Treatment and seroconversion in a cohort of children suffering from recent chronic Chagas infection in Yoro, Honduras

Between 1999-2002, Médécins Sans Frontières-Spain implemented a project seeking to determine the efficacy and safety of benznidazole in the treatment of recent chronic Chagas disease in a cohort of seropositive children in the Yoro Department, Honduras. A total of 24,471 children were screened for Trypanosoma cruzi IgG antibodies through conventional enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISA) on filter paper. Recombinant ELISA (0.93% seroprevalence) showed 256 initially reactive cases, including 232 confirmed positive cases. Of these, 231 individuals were treated with benznidazole (7.5 mg/kg/day) for 60 days and were followed with a strict weekly medical control and follow-up protocol. At the end of the project, 229 patients were examined by the Honduras Secretariat of Health for post-treatment serological assessments; 88.2% seroconverted after 18 months and 93.9% seroconverted after three years. No differences were found in the seroconversion rates according to age or sex. Most of the side effects of the treatment were minor. These results support the argument that in areas where T. cruzi I is predominant and in areas affected by T. cruzi II, when vector transmission has been interrupted, Chagas disease diagnosis and treatment are feasible, necessary and ethically indisputable.

ELECTROCORTICAL DYNAMICS OF MOTOR INHIBITORY CONTROL WITH AGING

Motor inhibitory control plays a central role in adaptive behaviors during the entire lifespan. Inhibitory motor control refers to the ability to stop all (global) or a part (selective) of a planned or ongoing motor action. Although the neural processing underlying the global inhibitory control has received much attention from cognitive neuroscientists, brain modulations that occur during selective inhibitory motor control remain unknown. The aim of the present thesis is to investigate the spatio-temporal brain processes of selective inhibitory motor control in young and old adults using high-density electroencephalography. In the first part, we focus on early (preparatory period) spatio-temporal brain processes involved in selective and global inhibitory control in young (study I) and old adults (study II) using a modified Go/No-go task. In study I, we distinguished global from selective inhibition in the early attentional stage of inhibitory control and provided neurophysiological evidence in favor of the combination model. In study II, we showed an under-recruitment of neural resources associated with preservation of performance in old adults during selective inhibition, suggesting efficient cerebral and behavioral adaptations to environmental changes. In the second part, we investigate beta oscillations in the late (post-execution period) spatio-temporal brain processes of selective inhibition during a motor Switching task (i.e., tapping movement from bimanual to unimanual) in young (study III) and old adults (study IV). In study III, we identified concomitant beta synchronization related (i) to sensory reafference processes, which enabled the stabilization of the movement that was perturbed after switching, and (ii) to active inhibition processes that prevented movement of the stopping hand. In study IV, we demonstrated a larger beta synchronization in frontal and parietal regions in old adults compared to young adults, suggesting age-related brain modulations in active inhibition processes. Apart from contributing to a basic understanding of the electrocortical dynamics underlying inhibitory motor control, the findings of the present studies contribute to knowledge regarding the further establishment of specific trainings with aging. -- Le contrôle de l'inhibition motrice joue un rôle central dans les adaptations comportementales quel que soit l'âge. L'inhibition motrice se réfère à la capacité à arrêter entièrement (globale) ou en partie (sélective) une action motrice planifiée ou en cours. Bien que les processus neuronaux sous-jacents de l'inhibition globale aient suscité un grand intérêt auprès des neurosciences cognitives, les modulations cérébrales dans le contrôle de l'inhibition motrice sélective sont encore peu connues. Le but de cette thèse est d'étudier les processus cérébraux spatio-temporels du contrôle de l'inhibition motrice sélective chez les adultes jeunes et âgés en utilisant l'électroencéphalogramme à haute densité. Dans la première partie, nous comparons les processus cérébraux spatio-temporels précoces (préparation motrice) de l'inhibition sélective et globale chez des adultes jeunes (étude I) et âgés (étude II) en utilisant une tâche Go/No-go modifiée. Dans l'étude I, nous avons distingué l'inhibition globale et sélective au niveau des processus attentionnels précoces du contrôle de l'inhibition et nous avons apporté des preuves neurophysiologiques de l'existence d'un modèle de combinaison. Dans l'étude II, nous avons montré une sous-activation neuronale associée à un maintien de la performance dans l'inhibition sélective chez les adultes âgés, suggérant des adaptations cérébrales et comportementales aux contraintes environnementales. Dans la seconde partie, nous examinons les processus cérébraux spatio-temporels tardifs (post-exécution motrice) de l'inhibition sélective pendant une tâche de Switching (tapping bimanuel vers un tapping unimanuel) chez des adultes jeunes (étude III) et âgés (étude IV). Dans l'étude III, nous avons distingué des synchronisations beta liées (i) au traitement des réafférences sensorielles permettant de stabiliser le mouvement perturbé après le switching, et (ii) aux processus d'inhibition active afin d'empêcher les mouvements de la main arrêtée. Dans l'étude IV, cette synchronisation beta était plus forte dans les régions frontales et pariétales chez les âgés par rapport aux jeunes adultes suggérant des modulations cérébrales de l'inhibition active avec l'âge. Outre la contribution fondamentale sur la compréhension des dynamiques électrocorticales dans le contrôle de l'inhibition motrice, les résultats de ces études contribuent à développer les connaissances pour la mise en place de programmes d'entraînements adaptés aux personnes âgées.

