Validação de um método para determinação simultânea de quatro ácidos orgânicos por cromatografia líquida de alta eficiência em polpas de frutas congeladas

Validation of a rapid method for the determination of ascorbic, citric, fumaric and tartaric acids in stored pulp fruit and its application as a quality parameter was performed. The validation parameters showed that for the four evaluated acids, the method presented low limits of detection (LOD) and quantification (LOQ), indicating good precision and accuracy, thus representing an important tool for quality assessment of stored fruit pulp. The results showed that the concentration of organic acids generally decreased with longer storage time in the fruit pulp under study. Amongst all the organic acids under investigation, ascorbic proved the least stable.

Metsäala monikulttuurisuuden koulussa

Kirjallisuusarvostelu

INFLUÊNCIA DO CONTEÚDO DE XILANAS NA BRANQUEABILIDADE, PROPRIEDADES HIGROSCÓPICAS, FISICO-MECÂNICAS E ÓPTICA DE POLPAS BRANQUEADAS DE EUCALIPTO

Bleached eucalypt kraft pulps are widely used in print and writing (P&W) and tissue paper manufacture. Among the quality requirements of pulp for these papers, xylan content has been controversial. The objective of this study was to evaluate the influence of xylan content on bleachability, hygroscopic, physic-mechanical and optical properties of the pulp. In this study industrial unbleached eucalyptus kraft pulp (15.6% xylans) treated with different NaOH loads to change its xylan content was used. Subsequently, pulps were bleached by the ODHT(EP)D sequence to achieve 90% ISO of brightness, then refined and submitted to hygroscopic, physicomechanical and optical tests. NaOH treatments decreased the xylan content to 14.5-5.9% using NaOH loads of 10-70 g L-1. Pulp bleachability was not significantly affected by xylan content decrease. The decrease in xylan content negatively affected the water retention value and Klemm capillarity of the pulp, while water absorption capacity was positively affected. Tensile and tear index were negatively influenced by the reduction in xylan content, whereas bulk and light scattering coefficient increased.

