Ion-exchange resins as stationary phase in reactive chromatography

Dynamic behavior of bothisothermal and non-isothermal single-column chromatographic reactors with an ion-exchange resin as the stationary phase was investigated. The reactor performance was interpreted by using results obtained when studying the effect of the resin properties on the equilibrium and kinetic phenomena occurring simultaneously in the reactor. Mathematical models were derived for each phenomenon and combined to simulate the chromatographic reactor. The phenomena studied includes phase equilibria in multicomponent liquid mixture¿ion-exchange resin systems, chemicalequilibrium in the presence of a resin catalyst, diffusion of liquids in gel-type and macroporous resins, and chemical reaction kinetics. Above all, attention was paid to the swelling behavior of the resins and how it affects the kinetic phenomena. Several poly(styrene-co-divinylbenzene) resins with different cross-link densities and internal porosities were used. Esterification of acetic acid with ethanol to produce ethyl acetate and water was used as a model reaction system. Choosing an ion-exchange resin with a low cross-link density is beneficial inthe case of the present reaction system: the amount of ethyl acetate as well the ethyl acetate to water mole ratio in the effluent stream increase with decreasing cross-link density. The enhanced performance of the reactor is mainly attributed to increasing reaction rate, which in turn originates from the phase equilibrium behavior of the system. Also mass transfer considerations favor the use ofresins with low cross-link density. The diffusion coefficients of liquids in the gel-type ion-exchange resins were found to fall rapidly when the extent of swelling became low. Glass transition of the polymer was not found to significantlyretard the diffusion in sulfonated PS¿DVB ion-exchange resins. It was also shown that non-isothermal operation of a chromatographic reactor could be used to significantly enhance the reactor performance. In the case of the exothermic modelreaction system and a near-adiabatic column, a positive thermal wave (higher temperature than in the initial state) was found to travel together with the reactive front. This further increased the conversion of the reactants. Diffusion-induced volume changes of the ion-exchange resins were studied in a flow-through cell. It was shown that describing the swelling and shrinking kinetics of the particles calls for a mass transfer model that explicitly includes the limited expansibility of the polymer network. A good description of the process was obtained by combining the generalized Maxwell-Stefan approach and an activity model that was derived from the thermodynamics of polymer solutions and gels. The swelling pressure in the resin phase was evaluated by using a non-Gaussian expression forthe polymer chain length distribution. Dimensional changes of the resin particles necessitate the use of non-standard mathematical tools for dynamic simulations. A transformed coordinate system, where the mass of the polymer was used as a spatial variable, was applied when simulating the chromatographic reactor columns as well as the swelling and shrinking kinetics of the resin particles. Shrinking of the particles in a column leads to formation of dead volume on top of the resin bed. In ordinary Eulerian coordinates, this results in a moving discontinuity that in turn causes numerical difficulties in the solution of the PDE system. The motion of the discontinuity was eliminated by spanning two calculation grids in the column that overlapped at the top of the resin bed. The reactive and non-reactive phase equilibrium data were correlated with a model derived from thethermodynamics of polymer solution and gels. The thermodynamic approach used inthis work is best suited at high degrees of swelling because the polymer matrixmay be in the glassy state when the extent of swelling is low.

Low C-reactive protein values at admission predict mortality in patients with severe community-acquired pneumonia caused by Streptococcus pneumoniae that require intensive care management.

PURPOSE: To identify risk factors associated with mortality in patients with severe community-acquired pneumonia (CAP) caused by S. pneumoniae who require intensive care unit (ICU) management, and to assess the prognostic values of these risk factors at the time of admission. METHODS: Retrospective analysis of all consecutive patients with CAP caused by S. pneumoniae who were admitted to the 32-bed medico-surgical ICU of a community and referral university hospital between 2002 and 2011. Univariate and multivariate analyses were performed on variables available at admission. RESULTS: Among the 77 adult patients with severe CAP caused by S. pneumoniae who required ICU management, 12 patients died (observed mortality rate 15.6 %). Univariate analysis indicated that septic shock and low C-reactive protein (CRP) values at admission were associated with an increased risk of death. In a multivariate model, after adjustment for age and gender, septic shock [odds ratio (OR), confidence interval 95 %; 4.96, 1.11-22.25; p = 0.036], and CRP (OR 0.99, 0.98-0.99 p = 0.034) remained significantly associated with death. Finally, we assessed the discriminative ability of CRP to predict mortality by computing its receiver operating characteristic curve. The CRP value cut-off for the best sensitivity and specificity was 169.5 mg/L to predict hospital mortality with an area under the curve of 0.72 (0.55-0.89). CONCLUSIONS: The mortality of patients with S. pneumoniae CAP requiring ICU management was much lower than predicted by severity scores. The presence of septic shock and a CRP value at admission <169.5 mg/L predicted a fatal outcome.

