Puomiankkurin uudelleensuunnittelu ja valmistus

Tämän diplomityön tavoitteena on ollut suunnitella uusi öljyntorjunnassa käytettävä puomiankkuri. Nykyisin käytössä olevat ankkurit ovat painavia, paljon tilaa vieviä, jäykkiä rakenteeltaan ja hankalia käyttää. Työn tavoitteena on ollut suunnitella rakenne, jossa muotoilun avulla pyritään korvaamaan ankkurin painoa ja saavuttaa hyvä tunkeutuminen eri pohjalaaduissa. Ankkurin suunnitteluun kuuluu merkittävänä osana materiaalinvalintaprosessi, jonka perusteella materiaaliksi valittiin kulutusteräs. Kulutusteräksen korkea lujuus ja hyvä kulumiskestävyys mahdollistavat ohuemman materiaalin käytön rakenteessa, jonka seurauksena rakenteen painoa saatiin vähennettyä merkittävästi. Ankkurin rakenteen suunnittelussa käytettiin hyväksi nykyisiä ankkurin rakenteita, joiden pohjalta hahmoteltiin eri variaatioita ankkureista. Suunnittelutyössä käytettiin hyväksi tyypillisiä ankkurirakenteita hyvien puolien kannalta, joita pyrittiin toteuttamaan uudessa ankkuri- rakenteessa. Ankkurin suunnittelu toteutettiin järjestelmällisen suunnittelun avulla, jossa ensin laadittiin ankkurille vaatimuslista. Tämän jälkeen laadittiin ankkurille toimintorakenne ja jakaminen osatoimintoihin. Ankkurin rakenteista toteutettiin kaksi eri versiota: sisävesillä ja merialueilla käytettävät ankkurit, joille laadittiin mitoitus. Työssä suunnitellun terävän tunkeutumisosan ja optimaalisen tunkeutumiskulman avulla ankkureiden painoa saatiin huomattavasti alhaisemmaksi, jonka seurauksena ankkurille saatiin kevyempi rakenne ja materiaalikustannukset pienenivät merkittävästi. Uusien ankkurien rakenne on pienemmän koon ja painon ansiosta käyttäjäystävällisempi.