Wet oxidation of recalcitrant lignin waters: Experimental and kinetic studies

The dissertation is based on four articles dealing with recalcitrant lignin water purification. Lignin, a complicated substance and recalcitrant to most treatment technologies, inhibits seriously pulp and paper industry waste management. Therefore, lignin is studied, using WO as a process method for its degradation. A special attention is paid to the improvement in biodegradability and the reduction of lignin content, since they have special importance for any following biological treatment. In most cases wet oxidation is not used as a complete ' mineralization method but as a pre treatment in order to eliminate toxic components and to reduce the high level of organics produced. The combination of wet oxidation with a biological treatment can be a good option due to its effectiveness and its relatively low technology cost. The literature part gives an overview of Advanced Oxidation Processes (AOPs). A hot oxidation process, wet oxidation (WO), is investigated in detail and is the AOP process used in the research. The background and main principles of wet oxidation, its industrial applications, the combination of wet oxidation with other water treatment technologies, principal reactions in WO, and key aspects of modelling and reaction kinetics are presented. There is also given a wood composition and lignin characterization (chemical composition, structure and origin), lignin containing waters, lignin degradation and reuse possibilities, and purification practices for lignin containing waters. The aim of the research was to investigate the effect of the operating conditions of WO, such as temperature, partial pressure of oxygen, pH and initial concentration of wastewater, on the efficiency, and to enhance the process and estimate optimal conditions for WO of recalcitrant lignin waters. Two different waters are studied (a lignin water model solution and debarking water from paper industry) to give as appropriate conditions as possible. Due to the great importance of re using and minimizing the residues of industries, further research is carried out using residual ash of an Estonian power plant as a catalyst in wet oxidation of lignin-containing water. Developing a kinetic model that includes in the prediction such parameters as TOC gives the opportunity to estimate the amount of emerging inorganic substances (degradation rate of waste) and not only the decrease of COD and BOD. The degradation target compound, lignin is included into the model through its COD value (CODligning). Such a kinetic model can be valuable in developing WO treatment processes for lignin containing waters, or other wastewaters containing one or more target compounds. In the first article, wet oxidation of "pure" lignin water was investigated as a model case with the aim of degrading lignin and enhancing water biodegradability. The experiments were performed at various temperatures (110 -190°C), partial oxygen pressures (0.5 -1.5 MPa) and pH (5, 9 and 12). The experiments showed that increasing the temperature notably improved the processes efficiency. 75% lignin reduction was detected at the lowest temperature tested and lignin removal improved to 100% at 190°C. The effect of temperature on the COD removal rate was lower, but clearly detectable. 53% of organics were oxidized at 190°C. The effect of pH occurred mostly on lignin removal. Increasing the pH enhanced the lignin removal efficiency from 60% to nearly 100%. A good biodegradability ratio (over 0.5) was generally achieved. The aim of the second article was to develop a mathematical model for "pure" lignin wet oxidation using lumped characteristics of water (COD, BOD, TOC) and lignin concentration. The model agreed well with the experimental data (R2 = 0.93 at pH 5 and 12) and concentration changes during wet oxidation followed adequately the experimental results. The model also showed correctly the trend of biodegradability (BOD/COD) changes. In the third article, the purpose of the research was to estimate optimal conditions for wet oxidation (WO) of debarking water from the paper industry. The WO experiments were' performed at various temperatures, partial oxygen pressures and pH. The experiments showed that lignin degradation and organics removal are affected remarkably by temperature and pH. 78-97% lignin reduction was detected at different WO conditions. Initial pH 12 caused faster removal of tannins/lignin content; but initial pH 5 was more effective for removal of total organics, represented by COD and TOC. Most of the decrease in organic substances concentrations occurred in the first 60 minutes. The aim of the fourth article was to compare the behaviour of two reaction kinetic models, based on experiments of wet oxidation of industrial debarking water under different conditions. The simpler model took into account only the changes in COD, BOD and TOC; the advanced model was similar to the model used in the second article. Comparing the results of the models, the second model was found to be more suitable for describing the kinetics of wet oxidation of debarking water. The significance of the reactions involved was compared on the basis of the model: for instance, lignin degraded first to other chemically oxidizable compounds rather than directly to biodegradable products. Catalytic wet oxidation of lignin containing waters is briefly presented at the end of the dissertation. Two completely different catalysts were used: a commercial Pt catalyst and waste power plant ash. CWO showed good performance using 1 g/L of residual ash gave lignin removal of 86% and COD removal of 39% at 150°C (a lower temperature and pressure than with WO). It was noted that the ash catalyst caused a remarkable removal rate for lignin degradation already during the pre heating for `zero' time, 58% of lignin was degraded. In general, wet oxidation is not recommended for use as a complete mineralization method, but as a pre treatment phase to eliminate toxic or difficultly biodegradable components and to reduce the high level of organics. Biological treatment is an appropriate post treatment method since easily biodegradable organic matter remains after the WO process. The combination of wet oxidation with subsequent biological treatment can be an effective option for the treatment of lignin containing waters.

Magnesiumhydroksidialkalin käytön vaikutukset päällystämättömän aikakauslehtipaperin valmistukseen

Magnesiumhydroksidin on havaittu soveltuvan natriumhydroksidin korvaajaksi mekaanisen massan peroksidivalkaisun alkalina. Työssä selvitettiin, miten magnesiumhydroksidi vaikuttaa paperin valmistukseen ja valmiin paperin ominaisuuksiin. Laboratoriokokeet osoittivat magnesiumhydroksidin soveltuvan mekaanisen massan peroksidivalkaisun alkaliksi, sillä vaaleustavoite saavutettiin sen avulla. Valkaistun massan varaustila, johtokyky sekä ζ -potentiaali laskivat magnesiumhydroksidin vaikutuksesta. Nämä johtivat huomattavasti korkeampaan paperin täyteaineretentioon. Massan vedenpidätyskyky kasvoi korvattaessa natriumhydroksidi magnesiumhydroksidilla. Arkkien ominaisuuksista vetoindeksi, valonsirontakerroin ja taivutusjäykkyys kasvoivat. Kaikki edellä mainitut ominaisuudet viittaavat siihen, että magnesiumhydroksidin käyttö parantaa hienoaineen sitoutumista paperiin.