Fruits of Butia capitata (Mart.) Becc as good sources of β -carotene and provitamina

Butia capitata is a palm tree, widely found in the Brazilian savanna. Their fruits are largely used by local communities to prepare juices, jellies and ice-creams. The main objective of this work was to determine the carotenoids profile of Butia capitata fruits and their provitamin A values. Total carotenoids content ranged from 11.1 to 43.9 μg.g-1; β-carotene was the predominant carotenoid (5.2-22.8 μg.g-1), followed by γ-carotene, phytoene, phytofluene, ζ-carotene, α-cryptoxanthin (or zeinoxanthin) and α-carotene. Provitamin A values varied from 50 to 200 RAE.100g-1. This result suggests that B. capitata pulp may be a good source of β-carotene and provitamin A.

Eetteröintiprosessien simulointivalmiuksien kehittäminen

Diplomityön tarkoituksena oli tutkia ETBE-prosessien simulointimallin kehittämistä. Simulointia varten valittiin eetteröinnin syöttövirroiksi etanoli ja tyypillinen FCC-kolonnin hiilivetysyöttö. Kirjallisuusosassa paneuduttiin tutkimaan syitä ETBE:n käytölle bensiinissä, valmistukseen tarvittavien raaka-aineiden lähteitä ja mahdollisia korvaavia raaka-aineita sekä mietittiin etanolissa olevien epäpuhtauksien vaikutusta prosessin tuotespesifikaatioihin. Kirjallisuusosassa tarkasteltiin lisäksi eri valmistajien markkinoimia eetteröintiteknologioita. Eetteröintiteknlogiat jaettiin perinteiseen tislaukseen pohjautuviin prosesseihin, reaktiiviseen tislaukseen pohjautuviin prosesseihin sekä Neste Engineering:in markkinoimaan NExETHERS-teknologiaan. Työn kokeellisessa osassa tutkittiin sekä etanolin epäpuhtauksien kulkeutumista prosessissa että kokeellisesti saadusta höyry-nestetasapainotiedosta määritettyjen Wilsonin yhtälön binääri-interaktioparametrien vaikutusta eetteröintiprosessin simulointituloksiin. Lopuksi simulointiin prosessia, jossa oli prosessin kannalta kriittiseksi havaitut etanolin epäpuhtaudet sekä hyviksi todetut binääri-interaktioparametrit etanolin ja FCC-syöttövirran C4-hiilivetyjen välillä. Uusilla binääriparametreilla saatuja simulointituloksia vertailtiin aikaisemmin samasta mallista vanhoilla binääriparametreilla saatuihin tuloksiin. Lopuksi tehtiin yhteenveto työn tuloksista ja annettiin ehdotukset jatkotutkimuksia varten.

Clinical evolution after a non-reactive hypothermic EEG following cardiac arrest.

BACKGROUND: Lack of electroencephalography (EEG) background reactivity during therapeutic hypothermia (TH) has been associated with poor outcome in post-anoxic comatose patients. However, decision on intensive care withdrawal is based on normothermic (NT) evaluations. This study aims at exploring whether patients showing recovery of EEG reactivity in NT after a non-reactive EEG in TH differ from those remaining non-reactive. METHODS: Patients with non-reactive EEG during TH were identified from our prospective registry of consecutive comatose adults admitted after successful resuscitation from CA between April 2009 and June 2014. Variables including neurological examination, serum neuron-specific enolase (NSE), procalcitonin, and EEG features were compared regarding impact on functional outcome at 3 months. RESULTS: Seventy-two of 197 patients (37 %) had a non-reactive EEG background during TH with thirteen (18 %) evolving towards reactivity in NT. Compared to those remaining non-reactive (n = 59), they showed significantly better recovery of brainstem reflexes (p < 0.001), better motor responses (p < 0.001), transitory consciousness improvement (p = 0.008), and a tendency toward lower NSE (p = 0.067). One patient recovering EEG reactivity survived with good functional outcome at 3 months. CONCLUSIONS: Recovery of EEG reactivity from TH to NT seems to distinguish two patients' subgroups regarding early neurological assessment and transitory consciousness improvement, corroborating the role of EEG in providing information about cerebral functions. Understanding these dynamic changes encourages maintenance of intensive support in selected patients even after a non-reactive EEG background in TH, as a small subgroup may indeed recover with good functional outcome.