Stop bugging me! : diversity in appearance of warning coloration

In nature, many animals use body coloration to communicate with each other. For example, colorations can be used as signals between individuals of the same species, but also to recognise individuals of other species, and if they may comprise a threat or not. Many animals use protective coloration to avoid predation. The two most common strategies of protective coloration are camouflage and aposematism. Camouflaged animals have coloration that minimises detection, usually by matching colours or structures in the background. Aposematic animals, on the other hand, signal to predators that they are defended. The defence can be physical structures, such as spikes and hairs, or chemical compounds that make the animal distasteful or even deadly toxic. In order for the warning signal to be effective, the predator has to recognise it as such. Studies have shown that birds for example, that are important visual predators on insects, learn to recognise and avoid unpalatable prey faster if they contrast the background or have large internal contrasts. Typical examples of aposematic species have conspicuous colours like yellow, orange or red, often in combination with black. My thesis focuses on the appearance and function of aposematic colour patterns. Even though researchers have studied aposematism for over a century, there is still a lot we do not know about the phenomenon. For example, as it is crucial that the predators recognise a warning signal, aposematic colorations should assumingly evolve homogeneously and be selected for maximal conspicuousness. Instead, there is an extensive variation of colours and patterns among warning colorations, and it is not uncommon to find typical cryptic colours, such as green and brown in aposematic colour patterns. One hypothesis to this variation is that an aposematic coloration does not have to be maximally signalling in order to be effective, instead it is sufficient to have distinct features that can be easily distinguished from edible prey. To be maximally conspicuous is one way to achieve this, but not the only way. Another hypothesis is that aposematic prey that do not exhibit maximal conspicuousness can exploit both camouflage and aposematism in a distance-dependent fashion, by being signalling when seen close up but camouflaged at a distance. Many prey animals also make use of both strategies by shifting colour at different ecological conditions such as seasonal variations, fluctuations in food resources or between life stages. Yet another explanation for the variation may be that prey animals are usually exposed to several predator species that vary in visual perception and tolerance towards various toxins. The aim with this thesis is, by studying their functions, to understand why aposematic warning signals vary in appearance, specifically in the level of conspicuousness, and if warning coloration can be combined with camouflage. In paper I, I investigated if the colour pattern of the aposematic larva of the Apollo butterfly (Parnassius apollo) can switch function with viewing distance, and be signalling at close range but camouflaged at a distance, by comparing detection time between different colour variants and distances. The results show that the natural coloration has a dual distance-dependent function. Moreover, the study shows that an aposematic coloration does not have to be selected for maximal conspicuousness. A prey animal can optimise its coloration primarily by avoiding detection, but also by investing in a secondary defence, which presence can be signalled if detected. In paper II, I studied how easily detected the coloration of the firebug (Pyrrhocoris apterus), a typical aposematic species, is at different distances against different natural backgrounds, by comparing detection time between different colour variants. Here, I found no distance-dependent switch in function. Instead, the results show that the coloration of the firebug is selected for maximal conspicuousness. One explanation for this is that the firebug is more mobile than the butterfly larva in study I, and movement is often incompatible with efficient camouflage. In paper III, I investigated if a seasonal related colour change in the chemically defended striated shieldbug (Graphosoma lineatum) is an adaptation to optimise a protective coloration by shifting from camouflage to aposematism between two seasons. The results confirm the hypothesis that the coloration expressed in the late summer has a camouflage function, blending in with the background. Further, I investigated if the internal pattern as such increased the effectiveness of the camouflage. Again, the results are in accordance with the hypothesis, as the patterned coloration was more difficult to detect than colorations lacking an internal pattern. This study shows how an aposematic species can optimise its defence by shifting from camouflage to aposematism, but in a different fashion than studied in paper I. The aim with study IV was to study the selection on aposematic signals by identifying characteristics that are common for colorations of aposematic species, and that distinguish them from colorations of other species. I compared contrast, pattern element size and colour proportion between a group of defended species and a group of undefended species. In contrast to my prediction, the results show no significant differences between the two groups in any of the analyses. One explanation for the non-significant results could be that there are no universal characteristics common for aposematic species. Instead, the selection pressures acting on defended species vary, and therefore affect their appearance differently. Another explanation is that all defended species may not have been selected for a conspicuous aposematic warning coloration. Taken together, my thesis shows that having a conspicuous warning coloration is not the only way to be aposematic. Also, aposematism and camouflage is not two mutually exclusive opposites, as there are prey species that exploit both strategies. It is also important to understand that prey animals are exposed to various selection pressures and trade-offs that affect their appearance, and determines what an optimal coloration is for each species or environment. In conclusion, I hold that the variation among warning colorations is larger and coloration properties that have been considered as archetypically aposematic may not be as widespread and representative as previously assumed.

Follicle and corpus luteum size and vascularity as predictors of fertility at the time of artificial insemination and embryo transfer in beef cattle

Abstract:Two ultrasound based fertility prediction methods were tested prior to embryo transfer (ET) and artificial insemination (AI) in cattle. Female bovines were submitted to estrous synchronization prior to ET and AI. Animals were scanned immediately before ET and AI procedure to target follicle and corpus luteum (CL) size and vascularity. In addition, inseminated animals were also scanned eleven days after insemination to target CL size and vascularity. All data was compared with fertility by using gestational diagnosis 35 days after ovulation. Prior to ET, CL vascularity showed a positive correlation with fertility, and no pregnancy occurred in animals with less than 40% of CL vascularity. Prior to AI and also eleven days after AI, no relationship with fertility was seen in all parameters analyzed (follicle and CL size and vascularity), and contrary, cows with CL vascularity greater than 70% exhibit lower fertility. In inseminated animals, follicle size and vascularity was positive related with CL size and vascularity, as shown by the presence of greater CL size and vascularity originated from follicle with also greater size and vascularity. This is the first time that ultrasound based fertility prediction methods were tested prior to ET and AI and showed an application in ET, but not in AI programs. Further studies are needed including hormone profile evaluation to improve conclusion.

