Run-Time Scalable Hardware for Reconfigurable Systems

La optimización de parámetros tales como el consumo de potencia, la cantidad de recursos lógicos empleados o la ocupación de memoria ha sido siempre una de las preocupaciones principales a la hora de diseñar sistemas embebidos. Esto es debido a que se trata de sistemas dotados de una cantidad de recursos limitados, y que han sido tradicionalmente empleados para un propósito específico, que permanece invariable a lo largo de toda la vida útil del sistema. Sin embargo, el uso de sistemas embebidos se ha extendido a áreas de aplicación fuera de su ámbito tradicional, caracterizadas por una mayor demanda computacional. Así, por ejemplo, algunos de estos sistemas deben llevar a cabo un intenso procesado de señales multimedia o la transmisión de datos mediante sistemas de comunicaciones de alta capacidad. Por otra parte, las condiciones de operación del sistema pueden variar en tiempo real. Esto sucede, por ejemplo, si su funcionamiento depende de datos medidos por el propio sistema o recibidos a través de la red, de las demandas del usuario en cada momento, o de condiciones internas del propio dispositivo, tales como la duración de la batería. Como consecuencia de la existencia de requisitos de operación dinámicos es necesario ir hacia una gestión dinámica de los recursos del sistema. Si bien el software es inherentemente flexible, no ofrece una potencia computacional tan alta como el hardware. Por lo tanto, el hardware reconfigurable aparece como una solución adecuada para tratar con mayor flexibilidad los requisitos variables dinámicamente en sistemas con alta demanda computacional. La flexibilidad y adaptabilidad del hardware requieren de dispositivos reconfigurables que permitan la modificación de su funcionalidad bajo demanda. En esta tesis se han seleccionado las FPGAs (Field Programmable Gate Arrays) como los dispositivos más apropiados, hoy en día, para implementar sistemas basados en hardware reconfigurable De entre todas las posibilidades existentes para explotar la capacidad de reconfiguración de las FPGAs comerciales, se ha seleccionado la reconfiguración dinámica y parcial. Esta técnica consiste en substituir una parte de la lógica del dispositivo, mientras el resto continúa en funcionamiento. La capacidad de reconfiguración dinámica y parcial de las FPGAs es empleada en esta tesis para tratar con los requisitos de flexibilidad y de capacidad computacional que demandan los dispositivos embebidos. La propuesta principal de esta tesis doctoral es el uso de arquitecturas de procesamiento escalables espacialmente, que son capaces de adaptar su funcionalidad y rendimiento en tiempo real, estableciendo un compromiso entre dichos parámetros y la cantidad de lógica que ocupan en el dispositivo. A esto nos referimos con arquitecturas con huellas escalables. En particular, se propone el uso de arquitecturas altamente paralelas, modulares, regulares y con una alta localidad en sus comunicaciones, para este propósito. El tamaño de dichas arquitecturas puede ser modificado mediante la adición o eliminación de algunos de los módulos que las componen, tanto en una dimensión como en dos. Esta estrategia permite implementar soluciones escalables, sin tener que contar con una versión de las mismas para cada uno de los tamaños posibles de la arquitectura. De esta manera se reduce significativamente el tiempo necesario para modificar su tamaño, así como la cantidad de memoria necesaria para almacenar todos los archivos de configuración. En lugar de proponer arquitecturas para aplicaciones específicas, se ha optado por patrones de procesamiento genéricos, que pueden ser ajustados para solucionar distintos problemas en el estado del arte. A este respecto, se proponen patrones basados en esquemas sistólicos, así como de tipo wavefront. Con el objeto de poder ofrecer una solución integral, se han tratado otros aspectos relacionados con el diseño y el funcionamiento de las arquitecturas, tales como el control del proceso de reconfiguración de la FPGA, la integración de las arquitecturas en el resto del sistema, así como las técnicas necesarias para su implementación. Por lo que respecta a la implementación, se han tratado distintos aspectos de bajo nivel dependientes del dispositivo. Algunas de las propuestas realizadas a este respecto en la presente tesis doctoral son un router que es capaz de garantizar el correcto rutado de los módulos reconfigurables dentro del área destinada para ellos, así como una estrategia para la comunicación entre módulos que no introduce ningún retardo ni necesita emplear recursos configurables del dispositivo. El flujo de diseño propuesto se ha automatizado mediante una herramienta denominada DREAMS. La herramienta se encarga de la modificación de las netlists correspondientes a cada uno de los módulos reconfigurables del sistema, y que han sido generadas previamente mediante herramientas comerciales. Por lo tanto, el flujo propuesto se entiende como una etapa de post-procesamiento, que adapta esas netlists a los requisitos de la reconfiguración dinámica y parcial. Dicha modificación la lleva a cabo la herramienta de una forma completamente automática, por lo que la productividad del proceso de diseño aumenta de forma evidente. Para facilitar dicho proceso, se ha dotado a la herramienta de una interfaz gráfica. El flujo de diseño propuesto, y la herramienta que lo soporta, tienen características específicas para abordar el diseño de las arquitecturas dinámicamente escalables propuestas en esta tesis. Entre ellas está el soporte para el realojamiento de módulos reconfigurables en posiciones del dispositivo distintas a donde el módulo es originalmente implementado, así como la generación de estructuras de comunicación compatibles con la simetría de la arquitectura. El router has sido empleado también en esta tesis para obtener un rutado simétrico entre nets equivalentes. Dicha posibilidad ha sido explotada para aumentar la protección de