Fuel poverty analysis in three spanish autonomous regions. Some retrofitting policy considerations

A person is to be regarded as living ‘in fuel poverty’ if he is a member of a household living on a lower income in a home which cannot be kept warm at a reasonable cost. This situation is mainly triggered by three factors: low household income, lack of energy efficiency and high energy invoices. Some European countries have already made some advantages towards officially defining fuel poverty in their countries. Nevertheless, in Spain only some research has been done and an official definition of the term is yet to come. This research explores the relation among households’ income, energy expenditure and housing stock in three autonomous regions in Spain in order to evaluate the housing stock of the fuel poor as well as to identify those households more in need. The results of the research allow establishing energy retrofitting priorities of existing housing stock as well as identifying current retrofitting policies limitations on order to tackle fuel poverty.

Behaviour of FRP confined concrete in square columns

A significant amount of research has been conducted on FRP-confined circular columns, but much less is known about rectangular/square columns in which the effectiveness of confinement is much reduced. This paper presents the results of experimental investigations on low strength square concrete columns confined with FRP. Axial compression tests were performed on ten intermediate size columns. The tests results indicate that FRP composites can significantly improve the bearing capacity and ductility of square section reinforced concrete columns with rounded corners. The strength enhancement ratio is greater the lower the concrete strength and also increases with the stiffness of the jacket. The confined concrete behaviour was predicted according to the more accepted theoretical models and compared with experimental results. There are two key parameters which critically influence the fitting of the models: the strain efficiency factor and the effect of confinement in non-circular sections.

Comportamiento térmico y mecánico del yeso con adiciones de aerogel de sílice granulado