Measurement and Improvement of Wet Paper Web Strength

Various strength properties of paper are measured to tell how well it resists breaks in a paper machine or in printing presses. The most often measured properties are dry tensile strength and dry tear strength. However, in many situations where paper breaks, it is not dry. For example, in web breaks after the wet pressing the dry matter content can be around 45%. Thus, wet-web strength is often a more critical paper property than dry strength. Both wet and dry strength properties of the samples were measured with a L&W tensile tester. Originally this device was not designed for the measurement of the wet web tensile strength, thus a new procedure to handle the wet samples was developed. The method was tested with Pine Kraft (never dried). The effect of different strength additives on the wet-web and dry paper tensile strength was studied. The polymers used in this experiment were aqueous solution of a cationic polyamidoamine-epichlorohydrin resin (PAE), cationic hydrophilised polyisocyanate and cationic polyvinylamine (PVAm). From all three used chemicals only Cationic PAE considerably increased the wet web strength. However it was noticed that at constant solids content all chemicals decreased the wet web tensile strength. So, since all chemicals enhanced solid content it can be concluded that they work as drainage aids, not as wet web strength additives. From all chemicals only PVAm increased the dry strength and two other chemicals even decreased the strength. As chemicals were used in strong diluted forms and were injected into the pulp slurry, not on the surface of the papersheets, changes in samples densities did not happen. Also it has to be noted that all these chemicals are mainly used to improve the wet strength after the drying of the web.

Painediffusöörin suunnitteluperusteiden kehittäminen

Pesu on tärkeä osa sellun tuotantoprosessia. Eräs tapa toteuttaa sellun pesu on käyttää painediffusööriä. Painediffusööri toimii syrjäytyspesuperiaatteella, eli poistaa sellu-massasta keittolipeää paineistetun pesuveden avulla. Työssä on kehitetty painediffusöörin suunnittelun lähtökohtia keräämällä tietoa laitteen toiminnasta, rakenteesta, valmistuksesta sekä nykyisistä epäkohdista, joihin esitetään parannusmahdollisuuksia. Tärkeimmät kehitysalueet laitteessa ovat valmistus-toleranssien väljentäminen sekä sihdin pystysuuntaisen liikkeen tuottaminen. Laitteen valmistustoleranssit on analysoitu perusteellisesti, ja niiden väljentämis-mahdollisuuksia on tutkittu. Väljentämiseen ehdotetaan erilaisia keinoja. Sihdin liike tuotetaan tällä hetkellä hydrauliikalla. Hydrauliikkakomponenteille on koottu mitoitusohjeita, joiden jälkeen esitellään keinoja hydrauliikkajärjestelmän kehittämiseen. Lopuksi esitellään muita lineaarisen liikkeen tuottamisvaihtoehtoja, joilla hydrauliikan voisi korvata. Rakenteessa käytetyille valmistusmateriaaleille on etsitty olemassa olevat yleisimpien materiaalistandardien mukaiset nimikkeet materiaalinvalinnan helpottamiseksi jatkossa. Pääasiallisten valmistusmateriaalien lisäksi on kerätty tietoa myös vaihtoehtoisista konstruktiomateriaaleista sekä materiaalinvalinnasta ja tuotesuunnittelusta yleensä.

Vihreät arvot osana sellutuotteiden markkinointia

Tutkimuksessa tarkasteltiin vihreitä arvoja sellun nykyisessä markkinoinnissa ja käsiteltiin lähiajan haasteita markkinoinnin näkökulmasta. Metsäsertifioinnit PEFC ja FSC vaikuttavat sellun markkinointiin, samaten nähtiin ympäristömerkkien olevan voimakkaammin tulossa mukaan sellun liiketoimintaan. Yrityksen suorituskykyä ympäristöasioissa kuvaamaan on kehitetty erilaisia indeksejä. Näissä on jo mukana sellua valmistavia yrityksiä. Lisäksi työssä tarkasteltiin sellua valmistavia yrityksiä.