circuitos con altos requisitos de seguridad, frente a ataques de canal lateral, mediante la implantación de lógica complementaria con rutado idéntico. Para controlar el proceso de reconfiguración de la FPGA, se propone en esta tesis un motor de reconfiguración especialmente adaptado a los requisitos de las arquitecturas dinámicamente escalables. Además de controlar el puerto de reconfiguración, el motor de reconfiguración ha sido dotado de la capacidad de realojar módulos reconfigurables en posiciones arbitrarias del dispositivo, en tiempo real. De esta forma, basta con generar un único bitstream por cada módulo reconfigurable del sistema, independientemente de la posición donde va a ser finalmente reconfigurado. La estrategia seguida para implementar el proceso de realojamiento de módulos es diferente de las propuestas existentes en el estado del arte, pues consiste en la composición de los archivos de configuración en tiempo real. De esta forma se consigue aumentar la velocidad del proceso, mientras que se reduce la longitud de los archivos de configuración parciales a almacenar en el sistema. El motor de reconfiguración soporta módulos reconfigurables con una altura menor que la altura de una región de reloj del dispositivo. Internamente, el motor se encarga de la combinación de los frames que describen el nuevo módulo, con la configuración existente en el dispositivo previamente. El escalado de las arquitecturas de procesamiento propuestas en esta tesis también se puede beneficiar de este mecanismo. Se ha incorporado también un acceso directo a una memoria externa donde se pueden almacenar bitstreams parciales. Para acelerar el proceso de reconfiguración se ha hecho funcionar el ICAP por encima de la máxima frecuencia de reloj aconsejada por el fabricante. Así, en el caso de Virtex-5, aunque la máxima frecuencia del reloj deberían ser 100 MHz, se ha conseguido hacer funcionar el puerto de reconfiguración a frecuencias de operación de hasta 250 MHz, incluyendo el proceso de realojamiento en tiempo real. Se ha previsto la posibilidad de portar el motor de reconfiguración a futuras familias de FPGAs. Por otro lado, el motor de reconfiguración se puede emplear para inyectar fallos en el propio dispositivo hardware, y así ser capaces de evaluar la tolerancia ante los mismos que ofrecen las arquitecturas reconfigurables. Los fallos son emulados mediante la generación de archivos de configuración a los que intencionadamente se les ha introducido un error, de forma que se modifica su funcionalidad. Con el objetivo de comprobar la validez y los beneficios de las arquitecturas propuestas en esta tesis, se han seguido dos líneas principales de aplicación. En primer lugar, se propone su uso como parte de una plataforma adaptativa basada en hardware evolutivo, con capacidad de escalabilidad, adaptabilidad y recuperación ante fallos. En segundo lugar, se ha desarrollado un deblocking filter escalable, adaptado a la codificación de vídeo escalable, como ejemplo de aplicación de las arquitecturas de tipo wavefront propuestas. El hardware evolutivo consiste en el uso de algoritmos evolutivos para diseñar hardware de forma autónoma, explotando la flexibilidad que ofrecen los dispositivos reconfigurables. En este caso, los elementos de procesamiento que componen la arquitectura son seleccionados de una biblioteca de elementos presintetizados, de acuerdo con las decisiones tomadas por el algoritmo evolutivo, en lugar de definir la configuración de las mismas en tiempo de diseño. De esta manera, la configuración del core puede cambiar cuando lo hacen las condiciones del entorno, en tiempo real, por lo que se consigue un control autónomo del proceso de reconfiguración dinámico. Así, el sistema es capaz de optimizar, de forma autónoma, su propia configuración. El hardware evolutivo tiene una capacidad inherente de auto-reparación. Se ha probado que las arquitecturas evolutivas propuestas en esta tesis son tolerantes ante fallos, tanto transitorios, como permanentes y acumulativos. La plataforma evolutiva se ha empleado para implementar filtros de eliminación de ruido. La escalabilidad también ha sido aprovechada en esta aplicación. Las arquitecturas evolutivas escalables permiten la adaptación autónoma de los cores de procesamiento ante fluctuaciones en la cantidad de recursos disponibles en el sistema. Por lo tanto, constituyen un ejemplo de escalabilidad dinámica para conseguir un determinado nivel de calidad, que puede variar en tiempo real. Se han propuesto dos variantes de sistemas escalables evolutivos. El primero consiste en un único core de procesamiento evolutivo, mientras que el segundo está formado por un número variable de arrays de procesamiento. La codificación de vídeo escalable, a diferencia de los codecs no escalables, permite la decodificación de secuencias de vídeo con diferentes niveles de calidad, de resolución temporal o de resolución espacial, descartando la información no deseada. Existen distintos algoritmos que soportan esta característica. En particular, se va a emplear el estándar Scalable Video Coding (SVC), que ha sido propuesto como una extensión de H.264/AVC, ya que este último es ampliamente utilizado tanto en la industria, como a nivel de investigación. Para poder explotar toda la flexibilidad que ofrece el estándar, hay que permitir la adaptación de las características del decodificador en tiempo real. El uso de las arquitecturas dinámicamente escalables es propuesto en esta tesis con este objetivo. El deblocking filter es un algoritmo que tiene como objetivo la mejora de la percepción visual de la imagen reconstruida, mediante el suavizado de los "artefactos" de bloque generados en el lazo del codificador. Se trata de una de las tareas más intensivas en procesamiento de datos de H.264/AVC y de SVC, y además, su carga computacional es altamente dependiente del nivel de escalabilidad seleccionado en el decodificador. Por lo tanto, el deblocking filter ha sido seleccionado como prueba de concepto