La presente tesis doctoral aborda el estudio de un nuevo material mineral, compuesto principalmente por una matriz de yeso (proveniente de un conglomerante industrial basado en sulfato de calcio multifase) y partículas de aerogel de sílice hidrófugo mesoporoso, compatibilizadas mediante un surfactante polimérico, debido a su alto carácter hidrófugo. La investigación se centra en conocer los factores que influyen en las propiedades mecánicas y conductividad térmica del material compuesto generado. Este estudio pretende contribuir al conocimiento sobre el desarrollo de nuevos morteros de elevado aislamiento térmico que puedan ser utilizados en la rehabilitación energética de edificios de viviendas existentes, debido a que estos representan gran parte del consumo energético del parque de viviendas de España, aunque también a nivel internacional. De los materiales utilizados para desarrollar los morteros estudiados, el yeso, además de ser un material muy abundante, especialmente en España, requiere una menor cantidad de energía para la fabricación de un conglomerante (debido a una menor temperatura de fabricación), en comparación con el cemento o la cal, por lo que presenta una menor huella de carbono que estos últimos. Por otro lado, el aerogel de sílice hidrófugo mesoporoso es, de acuerdo con la documentación disponible, el material que posee actualmente la mayor capacidad de aislamiento térmico en el mercado. El desarrollo de nuevos morteros minerales con una capacidad de aislamiento térmico mayor que los materiales aislantes utilizados tradicionalmente, tiene una aplicación relevante en los casos de rehabilitación energética de edificios históricos y patrimoniales, en los que se requiere la aplicación del aislamiento por el interior de la fachada, ya que este tipo de soluciones tienen el inconveniente de reducir el espacio habitable de las áreas involucradas, especialmente en zonas climáticas en las que el aislamiento térmico puede suponer un espesor considerable, por lo que es ideal utilizar materiales de altas prestaciones de aislamiento térmico capaces de aportar el mismo nivel de aislamiento (o incluso mayor), pero en un espesor considerablemente menor. La investigación se desarrolla en tres etapas: bibliográfica, experimental y de simulación. La primera etapa, parte del estudio de la bibliografía existente, relacionada con materiales aislantes, incluyendo soluciones basadas, tanto en morteros aislantes, como en paneles de aislamiento térmico. La segunda, de carácter experimental, se centra en estudiar la influencia de la microestrucrura y macroestructura, del nuevo material mineral, en las propiedades físicas elementales, mecánicas y conductividad térmica del compuesto. La tercera etapa, mediante una simulación del consumo energético, consiste en cuantificar teóricamente el potencial ahorro energético que puede aportar este material en un caso de rehabilitación energética en particular. La investigación experimental se centró principalmente en conocer los factores principales que influyen en las propiedades mecánicas y conductividad térmica de los materiales compuestos minerales desarrollados en esta tesis. Para ello, se llevó a cabo una caracterización de los materiales de estudio, así como el desarrollo de distintas muestras de ensayo, de tal forma que se pudo estudiar, tanto la hidratación del yeso en los compuestos, como su posterior microestructura y macroestructura, aspectos fundamentales para el entendimiento de las propiedades mecánicas y conductividad térmica del compuesto aislante. De este modo, se pudieron conocer y cuantificar, los factores que influyen en las propiedades estudiadas, aportando una base de conocimiento y entendimiento de este tipo de compuestos minerales con aerogel de sílice hidrófugo, no existiendo estudios publicados hasta el momento de finalización de esta tesis, con la aproximación al material propuesta en este estudio, ni con yeso (basado en sulfato de calcio multifase), ni con otro tipo de conglomerantes. Particularmente, se determinó la influencia que tiene la incorporación de partículas de aerogel de sílice hidrófugo, en grandes proporciones en volumen, en un compuesto mineral basado en distintas fases de sulfato de calcio. No obstante, para llevar a cabo las mezclas, fue necesario utilizar un surfactante para compatibilizar este tipo de partículas, con el conglomerante basado en agua. El uso de este tipo de aditivos tiene una influencia, no solo en el aerogel, sino en las propiedades del compuesto en general, dependiendo de su concentración, por lo que se establecieron dos porcentajes de adición: la primera, determinada a partir de la cantidad mínima necesaria para compatibilizar las mezclas (0,1% del agua de amasado), y la segunda, como límite superior, la concentración utilizada habitualmente a nivel industrial para estabilizar burbujas de aire en hormigones espumados (5%). El surfactante utilizado mostró la capacidad de modificar la superficie del aerogel, cambiando el comportamiento de las partículas frente al agua, permitiendo una invasión parcial de su estructura porosa, por parte del agua de amasado. Este comportamiento supone un aumento muy importante en la relación agua/yeso, afectando el hábito cristalino e influenciando negativamente las propiedades mecánicas de la matriz de yeso, presentando un efecto aún notable a mayor concentración de surfactante (5%). En cuanto a las propiedades finales alcanzadas, fue posible lograr un compuesto mineral ultraligero (200 kg/m3), con alrededor de un 60% de aerogel en volumen y de alta capacidad aislante (0,028 W/m•K), presentando una conductividad térmica notablemente menor que los morteros aislantes del mercado, e incluso también menor que la de los aislantes tradicionales basado en las lanas minerales o EPS; no obstante, con la limitante de presentar bajas propiedades mecánicas, condicionando su posible aplicación futura. Entre los factores principales relacionados con las propiedades mecánicas, se encontró que estas dependen exponencialmente del volumen de yeso en el compuesto; no obstante, factores de segundo orden, como el grado de hidratación, o una mejor distribución del conglomerante entre las partículas de aerogel, debido al aumento de la superficie específica del polvo mineral, pueden aumentar las propiedades mecánicas entre el doble y el triple, dependiendo del volumen de aerogel en cuestión. Además, se encontró que el aerogel, en conjunto con el surfactante, es capaz de introducir una gran cantidad de aire (0,70 m3 por cada m3 de aerogel), que unido al agua evaporada (no consumida por el conglomerante durante la hidratación), el volumen de aire total alcanza, generalmente, un 40%, independientemente de la cantidad de aerogel en la mezcla. De este modo, el aire introducido en la matriz desplaza las proporciones en volumen del aerogel y del yeso, disminuyendo, tanto las propiedades mecánicas, como la capacidad aislante de compuesto mineral. Por otro lado, la conductividad térmica mostró tener una dependencia directa de la contribución de las tres fases principales en el compuesto: yeso, aerogel y aire ocluido. De este modo, se pudo desarrollar un modelo matemático, adaptado de uno existente, capaz de calcular, con bastante precisión, la relación de los tres componentes mencionados, en la conductividad térmica de los compuestos, para el rango de volúmenes y materiales utilizados en esta tesis. Finalmente, la simulación del consumo energético realizada a una vivienda típica de España, de los años 1900 a 1959 (basada en muros de ladrillo macizo), para las zonas climáticas estudiadas (A, D y E), permitió observar el potencial ahorro energético que puede aportar este material, dependiendo de su espesor, como aislamiento interior de los muros de fachada. Particularmente, para la zona A, se determinó