NMR structures of three single-residue variants of the human prion protein

The NMR structures of three single-amino acid variants of the C-terminal domain of the human prion protein, hPrP(121–230), are presented. In hPrP(M166V) and hPrP(R220K) the substitution is with the corresponding residue in murine PrP, and in hPrP(S170N) it is with the corresponding Syrian hamster residue. All three substitutions are in the surface region of the structure of the cellular form of PrP (PrPC) that is formed by the C-terminal part of helix 3, with residues 218–230, and a loop of residues 166–172. This molecular region shows high species variability and has been implicated in specific interactions with a so far not further characterized “protein X,” and it is related to the species barrier for transmission of prion diseases. As expected, the three variant hPrP(121–230) structures have the same global architecture as the previously determined wild-type bovine, human, murine, and Syrian hamster prion proteins, but with the present study two localized “conformational markers” could be related with single amino acid exchanges. These are the length and quality of definition of helix 3, and the NMR-observability of the residues in the loop 166–172. Poor definition of the C-terminal part of helix 3 is characteristic for murine PrP and has now been observed also for hPrP(R220K), and NMR observation of the complete loop 166–172 has so far been unique for Syrian hamster PrP and is now also documented for hPrP(S170N).

Mapping the parameters of prion-induced neuropathology

We present a theoretical framework that enables us to dissect out the parametric dependencies of the pathogenesis of prion diseases. We are able to determine the influence of both host-dependent factors (connectivity, cell density, protein synthesis rate, and cell death) and strain-dependent factors (cell tropism, virulence, and replication rate). We use a model based on a linked system of differential equations on a lattice to explore how the regional distribution of central nervous system pathology in Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease, Gerstmann-Sträussler-Scheinker syndrome, and fatal familial insomnia relates to each of these factors. The model then is used to make qualitative predictions about the pathology for two possible hypothetical triggers of neuronal loss in prion diseases. Pathological progression in overexpressing mouse models has been shown to depend on the site of initial infection. The model allows us to compare the pathologies resulting from different inoculation routes.

A scrapie-like unfolding intermediate of the prion protein domain PrP(121–231) induced by acidic pH

The infectious agent of transmissible spongiform encephalopathies is believed to consist of an oligomeric isoform, PrPSc, of the monomeric cellular prion protein, PrPC. The conversion of PrPC to PrPSc is characterized by a decrease in α-helical structure, an increase in β-sheet content, and the formation of PrPSc amyloid. Whereas the N-terminal part of PrPC comprising residues 23–120 is flexibly disordered, its C-terminal part, PrP(121–231), forms a globular domain with three α-helices and a small β-sheet. Because the segment of residues 90–231 is protease-resistant in PrPSc, it is most likely structured in the PrPSc form. The conformational change of the segment containing residues 90–120 thus constitutes the minimal structural difference between PrPC and a PrPSc monomer. To test whether PrP(121–231) is also capable to undergo conformational transitions, we analyzed its urea-dependent unfolding transitions at neutral and acidic pH. We identified an equilibrium unfolding intermediate of PrP(121–231) that is exclusively populated at acidic pH and shows spectral characteristics of a β-sheet protein. The intermediate is in rapid equilibrium with native PrP(121–231), significantly populated in the absence of urea at pH 4.0, and may have important implications for the presumed formation of PrPSc during endocytosis.

Genetic influence on the structural variations of the abnormal prion protein

Prion diseases are characterized by the presence of the abnormal prion protein PrPSc, which is believed to be generated by the conversion of the α-helical structure that predominates in the normal PrP isoform into a β-sheet structure resistant to proteinase K (PK). In human prion diseases, two major types of PrPSc, type 1 and 2, can be distinguished based on the difference in electrophoretic migration of the PK-resistant core fragment. In this study, protein sequencing was used to identify the PK cleavage sites of PrPSc in 36 cases of prion diseases. We demonstrated two primary cleavage sites at residue 82 and residue 97 for type 1 and type 2 PrPSc, respectively, and numerous secondary cleavages distributed along the region spanning residues 74–102. Accordingly, we identify three regions in PrPSc: one N-terminal (residues 23–73) that is invariably PK-sensitive, one C-terminal (residues 103–231) that is invariably PK-resistant, and a third variable region (residues 74–102) where the site of the PK cleavage, likely reflecting the extent of the β-sheet structure, varies mostly as a function of the PrP genotype at codon 129.