de la aplicación de las arquitecturas dinámicamente escalables para la compresión de video. La arquitectura propuesta permite añadir o eliminar unidades de computación, siguiendo un esquema de tipo wavefront. La arquitectura ha sido propuesta conjuntamente con un esquema de procesamiento en paralelo del deblocking filter a nivel de macrobloque, de tal forma que cuando se varía del tamaño de la arquitectura, el orden de filtrado de los macrobloques varia de la misma manera. El patrón propuesto se basa en la división del procesamiento de cada macrobloque en dos etapas independientes, que se corresponden con el filtrado horizontal y vertical de los bloques dentro del macrobloque. Las principales contribuciones originales de esta tesis son las siguientes: - El uso de arquitecturas altamente regulares, modulares, paralelas y con una intensa localidad en sus comunicaciones, para implementar cores de procesamiento dinámicamente reconfigurables. - El uso de arquitecturas bidimensionales, en forma de malla, para construir arquitecturas dinámicamente escalables, con una huella escalable. De esta forma, las arquitecturas permiten establecer un compromiso entre el área que ocupan en el dispositivo, y las prestaciones que ofrecen en cada momento. Se proponen plantillas de procesamiento genéricas, de tipo sistólico o wavefront, que pueden ser adaptadas a distintos problemas de procesamiento. - Un flujo de diseño y una herramienta que lo soporta, para el diseño de sistemas reconfigurables dinámicamente, centradas en el diseño de las arquitecturas altamente paralelas, modulares y regulares propuestas en esta tesis. - Un esquema de comunicaciones entre módulos reconfigurables que no introduce ningún retardo ni requiere el uso de recursos lógicos propios. - Un router flexible, capaz de resolver los conflictos de rutado asociados con el diseño de sistemas reconfigurables dinámicamente. - Un algoritmo de optimización para sistemas formados por múltiples cores escalables que optimice, mediante un algoritmo genético, los parámetros de dicho sistema. Se basa en un modelo conocido como el problema de la mochila. - Un motor de reconfiguración adaptado a los requisitos de las arquitecturas altamente regulares y modulares. Combina una alta velocidad de reconfiguración, con la capacidad de realojar módulos en tiempo real, incluyendo el soporte para la reconfiguración de regiones que ocupan menos que una región de reloj, así como la réplica de un módulo reconfigurable en múltiples posiciones del dispositivo. - Un mecanismo de inyección de fallos que, empleando el motor de reconfiguración del sistema, permite evaluar los efectos de fallos permanentes y transitorios en arquitecturas reconfigurables. - La demostración de las posibilidades de las arquitecturas propuestas en esta tesis para la implementación de sistemas de hardware evolutivos, con una alta capacidad de procesamiento de datos. - La implementación de sistemas de hardware evolutivo escalables, que son capaces de tratar con la fluctuación de la cantidad de recursos disponibles en el sistema, de una forma autónoma. - Una estrategia de procesamiento en paralelo para el deblocking filter compatible con los estándares H.264/AVC y SVC que reduce el número de ciclos de macrobloque necesarios para procesar un frame de video. - Una arquitectura dinámicamente escalable que permite la implementación de un nuevo deblocking filter, totalmente compatible con los estándares H.264/AVC y SVC, que explota el paralelismo a nivel de macrobloque. El presente documento se organiza en siete capítulos. En el primero se ofrece una introducción al marco tecnológico de esta tesis, especialmente centrado en la reconfiguración dinámica y parcial de FPGAs. También se motiva la necesidad de las arquitecturas dinámicamente escalables propuestas en esta tesis. En el capítulo 2 se describen las arquitecturas dinámicamente escalables. Dicha descripción incluye la mayor parte de las aportaciones a nivel arquitectural realizadas en esta tesis. Por su parte, el flujo de diseño adaptado a dichas arquitecturas se propone en el capítulo 3. El motor de reconfiguración se propone en el 4, mientras que el uso de dichas arquitecturas para implementar sistemas de hardware evolutivo se aborda en el 5. El deblocking filter escalable se describe en el 6, mientras que las conclusiones finales de esta tesis, así como la descripción del trabajo futuro, son abordadas en el capítulo 7. ABSTRACT The optimization of system parameters, such as power dissipation, the amount of hardware resources and the memory footprint, has been always a main concern when dealing with the design of resource-constrained embedded systems. This situation is even more demanding nowadays. Embedded systems cannot anymore be considered only as specific-purpose computers, designed for a particular functionality that remains unchanged during their lifetime. Differently, embedded systems are now required to deal with more demanding and complex functions, such as multimedia data processing and high-throughput connectivity. In addition, system operation may depend on external data, the user requirements or internal variables of the system, such as the battery life-time. All these conditions may vary at run-time, leading to adaptive scenarios. As a consequence of both the growing computational complexity and the existence of dynamic requirements, dynamic resource management techniques for embedded systems are needed. Software is inherently flexible, but it cannot meet the computing power offered by hardware solutions. Therefore, reconfigurable hardware emerges as a suitable technology to deal with the run-time variable requirements of complex embedded systems. Adaptive hardware requires the use of reconfigurable devices, where its functionality can be modified on demand. In this thesis, Field Programmable Gate Arrays (FPGAs) have been selected as the most appropriate commercial technology existing nowadays to implement adaptive hardware systems. There are