Cardiothoracic ratio and vertebral heart size (VHS) to standardize the heart size of the tufted capuchin (Cebus apella Linnaeus, 1758) in computerized radiographic images

Abstract: The VHS and CTR were assessed using computerized thoracic radiographs of ten clinically healthy tufted capuchin monkeys (five males and five females) from the Wild Animal Screening Center in São Luís (Centro de Triagem de Animais Silvestres de São Luís-MA-CETAS). Radiographs were taken in laterolateral and dorsoventral projections to calculate the cardiothoracic ratio (VHS) and vertebral heart size (CTR). The VHS showed mean values of 9.34±0.32v (males) and 9.16±0.34v (females) and there was no statistical difference between males and females (p>0.05). The CTR showed mean values of 0.55±0.04 (males) and 0.52±0.03 (females) and there was no statistical difference between the sexes (p>0.05). There was positive correlation between VHS and CTR (r=0.78). The thoracic and heart diameters showed mean values of 5.70±0.48cm and 2.16±0.40cm in the males, respectively. In the females they measured 5.32±0.39cm and 2.94±0.32cm. There was no statistical difference between the sexes. Our results show that the high correlation found between VHS and CTR permitted the verification with similar clinical precision between the two methods to estimate alterations in the heart silhouette by radiographic examination of tufted capuchin, making it an easy technique to apply that can be considered in the investigation of heart problems for this wild species.

Is there correlation between the turbulent eddies size and mechanical hemolysis ?

Hemolytic profile of an artificial device chronically implanted in the cardiovascular system may represent the difference between the success and failure in its long-term performance. Last decades have witnessed efforts on the development of methods capable of predicting red blood cell damage in artificial organs. However, all of them have had limited success to predict hemolysis. The primary cause of this problem is that such models do not take into consideration structures of turbulent flow. The present paper demonstrates that microscopic measurable occurrences of the turbulent flow may be linked to red blood cell trauma. This study suggests that if the smallest turbulent eddies dimension is under 10 m m hemolysis is not dependent on the exposure time and the red blood cells damage depends only on the dissipation of the turbulent energy in the erythrocyte membrane. The analysis reported here opens the possibility of mapping the flow field in artificial assist devices based on the smallest eddy length scales. This is a promising new trend and should be considered in the designing requirements of the next generations of artificial organs.

Drop Size Measurements in a Laboratory Scale Venturi Scrubber

Venturi scrubbers are high efficiency gas cleaners in which suspended particles are removed from gas streams by droplets formed by liquid atomisation, usually in the venturi throat. The size of the droplets formed is of fundamental importance to the performance of the equipment, both in terms of pressure drop and collection efficiency. In this study, drop sizes in a cylindrical laboratory scale venturi scrubber were measured using a laser diffraction technique. Gas velocity and liquid to gas ratios varied from 50 to 90 m/s and 0.5 to 2.0 l/m3, respectively. Water was inserted as perpendicular jets at the beginning of the throat. Measurements were performed at three positions: two located along the throat, and the last one at the end of the diffuser. The data presented here are a typical example of pneumatic atomisation and can be relevant to other industrial applications such as combustion and engine technology. Finally, results are compared to available correlations and the validity of these equations is discussed.

