Critical appraisal of meta-analyses: an introductory guide for the practicing surgeon

ABSTRACT: Meta-analyses are an essential tool of clinical research. Meta-analyses of individual randomized controlled trials frequently constitute the highest possible level of scientific evidence for a given research question and allow surgeons to rapidly gain a comprehensive understanding of an important clinical issue. Moreover, meta-analyses often serve as cornerstones for evidence-based surgery, treatment guidelines, and knowledge transfer. Given the importance of meta-analyses to the medical (and surgical) knowledge base, it is of cardinal importance that surgeons have a basic grasp of the principles that guide a high-quality meta-analysis, and be able to weigh objectively the advantages and potential pitfalls of this clinical research tool. Unfortunately, surgeons are often ill-prepared to successfully conduct, critically appraise, and correctly interpret meta-analyses. The objective of this educational review is to provide surgeons with a brief introductory overview of the knowledge and skills required for understanding and critically appraising surgical meta-analyses as well as assessing their implications for their own surgical practice.

Effects of growth hormone (GH) replacement therapy on low-density lipoprotein apolipoprotein B100 kinetics in adult patients with GH deficiency: a stable isotope study

GH replacement therapy has been shown to improve the dyslipidemic condition in a substantial proportion of patients with adult GH deficiency. The mechanisms are not yet fully elucidated. Low-density lipoprotein (LDL) apolipoprotein B100 (apoB) formation and catabolism are important determinants of plasma cholesterol concentrations. This study examined the effect of GH replacement therapy on LDL apoB metabolism using a stable isotope turnover technique. LDL apoB kinetics was determined in 13 adult patients with GH deficiency before and after 3 months GH/placebo treatment in a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study. LDL apoB (13)C-leucine enrichment was determined by isotope-ratio mass spectrometry. Plasma volume was assessed by standardized radionuclide dilution technique. GH replacement therapy significantly decreased LDL cholesterol, LDL apoB concentrations, and LDL apoB pool size compared with placebo. Compared with baseline, GH replacement therapy resulted in a significant increase in plasma volume and fractional catabolic rate, whereas LDL formation rate remained unchanged. LDL lipid content did not significantly change after GH and placebo. This study suggests that short-term GH replacement therapy decreases the LDL apoB pool by increasing removal of LDL particles without changing LDL composition or LDL apoB production rate. In addition, it is possible that the beneficial effects of GH on the cardiovascular system contribute to these findings.

The effect of growth hormone (GH) replacement therapy in adult patients with type 1 diabetes mellitus and GH deficiency

Specific problems in patients with insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) and GH deficiency are hypoglycaemic attacks, increased insulin sensitivity and loss of energy. These problems may be related to GH deficiency.

Effects of growth hormone (GH) replacement therapy on very low density lipoprotein apolipoprotein B100 kinetics in patients with adult GH deficiency: a stable isotope study

Patients with adult GH deficiency are often dyslipidemic and may have an increased risk of cardiovascular disease. The secretion and clearance of very low density lipoprotein apolipoprotein B 100 (VLDL apoB) are important determinants of plasma lipid concentrations. This study examined the effect of GH replacement therapy on VLDL apoB metabolism using a stable isotope turnover technique. VLDL apoB kinetics were determined in 14 adult patients with GH deficiency before and after 3 months GH or placebo treatment in a randomized double blind, placebo-controlled study using a primed constant [1-(13)C]leucine infusion. VLDL apoB enrichment was determined by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry. GH replacement therapy increased plasma insulin-like growth factor I concentrations 2.9 +/- 0.5-fold (P < 0.001), fasting insulin concentrations 1.8 +/- 0.6-fold (P < 0.04), and hemoglobin A1C from 5.0 +/- 0.2% to 5.3 +/- 0.2% (mean +/- SEM; P < 0.001). It decreased fat mass by 3.4 +/- 1.3 kg (P < 0.05) and increased lean body mass by 3.5 +/- 0.8 kg (P < 0.01). The total cholesterol concentration (P < 0.02), the low density lipoprotein cholesterol concentration (P < 0.02), and the VLDL cholesterol/VLDL apoB ratio (P < 0.005) decreased. GH therapy did not significantly change the VLDL apoB pool size, but increased the VLDL apoB secretion rate from 9.2 +/- 2.0 to 25.9 +/- 10.3 mg/kg x day (P < 0.01) and the MCR from 11.5 +/- 2.7 to 20.3 +/- 3.2 mL/min (P < 0.03). No significant changes were observed in the placebo group. This study suggests that GH replacement therapy improves lipid profile by increasing the removal of VLDL apoB. Although GH therapy stimulates VLDL apoB secretion, this is offset by the increase in the VLDL apoB clearance rate, which we postulate is due to its effects in up-regulating low density lipoprotein receptors and modifying VLDL composition.