different ways of exploiting reconfigurability in reconfigurable devices. Among them is dynamic and partial reconfiguration. This is a technique which consists in substituting part of the FPGA logic on demand, while the rest of the device continues working. The strategy followed in this thesis is to exploit the dynamic and partial reconfiguration of commercial FPGAs to deal with the flexibility and complexity demands of state-of-the-art embedded systems. The proposal of this thesis to deal with run-time variable system conditions is the use of spatially scalable processing hardware IP cores, which are able to adapt their functionality or performance at run-time, trading them off with the amount of logic resources they occupy in the device. This is referred to as a scalable footprint in the context of this thesis. The distinguishing characteristic of the proposed cores is that they rely on highly parallel, modular and regular architectures, arranged in one or two dimensions. These architectures can be scaled by means of the addition or removal of the composing blocks. This strategy avoids implementing a full version of the core for each possible size, with the corresponding benefits in terms of scaling and adaptation time, as well as bitstream storage memory requirements. Instead of providing specific-purpose architectures, generic architectural templates, which can be tuned to solve different problems, are proposed in this thesis. Architectures following both systolic and wavefront templates have been selected. Together with the proposed scalable architectural templates, other issues needed to ensure the proper design and operation of the scalable cores, such as the device reconfiguration control, the run-time management of the architecture and the implementation techniques have been also addressed in this thesis. With regard to the implementation of dynamically reconfigurable architectures, device dependent low-level details are addressed. Some of the aspects covered in this thesis are the area constrained routing for reconfigurable modules, or an inter-module communication strategy which does not introduce either extra delay or logic overhead. The system implementation, from the hardware description to the device configuration bitstream, has been fully automated by modifying the netlists corresponding to each of the system modules, which are previously generated using the vendor tools. This modification is therefore envisaged as a post-processing step. Based on these implementation proposals, a design tool called DREAMS (Dynamically Reconfigurable Embedded and Modular Systems) has been created, including a graphic user interface. The tool has specific features to cope with modular and regular architectures, including the support for module relocation and the inter-module communications scheme based on the symmetry of the architecture. The core of the tool is a custom router, which has been also exploited in this thesis to obtain symmetric routed nets, with the aim of enhancing the protection of critical reconfigurable circuits against side channel attacks. This is achieved by duplicating the logic with an exactly equal routing. In order to control the reconfiguration process of the FPGA, a Reconfiguration Engine suited to the specific requirements set by the proposed architectures was also proposed. Therefore, in addition to controlling the reconfiguration port, the Reconfiguration Engine has been enhanced with the online relocation ability, which allows employing a unique configuration bitstream for all the positions where the module may be placed in the device. Differently to the existing relocating solutions, which are based on bitstream parsers, the proposed approach is based on the online composition of bitstreams. This strategy allows increasing the speed of the process, while the length of partial bitstreams is also reduced. The height of the reconfigurable modules can be lower than the height of a clock region. The Reconfiguration Engine manages the merging process of the new and the existing configuration frames within each clock region. The process of scaling up and down the hardware cores also benefits from this technique. A direct link to an external memory where partial bitstreams can be stored has been also implemented. In order to accelerate the reconfiguration process, the ICAP has been overclocked over the speed reported by the manufacturer. In the case of Virtex-5, even though the maximum frequency of the ICAP is reported to be 100 MHz, valid operations at 250 MHz have been achieved, including the online relocation process. Portability of the reconfiguration solution to today's and probably, future FPGAs, has been also considered. The reconfiguration engine can be also used to inject faults in real hardware devices, and this way being able to evaluate the fault tolerance offered by the reconfigurable architectures. Faults are emulated by introducing partial bitstreams intentionally modified to provide erroneous functionality. To prove the validity and the benefits offered by the proposed architectures, two demonstration application lines have been envisaged. First, scalable architectures have been employed to develop an evolvable hardware platform with adaptability, fault tolerance and scalability properties. Second, they have been used to implement a scalable deblocking filter suited to scalable video coding. Evolvable Hardware is the use of evolutionary algorithms to design hardware in an autonomous way, exploiting the flexibility offered by reconfigurable devices. In this case, processing elements composing the architecture are selected from a presynthesized library of processing elements, according to the decisions taken by the algorithm, instead of being decided at design time. This way, the configuration of the array may change as run-time environmental conditions do, achieving autonomous control of the dynamic reconfiguration process. Thus, the self-optimization property is added