Horizontal Slug Flow in a Large-Size Pipeline: Experimentation and Modeling

The knowledge of the slug flow characteristics is very important when designing pipelines and process equipment. When the intermittences typical in slug flow occurs, the fluctuations of the flow variables bring additional concern to the designer. Focusing on this subject the present work discloses the experimental data on slug flow characteristics occurring in a large-size, large-scale facility. The results were compared with data provided by mechanistic slug flow models in order to verify their reliability when modelling actual flow conditions. Experiments were done with natural gas and oil or water as the liquid phase. To compute the frequency and velocity of the slug cell and to calculate the length of the elongated bubble and liquid slug one used two pressure transducers measuring the pressure drop across the pipe diameter at different axial locations. A third pressure transducer measured the pressure drop between two axial location 200 m apart. The experimental data were compared with results of Camargo's1 algorithm (1991, 1993), which uses the basics of Dukler & Hubbard's (1975) slug flow model, and those calculated by the transient two-phase flow simulator OLGA.

Russia, China, India Foresight for Small and Medium size Enterprises in Uusimaa : Changes forecast in the Russian, Chinese and Indian operating environments from the viewpoint of small and middle-sized enterprises in Uusimaa

The report describes those factors of the future that are related to the growth and needs of Russia, China, and India and that may provide significant internationalisation potential for Uusimaa companies. The report examines the emerging trends and market-entry challenges for each country separately. Additionally, it evaluates the training needs of Uusimaa companies in terms of the current offerings available for education on topics related to Russia, China, and India. The report was created via the Delphi method: experts were interviewed, and both Trendwiki material and the latest literature were used to create a summary of experts’ views, statements, and reasons behind recent developments. This summary of views was sent back to the experts with the objective of reaching consensus synthesising the differing views or, at least, of providing argumentation for the various alternative lines of development. In addition to a number of outside experts and business leaders, all heads of Finpro’s Finland Trade Centers participated in the initial interviews. The summary was commented upon by all Finpro consultants and analysts for Russia, China, and India, with each focusing on his or her own area of expertise. The literature used consisted of reports, listed for each country, and an extensive selection of the most recent newspaper articles. The report was created in January-April 2010. On 22 April 2010 its results were reviewed at the final report presentation in cooperation with the Uusimaa ELY Centre.

Indoor air quality at a waste incineration plant in Finland

Waste has been incinerated for energy utilization for more than a hundred years, but the harmful emissions emitted from the incineration plants did not begin to cause concern until the 1980s. Many plants were shutdown and the waste incineration plant in Kyläsaari Helsinki was one of them. In later years, new landfill regulations have increased the interest in waste incineration. During the last year, four new plants were taken into operation in Finland, Westenergy in Vaasa among them. The presence of dust has been observed indoors at Westenergy waste incineration plant. Dust is defined as particles with a diameter above 10 μm, while fine particles have a diameter smaller than 2.5 μm, ultrafine under 0.1 μm and nanoparticles under 0.05 μm. In recent years, the focus of particle health research has been changed to investigate smaller particles. Ultrafine particles have been found to be more detrimental to health than larger particles. Limit values regulating the concentrations of ultrafine particles have not been determined yet. The objective of this thesis was to investigate dust and particles present inside the Westenergy waste incineration facility. The task was to investigate the potential pollutant sources and to give recommendations of how to minimize the presence of dust and particles in the power plant. The total particle number concentrations and size distributions where measured at 15 points inside the plant with an Engine Exhaust Particle Sizer (EEPS) Spectrometer. The measured particles were mainly in the ultrafine size range. Dust was only visually investigated, since the main purpose was to follow the dust accumulation. The measurement points inside the incineration plant were chosen according to investigate exposure to visitors and workers. At some points probable leakage of emissions were investigated. The measurements were carried out during approximately one month in March–April 2013. The results of the measurements showed that elevated levels of dust and particles are present in the indoor air at the waste incineration plant. The cleanest air was found in the control room, warehouse and office. The most polluted air was near the sources that were investigated due to possible leakage and in the bottom ash hall. However, the concentrations were near measured background concentrations in European cities and no leakage could be detected. The high concentrations were assumed to be a result of a lot of dust and particles present on surfaces that had not been cleaned in a while. The main source of the dust and particles present inside the waste incineration plant was thought to be particles and dust from the outside air. Other activities in the area around the waste incineration facility are ground work activities, stone crushing and traffic, which probably are sources of particle formation. Filtration of the outside air prior entering the facility would probably save personnel and visitors from nuisance and save in cleaning and maintenance costs.