un espesor óptimo de 1 cm, mientras que para la zona D y E, 3,5 y 3,9 cm respectivamente. En este sentido, el nuevo material estudiado es capaz de disminuir, entre un 35% y un 80%, el espesor de la capa aislante, en comparación con paneles de lana de roca o los morteros minerales de mayor capacidad aislante del mercado español respectivamente. ABSTRACT The present doctoral thesis studies a new mineral-based composite material, composed by a gypsum matrix (based on an industrial multiphase gypsum binder) and mesoporous hydrophobic silica aerogel particles, compatibilized with a polymeric surfactant due to the high hydrophobic character of the insulating particles. This study pretends to contribute to the development of new composite insulating materials that could be used in energy renovation of existing dwellings, in order to reduce their high energy consumption, as they represent a great part of the total energy consumed in Spain, but also internationally. Between the materials used to develop de studied insulating mortars, gypsum, besides being an abundant material, especially in Spain, requires less energy for the manufacture of a mineral binder (due to lower manufacturing temperatures), compared to lime or cement, thus presenting lower carbon footprint. In other hand, the hydrophobic mesoporous silica aerogel, is, according to the existing references, the material with the highest know insulating capacity in the market. The development of new mineral mortars with higher thermal insulation capacity than traditional insulating materials, presents a relevant application in energy retrofitting of historic and cultural heritage buildings, in which implies that the insulating material should be installed as an internal layer, rather than as an external insulating system. This type of solution involves a reduced internal useful area, especially in climatic zones where the demand for thermal insulation is higher, and so the insulating layer thickness, being idealistic to use materials with very high insulating properties, in order to reach same insulating level (or higher), but in lower thickness than the provided by traditional insulating materials. This research is developed in three main stages: bibliographic, experimental and simulation. The first stage starts by studying the existing references regarding thermally insulating materials, including existing insulating mortars and insulating panels. The second stage, mainly experimental, is centered in the study of the the influence of the microstructure and macrostructure in the physical and mechanical properties, and also in the thermal conductivity of the new mineral-based material. The thirds stage, through energy simulation, consists in theoretically quantifying the energy savings potential that can provide this type of insulating material, in a particular energy retrofitting case study. The experimental research is mainly focused in the study of the factors that influence the mechanical properties and the thermal conductivity of the thermal insulating mineral composites developed in this thesis. For this, the characterization of the studied materials has been performed, as well as the development of several experimental samples, in order to study the hydration of the mineral binder within the composites, but also the final microstructure and macrostructure, fundamental aspects for the understanding of the composite’s mechanical and insulating properties. Thus, is was possible to determine and quantify the factors that influence the studied material properties, providing a knowledge base and understanding of mineral composites that comprises mesoporous hydrophobic silica aerogel particles, being the first study up to date regarding the specific approach of the present study, regarding not just multiphase calcium sulfate plaster, but also other mineral binders. Particularly, the influence of the incorporation of hydrophobic silica aerogel particles, in high volume ratios into a mineral compound, based on different phases of calcium sulfate has been determined. However, to perform mixing, it is necessary to use a surfactant in order to compatibilize these particles with the water-based mineral binder. The use of such additives has an influence, not only in the aerogel, but the overall properties of the compound, so two different surfactant concentration has been studied: the first, the minimum amount of surfactant (used in this thesis) in order to develop the slurries (0.1% concentration of the mixing water), and the second, as the upper limit, the concentration usually used industrially to stabilize air bubbles in foamed concrete (5%). One of the side effects of using such additive, was the modification of the aerogel particles, by changing their behavior in respect to water, generating a partial invasion of the aerogel’s porous structure, by the mixing water. This behavior produces a very important increase in water/binder ratios, affecting the crystal habit and negatively influencing the mechanical properties of the gypsum matrix. This effect further increased when a higher concentration of surfactant (5%) is used. Regarding final materials properties, it was possible to achieve an ultra-lightweight mineral composite (200 kg/m3), with around 60% by volume of aerogel, presenting a very high insulating capacity (0.028 W/m•K), a noticeable lower thermal conductivity compared to the insulating mortars and traditional thermal insulating panels on the market, such as mineral wool or EPS; however, the limiting factor for future’s material application in buildings, is related to the very low mechanical properties achieved. Among the main factors related to the mechanical properties, it has been found an exponential correlation to the volume of gypsum in the composite. However, second-order factors such as the degree of hydration, or a better distribution of the binder between the aerogel particles, due to the increased surface area of the mineral powder, can increase the mechanical properties between two to three times, depending aerogel volume involved. In addition, it was found that the aerogel, together with the surfactant, is able to entrain a large amount of air volume (around 0.70 m3 per m3 of aerogel), which together with the evaporated water (not consumed by the binder during hydration), can reach generally around 40% of entrained air within the gypsum matrix, regardless of the amount of aerogel in the mixture. Thus, the entrained air into the matrix displaces the volume proportions of the aerogel and gypsum, reducing both mechanical and insulating properties of the mineral composite. On the other hand, it has been observed a direct contribution of three main phases into the thermal conductivity of the composite: gypsum, aerogel and entrained air. Thus, it was possible to develop a mathematical model (adapted from an existing one), capable of calculating quite accurate the thermal conductivity of such mineral composites, from the ratio these three components and for the range of volumes and materials used in this thesis. Finally, the energy simulation performed to a typical Spanish dwelling, from the years 1900 to 1959 (mainly constructed with massive clay bricks), within three climatic zones of Spain (A, D and E), showed the energy savings potential that can provide this type of insulating material, depending on the thickness of the applied layer. Particularly, for the climatic A zone, it has been found an optimal layer thickness of 1 cm, while for zone D and E, 3.5 and 3.9 cm respectively. In this manner, the new studied materials is capable of decreasing the thickness of the insulating layer by 35% and 80%, compared with rock wool panels or mineral mortars with the highest insulating performance of the Spanish market respectively.