to the native self-configurability of the dynamically scalable architectures. In addition, evolvable hardware adaptability inherently offers self-healing features. The proposal has proved to be self-tolerant, since it is able to self-recover from both transient and cumulative permanent faults. The proposed evolvable architecture has been used to implement noise removal image filters. Scalability has been also exploited in this application. Scalable evolvable hardware architectures allow the autonomous adaptation of the processing cores to a fluctuating amount of resources available in the system. Thus, it constitutes an example of the dynamic quality scalability tackled in this thesis. Two variants have been proposed. The first one consists in a single dynamically scalable evolvable core, and the second one contains a variable number of processing cores. Scalable video is a flexible approach for video compression, which offers scalability at different levels. Differently to non-scalable codecs, a scalable video bitstream can be decoded with different levels of quality, spatial or temporal resolutions, by discarding the undesired information. The interest in this technology has been fostered by the development of the Scalable Video Coding (SVC) standard, as an extension of H.264/AVC. In order to exploit all the flexibility offered by the standard, it is necessary to adapt the characteristics of the decoder to the requirements of each client during run-time. The use of dynamically scalable architectures is proposed in this thesis with this aim. The deblocking filter algorithm is the responsible of improving the visual perception of a reconstructed image, by smoothing blocking artifacts generated in the encoding loop. This is one of the most computationally intensive tasks of the standard, and furthermore, it is highly dependent on the selected scalability level in the decoder. Therefore, the deblocking filter has been selected as a proof of concept of the implementation of dynamically scalable architectures for video compression. The proposed architecture allows the run-time addition or removal of computational units working in parallel to change its level of parallelism, following a wavefront computational pattern. Scalable architecture is offered together with a scalable parallelization strategy at the macroblock level, such that when the size of the architecture changes, the macroblock filtering order is modified accordingly. The proposed pattern is based on the division of the macroblock processing into two independent stages, corresponding to the horizontal and vertical filtering of the blocks within the macroblock. The main contributions of this thesis are: - The use of highly parallel, modular, regular and local architectures to implement dynamically reconfigurable processing IP cores, for data intensive applications with flexibility requirements. - The use of two-dimensional mesh-type arrays as architectural templates to build dynamically reconfigurable IP cores, with a scalable footprint. The proposal consists in generic architectural templates, which can be tuned to solve different computational problems. •A design flow and a tool targeting the design of DPR systems, focused on highly parallel, modular and local architectures. - An inter-module communication strategy, which does not introduce delay or area overhead, named Virtual Borders. - A custom and flexible router to solve the routing conflicts as well as the inter-module communication problems, appearing during the design of DPR systems. - An algorithm addressing the optimization of systems composed of multiple scalable cores, which size can be decided individually, to optimize the system parameters. It is based on a model known as the multi-dimensional multi-choice Knapsack problem. - A reconfiguration engine tailored to the requirements of highly regular and modular architectures. It combines a high reconfiguration throughput with run-time module relocation capabilities, including the support for sub-clock reconfigurable regions and the replication in multiple positions. - A fault injection mechanism which takes advantage of the system reconfiguration engine, as well as the modularity of the proposed reconfigurable architectures, to evaluate the effects of transient and permanent faults in these architectures. - The demonstration of the possibilities of the architectures proposed in this thesis to implement evolvable hardware systems, while keeping a high processing throughput. - The implementation of scalable evolvable hardware systems, which are able to adapt to the fluctuation of the amount of resources available in the system, in an autonomous way. - A parallelization strategy for the H.264/AVC and SVC deblocking filter, which reduces the number of macroblock cycles needed to process the whole frame. - A dynamically scalable architecture that permits the implementation of a novel deblocking filter module, fully compliant with the H.264/AVC and SVC standards, which exploits the macroblock level parallelism of the algorithm. This document is organized in seven chapters. In the first one, an introduction to the technology framework of this thesis, specially focused on dynamic and partial reconfiguration, is provided. The need for the dynamically scalable processing architectures proposed in this work is also motivated in this chapter. In chapter 2, dynamically scalable architectures are described. Description includes most of the architectural contributions of this work. The design flow tailored to the scalable architectures, together with the DREAMs tool provided to implement them, are described in chapter 3. The reconfiguration engine is described in chapter 4. The use of the proposed scalable archtieectures to implement evolvable hardware systems is described in chapter 5, while the scalable deblocking filter is described in chapter 6. Final conclusions of this thesis, and the description of future work, are addressed in chapter 7.