In vitro and in vivo experimental models for drug screening and development for Chagas disease

Chagas disease, a neglected illness, affects nearly 12-14 million people in endemic areas of Latin America. Although the occurrence of acute cases sharply has declined due to Southern Cone Initiative efforts to control vector transmission, there still remain serious challenges, including the maintenance of sustainable public policies for Chagas disease control and the urgent need for better drugs to treat chagasic patients. Since the introduction of benznidazole and nifurtimox approximately 40 years ago, many natural and synthetic compounds have been assayed against Trypanosoma cruzi, yet only a few compounds have advanced to clinical trials. This reflects, at least in part, the lack of consensus regarding appropriate in vitro and in vivo screening protocols as well as the lack of biomarkers for treating parasitaemia. The development of more effective drugs requires (i) the identification and validation of parasite targets, (ii) compounds to be screened against the targets or the whole parasite and (iii) a panel of minimum standardised procedures to advance leading compounds to clinical trials. This third aim was the topic of the workshop entitled Experimental Models in Drug Screening and Development for Chagas Disease, held in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, on the 25th and 26th of November 2008 by the Fiocruz Program for Research and Technological Development on Chagas Disease and Drugs for Neglected Diseases Initiative. During the meeting, the minimum steps, requirements and decision gates for the determination of the efficacy of novel drugs for T. cruzi control were evaluated by interdisciplinary experts and an in vitro and in vivo flowchart was designed to serve as a general and standardised protocol for screening potential drugs for the treatment of Chagas disease.

On AUV control architecture

This paper surveys control architectures proposed in the literature and describes a control architecture that is being developed for a semi-autonomous underwater vehicle for intervention missions (SAUVIM) at the University of Hawaii. Conceived as hybrid, this architecture has been organized in three layers: planning, control and execution. The mission is planned with a sequence of subgoals. Each subgoal has a related task supervisor responsible for arranging a set of pre-programmed task modules in order to achieve the subgoal. Task modules are the key concept of the architecture. They are the main building blocks and can be dynamically re-arranged by the task supervisor. In our architecture, deliberation takes place at the planning layer while reaction is dealt through the parallel execution of the task modules. Hence, the system presents both a hierarchical and an heterarchical decomposition, being able to show a predictable response while keeping rapid reactivity to the dynamic environment

Parental influences on pathogen resistance in brown trout embryos and effects of outcrossing within a river network.

Phenotypic plasticity can increase tolerance to heterogeneous environments but the elevations and slopes of reaction norms are often population specific. Disruption of locally adapted reaction norms through outcrossing can lower individual viability. Here, we sampled five genetically distinct populations of brown trout (Salmo trutta) from within a river network, crossed them in a full-factorial design, and challenged the embryos with the opportunistic pathogen Pseudomonas fluorescens. By virtue of our design, we were able to disentangle effects of genetic crossing distance from sire and dam effects on early life-history traits. While pathogen infection did not increase mortality, it was associated with delayed hatching of smaller larvae with reduced yolk sac reserves. We found no evidence of a relationship between genetic distance (W, FST) and the expression of early-life history traits. Moreover, hybrids did not differ in phenotypic means or reaction norms in comparison to offspring from within-population crosses. Heritable variation in early life-history traits was found to remain stable across the control and pathogen environments. Our findings show that outcrossing within a rather narrow geographical scale can have neutral effects on F1 hybrid viability at the embryonic stage, i.e. at a stage when environmental and genetic effects on phenotypes are usually large.

