Vulnerable and invisible : depictions of trafficking victims in public awareness campaigns

Public concern about the crime of human trafficking has dramatically risen over the last two decades. . This concern and panic has both spawned and been fuelled by an array of public awareness campaigns that aim to educate the public about this crime. Campaigns such as the Blue Blindfold Campaign in the UK, the UN-driven Blue Heart Campaign, and the worldwide Body Shop campaign have contributed to the public’s awareness and, to an extent, understanding of the phenomenon of human trafficking. This research explores these and other government and non-government campaigns aimed at raising public awareness of human trafficking. It questions the rationale, call to action and impact of these efforts, and analyses the depiction of trafficking victims in these campaigns. In particular, this research argues that some of these campaigns perpetuate an understanding of a hierarchy of victimisation of trafficking. A public focus on sex trafficking often results in the conflation of prostitution and trafficking, and renders invisible the male and female victims of trafficking for other forms of labour.

The social construction of prostitution in Californian 'John' Schools

The existence of prostitution in society continues to be a highly contested issue in both political and social arenas. With traditional criminal justice methods to address prostitution focussing predominantly on sex workers, newly formed initiatives have been created to target the demand side of prostitution. ‘John Schools’ – diversionary programs for clients, or ‘johns’ who have been arrested for prostitution offences – aim to educate participants on the various harms and risks associated with such behaviour and claim to provide an innovative means to reduce prostitution by decreasing demand for sexual services. It is evident however, that these programs perpetuate traditional social constructions of prostitution, characterising the act, and the actors, as sexually deviant. This paper examines the curriculum of these programs in order to identify how prostitution is constructed, firstly through the depiction of the victims in the program, and secondly through the characterisation of prostitution offenders. This paper argues that such initiatives merely extend the charge of sexual deviance from the sellers of sex to the buyers, and fail to acknowledge autonomy and choice for sex workers and clients.

Comprehensive Addictive Behaviors and Disorders, Volume 1 : Principles of Addiction

"Principles of Addiction provides a solid understanding of the definitional and diagnostic differences between use, abuse, and disorder. It describes in great detail the characteristics of these syndromes and various etiological models. The book's three main sections examine the nature of addiction, including epidemiology, symptoms, and course; alcohol and drug use among adolescents and college students; and detailed descriptions of a wide variety of addictive behaviors and disorders, encompassing not only drugs and alcohol, but caffeine, food, gambling, exercise, sex, work, social networking, and many other areas. This volume is especially important in providing a basic introduction to the field as well as an in-depth review of our current understanding of the nature and process of addictive behaviors. Principles of Addiction is one of three volumes comprising the 2,500-page series, Comprehensive Addictive Behaviors and Disorders. This series provides the most complete collection of current knowledge on addictive behaviors and disorders to date. In short, it is the definitive reference work on addictions."--publisher website

Perspectives in Human Sexuality

This book is an overview of key debates, research findings and theories in the area of sex and sexuality. Controversial issues are discussed in an informative and fair, balanced manner. With its sociological orientation, Perspectives in Human Sexuality employs a range of empirical and theoretical resources, including those which utilise scientific, medical, historical and ethical knowledge in order to elucidate the critical issues affecting contemporary life. This is the first textbook written especially for undergraduate students to offer a detailed and comprehensive introduction to sex and sexuality from an Australian and New Zealand perspective. This work examines issues such as sex and age, sex work and gay, lesbian and queer sex. Leading Australian and New Zealand authors in the field of sex and sexuality have contributed to the book. The book deals with sexuality from an Australasian perspective, addressing the specific concerns and interests of an Australasian audience, providing it with a unique standing in the current market.