Etelä-Savon bioenergia-alan yritysten kansainvälistymismahdollisuudet Saksan markkinoilla

Pienten ja keskisuurten yritysten kansainvälistyminen etenee tyypillisesti hyvin maltillisesti, askel-askeleelta. Kotimarkkinoiden rajalliset kasvumahdollisuudet ja kansainvälisten markkinoiden houkuttelevuus ovat tärkeimpiä syitä vientitoiminnan aloittamiselle. Nykyisessä globaalissa liiketoimintaympäristössä kilpailu on kovaa ja vaatii yrityksiltä paljon osaamista ja resursseja. Pk-yritysten rajallisia resursseja voidaan kehittää ja lisätä yritysten välisen verkostoitumisen ja ulkopuolisten toimijoiden avulla. Tämä diplomityö on toteutettu osana Cleantech Finland Bioenergy –kehitysprojektia, joka pyrkii edistämään Savon alueen bioenergia-alan yritysten kansainvälistymis-mahdollisuuksia. Tutkimuksen tavoitteena on kasvattaa tietoutta erilaisista kansainvälistymisstrategioista ja vientitoiminnan vaatimista toimenpiteistä. Empiirisen tutkimuksen tärkein tavoite on tukea tutkimuksessa mukana olevien pk-yritysten kansainvälisen liiketoiminnan aloittamista. Tutkimuksen tulokset osoittavat, että kehittyvä bioenergia-ala ja Saksan markkinat tarjoavat pk-yrityksille kasvumahdollisuuksia. Tuloksissa painotetaan pk-yritysten oman osaamisen kehittämistä ja kykyä pitkäjänteiseen työhön. Ymmärtämällä asiakkaiden ostopäätösprosessia, voidaan omaa myynti- ja markkinointiosaamista sekä rajallisia resursseja keskittää oikeisiin asioihin.

Influence of seed size and ecological factors on the germination and emergence of field bindweed (Convolvulus arvensis)

An understanding of seed germination ecology of weeds can assist in predicting their potential distribution and developing effective management strategies. Influence of environmental factors and seed size on germination and seedling emergence of Convolvulus arvensis (field bindweed) was studied in laboratory and greenhouse conditions. Germination occurred over a wide range of constant temperatures, between 15 and 40 ºC, with optimum germination between 20 and 25 ºC. Time to start germination, time to 50% germination and mean germination time increased while germination percentage and germination index decreased with an increase in temperature from 20 ºC, salinity and osmotic stress. However, germination was tolerant to low salt (25 mM) or osmotic stress (0.2 MPa), but as salinity and osmotic stress increased, germination percentage and germination index decreased. Seeds of C. arvensis placed at soil surface showed maximum emergence and decreased as seeding depth increased. Seeds of C. arvensis germinated over a wide range of pH (4 to 9) but optimum germination occurred at pH 6 to 8. Under highly alkaline and acidic pH, time to start germination, time to 50% germination and mean germination time increased while germination percentage and germination index decreased. Increase in field capacity caused decreased time to start germination, time to 50% germination and mean germination time but increased germination percentage and germination index. Bigger seeds had low time to start germination, time to 50% germination and mean germination time but high germination percentage and germination index. Smaller seeds were more sensitive to environmental factors as compared to larger or medium seeds. It can be concluded that except for pH, all environmental factors and seed sizes adversely affect C. arvensis as regards seed germination or emergence and germination or emergence traits, and larger seeds result in improved stand establishment and faster germination than small seeds, regardless of moisture stress or deeper seeding depth.