Identification of Rare High-Avidity, Tumor-Reactive CD8+ T Cells by Monomeric TCR-Ligand Off-Rates Measurements on Living Cells.

The avidity of the T-cell receptor (TCR) for antigenic peptides presented by the peptide-MHC (pMHC) on cells is a key parameter for cell-mediated immunity. Yet a fundamental feature of most tumor antigen-specific CD8(+) T cells is that this avidity is low. In this study, we addressed the need to identify and select tumor-specific CD8(+) T cells of highest avidity, which are of the greatest interest for adoptive cell therapy in patients with cancer. To identify these rare cells, we developed a peptide-MHC multimer technology, which uses reversible Ni(2+)-nitrilotriacetic acid histidine tags (NTAmers). NTAmers are highly stable but upon imidazole addition, they decay rapidly to pMHC monomers, allowing flow-cytometric-based measurements of monomeric TCR-pMHC dissociation rates of living CD8(+) T cells on a wide avidity spectrum. We documented strong correlations between NTAmer kinetic results and those obtained by surface plasmon resonance. Using NTAmers that were deficient for CD8 binding to pMHC, we found that CD8 itself stabilized the TCR-pMHC complex, prolonging the dissociation half-life several fold. Notably, our NTAmer technology accurately predicted the function of large panels of tumor-specific T cells that were isolated prospectively from patients with cancer. Overall, our results demonstrated that NTAmers are effective tools to isolate rare high-avidity cytotoxic T cells from patients for use in adoptive therapies for cancer treatment.

Application of nitrogen sources on grapevines and effect on yield and must composition

This study was carried out to evaluate the yield, total N content in leaves and must composition of grapes from the Cabernet Sauvignon variety subjected to the application of urea and organic compost. Cabernet Sauvignon grapevines in Rosário do Sul, RS, Brazil, in 2008, 2009 and 2010 were subjected to annual application of 40 kg N ha-1 in the form of organic compost and urea, and compared to unfertilized grapevines. In the 2008/09, 2009/10 and 2010/11 crop seasons, leaves were collected for analysis of total N content. At maturation of the grapes, the yield and quality attributes of the must were evaluated. The application of N sources, especially organic compost, increased the N content in the whole leaf at full flowering. Application of organic compost and urea has little effect on grape yield and does not affect the total nutrient content in the must, nor the enological attributes.