Institutionalization

During the 18th and 19th centuries, prostitution came to be understood as a potentially disruptive element in the management of society. New forms of social control developed that sought to transform the souls of prostitutes to better control their bodies. Institutions for managing prostitutes, such as Magdalen Homes and lock hospitals, were introduced or increased in number throughout the British Empire, North America, and Western Europe. Often these institutions had as their stated objective the physical purification and moral reform of prostitutes, appearing to make a dramatic break with earlier methods of social control that had relied on practices of physical punishment and spatial segregation. Emergent institutions for the social control of prostitutes used a regimen of religious training, hard labor, and medical expertise. The objective of the Magdalen Home was not to punish sin but to absolve it, while the function of the lock hospital was not simply to confine the ill, but to confine the ill to "cure" them. The role of these institutions was not only symbolic, mirroring in some way the operation of earlier forms of social control, but was also practical and transformative. The mass institutionalization of prostitutes that occurred during the 18th and 19th centuries produced and emphasized sexual, class, and gender boundaries, grounded in the broad distinction between "pure" and "impure" women. Because of its association with sin, prostitution before the 18th century had been constructed as a religious problem relating to salvation and penitence. Throughout Western Europe during the Middle Ages, prostitutes, like the medieval leper and the Jew, were subject to restrictions designed to distinguish and isolate them from other members of their communities. The repression of prostitution during the Middle Ages was neither systematic nor highly organized, although it reinforced the image of the prostitute as sinful "other".

Penal Colonies

Prostitution has been closely associated with the transportation of women convicts to British penal colonies. Convict labor was used to found a number of British colonies including Barbados, Jamaica, Maryland, Virginia, Singapore, New South Wales, Tasmania, and Western Australia. Between 1607 and 1939, Britain transported approximately 400,000 convicts, 162,000 of whom came to Australia and about 50,000 to North America. Significant numbers of women were among those transported to the Australian and North American colonies, although their numbers were relatively small in comparison to male convicts. Transportation was typically reserved for the most recalcitrant of female offenders. Most women transported came from working-class populations, resided in metropolitan centers, and were single at the time of their offense. Although few of these women were actually sentenced for activities associated with prostitution, large numbers had a history of involvement with prostitution. Transportation was considered to offer prostitutes a chance at redemption, with colonial commentators drawing contrasts between the Old World and its vice-ridden sensuality and the colonies, which offered opportunities for redemption through religious devotion and hard work. Many women transported to the Australian colonies were described by officials as being "on the town" at their time of apprehension and were collectively considered to be "damned whores, possessed of neither virtue nor honesty". Recently, historians have argued that these assessments were emblematic of middle-class prejudices toward the open and aggressive sexuality of working-class women. The number of convict women involved in prostitution may have been higher than recorded crimes, typically involving "larceny", suggest. A number of women were charged with theft from men who had paid them (or, in some instances, refused to pay them) for sex. Historians have estimated that one in five convict women were part-time or full-time prostitutes before transportation. Many continued in prostitution after transportation, with prostitution becoming an important element in the social and economic life of the Australian colonies, where, between 1788-1830, men outnumbered women six to one. Officially, prostitution was tolerated to dissuade men from vice. For women, prostitution presented a means of securing physical protection and accommodation at a time when general amenities and employment opportunities were restricted.

Key Concepts in Crime and Society

This book is an introduction to key issues in the area of crime as it connects to society. The book is divided into three parts: Understanding Crime and Criminality: introduces topics such as the social construction of crime and deviance, social control, the fear of crime, poverty and exclusion, white collar crime, victims of crime, race/gender and crime. Types of Crime and Criminality: explores examples including human trafficking, sex work, drug crime, environmental crime, cyber crime, war crime, terrorism, and interpersonal violence. Responses to Crime: looks at areas such as crime and the media, policing, moral panics, deterrence, prisons and rehabilitation.

The rise and fall of Rentboy.com

Earlier this week, the New York Police Department in partnership with Homeland Security arrested seven people and seized a number of documents pertaining to the website Rentboy.com. Although the website purports to help men connect for companionship only, authorities allege that it has been used to “facilitate the promotion, management, establishment, and carrying on of an unlawful activity, namely an enterprise involving prostitution”. Unlike Australia, which started the decriminalisation of sex work as early as 1979, sex work is illegal across all of the USA, save a few counties in Nevada where it is subject to heavy regulation. The raid on Rentboy.com raises important questions about sex work, including its visibility, consumer demand for such services, and the ongoing marginalisation of those who buy and sell sexual services...