Transmission of digital chaotic and information-bearing signals in optical communication systems

A new proposal to have secure communications in a system is reported. The basis is the use of a synchronized digital chaotic systems, sending the information signal added to an initial chaos. The received signal is analyzed by another chaos generator located at the receiver and, by a logic boolean function of the chaotic and the received signals, the original information is recovered. One of the most important facts of this system is that the bandwidth needed by the system remain the same with and without chaos.

Analysis of quality of experience in 3D video systems

Esta tesis presenta un estudio exhaustivo sobre la evaluación de la calidad de experiencia (QoE, del inglés Quality of Experience) percibida por los usuarios de sistemas de vídeo 3D, analizando el impacto de los efectos introducidos por todos los elementos de la cadena de procesamiento de vídeo 3D. Por lo tanto, se presentan varias pruebas de evaluación subjetiva específicamente diseñadas para evaluar los sistemas considerados, teniendo en cuenta todos los factores perceptuales relacionados con la experiencia visual tridimensional, tales como la percepción de profundidad y la molestia visual. Concretamente, se describe un test subjetivo basado en la evaluación de degradaciones típicas que pueden aparecer en el proceso de creación de contenidos de vídeo 3D, por ejemplo debidas a calibraciones incorrectas de las cámaras o a algoritmos de procesamiento de la señal de vídeo (p. ej., conversión de 2D a 3D). Además, se presenta el proceso de generación de una base de datos de vídeos estereoscópicos de alta calidad, disponible gratuitamente para la comunidad investigadora y que ha sido utilizada ampliamente en diferentes trabajos relacionados con vídeo 3D. Asimismo, se presenta otro estudio subjetivo, realizado entre varios laboratorios, con el que se analiza el impacto de degradaciones causadas por la codificación de vídeo, así como diversos formatos de representación de vídeo 3D. Igualmente, se describen tres pruebas subjetivas centradas en el estudio de posibles efectos causados por la transmisión de vídeo 3D a través de redes de televisión sobre IP (IPTV, del inglés Internet Protocol Television) y de sistemas de streaming adaptativo de vídeo. Para estos casos, se ha propuesto una innovadora metodología de evaluación subjetiva de calidad vídeo, denominada Content-Immersive Evaluation of Transmission Impairments (CIETI), diseñada específicamente para evaluar eventos de transmisión simulando condiciones realistas de visualización de vídeo en ámbitos domésticos, con el fin de obtener conclusiones más representativas sobre la experiencia visual de los usuarios finales. Finalmente, se exponen dos experimentos subjetivos comparando varias tecnologías actuales de televisores 3D disponibles en el mercado de consumo y evaluando factores perceptuales de sistemas Super Multiview Video (SMV), previstos a ser la tecnología futura de televisores 3D de consumo, gracias a una prometedora visualización de contenido 3D sin necesidad de gafas específicas. El trabajo presentado en esta tesis ha permitido entender los factores perceptuales y técnicos relacionados con el procesamiento y visualización de contenidos de vídeo 3D, que pueden ser de utilidad en el desarrollo de nuevas tecnologías y técnicas de evaluación de la QoE, tanto metodologías subjetivas como métricas objetivas. ABSTRACT This thesis presents a comprehensive study of the evaluation of the Quality of Experience (QoE) perceived by the users of 3D video systems, analyzing the impact of effects introduced by all the elements of the 3D video processing chain. Therefore, various subjective assessment tests are presented, particularly designed to evaluate the systems under consideration, and taking into account all the perceptual factors related to the 3D visual experience, such as depth perception and visual discomfort. In particular, a subjective test is presented, based on evaluating typical degradations that may appear during the content creation, for instance due to incorrect camera calibration or video processing algorithms (e.g., 2D to 3D conversion). Moreover, the process of generation of a high-quality dataset of 3D stereoscopic videos is described, which is freely available for the research community, and has been already widely used in different works related with 3D video. In addition, another inter-laboratory subjective study is presented analyzing the impact of coding impairments and representation formats of stereoscopic video. Also, three subjective tests are presented studying the effects of transmission events that take place in Internet Protocol Television (IPTV) networks and adaptive streaming scenarios for 3D video. For these cases, a novel subjective evaluation methodology, called Content-Immersive Evaluation of Transmission Impairments (CIETI), was proposed, which was especially designed to evaluate transmission events simulating realistic home-viewing conditions, to obtain more representative conclusions about the visual experience of the end users. Finally, two subjective experiments are exposed comparing various current 3D displays available in the consumer market, and evaluating perceptual factors of Super Multiview Video (SMV) systems, expected to be the future technology for consumer 3D displays thanks to a promising visualization of 3D content without specific glasses. The work presented in this thesis has allowed to understand perceptual and technical factors related to the processing and visualization of 3D video content, which may be useful in the development of new technologies and approaches for QoE evaluation, both subjective methodologies and objective metrics.

How the owl resolves auditory coding ambiguity

The barn owl (Tyto alba) uses interaural time difference (ITD) cues to localize sounds in the horizontal plane. Low-order binaural auditory neurons with sharp frequency tuning act as narrow-band coincidence detectors; such neurons respond equally well to sounds with a particular ITD and its phase equivalents and are said to be phase ambiguous. Higher-order neurons with broad frequency tuning are unambiguously selective for single ITDs in response to broad-band sounds and show little or no response to phase equivalents. Selectivity for single ITDs is thought to arise from the convergence of parallel, narrow-band frequency channels that originate in the cochlea. ITD tuning to variable bandwidth stimuli was measured in higher-order neurons of the owl’s inferior colliculus to examine the rules that govern the relationship between frequency channel convergence and the resolution of phase ambiguity. Ambiguity decreased as stimulus bandwidth increased, reaching a minimum at 2–3 kHz. Two independent mechanisms appear to contribute to the elimination of ambiguity: one suppressive and one facilitative. The integration of information carried by parallel, distributed processing channels is a common theme of sensory processing that spans both modality and species boundaries. The principles underlying the resolution of phase ambiguity and frequency channel convergence in the owl may have implications for other sensory systems, such as electrolocation in electric fish and the computation of binocular disparity in the avian and mammalian visual systems.

On cortical coding of vocal communication sounds in primates

Understanding how the brain processes vocal communication sounds is one of the most challenging problems in neuroscience. Our understanding of how the cortex accomplishes this unique task should greatly facilitate our understanding of cortical mechanisms in general. Perception of species-specific communication sounds is an important aspect of the auditory behavior of many animal species and is crucial for their social interactions, reproductive success, and survival. The principles of neural representations of these behaviorally important sounds in the cerebral cortex have direct implications for the neural mechanisms underlying human speech perception. Our progress in this area has been relatively slow, compared with our understanding of other auditory functions such as echolocation and sound localization. This article discusses previous and current studies in this field, with emphasis on nonhuman primates, and proposes a conceptual platform to further our exploration of this frontier. It is argued that the prerequisite condition for understanding cortical mechanisms underlying communication sound perception and production is an appropriate animal model. Three issues are central to this work: (i) neural encoding of statistical structure of communication sounds, (ii) the role of behavioral relevance in shaping cortical representations, and (iii) sensory–motor interactions between vocal production and perception systems.