Species-barrier-independent prion replication in apparently resistant species

Transmission of prions between mammalian species is thought to be limited by a “species barrier,” which depends on differences in the primary structure of prion proteins in the infecting inoculum and the host. Here we demonstrate that a strain of hamster prions thought to be nonpathogenic for conventional mice leads to prion replication to high levels in such mice but without causing clinical disease. Prions pathogenic in both mice and hamsters are produced. These results demonstrate the existence of subclinical forms of prion infection with important public health implications, both with respect to iatrogenic transmission from apparently healthy humans and dietary exposure to cattle and other species exposed to bovine spongiform encephalopathy prions. Current definitions of the species barrier, which have been based on clinical end-points, need to be fundamentally reassessed.

Structure of the recombinant full-length hamster prion protein PrP(29–231): The N terminus is highly flexible

The prion diseases seem to be caused by a conformational change of the prion protein (PrP) from the benign cellular form PrPC to the infectious scrapie form PrPSc; thus, detailed information about PrP structure may provide essential insights into the mechanism by which these diseases develop. In this study, the secondary structure of the recombinant Syrian hamster PrP of residues 29–231 [PrP(29–231)] is investigated by multidimensional heteronuclear NMR. Chemical shift index analysis and nuclear Overhauser effect data show that PrP(29–231) contains three helices and possibly one short β-strand. Most striking is the random-coil nature of chemical shifts for residues 30–124 in the full-length PrP. Although the secondary structure elements are similar to those found in mouse PrP fragment PrP(121–231), the secondary structure boundaries of PrP(29–231) are different from those in mouse PrP(121–231) but similar to those found in the structure of Syrian hamster PrP(90–231). Comparison of resonance assignments of PrP(29–231) and PrP(90–231) indicates that there may be transient interactions between the additional residues and the structured core. Backbone dynamics studies done by using the heteronuclear [1H]-15N nuclear Overhauser effect indicate that almost half of PrP(29–231), residues 29–124, is highly flexible. This plastic region could feature in the conversion of PrPC to PrPSc by template-assisted formation of β-structure.

Chaperone-supervised conversion of prion protein to its protease-resistant form

Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSEs) are lethal, infectious disorders of the mammalian nervous system. A TSE hallmark is the conversion of the cellular protein PrPC to disease-associated PrPSc (named for scrapie, the first known TSE). PrPC is protease-sensitive, monomeric, detergent soluble, and primarily α-helical; PrPSc is protease-resistant, polymerized, detergent insoluble, and rich in β-sheet. The “protein-only” hypothesis posits that PrPSc is the infectious TSE agent that directly converts host-encoded PrPC to fresh PrPSc, harming neurons and creating new agents of infection. To gain insight on the conformational transitions of PrP, we tested the ability of several protein chaperones, which supervise the conformational transitions of proteins in diverse ways, to affect conversion of PrPC to its protease-resistant state. None affected conversion in the absence of pre-existing PrPSc. In its presence, only two, GroEL and Hsp104 (heat shock protein 104), significantly affected conversion. Both promoted it, but the reaction characteristics of conversions with the two chaperones were distinct. In contrast, chemical chaperones inhibited conversion. Our findings provide new mechanistic insights into nature of PrP conversions, and provide a new set of tools for studying the process underlying TSE pathogenesis.