Predictive motion control of a mirosot mobile robot

This paper discusses predictive motion control of a MiRoSoT robot. The dynamic model of the robot is deduced by taking into account the whole process - robot, vision, control and transmission systems. Based on the obtained dynamic model, an integrated predictive control algorithm is proposed to position precisely with either stationary or moving obstacle avoidance. This objective is achieved automatically by introducing distant constraints into the open-loop optimization of control inputs. Simulation results demonstrate the feasibility of such control strategy for the deduced dynamic model

Enterovirus 75 and aseptic meningitis, Spain, 2005.

Although most human enterovirus (EV) (genus Enterovirus, family Picornaviridae) infections are asymptomatic, they can cause upper respiratory illness, febrile rash, aseptic meningitis, pleurodynia, encephalitis, acute flaccid paralysis, and neonatal sepsislike disease (1). Most EVs have been implicated in aseptic meningitis, most notably echovirus (E) 30, 9, 6, and 11 and coxsackie B virus (CBV) type 5 (2); other serotypes are less frequently associated with neurologic disease.

Multiple insecticide resistance in Aedes aegypti (Diptera: Culicidae) populations compromises the effectiveness of dengue vector control in French Guiana

In French Guiana, pyrethroids and organophosphates have been used for many years against Aedes aegypti. We aimed to establish both the resistance level of Ae. aegypti and the ultra low volume spray efficacy to provide mosquito control services with practical information to implement vector control and resistance management. Resistance to deltamethrin and fenitrothion was observed. In addition, the profound loss of efficacy of AquaK'othrine® and the moderate loss of efficacy of Paluthion® 500 were recorded. Fenitrothion remained the most effective candidate for spatial application in French Guiana until its removal in December 2010. Further investigation of the mechanism of resistance to deltamethrin demonstrated the involvement of mixed-function oxidases and, to a lesser extent, of carboxylesterases. However, these observations alone cannot explain the level of insecticide resistance we observed during tube and cage tests.

"The 3/3 strategy": a successful multifaceted hospital wide hand hygiene intervention based on WHO and continuous quality improvement methodology.

BACKGROUND Only multifaceted hospital wide interventions have been successful in achieving sustained improvements in hand hygiene (HH) compliance. METHODOLOGY/PRINCIPAL FINDINGS Pre-post intervention study of HH performance at baseline (October 2007-December 2009) and during intervention, which included two phases. Phase 1 (2010) included multimodal WHO approach. Phase 2 (2011) added Continuous Quality Improvement (CQI) tools and was based on: a) Increase of alcohol hand rub (AHR) solution placement (from 0.57 dispensers/bed to 1.56); b) Increase in frequency of audits (three days every three weeks: "3/3 strategy"); c) Implementation of a standardized register form of HH corrective actions; d) Statistical Process Control (SPC) as time series analysis methodology through appropriate control charts. During the intervention period we performed 819 scheduled direct observation audits which provided data from 11,714 HH opportunities. The most remarkable findings were: a) significant improvements in HH compliance with respect to baseline (25% mean increase); b) sustained high level (82%) of HH compliance during intervention; c) significant increase in AHRs consumption over time; c) significant decrease in the rate of healthcare-acquired MRSA; d) small but significant improvements in HH compliance when comparing phase 2 to phase 1 [79.5% (95% CI: 78.2-80.7) vs 84.6% (95% CI:83.8-85.4), p<0.05]; e) successful use of control charts to identify significant negative and positive deviations (special causes) related to the HH compliance process over time ("positive": 90.1% as highest HH compliance coinciding with the "World hygiene day"; and "negative":73.7% as lowest HH compliance coinciding with a statutory lay-off proceeding). CONCLUSIONS/SIGNIFICANCE CQI tools may be a key addition to WHO strategy to maintain a good HH performance over time. In addition, SPC has shown to be a powerful methodology to detect special causes in HH performance (positive and negative) and to help establishing adequate feedback to healthcare workers.