An Empirical Comparison of Reuse in Embedded and Nonembedded Systems

High-quality software, delivered on time and budget, constitutes a critical part of most products and services in modern society. Our government has invested billions of dollars to develop software assets, often to redevelop the same capability many times. Recognizing the waste involved in redeveloping these assets, in 1992 the Department of Defense issued the Software Reuse Initiative. The vision of the Software Reuse Initiative was "To drive the DoD software community from its current "re-invent the software" cycle to a process-driven, domain-specific, architecture-centric, library-based way of constructing software.'' Twenty years after issuing this initiative, there is evidence of this vision beginning to be realized in nonembedded systems. However, virtually every large embedded system undertaken has incurred large cost and schedule overruns. Investigations into the root cause of these overruns implicates reuse. Why are we seeing improvements in the outcomes of these large scale nonembedded systems and worse outcomes in embedded systems? This question is the foundation for this research. The experiences of the Aerospace industry have led to a number of questions about reuse and how the industry is employing reuse in embedded systems. For example, does reuse in embedded systems yield the same outcomes as in nonembedded systems? Are the outcomes positive? If the outcomes are different, it may indicate that embedded systems should not use data from nonembedded systems for estimation. Are embedded systems using the same development approaches as nonembedded systems? Does the development approach make a difference? If embedded systems develop software differently from nonembedded systems, it may mean that the same processes do not apply to both types of systems. What about the reuse of different artifacts? Perhaps there are certain artifacts that, when reused, contribute more or are more difficult to use in embedded systems. Finally, what are the success factors and obstacles to reuse? Are they the same in embedded systems as in nonembedded systems? The research in this dissertation is comprised of a series of empirical studies using professionals in the aerospace and defense industry as its subjects. The main focus has been to investigate the reuse practices of embedded systems professionals and nonembedded systems professionals and compare the methods and artifacts used against the outcomes. The research has followed a combined qualitative and quantitative design approach. The qualitative data were collected by surveying software and systems engineers, interviewing senior developers, and reading numerous documents and other studies. Quantitative data were derived from converting survey and interview respondents' answers into coding that could be counted and measured. From the search of existing empirical literature, we learned that reuse in embedded systems are in fact significantly different from nonembedded systems, particularly in effort in model based development approach and quality where the development approach was not specified. The questionnaire showed differences in the development approach used in embedded projects from nonembedded projects, in particular, embedded systems were significantly more likely to use a heritage/legacy development approach. There was also a difference in the artifacts used, with embedded systems more likely to reuse hardware, test products, and test clusters. Nearly all the projects reported using code, but the questionnaire showed that the reuse of code brought mixed results. One of the differences expressed by the respondents to the questionnaire was the difficulty in reuse of code for embedded systems when the platform changed. The semistructured interviews were performed to tell us why the phenomena in the review of literature and the questionnaire were observed. We asked respected industry professionals, such as senior fellows, fellows and distinguished members of technical staff, about their experiences with reuse. We learned that many embedded systems used heritage/legacy development approaches because their systems had been around for many years, before models and modeling tools became available. We learned that reuse of code is beneficial primarily when the code does not require modification, but, especially in embedded systems, once it has to be changed, reuse of code yields few benefits. Finally, while platform independence is a goal for many in nonembedded systems, it is certainly not a goal for the embedded systems professionals and in many cases it is a detriment. However, both embedded and nonembedded systems professionals endorsed the idea of platform standardization. Finally, we conclude that while reuse in embedded systems and nonembedded systems is different today, they are converging. As heritage embedded systems are phased out, models become more robust and platforms are standardized, reuse in embedded systems will become more like nonembedded systems.

Restraint systems evaluation project codebook.

Mode of access: Internet.

Challenging the dogma: the hidden layer of non-protein-coding RNAs in complex organisms

The central dogma of biology holds that genetic information normally flows from DNA to RNA to protein. As a consequence it has been generally assumed that genes generally code for proteins, and that proteins fulfil not only most structural and catalytic but also most regulatory functions, in all cells, from microbes to mammals. However, the latter may not be the case in complex organisms. A number of startling observations about the extent of non-protein-coding RNA (ncRNA) transcription in the higher eukaryotes and the range of genetic and epigenetic phenomena that are RNA-directed suggests that the traditional view of the structure of genetic regulatory systems in animals and plants may be incorrect. ncRNA dominates the genomic output of the higher organisms and has been shown to control chromosome architecture, mRNA turnover and the developmental timing of protein expression, and may also regulate transcription and alternative splicing. This paper re-examines the available evidence and suggests a new framework for considering and understanding the genomic programming of biological complexity, autopoletic development and phenotypic variation. BioEssays 25:930-939,2003. (C) 2003 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

Investigations into MIMO systems from an electromagnetic perspective

The paper presents investigations into multiple input multiple output wireless communication systems, which are carried out from an electromagnetic perspective. The first part of the paper focuses on signal propagation models, which can be used for determining the MIMO system capacity or its performance when various space-time coding schemes are applied. Two types of models are considered. In the first model, array antennas are treated in an exact electromagnetic manner but interactions with scattering objects are incorporated using an approximate single bounce scattering approach. The other model is a simple but exact electromagnetic (EM) model, which takes into account EM interactions between antennas and scatterers. In this model, parallel wire dipoles represent antennas as well as scatterers. The second part of the paper reports on investigations into two types of MIMO testbeds. The first one is a simple transmit/receive diversity tested while the other one is a full MIMO testbed. The paper briefly describes the results obtained during the undertaken investigations

