Effect of Mixture Composition on Relative Strength of Highly Flowable Underwater Concrete

Concrete used for underwater repair is often proportioned to spread readily into place and self-consolidate, and to develop high resistance to segregation and water dilution. An investigation was carried out to determine the effect of the dosage of antiwashout admixture, water-cementitious materials ratio (w/cm), and binder composition on the relative residual strength of highly flowable underwater concrete. Two types of antiwashout admixtures were used: a powdered welan gum at 0.07 and 0.15% by mass of binder, and a liquid-based cellulosic admixture employed at a high dosage of 1 to 1.65 L/100 kg of cementitious materials. The w/cms were set at 0.41 and 0.47 to secure adequate performance of underwater concrete for construction and repair. Four binder compositions were used: a Canadian Type 10 cement; a cement with 10% silica fume replacement; a cement with 50% replacement of granulated blast-furnace slag; and a ternary binder containing 6% silica fume and 20% Class F fly ash. Test results indicate that for a given washout mass loss and slump flow consistency, greater relative residual strength can be secured when the dosage of antiwashout admixture is increased, the w/cm is reduced, and a binary binder with 10% silica fume substitution or the ternary binder are employed. Such mixtures can develop relative residual compressive strengths of 85 and 80%, compared to mixtures cast in air, when the value of washout loss is limited to 4 and 6% for mixtures with slump flow values of 450 and 550 mm, respectively.

Effect of Free-Fall Height in Water on Performance of Flowable Concrete

Concrete placed under water should be proportioned to flow readily into place with minimum materials separation. Unlike concrete cast for deep tremie seals, the use of concrete in repairs often necessitates some free fall of the mixture through water. Such placement conditions lead to greater risk of water erosion and segregation, and should be addressed in proportioning highly flowable underwater concrete. This paper evaluates the effect of free-fall height (FFH) of concrete through water on resulting in-place properties. Concrete was cast in blocks measuring 0.54 x 0.44 x 1 m with the initial FFH in water ranging between 0.25 and 0.60 m. In-place compressive and splitting tensile strengths, unit weight, and depth of washed-out and sedimentation materials were determined. In total, 24 highly flowable mixtures with slump flows greater than 500 mm were investigated. The evaluated mixtures were prepared with various hydraulic binders, including conventional Type 10 cement, a binary mixture with 10% of silica fume (SF), and a ternary binder incorporating 20% of fly ash (FA) and 6% of SF. The mixtures were proportioned with water-binder ratios (w/b) ranging between 0.41 and 0.47. Test results show that the increase of FFH of fresh concrete in water can greatly decrease the residual strength and significantly increase the thickness of washed out and sedimentation materials. The incorporation of 10% of SF, or 20% of FA and 6% of SF, and the reduction of the w/b from 0.47 to 0.41 can, however, lead to a significant increase in washout resistance and residual strength. A relationship between residual strength and the coupled factor of free-fall drop of concrete in water and washout resistance is established.