Trends in C-O and C-N bond formations over transition metal surfaces: An insight into kinetic sensitivity in catalytic reactions

Transition metal catalyzed bond formation is a fundamental process in catalysis and is of general interest throughout chemistry. To date, however, the knowledge of association reactions is rather limited, relative to what is known about dissociative processes. For example, surprisingly little is known about how the bond-forming ability of a metal, in general, varies across the Periodic Table. In particular, the effect of reactant valency on such trends is poorly understood. Herein, the authors examine these key issues by using density functional theory calculations to study CO and CN formations over the 4d metals. The calculations reveal that the chemistries differ in a fundamental way. In the case of CO formation, the reaction enthalpies span a much greater range than those of CN formation. Moreover, CO formation is found to be kinetically sensitive to the metal; here the reaction barriers (E-a) are found to be influenced by the reaction enthalpy. CN formation, conversely, is found to be relatively kinetically insensitive to the metal, and there is no correlation found between the reaction barriers and the reaction enthalpy. Analysis has shown that at the final adsorbed state, the interaction between N and the surface is relatively greater than that of O. Furthermore, in comparison with O, relatively less bonding between the surface and N is observed to be lost during transition state formation. These greater interactions between N and the surface, which can be related to the larger valency of N, are found to be responsible for the relatively smaller enthalpy range and limited variation in E-a for CN formation. (C) 2007 American Institute of Physics.

The dissociation of molecularly adsorbed CO and CN over the 4d transition metals: A universal relationship between the reaction barriers and the reaction enthalpies

Density functional theory calculations are used to study the stability of molecularly adsorbed CO and CN over transition metal surfaces. The minimum energy reaction pathways, corresponding reaction barriers (E-a), and reaction enthalpies (Delta H) for the dissociation of CO and CN to atomic products over the 4d transition metals from Zr to Pd have been determined. CO is found to be the more stable adsorbate on the right hand side of the period (from Tc onwards), whereas CN is the more stable surface species on the early metals (Zr, Nb and Mo). A single linear relationship is found to exist that correlates the barriers of both reactions with their respective reaction enthalpies. (c) 2006 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Importance of electronegativity differences and surface structure in molecular dissociation reactions at transition metal surfaces

The dissociative adsorption of N-2 has been studied at both monatomic steps and flat regions on the surfaces of the 4d transition metals from Zr to Pd. Using density functional theory (DFT) calculations, we have determined and analyzed the trends in both straight reactivity and structure sensitivity across the periodic table. With regards to reactivity, we find that the trend in activation energy (Ea) is determined mainly by a charge transfer from the surface metal atoms to the N atoms during transition state formation, namely, the degree of ionicity of the N-surface bond at the transition state. Indeed, we find that the strength of the metal-N bond at the transition state (and therefore the trend in Ea) can be predicted by the difference in Mulliken electronegativity between the metal and N. Structure sensitivity is analyzed in terms of geometric and electronic effects. We find that the lowering of Ea due to steps is more pronounced on the right-hand side of the periodic table. It is found that for the early transition metals the geometric and electronic effects work in opposition when going from terrace to step active site. In the case of the late 4d metals, however, these effects work in combination, producing a more marked reduction in Ea.

Reactivity of the 4d transition metals toward N hydrogenation and NH dissociation: A DFT-based HSAB analysis

The density functional theory (DFT) based hard-soft acid-base (HSAB) reactivity indices, including the electrophilicity index, have been successfully applied to many areas of molecular chemistry. In this work we test the applicability of such an approach to fundamental surface chemistry. We have considered, as prototypical surface reactions, both the hydrogenation of atomic nitrogen and the dissociative adsorption of the NH molecular radical. By use of a DFT methodology, the minimum energy reaction pathways, and corresponding reaction barriers, of the above reactions over Zr(001), Nb(110), Mo(110), Tc(001), Ru(001), Rh(111), and Pd(111) have been determined. By consideration of the chemical potential and chemical hardness of the surface metal atoms, and the principle of electronegativity equalization, it is found that the charge transferred to the NH radical during the process of dissociative adsorption correlates very well with that determined by Mulliken population analysis. Furthermore, it is found that the stability of the NH/surface transition state complex relates directly to this charge transfer and that the trend in transition state stability predicted by a HSAB; treatment correlates very strongly with that determined by DFT calculations. With regards to N hydrogenation, we find that during the course of the reaction, H loses cohesion to the surface, as it must migrate from a 3-fold hollow site to either a bridge or top site, to react with N. Partial density of states (PDOS) and Mulliken population analysis reveal that this loss of bonding is accompanied by charge transfer from H to the surface metal atoms. Moreover, by simple modeling, we show that the reaction barriers are directly proportional to this mandatory charge transfer. Indeed, it is found that the reaction barriers correlate very well with the electrophilicity index of the metal atoms.