2.6 MW:n tuulivoimakonvertterin nestejäähdytysjärjestelmän komponentit ja hinnat

Tässä tutkimuksessa selvitettiin nestejäähdytteisen 2.6 MW:n tuulivoimakonvertterin jäähdytysjärjestelmään kuuluvat komponentit ja niiden hinnat. Tällä pyritään helpottamaan uutta teknologiaa hyödyntävien jäähdytysjärjestelmien kehittäjiä kaupallistamaan tuotteensa selvittämällä heille nykyisten jäähdytysjärjestelmien hintaluokka. Työ tehtiin kirjallisuuskatsauksena ja lähteinä käytettiin pääasiassa ABB:lta saatavia julkisia materiaaleja. Komponenttien hinnat haettiin internetin hakukoneiden avulla, sekä lähettämällä tarjouspyyntöjä myyjille, jotka eivät hintojaan olleet suoraan ilmoittaneet. Hinnat komponenteista kerättiin 1, 10, 50 ja 100 kappaleen toimituserille, jolloin voitiin vertailla myös kuinka paljon edullisemmaksi sarjatuotanto tulisi, kuin yksittäisen tuotteen valmistaminen. Tuloksista huomattiin, että konvertterikaapiston sisäiset jäähdytysjärjestelmään kuuluvat komponentit muodostavat vain pienen osan siitä hinnasta, mikä aiheutuu ulkopuolisesta jäähdytysyksiköstä, johon kaapisto on kytkettävä. Käytettäessä yksittäistä jäähdytysyksikköä on koko jäähdytysjärjestelmän hinta 14-15 000 €, josta ulkoisen jäähdytysyksikön osuus on 12 000 €, eli yli 80 % kokonaishinnasta. Sarjatuotannossa hinta putoaa etenkin jäähdytysyksikön osalta huomattavasti. Uusia teknologioita kaupallistettaessa on niiden kokonaisuudessaan oltava tätä summaa halvempia, johon paras tapa päästä on keskittää huomionsa ulkoisen jäähdytysyksikön kustannusten laskemiseen. Toinen vaihtoehto kaupalliseen menestykseen, on tehdä samanhintainen jäähdytysjärjestelmä, mutta jäähdytysteholtaan huomattavasti tehokkaampi, sekä kooltaan pienempi.

Weed control in corn and weed sample size for growth evaluations

The objectives of this study were to evaluate baby corn yield, green corn yield, and grain yield in corn cultivar BM 3061, with weed control achieved via a combination of hoeing and intercropping with gliricidia, and determine how sample size influences weed growth evaluation accuracy. A randomized block design with ten replicates was used. The cultivar was submitted to the following treatments: A = hoeings at 20 and 40 days after corn sowing (DACS), B = hoeing at 20 DACS + gliricidia sowing after hoeing, C = gliricidia sowing together with corn sowing + hoeing at 40 DACS, D = gliricidia sowing together with corn sowing, and E = no hoeing. Gliricidia was sown at a density of 30 viable seeds m-2. After harvesting the mature ears, the area of each plot was divided into eight sampling units measuring 1.2 m² each to evaluate weed growth (above-ground dry biomass). Treatment A provided the highest baby corn, green corn, and grain yields. Treatment B did not differ from treatment A with respect to the yield values for the three products, and was equivalent to treatment C for green corn yield, but was superior to C with regard to baby corn weight and grain yield. Treatments D and E provided similar yields and were inferior to the other treatments. Therefore, treatment B is a promising one. The relation between coefficient of experimental variation (CV) and sample size (S) to evaluate growth of the above-ground part of the weeds was given by the equation CV = 37.57 S-0.15, i.e., CV decreased as S increased. The optimal sample size indicated by this equation was 4.3 m².