The importance of growth hormone in the regulation of erythropoiesis, red cell mass, and plasma volume in adults with growth hormone deficiency

Total body water (TBW) is reduced in adult GH deficiency (GHD) largely due to a reduction of extracellular water. It is unknown whether total blood volume (TBV) contributes to the reduced extracellular water in GHD. GH and insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-I) have been demonstrated to stimulate erythropoiesis in vitro, in animal models, and in growing children. Whether GH has a regulatory effect on red cell mass (RCM) in adults is not known. We analyzed body composition by bioelectrical impedance and used standard radionuclide dilution methods to measure RCM and plasma volume (PV) along with measuring full blood count, ferritin, vitamin B12, red cell folate, IGF-I, IGF-binding protein-3, and erythropoietin in 13 adult patients with GHD as part of a 3-month, double blind, placebo-controlled trial of GH (0.036 U/kg.day). TBW and lean body mass significantly increased by 2.5 +/- 0.53 kg (mean +/- SEM; P < 0.004) and 3.4 +/- 0.73 kg (P < 0.004), respectively, and fat mass significantly decreased by 2.4 +/- 0.32 kg (P < 0.001) in the GH-treated group. The baseline RCM of all patients with GHD was lower than the predicted normal values (1635 +/- 108 vs. 1850 +/- 104 mL; P < 0.002). GH significantly increased RCM, PV, and TBV by 183 +/- 43 (P < 0.006), 350 +/- 117 (P < 0.03), and 515 +/- 109 (P < 0.004) mL, respectively. The red cell count increased by 0.36 +/- 0.116 x 10(12)/L (P < 0.03) with a decrease in ferritin levels by 39.1 +/- 4.84 micrograms/L (P < 0.001) after GH treatment. Serum IGF-I and IGF-binding protein-3 concentrations increased by 3.0 +/- 0.43 (P < 0.001) and 1.3 +/- 0.15 (P < 0.001) SD, respectively, but the erythropoietin concentration was unchanged after GH treatment. No significant changes in body composition or blood volume were recorded in the placebo group. Significant positive correlations could be established between changes in TBW and TBV, lean body mass and TBV (r = 0.78; P < 0.04 and r = 0.77; P < 0.04, respectively), and a significant negative correlation existed between changes in fat mass and changes in TBV in the GH-treated group (r = -0.95; P < 0.02). We conclude that 1) erythropoiesis is impaired in GHD; 2) GH stimulates erythropoiesis in adult GHD; and 3) GH increases PV and TBV, which may contribute to the increased exercise performance seen in these patients.

The consequences of growth hormone deficiency in adulthood, and the effects of growth hormone replacement

The availability of recombinant human growth hormone (GH) has resulted in investigation of the role of GH in adulthood and the effects of GH replacement in the GH-deficient adult. These studies have led to the recognition of a specific syndrome of GH-deficiency, characterized by symptoms, signs and investigative findings. Adults with long-standing growth hormone deficiency are often overweight, have altered body composition, with reduced lean body mass (LBM), increased fat mass (FM), reduced total body water and reduced bone mass. In addition, there is reduced physical and cardiac performance, altered substrate metabolism and an abnormal lipid profile predisposing to the development of cardiovascular disease. Adults with GH deficiency report reduced psychological well-being and quality of life. These changes may contribute to the morbidity and premature mortality observed in hypopituitary adults on conventional replacement therapy. GH treatment restores LBM, reduces FM, increases total body water and increases bone mass. Following GH therapy, increases are recorded in exercise capacity and protein synthesis, and "favourable" alterations occur in plasma lipids. In addition, psychological well-being and quality of life improve with replacement therapy. GH is well tolerated; adverse effects are largely related to fluid retention and respond to dose adjustment. It is likely that GH replacement will become standard therapy for the hypopituitary adult in the near future. The benefits of GH replacement in the GH-deficient adult have been unequivocally demonstrated in studies lasting up to 3 years. The results of longer term studies are awaited to determine whether these benefits are sustained over a lifetime.

Calibration and analysis of the 2007 data

he physics program of the NA61/SHINE (SHINE = SPS Heavy Ion and Neutrino Experiment) experiment at the CERN SPS consists of three subjects. In the first stage of data taking (2007-2009) measurements of hadron production in hadron-nucleus interactions needed for neutrino (T2K) and cosmic-ray (Pierre Auger and KASCADE) experiments will be performed. In the second stage (2009-2010) hadron production in proton-proton and proton-nucleus interactions needed as reference data for a better understanding of nucleus-nucleus reactions will be studied. In the third stage (2009-2013) energy dependence of hadron production properties will be measured in p+p, p+Pb interactions and nucleus-nucleus collisions, with the aim to identify the properties of the onset of deconfinement and find evidence for the critical point of strongly interacting matter. The NA61 experiment was approved at CERN in June 2007. The first pilot run was performed during October 2007. Calibrations of all detector components have been performed successfully and preliminary uncorrected spectra have been obtained. High quality of track reconstruction and particle identification similar to NA49 has been achieved. The data and new detailed simulations confirm that the NA61 detector acceptance and particle identification capabilities cover the phase space required by the T2K experiment. This document reports on the progress made in the calibration and analysis of the 2007 data.