Why Do Some International Institutions Contain Strong Dispute Settlement Provisions: New Evidence from Preferential Trade Agreements

To understand why some international institutions have stronger dispute settlement mechanisms (DSMs) than others, we investigate the dispute settlement provisions of nearly 600 preferential trade agreements (PTAs), which possess several desirable case-selection features and are evoked more than is realized. We broaden the study of dispute settlement design beyond “legalization” and instead reorient theorizing around a multi-faceted conceptualization of the strength of DSMs. We posit that strong DSMs are first and foremost a rational response to features of agreements that require stronger dispute settlement, such as depth and large memberships. Multivariate empirical tests using a new data set on PTA design confirm these expectations and reveal that depth – the amount of policy change specified in an agreement – is the most powerful and consistent predictor of DSM strength, providing empirical support to a long-posited but controversial conjecture. Yet power also plays a sizeable role, since agreements among asymmetric members are more likely to have strong DSMs due to their mutual appeal, as are those involving the United States. Important regional differences also emerge, as PTAs across the Americas are designed with strong dispute settlement, as are Asian PTAs, which contradicts the conventional wisdom about Asian values and legalization. Our findings demonstrate that rationalism explains much of international institutional design, yet it can be enhanced by also incorporating power-based and regional explanations.

Ratemaking agreements covering rates from Hong Kong, Macao and Taiwan to U.S. Atlantic and Gulf Coast ports, FONSI-EA.

Mode of access: Internet.

Hearings on H.R. 10451, Navy nuclear career incentive act, before the Subcommittee on Military Compensation of the Committee on Armed Services, House of Representatives, Ninety-fourth Congress, first session ...

Mode of access: Internet.

BLS measures of compensation.

"February 1986"

Federal employee compensation program, Basic claims examiner training course : resource book.

Spine title: Basic claims examiner training course. Resource book.

Civilians in DOD : their productivity and compensation

Cover title

Women in the military : Air Force revises job availability but entry screening needs review : report to the Chairman, Subcommittee on Military Personnel and Compensation, Committee on Armed Services, House of Representatives /

"B-230552"--p. 1.

Reciprocal trade agreements program : hearings before the Committee on ways and means, House of Representatives, Eightieth Congress, first session : on the operation of the Trade agreements act and the proposed International trade organization.

No more published?

Uneconomical practices in the administration of employment service and unemployment compensation programs, Bureau of Employment Security, Department of Labor /

Mode of access: Internet.

Legislative restrictions on union security agreements.

"March 1948."

Cantaloups; report on escape-clause investigation no. 7-98, under the provisions of section 7 of the Trade agreements extension act of 1951, as amended.

Mode of access: Internet.

Violins and violas; report to the President on escape-clause investigation no. 55 under the provisions of section 7 of the Trade agreements extension act of 1951, as amended.

Mode of access: Internet.

Unemployment compensation, what and why? /

"This brief study of the purposes and operation of the unemployment compensation systems was written by Gladys R. Friedman, technical advisor in the Division of legislative aid." -- p. [II].

The federal-state program for unemployment compensation /

"December 1936."

What you should know about unemployment compensation : some questions and answers concerning the unemployment compensation provisions of the Social Security Act and state unemployment laws /

"March 1937."