Measuring the degree of spatial correlation between pathological lesions in Alzheimer's disease

The pathological lesions characteristic of Alzheimer's disease (AD), viz., senile plaques (SP) and neurofibrillary tangles (NFT) may not be randomly distributed with reference to each other but exhibit a degree of sptial association or correlation, information on the degree of association between SP and NFT or between the lesions and normal histological features, such as neuronal perikarya and blood vessels, may be valuable in elucidating the pathogenesis of AD. This article reviews the statistical methods available for studying the degree of spatial association in histological sections of AD tissue. These include tests of interspecific association between two or more histological features using chi-square contingency tables, measurement of 'complete' and 'absolute' association, and more complex methods that use grids of contiguous samples. In addition, analyses of association using correlation matrices and stepwise multiple regression methods are described. The advantages and limitations of each method are reviewed and possible future developments discussed.

The spatial patterns of Pick bodies, Pick cells and Alzheimer’s disease pathology in Pick’s disease

The spatial patterns of Pick bodies (PB), Pick cells (PC), senile plaques (SP) and neurofibrillary tangles (NFT) were studied in the frontal and temporal lobe in nine cases of Pick’s disease (PD). Pick bodies exhibited clustering in 41/44 (93%) of analyses and clusters of PB were regularly distributed parallel to the tissue boundary in 24/41 (58%) of analyses. Pick cells exhibited clustering with regular periodicity of clusters in 14/16 (88%) analyses, SP in three out of four (75%) analyses and NFT in 21/27 (78%) analyses. The largest clusters of PB were observed in the dentate gyrus and PC in the frontal cortex. In 10/17 (59%) brain areas studied, a positive or negative correlation was observed between the densities of PB and PC. The densities of PB and NFT were not significantly correlated in the majority of brain areas but a negative correlation was observed in 7/29 (24%) brain areas. The data suggest that PB and PC in patients with PD exhibit essentially the same spatial patterns as SP and NFT in Alzheimer’s disease (AD) and Lewy bodies (LB) in dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB). In addition, there was a spatial correlation between the clusters of PB and PC, suggesting a pathogenic relationship between the two lesions. However, in the majority of tissues examined there was no spatial correlation between the clusters of PB and NFT, suggesting that the two lesions develop in association with different populations of neurons.

Degeneration of cortical neurons associated with diffuse beta-amyloid (Abeta) deposits in Alzheimer’s disease

The frequency of morphological abnormalities in neuronal perikarya which were in contact with diffuse beta-amyloid (Abeta) deposits in patients with Alzheimer’s disease (AD) was compared with neurons located adjacent to the deposits. Morphological abnormalities were also studied in elderly, non-demented (ND) cases with and without diffuse Abeta deposits. In AD and ND cases with Abeta deposits, an increased proportion of neurons in contact with diffuse deposits exhibited at least one abnormality compared with neurons located adjacent to the deposits. Neurons in contact with diffuse deposits exhibited a greater frequency of abnormalities of shape, nuclei, nissl substance and had a higher frequency of cytoplasmic vacuoles compared with adjacent neurons. A greater frequency of abnormalities of shape, nissl substance and in the frequency of displaced nuclei were also observed in neurons adjacent to diffuse deposits in AD compared with ND cases. With the exception of absent nuclei, morphological abnormalities adjacent to diffuse deposits in ND cases were similar to those of ND cases without Abeta deposits. These results suggest that neuronal degeneration is associated with the earliest stages of Abeta deposit formation and is not specifically related to the formation of mature senile plaques.

A comparison of histological and immunohistochemical methods for quantifying the pathological lesions of Pick's disease