Intrinsic ROS-production capacity of nanoparticles

Engineered nanomaterials (ENMs) exhibit special physicochemical properties and thus are finding their way into an increasing number of industries, enabling products with improved properties. Their increased use brings a greater likelihood of exposure to the nanoparticles (NPs) that could be released during the life cycle of nano-abled products. The field of nanotoxicology has emerged as a consequence of the development of these novel materials, and it has gained ever more attention due to the urgent need to gather information on exposure to them and to understand the potential hazards they engender. However, current studies on nanotoxicity tend to focus on pristine ENMs, and they use these toxicity results to generalize risk assessments on human exposure to NPs. ENMs released into the environment can interact with their surroundings, change characteristics and exhibit toxicity effects distinct from those of pristine ENMs. Furthermore, NPs' large surface areas provide extra-large potential interfaces, thus promoting more significant interactions between NPs and other co-existing species. In such processes, other species can attach to a NP's surface and modify its surface functionality, in addition to the toxicity in normally exhibits. One particular occupational health scenario involves NPs and low-volatile organic compounds (LVOC), a common type of pollutant existing around many potential sources of NPs. LVOC can coat a NP's surface and then dominate its toxicity. One important mechanism in nanotoxicology is the creation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) on a NP's surface; LVOC can modify the production of these ROS. In summary, nanotoxicity research should not be limited to the toxicity of pristine NPs, nor use their toxicity to evaluate the health effects of exposure to environmental NPs. Instead, the interactions which NPs have with other environmental species should also be considered and researched. The potential health effects of exposure to NPs should be derived from these real world NPs with characteristics modified by the environment and their distinct toxicity. Failure to suitably address toxicity results could lead to an inappropriate treatment of nano- release, affect the environment and public health and put a blemish on the development of sustainable nanotechnologies as a whole. The main objective of this thesis is to demonstrate a process for coating NP surfaces with LVOC using a well-controlled laboratory design and, with regard to these NPs' capacity to generate ROS, explore the consequences of changing particle toxicity. The dynamic coating system developed yielded stable and replicable coating performance, simulating an important realistic scenario. Clear changes in the size distribution of airborne NPs were observed using a scanning mobility particle sizer, were confirmed using both liquid nanotracking analyses and transmission electron microscopy (TEM) imaging, and were verified thanks to the LVOC coating. Coating thicknesses corresponded to the amount of coating material used and were controlled using the parameters of the LVOC generator. The capacity of pristine silver NPs (Ag NPs) to generate ROS was reduced when they were given a passive coating of inert paraffin: this coating blocked the reactive zones on the particle surfaces. In contrast, a coating of active reduced-anthraquinone contributed to redox reactions and generated ROS itself, despite the fact that ROS generation due to oxidation by Ag NPs themselves was quenched. Further objectives of this thesis included development of ROS methodology and the analysis of ROS case studies. Since the capacity of NPs to create ROS is an important effect in nanotoxicity, we attempted to refine and standardize the use of 2'7-dichlorodihydrofluorescin (DCFH) as a chemical tailored for the characterization of NPs' capacity for ROS generation. Previous studies had reported a wide variety of results, which were due to a number of insufficiently well controlled factors. We therefore cross-compared chemicals and concentrations, explored ways of dispersing NP samples in liquid solutions, identified sources of contradictions in the literature and investigated ways of reducing artificial results. The most robust results were obtained by sonicating an optimal sample of NPs in a DCFH-HRP solution made of 5,M DCFH and 0.5 unit/ml horseradish peroxidase (HRP). Our findings explained how the major reasons for previously conflicting results were the different experimental approaches used and the potential artifacts appearing when using high sample concentrations. Applying our advanced DCFH protocol with other physicochemical characterizations and biological analyses, we conducted several case studies, characterizing aerosols and NP samples. Exposure to aged brake wear dust engenders a risk of potential deleterious health effects in occupational scenarios. We performed microscopy and elemental analyses, as well as ROS measurements, with acellular and cellular DCFH assays. TEM images revealed samples to be heterogeneous mixtures with few particles in the nano-scale. Metallic and non-metallic elements were identified, primarily iron, carbon and oxygen. Moderate amounts of ROS were detected in the cell-free fluorescent tests; however, exposed cells were not dramatically activated. In addition to their highly aged state due to oxidation, the reason aged brake wear samples caused less oxidative stress than fresh brake wear samples may be because of their larger size and thus smaller relative reactive surface area. Other case studies involving welding fumes and differently charged NPs confirmed the performance of our DCFH assay and found ROS generation linked to varying characteristics, especially the surface functionality of the samples. Les nanomatériaux manufacturés (ENM) présentent des propriétés physico-chimiques particulières et ont donc trouvés des applications dans un nombre croissant de secteurs, permettant de réaliser des produits ayant des propriétés améliorées. Leur utilisation accrue engendre un plus grand risque pour les êtres humains d'être exposés à des nanoparticules (NP) qui sont libérées au long de leur