Projektimarkkinoinnin haasteet ja suhteiden tunnistaminen

Tässä tutkimustyössä oli tavoitteena tutkia projektimarkkinointiin liittyviä haasteita, joita Andritz Oy Wood Processing on kohdannut yhdessä sellu- ja paperiteollisuuden projektissa ja kolmessa puupohjaisen biomassavoimalaitoksen projektissa. Työn tarkoitus oli nostaa esille millaisia yhteisiä haasteita näiden tutkittujen projektien välillä on olemassa ja mihin työn kohteena olevan yrityksen tulisi keskittyä projektimarkkinointiprosessissa. Teoriaosiossa käsitellään monipuolisesti projektiliiketoimintaan liittyviä teorioita. Ensimmäiseksi tarkastellaan projektimarkkinointi- ja projektimarkkinointiprosessimalleja. Näiden jälkeen tutkitaan D-U-C-mallia (epäjatkuvuus, ainutkertaisuus ja monimutkaisuus), joka esiintyy hyvin monen tutkijan tutkimuksissa, kun käsitellään projektiliiketoimintaa. Lopuksi teoriaosiossa tarkastellaan asiakassuhteita ja miljööanalyysia projektiliiketoiminnassa. Tutkimuksen empiirisessä ensimmäisessä osiossa käydään läpi projektimarkkinointiin liittyvät haasteet, jotka löytyivät tutkituista tapausesimerkeistä. Tämän jälkeen jokaisesta projektista on laadittu miljöökartoitus, jonka perusteella nähdään projektien miljöiden vaihtelevuus. Viimeisenä asiana empiirisessä osiossa käydään läpi perusteet, jotka vaikuttivat projektitoimittajan valintaan. Teoreettisen ja empiirisen aineiston pohjalta on laadittu yritykselle suosituksia, joiden uskotaan parantavan yrityksen kilpailukykyä projektiliiketoiminnassa. Esiin nousseet asiat projektimarkkinoinnissa ovat monille itsestään selvyyksiä, mutta niiden toteuttamisessa on vielä paljon kehitettävää.

Effect of forest-based biofuels production on carbon footprint, Case: Integrated LWC paper mill

International energy and climate strategies also set Finland’s commitments to increasing the use of renewable energy sources and reducing greenhouse gas emissions. The target can be achieved by, for example, increasing the use of energy wood. Finland’s forest biomass potential is significant compared with current use. Increased use will change forest management and wood harvesting methods however. The thesis examined the potential for integrated pulp and paper mills to increase bioenergy production. The effects of two bioenergy production technologies on the carbon footprint of an integrated LWC mill were studied at mill level and from the cradle-to-customer approach. The LignoBoost process and FT diesel production were chosen as bioenergy cases. The data for the LignoBoost process were obtained from Metso and for the FT diesel process from Neste Oil. The rest of the information is based on the literature and databases of the KCL-ECO life-cycle computer program and Ecoinvent. In both case studies, the carbon footprint was reduced. From the results, it can be concluded that it is possible to achieve a fossil-fuel-free pulp mill with the LignoBoost process. By using steam from the FT diesel process, the amount of auxiliary fuel can be reduced considerably and the bark boiler can be replaced. With a choice of auxiliary fuels for use in heat production in the paper mill and the production methods for purchased electricity, it is possible to affect the carbon footprints even more in both cases.

Kuplakokojakauman hallinta happidelignifioinnissa

Työn tarkoituksena oli uutta kuvantamistekniikkaa hyödyntäen tutkia erilaisten tekijöiden vaikutusta kaasun dispergoitumiseen kemikaalisekoittimessa, kun kaasua sekoitetaan keskisakeaan massaan. Lisäksi työssä pyrittiin selvittämään, kuinka paljon kuitususpensioon tuotettu kaasufaasin kuplakokojakauma vaikuttaa happidelignifioinnin tulokseen. Kaasumaisten aineiden käyttäytymistä keskisakeissa kuitususpensiossa ei tarkkaan tunneta. Mikäli kaasumaisen hapen käyttäytymisestä saadaan uutta tietoa, tarjoaa tämä muun muassa uusia mahdollisuuksia kaasua sekoittavien laitteiden tuotekehityksessä. Työn kokeellinen osuus koostui kahdesta osasta, joista ensimmäisessä osassa selvitettiin sekoittimen roottorin pyörimisnopeuden, reaktorin kaasutilavuuden sekä suspension sakeuden vaikutusta muodostuvaan kaasun kuplakokojakaumaan. Työn jälkimmäisessä osassa arvioitiin yksivaiheisten keskisakeudessa tehtyjen happidelignifiointien perusteella suspensioon tuotetun kaasun kuplakokojakauman merkitystä happidelignifiointitulokseen. Kuplakokojakaumat määritettiin reaktoriin kiinnitetyllä kameralla kuvatuista valokuvista, joita otettiin sekoitustapahtuman aikana. Työn tuloksien perusteella sekoituksen voimakkuudella oli suurin vaikutus suspensioon muodostuvan kuplakokojakauman kannalta. Roottorin kierrosnopeuden kasvaessa kaasun keskimääräinen kuplakoko pieneni sekä havaittujen kuplien lukumäärää kasvoi huomattavasti. Myös suspension sakeuden kasvattamisen havaittiin vaikuttavan kuplakokoon pienentävästi. Happidelignifioinneissa saavutettiin paras kappareduktio, kun kaasun kuplakoko oli mahdollisimman pieni. Käytetty kuvantamistekniikka on tiettävästi ensimmäinen menetelmä, jolla saadaan reaaliaikaista tietoa vain muutamien kymmenien mikrometrien kokoisten kaasukuplien käyttäytymisestä oikeassa prosessitilanteessa.