Bodyweight and migration-related differences in motor abilities in preschool children "Ballabeina"

Introduction: Motor abilities in schoolchildren have been decreasing in the last two decades (Bös, 2003, Tomkinson et al., 2003). This may be related to the dramatic increase in overweight and adiposity during the same time period. Children of migrant background are especially affected (Lasserre et al., 2007). But little is known about the relationship between BMI and migration background and motor abilities in preschool children. Methods/Design We carried out a cross-sectional analysis with 665 children (age 5.1 ± 0.6 years; 49.8 % female) of 40 randomly selected kindergarten classes from German and French speaking regions in Switzerland with a high migrant background. We investigated BMI, cardiorespiratory fitness (20 m shuttle run), static (displacement of center of pressure (COP)) and dynamic (balancing forward on a beam) postural control and overall fitness (obstacle course). Results: Of the children, 9.6 % were overweight, 10.5 % were obese (Swiss national percentiles) and 72.8 % were of migrant background (at least one parent born outside of Switzerland). Mean BMI from children of non-migrant background was 15.5 ± 1.1 kg/m2, while migrant children had a mean BMI of 15.8 ± 1.7 kg/m2 (p=0.08). Normal-weight children performed better in cardiorespiratory fitness (3.1 ± 1.4 vs. 2.6 ± 1.1 stages, p<0.001), overall fitness (18.9 ± 4.4 vs. 20.8 ± 4.6 sec, p<0.001) and in dynamic balance (4.9 ± 3.5 vs. 3.8 ± 2.5 steps, p<0.001) compared to overweight and obese children, while the latter had less postural sway (COP: 956 ± 302 vs. 1021 ± 212 mm, p=0.008). There was a clear inverse dose-response relationship between weight status and dynamic motor abilities. There were no significant differences in most tested motor abilities between non-migrant and migrant. The latter performed less well in only one motor test (overall fitness: 20.2 ± 5.2 vs. 18.3 ± 3.5 sec, p<0.001). These findings persisted after adjustment for BMI. Conclusion In preschool children, differences in motor abilities are already present between normal weight and overweight/obese children. However, migrant children demonstrate similar motor abilities compared to non-migrant children for almost all tests, despite their slightly higher BMI.

Vector control intervention towards interruption of transmission of Chagas disease by Rhodnius prolixus, main vector in Guatemala

In Guatemala, the Ministry of Health (MoH) began a vector control project with Japanese cooperation in 2000 to reduce the risk of Chagas disease infection. Rhodnius prolixus is one of the principal vectors and is targeted for elimination. The control method consisted of extensive residual insecticide spraying campaigns, followed by community-based surveillance with selective respraying. Interventions in nine endemic departments identified 317 villages with R. prolixus of 4,417 villages surveyed. Two cycles of residual insecticide spraying covered over 98% of the houses in the identified villages. Fourteen villages reinfestated were all resprayed. Between 2000-2003 and 2008, the number of infested villages decreased from 317 to two and the house infestation rate reduced from 0.86% to 0.0036%. Seroprevalence rates in 2004-2005, when compared with an earlier study in 1998, showed a significant decline from 5.3% to 1.3% among schoolchildren in endemic areas. The total operational cost was US$ 921,815, where the cost ratio between preparatory, attack and surveillance phases was approximately 2:12:1. In 2008, Guatemala was certified for interruption of Chagas disease transmission by R. prolixus. What facilitated the process was existing knowledge in vector control and notable commitment by the MoH, as well as political, managerial and technical support by external stakeholders.

Swiss adolescents' and adults' perceptions of cannabis use : a qualitative study

Abstract Few studies have attempted to investigate the nature of adolescents' and adults' conceptions and perceptions of cannabis use. Our objectives were to explore adolescent and adult perception of use and misuse of cannabis, and their opinions and beliefs about the current legal context and preventive strategies. We used focus group dis¬cussions with four categories of stakeholders: younger (12-15 year old) adolescents, older (16-19 year old) adolescents, parents of teen¬agers and professionals working with young people. In some areas (legal framework, role of the media, importance of early preventive inter¬ventions), we found consensual attitudes and beliefs across the four groups of participants. In all four groups, participants did not have any consensual vision of the risks of cannabis use or the definition of misuse. In the area of the prevention of cannabis use/misuse, while parents focused on the potential role of professionals and the media, thus minimizing their own educa¬tional and preventive role, professionals stressed the importance of parental control and educa¬tion. Within the Swiss context, we conclude there exists an urgent need for information and clari¬fication of the issues linked with cannabis use and misuse directed at parents and professionals.