cycle de vie. En conséquence, la nanotoxicologie a émergé et gagné de plus en plus d'attention dû à la nécessité de recueillir les renseignements nécessaires sur l'exposition et les risques associés à ces nouveaux matériaux. Cependant, les études actuelles sur la nanotoxicité ont tendance à se concentrer sur les ENM et utiliser ces résultats toxicologiques pour généraliser l'évaluation des risques sur l'exposition humaine aux NP. Les ENM libérés dans l'environnement peuvent interagir avec l'environnement, changeant leurs caractéristiques, et montrer des effets de toxicité distincts par rapport aux ENM originaux. Par ailleurs, la grande surface des NP fournit une grande interface avec l'extérieur, favorisant les interactions entre les NP et les autres espèces présentes. Dans ce processus, d'autres espèces peuvent s'attacher à la surface des NP et modifier leur fonctionnalité de surface ainsi que leur toxicité. Un scénario d'exposition professionnel particulier implique à la fois des NP et des composés organiques peu volatils (LVOC), un type commun de polluant associé à de nombreuses sources de NP. Les LVOC peuvent se déposer sur la surface des NP et donc dominer la toxicité globale de la particule. Un mécanisme important en nanotoxicologie est la création d'espèces réactives d'oxygène (ROS) sur la surface des particules, et les LVOC peuvent modifier cette production de ROS. En résumé, la recherche en nanotoxicité ne devrait pas être limitée à la toxicité des ENM originaux, ni utiliser leur toxicité pour évaluer les effets sur la santé de l'exposition aux NP de l'environnement; mais les interactions que les NP ont avec d'autres espèces environnementales doivent être envisagées et étudiées. Les effets possibles sur la santé de l'exposition aux NP devraient être dérivés de ces NP aux caractéristiques modifiées et à la toxicité distincte. L'utilisation de résultats de toxicité inappropriés peut conduire à une mauvaise prise en charge de l'exposition aux NP, de détériorer l'environnement et la santé publique et d'entraver le développement durable des industries de la nanotechnologie dans leur ensemble. L'objectif principal de cette thèse est de démontrer le processus de déposition des LVOC sur la surface des NP en utilisant un environnement de laboratoire bien contrôlé et d'explorer les conséquences du changement de toxicité des particules sur leur capacité à générer des ROS. Le système de déposition dynamique développé a abouti à des performances de revêtement stables et reproductibles, en simulant des scénarios réalistes importants. Des changements clairs dans la distribution de taille des NP en suspension ont été observés par spectrométrie de mobilité électrique des particules, confirmé à la fois par la méthode dite liquid nanotracking analysis et par microscopie électronique à transmission (MET), et a été vérifié comme provenant du revêtement par LVOC. La correspondance entre l'épaisseur de revêtement et la quantité de matériau de revêtement disponible a été démontré et a pu être contrôlé par les paramètres du générateur de LVOC. La génération de ROS dû aux NP d'argent (Ag NP) a été diminuée par un revêtement passif de paraffine inerte bloquant les zones réactives à la surface des particules. Au contraire, le revêtement actif d'anthraquinone réduit a contribué aux réactions redox et a généré des ROS, même lorsque la production de ROS par oxydation des Ag NP avec l'oxygène a été désactivé. Les objectifs associés comprennent le développement de la méthodologie et des études de cas spécifique aux ROS. Etant donné que la capacité des NP à générer des ROS contribue grandement à la nanotoxicité, nous avons tenté de définir un standard pour l'utilisation de 27- dichlorodihydrofluorescine (DCFH) adapté pour caractériser la génération de ROS par les NP. Des etudes antérieures ont rapporté une grande variété de résultats différents, ce qui était dû à un contrôle insuffisant des plusieurs facteurs. Nous avons donc comparé les produits chimiques et les concentrations utilisés, exploré les moyens de dispersion des échantillons HP en solution liquide, investigué les sources de conflits identifiées dans les littératures et étudié les moyens de réduire les résultats artificiels. De très bon résultats ont été obtenus par sonication d'une quantité optimale d'échantillons de NP en solution dans du DCFH-HRP, fait de 5 nM de DCFH et de 0,5 unité/ml de Peroxydase de raifort (HRP). Notre étude a démontré que les principales raisons causant les conflits entre les études précédemment conduites dans la littérature étaient dues aux différentes approches expérimentales et à des artefacts potentiels dus à des concentrations élevées de NP dans les échantillons. Utilisant notre protocole DCFH avancé avec d'autres caractérisations physico-chimiques et analyses biologiques, nous avons mené plusieurs études de cas, caractérisant les échantillons d'aérosols et les NP. La vielle poussière de frein en particulier présente un risque élevé d'exposition dans les scénarios professionnels, avec des effets potentiels néfastes sur la santé. Nous avons effectué des analyses d'éléments et de microscopie ainsi que la mesure de ROS avec DCFH cellulaire et acellulaire. Les résultats de MET ont révélé que les échantillons se présentent sous la forme de mélanges de particules hétérogènes, desquels une faible proportion se trouve dans l'échelle nano. Des éléments métalliques et non métalliques ont été identifiés, principalement du fer, du carbone et de l'oxygène. Une quantité modérée de ROS a été détectée dans le test fluorescent acellulaire; cependant les cellules exposées n'ont pas été très fortement activées. La raison pour laquelle les échantillons de vielle poussière de frein causent un stress oxydatif inférieur par rapport à la poussière de frein nouvelle peut-être à cause de leur plus grande taille engendrant une surface réactive proportionnellement plus petite, ainsi que leur état d'oxydation avancé diminuant la réactivité. D'autres études de cas sur les fumées de soudage et sur des NP différemment chargées ont confirmé la performance de notre test DCFH et ont trouvé que la génération de ROS est liée à certaines caractéristiques, notamment la fonctionnalité de surface des échantillons.