Counts of Pick bodies (PB), Pick cells (PC), senile plaques (SP) and neurofibrillary tangles (NFT) were made in the frontal and temporal cortex from patients with Pick's disease (PD). Lesions were stained histologically with hematoxylin and eosin (HE) and the Bielschowsky silver impregnation method and labeled immunohistochemically with antibodies raised to ubiquitin and tau. The greatest numbers of PB were revealed by immunohistochemistry. Counts of PB revealed by ubiquitin and tau were highly positively correlated which suggested that the two antibodies recognized virtually identical populations of PB. The greatest numbers of PC were revealed by HE followed by the anti-ubiquitin antibody. However, the correlation between counts was poor, suggesting that HE and ubiquitin revealed different populations of PC. The greatest numbers of SP and NFT were revealed by the Bielschowsky method indicating the presence of Alzheimer-type lesions not revealed by the immunohistochemistry. In addition, more NFT were revealed by the anti-ubiquitin compared with the anti-tau antibody. The data suggested that in PD: (i) the anti-ubiquitin and anti-tau antibodies were equally effective at labeling PB; (ii) both HE and anti-ubiquitin should be used to quantitate PC; and (iii) the Bielschowsky method should be used to quantitate SP and NFT.

Is neuropathological heterogeneity in Alzheimer’s disease related to apolipoprotein genotype?

The abundance of senile plaques (SP) and neurofibrillary tangles (NFT) was studied in cortical and subcortical regions from 30 patients with Alzheimer’s disease (AD) expressing different apolipoprotein E (apoE) genotypes. Principal components analysis (PCA) was used to identify the most important neuropathological variations between individual patients and to determine whether these variations were related to apoE genotype. The first two principal components (PC) accounted for 60% and 40% of the total variance of the SP and NFT data respectively. The abundance of SP in the frontal and occipital cortex and NFT in the frontal cortex, amygdala and substantia nigra were positively correlated with the first principal component (PC1). Analysis of the SP data revealed that the apoE score of the patient (the sum of the two alleles) was positively correlated with PC1 while analysis of the NFT data revealed no significant correlations between apoE score and the PC. The data suggest that apoE genotype was more closely related to variations in the distribution and abundance of SP than of NFT. In addition, a more rapid spread of SP into the frontal and occipital cortex may occur in patients with a high apoE score.

Lewy body and Alzheimer pathology in temporal lobe in dementia with Lewy bodies

The density of Lewy bodies (LB), senile plaques (SP), and neurofibrillary tangles (NFT) was studied in the temporal lobe in four patients diagnosed with ‘pure’ dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB) and eight patients diagnosed with DLB with associated Alzheimer’s disease (DLB/AD). In both patient groups, the density of LB was greatest in the lateral occipitotemporal gyrus (LOT) and least in areaas CA1 and CA4 of the hippocampus. In DLB/AD, the densities of SP and NFT were greatest in the cortical regions and in area CA1 of the hippocampus respectively. Mean LB densities in the temporal lobe were similar in ‘pure’ DLB and DLB/AD patients but mean SP and NFT densities were greater in DLB/AD. No significant correlations were observed between the densities of LB, SP and NFT in any brain region. The data suggest that in the temporal lobe LB and SP/NFT are distributed differently; SP and NFT in DLB/AD are distributed similarly to ‘pure’ AD and also that LB and AD pathologies appear to develop independently. Hence, the data support the hypothesis that some cases of DLB combine the features of DLB and AD.

Does the neurodegeneration of Alzheimer’s disease spread between visual cortical regions B17 and B18 via the feedforward or feedback short cortico-cortical projections?

The laminar distribution of senile plaques (SP) and neurofibrillary tangles (NFT) was studied in areas B17 and B18 of the visual cortex in 18 cases of Alzheimer’s disease which varied in disease onset and duration. The objective was to test the hypothesis that SP and NFT could spread via either the feedforward or feedback short cortico-cortical projections. In area B17, the mean density of SP and NFT reached a maximum in lamina III and in laminae II and III respectively. In B18, mean SP density was maximal in laminae III and IV and NFT density in laminae II and III. No significant correlations were observed in any cortical lamina between the density of SP and patient age. However, the density of NFT in laminae III, IV and VI in B18 was negatively correlated with patient age. In addition, in B18, the density of SP in lamina II and lamina V was negatively correlated with disease duration and disease onset respectively. Although these results suggest that SP and NFT might spread between B17 and B18 via the feedforward short cortico-cortical projections, it is also possible that the longer cortico-cortical and cortico-subcortical connections may be involved.