The importance of hydrogen's potential-energy surface and the strength of the forming R-H bond in surface hydrogenation reactions

An understanding of surface hydrogenation reactivity is a prevailing issue in chemistry and vital to the rational design of future catalysts. In this density-functional theory study, we address hydrogenation reactivity by examining the reaction pathways for N+H -> NH and NH+H -> NH2 over the close-packed surfaces of the 4d transition metals from Zr-Pd. It is found that the minimum-energy reaction pathway is dictated by the ease with which H can relocate between hollow-site and top-site adsorption geometries. A transition state where H is close to a top site reduces the instability associated with bond sharing of metal atoms by H and N (NH) (bonding competition). However, if the energy difference between hollow-site and top-site adsorption energies (Delta E-H) is large this type of transition state is unfavorable. Thus we have determined that hydrogenation reactivity is primarily controlled by the potential-energy surface of H on the metal, which is approximated by Delta E-H, and that the strength of N (NH) chemisorption energy is of less importance. Delta E-H has also enabled us to make predictions regarding the structure sensitivity of these reactions. Furthermore, we have found that the degree of bonding competition at the transition state is responsible for the trend in reaction barriers (E-a) across the transition series. When this effect is quantified a very good linear correlation is found with E-a. In addition, we find that when considering a particular type of reaction pathway, a good linear correlation is found between the destabilizing effects of bonding competition at the transition state and the strength of the forming N-H (HN-H) bond. (c) 2006 American Institute of Physics.

The catalytic role of water in CO oxidation

Water, one of the most popular species in our planet, can play a catalytic role in many reactions, including reactions in heterogeneous catalysis. In a recent experimental work, Bergeld, Kasemo, and Chakarov demonstrated that water is able to promote CO oxidation under low temperatures (similar to200 K). In this study, we choose CO oxidation on Pt(111) in the presence of water as a model system to address the catalytic role of water for surface reactions in general using density functional theory. Many elementary steps possibly involved in the CO oxidation on Pt(111) at low temperatures have been investigated. We find the following. First, in the presence of water, the CO oxidation barrier is reduced to 0.33 eV (without water the barrier is 0.80 eV). This barrier reduction is mainly due to the H-bonding between the H in the H2O and the O at the transition state (TS), which stabilizes the TS. Second, CO can readily react with OH with a barrier of 0.44 eV, while COOH dissociation to produce CO2 is not easy (the barrier is 1.02 eV). Third, in the H2O+OH mixed phase, CO can be easily converted into CO2. It occurs through two steps: CO reacts with OH, forming COOH; and COOH transfers the H to a nearby H2O and, at the same time, an H in the H2O transfers to a OH, leading to CO2 formation. The reaction barrier of this process is 0.60 eV under CO coverage of 1/6 ML and 0.33 eV under CO coverage of 1/3 ML. The mechanism of CO oxidation at low temperatures is discussed. On the basis of our calculations, we propose that the water promotion effect can in general be divided into two classes: (i) By H-bonding between the H of H2O and an electron negative species such as the O in the reaction of CO+O+H2O-->CO2+H2O, H2O can stabilize the TS of the reaction and hence reduce the barrier. (ii) H2O first dissociates into H and OH and then OH or H participates directly in the reaction to induce new reaction mechanism with more favorable routes, in which OH or H can act as an intermediate. (C) 2003 American Institute of Physics.

Resolution of an ancient surface science anomaly: Work function change induced by N adsorption on W{100}

For many decades it has been assumed that an adsorbate centered above a metal surface and with a net negative charge should increase the work function of the surface. However, despite their electronegativity, N adatoms on W{100} cause a significant work function decrease. Here we present a resolution of this anomaly. Using density functional theory, we demonstrate that while the N atom carries a negative charge, of overriding importance is a reduction in the surface overspill electron density into the vacuum, when that charge is engaged in bonding to the adatom. This novel interpretation is fundamentally important in the general understanding of work function changes induced by atomic adsorbates.

Mechanism of H-2 metabolism on Fe-only hydrogenases

The metabolism of hydrogen (H-2 2H(+) + 2e(-)) constitutes a central process in the global biological energy cycle. Among all the enzymes that can mediate this process, Fe-only hydrogenases are unique in their particular high reactivity. Recently, some important progresses have been achieved. Following our previous paper [Z.-P. Liu and P. Hu, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 124, 5175 (2002)] that characterizes the individual redox state of the active site of Fe-only hydrogenase, in this work we have determined the feasible reaction pathways and energetics for the H-2 metabolism on the active site of Fe-only hydrogenases, using density functional theory. We show that H-2 metabolism possesses very low reaction barriers and a proximal base from a nearby protein plays an important role in H-2 metabolism. (C) 2002 American Institute of Physics.

Hydrogenation of S to H2S on Pt(111): A first-principles study

Density-functional theory has been used to investigate the chemisorption of S, SH, and H2S as well as the coadsorption of S and H and SH and H on Pt(111). In addition reaction pathways and energy profiles for the conversion of adsorbed S and H into gas-phase H2S have been determined. It has been found that S, SH, and H2S bind preferentially at face-centered-cubic (fcc), bridge, and top sites, respectively. Both the S+H and SH+H reactions have high barriers (similar to1 eV) and high exothermicities (similar to1 eV). This reveals that adsorbed H2S and SH are highly unstable adsorbates on Pt(111) and that adsorbed S (and H) is the most stable SHX (X=0,1,2) intermediate on Pt(111) (C) 2001 American Institute of Physics.

