TTIP and Public Procurement: Going beyond the tip of the iceberg. CEPS Policy Brief No. 339, March 2016

Trade negotiations involving international public procurement rules are on the rise, stimulating a growing interest in having a clear picture of the economic stakes involved, including the current level of international openness. A recent paper published by the European Centre for International Political Economy (Messerlin, 2016) made an attempt to provide a range of estimates for the EU and the US and found relatively low rates of import penetration. This analytical approach, however, looked only at the ‘tip of the procurement iceberg’, as the data used covered primarily only one modality of international procurement (direct cross-border), which is not the main avenue for international government procurement. Other modalities, such as procurement from foreign subsidiaries established in Europe, account for much more. Such an approach therefore ignores the main modalities through which foreign firms win EU contracts. Once these other main procurement modalities are taken into account, EU openness in procurement is much higher. Comparable data across all modalities do not yet exist for the US, but we do have clear evidence that the US has introduced the largest number of protectionist procurement measures since 2008 affecting all modalities for international procurement. Against this background, this Policy Brief makes four basic points: i. Public procurement is a key area of trade negotiations, and TTIP is no exception to this rule. ii. The existing levels of openness in procurement markets need to be assessed across all three main procurement modalities and not based only on direct cross-border procurement, which is not the main procurement avenue. According to this comprehensive metric, the EU market already has a high foreign participation rate, including by US companies. iii. Unfortunately, similar data do not exist for the US market. But there is growing evidence of discriminatory measures introduced in recent years, which impede the ability of EU firms to compete on a level-playing field in US procurement markets. iv. The importance of procurement as a key negotiating area requires better data and a greater analytical engagement.

Democracy,

Natural rights of man.--Principles of democracy.--The Constitution.--Political economy.--Social welfare.--Religion.--Foreign affairs.--Appendix: 1. Axioms and dicta. II. Opinion of contemporaries. III. Select bibliography (p. 283-285)

Minutes of proceedings.

Mode of access: Internet.

Proceedings and transactions of the Royal Society of Canada. Déliberations et mémoires de la Société royale du Canada.

French title varies: 1882/83-<1965> Mémoires et comptes rendus de la Société royale du Canada; <1972-> Délibérations et mémoires de la Société royale du Canada.

Eighth International congress of applied chemistry, Washington and New York, September 4 to 13, 1912.

"Members": v. 28, p. 365-463.

Seventh International Congress of Applied Chemistry, London, May 27th to June 2d, 1909.

Edited by Sir William Ramsay, William Macnab, and others.

The complete works of Henry George ...

On cover: Complete works of Henry George. Fels fund. Library edition ...

Essays and addresses /

The pleasures of reading.--Bishop Berkeley's life and letters.--Handel.--Cobden and the Manchester school.--Politics and political economy.--A fragment of progress.--The religion of humanity.

History of shipping subsidies,

Originally published as the author's thesis, Iowa state university, 1898.

References for literary workers, with introductions to topics and questions for debate;

Introduction.--History.--Biography.--Politics.--Political economy.--Education.--Literature.--Art.--Science.--Philosophy.--Ethics.--Religion.--Miscellaneous.--Questions with references.--Questions without references.--Cyclopaedeas and periodicals referred to, with abbreviated forms.

Fu min ce : er juan /

Translation by W.E. Macklin of Henry George's Progress and poverty.

The collected writings of Thomas De Quincey,

Title within ornamental borders.

A letter to the Right Honorable Sir Robert Peel, bart. etc., on the condition of England, and on the means of removing the causes of distress.

Added title page: The budget. A series of letters on financial, commercial, and colonial policy. By a member of the Political Economy club. No. IX.

The works of John Ruskin.

v. 1-4. Modern painters.-v.5-6. The stones of Venice.-v.7. Seven lamps of architecture. Lectures on architecture and painting. The study of architecture. Poetry of architecture.-v.8. Two paths ... on art. Lectures on art. Political economy of art. Pre-Raphaelitism. Notes on the construction of sheepfolds. King of the golden river.-v.9. Elements of drawing. Elements of perspective. Aratra pentelici.-v.10. Ariadne Florentina. Fors clavigera.-v.11. Sesame and lilies. Ethics of the dust. Crown of wild olive. Queen of the air.-v.12. Time and tide. Unto this last. Munera pulveris. Eagle's nest.

The complete works of Henry George.

On cover: Complete works of Henry George.