 95/46/CE relative à la protection des personnes physiques à l’égard du traitement des données à caractère personnel, ces tiers revêtent la qualité de sous–traitant lorsqu’ils traitent des données pour compte du responsable du traitement de données. Ce dernier doit choisir un sous–traitant qui apporte des garanties suffisantes au regard des mesures de sécurité technique et d’organisation relatives aux traitements à effectuer, et il doit veiller au respect de ces mesures. L’existence de labels de sécurité pourrait faciliter le choix du sous–traitant. S’agissant de données très sensibles comme les données génétiques, il serait opportun d’envisager un contrôle préalable par l’autorité de contrôle ou par un détaché à la protection des données. Il demeure alors à déterminer le véritable responsable du traitement des données du patient, ce qui dépend fortement du poids socialement reconnu et attribué aux différents acteurs de la relation thérapeutique.

The benefits of providing benefit information in a patient information leaflet

Objective: To examine the effects of providing two different types of written information about medicine benefits in a patient information leaflet (PIL). Setting: Participants were 358 adult volunteers from the general population recruited from a London railway station and central Reading. Method: The study used a controlled empirical methodology in which people were given a hypothetical, but realistic, scenario about visiting their doctor and being prescribed medication. They then read an information leaflet about the medicine that contained neither, one, or both benefit statements, and finally completed a number of Likert rating scales. Outcome measures included perceived satisfaction and helpfulness of the information, effectiveness and appropriateness of the medicine, benefit and risk to health, and intention to comply. Key findings: Both types of benefit information led to significantly higher ratings on all of the measures taken. Conclusions: Provision of a relatively short ‘benefit’ statement can significantly improve people’s judgements and intention to take a medicine. The findings are important and timely as the European Union is currently considering reviewing their regulations to allow for the inclusion of limited non-promotional benefit information in PILs.

[Abdominal pain in the general doctor's practice]

Abdominal pain is a frequent symptom and in the majority of cases the underlying disease is not life threatening. The general practitioner's first task is to differentiate between inflammatory and other diseases. The patient's history, the clinical examination and laboratory tests form the basis for the differential diagnosis. A sonography is the first additional examination in the vast majority of the cases. Accidentally found gallstones usually do not require surgical intervention. Surgery in asymptomatic patients should be limited to gallbladder polyps and patients with calcifications in their gallbladder wall.