The crystal structure of the nitrogen regulation fragment of the yeast prion protein Ure2p

The yeast nonchromosomal gene [URE3] is due to a prion form of the nitrogen regulatory protein Ure2p. It is a negative regulator of nitrogen catabolism and acts by inhibiting the transcription factor Gln3p. Ure2p residues 1–80 are necessary for prion generation and propagation. The C-terminal fragment retains nitrogen regulatory activity, albeit somewhat less efficiently than the full-length protein, and it also lowers the frequency of prion generation. The crystal structure of this C-terminal fragment, Ure2p(97–354), at 2.3 Å resolution is described here. It adopts the same fold as the glutathione S-transferase superfamily, consistent with their sequence similarity. However, Ure2p(97–354) lacks a properly positioned catalytic residue that is required for S-transferase activity. Residues within this regulatory fragment that have been indicated by mutational studies to influence prion generation have been mapped onto the three-dimensional structure, and possible implications for prion activity are discussed.

An amyloid-forming peptide from the yeast prion Sup35 reveals a dehydrated β-sheet structure for amyloid

X-ray diffraction and other biophysical tools reveal features of the atomic structure of an amyloid-like crystal. Sup35, a prion-like protein in yeast, forms fibrillar amyloid assemblies intrinsic to its prion function. We have identified a polar peptide from the N-terminal prion-determining domain of Sup35 that exhibits the amyloid properties of full-length Sup35, including cooperative kinetics of aggregation, fibril formation, binding of the dye Congo red, and the characteristic cross-β x-ray diffraction pattern. Microcrystals of this peptide also share the principal properties of the fibrillar amyloid, including a highly stable, β-sheet-rich structure and the binding of Congo red. The x-ray powder pattern of the microcrystals, extending to 0.9-Å resolution, yields the unit cell dimensions of the well-ordered structure. These dimensions restrict possible atomic models of this amyloid-like structure and demonstrate that it forms packed, parallel-stranded β-sheets. The unusually high density of the crystals shows that the packed β-sheets are dehydrated, despite the polar character of the side chains. These results suggest that amyloid is a highly intermolecularly bonded, dehydrated array of densely packed β-sheets. This dry β-sheet could form as Sup35 partially unfolds to expose the peptide, permitting it to hydrogen-bond to the same peptide of other Sup35 molecules. The implication is that amyloid-forming units may be short segments of proteins, exposed for interactions by partial unfolding.

Pseudoknots in prion protein mRNAs confirmed by comparative sequence analysis and pattern searching

The human prion gene contains five copies of a 24 nt repeat that is highly conserved among species. An analysis of folding free energies of the human prion mRNA, in particular in the repeat region, suggested biased codon selection and the presence of RNA patterns. In particular, pseudoknots, similar to the one predicted by Wills in the human prion mRNA, were identified in the repeat region of all available prion mRNAs available in GenBank, but not those of birds and the red slider turtle. An alignment of these mRNAs, which share low sequence homology, shows several co-variations that maintain the pseudoknot pattern. The presence of pseudoknots in yeast Sup35p and Rnq1 suggests acquisition in the prokaryotic era. Computer generated three-dimensional structures of the human prion pseudoknot highlight protein and RNA interaction domains, which suggest a possible effect in prion protein translation. The role of pseudoknots in prion diseases is discussed as individuals with extra copies of the 24 nt repeat develop the familial form of Creutzfeldt–Jakob disease.

Mapping the early steps in the pH-induced conformational conversion of the prion protein

Under certain conditions, the prion protein (PrP) undergoes a conformational change from the normal cellular isoform, PrPC, to PrPSc, an infectious isoform capable of causing neurodegenerative diseases in many mammals. Conversion can be triggered by low pH, and in vivo this appears to take place in an endocytic pathway and/or caveolae-like domains. It has thus far been impossible to characterize the conformational change at high resolution by experimental methods. Therefore, to investigate the effect of acidic pH on PrP conformation, we have performed 10-ns molecular dynamics simulations of PrPC in water at neutral and low pH. The core of the protein is well maintained at neutral pH. At low pH, however, the protein is more dynamic, and the sheet-like structure increases both by lengthening of the native β-sheet and by addition of a portion of the N terminus to widen the sheet by another two strands. The side chain of Met-129, a polymorphic codon in humans associated with variant Creutzfeldt–Jakob disease, pulls the N terminus into the sheet. Neutralization of Asp-178 at low pH removes interactions that inhibit conversion, which is consistent with the Asp-178–Asn mutation causing human prion diseases.