The roles of PKCδ and Src kinases in the glucocorticoid induction and the TGF-β superinduction of the mouse mammary tumor virus transcription in B lymphocytes

Résumé : Le virus tumoral de la glande mammaire de la souris (MMTV) est un rétrovirus provoquant le développement de tumeurs dans les glandes mammaires des souris susceptibles femelles. Au cours de son évolution, le virus s'est adapté et s'exprime dans des cellules spécialisées. Les lymphocytes B sont les premières cellules infectées et elles sont essentielles pour la propagation de l'infection aux glandes mammaires. Dans notre étude, le virus MMTV a été utilisé afin d'examiner les voies de signalisation induites par les glucocorticoïdes (dexaméthasone (dex), une hormone stéroïdienne) et le transforming growth factor-f3 (TGF-P, une cytokine), deux molécules impliquées dans l'activation de la transcription à partir du promoteur du MMTV dans les cellules B. Le TGF-P seul n'influence pas l'activité du promoteur du MMTV. Par contre, en synergie avec dex, le TGF-P provoque une super-induction de l'expression du promoteur par rapport à une stimulation par le glucocorticoïde seul. Cette super-induction est régulée par une famille de protéines, les Smads. Ainsi, dans les lymphocytes B, l'utilisation du MMTV a permis de mettre en évidence une nouvelle synergie entre les glueocortieoïdes et le TGF-p. pans ce travail, l'utilisation d'inhibiteurs pharmacologiques et de mutants « dominant-négatifs » nous a pet mis de démontrer qu'une Protéine Kinase C delta (PKC5) active est impliquée dans la transduction du signal lors de la réponse au dex ainsi que celle au TGF-P. Néanmoins, la PKC5 est régulée différemment dans chaque voie spécifique : la voie du TGF-p nécessitait l'activation du PKC5 par diacylglycerol (DAG) et la phosphorylation de tyrosines spécifiques, alors que la voie impliquant les glucocorticoïdes ne le nécessitait pas. Nous avons aussi démontré qu'une tyrosine kinase de la famille Src est responsable de la phosphorylation des tyrosines sur la PKC5. Les essais de kinase in vitro nous ont permis de découvrir que plusieurs Src kinases peuvent phosphoryler la PKC6 dans les cellules B et qu'elles étaient constitutivement actives. Enfin, nous avons montré qu'il existe une interaction protéine - protéine induite par dex, entre le récepteur aux glucocorticoïdes (GR) et la PKC5 dans les cellules B, une association qui n'a pas été démontrée auparavant. Par ailleurs, nous avons analysé les domaines d'interactions entre PKC5 et GR en utilisant les essais de «GST pull-down». Nos résultats montrent que le domaine régulateur de la PKC5 et celui qui interagit avec l'ADN du GR sont impliqués. En résumé, nous avons trouvé que dans une lignée lymphocytaire B, le virus MMTV utilise des mécanismes pour réguler à la fois la transcription et la voie de signalisation qui sont différents de ceux utilisés dans les cellules mammaires épithéliales et les fibroblastes. Nos découvertes pourraient être utilisées comme modèles pour l'étude de gènes cellulaires impliqués dans des processus tels qu'inflammation, immunité ou cancérogénèse. Summary: Mouse Mammary Tumor Virus (MMTV) is a retrovirus that causes tumors in the mammary glands of susceptible female mice and has adapted evolutionarily to be expressed in specialized cells. The B lymphocytes are the first cells to be infected by the MMTV and are essential for the spread of infection to the mammary glands. Here, we used the MMTV as a model system to investigate the signalling cascade induced by giucocorticoids (dexamethasone, "dex", a steroid hormone), and by Transforming Growth Factor-beta (TGF-P, a cytokine) leading to its transcriptional activation in B lymphocytes. By itself, TGF-I3 does not affect the basal activity of the MMTV promoter. However, TGF-13 significantly increases glucocorticoid-induced expression, through its effectors, the Smad factors. Thus, MMTV in B cells demonstrates a novel synergism between glucocorticoids and TGF-16. In this thesis project, we present evidence, based on the use of pharmacological inhibitors and of dominant-negative mutants, that an active Protein Kinase C delta (PKC6) is required as a signal transducer for the dex response and for the TGF-P superinduction as well. The PKC6 is differentially regulated in each specific pathway: whereas the TGF-13 superinduction required PKC6 to be activated by diacylglycerol (DAG) and to be phosphorylated at specific tyrosine residues, the glueocorticoid-induced pathway did not. We also showed that a protein tyrosine kinase of the Src family is responsible for the phosphorylation of tyrosines on PKC6. By performing in vitro kinase assays, we found that several Src kinases of B cells were able to phosphorylate PKC6 and that they were constitutively active. Finally, we demonstrate a dex-dependent functional protein-protein interaction between the glucocorticoid receptor (GR) and PKC6 in B cells, an association that has not been previously described. We further analysed the interacting domains of PKG6 and GR using in vitro GST pull-down assays, whereby the regulatory domain of PKC6 and the extended DNA-binding domain of the GR were involved. In summary, we found that in B-lymphoid cell lines, MMTV uses novel mechanisms of transcriptional control and signal transduction that are different from those at work in mammary epithelial or fibroblastic cells. These findings will be used as model for cellular genes involved in cellular processes such as immune functions, inflammation, or oncogenic transformation that may have a similar pattern of regulation.