Analysis, reliability and optimization of reinforced concrete 2-D structures

In this paper a consistent analysis of reinforced concrete (RC) two-dimensional (2-D) structures,namely slab structures subjected to in-plane and out-plane forces, is presented. By using this method of analysis the well established methodology for dimensioning and verifying RC sections of beam structures is extended to 2-D structures. The validity of the proposed analysis results is checked by comparing them with some published experimental test results. Several examples show some of these proposed analysis features, such as the influence of the reinforcement layout on the service and ultimate behavior of a slab structure and the non straightforward problem of the optimal dimension at a slab point subjected to several loading cases. Also, in these examples, the method applications to design situations as multiple steel families and non orthogonal reinforcement layout are commented.

Radiological impact of cement, concrete and admixtures in Spain

It has been analyzed samples of portland cement (PC) with and without admixtures, samples of calcium aluminate cement (CAC) with different content of Al2O3 and specimens of concrete made with PC and CAC using High Resolution Gamma Spectrometry. The activity concentration index (I) is much less than 0.5 mSv y-1 for all the concrete specimens according to the Radiation protection document 112 of the European Commission. The PC without admixtures (CEM I 52,5 R) and the PC with addition of limestone (CEM II/BL 32,5 N) also have an I value much lower than 0.5 and the PC with the addition of fly ash and blast furnace slag (CEM IV/B (V) 32,5 N and III/A 42.5 N/SR) have an I value close to 0.6. The I value of the CAC used in the manufacture of structural precast concrete is of the order of 1 mSv y-1. Some of the CAC used in refractory concrete reaches a value close to 2 mSv y-1.