Human trafficking heroes and villains: Representing the problem in anti-trafficking awareness campaigns

Since the declaration by the United Nations that awareness raising should be a key part of efforts to combat human trafficking, government and non-government organisations have produced numerous public awareness campaigns designed to capture the public’s attention and sympathy. These campaigns represent the ‘problem’ of trafficking in specific ways, creating heroes and villains by placing the blame for trafficking on some, while obscuring the responsibility of others. This paper adopts Carol Bacchi’s ‘What is the problem represented to be?’ framework for examining the politicisation of problem representation in 18 anti-trafficking awareness campaigns. It is argued that these campaigns construct a narrow understanding of the problem through the depiction of ‘ideal offenders’. In particular, a strong focus on the demand for commercial sex as causative of human trafficking serves to obscure the problematic role of consumerism in a wide range of industries, and perpetuates an understanding of trafficking that fails to draw a necessary distinction between the demand for labour, and the demand for ‘exploitable’ labour. This problem representation also obscures the role governments in destination countries may play in causing trafficking through imposing restrictive migration regimes that render migrants vulnerable to traffickers.

Gender and health: a social movement’s agenda for Big Pharma.

Social movements have an important new campaigning and organizing competence in new information communication technologies. These technologies also enable the members of social movements to readily research the accuracy of information: knowledge becomes globalized and readily accessible. In relation to Big Pharma, women’s social movements and social movements of the medicated intersect, and there is now a substantial challenge to Big Pharma both within developed and developing countries from the terrain of gender and health. This paper documents those challenges and looks towards their consequences in the future both in respect of Big Pharma but also in terms of 'academic' research

Recasting 'Black Venus' in the new African Diaspora

This article explores the ways in which transnational feminist analysis can be deployed to reconfigure new gendered and racialized cartographies of the African Diaspora in Europe. First, I position contemporary film representations of trafficked Nigerian sex workers in Italy in dialogical relation to 19th century discourses of black sexuality - in particular, Sharpley-Whiting's (1999) reinscribed 'Black Venus Master Narrative' - and assess historical and geographical (dis)continuities in their modes of signification. Second, by linking endemic factors feeding the supply of Nigerian women for the purposes of (in)voluntary participation in the Italian sex industry, such as the localized feminization of poverty and regionally specific perceptions of sex work as a temporary economic strategy, I engage with broader feminist debates on victimization and agency in global sex work and migration literatures. In doing so, this dialectical think piece highlights the gendered complexities of new African diasporic formations and the ways in which their growth is facilitated by broader illegal networks that shape and are shaped by vicissitudes in glocalized economies. © 2004 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Dentro de portas : trabalhadoras do sexo em contexto de interior : utilização e acesso a serviços de saúde na área da infeção VIH-Sida

RESUMO - O presente estudo pretende contribuir a nível de saúde pública para o planeamento de estratégias orientadas para a prevenção, rastreio e tratamento do VIH/Sida em trabalhadores sexuais em contexto de interior. Esta é uma população de difícil acesso, particularmente vulnerável à infeção por VIH, e associada a fatores de risco que incluem a pobreza, discriminação e desigualdade de género, estigma e exclusão social, condicionando o seu acesso a serviços de saúde. Analisaram-se 272 questionários aplicados no âmbito do estudo PREVIH na área da Grande Lisboa no período entre Agosto de 2011 e Setembro de 2012 a pessoas que fazem trabalho sexual em contexto de interior. Foi realizada uma abordagem analítica permitindo a descrição do fenómeno e a análise da relação entre variáveis sociodemográficas e variáveis sobre o acesso a saúde para informação, prevenção e teste na área do VIH/Sida. Verificou-se que nesta amostra maioritariamente feminina existe elevada presença dos outros dois géneros e os indivíduos são maioritariamente migrantes. O trabalho sexual é uma forma exclusiva de trabalho, sendo exercido a tempo inteiro e em apartamentos. Foram detetados condicionamentos no acesso a serviços de saúde nas populações minoritárias e mais suscetíveis a discriminação, tanto na questão do género como da nacionalidade. Estes resultados apontam para a necessidade de planear intervenções nesta área que permitam uma abordagem participativa e de proximidade com as populações mais vulneráveis e também a necessidade de dar continuidade à investigação nesta área no sentido de reforçar políticas de saúde pública aplicadas a trabalhadores sexuais.