New structures for goat corrals to control peridomestic populations of Triatoma infestans (Hemiptera: Reduviidae) in the Gran Chaco of Argentina

Goat production is an important economic activity for rural communities in the Gran Chaco of Argentina. Goat corrals are important for the survival of peridomestic populations of Triatoma infestans. This study evaluated the impact of modifying the traditional structure of goat corrals on T. infestans populations and goat productivity in the region of Los Llanos (La Rioja). Thirty-nine experimental corrals were constructed and 57 traditional corrals were used as controls. We evaluated the infestations of the control and experimental corrals for five years following construction of the structures. The results showed that the new structures did not prevent the colonization, although it enhanced the detection of infestation at low densities of T. infestans. No significant difference was found in T. infestans population abundance between control and experimental corrals, probably because of the different detectability in the two types of structures, especially among the small nymphs. Although goat productivity average was higher in experimental than in control corrals, no significant difference was found because of high variability. The new structures can be used as a complement to promote the development of rural communities. Acceptability and adoption of the new corrals by the owners was high, as the enclosures offered better protection for the goats, increased growth of kids and facilitated herd handling.

Colorectal cancer survival in the USA and Europe: a CONCORD high-resolution study.

OBJECTIVES: To assess the extent to which stage at diagnosis and adherence to treatment guidelines may explain the persistent differences in colorectal cancer survival between the USA and Europe. DESIGN: A high-resolution study using detailed clinical data on Dukes' stage, diagnostic procedures, treatment and follow-up, collected directly from medical records by trained abstractors under a single protocol, with standardised quality control and central statistical analysis. SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS: 21 population-based registries in seven US states and nine European countries provided data for random samples comprising 12 523 adults (15-99 years) diagnosed with colorectal cancer during 1996-1998. OUTCOME MEASURES: Logistic regression models were used to compare adherence to 'standard care' in the USA and Europe. Net survival and excess risk of death were estimated with flexible parametric models. RESULTS: The proportion of Dukes' A and B tumours was similar in the USA and Europe, while that of Dukes' C was more frequent in the USA (38% vs 21%) and of Dukes' D more frequent in Europe (22% vs 10%). Resection with curative intent was more frequent in the USA (85% vs 75%). Elderly patients (75-99 years) were 70-90% less likely to receive radiotherapy and chemotherapy. Age-standardised 5-year net survival was similar in the USA (58%) and Northern and Western Europe (54-56%) and lowest in Eastern Europe (42%). The mean excess hazard up to 5 years after diagnosis was highest in Eastern Europe, especially among elderly patients and those with Dukes' D tumours. CONCLUSIONS: The wide differences in colorectal cancer survival between Europe and the USA in the late 1990s are probably attributable to earlier stage and more extensive use of surgery and adjuvant treatment in the USA. Elderly patients with colorectal cancer received surgery, chemotherapy or radiotherapy less often than younger patients, despite evidence that they could also have benefited.