Multifunctional cement composites strain and damage sensors applied on reinforced concrete (RC) structural elements

In this research, strain-sensing and damage-sensing functional properties of cement composites have been studied on a conventional reinforced concrete (RC) beam. Carbon nanofiber (CNFCC) and fiber (CFCC) cement composites were used as sensors on a 4 m long RC beam. Different casting conditions (in situ or attached), service location (under tension or compression) and electrical contacts (embedded or superficial) were compared. Both CNFCC and CFCC were suitable as strain sensors in reversible (elastic) sensing condition testing. CNFCC showed higher sensitivities (gage factor up to 191.8), while CFCC only reached gage factors values of 178.9 (tension) or 49.5 (compression). Furthermore, damage-sensing tests were run, increasing the applied load progressively up to the RC beam failure. In these conditions, CNFCC sensors were also strain sensitive, but no damage sensing mechanism was detected for the strain levels achieved during the tests. Hence, these cement composites could act as strain sensors, even for severe damaged structures near to their collapse.

An improved procedure for obtaining and maintaining well characterized partial water saturation states on concrete samples to be used for mass transport tests

A conditioning procedure is proposed allowing to install into the concrete specimens any selected value of water saturation degree with homogeneous moisture distribution. This is achieved within the least time and the minimum alteration of the concrete specimens. The protocol has the following steps: obtaining basic drying data at 50 °C (water absorption capacity and drying curves); unidirectional drying of the specimens at 50 °C until reaching the target saturation degree values; redistribution phase in closed containers at 50 °C (with measurement of the quasi-equilibrium relative humidities); storage into controlled environment chambers until and during mass transport tests, if necessary. A water transport model is used to derive transport parameters of the tested materials from the drying data, i.e., relative permeabilities and apparent water diffusion coefficients. The model also allows calculating moisture profiles during isothermal drying and redistribution phases, thus allowing optimization of the redistribution times for obtaining homogeneous moisture distributions.

Recommendation of RILEM TC 178-TMC: Testing and modelling chloride penetration in concrete

This RILEM Technical Recommendation intends to give a general description of methods of sampling for obtaining chloride concentration profiles in concrete, applicable both for laboratory cast concrete specimens, for concrete cores taken from structures and for testing on site. These sampling procedures may be applied for obtaining concentration profiles of any other chemical species present in concrete.

Feasibility of electrochemical chloride extraction from structural reinforced concrete using a sprayed conductive graphite powder–cement paste as anode

This article summarizes research on the application of a conductive cement paste as an anode in the now classical technique of electrochemical extraction of chlorides applied to a concrete structural element by spraying the paste on the surface of a concrete structural element, a pillar. Sprayed conductive cement paste, by adding graphite powder, is particularly useful to treat sizable vertical surfaces such are structural supports. Outcomes indicate that this kind of anode not only provides electrochemical chloride removal with similar efficiency, but also is able to retain moisture even without the use of a continuous dampening system.

Moisture Distribution in Partially Saturated Concrete Studied by Impedance Spectroscopy

The moisture content and its spatial distribution has a great influence on the durability properties of concrete structures. Several non-destructive techniques have been used for the determination of the total water content, but moisture distribution is difficult to determine. In this paper impedance spectroscopy is used to study the water distribution in concrete samples with controlled and homogeneously distributed moisture contents. The technique is suitable for the determination of water distribution inside the sample, using the appropriate equivalent circuits. It is shown that using the selected drying procedures there is no change in the solid phase of the samples, although the technique can only be used for the qualitative study of variations in the solid phase when samples are too thick. The results of this work show that for a wide range of concrete percentages of saturation, from full to 18 % saturation, practically all the pores keep at least a thin layer of electrolyte covering their walls, since the capacitance measurement results are practically independent of the saturation degree.

Chloride Penetration Prediction in Concrete through an Empirical Model Based on Constant Flux Diffusion

An empirical model based on constant flux is presented for chloride transport through concrete in atmospherical exposure conditions. A continuous supply of chlorides is assumed as a constant mass flux at the exposed concrete surface. The model is applied to experimental chloride profiles obtained from a real marine structure, and results are compared with the classical error-function model. The proposed model shows some advantages. It yields a better predictive capacity than the classical error-function model. The previously observed chloride surface concentration increases are compatible with the proposed model. Nevertheless, the predictive capacity of the model can fail if the concrete microstructure changes with time. The model seems to be appropriate for well-maturated concretes exposed to a marine environment in atmospherical conditions.