Relationships between morphological types of plaque in Alzheimer’s disease as revealed in silver and immunostained preparations

The objective of this study was to determine the possible relationships between the morphological types of plaque revealed in silver and immunostained sections of Alzheimer’s disease (AD) tissue. The density of cored and uncored senile plaques in Glees and Marsland preparations, and of diffuse, primitive, classic and compact beta/A4 deposits in immunostained preparations were estimated. A principal components analysis (PCA) of the data suggested that three uncorrelated principal components accounted for 80% of the variation in lesion density in the tissues. This suggested that thee processes lead independently to the formation of: (1) the uncored Glees plaques; (2) the primitive beta/A4 deposits and most of the classic beta/A4 deposits and (3) the compact beta/A4 deposits and the remaining classic deposits. Hence, the uncored plaques revealed by the Glees stain and the primitive beta/A4 deposits represented distinct plaque populations. In addition, the classic beta/A4 deposits did not appear to represent a uniform plaque population but to originate from at least two pathological processes. The uncored Glees plaques appeared to the only plaque population closely related to the diffuse beta/A4 deposits.

Alzheimer's disease: Are cellular neurofibrillary tangles linked to beta/A4 formation at the projection sites?

The density of senile plaques (SP) and cellular neurofibrillary tabgles (NFT) revealed by the Glees and Gallyas stains; and beta/A4 deposits revealed by immunocytochemical staining, was estimated in the hippocampus and adjacent gyri in Alzheimer's disease (AD). Stepwise multiple regression was used to detemine whether the density of cellular NFT was related to the density of SP or beta/A4 deposits totalled over the projection sites. Cellular NFT density was only weakly correlated with the density of Glees SP and beta/A4 deposits at some of the projection sites. However, beta/A4 deposit density in a tissue was strongly correlated with the density of beta/A4 deposits at the projection sites suggesting that the lesions could spread through the brain. Hence, although there is a strong correlation between the density of beta/A4 deposits in different parts of the hippocampal formation there is little association between SP or beta/A4 and cellular NFT. These results do not provide strong evidence that beta/A4 protein is the cause of the neuritc changes in AD.

Neuropathological changes in the visual cortex in Alzheimer's disease

A survey of 106 cases of Alzheimer's disease (AD) indicated that senile plaques (SP) and neurofibrillary tangles (NFT) were recorded as frequent or abundant in the visual cortex in 72% and 27% of cases respectively. Comparable estimates for other brain regions were 89% for both lesions in temporal cortex and 94% and 95% respectively in the hippocampus. In 18 cases studied in detail, the density of SP and NFT was greater in B19/18 than in B17 in cases with early onset and short duration. The density of SP and NFT in B17, B18/19 and parietal cortex was negatively correlated with age at death of the patient but not with duration of the disease. In about 50% of tissue sections examined SP and NFT were clustered at a particular depth in the cortex. Clustering was more frequent in the upper layers of the cortex and in early onset cases. It was concluded that visual stimuli that evoke activity in different areas of visual cortex might be developed as a diagnostic test for early onset AD.

Ophthalmological manifestations of multiple sclerosis

Optic neuritis, as a result of the formation of demyelination plaques in the optic nerve, is one of the commonest early symptoms of multiple sclerosis. Hence, it is important that optometrists are aware of the symptoms of optic neuritis and of the conditions with which it can be confused. However, only a proportion of patients with optic neuritis will develop the symptoms of multiple sclerosis. The first part of the article describes the symptoms and differential diagnosis of optic neuritis and its relationship with multiple sclerosis. In the second part of the article, the variety of visual changes and symptoms which can be observed in multiple sclerosis patients will be described.

Distribution of A4 protein and neurofibrillary change in the hippocampus in Alzheimer's disease

The principal components of classical senile plaques (SP) in Alzheimer's disease (AD) appear to be A4/beta protein and paired helical filaments (PHF). A4 deposits may evolve into classical SP in brain regions vulnerable to the formation of PHF. We have investigated the diatribution of A4 deposits using an immunostain and the neurofibrillary change using the Gallyas stain in various regions of the hippocampus. This region is particularly affected in AD and also has relatively restricted inputs and outputs. In 6 patients we found a significant preponderance of A4 deposits in the adjacent parahippocampal gyrus (PHG) compared with all regions of the hippocampus. However, plaque-like clusters of PHF (Gallyas plaques) were more abundant in the subiculum while neurofibrillary tangles (NFT) were more abundant in the subiculum and region CA1 compared with the PHG and other hippocampal regions. Hence, A4 deposits appear to be concentrated in the region providing a major input into the hippocampus while the neurofibrillary changes are characteristic of the major output areas (subiculum and CA1). Hence, the data suggest that A4 formation and the neurofibrillary changes may occur in regions of the hippocampus that are connected anatomically.