The intrinsic mechanisms of softwood fiber damage in brown stock fiber line unit operations Lappeenranta 2010

The effects of pulp processing on softwood fiber properties strongly influence the properties of wet and dry paper webs. Pulp strength delivery studies have provided observations that much of the strength potential of long fibered pulp is lost during brown stock fiber line operations where the pulp is merely washed and transferred to the subsequent processing stages. The objective of this work was to study the intrinsic mechanisms which maycause fiber damage in the different unit operations of modern softwood brown stock processing. The work was conducted by studying the effects of industrial machinery on pulp properties with some actions of unit operations simulated in laboratory scale devices under controlled conditions. An optical imaging system was created and used to study the orientation of fibers in the internal flows during pulp fluidization in mixers and the passage of fibers through the screen openings during screening. The qualitative changes in fibers were evaluated with existing and standardized techniques. The results showed that each process stage has its characteristic effects on fiber properties: Pulp washing and mat formation in displacement washers introduced fiber deformations especially if the fibers entering the stage were intact, but it did not decrease the pulp strength properties. However, storage chests and pulp transfer after displacement washers contributed to strength deterioration. Pulp screening proved to be quite gentle, having the potential of slightly evening out fiber deformations from very deformed pulps and vice versa inflicting a marginal increase in the deformation indices if the fibers were previously intact. Pulp mixing in fluidizing industrial mixers did not have detrimental effects on pulp strength and had the potential of slightly evening out the deformations, provided that the intensity of fluidization was high enough to allow fiber orientation with the flow and that the time of mixing was short. The chemical and mechanical actions of oxygen delignification had two distinct effects on pulp properties: chemical treatment clearly reduced pulp strength with and without mechanical treatment, and the mechanical actions of process machinery introduced more conformability to pulp fibers, but did not clearly contribute to a further decrease in pulp strength. The chemical composition of fibers entering the oxygen stage was also found to affect the susceptibility of fibers to damage during oxygen delignification. Fibers with the smallest content of xylan were found to be more prone to irreversibledeformations accompanied with a lower tensile strength of the pulp. Fibers poor in glucomannan exhibited a lower fiber strength while wet after oxygen delignification as compared to the reference pulp. Pulps with the smallest lignin content on the other hand exhibited improved strength properties as compared to the references.

Fraktioinnin tehostaminen lajittelussa

Painelajittimet ovat yleisimpiä hiokkeen lajitteluun käytettyjä lajittimia. Painelajittimien suorituskyky on parantunut viimeisten vuosikymmenien aikana niin paljon, että pyörrepuhdistuksesta on pääosin voitu luopua osana hiokkeen lajittelua. Painelajittimen erinomaisuus perustuu siihen, että sillä voidaan erottaa massasta hyvinkin erilaisia epäpuhtauksia. Nykyään vallitsevia painelajittelun trendejä ovat sakeuden nosto, energiankulutuksen vähentäminen sekä eri fraktioiden erottumisen tehostuminen. Kaikilla pyritään vähentämään vedenkäyttöä ja parantamaan massan ominaisuuksia jatkoprosesseja silmälläpitäen. Tässä työssä tarkasteltiin painelajittimen roottorin kierrosnopeuden vaikutusta akseptimassan laatuun. Luodaan malli freeness-pudotukselle lajittimen yli. Sekä tarkastellaan myös automaatioon pohjautuvan säädön käyttöönottoa lajittimen akseptimassan freenesvaihteluiden tasaamiseksi. Toisaalta tehdään myös suppea selvitys lajittimien energiankulutuksista erilaisilla roottorin pyörimisnopeuksilla. Tuotantokäytössä oleviin lajittimiin asennettujen invertterisäätöjen ja koepisteistä saatujen tulosten avulla voidaan todeta, että laskemalla roottorin pyörimisnopeutta voidaan lajittimessa tapahtuvaa freenespudotusta kasvattaa. Samalla saavutetaan hyötyjä myös muissa massan ominaisuuksissa, kuten vetolujuudessa. Automaattisäädön käyttöönotolla saavutetaan huomattavasti pienempi hajonta akseptimassan freeneksessä. Rejektilinjan lajittimissa hajonta lähes puolittui ja päälinjan lajittimissa päästiin noin kolmanneksen parannukseen. Energian kulutuksia tutkittaessa huomataan, että roottorin kierrosnopeutta alentamalla voidaan merkittävästi vähentää lajittimien energian kulutusta. Parhaassa tapauksessa voidaan säästää neljännes lajittelun energiakustannuksissa.