Preliminary interpretation of shaking-table response of a full-scale 3-storey building composed of thin reinforced concrete sandwich walls

In the last few decades, the use of cast in situ reinforced concrete sandwich panels for the construction of low- to mid-rise buildings has become more and more widespread due to several interesting properties of this construction technique, such as fast construction and high thermal and acoustic performances. Nonetheless the level of knowledge of the structural behavior of systems made of squat reinforced concrete sandwich panels is still not so consolidated, especially with reference to the seismic response, due to the lack of experimental studies. In recent years, while various experimental tests have been conducted on single panels aimed at assessing their seismic capacity, only few tests have been carried out on more complex structural systems. In this paper, the experimental results of a series of shaking-table tests performed on a full-scale 3-storey building are presented in detail. The main goal is to give to the scientific community the possibility of develop independent interpretation of these experimental results. An in-depth interpretation of the discrepancies between the analytical predictions and the experimental results is beyond the objective of this paper and is still under development. Nonetheless, preliminary interpretations indicate that both the stiffness and the strength of the building under dynamic excitation appear quite superior with respect to those expected from the results of previous pseudo-static cyclic tests conducted on simple specimens.

Efficiency of a conductive cement-based anodic system for the application of cathodic protection, cathodic prevention and electrochemical chloride extraction to control corrosion in reinforced concrete structures

This article describes the research carried out regarding the application of cathodic protection (CP) and cathodic prevention (CPrev), in some cases with a pre-treatment of electrochemical chloride extraction (ECE), on representative specimens of reinforced concrete structures, using an anodic system consisting of a graphite-cement paste applied as a coating on the surface. The aim of this research is to find out the competence of this anode for the aforementioned electrochemical treatments. The efficiency of this anode has been clearly demonstrated, as well as its capability to apply a combined process of ECE and after CP.

Procedure for calculating the chloride diffusion coefficient and surface concentration from a profile having a maximum beyond the concrete surface

Chlorides induce local corrosion in the steel reinforcements when reaching the bar surface. The measurement of the rate of ingress of these ions, is made by mathematically fitting the so called “error function equation” into the chloride concentration profile, obtaining so the diffusion coefficient and the chloride concentration at the concrete surface. However, the chloride profiles do not always follow Fick’s law by having the maximum concentration at the concrete surface, but often the profile shows a maximum concentration more in the interior, which indicates a different composition and performance of the most external concrete layer with respect to the internal zones. The paper presents a procedure prepared during the time of the RILEM TC 178-TMC: “Testing and modeling chloride penetration in concrete”, which suggests neglecting the external layer where the chloride concentration increases and using the maximum as an “apparent” surface concentration, called C max and to fit the error function equation into the decreasing concentration profile towards the interior. The prediction of evolution should be made also from the maximum.

Shape Effect of Electrochemical Chloride Extraction in Structural Reinforced Concrete Elements Using a New Cement-Based Anodic System

This article shows the research carried out by the authors focused on how the shape of structural reinforced concrete elements treated with electrochemical chloride extraction can affect the efficiency of this process. Assuming the current use of different anode systems, the present study considers the comparison of results between conventional anodes based on Ti-RuO2 wire mesh and a cement-based anodic system such as a paste of graphite-cement. Reinforced concrete elements of a meter length were molded to serve as laboratory specimens, to closely represent authentic structural supports, with circular and rectangular sections. Results confirm almost equal performances for both types of anode systems when electrochemical chloride extraction is applied to isotropic structural elements. In the case of anisotropic ones, such as rectangular sections with no uniformly distributed rebar, differences in electrical flow density were detected during the treatment. Those differences were more extreme for Ti-RuO2 mesh anode system. This particular shape effect is evidenced by obtaining the efficiencies of electrochemical chloride extraction in different points of specimens.