A first principles study of methanol decomposition on Pd(111): Mechanisms for O-H bond scission and C-O bond scission

There is some dispute as to whether methanol decomposition occurs by O-H bond scission or C-O bond scission. By carrying out density functional theory calculations, we investigate both scenario of the reaction pathways of methanol decomposition on a Pd(111) surface. It is shown that the O-H bond scission pathway is much more energetically favorable than the C-O bond scission pathway. The high reaction barrier in the latter case is found to be due to the poor bonding abilities of CH3 and OH with the surface at the reaction sites. (C) 2001 American Institute of Physics.

General trends in the barriers of catalytic reactions on transition metal surfaces

A catalyst preparation by design is one of the ultimate goals in chemistry. The first step towards this goal is to understand the origin of reaction barriers. In this study, we have investigated several catalytic reactions on some transition metal surfaces, using density functional theory. All the reaction barriers have been determined. By detailed analyses we obtain some insight into the reaction barrier. Each barrier is related to (i) the potential energy surface of reactants on the surface, (ii) the total chemisorption energy of reactants, and (iii) the metal d orbital occupancy and the reactant valency. (C) 2001 American Institute of Physics.

Stepwise addition reactions in ammonia synthesis: A first principles study

Catalytic ammonia synthesis is believed to proceed via dissociation of N-2 and H-2 with subsequent stepwise addition reactions from an adsorbed nitrogen atom to NH3. The first step, N-2 dissociation, has been thoroughly studied. However, little is known about the microscopic details of the stepwise addition reactions. To shed light on these stepwise addition reactions, density functional theory calculations with the generalized gradient approximation are employed to investigate NHx (x=1,3) formation on Ru(0001). Transition states and reaction barriers are determined in each elementary step. It is found that the reaction barriers for stepwise addition reactions are rather high, for example, the barrier for NH hydrogenation is calculated to be 1.28 eV, which is comparable with that of N-2 dissociation. In addition, one of the stepwise addition reactions on a stepped surface is also considered. The reaction barrier is found to be much higher than that of N-2 dissociation on the same stepped surface, which indicates the importance of stepwise addition reactions in ammonia synthesis. (C) 2001 American Institute of Physics.

Insight into electron-mediated reaction mechanisms: Catalytic CO oxidation on a ruthenium surface

Ruthenium is one of the poorest catalysts for CO oxidation under normal conditions (low or medium O coverage and normal temperature). However, a recent study [Science 285, 1042 (1999)] reveals that, under femtosecond laser irradiation, CO2 can be formed on the Ru surface, and the reaction follows an electron-mediated mechanism. We carried out density functional theory calculations to investigate CO oxidation via an electron-mediated mechanism on Ru(0001). By comparison to the reaction under normal conditions, following features emerge in the electron-mediated mechanism: (i) more reaction channels are open; (ii) the reaction barrier is significantly lowered. The physical origins for these novel features have been analyzed. (C) 2001 American Institute of Physics.

CO oxidation on Pd(100) and Pd(111): A comparative study of reaction pathways and reactivity at low and medium coverages

We have performed density functional theory calculations with the generalized gradient approximation to investigate CO oxidation on a close-packed transition metal surface, Pd(lll), and a more open surface, Pd(100), aiming to shed light on surface structure effects on reaction pathways and reactivity, an important issue in catalysis. Reaction pathways on both surfaces at two different coverages have been studied. It is found that the reaction pathways on both surfaces possess crucial common features despite the fact that they have different surface symmetries. Having determined reaction barriers in these systems, we find that the reaction on Pd(lll) is strongly coverage dependent. Surface coverages, however, have little effect on the reaction on Pd(100). Calculations also reveal that the low coverage reactions are structure sensitive while the medium coverage reactions are not. Detailed discussions on these results are given.

Softened C-H modes of adsorbed methyl and their implications for dehydrogenation: An ab initio study

To investigate the softening of CH vibrational frequencies and their implications for dehydrogenation of adsorbed hydrocarbons, an issue of scientific and technological importance, density functional theory calculations have been performed on the chemisorption and dehydrogenation of CH3 on Cu(111) and Pt(111) surfaces. By comparing these results with those of Ni(111) we find that the CH bonds of the adsorbate, when close enough, interact with metal atoms of the surface. It is this interaction and its associated lengthening and weakening of CH bonds that is the physical origin of mode softening. We rule out the possibility of a relationship between the mere presence of mode softening and dehydrogenation. We do show, however, that there is a clear relationship between the extent to which a surface can induce mode softening and the activation energy to dehydrogenation. In addition, periodic trends concerning the extent of mode softening are reproduced. (C) 2001 American Institute of Physics.