Vitamin E intake from natural sources and head and neck cancer risk : a pooled analysis in the International Head and Neck Cancer Epidemiology consortium.

BACKGROUND: Evidence for the possible effect of vitamin E on head and neck cancers (HNCs) is limited. METHODS: We used individual-level pooled data from 10 case-control studies (5959 cases and 12 248 controls) participating in the International Head and Neck Cancer Epidemiology (INHANCE) consortium to assess the association between vitamin E intake from natural sources and cancer of the oral cavity/pharynx and larynx. Adjusted odds ratios (ORs) and 95% confidence intervals (CIs) were estimated using unconditional logistic regression models applied to quintile categories of nonalcohol energy-adjusted vitamin E intake. RESULTS: Intake of vitamin E was inversely related to oral/pharyngeal cancer (OR for the fifth vs the first quintile category=0.59, 95% CI: 0.49-0.71; P for trend <0.001) and to laryngeal cancer (OR=0.67, 95% CI: 0.54-0.83, P for trend <0.001). There was, however, appreciable heterogeneity of the estimated effect across studies for oral/pharyngeal cancer. Inverse associations were generally observed for the anatomical subsites of oral and pharyngeal cancer and within covariate strata for both sites. CONCLUSION: Our findings suggest that greater vitamin E intake from foods may lower HNC risk, although we were not able to explain the heterogeneity observed across studies or rule out certain sources of bias.

Simulated Annealing, High-Order Statistics and Mutual Information for Separation of Sources

In this article, the fusion of a stochastic metaheuristic as Simulated Annealing (SA) with classical criteria for convergence of Blind Separation of Sources (BSS), is shown. Although the topic of BSS, by means of various techniques, including ICA, PCA, and neural networks, has been amply discussed in the literature, to date the possibility of using simulated annealing algorithms has not been seriously explored. From experimental results, this paper demonstrates the possible benefits offered by SA in combination with high order statistical and mutual information criteria for BSS, such as robustness against local minima and a high degree of flexibility in the energy function.

Combinative effects of β-Lapachone and APO866 on pancreatic cancer cell death through reactive oxygen species production and PARP-1 activation.

UNLABELLED: Pancreatic cancer (PC) is one of the most lethal human malignancies and a major health problem. Patients diagnosed with PC and treated with conventional approaches have an overall 5-year survival rate of less than 5%. Novel strategies are needed to treat this disease. Herein, we propose a combinatorial strategy that targets two unrelated metabolic enzymes overexpressed in PC cells: NAD(P)H: quinone oxidoreductase-1 (NQO1) and nicotinamide phosphoribosyl transferase (NAMPT) using β-lapachone (BL) and APO866, respectively. We show that BL tremendously enhances the antitumor activity of APO866 on various PC cell lines without affecting normal cells, in a PARP-1 dependent manner. The chemopotentiation of APO866 with BL was characterized by the following: (i) nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD) depletion; (ii) catalase (CAT) degradation; (iii) excessive H2O2 production; (iv) dramatic drop of mitochondrial membrane potential (MMP); and finally (v) autophagic-associated cell death. H2O2 production, loss of MMP and cell death (but not NAD depletion) were abrogated by exogenous supplementation with CAT or pharmacological or genetic inhibition of PARP-1. Our data demonstrates that the combination of a non-lethal dose of BL and low dose of APO866 optimizes significantly cell death on various PC lines over both compounds given separately and open new and promising combination in PC therapy.

Reply to 'Sources of uncertainties in cod distribution models'

Ingvaldsen et al. comment on our study assessing global fish interchanges between the North Atlantic and Pacific oceans for more than 500 species during the entire 21st century. They propose that discrepancies between our model projections and observed data for cod in the Barents Sea are the result of the choice of Atmosphere-Ocean General Circulation Models (AOGCMs). We address this assertion here, re-running the cod model with additional observation data from the Barents Sea1, 3, and show that the lack of open-access, archived data for the Barents Sea was the primary cause of local prediction mismatch. This finding recalls the importance of systematic deposit of biodiversity data in global databases