Advanced receivers for next generation wireless communication systems

Despite extensive progress on the theoretical aspects of spectral efficient communication systems, hardware impairments, such as phase noise, are the key bottlenecks in next generation wireless communication systems. The presence of non-ideal oscillators at the transceiver introduces time varying phase noise and degrades the performance of the communication system. Significant research literature focuses on joint synchronization and decoding based on joint posterior distribution, which incorporate both the channel and code graph. These joint synchronization and decoding approaches operate on well designed sum-product algorithms, which involves calculating probabilistic messages iteratively passed between the channel statistical information and decoding information. Channel statistical information, generally entails a high computational complexity because its probabilistic model may involve continuous random variables. The detailed knowledge about the channel statistics for these algorithms make them an inadequate choice for real world applications due to power and computational limitations. In this thesis, novel phase estimation strategies are proposed, in which soft decision-directed iterative receivers for a separate A Posteriori Probability (APP)-based synchronization and decoding are proposed. These algorithms do not require any a priori statistical characterization of the phase noise process. The proposed approach relies on a Maximum A Posteriori (MAP)-based algorithm to perform phase noise estimation and does not depend on the considered modulation/coding scheme as it only exploits the APPs of the transmitted symbols. Different variants of APP-based phase estimation are considered. The proposed algorithm has significantly lower computational complexity with respect to joint synchronization/decoding approaches at the cost of slight performance degradation. With the aim to improve the robustness of the iterative receiver, we derive a new system model for an oversampled (more than one sample per symbol interval) phase noise channel. We extend the separate APP-based synchronization and decoding algorithm to a multi-sample receiver, which exploits the received information from the channel by exchanging the information in an iterative fashion to achieve robust convergence. Two algorithms based on sliding block-wise processing with soft ISI cancellation and detection are proposed, based on the use of reliable information from the channel decoder. Dually polarized systems provide a cost-and spatial-effective solution to increase spectral efficiency and are competitive candidates for next generation wireless communication systems. A novel soft decision-directed iterative receiver, for separate APP-based synchronization and decoding, is proposed. This algorithm relies on an Minimum Mean Square Error (MMSE)-based cancellation of the cross polarization interference (XPI) followed by phase estimation on the polarization of interest. This iterative receiver structure is motivated from Master/Slave Phase Estimation (M/S-PE), where M-PE corresponds to the polarization of interest. The operational principle of a M/S-PE block is to improve the phase tracking performance of both polarization branches: more precisely, the M-PE block tracks the co-polar phase and the S-PE block reduces the residual phase error on the cross-polar branch. Two variants of MMSE-based phase estimation are considered; BW and PLP.

Finite connectivity systems as error-correcting codes

We investigate the performance of parity check codes using the mapping onto spin glasses proposed by Sourlas. We study codes where each parity check comprises products of K bits selected from the original digital message with exactly C parity checks per message bit. We show, using the replica method, that these codes saturate Shannon's coding bound for K?8 when the code rate K/C is finite. We then examine the finite temperature case to asses the use of simulated annealing methods for decoding, study the performance of the finite K case and extend the analysis to accommodate different types of noisy channels. The analogy between statistical physics methods and decoding by belief propagation is also discussed.

Retrieving designs from a sketch using an automated GT coding and classification system

While the retrieval of existing designs to prevent unnecessary duplication of parts is a recognised strategy in the control of design costs the available techniques to achieve this, even in product data management systems, are limited in performance or require large resources. A novel system has been developed based on a new version of an existing coding system (CAMAC) that allows automatic coding of engineering drawings and their subsequent retrieval using a drawing of the desired component as the input. The ability to find designs using a detail drawing rather than textual descriptions is a significant achievement in itself. Previous testing of the system has demonstrated this capability but if a means could be found to find parts from a simple sketch then its practical application would be much more effective. This paper describes the development and testing of such a search capability using a database of over 3000 engineering components.

Stimulating design reuse through automated coding

In designing new product the ability to retrieve drawings of existing components is important if costs are to be controlled by preventing unnecessary duplication if parts. Component coding and classification systems have been used successfully for these purposes but suffer from high operational costs and poor usability arising directly from the manual nature of the coding process itself. A new version of an existing coding system (CAMAC) has been developed to reduce costs by automatically coding engineering drawings. Usability is improved be supporting searches based on a drawing or sketch of the desired component. Test results from a database of several thousand drawings are presented.

Cryptographic techniques for personal communication systems security

The advent of personal communication systems within the last decade has depended upon the utilization of advanced digital schemes for source and channel coding and for modulation. The inherent digital nature of the communications processing has allowed the convenient incorporation of cryptographic techniques to implement security in these communications systems. There are various security requirements, of both the service provider and the mobile subscriber, which may be provided for in a personal communications system. Such security provisions include the privacy of user data, the authentication of communicating parties, the provision for data integrity, and the provision for both location confidentiality and party anonymity. This thesis is concerned with an investigation of the private-key and public-key cryptographic techniques pertinent to the security requirements of personal communication systems and an analysis of the security provisions of Second-Generation personal communication systems is presented. Particular attention has been paid to the properties of the cryptographic protocols which have been employed in current Second-Generation systems. It has been found that certain security-related protocols implemented in the Second-Generation systems have specific weaknesses. A theoretical evaluation of these protocols has been performed using formal analysis techniques and certain assumptions made during the development of the systems are shown to contribute to the security weaknesses. Various attack scenarios which exploit these protocol weaknesses are presented. The Fiat-Sharmir zero-knowledge cryptosystem is presented as an example of how asymmetric algorithm cryptography may be employed as part of an improved security solution. Various modifications to this cryptosystem have been evaluated and their critical parameters are shown to be capable of being optimized to suit a particular applications. The implementation of such a system using current smart card technology has been evaluated.

A mean field theory of coded CDMA systems

We present a mean field theory of code-division multiple access (CDMA) systems with error-control coding. On the basis of the relation between the free energy and mutual information, we obtain an analytical expression of the maximum spectral efficiency of the coded CDMA system, from which a mean field description of the coded CDMA system is provided in terms of a bank of scalar Gaussian channels whose variances in general vary at different code symbol positions. Regular low-density parity-check (LDPC)-coded CDMA systems are also discussed as an example of the coded CDMA systems.