Prévention du VIH chez les femmes travailleuses du sexe de Conakry, République de Guinée : conseil dépistage volontaire, comportements à risque et infections sexuellement transmissibles

Problématique : Les femmes travailleuses du sexe (TS) constituent la population le plus à risque d’infection au VIH dans différents pays d’Afrique subsaharienne. Plusieurs interventions y ont ainsi été menées pour réduire le risque d’infection en influant sur les facteurs de risque. Parmi ces interventions, on peut citer la promotion de l’utilisation du préservatif de même que le dépistage et le traitement des infections sexuellement transmissibles (IST). Cependant, certaines composantes sont peu représentées dans ce panel d’interventions offertes aux femmes TS. Le conseil dépistage volontaire pourrait s’avérer une intervention utile de prévention primaire et secondaire pour cette population mais son acceptabilité est mal connue. Par ailleurs, en termes de surveillance de l’épidémie, l’évaluation de la validité de l’auto-rapport d’utilisation du préservatif, indicateur fréquemment utilisé lors d’enquêtes populationnelles serait souhaitable. Enfin, pour ce qui est de la prévention de l’infection dans cette population, l’effet du désir d’enfant sur l’utilisation non systématique du condom avec le principal partenaire régulier non payant est peu connu. Il en est de même pour la prévalence de certaines IST comme le VPH-16 et l’effet combiné de facteurs sociodémographiques, comportementaux et préventifs sur la présence de ces IST. Objectifs : Les objectifs de cette thèse sont 1) de mesurer l’acceptabilité et les conséquences du conseil dépistage volontaire du VIH chez les femmes TS de Conakry en Guinée; 2) d’évaluer la validité de l’auto-rapport de l’utilisation du préservatif dans cette population grâce à un indicateur biologique de présence de sperme, l’antigène spécifique de la prostate (PSA); 3) d’estimer la fréquence d’utilisation systématique du préservatif avec les partenaires clients et non-clients des femmes TS et d’étudier l’importance du désir d’enfant dans l’utilisation non systématique du préservatif avec le principal partenaire régulier non-client et 4) de mesurer la prévalence des IST et du VIH et d’étudier les facteurs sociodémographiques, comportementaux et préventifs qui y sont associés. Méthodologie : Nous avons mené une étude longitudinale dans la ville de Conakry en Guinée auprès de 421 femmes TS recrutées dans trois services de santé adaptés pour elles. Un devis mixte répété un an plus tard a permis de collecter des données quantitatives et qualitatives. Des analyses biologiques de dépistage des IST et du VIH ont été effectuées. Résultats : Le premier article de résultats présenté dans cette thèse montre que l’acceptabilité du conseil dépistage volontaire est élevée chez les femmes TS. En effet, les taux d’acceptation du test, de retour pour la prise de résultats et de notification du statut sérologique avoisinaient les 100%. Cette acceptabilité semblait être le fait d’une perception de risque d’infection élevé, mais aussi d’une pression sociale du milieu prostitutionnel pour effectuer le dépistage et révéler le statut sérologique. Les conséquences négatives au dépistage étaient rares. Le deuxième article montre que l’auto-rapport de l’usage récent du préservatif a une très faible sensibilité lorsque comparé à l’étalon d’or que constitue la PSA. Ainsi, la plupart des personnes chez qui la PSA était retrouvée ne rapportaient aucun rapport non protégé récent. La discordance entre l’auto-rapport d’utilisation récente du préservatif et la présence de PSA était associée à une perception de risque d’infection au VIH élevé. Enfin, la troisième section montre que si l’utilisation systématique du préservatif était très fréquente avec les clients, elle l’est beaucoup moins avec le principal partenaire régulier non-client. Le désir d’enfant de la femme TS contribue de manière significative à l’utilisation non systématique du condom avec ce type de partenaire. Des facteurs sociodémographiques, comportementaux et la coinfection par d’autres IST sont associés à la présence d’IST/VIH, ces dernières étant fréquentes dans la population des femmes TS malgré les nombreuses interventions qui y sont menées. Conclusion : En conclusion, l’on peut dire que la prévention du VIH chez les femmes TS constitue un défi nécessitant des interventions intégrées tenant compte du contexte commercial dans lequel ces interventions sont implantées et des aspirations des femmes TS en matière de reproduction.