B lymphocyte-restricted expression of prion protein does not enable prion replication in prion protein knockout mice

Prion replication in spleen and neuroinvasion after i.p. inoculation of mice is impaired in forms of immunodeficiency where mature B lymphocytes are lacking. In spleens of wild-type mice, infectivity is associated with B and T lymphocytes and stroma but not with circulating lymphocytes. We generated transgenic prion protein knockout mice overexpressing prion protein in B lymphocytes and found that they failed to accumulate prions in spleen after i.p. inoculation. We conclude that splenic B lymphocytes are not prion-replication competent and that they acquire prions from other cells, most likely follicular dendritic cells with which they closely associate and whose maturation depends on them.

Ex vivo propagation of infectious sheep scrapie agent in heterologous epithelial cells expressing ovine prion protein

Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies, or prion diseases, are fatal degenerative disorders of the central nervous system that affect humans and animals. Prions are nonconventional infectious agents whose replication depends on the host prion protein (PrP). Transmission of prions to cultured cells has proved to be a particularly difficult task, and with a few exceptions, their experimental propagation relies on inoculation to laboratory animals. Here, we report on the development of a permanent cell line supporting propagation of natural sheep scrapie. This model was obtained by stable expression of a tetracycline-regulatable ovine PrP gene in a rabbit epithelial cell line. After exposure to scrapie agent, cultures were repeatedly found to accumulate high levels of abnormal PrP (PrPres). Cell extracts induced a scrapie-like disease in transgenic mice overexpressing ovine PrP. These cultures remained healthy and stably infected upon subpassaging. Such data show that (i) cultivated cells from a nonneuronal origin can efficiently replicate prions; and (ii) species barrier can be crossed ex vivo through the expression of a relevant PrP gene. This approach led to the ex vivo propagation of a natural transmissible spongiform encephalopathy agent (i.e., without previous experimental adaptation to rodents) and might be applied to human or bovine prions.

A role for intermolecular disulfide bonds in prion diseases?

The key event in prion diseases seems to be the conversion of the prion protein PrP from its normal cellular isoform (PrPC) to an aberrant “scrapie” isoform (PrPSc). Earlier studies have detected no covalent modification in the scrapie isoform and have concluded that the PrPC → PrPSc conversion is a purely conformational transition involving no chemical reactions. However, a reexamination of the available biochemical data suggests that the PrPC → PrPSc conversion also involves a covalent reaction of the (sole) intramolecular disulfide bond of PrPC. Specifically, the data are consistent with the hypothesis that infectious prions are composed of PrPSc polymers linked by intermolecular disulfide bonds. Thus, the PrPC → PrPSc conversion may involve not only a conformational transition but also a thiol/disulfide exchange reaction between the terminal thiolate of such a PrPSc polymer and the disulfide bond of a PrPC monomer. This hypothesis seems to account for several unusual features of prion diseases.

Prion protein: Evolution caught en route

The prion protein displays a unique structural ambiguity in that it can adopt multiple stable conformations under physiological conditions. In our view, this puzzling feature resulted from a sudden environmental change in evolution when the prion, previously an integral membrane protein, got expelled into the extracellular space. Analysis of known vertebrate prions unveils a primordial transmembrane protein encrypted in their sequence, underlying this relocalization hypothesis. Apparently, the time elapsed since this event was insufficient to create a “minimally frustrated” sequence in the new milieu, probably due to the functional constraints set by the importance of the very flexibility that was created in the relocalization. This scenario may explain why, in a structural sense, the prion protein is still en route toward becoming a foldable globular protein.