Principal components analysis of Alzheimer's disease based on neuropathological data: a study of 79 patients

A principal components analysis was carried out on neuropathological data collected from 79 cases of Alzheimer's disease (AD) diagnosed in a single centre. The purpose of the study was to determine whether on neuropathological criteria there was evidence for clearly defined subtypes of the disease. Two principal components (PC1 and PC2) were extracted from the data. PC1 was considerable more important than PC2 accounting for 72% of the total variance. When plotted in relation to the first two principal components the majority of cases (65/79) were distributed in a single cluster within which subgroupings were not clearly evident. In addition, there were a number of individual, mainly early-onset cases, which were neither related to each other nor to the main cluster. The distribution of each neuropathological feature was examined in relation to PC1 and 2, Disease onset, rhe degree of gross brain atrophy, neuronal loss and the devlopment of senile plaques (SP) and neurofibrillary tangles (NFT) were negatively correlated with PC1. The devlopment of SP and NFT and the degree of brain athersclerosis were positively correlated with PC2. These results suggested: 1) that there were different forms of AD but no clear division of the cases into subclasses could be made based on the neuropathological criteria used; the cases showing a more continuous distribution from one form to another, 2) that disease onset was an important variable and was associated with a greater development of pathological changes, 3) familial cases were not a distinct subclass of AD; the cases being widely distributed in relation to PC1 and PC2 and 4) that there may be two forms of late-onset AD whic grade into each other, one of which was associated with less SP and NFT development but with a greater degree of brain atherosclerosis.

Large diameter optic nerve axon fibres in Alzheimer's disease

A variety of visual symptoms have been associated with Alzheimer's disease (AD). These include delays in flash visual evoked potentials which indicate a disruption of the integrity of the visual pathway. Examination of the visual cortex has revealed the presence of both senile plaques and neurofibrillary tangles. The purpose of this study was to determine whether there were differences in the number and/or size of optic nerve axons between AD patients and non-demented age-matched controls. Five optic nerves from AD patients and five from age-matched controls were embedded in epon resin and 1 micron sections prepared on a Reichert ultramicrotome. The sections were then stained in toluidine blue and examined at x400 magnification. The numbers of axons were counted in photographs of three fields taken at random from each section. To evaluate the axon diameters, 70 axons were chosen at random from each patient and measured using a calibrated eyepiece graticule. The total axon counts revealed no significant differences between the AD optic nerves and the age-matched controls. However, the frequency distribution of axon diameters was significantly different in the two groups. In particular, there were fewer larger diameter axons in patients with AD as previously reported. Degeneration of the large diameter axons suggests involvement of the magnocellular as opposed to the parvocellular pathways. Hence, there could be differences in visual performance of AD patients compared with normals which could be important in clinical diagnosis.

Alzheimer’s disease and the eye

Dementia, including Alzheimer’s disease (AD), is a major disorder causing visual problems in the elderly population. The pathology of AD includes the deposition in the brain of abnormal aggregates of ß-amyloid (Aß) in the form of senile plaques (SP) and abnormally phosphorylated tau in the form of neurofibrillary tangles (NFT). A variety of visual problems have been reported in patients with AD including loss of visual acuity (VA), colour vision and visual fields; changes in pupillary response to mydriatics, defects in fixation and in smooth and saccadic eye movements; changes in contrast sensitivity and in visual evoked potentials (VEP); and disturbances of complex visual functions such as reading, visuospatial function, and in the naming and identification of objects. Many of these changes are controversial with conflicting data in the literature and no ocular or visual feature can be regarded as particularly diagnostic of AD. In addition, some pathological changes have been observed to affect the eye, visual pathway, and visual cortex in AD. The optometrist has a role in helping a patient with AD, if it is believed that signs and symptoms of the disease are present, so as to optimize visual function and improve the quality of life. (J Optom 2009;2:103-111 ©2009 Spanish Council of Optometry)