Pretreatment in membrane filtration of wood hydrolysate

Interest in recovery of valuable components from process streams has increased in recent years. Purpose of biorefinery is to utilize components that otherwise would go to waste. Hemicelluloses, for example, could be utilized in production of many valuable products. One possible way to separate and fractionate hemicelluloses is membrane filtration. In the literature part of this work membrane fouling in filtration processes of pulp and paper process- and wastewaters was investigated. Especially purpose was to find out the possible fouling compounds, after which facilities to remove or modify such components less harmful were studied. In the experimental part different pretreatment methods, mainly to remove or degrade lignin from wood hydrolysate, were studied. In addition, concentration of hemicelluloses and separation from lignin were examined with two ultrafiltration membranes; UFX5 and RC70PP. Changes in feed solution, filtration capacity and fouling of membranes were used to evaluate the effects of pretreatment methods. Changes in hydrolysate composition were observed with different analysis methods. Filtration of hydrolysate proved to be challenging, especially with the UFX5 membrane. The more hydrophilic RC70PP membrane did not seem to be fouled as severely as the UFX5 membrane, according to pure water flux measurements. The UFX5 membrane retained hemicelluloses rather well, but problems arose from rapid flux decline resulting from concentration polarization and fouling of membrane. Most effective pretreatment methods in the case with the UFX5 membrane proved to be prefiltration with the RC70PP membrane, activated carbon adsorption and photocatalytic oxidation using titanium dioxide and UV radiation. An additional experiment with PHW extract showed that pulsed corona discharge treatment degraded lignin quite efficiently and thus improved filtration capacity remarkably, even over six times compared to the filtration with untreated extract.

Utilization of retention chemicals in non-wood containing furnishes

The usage of the non-wood pulps in furnishes for various paper grades is the real alternative for substitution of wood fibres in the papermaking. This is especially important now, when the prices for wood are increasing and forest resources are depleting in many regions of our planet. However, there are several problems associated with utilization of such pulps. In terms of the papermaking process one of the main problems is the poor dewatering of the non-wood pulps. This problem can be partially solved by means of retention aids. In the literature part were described technological features of the non-wood pulps as the raw materials for paper production. Moreover, overviews of the retention chemicals and methods for retention measurement were done; special attention was paid to the mechanisms of retention and drainage. Finally, factors affecting on the drainage and retention of non-wood pulps were considered holistically. Particular emphasis was put on the possibility of enzyme treatment for drainage improvement. It was stated that retention aids can significantly improve dewatering of non-wood pulps. In the experimental part the goal was to investigate influence of various microparticle retention aids on the drainage, retention and formation of furnish containing wheat straw pulp, obtained by novel pulping process (Formico™Fib). The parallel test were performed with reference furnish containing only wood pulps. It was found that Bentonite-CPAM retention aid can significantly improve drainage and retention; however formation seems be suffer from such additives. It was stated that performance of the Silica-Starch retention aid significantly depends on the starch dosing sequence and wet-end conditions; this system have shown better formation than other tested retention aids. Silica-CPAM retention aid have provided comparable results in retention and drainage with Bentonite-CPAM, while Silica-starch did not improve dewatering and yielded in lowest filler retention among other aids. Ultimately, optimal dosages for the tested retention chemicals have been suggested.