Seulamurskaimen murskausominaisuuksien tutkiminen ja kehittäminen

Työn tavoitteena oli kehittää seulamurskaimen murskausprosessia selvittämällä murskaukseen vaikuttavia tekijöitä. Murskausprosessin sisäistämisen myötä voidaan saavuttaa parempi jaekoon hallinta, parantaa kapasiteettia sekä luoda tehokkaampia murskaussovelluksia. Murskausprosessia tutkittiin aluksi murskaukseen vaikuttavien teorioiden kautta. Teoriapohjaista tietoa ja murskaustapahtumaa tutkittiin käytännön testeillä, joissa testattiin seulamurskainta useilla eri materiaaleilla ja erilaisilla tuotevariaatioilla. Testeissä kerättiin näytteitä jaekoon jatkotutkimusta varten sekä saatujen tulosten pohjalta vertailtiin eri tuotevariaatioiden keskeisiä eroja. Saavutettuja tuloksia analysoitiin ja kehitettiin uusia potentiaalisia ratkaisuja seulamurskaimiin. Seulamurskaimen nykyinen rakenne on kehitetty ennen kaikkea seulontasovelluksiin ja sen toiminta perustuu rungon sisällä materiaalin pyörivään liikkeeseen. Murskausprosessissa on kuitenkin oleellista pyrkiä vähentämään sisäistä pyörintäliikettä, joka on hidasteena kappaleiden murskaukselle. Lisäksi seulamurskaimessa on useita rakenteita, jotka on kehitetty erityisesti seulontaa varten ja niiden uudenlaisella rakennesuunnittelulla voitaisiin saavuttaa huomattavasti parempia tuloksia murskauksen kannalta. Nämä tekijät kuitenkin vaativat huomattavan paljon tehoa, mikä puolestaan saattaa asettaa uusia haasteita suunnitteluun, sillä seulamurskaimessa käytettävissä oleva teho on varsin rajallinen.

Hallintoelinten oikeudenmukainen palkitseminen - toimialavertailu osuustoiminnallisissa organisaatioissa

Työn tarkoituksena oli lähteä tutkimaan palkitsemisen, vaativuuden ja tehtävien eroavaisuuksia kolmen osuustoiminnallisen organisaation hallintoelinten välillä. Tavoitteena oli selvittää, miten palkitsemisen horisontaalista oikeudenmukaisuutta voitaisiin kehittää osuustoiminnallisten organisaatioiden hallintoelimissä. Tutkimus toteutettiin kvantitatiivisena kyselylomaketutkimuksena, ja analysointimenetelmänä käytettiin regressioanalyysiä. Tutkimuksen teoreettinen viitekehys koostui palkitsemisesta ja sen oikeudenmukaisuudesta keskittyen horisontaaliseen ulottuvuuteen, työn vaativuudesta sekä aiempien tutkimusten perusteella palkitsemiseen vaikuttavista tekijöistä muun muassa rakenteen, toimialan ja strategian näkökulmista. Tutkimuksessa havaittiin, että tilaajaorganisaatiossa X palkkiot olivat vertailuorganisaatiota Y ja Z korkeammat. Erot vaativuuden ja tehtävien osalta eivät olleet yhtä suuria kuin palkkioissa, mutta organisaatiossa X nämäkin olivat pääasiassa korkeammalla tasolla. Regressioanalyysissä kävi ilmi, että työn vaativuus selittää suurimman osan palkitsemisen kertymästä ja muut tilastollisesti merkittävät selittävät muuttujat olivat huomattavasti vähäisempiä. Organisaation X korkeamman palkkiotason voitiin nähdä johtuvan erilaisesta palkkiorakenteesta sekä siitä, että se otti palkitsemisessa organisaation koon huomioon; palkkiot vaihtelivat huomattavasti enemmän alueorganisaatioiden kesken kuin organisaatiossa Y ja Z. Johtopäätöksenä voidaan sanoa, että työn vaativuusarviointi palkkioiden horisontaalista oikeudenmukaisuutta arvioitaessa on merkittävimmässä asemassa. Muiden tarkasteltujen muuttujien osalta tulokset eivät olleet aivan odotetun kaltaisia tai täysin yhdenmukaisia aiempien tutkimusten kanssa, vaikka samansuuntaisiakin havaintoja saatiin. Työn tärkein anti oli kuitenkin työn vaativuusarvioinnin tärkeyden havaitseminen hallintoelintyön palkitsemisen yhteydessä horisontaalisella tasolla.